arXiv++ Combinatorics

An edge-colored graph $G$ is called properly colored if every two adjacent edges are assigned different colors. A monochromatic triangle is a cycle of length 3 with all the edges having the same color. Given a tree $T_0$, let $\mathcal{T}(n,T_0)$ be the collection of $n$-vertex trees that are subdivisions of $T_0$. It is conjectured that for each fixed tree $T_0$, there is a function $f(T_0)$ such that for each integer $n\geq f(T_0)$ and each $T\in \mathcal{T}(n,T_0)$, every edge-colored complete graph $K_n$ without containing monochromatic triangle must contain a properly colored copy of $T$. We confirm the conjecture in the case that $T_0$ is a star. A weaker version of the above conjecture is also obtained. Moreover, to get a nice quantitative estimation of $f(T_0)$ when $T_0$ is a star requires determining the constraint Ramsey number of a monochromatic triangle and a rainbow star, which is of independent interest.

For a polymatroid $P$ over $[n]$, Bernardi, Kálmán and Postnikov [\emph{Adv. Math.} 402 (2022) 108355] introduced the polymatroid Tutte polynomial $\mathscr{T}_{P}$ relying on the order $1<2<\cdots<n$ of $[n]$, which generalizes the classical Tutte polynomial from matroids to polymatroids. They proved the independence of this order by the fact that $\mathscr{T}_{P}$ is equivalent to another polynomial that only depends on $P$. In this paper, similar to the Tutte's original proof of the well-definedness of the Tutte polynomial defined by the summation over all spanning trees using activities depending on the order of edges, we give a direct and elementary proof of the well-definedness of the polymatroid Tutte polynomial.

Sandpile groups are a subtle graph isomorphism invariant, in the form of a finite abelian group, whose cardinality is the number of spanning trees in the graph. We study their group structure for graphs obtained by attaching a cone vertex to a tree. For example, it is shown that the number of generators of the sandpile group is at most one less than the number of leaves in the tree. For trees on a fixed number of vertices, the paths and stars are shown to provide extreme behavior, not only for the number of generators, but also for the number of spanning trees, and for Tutte polynomial evaluations that count the recurrent sandpile configurations by their numbers of chips.

This article considers a class of disordered mean-field combinatorial optimization problems. We focus on the Gibbs measure, where the inverse temperature does not vary with the size of the graph and the edge weights are sampled from a general distribution under mild assumptions. Our results consist of the Law of Large Numbers and Central Limit Theorems for the log-partition function, the weight of a typical configuration, and the Gibbs average in both quenched and annealed forms. We also derive quenched Poisson convergence for the size of the intersection of two independent samples, yielding replica symmetry of the model. Applications cover popular models from the literature, such as the Minimal Matching Problem, Traveling Salesman Problem, and Minimal Spanning Tree Problem, on a sequence of deterministic and random dense block graphs of increasing size.

Given a spanning tree $T$ of a planar graph $G$, the co-tree of $T$ is the spanning tree of the dual graph $G^*$ with edge set $(E(G)-E(T))^*$. Grünbaum conjectured in 1970 that every planar 3-connected graph $G$ contains a spanning tree $T$ such that both $T$ and its co-tree have maximum degree at most 3. While Grünbaum's conjecture remains open, Biedl proved that there is a spanning tree $T$ such that $T$ and its co-tree have maximum degree at most 5. By using new structural insights into Schnyder woods, we prove that there is a spanning tree $T$ such that $T$ and its co-tree have maximum degree at most 4.

In this paper we introduce a new model of random spanning trees that we call choice spanning trees, constructed from so-called choice random walks. These are random walks for which each step is chosen from a subset of random options, according to some pre-defined rule. The choice spanning trees are constructed by running a choice modified version of Wilson's algorithm or the Aldous-Broder algorithm on the complete graph. We show that the scaling limits of these choice spanning trees are slight variants of random aggregation trees previously considered by Curien and Haas (2017). Moreover, we show that the loop-erasure of a choice random walk run on the complete graph converges after rescaling to a generalized Rayleigh process, extending a result of Evans, Pitman and Winter (2006). These are all natural extensions of similar results for uniform spanning trees.

We study the Gaussian statistical models whose log-likelihood function has a unique complex critical point, i.e., has maximum likelihood degree one. We exploit the connection developed by Améndola et. al. between the models having maximum likelihood degree one and homaloidal polynomials. We study the spanning tree generating function of a graph and show this polynomial is homaloidal when the graph is chordal. When the graph is a cycle on $n$ vertices, $n \geq 4$, we prove the polynomial is not homaloidal, and show that the maximum likelihood degree of the resulting model is the $n$th Eulerian number. These results support our conjecture that the spanning tree generating function is a homaloidal polynomial if and only if the graph is chordal. We also provide an algebraic formulation for the defining equations of these models. Using existing results, we provide a computational study on constructing new families of homaloidal polynomials. In the end, we analyze the symmetric determinantal representation of such polynomials and provide an upper bound on the size of the matrices involved.

Let $G$ be a 3-connected planar graph. Define the co-tree of a spanning tree $T$ of $G$ as the graph induced by the dual edges of $E(G)-E(T)$. The well-known cut-cycle duality implies that the co-tree is itself a tree. Let a $k$-tree be a spanning tree with maximum degree $k$. In 1970, Grünbaum conjectured that every 3-connected planar graph contains a 3-tree whose co-tree is also a 3-tree. In 2014, Biedl showed that every such graph contains a 5-tree whose co-tree is a 5-tree. In this paper, we present an easier proof of Biedl's result

In the Properly Colored Spanning Tree problem, we are given an edge-colored undirected graph and the goal is to find a properly colored spanning tree, i.e., a spanning tree in which any two adjacent edges have distinct colors. The problem is interesting not only from a graph coloring point of view, but is also closely related to the Degree Bounded Spanning Tree and (1,2)-Traveling Salesman problems, two classical questions that have attracted considerable interest in combinatorial optimization and approximation theory. Previous work on properly colored spanning trees has mainly focused on determining the existence of such a tree and hence has not considered the question from an algorithmic perspective. We propose an optimization version called Maximum-size Properly Colored Forest problem, which aims to find a properly colored forest with as many edges as possible. We consider the problem in different graph classes and for different numbers of colors, and present polynomial-time approximation algorithms as well as inapproximability results for these settings. Our proof technique relies on the sum of matching matroids defined by the color classes, a connection that might be of independent combinatorial interest. We also consider the Maximum-size Properly Colored Tree problem, which asks for the maximum size of a properly colored tree not necessarily spanning all the vertices. We show that the optimum is significantly more difficult to approximate than in the forest case, and provide an approximation algorithm for complete multigraphs.

We study the minimum spanning tree distribution on the space of spanning trees of the $n$-by-$n$ grid for large $n$. We establish bounds on the decay rates of the probability of the most and the least probable spanning trees as $n\rightarrow\infty$.

We study the minimal spanning arborescence which is the directed analogue of the minimal spanning tree, with a particular focus on its infinite volume limit and its geometric properties. We prove that in a certain large class of transient trees, the infinite volume limit exists almost surely. We also prove that for nonamenable, unimodular graphs, the limit is almost surely one-ended assuming a certain sufficient condition that guarantees the existence of the limit. This object cannot be studied using well-known algorithms, such as Kruskal's or Prim's algorithm, to sample the minimal spanning tree which has been instrumental in getting analogous results about them (Lyons, Peres, and Schramm). Instead, we use a recursive algorithm due to Chu, Liu, Edmonds, and Bock, which leads to a novel stochastic process which we call the \emph{loop contracting random walk}. This is similar to the well-known and widely studied loop erased random walk, except instead of erasing loops we contract them. The full algorithm bears similarities with the celebrated Wilson's algorithm to generate uniform spanning trees and can be seen as a certain limit of the original Wilson's algorithm.

We give an affirmative answer to a long-standing conjecture of Thomassen, stating that every sufficiently highly connected graph has a $k$-vertex-connected orientation. We prove that a connectivity of order $O(k^2)$ suffices. As a key tool, we show that for every pair of positive integers $d$ and $t$, every $(t \cdot h(d))$-connected graph contains $t$ edge-disjoint $d$-rigid (in particular, $d$-connected) spanning subgraphs, where $h(d) = 10d(d+1)$. This also implies a positive answer to the conjecture of Kriesell that every sufficiently highly connected graph $G$ contains a spanning tree $T$ such that $G-E(T)$ is $k$-connected.

In a given graph, a HIST is a spanning tree without $2$-valent vertices. Motivated by developing a better understanding of HIST-free graphs, i.e. graphs containing no HIST, in this article's first part we study HIST-critical graphs, i.e. HIST-free graphs in which every vertex-deleted subgraph does contain a HIST (e.g. a triangle). We give an almost complete characterisation of the orders for which these graphs exist and present an infinite family of planar examples which are $3$-connected and in which nearly all vertices are $4$-valent. This leads naturally to the second part in which we investigate planar $4$-regular graphs with and without HISTs, motivated by a conjecture of Malkevitch, which we computationally verify up to order $22$. First we enumerate HISTs in antiprisms, whereafter we present planar $4$-regular graphs with and without HISTs, obtained via line graphs. Finally, we confirm Malkevitch's conjecture for the family of line graphs of cyclically $4$-edge connected cubic graphs.

We introduce the notion of quota trees in directed graphs. Given a nonnegative integer ``quota'' for each vertex of a directed multigraph $G$, a quota tree is an immersed rooted tree which hits each vertex of $G$ the prescribed number of times. When the quotas are all one, the tree is actually embedded and we recover the usual notion of a spanning arborescence (directed spanning tree). The usual algorithms which produce spanning arborescences with various properties typically have (sometimes more complicated) ``quota'' analogues. Our original motivation for studying quota trees was the problem of characterizing the sizes of the Myhill-Nerode equivalence classes in a connected deterministic finite-state automaton recognizing a given regular language. We show that the obstruction to realizing a given set of M-N class sizes is precisely the existence of a suitable quota tree. In this paper we develop the basic theory of quota trees. We give necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of a quota tree (or forest) over a given directed graph with specified quotas, solving the M-N class size problem as a special case. We discuss some potential applications of quota trees and forests, and connect them to the $k$ lightest paths problem. We give two proofs of the main theorem: one based on an algorithmic loop invariant, and one based on direct enumeration of quota trees. For the latter, we use Lagrange inversion to derive a formula which vastly generalizes both the matrix-tree theorem and Cayley's formula for counting labeled trees. We give an efficient algorithm to sample uniformly from the set of forests with given quotas, as well as a generalization of Edmonds' algorithm for computing a minimum-weight quota forest.

In this paper, we investigate the complexity of an infinite family of Cayley graphs $\mathcal{D}_{n}=Cay(\mathbb{D}_{n}, b^{\pmβ_1},b^{\pmβ_2},\ldots,b^{\pmβ_s}, a b^{γ_1}, a b^{γ_2},\ldots, a b^{γ_t} )$ on the dihedral group $\mathbb{D}_{n}=\langle a,b| a^2=1, b^n=1,(a\,b)^2=1\rangle$ of order $2n.$ We obtain a closed formula for the number $τ(n)$ of spanning trees in $\mathcal{D}_{n}$ in terms of Chebyshev polynomials, investigate some arithmetical properties of this function, and find its asymptotics as $n\to\infty.$ Moreover, we show that the generating function $F(x)=\sum\limits_{n=1}^\inftyτ(n)x^n$ is a rational function with integer coefficients.

The family of planar graphs is a particularly important family and models many real-world networks. In this paper, we propose a principled framework based on the widely-known Apollonian packing process to generate new planar network, i.e., Type-II Apollonian network $\mathcal{A}_{t}$. The manipulation is different from that of the typical Apollonian network, and is proceeded in terms of the iterative addition of triangle instead of vertex. As a consequence, network $\mathcal{A}_{t}$ turns out to be hamiltonian and eulerian, however, the typical Apollonian network is not. Then, we in-depth study some fundamental structural properties on network $\mathcal{A}_{t}$, and verify that network $\mathcal{A}_{t}$ is sparse like most real-world networks, has scale-free feature and small-world property, and exhibits disassortative mixing structure. Next, we design an effective algorithm for solving the problem of how to enumerate spanning trees on network $\mathcal{A}_{t}$, and derive the asymptotic solution of the spanning tree entropy, which suggests that Type-II Apollonian network is more reliable to a random removal of edges than the typical Apollonian network. Additionally, we study trapping problem on network $\mathcal{A}_{t}$, and use average trapping time as metric to show that Type-II Apollonian network $\mathcal{A}_{t}$ has better structure for fast information diffusion than the typical Apollonian network.

Let $G$ be a connected graph and $L(G)$ the set of all integers $k$ such that $G$ contains a spanning tree with exactly $k$ leaves. We show that for a connected graph $G$, the set $L(G)$ is contiguous. It follows from work of Chen, Ren, and Shan that every connected and locally connected $n$-vertex graph -- this includes triangulations -- has a spanning tree with at least $n/2 + 1$ leaves, so by a classic theorem of Whitney and our result, in any plane $4$-connected $n$-vertex triangulation one can find for any integer $k$ which is at least $2$ and at most $n/2 + 1$ a spanning tree with exactly $k$ leaves (and each of these trees can be constructed in polynomial time). We also prove that there exist infinitely many $n$ such that there is a plane $4$-connected $n$-vertex triangulation containing a spanning tree with $2n/3$ leaves, but no spanning tree with more than $2n/3$ leaves.

A cut of a graph can be represented in many different ways. Here we propose to represent a cut through a ``relation tree'', which is a spanning tree with signed edges. We show that this picture helps to classify the main greedy heuristics for the maximum cut problem, in analogy with the minimum spanning tree problem. Namely, all versions of the Sahni-Gonzalez~(SG) algorithms could be classified as the Prim class, while various Edge-Contraction~(EC) algorithms are of the Kruskal class. We further elucidate the relation of this framework to the stabilizer formalism in quantum computing, and point out that the recently proposed \textit{ADAPT-Clifford} algorithm is a reformulation of a refined version of the SG algorithm, SG3. Numerical performance of the typical algorithms from the two classes are studied with various kinds of graphs. It turns out that, the Prim-class algorithms perform better for general dense graphs, and the Kruskal-class algorithms performs better when the graphs are sparse enough.

We consider partitions of a point set into two parts, and the lengths of the minimum spanning trees of the original set and of the two parts. If $w(P)$ denotes the length of a minimum spanning tree of $P$, we show that every set $P$ of $n \geq 12$ points admits a bipartition $P= R \cup B$ for which the ratio $\frac{w(R)+w(B)}{w(P)}$ is strictly larger than $1$; and that $1$ is the largest number with this property. Furthermore, we provide a very fast algorithm that computes such a bipartition in $O(1)$ time and one that computes the corresponding ratio in $O(n \log{n})$ time. In certain settings, a ratio larger than $1$ can be expected and sometimes guaranteed. For example, if $P$ is a set of $n$ random points uniformly distributed in $[0,1]^2$ ($n \to \infty$), then for any $\eps>0$, the above ratio in a maximizing partition is at least $\sqrt2 -\eps$ with probability tending to $1$. As another example, if $P$ is a set of $n$ points with spread at most $α\sqrt{n}$, for some constant $α>0$, then the aforementioned ratio in a maximizing partition is $1 + Ω(α^{-2})$. All our results and techniques are extendable to higher dimensions.

Miquel dynamics is a discrete time dynamics for circle patterns, which relies on Miquel's six circle theorem. Previous work shows that the evolution of the circle centers satisfy the dSKP equation on the octahedral lattice $A_3$. As a consequence, Miquel dynamics is a discrete integrable system. Moreover, Miquel dynamics give rise to a real-valued cluster structure. The evolution of the cluster variables under Miquel dynamics is also called a Y-system in the discrete integrable systems community. If the Y-system is real positive-valued then the circle pattern is accompanied by an invariant dimer model, an exactly solvable model studied in statistical physics. However, while circle patterns are Möbius invariant, the circle centers and the Y-system are not Möbius invariant, which violates the so called transformation group principle. In this article we show that half the intersection points satisfy the dSKP equation as well, and we introduce two new real-valued Y-systems for Miquel dynamics that involve only the intersection points. Therefore, the new Y-systems are Möbius invariant, and thus satisfy the transformation group principle. We also show that the circle centers and intersection points combined satisfy the dSKP equation on the 4-dimensional octahedral lattice $A_4$. In addition, we present two more complex-valued Y-systems for Miquel dynamics, which are real-valued in and only in the case of integrable circle patterns. We also investigate the special cases of harmonic embeddings and s-embeddings, which relate to the spanning tree and Ising model respectively.