arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $G=(\mathbb Z/n\mathbb Z) \oplus (\mathbb Z/n\mathbb Z)$. Let $\mathsf {s}_{\leq k}(G)$ be the smallest integer $\ell$ such that every sequence of $\ell$ terms from $G$, with repetition allowed, has a nonempty zero-sum subsequence with length at most $k$. It is known that $\mathsf {s}_{\leq 2n-1-k}(G)=2n-1+k$ for $k\in [0,n-1]$, with the structure of extremal sequences showing this bound tight determined when $k\in \{0,1,n-1\}$, and for various special cases when $k\in [2,n-2]$. For the remaining values $k\in [2,n-2]$, the characterization of extremal sequences of length $2n-2+k$ avoiding a nonempty zero-sum of length at most $2n-1-k$ remained open in general, with it conjectured that they must all have the form $e_1^{[n-1]} \boldsymbol{\cdot} e_2^{[n-1]} \boldsymbol{\cdot} (e_1 +e_2)^{[k]}$ for some basis $(e_1,e_2)$ for $G$. Here $x^{[n]}$ denotes a sequence consisting of the term $x$ repeated $n$ times. In this paper, we establish this conjecture for all $k\in [2,n-2]$ when $n$ is prime, which in view of other recent work, implies the conjectured structure for all rank two abelian groups.

We begin by explaining how arguments used by R. Wilson to give an elementary proof of the $\mathbb F_p$ case for the Ax-Katz Theorem can also be used to prove the following generalization of the Chevalley-Warning and Ax-Katz Theorems for $\mathbb F_p$, where we allow varying prime power moduli. Given any box $\mathcal B=\mathcal I_1\times\ldots\times\mathcal I_n$, with each $\mathcal I_j\subseteq\mathbb Z$ a complete system of residues modulo $p$, and a collection of nonzero polynomials $f_1,\ldots,f_s\in \mathbb Z[X_1,\ldots,X_n]$, then the set of common zeros inside the box, $$V=\{\mathbf a\in \mathcal B:\; f_1(\textbf a)\equiv 0\mod p^{m_1},\ldots,f_s(\textbf a)\equiv 0\mod p^{m_s}\},$$ satisfies $|V|\equiv 0\mod p^m$, provided $n>(m-1)\max_{i\in [1,s]}\Big\{p^{m_i-1}\mathsf{deg} f_i\Big\}+ \sum_{i=1}^{s}\frac{p^{m_i}-1}{p-1}\mathsf{deg} f_i.$ The introduction of the box $\mathcal B$ adds a degree of flexibility, in comparison to prior work of Zhi-Wei Sun. Indeed, incorporating the ideas of Sun, a weighted version of the above result is given. We continue by explaining how the added flexibility, combined with an appropriate use of Hensel's Lemma to choose the complete system of residues $\mathcal I_j$, effectively allows many combinatorial applications of the Chevalley-Warning and Ax-Katz Theorems, previously only valid for $\mathbb F_p^n$, to extend with bare minimal modification to validity for an arbitrary finite abelian $p$-group $G$. We illustrate this be giving several examples, including a new proof of the exact value of the Davenport Constant $\mathsf D(G)$ for finite abelian $p$-groups, a streamlined proof of the Kemnitz Conjecture, and the resolution of a problem of Xiaoyu He regarding zero-sums of length $k\exp(G)$ related to a conjecture of Kubertin.

Let $G=C_n\oplus C_{mn}$ with $n\geq 2$ and $m\geq 1$, and let $k\in [0,n-1]$. It is known that any sequence of $mn+n-1+k$ terms from $G$ must contain a nontrivial zero-sum of length at most $mn+n-1-k$. The associated inverse question is to characterize those sequences with maximal length $mn+n-2+k$ that fail to contain a nontrivial zero-sum subsequence of length at most $mn+n-1-k$. For $k\leq 1$, this is the inverse question for the Davenport Constant. For $k=n-1$, this is the inverse question for the $η(G)$ invariant concerning short zero-sum subsequences. The structure in both these cases is known, and the structure for $k\in [2,n-2]$ when $m=1$ was studied previously with it conjectured that they must have the form $S=e_1^{[n-1]}\boldsymbol{\cdot} e_2^{[n-1]}\boldsymbol{\cdot} (e_1+e_2)^{[k]}$ for some basis $(e_1,e_2)$, with the conjecture established in many cases. We focus on $m\geq 2$. Assuming the conjectured structure holds for $k\in [2,n-2]$ in $C_n\oplus C_n$, we characterize the structure of all sequences of maximal length $mn+n-2+k$ in $C_n\oplus C_{mn}$ that fail to contain a nontrivial zero-sum of length at most $mn+n-1-k$, showing they must have either have the form $S=e_1^{[n-1]}\boldsymbol{\cdot} e_2^{[sn-1]}\boldsymbol{\cdot} (e_1+e_2)^{[(m-s)n+k]}$ for some $s\in [1,m]$ and basis $(e_1,e_2)$ with $\mathsf{ord}(e_2)=mn$, or else have the form $S=g_1^{[n-1]}\boldsymbol{\cdot} g_2^{[n-1]}\boldsymbol{\cdot} (g_1+g_2)^{[(m-1)n+k]}$ for some generating set $\{g_1,g_2\}$ with $\mathsf{ord}(g_1+g_2)=mn$. Additionally, we give a new proof of the precise structure in the case $k=n-1$ for $m=1$. Combined with known results, our results unconditionally establish the structure of extremal sequences in $G=C_n\oplus C_{mn}$ in many cases.

Our motivating goal is factorization in Krull Domains $H$ with finitely generated class group $G$. The elasticity $ρ(H)$ is the maximal number of atoms in any re-factorization of a product of $k$ atoms. The elasticities are the same as those of a combinatorial monoid of zero-sum sequences $B(G_0)$, where $G_0\subseteq G$ are the classes with height one primes. We characterize when finite elasticity holds for any Krull Domain with finitely generated class group. Our results are valid for the more general class of Transfer Krull Monoids (over a subset $G_0$ of a finitely generated abelian group $G$). We show there is a minimal $s\leq (d+1)m$, where $d$ is the torsion free rank and $m$ is the torsion exponent, such that $ρ_s(H)<\infty$ implies $ρ_k(H)<\infty$ for all $k\geq 1$. This ensures $ρ(H)<\infty$ if and only if $ρ_{(d+1)m}(H)<\infty$. Our characterization is in terms of a simple combinatorial obstruction to infinite elasticity: there existing a subset $G_0^\diamond\subseteq G_0$ and bound $N$ such that there are no nontrivial zero-sum sequences with terms from $G_0^\diamond$, and every minimal zero-sum sequence has at most $N$ terms from $G_0\setminus G_0^\diamond$. We give an explicit description of $G_0^\diamond$ in terms of the Convex Geometry of $G_0$ modulo the torsion subgroup $G_T\leq G$, and show finite elasticity is equivalent to there being no positive linear combination of the elements of this explicitly defined subset equal to $0$ modulo $G_T$. We use our results to show finite elasticity implies the set of distances $Δ(H)$, the catenary degree $\mathsf c(H)$ (for Krull Monoids) and a weakened tame degree (for Krull Monoids) are all also finite, and that the Structure Theorem for Unions holds. Our results for factorization in Transfer Krull Monoids are accomplished by developing an extensive theory in Convex Geometry generalizing positive bases.

The $3k-4$ Theorem is a classical result which asserts that if $A,\,B\subseteq \mathbb Z$ are finite, nonempty subsets with \begin{equation}\label{hyp}|A+B|=|A|+|B|+r\leq |A|+|B|+\min\{|A|,\,|B|\}-3-δ,\end{equation} where $δ=1$ if $A$ and $B$ are translates of each other, and otherwise $δ=0$, then there are arithmetic progressions $P_A$ and $P_B$ of common difference such that $A\subseteq P_A$, $B\subseteq P_B$, $|B|\leq |P_B|+r+1$ and $|P_A|\leq |A|+r+1$. It is one of the few cases in Freiman's Theorem for which exact bounds on the sizes of the progressions are known. The hypothesis above is best possible in the sense that there are examples of sumsets $A+B$ having cardinality just one more, yet $A$ and $B$ cannot both be contained in short length arithmetic progressions. In this paper, we show that the hypothesis above can be significantly weakened and still yield the same conclusion for one of the sets $A$ and $B$. Specifically, if $|B|\geq 3$, $s\geq 1$ is the unique integer with $$(s-1)s\left(\frac{|B|}{2}-1\right)+s-1<|A|\leq s(s+1)\left(\frac{|B|}{2}-1\right)+s,$$ and \begin{equation}\label{hyp2} |A+B|=|A|+|B|+r< (\frac{|A|}{s}+\frac{|B|}{2}-1)(s+1),\end{equation} then we show there is an arithmetic progression $P_B\subseteq \mathbb Z$ with $B\subseteq P_B$ and $|P_B|\leq |B|+r+1$. The above hypothesis is best possible (without additional assumptions on $A$) for obtaining such a conclusion.

Let $G$ be a finite group. A sequence over $G$ means a finite sequence of terms from $G$, where repetition is allowed and the order is disregarded. A product-one sequence is a sequence whose elements can be ordered such that their product equals the identity element of the group. The set of all product-one sequences over $G$ (with concatenation of sequences as the operation) is a finitely generated C-monoid. Product-one sequences over dihedral groups have a variety of extremal properties. This article provides a detailed investigation, with methods from arithmetic combinatorics, of the arithmetic of the monoid of product-one sequences over dihedral groups.

For a sequence $S$ of terms from an abelian group $G$ of length $|S|$, let $Σ_n(S)$ denote the set of all elements that can be represented as the sum of terms in some $n$-term subsequence of $S$. When the subsum set is very small, $|Σ_n(S)|\leq |S|-n+1$, it is known that the terms of $S$ can be partitioned into $n$ nonempty sets $A_1,\ldots,A_n\subseteq G$ such that $Σ_n(S)=A_1+\ldots+A_n$. Moreover, if the upper bound is strict, then $|A_i\setminus Z|\leq 1$ for all $i$, where $Z=\bigcap_{i=1}^{n}(A_i+H)$ and $H=\{g\in G:\; g+Σ_n(S)=Σ_n(S)\}$ is the stabilizer of $Σ_n(S)$. This allows structural results for sumsets to be used to study the subsum set $Σ_n(S)$ and is one of the two main ways to derive the natural subsum analog of Kneser's Theorem for sumsets. In this paper, we show that such a partitioning can be achieved with sets $A_i$ of as near equal a size as possible, so $\lfloor \frac{|S|}{n}\rfloor \leq |A_i|\leq \lceil\frac{|S|}{n}\rceil$ for all $i$, apart from one highly structured counterexample when $|Σ_n(S)|= |S|-n+1$ with $n=2$. The added information of knowing the sets $A_i$ are of near equal size can be of use when applying the aforementioned partitioning result, or when applying sumset results to study $Σ_n(S)$. We also give an extension increasing the flexibility of the aforementioned partitioning result and prove some stronger results when $n\geq \frac12|S|$ is very large.

The $3k-4$ conjecture in groups $\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ for $p$ prime states that if $A$ is a nonempty subset of $\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ satisfying $2A\neq \mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ and $|2A|=2|A|+r \leq \min\{3|A|-4,\;p-r-4\}$, then $A$ is covered by an arithmetic progression of size at most $|A|+r+1$. A theorem of Serra and Zémor proves the conjecture provided $r\leq 0.0001|A|$, without any additional constraint on $|A|$. Subject to the mild additional constraint $|2A|\leq 3p/4$ (which is optimal in a sense explained in the paper), our first main result improves the bound on $r$, allowing $r\leq 0.1368|A|$. We also prove a variant which further improves this bound on $r$ provided $A$ is sufficiently dense. We then give several applications. First we apply the above variant to give a new upper bound for the maximal density of $m$-sum-free sets in $\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$, i.e., sets $A$ having no solution $(x,y,z)\in A^3$ to the equation $x+y=mz$, where $m\geq 3$ is a fixed integer. The previous best upper bound for this maximal density was $1/3.0001$ (using the Serra-Zémor Theorem). We improve this to $1/3.1955$. We also present a construction following an idea of Schoen, which yields a lower bound for this maximal density of the form $1/8+o(1)_{p\to\infty}$. Another application of our main results concerns sets of the form $\frac{A+A}{A}$ in $\mathbb{F}_p$, and we also improve the structural description of large sum-free sets in $\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$.

Let $[a,b]$ denote the integers between $a$ and $b$ inclusive and, for a finite subset $X \subseteq \mathbb{Z}$, let the diameter of $X$ be equal to $\max(X)-\min(X)$. We write $X<_p\,Y$ provided $\max(X)<\min(Y)$. For a positive integer $m$, let $f(m,m,m;2)$ be the least integer $N$ such that any $2$-coloring $Δ: [1, N]\rightarrow \{0,1\}$ has three monochromatic $m$-sets $B_1, B_2, B_3 \subseteq [1,N]$ (not necessarily of the same color) with $B_1<_p\, B_2 <_p\, B_3$ and $diam(B_1)\leq diam(B_2)\leq diam(B_3)$. Improving upon upper and lower bounds of Bialostocki, Erd\H os and Lefmann, we show that $f(m,m,m;2)=8m-5+\lfloor\frac{2m-2}{3}\rfloor+δ$ for $m\geq 2$, where $δ=1$ if $m\in \{2,5\}$ and $δ=0$ otherwise.

Let $R$ be a ring and let $\mathcal C$ be a small class of right $R$-modules which is closed under finite direct sums, direct summands, and isomorphisms. Let $\mathcal V (\mathcal C)$ denote a set of representatives of isomorphism classes in $\mathcal C$ and, for any module $M$ in $\mathcal C$, let $[M]$ denote the unique element in $\mathcal V (\mathcal C)$ isomorphic to $M$. Then $\mathcal V (\mathcal C)$ is a reduced commutative semigroup with operation defined by $[M] + [N] = [M \oplus N]$, and this semigroup carries all information about direct-sum decompositions of modules in $\mathcal C$. This semigroup-theoretical point of view has been prevalent in the theory of direct-sum decompositions since it was shown that if $\operatorname{End}_R (M)$ is semilocal for all $M\in \mathcal C$, then $\mathcal V (\mathcal C)$ is a Krull monoid. Suppose that the monoid $\mathcal V (\mathcal C)$ is Krull with a finitely generated class group (for example, when $\mathcal C$ is the class of finitely generated torsion-free modules and $R$ is a one-dimensional reduced Noetherian local ring). In this case we study the arithmetic of $\mathcal V (\mathcal C)$ using new methods from zero-sum theory. Furthermore, based on module-theoretic work of Lam, Levy, Robson, and others we study the algebraic and arithmetic structure of the monoid $\mathcal V (\mathcal C)$ for certain classes of modules over Prüfer rings and hereditary Noetherian prime rings.

For a finite abelian group $G$ and a positive integer $d$, let $\mathsf s_{d \mathbb N} (G)$ denote the smallest integer $\ell \in \mathbb N_0$ such that every sequence $S$ over $G$ of length $|S| \ge \ell$ has a nonempty zero-sum subsequence $T$ of length $|T| \equiv 0 \mod d$. We determine $\mathsf s_{d \mathbb N} (G)$ for all $d\geq 1$ when $G$ has rank at most two and, under mild conditions on $d$, also obtain precise values in the case of $p$-groups. In the same spirit, we obtain new upper bounds for the Erd{\H o}s--Ginzburg--Ziv constant provided that, for the $p$-subgroups $G_p$ of $G$, the Davenport constant $\mathsf D (G_p)$ is bounded above by $2 \exp (G_p)-1$. This generalizes former results for groups of rank two.

Let G be a finite additive abelian group with exponent exp(G)=n>1 and let A be a nonempty subset of {1,...,n-1}. In this paper, we investigate the smallest positive integer $m$, denoted by s_A(G), such that any sequence {c_i}_{i=1}^m with terms from G has a length n=exp(G) subsequence {c_{i_j}}_{j=1}^n for which there are a_1,...,a_n in A such that sum_{j=1}^na_ic_{i_j}=0. When G is a p-group, A contains no multiples of p and any two distinct elements of A are incongruent mod p, we show that s_A(G) is at most $\lceil D(G)/|A|\rceil+exp(G)-1$ if |A| is at least (D(G)-1)/(exp(G)-1), where D(G) is the Davenport constant of G and this upper bound for s_A(G)in terms of |A| is essentially best possible. In the case A={1,-1}, we determine the asymptotic behavior of s_{1,-1}(G) when exp(G) is even, showing that, for finite abelian groups of even exponent and fixed rank, s_{1,-1}(G)=exp(G)+log_2|G|+O(log_2log_2|G|) as exp(G) tends to the infinity. Combined with a lower bound of $exp(G)+sum{i=1}{r}\lfloor\log_2 n_i\rfloor$, where $G=\Z_{n_1}\oplus...\oplus \Z_{n_r}$ with 1<n_1|... |n_r, this determines s_{1,-1}(G), for even exponent groups, up to a small order error term. Our method makes use of the theory of L-intersecting set systems. Some additional more specific values and results related to s_{1,-1}(G) are also computed.

Let $H$ be a Krull monoid with finite class group $G$ such that every class contains a prime divisor (for example, a ring of integers in an algebraic number field or a holomorphy ring in an algebraic function field). The catenary degree $\mathsf c (H)$ of $H$ is the smallest integer $N$ with the following property: for each $a \in H$ and each two factorizations $z, z'$ of $a$, there exist factorizations $z = z_0, ..., z_k = z'$ of $a$ such that, for each $i \in [1, k]$, $z_i$ arises from $z_{i-1}$ by replacing at most $N$ atoms from $z_{i-1}$ by at most $N$ new atoms. Under a very mild condition on the Davenport constant of $G$, we establish a new and simple characterization of the catenary degree. This characterization gives a new structural understanding of the catenary degree. In particular, it clarifies the relationship between $\mathsf c (H)$ and the set of distances of $H$ and opens the way towards obtaining more detailed results on the catenary degree. As first applications, we give a new upper bound on $\mathsf c(H)$ and characterize when $\mathsf c(H)\leq 4$.

Let $A, B\subseteq \mathbb{Z}$ be finite, nonempty subsets with $\min A=\min B=0$, and let $$δ(A,B)={\begin{array}{ll} 1 & \hbox{if} A\subseteq B, 0 & \hbox{otherwise.} If $\max B\leq \max A\leq |A|+|B|-3$ and \label{one}|A+B|\leq |A|+2|B|-3-δ(A,B), then we show $A+B$ contains an arithmetic progression with difference 1 and length $|A|+|B|-1$. As a corollary, if \eqref{one} holds, $\max(B)\leq \max(A)$ and either $\gcd(A)=1$ or else $\gcd(A+B)=1$ and $|A+B|\leq 2|A|+|B|-3$, then $A+B$ contains an arithmetic progression with difference 1 and length $|A|+|B|-1$.

An old conjecture of Graham stated that if $n$ is a prime and $S$ is a sequence of $n$ terms from the cyclic group $C_n$ such that all (nontrivial) zero-sum subsequences have the same length, then $S$ must contain at most two distinct terms. In 1976, Erdős and Szemeredi gave a proof of the conjecture for sufficiently large primes $n$. However, the proof was complicated enough that the details for small primes were never worked out. Both in the paper of Erdős and Szemeredi and in a later survey by Erdős and Graham, the complexity of the proof was lamented. Recently, a new proof, valid even for non-primes $n$, was given by Gao, Hamidoune and Wang, using Savchev and Chen's recently proved structure theorem for zero-sum free sequences of long length in $C_n$. However, as this is a fairly involved result, they did not believe it to be the simple proof sought by Erdős, Graham and Szemeredi. In this paper, we give a short proof of the original conjecture that uses only the Cauchy-Davenport Theorem and pigeonhole principle, thus perhaps qualifying as a simple proof. Replacing the use of the Cauchy-Davenport Theorem with the Devos-Goddyn-Mohar Theorem, we obtain an alternate proof, albeit not as simple, of the non-prime case. Additionally, our method yields an exhaustive list detailing the precise structure of $S$ and works for an arbitrary finite abelian group, though the only non-cyclic group for which this is nontrivial is $C_2\oplus C_{2m}$.

Let $G$ be a finite abelian group and let $A\subseteq \mathbb{Z}$ be nonempty. Let $D_A(G)$ denote the minimal integer such that any sequence over $G$ of length $D_A(G)$ must contain a nontrivial subsequence $s_1... s_r$ such that $\sum_{i=1}^{r}w_is_i=0$ for some $w_i\in A$. Let $E_A(G)$ denote the minimal integer such that any sequence over $G$ of length $E_A(G)$ must contain a subsequence of length $|G|$, $s_1... s_{|G|}$, such that $\sum_{i=1}^{|G|}w_is_i=0$ for some $w_i\in A$. In this paper, we show that $$E_A(G)=|G|+D_A(G)-1,$$ confirming a conjecture of Thangadurai and the expectations of Adhikari, et al. The case $A=\{1\}$ is an older result of Gao, and our result extends much partial work done by Adhikari, Rath, Chen, David, Urroz, Xia, Yuan, Zeng and Thangadurai. Moreover, under a suitable multiplicity restriction, we show that not only can zero be represented in this manner, but an entire nontrivial subgroup, and if this subgroup is not the full group $G$, we obtain structural information for the sequence generalizing another non-weighted result of Gao. Our full theorem is valid for more general $n$-sums with $n\geq |G|$, in addition to the case $n=|G|$.

Let $t\geq 1$, let $A$ and $B$ be finite, nonempty subsets of an abelian group $G$, and let $A\pp{i} B$ denote all the elements $c$ with at least $i$ representations of the form $c=a+b$, with $a\in A$ and $b\in B$. For $|A|, |B|\geq t$, we show that either \be\label{almost}\Sum{i=1}{t}|A\pp{i} B|\geq t|A|+t|B|-2t^2+1,\ee or else there exist $A'\subseteq A$ and $B'\subseteq B$ with \ber \nn l&:=&|A\setminus A'|+|B\setminus B'|\leq t-1, \nn A'\pp{t}B'&=&A'+B'=A\pp{t}B,{and} \nn \Sum{i=1}{t}|A\pp{i}B|&\geq& t|A|+t|B|-(t-l)(|H|-ρ)-tl\geq t|A|+t|B|-t|H|,\eer where $H$ is the (nontrivial) stabilizer of $A\pp{t} B$ and $ρ=|A'+H|-|A'|+|B'+H|-|B'|$. In the case $t=2$, we improve (\ref{almost}) to $|A\pp{1}B|+|A\pp{2}B|\geq 2|A|+2|B|-4$.

Let $G$ be a finite abeilian group. A sequence $S$ with terms from $G$ is zero-sum if the sum of terms in $S$ equals zero. It is a minimal zero-sum sequence if no proper, nontrivial subsequence is zero-sum. The maximal length of a minimal zero-sum subsequence in $G$ is the Davenport constant, denoted $D(G)$. For a rank 2 group $G=C_n \oplus C_n$, it is known that $D(G)=2n-1$. However, the structure of all maximal length minimal zero-sum sequences remains open. If every such sequence contains a term with multiplicity $n-1$, then $C_n \oplus C_n$ is said to have Property B, and it is conjectured that this is true for all rank 2 groups $C_n \oplus C_n$. In this paper, we show that Property B is multiplicative, namely, if $G=C_n \oplus C_n$ and $G=C_m \oplus C_m$ both satisfy Property B, with $m, n\geq 3$ odd and $mn>9$, then $C_{mn}\oplus C_{mn}$ satisfies Property B also. Combined with previous work in the literature, this reduces the question of establishing Property B to the prime cases, and in such case the complete structural description of the sequence follows.

Let $p>7$ be a prime, let $G=\Z/p\Z$, and let $S_1=\prod_{i=1}^p g_i$ and $S_2=\prod_{i=1}^p h_i$ be two sequences with terms from $G$. Suppose that the maximum multiplicity of a term from either $S_1$ or $S_2$ is at most $\frac{2p+1}{5}$. Then we show that, for each $g\in G$, there exists a permutation $σ$ of $1,2,..., p$ such that $g=\sum_{i=1}^{p}(g_i\cdot h_{σ(i)})$. The question is related to a conjecture of A. Bialostocki concerning weighted subsequence sums and the Erdős-Ginzburg-Ziv Theorem.

Let $A, B\subseteq \mathbb{R}^2$ be finite, nonempty subsets, let $s\geq 2$ be an integer, and let $h_1(A,B)$ denote the minimal number $t$ such that there exist $2t$ (not necessarily distinct) parallel lines, $\ell_1,...,\ell_{t},\ell'_1,...,\ell'_{t}$, with $A\subseteq \bigcup_{i=1}^{t}\ell_i$ and $B\subseteq\bigcup_{i=1}^{t}\ell'_i$. Suppose $h_1(A,B)\geq s$. Then we show that: (a) if $||A|-|B||\leq s$ and $|A|+|B|\geq 4s^2-6s+3$, then $$|A+B|\geq (2-\frac 1 s)(|A|+|B|)-2s+1;$$ (b) if $|A|\geq |B|+s$ and $|B|\geq 2s^2-{7/2}s+{3/2}$, then $$|A+B|\geq |A|+(3-\frac 2 s)|B|-s;$$ (c) if $|A|\geq {1/2}s(s-1)|B|+s$ and either $|A|> {1/8}(2s-1)^2|B|-{1/4}(2s-1)+\frac{(s-1)^2}{2(|B|-2)}$ or $|B|\geq \frac{2s+4}{3}$, then $$|A+B|\geq |A|+s(|B|-1).$$ This extends the 2-dimensional case of the Freiman $2^d$--Theorem to distinct sets $A$ and $B$, and, in the symmetric case $A=B$, improves the best prior known bound for $|A|+|B|$ (due to Stanchescu, and which was cubic in $s$) to an exact value. As part of the proof, we give general lower bounds for two dimensional subsets that improve the 2-dimensional case of estimates of Green and Tao and of Gardner and Gronchi, and that generalize the 2-dimensional case of the Brunn-Minkowski Theorem.