arXiv++ Combinatorics

A digraph is {\em $d$-dominating} if every set of at most $d$ vertices has a common out-neighbor. For all integers $d\geq 2$, let $f(d)$ be the smallest integer such that the vertices of every 2-edge-colored (finite or infinite) complete digraph (including loops) can be covered by the vertices of at most $f(d)$ monochromatic $d$-dominating subgraphs. Note that the existence of $f(d)$ is not obvious -- indeed, the question which motivated this paper was simply to determine whether $f(d)$ is bounded, even for $d=2$. We answer this question affirmatively for all $d\geq 2$, proving $4\leq f(2)\le 8$ and $2d\leq f(d)\le 2d\left(\frac{d^{d}-1}{d-1}\right)$ for all $d\ge 3$. We also give an example to show that there is no analogous bound for more than two colors. Our result provides a positive answer to a question regarding an infinite analogue of the Burr-Erdős conjecture on the Ramsey numbers of $d$-degenerate graphs. Moreover, a special case of our result is related to properties of $d$-paradoxical tournaments.

The orientation completion problem for a class of oriented graphs asks whether a given partially oriented graph can be completed to an oriented graph in the class by orienting the unoriented edges of the partially oriented graph. Orientation completion problems have been studied recently for several classes of oriented graphs, yielding both polynomial time solutions as well as NP-completeness results. Local tournaments are a well-structured class of oriented graphs that generalize tournaments and their underlying graphs are intimately related to proper circular-arc graphs. According to Skrien, a connected graph can be oriented as a local tournament if and only if it is a proper circular-arc graph. Proper interval graphs are precisely the graphs which can be oriented as acyclic local tournaments. It has been proved that the orientation completion problems for the classes of local tournaments and acyclic local tournaments are both polynomial time solvable. In this paper we characterize the partially oriented graphs that can be completed to local tournaments by determining the complete list of obstructions. These are in a sense minimal partially oriented graphs that cannot be completed to local tournaments. The result may be viewed as an extension of the well-known forbidden subgraph characterization of proper circular-arc graphs obtained by Tucker. The complete list of obstructions for acyclic local tournament orientation completions has been given in a companion paper.

Let $D$ be a $k$-regular bipartite tournament on $n$ vertices. We show that, for every $p$ with $2 \le p \le n/2-2$, $D$ has a cycle $C$ of length $2p$ such that $D \setminus C$ is hamiltonian unless $D$ is isomorphic to the special digraph $F_{4k}$. This statement was conjectured by Manoussakis, Song and Zhang [K. Zhang, Y. Manoussakis, and Z. Song. Complementary cycles containing a fixed arc in diregular bipartite tournaments. Discrete Mathematics, 133(1-3):325--328,1994]. In the same paper, the conjecture was proved for $p=2$ and more recently Bai, Li and He gave a proof for $p=3$ [Y. Bai, H. Li, and W. He. Complementary cycles in regular bipartite tournaments. Discrete Mathematics, 333:14--27, 2014].

Given a tournament $T$, a module of $T$ is a subset $M$ of $V(T)$ such that for $x, y\in M$ and $v\in V(T)\setminus M$, $(x,v)\in A(T)$ if and only if $(y,v)\in A(T)$. The trivial modules of $T$ are $\emptyset$, $\{u\}$ $(u\in V(T))$ and $V(T)$. The tournament $T$ is indecomposable if all its modules are trivial; otherwise it is decomposable. The decomposability index of $T$, denoted by $δ(T)$, is the smallest number of arcs of $T$ that must be reversed to make $T$ indecomposable. In a previous paper, we proved that for $n \geq 5$, we have $δ(n) = \left\lceil \frac{n+1}{4} \right\rceil$, where $δ(n)$ is the maximum of $δ(T)$ over the tournaments $T$ with $n$ vertices. In this paper, we characterize the tournaments $T$ with $δ$-maximal decomposability, i.e., such that $δ(T)=δ(\vert T\vert)$.

We describe computer searches that prove the graph reconstruction conjecture for graphs with up to 13 vertices and some limited classes on larger sizes. We also investigate the reconstructibility of tournaments up to 13 vertices, digraphs up to 9 vertices, and posets up to 13 points. In all cases, our results also apply to the set reconstruction problem that uses the isomorph-reduced deck.

Let $S_k(n)$ be the maximum number of orientations of an $n$-vertex graph $G$ in which no copy of $K_k$ is strongly connected. For all integers $n$, $k\geq 4$ where $n\geq 5$ or $k\geq 5$, we prove that $S_k(n) = 2^{t_{k-1}(n)}$, where $t_{k-1}(n)$ is the number of edges of the $n$-vertex $(k-1)$-partite Turán graph $T_{k-1}(n)$, and that $T_{k-1}(n)$ is the only $n$-vertex graph with this number of orientations. Furthermore, $S_4(4) = 40$ and this maximality is achieved only by $K_4$.

A celebrated unresolved conjecture of Erdös and Hajnal states that for every undirected graph $H$ there exists $ ε(H) > 0 $ such that every undirected graph on $ n $ vertices that does not contain $H$ as an induced subgraph contains a clique or a stable set of size at least $ n^{ε(H)} $. This conjecture has a directed equivalent version stating that for every tournament $H$ there exists $ ε(H) > 0 $ such that every $H-$free $n-$vertex tournament $T$ contains a transitive subtournament of size at least $ n^{ε(H)} $. Recently the conjecture was proved for all six-vertex tournaments, except $K_{6}$. In this paper we construct two infinite families of tournaments for which the conjecture is still open for infinitely many tournaments in these two families $-$ the family of so-called super nebulas and the family of so-called super triangular galaxies. We prove that for every super nebula $H_{1}$ and every $Δ$galaxy $H_{2}$ there exist $ε(H_{1},H_{2})$ such that every $\lbrace H_{1},H_{2}\rbrace$$-$free tournament $T$ contains a transitive subtournament of size at least $\mid$$T$$\mid^{ε(H_{1},H_{2})}$. We also prove that for every central triangular galaxy $H$ there exist $ε(K_{6},H)$ such that every $\lbrace K_{6},H\rbrace$$-$free tournament $T$ contains a transitive subtournament of size at least $\mid$$T$$\mid^{ε(K_{6},H)}$. And we give an extension of our results.

We consider the Erdős-Pósa property for immersions and topological minors in tournaments. We prove that for every simple digraph $H$, $k\in \mathbb{N}$, and tournament $T$, the following statements hold: (i) If in $T$ one cannot find $k$ arc-disjoint immersion copies of $H$, then there exists a set of $\mathcal{O}_H(k^3)$ arcs that intersects all immersion copies of $H$ in $T$. (ii) If in $T$ one cannot find $k$ vertex-disjoint topological minor copies of $H$, then there exists a set of $\mathcal{O}_H(k\log k)$ vertices that intersects all topological minor copies of $H$ in $T$. This improves the results of Raymond [DMTCS '18], who proved similar statements under the assumption that $H$ is strongly connected.

We prove that for all countable tournaments $D$ the recently discovered compactification $|D|$ by their ends and limit edges contains a topological Hamilton path: a topological arc that contains every vertex. If $D$ is strongly connected, then $|D|$ contains a topological Hamilton circle. These results extend well-known theorems about finite tournaments, which we show do not extend to the infinite in a purely combinatorial setting.

We prove that a tournament and its complement contain the same number of oriented Hamiltonian paths (resp. cycles) of any given type, as a generalization of Rosenfeld's result proved for antidirected paths.

The theory of quasirandomness has greatly expanded from its inaugural graph theoretical setting to several different combinatorial objects such as hypergraphs, tournaments, permutations, etc. However, these quasirandomness variants have been done in an ad-hoc case-by-case manner. In this paper, we propose three new hierarchies of quasirandomness properties that can be naturally defined for arbitrary combinatorial objects. Our properties are also "natural" in more formal sense: they are preserved by local combinatorial constructions (encoded by open interpretations). We show that our quasirandomness properties have several different but equivalent characterizations that are similar to hypergraph quasirandomness properties. We also prove several implications and separations comparing them to each other and to what has been known for hypergraphs. The main notion explored by our statements and proofs is that of unique coupleability: two limit objects are uniquely coupleable if there is a unique limit object in the combined theory that is an alignment (i.e., a coupling) of these two objects.

We build a collection of topological Ramsey spaces of trees giving rise to universal inverse limit structures,extending Zheng's work for the profinite graph to the setting of Fraïssé classes of finite ordered binary relational structures with the Ramsey property. This work is based on the Halpern-Läuchli theorem, but different from the Milliken space of strong subtrees. Based on these topological Ramsey spaces and the work of Huber-Geschke-Kojman on inverse limits of finite ordered graphs, we prove that for each such Fraïssé class, its universal inverse limit structure has finite big Ramsey degrees under finite Baire-measurable colorings. For such \Fraisse\ classes satisfying free amalgamation as well as finite ordered tournaments and finite partial orders with a linear extension, we characterize the exact big Ramsey degrees.

In this paper, we compute competition indices and periods of multipartite tournaments. We first show that the competition period of an acyclic digraph $D$ is one and $ζ(D) +1$ is a sharp upper bound of the competition index of $D$ where $ζ(D)$ is the sink elimination index of $D$. Then we prove that, especially, for an acyclic $k$-partite tournament $D$, the competition index of $D$ is $ζ(D)$ or $ζ(D) +1$ for an integer $k \ge 3$. By developing useful tools to create infinitely many directed walks in a certain regular pattern from given directed walks, we show that the competition period of a multipartite tournament with sinks and directed cycles is at most three. We also prove that the competition index of a primitive digraph does not exceed its exponent.

We prove that every $n$-vertex tournament has at most $n\left(\frac{n-1}{2}\right)^k$ walks of length $k$.

Rosenfeld Conjectured in 1972 that there exists an integer K $\geq$ 8 such that any tournament of order n $\geq$ K contains any Hamiltonian oriented path. In 2000, Havet and Thomassé proved this conjecture for any tournament with exactly 3 exceptions. We give a simplified proof of this fact.

Akin to the Erdős-Rademacher problem, Linial and Morgenstern made the following conjecture in tournaments: for any $d\in (0,1]$, among all $n$-vertex tournaments with $d\binom{n}{3}$ many 3-cycles, the number of 4-cycles is asymptotically minimized by a special random blow-up of a transitive tournament. Recently, Chan, Grzesik, Král' and Noel introduced spectrum analysis of adjacency matrices of tournaments in this study, and confirmed this for $d\geq 1/36$. In this paper, we investigate the analogous problem of minimizing the number of cycles of a given length. We prove that for integers $\ell\not\equiv 2\mod 4$, there exists some constant $c_\ell>0$ such that if $d\geq 1-c_\ell$, then the number of $\ell$-cycles is also asymptotically minimized by the same family of extremal examples for $4$-cycles. In doing so, we answer a question of Linial and Morgenstern about minimizing the $q$-norm of a probabilistic vector with given $p$-norm for any integers $q>p>1$. For integers $\ell\equiv 2\mod 4$, however the same phenomena do not hold for $\ell$-cycles, for which we can construct an explicit family of tournaments containing fewer $\ell$-cycles for any given number of $3$-cycles. We conclude by proposing two conjectures on the minimization problem for general cycles in tournaments.

We settle a version of the conjecture about intransitive dice posed by Conrey, Gabbard, Grant, Liu and Morrison in 2016 and Polymath in 2017. We consider generalized dice with $n$ faces and we say that a die $A$ beats $B$ if a random face of $A$ is more likely to show a higher number than a random face of $B$. We study random dice with faces drawn iid from the uniform distribution on $[0,1]$ and conditioned on the sum of the faces equal to $n/2$. Considering the "beats" relation for three such random dice, Polymath showed that each of eight possible tournaments between them is asymptotically equally likely. In particular, three dice form an intransitive cycle with probability converging to $1/4$. In this paper we prove that for four random dice not all tournaments are equally likely and the probability of a transitive tournament is strictly higher than $3/8$.

Tournaments are orientations of the complete graph, and the directed Ramsey number $R(k)$ is the minimum number of vertices a tournament must have to be guaranteed to contain a transitive subtournament of size $k$, which we denote by $TT_k$. We include a computer-assisted proof of a conjecture by Sanchez-Flores that all $TT_6$-free tournaments on 24 and 25 vertices are subtournaments of $ST_{27}$, the unique largest TT_6-free tournament. We also classify all $TT_6$-free tournaments on 23 vertices. We use these results, combined with assistance from SAT technology, to obtain the following improved bounds: $34 \leq R(7) \leq 47$.

In 1976, Alspach, Mason, and Pullman conjectured that any tournament $T$ of even order can be decomposed into exactly ${\rm ex}(T)$ paths, where ${\rm ex}(T):= \frac{1}{2}\sum_{v\in V(T)}|d_T^+(v)-d_T^-(v)|$. We prove this conjecture for all sufficiently large tournaments. We also prove an asymptotically optimal result for tournaments of odd order.

A celebrated unresolved conjecture of Erdös and Hajnal states that for every undirected graph $H$ there exists $ ε(H) > 0 $ such that every undirected graph on $ n $ vertices that does not contain $H$ as an induced subgraph contains a clique or a stable set of size at least $ n^{ε(H)} $. The conjecture has a directed equivalent version stating that for every tournament $H$ there exists $ ε(H) > 0 $ such that every $H-$free $n-$vertex tournament $T$ contains a transitive subtournament of order at least $ n^{ε(H)} $. Both the directed and the undirected versions of the conjecture are known to be true for small graphs (tournaments). So far the conjecture was proved only for some specific families of prime tournaments, tournaments constructed according to the so$-$called substitution procedure allowing to build bigger graphs, and for all five$-$vertex tournaments. Recently the conjecture was proved for all six$-$vertex tournament, with one exception, but the question about the correctness of the conjecture for all seven$-$vertex tournaments remained open. In this paper we prove the correctness of the conjecture for several seven$-$vertex tournaments.