arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this paper, we investigate the number of induced subgraphs and subdigraphs of Paley graphs and Paley tournaments where the (out-)degree of each vertex has the same parity. For Paley graphs, we establish a lower bound for the number of large even induced subgraphs, particularly those containing a constant proportion of vertices. We determine the number of even-even partitions of Paley graphs, showing it is exponential if $q\equiv 1\Mod{8}$ and is trivial if $q\equiv 5\Mod{8}$, while proving the non-existence of even-even partition for Paley tournaments. Furthermore, we derive asymptotic formulas for the numbers of even induced sub(di)graphs of order $r=o(q^{1/4})$ in Paley graphs and Paley tournaments, demonstrating their concentration around the expected values in the corresponding random (di)graph models. In the context of coding theory, we establish a correspondence between even/odd induced sub(di)graphs of Paley graphs (tournaments) and maximum distance separable (MDS) self-dual codes that can be constructed via (extended) generalized Reed-Solomon codes from subsets of finite fields. As a consequence, our contribution on induced subgraphs leads to new existence and counting results about MDS self-dual codes.

The score set of a tournament is defined as the set of its distinct out-degrees. In 1978, Reid proposed the conjecture that for any set of nonnegative integers $D$, there exists a tournament $T$ with a degree set $D$. In 1989, Yao presented an arithmetical proof of the conjecture, but a general polynomial-time construction algorithm is not known. This paper proposes a necessary and sufficient condition and a separate necessary condition, based on the existing Landau's theorem for the problem of reconstructing score sequences from score sets of tournament graphs. The necessary condition introduces a structured set that enables the use of group-theoretic techniques, offering not only a framework for solving the reconstruction problem but also a new perspective for approaching similar problems. In particular, the same theoretical approach can be extended to reconstruct valid score sets given constraints on the frequency of distinct scores in tournaments. Based on these conditions, we have developed three algorithms that demonstrate the practical utility of our framework: a polynomial-time algorithm and a scalable algorithm for reconstructing score sequences, and a polynomial-time network-building method that finds all possible score sequences for a given score set. Moreover, the polynomial-time algorithm for reconstructing the score sequence of a tournament for a given score set can be used to verify Reid's conjecture. These algorithms have practical applications in sports analysis, ranking prediction, and machine learning tasks such as learning-to-rank models and data imputation, where the reconstruction of partial rankings or sequences is essential for recommendation systems and anomaly detection.

As a directed analog of Sidorenko's conjecture in extremal graph theory, Fox, Himwich, Zhou, and the second author defined an oriented graph $H$ to be tournament Sidorenko (anti-Sidorenko) if the random tournament asymptotically minimizes (maximizes) the number of copies of $H$ among all tournaments. We prove new inequalities of this form for oriented trees and cycles, considering both local and global notions of the Sidorenko property. We make progress on a conjecture of the aforementioned authors that every tree has an anti-Sidorenko direction, and give a characterization of short paths. For long paths we show that orientations are split symmetrically between being locally Sidorenko and anti-Sidorenko, yet almost all orientations are not globally Sidorenko. Finally, we give algorithms characterizing the local Sidorenko status of paths and cycles when the number of vertices is not divisible by four.

We study the following Ramsey-theoretic question: given a $q$-coloring of the edges of a tournament, how long of a directed path can we guarantee whose edges avoid one of the colors? Questions of this type have applications in many areas, such as vector sequences, convex geometry, and extremal hypergraph theory, and have been extensively studied over the past 50 years. We prove that if $\varepsilon>0$ is fixed and $q$ is sufficiently large, then every $q$-edge-colored $N$-vertex tournament contains a color-avoiding directed path of length $N^{1-\varepsilon}$. This answers a question of Gowers and Long, strengthens several of their results, and extends earlier work of Loh.

Havet and Thomassé proved that every tournament of order $n\geq 8$ contains every oriented Hamiltonian path, which was conjectured by Rosenfeld. Recently, it was shown that in any tournament $T$ of order $n\geq 8$, there exists an arc $e$ such that $T-e$ contains any oriented Hamiltonian path. A natural extension of this problem is to study the stability of this property under arbitrary arc deletion. In this paper, we prove that every arc $e$ in a tournament $T$ of order $n\geq 8$ satisfies that $T-e$ contains every oriented Hamiltonian path, except for some explicitly described exceptions.

This paper is devoted to the structure of the complete asymptotic expansion of the probability that a large combinatorial object is irreducible or consists of a given number of irreducible parts, where irreducibility is understood in terms of combinatorial construction SEQ, labeled or unlabeled. We show that for rapidly growing (i.e. gargantuan) combinatorial classes, the coefficients that appear in this expansion are integers and can be interpreted as linear combinations of the counting sequences of three closely related combinatorial classes. We apply this general asymptotic result to labeled and unlabeled (multi-)tournaments, as well as to (multi-)permutations and (multi-)matchings. We also explore the limits of our approach with respect to other combinatorial constructions.

Given an oriented graph $D$, the inversion of a subset $X$ of vertices consists in reversing the orientation of all arcs with both endpoints in $X$. When the subset $X$ is of size $p$ (resp. at most $p$), this operation is called an $(=p)$-inversion (resp. $(\leq p)$-inversion). Then, an oriented graph is $(=p)$-invertible if it can be made acyclic by a sequence of $p$-inversions. We observe that, for $n=|V(D)|$, deciding whether $D$ is $(=n-1)$-invertible is equivalent to deciding whether $D$ is acyclically pushable, and thus NP-complete. In all other cases, when $p \neq n-1$, we construct a polynomial-time algorithm to decide $(=p)$-invertibility. We then consider the $(= p)$-inversion number, $\text{inv}^{= p}(D)$ (resp. $(\leq p)$-inversion number, $\text{inv}^{\leq p}(D)$), defined as the minimum number of $(=p)$-inversions (resp. $(\leq p)$-inversions) rendering $D$ acyclic. We show that every $(=p)$-invertible digraph $D$ satisfies $\text{inv}^{= p}(D) \leq |A(D)|$ for every integer $p\geq 2$. When $p$ is even, we bound $\text{inv}^{= p}$ by a (linear) function of the feedback arc set number, and rule out the existence of any bounding function for odd $p$. Finally, we study the complexity of deciding whether the $(= p)$-inversion number, or the $(\leq p)$-inversion number, of a given oriented graph is at most a given integer $k$. For any fixed positive integer $p \geq 2$, when $k$ is part of the input, we show that both problems are NP-hard even in tournaments. In general oriented graphs, we prove $W[1]$-hardness for both problems when parameterized by $p$, even for $k=1$. In contrast, we exhibit polynomial kernels in $p + k$ for both problems in tournaments.

The dichromatic number $\vecχ(D)$ of a digraph $D=(V,A)$ is the minimum number of sets in a partition $V_1,\ldots{},V_k$ of $V$ into $k$ subsets so that the induced subdigraph $D[V_i]$ is acyclic for each $i\in [k]$. This is a generalization of the chromatic number for undirected graphs as a graph has chromatic number at most $k$ if and only if the complete biorientation of $G$ (replace each edge by a directed 2-cycle) has dichromatic number at most $k$. In this paper we introduce the acyclic dichromatic number $\vecχ_{\rm a}(D)$ of a digraph $D$ as the minimum number of sets in a partition $V_1,\ldots{},V_k$ of $V$ so that the induced subdigraph $D[V_i]$ is acyclic for each $i\in [k]$ and each of the bipartite induced subdigraphs $D[V_i,V_j]$ is acyclic for each $1\leq i<j\leq k$. This parameter, which resembles the definition of acyclic chromatic number for undirected graphs, has apparently not been studied before. We derive a number of results which display the difference between the dichromatic number and the acyclic dichromatic number, in particular, there are digraphs $D$ with arbitrarily large $\vecχ_{\rm a}(D)-\vecχ(D)$, even among tournaments with dichromatic number 2 and bipartite tournaments (where the dichromatic number is always 2). We prove several complexity results, including that deciding whether $\vecχ_{\rm a}(D)\leq 2$ is NP-complete already for bipartite digraphs, while it is polynomial for tournaments (contrary to the case for dichromatic number). We also generalize the concept of heroes of a tournament to acyclic heroes of tournaments.

Tournament ranking is a function that assigns each vertex of a tournament (i.e., a directed graph without loops, in which each pair of different vertexes is connected by exactly one arc) a number called the rank of the vertex. One of approaches to constructing tournament rankings suggests choosing a ranking that satisfies a fixed set of axioms. In another approach, proposed by Erdős and Moon, only injective rankings are considered, and among them, one that minimises the number of backward arcs is selected (an arc $x\to y$ is called backward iff the rank of $x$ is less than the rank of $y$). We combine these two approaches as follows: among the rankings that satisfy a fixed set of axioms, we choose one that minimises the number of backward arcs. The Erdős-Moon approach naturally leads to the question of how small the proportion of backward arcs can be guaranteed when using injective rankings. Erdős and Moon showed that the answer to this question is $1/2$. A similar question arises in our approach: how small the proportion of backward arcs can be guaranteed when using rankings that satisfy a set of axioms $\mathcal{A}$? We call this number the Erdős-Moon number of $\mathcal{A}$. We prove that the Erdős-Moon number of the Copeland axiom equals $3/4$.

For a fixed integer $e \geqslant 3$ and $n$ large enough, we show that the number of congruence classes modulo $2^e$ of characteristic polynomials of $n \times n$ symmetric $\{\pm 1\}$-matrices with constant diagonal is equal to $2^{\binom{e-2}{2}}$ if $n$ is even or $2^{\binom{e-2}{2}+1}$ if $n$ is odd, thereby solving a conjecture of Greaves and Yatsyna from 2019. We also show that, for $n$ large enough, the number of congruence classes modulo $2^e$ of characteristic polynomials of $n \times n$ skew-symmetric $\{\pm 1\}$-matrices with constant diagonal is equal to $2^{\lfloor \frac{e-1}{2} \rfloor\lfloor \frac{e-2}{2} \rfloor}$ if $n$ is even or $2^{\lfloor \frac{e-2}{2} \rfloor\lfloor \frac{e-3}{2} \rfloor}$ if $n$ is odd. We introduce the concept of a lift graph/tournament, which serves as our main tool. We also introduce the notion of the walk polynomial of a graph, which enables us to show the existence of the requisite lift tournaments.

We extend the list of tournaments $S$ for which the complete structural description for tournaments excluding $S$ as a subtournament is known. Specifically, let $Δ(1, 2, 2)$ be a tournament on five vertices obtained from a cyclic triangle by substituting a two-vertex tournament for two of its vertices. In this paper, we show that tournaments excluding $Δ(1, 2, 2)$ as a subtournament are either isomorphic to one of three small tournaments, obtained from a transitive tournament by reversing edges in vertex-disjoint directed paths, or obtained from a smaller tournament with the same property by applying one of two operations. In particular, one of these operations creates a homogeneous set that induces a subtournament isomorphic to one of three fixed tournaments, and the other creates a homogeneous pair such that their union induces a subtournament isomorphic to a fixed tournament. As an application of this result, we present an upper bound for the chromatic number, a lower bound for the size of a largest transitive subtournament, and a lower bound for the number of vertex-disjoint cyclic triangles for such tournaments. The bounds that we present are all best possible.

We define symmetric designs of dimension $n$ and propriety $d$, providing a unifying generalization of several classes of higher-dimensional symmetric designs previously studied. We focus on the case $n=d=3$, which leads to the following question: Can we fill the $v^3$ cells of a $v\times v\times v$ cube with $\{0,1\}$ in such a way that each layer parallel to each face contains a fixed number $k$ of ones, and that for every two parallel layers there are exactly $λ$ positions where they have matching ones? We establish necessary conditions on the parameters $(v,k,λ)$, introduce notions of difference sets and multipliers for these objects, and enumerate small examples up to equivalence. Furthermore, we construct infinite families of these objects using difference sets, symmetric designs, doubly regular tournaments, Hadamard matrices, Latin cubes, and association schemes on triples.

In this work, we investigate Maker-Breaker directed triangle games -- a directionally constrained variant of the classical Maker-Breaker triangle game. Our board of interest is a tournament, and the winning sets constitute all directed triangles ($3$-cycles) present in the tournament. We begin by studying the Maker-Breaker directed triangle game played on a specially defined tournament called the parity tournament, and we identify the board size threshold to be $n=7$, which is to say that if the size (i.e.\ the number of vertices) of the parity tournament equals $n$, Breaker has a winning strategy for $3\leq n< 7$, while Maker can ensure a win for herself for $n\geq 7$. For the $(1:b)$ biased version of this game, we prove that the bias threshold $b^*(n)$ satisfies $\sqrt{\left(1/12+o(1)\right)\ n}\leq b^{*}(n) \leq\sqrt{\left(8/3+o(1)\right)\ n}$, which matches the order of magnitude (\ $\sqrt{n}$) of the bias threshold for the undirected counterpart of this game. Next, we consider the game on random tournaments $T(n,p)$ with labeled vertices $1,2,\ldots,n$, such that the edge between $i$ and $j$, for each $i<j$, is directed from $i$ towards $j$ with probability $p$, independent of all else. We prove that Maker wins this game with probability approaching $1$ as $n \to \infty$ for any fixed $p \in (0,1)$. Extending the notion of `bias' from undirected games to our directed framework, we introduce the $(1: κ(n))$ flip-biased Maker-Breaker directed triangle game on the parity tournament, where we allow Breaker to strategically flip the directions of a fixed number of edges $κ(n)$ before the game begins. We show that the flip-bias threshold $κ^*(n)$ is asymptotically equal to $n^2/4$ as $n \to \infty$. This work opens up the possibility of studying a variety of directionally constrained Maker-Breaker positional games on tournaments (and more generally, on directed graphs).

In 1934 L. Rédei published his famous theorem that the number of Hamiltonian paths in a tournament is odd. In fact it is a corollary of a stronger theorem in his paper. Stronger theorems were also obtained in the early 1970s by G.A. Dirac in his lectures at Aarhus University and by C. Berge in his monographs on graphs and hypergraphs. We exhibit the stronger theorems of Rédei, Dirac and Berge and explain connections between them. The stronger theorem of Dirac has two corollaries, one equivalent to Rédei's stronger theorem and the other related to Berge's stronger theorem.

Given a digraph $D$ with no loops, the \textit{dicoloring graph} of $D$, denoted by $\mathcal{D}_k(D)$, is the graph whose vertices are the acyclic $k$-colorings of $D$ and two colorings are adjacent in $\mathcal{D}_k(D)$ if they differ in color on exactly one vertex. In this paper, we prove that there is no expression $φ(\vecχ)$ in terms of the dichromatic number $\vecχ$, such that the graph $\mathcal{D}_k(D)$ is connected for all graphs $D$ and integers $k\geq φ(\vecχ)$. We give conditions for the dicoloring graph of two infinite families of circulant tournaments to be connected, and we provide upper bounds for its diameter. In particular, for the Payley tournament $\vec{C}_{7}(1,2,4)$, also known as $ST_7$, we prove that $\mathcal{D}_k(\vec{C}_{7}(1,2,4))$ is connected and has diameter 8, for each $k\geq 3$.

We prove that for every surface $Σ$, the class of Eulerian directed graphs that are Eulerian embeddable into $Σ$ (in particular they have degree at most $4$) is well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. This result marks one of the most versatile directed graph classes (besides tournaments) for which we are aware of a positive well-quasi-ordering result regarding a well-studied graph relation. Our result implies that the class of bipartite circle graphs is well-quasi-ordered under the pivot-minor relation. Furthermore, this also yields two other interesting applications, namely, a polynomial-time algorithm for testing immersion closed properties of Eulerian-embeddable graphs into a fixed surface, and a characterisation of the Erdős-Pósa property for Eulerian digraphs of maximum degree four. Further, in order to prove the mentioned result, we prove that Eulerian digraphs of carving width bounded by some constant $k$ (which correspond to Eulerian digraphs with bounded treewidth and additionally bounded degree) are well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion. We actually prove a stronger result where we allow for vertices of the Eulerian digraphs to be labeled by elements of some well-quasi-order $Ω$. We complement these results with a proof that the class of Eulerian planar digraphs of treewidth at most $3$ is not well-quasi-ordered by strong immersion, noting that any antichain of bounded treewidth cannot have bounded degree.

Strongly chordal digraphs are included in the class of chordal digraphs and generalize strongly chordal graphs and chordal bipartite graphs. They are the digraphs that admit a linear ordering of its vertex set for which their adjacency matrix does not contain the $Γ$ matrix as a submatrix. In general, it is not clear if these digraphs can be recognized in polynomial time. We focus on multipartite tournaments with possible loops. We give a polynomial-time recognition algorithm and a forbidden induced subgraph characterization of the strong chordality for each of the following cases: tournaments with possible loops, reflexive multipartite tournaments, irreflexive bipartite tournaments, irreflexive tournaments minus one arc, and balanced digraphs. In addition, we prove that in a strongly chordal digraph the minimum size of a total dominating set equals the maximum number of disjoint in-neighborhoods, and this number can be calculated in linear time given a $Γ$-free ordering of the input graph.

We introduce the notion of equiangular tight frames in real symplectic spaces and formulate a conjecture on their existence in terms of the dimension and number of vectors. Our main results shows the "symplectic Zauner's conjecture" is equivalent to the skew Hadamard conjecture. The proof involves counting subgraphs called "diamonds" in tournaments.

For an oriented graph $D$, the inversion of $X\subseteq V(D)$ in $D$ is the graph obtained by reversing the orientation of all arcs with both ends in $X$. The inversion number $\mathrm{inv}(D)$ is the minimum number of inversions needed to obtain an acyclic oriented graph. We show that the dijoin conjecture of Bang-Jensen, da Silva and Havet, that $\mathrm{inv}(D_1\rightarrow D_2)=\mathrm{inv}(D_1)+\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$, is true in the case where $\mathrm{inv}(D_1)=2$ and $\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$ is even. We also characterise the cases $\mathrm{inv}(D_1)=2$ and $\mathrm{inv}(D_2)$ odd, for which the conjecture does and does not hold. We then go on to show a similar result for n-joins, in doing so we prove a conjecture of Alon, Powierski, Savery, Scott and Wilmer. Our proofs build on the idea of tournament minimum rank, introduced by Behague, Johnston, Morrison and Ogden.

The chromatic profile of a digraph $H$, denoted by $δ_χ^{+}(H,k)$, is the infimum $d$ such that any $H$-free digraph $D$ on $n$ vertices with minimum out-degree $δ^{+}(D) \ge dn$ must be $k$-colorable. We determine the exact chromatic profile for several fundamental classes of digraphs. Our main result is a directed analogue of the Andrásfai-Erdős-Sós theorem, stating that $δ_χ^{+}(T_r, r-1)=\frac{3 r-7}{3 r-4}$, where $T_r$ is the transitive tournament on $r$ vertices. We then determine the chromatic profile for directed odd cycles, showing that $δ^+_χ(\overrightarrow{C}_{2\ell+1},2)=1/2$ for all $\ell\ge 1$. Finally, we resolve the profile for the three remaining orientations of the pentagon, establishing that $δ_χ^{+}(C_{5}',2)=δ_χ^{+}(C_{5}'',2)=δ_χ^{+}(C_{5}''',2)=1/3$.