arXiv++ Combinatorics

Banach's matchbox problem considers the setting of two matchboxes that each initially contain the same number of matches. Boxes are chosen with equal probability and a match removed each time. The problem concerns the law of the number of matches remaining in one box once the other box empties. Knuth considered a generalization of this problem whereby `big-choosers' arrive with probability $p$ and remove a match from the box with the most number remaining, and `little-choosers' arrive with probability $1-p$ and remove a match from the box with the least number remaining. In this paper we consider Knuth's generalization for the case of $k$ matchboxes. We determine the generating function for the expected number of matches remaining in $k-1$ matchboxes once a box first empties, a quantity we refer to as the `residue'. Interestingly, this generating function is a quotient whose denominator contains a generating function for a special case of the Raney numbers. The form for this generating function allows us to give an expression for the expected residue in terms of a sum that involves diagonal state return probabilities, where a diagonal state is a configuration in which all matchboxes each contain the same number of matches. We use analytic techniques to determine the asymptotic behaviour of this expected value for all values of $p$, which involves the study of an asymmetric random walk. We also consider the expected value of the order of the first return to a diagonal state and determine its asymptotic behaviour. The coefficients of the diagonal state probability generating function are shown to be related to `manila folder configurations in a filing cabinet', and we make this connection precise. This allows us to use known results for the enumeration of such manila folder configurations to give a closed form expression for the diagonal state return probabilities.

The lacking polynomial is a graph polynomial introduced by Chan, Marckert, and Selig in 2013 that is closely related to the Tutte polynomial of a graph. It arose by way of a generalization of the Abelian sandpile model and is essentially the generating function of the level statistic on the set of recurrent configurations, called stochastically recurrent states, for that model. In this note we consider the lacking polynomial of the complete bipartite graph. We classify the stochastically recurrent states of the stochastic sandpile model on the complete bipartite graphs $K_{2,n}$ and $K_{m,2}$ where the sink is always an element of the set counted by the first index. We use these characterizations to give explicit formulae for the lacking polynomials of these graphs. Log-concavity of the sequence of coefficients of these two lacking polynomials is proven, and we conjecture log-concavity holds for this general class of graphs.

This paper studies sorted recurrent configurations of the Abelian sandpile model on the complete split graph. We introduce two natural toppling processes, CTI and ITC toppling, on the recurrent configurations and use these to define two toppling delay statistics, wtopple$_{CTI}$ and wtopple$_{ITC}$. These new toppling delay statistics are time-weighted sums for the number of vertices that topple during each iteration of the toppling processes. We then introduce the bivariate $q,t$-CTI and $q,t$-ITC polynomials that are the generating functions of the bistatistics (level,wtopple$_{ITC}$) and (level,wtopple$_{CTI}$), where level is the well-established sandpile level statistic. We prove the bistatistic (level,wtopple$_{ITC}$) maps to a bistatistic (area,bounce) on Schröder paths that was introduced by Egge, Haglund, Killpatrick and Kremer (2003). This establishes equality of the $q,t$-ITC polynomial and the $q,t$-Schröder polynomial of those same authors. This connection allows us to relate the $q,t$-ITC polynomial to the theory of symmetric functions and also establishes symmetry of the $q,t$-ITC polynomials. We conjecture equality of the $q,t$-CTI and $q,t$-ITC polynomials. We also present and prove a characterization of sorted recurrent configurations as a new class of polyominoes that we call sawtooth polyominoes. The CTI and ITC toppling processes on sorted recurrent configurations are proven to correspond to bounce paths within the polyominoes. The main difference between the two bounce paths is the initial direction in which they travel. In addition to this, and building on the results of Aval, D'Adderio, Dukes, and Le Borgne (2016), we present a cycle lemma for a slight extension of stable configurations that allows for an enumeration of sorted recurrent configurations within the framework of the sandpile model.

We provide an explicit description of the recurrent configurations of the sandpile model on a family of graphs $\widehat{G}_{μ,ν}$, which we call clique-independent graphs, indexed by two compositions $μ$ and $ν$. Moreover, we define a delay statistic on these configurations, and we show that, together with the usual level statistic, it can be used to provide a new combinatorial interpretation of the celebrated shuffle theorem of Carlsson and Mellit. More precisely, we will see how to interpret the polynomials $\langle \nabla e_n, e_μh_ν\rangle$ in terms of these configurations.

Let alpha = a_1 a_2 ... a_n be a sequence of nonnegative integers. The ascent set of alpha, Asc(alpha), consists of all indices k where a_{k+1} > a_k. An ascent sequence is alpha where the growth of the a_k is bounded by the elements of Asc(alpha). These sequences were introduced by Bousquet-Mélou, Claesson, Dukes and Kitaev and have many wonderful properties. In particular, they are in bijection with unlabeled (2+2)-free posets, permutations avoiding a particular bivincular pattern, certain upper-triangular nonnegative integer matrices, and a class of matchings. A weak ascent of alpha is an index k with a_{k+1} >= a_k and weak ascent sequences are defined analogously to ascent sequences. These were studied by Bényi, Claesson and Dukes and shown to have analogous equinumerous sets. Given a nonnegative integer d, we define a difference d ascent to be an index k such that a_{k+1} > a_k - d. We study the properties of the corresponding d-ascent sequences, showing that some of the maps from the weak case can be extended to bijections for general d while the extensions of others continue to be injective (but not surjective). We also make connections with other combinatorial objects such as rooted duplication trees and restricted growth functions.

In this paper we investigate a permutation statistic that was independently introduced by Romik in 2005. This statistic counts the number of bumps that occur during the execution of the Robinson-Schensted procedure when applied to a given permutation. We provide several interpretations of this bump statistic that include the tableaux shape and also as an extremal problem concerning permutations and increasing subsequences. Several aspects of this bump statistic are investigated from both structural and enumerative viewpoints.

In this paper we consider a general system of activities that can, but do not have to, occur. This system is governed by a set containing two types of constraints: precedence and response. A precedence constraint dictates that an activity can only occur if it has been preceded by some other specified activity. Response constraints are similarly defined. An execution of the system is a listing of activities in the order they occur and which satisfies all constraints. These listings are known as traces. Such systems naturally arise in areas of theoretical computer science and decision science. An outcome of the freedom with which activities can occur is that there are many different possible executions, and gaining a combinatorial insight into these is a non-trivial problem. We characterize all of the ways in which such a system can be executed. Our approach uses order theory to provide a classification in terms of the linear extensions of posets constructed from the constraint sets. This characterization is essential in calculating the stakeholder utility metrics that have been developed by the first author that allow for quantitative comparisons of such systems/processes. It also allows for a better understanding of the theoretical backbone to these processes.

In this paper we define a variant of the Ising model in which spins are replaced with permutations. The energy between two spins is a function of the relative disorder of one spin, a permutation, to the other. This model is motivated by a complexity measure for declarative systems. For such systems a state is a permutation and the permutation sorting complexity measures the average sequential disorder of neighbouring states. To measure the relative disorder between two spins we use a symmetrized version of the descent permutation statistic that has appeared in the works of Chatterjee \& Diaconis and Petersen. The classical Ising model corresponds to the length-2 permutation case of this new model. We consider and prove some elementary properties for the 1D case of this model in which spins are length-3 permutations.

The score sequence of a tournament is the sequence of the out-degrees of its vertices arranged in nondecreasing order. The problem of counting score sequences of a tournament with $n$ vertices is more than 100 years old (MacMahon 1920). In 2013 Hanna conjectured a surprising and elegant recursion for these numbers. We settle this conjecture in the affirmative by showing that it is a corollary to our main theorem, which is a factorization of the generating function for score sequences with a distinguished index. We also derive a closed formula and a quadratic time algorithm for counting score sequences.

In this paper we examine a procedure that, on starting with an integer $n$, results in a pair of equal integers that are no greater than $n$. We call the resulting value the \textit{strange root} of $n$ and we show how this strange-root-finding procedure is intimately linked to the game of Tchoukaillon solitaire. We analyze the strange-root-finding procedure in reverse to determine when a prescribed value is the strange root of at most two integers. We present a conjecture about strange roots and translate this conjecture into one involving Tchoukaillon solitaire.

In this paper we introduce {\em weak ascent sequences}, a class of number sequences that properly contains ascent sequences. We show how these sequences uniquely encode each of the following objects: permutations avoiding a particular length-4 bivincular pattern; upper-triangular binary matrices that satisfy a column-adjacency rule; factorial posets that are weakly (3+1)-free. We also show how weak ascent sequences are related to a class of pattern avoiding inversion sequences that has been a topic of recent research by Auli and Elizalde. Finally, we consider the problem of enumerating these new sequences and give a closed form expression for the number of weak ascent sequences having a prescribed length and number of weak ascents.

This paper establishes connections between EW-tableaux and parallelogram polyominoes by using recent research regarding the sandpile model on the complete bipartite graph. This paper presents and proves a direct bijection between rectangular EW-tableaux and labelled ribbon parallelogram polyominoes. The significance of this is that allows one to move between these objects without the need for `recurrent configurations', the central object which previously tied this work together. It introduces the notion of a marked rectangular EW-tableaux that exactly encode all recurrent configurations of the sandpile model on the complete bipartite graph. This shows how non-cornersupport entries that featured in previous work can be utilized in a simple but important way in relation to EW-tableaux. It lifts the bijection between rectangular EW-tableaux and labelled ribbon parallelogram polyominoes to a bijection between marked rectangular EW-tableaux and labelled parallelogram polyominoes. This bijection helps us to fully understand the aspects of these very different objects that are, in a sense, different sides of the same coin.

We classify recurrent states of the Abelian sandpile model (ASM) on the complete split graph. There are two distinct cases to be considered that depend upon the location of the sink vertex in the complete split graph. This characterisation of decreasing recurrent states is in terms of Motzkin words and can also be characterised in terms of combinatorial necklaces. We also give a characterisation of the recurrent states in terms of a new type of parking function that we call a tiered parking function. These parking functions are characterised by assigning a tier (or colour) to each of the cars, and specifying how many cars of a lower-tier one wishes to have parked before them. We also enumerate the different sets of recurrent configurations studied in this paper, and in doing so derive a formula for the number of spanning trees of the complete split graph that uses a bijective Prüfer code argument.

A permutation graph is a graph whose edges are given by inversions of a permutation. We study the Abelian sandpile model (ASM) on such graphs. We exhibit a bijection between recurrent configurations of the ASM on permutation graphs and the tiered trees introduced by Dugan et al. [10]. This bijection allows certain parameters of the recurrent configurations to be read on the corresponding tree. In particular, we show that the level of a recurrent configuration can be interpreted as the external activity of the corresponding tree, so that the bijection exhibited provides a new proof of a famous result linking the level polynomial of the ASM to the ubiquitous Tutte polynomial. We show that the set of minimal recurrent configurations is in bijection with the set of complete non-ambiguous binary trees introduced by Aval et al. [2], and introduce a multi-rooted generalization of these that we show to correspond to all recurrent configurations. In the case of permutations with a single descent, we recover some results from the case of Ferrers graphs presented in [11], while we also recover results of Perkinson et al. [16] in the case of threshold graphs.

We classify all recurrent configurations of the Abelian sandpile model (ASM) on Ferrers graphs. The classification is in terms of decorations of EW-tableaux, which undecorated are in bijection with the minimal recurrent configurations. We introduce decorated permutations, extending to decorated EW-tableaux a bijection between such tableaux and permutations, giving a direct bijection between the decorated permutations and all recurrent configurations of the ASM. We also describe a bijection between the decorated permutations and the intransitive trees of Postnikov, the breadth-first search of which corresponds to a canonical toppling of the corresponding configurations.

The combined work of Bousquet-Mélou, Claesson, Dukes, Jelínek, Kitaev, Kubitzke and Parviainen has resulted in non-trivial bijections among ascent sequences, (2+2)-free posets, upper-triangular integer matrices, and pattern-avoiding permutations. To probe the finer behavior of these bijections, we study two types of restrictions on ascent sequences. These restrictions are motivated by our results that their images under the bijections are natural and combinatorially significant. In addition, for one restriction, we are able to determine the effect of poset duality on the corresponding ascent sequences, matrices and permutations, thereby answering a question of the first author and Parviainen in this case. The second restriction should appeal to Catalaniacs.

In this paper we present new results for the combinatorics of web diagrams and web worlds. These are discrete objects that arise in the physics of calculating scattering amplitudes in non-abelian gauge theories. Web-colouring and web-mixing matrices (collectively known as web matrices) are indexed by ordered pairs of web-diagrams and contain information relating the number of colourings of the first web diagram that will produce the second diagram. We introduce the black diamond product on power series and show how it determines the web-colouring matrix of disjoint web worlds. Furthermore, we show that combining known physical results with the black diamond product gives a new technique for generating combinatorial identities. Due to the complicated action of the product on power series, the resulting identities appear highly non-trivial. We present two results to explain repeated entries that appear in the web matrices. The first of these shows how diagonal web matrix entries will be the same if the comparability graphs of their associated decomposition posets are the same. The second result concerns general repeated entries in conjunction with a flipping operation on web diagrams. We present a combinatorial proof of idempotency of the web-mixing matrices, previously established using physical arguments only. We also show how the entries of the square of the web-colouring matrix can be achieved by a linear transformation that maps the standard basis for formal power series in one variable to a sequence of polynomials. We look at one parameterized web world that is related to indecomposable permutations and show how determining the web-colouring matrix entries in this case is equivalent to a combinatorics on words problem.

In this paper we examine the sorting operator $T(LnR)=T(R)T(L)n$. Applying this operator to a permutation is equivalent to passing the permutation reversed through a stack. We prove theorems that characterise $t$-revstack sortability in terms of patterns in a permutation that we call $zigzag$ patterns. Using these theorems we characterise those permutations of length $n$ which are sorted by $t$ applications of $T$ for $t=0,1,2,n-3,n-2,n-1$. We derive expressions for the descent polynomials of these six classes of permutations and use this information to prove Steingrímsson's sorting conjecture for those six values of $t$. Symmetry and unimodality of the descent polynomials for general $t$-revstack sortable permutations is also proven and three conjectures are given.

We introduce two operators on stable configurations of the sandpile model that provide an algorithmic bijection between recurrent and parking configurations. This bijection preserves their equivalence classes with respect to the sandpile group. The study of these operators in the special case of the complete bipartite graph ${K}_{m,n}$ naturally leads to a generalization of the well known Cyclic Lemma of Dvoretsky and Motzkin, via pairs of periodic bi-infinite paths in the plane having slightly different slopes. We achieve our results by interpreting the action of these operators as an action on a point in the grid $\mathbb{Z}^2$ which is pointed to by one of these pairs of paths. Our Cyclic lemma allows us to enumerate several classes of polyominoes, and therefore builds on the work of Irving and Rattan (2009), Chapman et al. (2009), and Bonin et al. (2003).

We introduce a new combinatorial object called a web world that consists of a set of web diagrams. The diagrams of a web world are generalizations of graphs, and each is built on the same underlying graph. Instead of ordinary vertices the diagrams have pegs, and edges incident to a peg have different heights on the peg. The web world of a web diagram is the set of all web diagrams that result from permuting the order in which endpoints of edges appear on a peg. The motivation comes from particle physics, where web diagrams arise as particular types of Feynman diagrams describing scattering amplitudes in non-Abelian gauge (Yang-Mills) theories. To each web world we associate two matrices called the web-colouring matrix and web-mixing matrix. The entries of these matrices are indexed by ordered pairs of web diagrams (D_1,D_2), and are computed from those colourings of the edges of D_1 that yield D_2 under a transformation determined by each colouring. We show that colourings of a web diagram (whose constituent indecomposable diagrams are all unique) that lead to a reconstruction of the diagram are equivalent to order-preserving mappings of certain partially ordered sets (posets) that may be constructed from the web diagrams. For web worlds whose web graphs have all edge labels equal to 1, the diagonal entries of web-mixing and web-colouring matrices are obtained by summing certain polynomials determined by the descents in permutations in the Jordan-Holder set of all linear extensions of the associated poset. We derive tri-variate generating generating functions for the number of web worlds according to three statistics and enumerate the number of different web diagrams in a web world. Three special web worlds are examined in great detail, and the traces of the web-mixing matrices calculated in each case.