arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $T$ be a tree on $n$ vertices. We can regard the edges of $T$ as transpositions of the vertex set; their product (in any order) is a cyclic permutation. All possible cyclic permutations arise (each exactly once) if and only if the tree is a star. In this paper we find the number of realised cycles, and obtain some results on the number of realisations of each cycle, for other trees. We also solve the inverse problem of the number of trees which give rise to a given cycle. On the way, we meet some familiar number sequences including the Euler and Fuss--Catalan numbers.

The undirected power graph (or simply power graph) of a group $G$, denoted by $P(G)$, is a graph whose vertices are the elements of the group $G$, in which two vertices $u$ and $v$ are connected by an edge between if and only if either $u=v^i$ or $v=u^j$ for some $i$, $j$. A number of important graph classes, including perfect graphs, cographs, chordal graphs, split graphs, and threshold graphs, can be defined either structurally or in terms of forbidden induced subgraphs. We examine each of these five classes and attempt to determine for which groups $G$ the power graph $P(G)$ lies in the class under consideration. We give complete results in the case of nilpotent groups, and partial results in greater generality. In particular, the power graph is always perfect; and we determine completely the groups whose power graph is a threshold or split graph (the answer is the same for both classes). We give a number of open problems.

Diagonal groups are one of the classes of finite primitive permutation groups occurring in the conclusion of the O'Nan-Scott theorem. Several of the other classes have been described as the automorphism groups of geometric or combinatorial structures such as affine spaces or Cartesian decompositions, but such structures for diagonal groups have not been studied. The main purpose of this paper is to describe and characterise such structures, which we call diagonal semilattices. Unlike the diagonal groups in the O'Nan-Scott theorem, which are defined over finite characteristically simple groups, our construction works over any group, finite or infinite. A diagonal semilattice depends on a dimension m and a group T. For m=2, it is a Latin square, the Cayley table of T, though in fact any Latin square satisfies our axioms. However, for m>=3, the group T emerges naturally and uniquely from the axioms. (The situation somewhat resembles projective geometry, where projective planes exist in profusion but higher-dimensional structures are coordinatised by an algebraic object, a division ring.) A diagonal semilattice is contained in the partition lattice on a set, and we provide an introduction to the calculus of partitions. Many of the concepts and constructions come from experimental design in statistics. We also determine when a diagonal group can be primitive, or quasiprimitive (these conditions are equivalent for diagonal groups). Associated with the diagonal semilattice is a graph, the diagonal graph, which has the same automorphism group except in four small cases with m<=3. The class of diagonal graphs includes some well-known families, Latin-square graphs and folded cubes. We obtain partial results on the chromatic number of a diagonal graph, and mention an application to synchronization.

Square lattice designs are often used in trials of new varieties of various agricultural crops. However, there are no square lattice designs for 36 varieties in blocks of size six for four or more replicates. Here we use three different approaches to construct designs for up to eight replicates. All the designs perform well in terms of giving a low average variance of variety contrasts. Supplementary materials are available online.

For any finite group $G$, and any positive integer $n$, we construct an association scheme which admits the diagonal group $D_n(G)$ as a group of automorphisms. The rank of the association scheme is the number of partitions of $n$ into at most $|G|$ parts, so is $p(n)$ if $|G|\ge n$; its parameters depend only on $n$ and $|G|$. For $n=2$, the association scheme is trivial, while for $n=3$ its relations are the Latin square graph associated with the Cayley table of $G$ and its complement. A transitive permutation group $G$ is said to be \emph{AS-free} if there is no non-trivial association scheme admitting $G$ as a group of automorphisms. A consequence of our construction is that an AS-free group must be either $2$-homogeneous or almost simple. We construct another association scheme, finer than the above scheme if $n>3$, from the Latin hypercube consisting of $n$-tuples of elements of $G$ with product the identity.

The Hall--Paige conjecture asserts that a finite group has a complete mapping if and only if its Sylow subgroups are not cyclic. The conjecture is now proved, and one aim of this paper is to document the final step in the proof (for the sporadic simple group $\mathrm{J}_4$). We apply this result to prove that primitive permutation groups of simple diagonal type with three or more simple factors in the socle are non-synchronizing. We also give the simpler proof that, for groups of affine type, or simple diagonal type with two socle factors, synchronization and separation are equivalent. Synchronization and separation are conditions on permutation groups which are stronger than primitivity but weaker than $2$-homogeneity, the second of these being stronger than the first. Empirically it has been found that groups which are synchronizing but not separating are rather rare. It follows from our results that such groups must be primitive of almost simple type.

We consider designs for cancer trials which allow each medical centre to treat only a limited number of cancer types with only a limited number of drugs. We specify desirable properties of these designs, and prove some consequences. Then we give several different constructions. Finally we generalise this to three or more types of object, such as biomarkers.

We study equitable partitions of Latin-square graphs, and give a complete classification of those whose quotient matrix does not have an eigenvalue $-3$.

It is known that, if we take a countable model of Zermelo--Fraenkel set theory ZFC and "undirect" the membership relation (that is, make a graph by joining $x$ to $y$ if either $x\in y$ or $y\in x$), we obtain the Erdős--Rényi random graph. The crucial axiom in the proof of this is the Axiom of Foundation, so it is natural to wonder what happens if we delete this axiom, or replace it by an alternative (such as Aczel's Anti-Foundation Axiom). The resulting graph may fail to be simple, it may have loops (if $x\in x$ for some $x$) or multiple edges (if $x\in y$ and $y\in x$ for some $x,y$). We show that, in ZFA, if we keep the loops and ignore the multiple edges, we obtain the "random loopy graph" (which is $\aleph_0$-categorical and homogeneous), but if we keep multiple edges, the resulting graph is not $\aleph_0$-categorical, but has infinitely many $1$-types. Moreover, if we keep only loops and double edges and discard single edges, the resulting graph contains countably many connected components isomorphic to any given finite connected graph with loops.

Let $R_m$ be the (unique) universal homogeneous $m$-edge-coloured countable complete graph ($m\ge2$), and $G_m$ its group of colour-preserving automorphisms. The group $G_m$ was shown to be simple by John Truss. We examine the automorphism group of $G_m$, and show that it is the group of permutations of $R_m$ which induce permutations on the colours, and hence an extension of $G_m$ by the symmetric group of degree $m$. We show further that the extension splits if and only if $m$ is odd, and in the case where $m$ is even and not divisible by~$8$ we find the smallest supplement for $G_m$ in its automorphism group. (This unpublished paper from 2007 is placed here because of renewed interest in the topic.)

A triple array is a rectangular array containing letters, each letter occurring equally often with no repeats in rows or columns, such that the number of letters common to two rows, two columns, or a row and a column are (possibly different) non-zero constants. Deleting the condition on the letters common to a row and a column gives a double array. We propose the term \emph{sesqui-array} for such an array when only the condition on pairs of columns is deleted. Thus all triple arrays are sesqui-arrays. In this paper we give three constructions for sesqui-arrays. The first gives $(n+1)\times n^2$ arrays on $n(n+1)$ letters for $n\geq 2$. (Such an array for $n=2$ was found by Bagchi.) This construction uses Latin squares. The second uses the \emph{Sylvester graph}, a subgraph of the Hoffman--Singleton graph, to build a good block design for $36$ treatments in $42$ blocks of size~$6$, and then uses this in a $7\times 36$ sesqui-array for $42$ letters. We also give a construction for $K\times(K-1)(K-2)/2$ sesqui-arrays on $K(K-1)/2$ letters. This construction uses biplanes. It starts with a block of a biplane and produces an array which satisfies the requirements for a sesqui-array except possibly that of having no repeated letters in a row or column. We show that this condition holds if and only if the \emph{Hussain chains} for the selected block contain no $4$-cycles. A sufficient condition for the construction to give a triple array is that each Hussain chain is a union of $3$-cycles; but this condition is not necessary, and we give a few further examples. We also discuss the question of which of these arrays provide good designs for experiments.

The \emph{power graph} $P(G)$ of a group $G$ is the graph whose vertex set is $G$, with $x$ and $y$ joined if one is a power of the other; the \emph{directed power graph} $\vec{P}(G)$ has the same vertex set, with an arc from $x$ to $y$ if $y$ is a power of $x$. It is known that, for finite groups, the power graph determines the directed power graph up to isomorphism. However, it is not true that any isomorphism between power graphs induces an isomorphism between directed power graphs. Moreover, for infinite groups the power graph may fail to determine the directed power graph. In this paper, we consider power graphs of torsion-free groups. Our main results are that, for torsion-free nilpotent groups of class at most $2$, and for groups in which every non-identity element lies in a unique maximal cyclic subgroup, the power graph determines the directed power graph up to isomorphism. For specific groups such as $\mathbb{Z}$ and $\mathbb{Q}$, we obtain more precise results. Any isomorphism $P(\mathbb{Z})\to P(G)$ preserves orientation, so induces an isomorphism between directed power graphs; in the case of $\mathbb{Q}$, the orientations are either all preserved or all reversed. We also obtain results about groups in which every element is contained in a unique maximal cyclic subgroup (this class includes the free and free abelian groups), and about subgroups of the additive group of $\mathbb{Q}$ and about $\mathbb{Q}^n$.

The cycle polynomial of a finite permutation group $G$ is the generating function for the number of elements of $G$ with a given number of cycles: \[F_G(x) = \sum_{g\in G}x^{c(g)},\] where $c(g)$ is the number of cycles of $g$ on $Ω$. In the first part of the paper, we develop basic properties of this polynomial, and give a number of examples. In the 1970s, Richard Stanley introduced the notion of reciprocity for pairs of combinatorial polynomials. We show that, in a considerable number of cases, there is a polynomial in the reciprocal relation to the cycle polynomial of $G$; this is the orbital chromatic polynomial of $Γ$ and $G$, where $Γ$ is a $G$-invariant graph, introduced by the first author, Jackson and Rudd. We pose the general problem of finding all such reciprocal pairs, and give a number of examples and characterisations: the latter include the cases where $Γ$ is a complete or null graph or a tree. The paper concludes with some comments on other polynomials associated with a permutation group.

A \emph{chromatic root} is a root of the chromatic polynomial of a graph. Any chromatic root is an algebraic integer. Much is known about the location of chromatic roots in the real and complex numbers, but rather less about their properties as algebraic numbers. This question was the subject of a seminar at the Isaac Newton Institute in late 2008. The purpose of this paper is to report on the seminar and subsequent developments. We conjecture that, for every algebraic integer $α$, there is a natural number $n$ such that $α+n$ is a chromatic root. This is proved for quadratic integers, an extension to cubic integers has been found by Adam Bohn. The idea is to consider certain special classes of graphs for which the chromatic polynomial is a product of linear factors and one "interesting" factor of larger degree. We also report computational results on the Galois groups of irreducible factors of the chromatic polynomial for some special graphs. Finally, extensions to the Tutte polynomial are mentioned briefly.

This paper addresses the question whether triple arrays can be constructed from Youden squares developed from difference sets. We prove that if the difference set is abelian, then having $-1$ as multiplier is both a necessary and sufficient condition for the construction to work. Using this, we are able to give a new infinite family of triple arrays. We also give an alternative and more direct version of the construction, leaving out the intermediate step via Youden squares. This is used when we analyse the case of non-abelian difference sets, for which we prove a sufficient condition for giving triple arrays. We do a computer search for such non-abelian difference sets, but have not found any examples satisfying the given condition.

We prove that the highest rank of a string C-group constructed from an alternating group $Alt_n$ is 0 if $n=3, 4, 6, 7, 8$; 3 if $n=5$; 4 if $n=9$; 5 if $n=10$; 6 if $n=11$; and $\lfloor\frac{n-1}{2}\rfloor$ if $n\geq 12$. This solves a conjecture made by the last three authors in 2012.

Let $G$ be a group. The \emph{power graph} of $G$ is a graph with the vertex set $G$, having an edge between two elements whenever one is a power of the other. We characterize nilpotent groups whose power graphs have finite independence number. For a bounded exponent group, we prove its power graph is a perfect graph and we determine its clique/chromatic number. Furthermore, it is proved that for every group $G$, the clique number of the power graph of $G$ is at most countably infinite. We also measure how close the power graph is to the \emph{commuting graph} by introducing a new graph which lies in between. We call this new graph as the \emph{enhanced power graph}. For an arbitrary pair of these three graphs we characterize finite groups for which this pair of graphs are equal.

An automaton is said to be synchronizing if there is a word in the transitions which sends all states of the automaton to a single state. Research on this topic has been driven by the Černý conjecture, one of the oldest and most famous problems in automata theory, according to which a synchronizing $n$-state automaton has a reset word of length at most $(n-1)^2$. The transitions of an automaton generate a transformation monoid on the set of states, and so an automaton can be regarded as a transformation monoid with a prescribed set of generators. In this setting, an automaton is synchronizing if the transitions generate a constant map. A permutation group $G$ on a set $Ω$ is said to synchronize a map $f$ if the monoid $\langle G,f\rangle$ generated by $G$ and $f$ is synchronizing in the above sense; we say $G$ is synchronizing if it synchronizes every non-permutation. The classes of synchronizing groups and friends form an hierarchy of natural and elegant classes of groups lying strictly between the classes of primitive and $2$-homogeneous groups. These classes have been floating around for some years and it is now time to provide a unified reference on them. The study of all these classes has been prompted by the Černý conjecture, but it is of independent interest since it involves a rich mix of group theory, combinatorics, graph endomorphisms, semigroup theory, finite geometry, and representation theory, and has interesting computational aspects as well. So as to make the paper self-contained, we have provided background material on these topics. Our purpose here is to present results that show the connections between the various areas of mathematics mentioned above, we include a new result on the Černý conjecture, some challenges to finite geometers, some thoughts about infinite analogues, and a long list of open problems.

A classic result of Delsarte connects the strength (as orthogonal array) of a linear code with the minimum weight of its dual: the former is one less than the latter. We show that Delsarte's observation extends to codes over arbitrary finite rings. Since the paper of Hammons \emph{et al.}, there is a lot of interest in codes over rings, especially in codes over $Z_4$ and their (usually non-linear) binary Gray map images. We show that Delsarte's observation extends to codes over arbitrary finite commutative rings with identity. Also, we show that the strength of the Gray map image of a $Z_4$ code is one less than the minimum Lee weight of its Gray map image.

This article, showing that almost all objects in the title are asymmetric, is re-typed from a manuscript I wrote somewhere around 1980 (after the papers of Bang and Friedland on the permanent conjecture but before those of Egorychev and Falikman). I am not sure of the exact date. The manuscript had been lost, but surfaced among my papers recently. I am grateful to Laci Babai and Ian Wanless who have encouraged me to make this document public, and to Ian for spotting a couple of typos. In the section on Latin squares, Ian objects to my use of the term "cell"; this might be more reasonably called a "triple" (since it specifies a row, column and symbol), but I have decided to keep the terminology I originally used. The result for Latin squares is in B. D. McKay and I. M. Wanless, On the number of Latin squares, Annals of Combinatorics 9 (2005), 335-344 (arXiv 0909.2101), while the result for Steiner triple systems is in L. Babai, Almost all Steiner triple systems are asymmetric, Annals of Discrete Mathematics 7 (1980), 37-39.