arXiv++ Combinatorics

It is very well-known that there are precisely two minimal non-planar graphs: $K_5$ and $K_{3,3}$ (degree 2 vertices being irrelevant in this context). In the language of crossing numbers, these are the only 1-crossing-critical graphs: they each have crossing number at least one, and every proper subgraph has crossing number less than one. In 1987, Kochol exhibited an infinite family of 3-connected, simple 2-crossing-critical graphs. In this work, we: (i) determine all the 3-connected 2-crossing-critical graphs that contain a subdivision of the Möbius Ladder $V_{10}$; (ii) show how to obtain all the not 3-connected 2-crossing-critical graphs from the 3-connected ones; (iii) show that there are only finitely many 3-connected 2-crossing-critical graphs not containing a subdivision of $V_{10}$; and (iv) determine all the 3-connected 2-crossing-critical graphs that do not contain a subdivision of $V_{8}$.

The Harary-Hill Conjecture States that the number of crossings in any drawing of the complete graph $ K_n $ in the plane is at least $Z(n):=\frac{1}{4}\left\lfloor \frac{n}{2}\right\rfloor \left\lfloor\frac{n-1}{2}\right\rfloor \left\lfloor \frac{n-2}{2}\right\rfloor\left\lfloor \frac{n-3}{2}\right\rfloor$. In this paper, we settle the Harary-Hill conjecture for {\em shellable drawings}. We say that a drawing $D$ of $ K_n $ is {\em $ s $-shellable} if there exist a subset $ S = \{v_1,v_2,\ldots,v_ s\}$ of the vertices and a region $R$ of $D$ with the following property: For all $1 \leq i < j \leq s$, if $D_{ij}$ is the drawing obtained from $D$ by removing $v_1,v_2,\ldots v_{i-1},v_{j+1},\ldots,v_{s}$, then $v_i$ and $v_j$ are on the boundary of the region of $D_{ij}$ that contains $R$. For $ s\geq n/2 $, we prove that the number of crossings of any $ s $-shellable drawing of $ K_n $ is at least the long-conjectured value Z(n). Furthermore, we prove that all cylindrical, $ x $-bounded, monotone, and 2-page drawings of $ K_n $ are $ s $-shellable for some $ s\geq n/2 $ and thus they all have at least $ Z(n) $ crossings. The techniques developed provide a unified proof of the Harary-Hill conjecture for these classes of drawings.

A "book" with k pages consists of a straight line (the "spine") and k half-planes (the "pages"), such that the boundary of each page is the spine. If a graph is drawn on a book with k pages in such a way that the vertices lie on the spine, and each edge is contained in a page, the result is a k-page book drawing (or simply a k-page drawing). The pagenumber of a graph G is the minimum k such that G admits a k-page embedding (that is, a k-page drawing with no edge crossings). The k-page crossing number nu_k(G) of G is the minimum number of crossings in a k-page drawing of G. We investigate the pagenumbers and k-page crossing numbers of complete bipartite graphs. We find the exact pagenumbers of several complete bipartite graphs, and use these pagenumbers to find the exact k-page crossing number of K_{k+1,n} for 3<=k<=6. We also prove the general asymptotic estimate lim_{k->oo} lim_{n->oo} nu_k(K_{k+1,n})/(2n^2/k^2)=1. Finally, we give general upper bounds for nu_k(K_{m,n}), and relate these bounds to the k-planar crossing numbers of K_{m,n} and K_n.

Zarankiewicz's Conjecture (ZC) states that the crossing number cr$(K_{m,n})$ equals $Z(m,n):=\floor{\frac{m}{2}} \floor{\frac{m-1}{2}} \floor{\frac{n}{2}} \floor{\frac{n-1}{2}}$. Since Kleitman's verification of ZC for $K_{5,n}$ (from which ZC for $K_{6,n}$ easily follows), very little progress has been made around ZC; the most notable exceptions involve computer-aided results. With the aim of gaining a more profound understanding of this notoriously difficult conjecture, we investigate the optimal (that is, crossing-minimal) drawings of $K_{5,n}$. The widely known natural drawings of $K_{m,n}$ (the so-called Zarankiewicz drawings) with $Z(m,n)$ crossings contain antipodal vertices, that is, pairs of degree-$m$ vertices such that their induced drawing of $K_{m,2}$ has no crossings. Antipodal vertices also play a major role in Kleitman's inductive proof that cr$(K_{5,n}) = Z(5,n)$. We explore in depth the role of antipodal vertices in optimal drawings of $K_{5,n}$, for $n$ even. We prove that if {$n \equiv 2$ (mod 4)}, then every optimal drawing of $K_{5,n}$ has antipodal vertices. We also exhibit a two-parameter family of optimal drawings $D_{r,s}$ of $K_{5,4(r+s)}$ (for $r,s\ge 0$), with no antipodal vertices, and show that if $n\equiv 0$ (mod 4), then every optimal drawing of $K_{5,n}$ without antipodal vertices is (vertex rotation) isomorphic to $D_{r,s}$ for some integers $r,s$. As a corollary, we show that if $n$ is even, then every optimal drawing of $K_{5,n}$ is the superimposition of Zarankiewicz drawings with a drawing isomorphic to $D_{r,s}$ for some nonnegative integers $r,s$.

A "book with k pages" consists of a straight line (the "spine") and k half-planes (the "pages"), such that the boundary of each page is the spine. If a graph is drawn on a book with k pages in such a way that the vertices lie on the spine, and each edge is contained in a page, the result is a k-page book drawing (or simply a k-page drawing). The k-page crossing number nu_k(G) of a graph G is the minimum number of crossings in a k-page drawing of G. In this paper we investigate the k-page crossing numbers of complete graphs K_n. We use semidefinite programming techniques to give improved lower bounds on nu_k(K_n) for various values of k. We also use a maximum satisfiability reformulation to calculate the exact value of nu_k(K_n) for several values of k and n. Finally, we investigate the best construction known for drawing K_n in k pages, calculate the resulting number of crossings, and discuss this upper bound in the light of the new results reported in this paper.

Let $f(n,k)$ be the minimum number of edges that must be removed from some complete geometric graph $G$ on $n$ points, so that there exists a tree on $k$ vertices that is no longer a planar subgraph of $G$. In this paper we show that $(1/2)\frac{n^2}{k-1}-\frac{n}{2}\le f(n,k) \le 2 \frac{n(n-2)}{k-2}$. For the case when $k=n$, we show that $2 \le f(n,n) \le 3$. For the case when $k=n$ and $G$ is a geometric graph on a set of points in convex position, we show that at least three edges must be removed.

Around 1958, Hill described how to draw the complete graph $K_n$ with [Z(n) :=1/4\lfloor \frac{n}{2}\rfloor \lfloor \frac{n-1}{2}\rfloor \lfloor \frac{n-2}{2}% \rfloor \lfloor \frac{n-3}{2}\rfloor] crossings, and conjectured that the crossing number $\crg (K_{n})$ of $K_n$ is exactly Z(n). This is also known as Guy's conjecture as he later popularized it. Towards the end of the century, substantially different drawings of $K_{n}$ with Z(n) crossings were found. These drawings are \emph{2-page book drawings}, that is, drawings where all the vertices are on a line $\ell$ (the spine) and each edge is fully contained in one of the two half-planes (pages) defined by $\ell$. The \emph{2-page crossing number} of $K_{n} $, denoted by $ν_{2}(K_{n})$, is the minimum number of crossings determined by a 2-page book drawing of $K_{n}% $. Since $\crg(K_{n}) \leν_{2}(K_{n})$ and $ν_{2}(K_{n}) \le Z(n)$, a natural step towards Hill's Conjecture is the %(formally) weaker conjecture $ν_{2}(K_{n}) = Z(n)$, popularized by Vrt'o. %As far as we know, this natural %conjecture was first raised by Imrich Vrt'o in 2007. %Prior to this paper, results known for $ν_2(K_n)$ were basically %the same as for $\crg (K_n)$. Here In this paper we develop a novel and innovative technique to investigate crossings in drawings of $K_{n}$, and use it to prove that $ν_{2}(K_{n}) = Z(n) $. To this end, we extend the inherent geometric definition of $k$-edges for finite sets of points in the plane to topological drawings of $K_{n}$. We also introduce the concept of ${\leq}{\leq}k$-edges as a useful generalization of ${\leq}k$-edges and extend a powerful theorem that expresses the number of crossings in a rectilinear drawing of $K_{n}$ in terms of its number of $(\le k)$-edges to the topological setting.

Richter and Thomassen proved that every graph has an edge $e$ such that the crossing number $\ucr(G-e)$ of $G-e$ is at least $(2/5)\ucr(G) - O(1)$. Fox and Cs. Tóth proved that dense graphs have large sets of edges (proportional in the total number of edges) whose removal leaves a graph with crossing number proportional to the crossing number of the original graph; this result was later strenghtened by Černý, Kynčl and G. Tóth. These results make our understanding of the {decay} of crossing numbers in dense graphs essentially complete. In this paper we prove a similar result for large sparse graphs in which the number of edges is not artificially inflated by operations such as edge subdivisions. We also discuss the connection between the decay of crossing numbers and expected crossing numbers, a concept recently introduced by Mohar and Tamon.

A graph is crossing-critical if the removal of any of its edges decreases its crossing number. This work is motivated by the following question: to what extent is crossing- criticality a property that is inherent to the structure of a graph, and to what extent can it be induced on a noncritical graph by multiplying (all or some of) its edges? It is shown that if a nonplanar graph G is obtained by adding an edge to a cubic polyhedral graph, and G is sufficiently connected, then G can be made crossing-critical by a suitable multiplication of edges.

Devadoss asked: (1) can every polygon be convexified so that no internal visibility (between vertices) is lost in the process? Moreover, (2) does such a convexification exist, in which exactly one vertex is moved at a time (that is, using {\em single-vertex moves})? We prove the redundancy of the "single-vertex moves" condition: an affirmative answer to (1) implies an affirmative answer to (2). Since Aichholzer et al. recently proved (1), this settles (2).

Let $P$ be a set of points in general position in the plane. Join all pairs of points in $P$ with straight line segments. The number of segment-crossings in such a drawing, denoted by $\crg(P)$, is the \emph{rectilinear crossing number} of $P$. A \emph{halving line} of $P$ is a line passing though two points of $P$ that divides the rest of the points of $P$ in (almost) half. The number of halving lines of $P$ is denoted by $h(P)$. Similarly, a $k$\emph{-edge}, $0\leq k\leq n/2-1$, is a line passing through two points of $P$ and leaving exactly $k$ points of $P$ on one side. The number of $(\le k)$-edges of $P$ is denoted by $E_{\leq k}(P) $. Let $\rcr(n)$, $h(n)$, and $E_{\leq k}(n) $ denote the minimum of $\crg(P)$, the maximum of $h(P)$, and the minimum of $E_{\leq k}(P) $, respectively, over all sets $P$ of $n$ points in general position in the plane. We show that the previously best known lower bound on $E_{\leq k}(n)$ is tight for $k<\lceil (4n-2) /9\rceil $ and improve it for all $k\geq \lceil (4n-2) /9 \rceil $. This in turn improves the lower bound on $\rcr(n)$ from $0.37968\binom{n} {4}+Θ(n^{3})$ to {277/729}\binom{n}{4}+Θ(n^{3})\geq 0.37997\binom{n}{4}+Θ(n^{3})$. We also give the exact values of $\rcr(n)$ and $h(n) $ for all $n\leq27$. Exact values were known only for $n\leq18$ and odd $n\leq21$ for the crossing number, and for $n\leq14$ and odd $n\leq21$ for halving lines.

We show that every sufficiently large plane triangulation has a large collection of nested cycles that either are pairwise disjoint, or pairwise intersect in exactly one vertex, or pairwise intersect in exactly two vertices. We apply this result to show that for each fixed positive integer $k$, there are only finitely many $k$-crossing-critical simple graphs of average degree at least six. Combined with the recent constructions of crossing-critical graphs given by Bokal, this settles the question of for which numbers $q>0$ there is an infinite family of $k$-crossing-critical simple graphs of average degree $q$.

Let $B$ and $R$ be point sets (of {\em blue} and {\em red} points, respectively) in the plane, such that $P:=B\cup R$ is in general position, and $|P|$ is even. A line $\ell$ is {\em balanced} if it spans one blue and one red point, and on each open halfplane of $\ell$, the number of blue points minus the number of red points is the same. We prove that $P$ has at least $\min \{|B|,|R|\} $ balanced lines. This refines a result by Pach and Pinchasi, who proved this for the case $|B|=|R|$.

Let $S$ be a set of $r$ red points and $b=r+2d$ blue points in general position in the plane, with $d\geq 0$. A line $\ell$ determined by them is said to be balanced if in each open half-plane bounded by $\ell$ the difference between the number of red points and blue points is $d$. We show that every set $S$ as above has at least $r$ balanced lines. The main techniques in the proof are rotations and a generalization, sliding rotations, introduced here.

The point sets of all known optimal rectilinear drawings of $K_n$ share an unmistakeable clustering property, the so--called {\em 3--decomposability}. It is widely believed that the underlying point sets of all optimal rectilinear drawings of $K_n$ are 3--decomposable. We give a lower bound for the minimum number of $(\le k)$--sets in a 3--decomposable $n$--point set. As an immediate corollary, we obtain a lower bound for the crossing number $\rcr(\dd)$ of any rectilinear drawing $\dd$ of $K_n$ with underlying 3--decomposable point set, namely $\rcr(\dd) > {2/27}(15-π^{2})\binom{n}{4}+Θ(n^{3}) \approx 0.380029\binom{n}{4} + Θ(n^3)$. This closes this gap between the best known lower and upper bounds for the rectilinear crossing number $\rcr(K_n)$ of $K_n$ by over 40%, under the assumption of 3--decomposability.

It has been long congectured that the crossing number of $C_m\times C_n$ is $(m-2)n$ for $2<m<=n$. In this paper we proved that conjecture is true for all but finitely many $n$ for each $m$. More specifically we proved conjecture for $n>=(m/2)((m+3)^2/2+1)$.The proof is largely based on the theory of arrangements introduced by Adamsson and further developed by Adamsson and Richter.