arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study tropical circuits with scalar multiplication gates, that is, algebraic circuits whose gates implement $\max$, $+$, or multiplication with a positive constant. For such circuits, we prove exponential size lower bounds for computing maximum weight directed spanning trees and maximum weight bipartite perfect matchings. As a corollary, we obtain an exponential size separation between monotone and non-monotone maxout neural networks, which generalize the popularly used ReLU neural networks. One conclusion from this is that neural network models with enforced convexity constraints, such as input-convex neural networks (ICNNs), sometimes need to be exponentially larger than their unrestricted counterparts in order to express the same functions.

A $4$-uniform $2$-cycle in a $4$-uniform hypergraph of length $t$ is a cyclic ordering of $2t$ vertices $v_1v_2\cdots v_{2t}v_1$ such that $v_{2i+1}v_{2i+2}v_{2i+3}v_{2i+4}$ are edges for $0\le i\le t-1$ while the addition is modulo $2t$. For every $γ>0$ and large $n$, we characterize the $n$-vertex $4$-uniform hypergraphs such that every triple of vertices is contained in at least $(1/3+γ)n$ edges and admits a Hamilton $2$-cycle. Up to the error term $γn$, the assumption on the minimum codegree is best possible and verifies a conjecture of Garbe and Mycroft. As a consequence, this gives a polynomial-time algorithm that decides whether an $n$-vertex $4$-uniform hypergraph with minimum codegree $(1/3+γ)n$ contains a Hamilton $2$-cycle. This stands as a steep contrast to the graph case where such a hardness gap has size $o(n)$.

We study the computational complexity of problems that ask if a given graph admits an edge-coloring that does not contain an edge-colored clique from some fixed finite family. We show that every such problem is poly-time equivalent to a Constraint Satisfaction Problem, yielding a P vs. NP-complete dichotomy. Our main contribution lies in the reduction from the CSP to the coloring problem where we apply methods from Ramsey theory and a novel notion of cut-homotopy.

Given a nonnegative matrix $X$, a factorization rank $r$ and a real parameter $p$, entrywise power matrix factorization (EPMF) looks for a low-rank matrix $X_r$ such that $X = |X_r|^{\circ p}$ (exact case) or $X \approx |X_r|^{\circ p}$ (approximate case), where $(\cdot)^{\circ p}$ denotes the component-wise exponent. EPMF includes the modulus model ($p=1$) and component-wise square factorization ($p=2$) as special cases, the latter being closely related to the square root rank. We analyze the computational complexity of the exact decision problem and the Frobenius-norm approximation problem, and establish a complete complexity landscape. In the exact case, we show that EPMF is equivalent to the combinatorial problem of flipping the signs of the entries of a given matrix $X$ to obtain a rank-$r$ matrix, which we refer to as the signing problem. We first show that the signing problem, and hence exact EPMF, is strongly NP-hard, improving a weak NP-hardness result for the square-root-rank of Fawzi et al. (Math. Prog., 2015). We then show that the signing problem can be solved in polynomial-time when $r$ is fixed. Moreover, when the rank $r$ is part of the input, we show that for generic matrices the algorithm is fixed-parameter tractable (FPT) in the parameter $r$; in fact, the running time is linear in the input size $X$. In the approximate case using the Frobenius norm as an error measure, we show that EPMF is NP-hard, already when $r=2$, the smallest nontrivial case.

The Chromatic Sum problem asks, given a graph $G$ and an integer $k$, whether $G$ admits a colouring $c$ with sum $\sum_{v\in V}c(v) \leq k$. We study the complexity of Chromatic Sum on graph classes defined by some set of forbidden graphs. First, we show that three known frameworks fully classify the complexity of Chromatic Sum on $HH$-minor-free graphs and $HH$-topological-minor-free graphs for any set of graphs $HH$, and on $HH$-subgraph-free graphs for any finite set of graphs $HH$. To show this, we prove a new NP-completeness result for Chromatic Sum on certain subdivisions of planar subcubic graphs. Next, we consider other containment relations. We formalise a novel framework of problems that are NP-complete for planar graphs as well as for graphs of bounded independence number. For every problem in this framework, we obtain an almost complete complexity classification on $H$-induced-minor-free graphs, $H$-induced-topological-minor-free graphs, and $H$-free graphs for every graph $H$. We show that Chromatic Sum belongs to this framework, as do several other problems. We also define a more fine-grained framework for the induced subgraph relation. We apply this to obtain a complete complexity classification for Chromatic Sum on $H$-free graphs, as well as for several other problems. We justify the choice of this framework by proving that Chromatic Sum is NP-complete for graphs of clique-width at most $3$. This result complements a known polynomial-time result for graphs of clique-width at most $2$.

We study the computational complexity of several counting problems on graphs. Each of these problems consists of counting orderings of the vertices or edges with adjacency constraints. We show $\#P$-completeness for all of them via a common new technique. Given a counting function $C$ of interest, we define a parameterized family of instances $G_q$, where the parameter $q$ controls the amplification of a simple gadget. After multiplying by an explicit factor $f(q)$, we show that the values of $f(q) \cdot C(G_q)$, for positive integers $q$, agree with a rational function in $q$ whose numerator and denominator can be interpolated in polynomial time. We then recover a $\#P$-hard function by evaluating this rational function symbolically at a limiting value $L \in \mathbb{Q} \cup \{\infty, -\infty\}$. With this methodology, we show $\#P$-completeness for the following counting problems: (a) successive vertex orderings of bipartite graphs, (b) st-numberings of graphs, (c) shellings of bipartite graphs, (d) linear extensions of N-free posets of height $3$, and (e) linear extensions of posets of height $2$. Result (d) settles a conjecture of Felsner and Manneville (2015). Although result (e) was first proved by Dittmer and Pak (2018), we include an alternative proof, using our technique, that does not rely on the result of Brightwell and Winkler (1991) about the hardness of counting linear extensions for general posets.

The KKL Theorem, a seminal result in boolean function analysis, characterizes the structure of low-influence (non-expanding) functions on the hypercube. While recent years have seen breakthrough results across a variety of areas relying on analogs of the KKL Theorem beyond the cube (e.g., on product spaces, Grassmann graphs), further progress has been inhibited by our poor understanding of the phenomenon across more general domains. Motivated in this context, Bafna, Hopkins, Kaufman, and Lovett (STOC 2022) and Gur, Lifshitz, and Liu (STOC 2022) proved a generalized KKL-type Theorem for spectral high dimensional expanders (HDX). Their results, however, remain highly restricted due to strong quantitative expansion requirements on the underlying complex. In this work, we introduce a simple local-to-global method for analyzing low influence functions on simplicial complexes. Using this method we prove a local-to-global KKL-type Theorem: any simplicial complex whose links satisfy a KKL-Theorem also satisfies such a result globally. Building on Gotlib and Kaufman (RANDOM 2023), we also prove a weaker dimension-dependent KKL-type Theorem for simplicial complexes with any non-trivial (two-sided) expansion. As concrete applications of our framework, we give the first characterization of non-expanding functions on `combinatorial' HDX such as dense clique complexes and a corresponding Kruskal-Katona Theorem, as well as a small-set expansion theorem for the Ramanujan Complexes of Lubotzky, Samuels, and Vishne (EJC '05).

We introduce an approach to distinguishing isomorphism types of graphs based on vector spaces of polynomials that are set-wise invariant under permutations ("separating modules," which are representations of the symmetric group), inspired by the Geometric Complexity Theory approach to separating complexity classes (Mulmuley & Sohoni, SIAM J. Comput., 2001). We characterize the power of this method for distinguishing non-isomorphic graphs under several different complexity measures: - We show that separating modules of "support-degree" $k$ (each monomial touches at most $k$ vertices) are equivalent to the counts of $O(k)$-vertex subgraphs. This is strictly weaker than $O(k)$-dimensional Weisfeiler--Leman (Fürer, ICALP '01). - We show that separating modules of symmetric circuit size $n^{Θ(k)}$ are equivalent to $Θ(k)$-WL. This generalizes and strengthens a result of Dawar & Wilsenach (CSL '18; ICALP '20; ACM Trans. Comput. Log., 2022; Theory Comput., 2025): they proved one direction of this equivalence for invariant polynomials; we generalize to separating modules and prove both directions. - When considering only the multiplicities of separating modules (as was proposed in GCT by Mulmuley & Sohoni, ibid., rather than the polynomials themselves), we show that two graphs are separated by multiplicities if and only if their automorphism groups have different cycle indices. The latter result is notable in the analogy with GCT, as it is the only result we are aware of in which the multiplicity approach to separating isomorphism types of objects has been given an "intrinsic" characterization in terms of the objects themselves. We use this to show that for graphs, multiplicity obstructions are stronger than occurrence obstructions. We also connect invariant polynomials to the Graph Reconstruction Conjectures and Forman's "invariants of finite type" (Adv. Math., 2004).

We prove that random linear codes have nearly optimal discrepancy properties in a broad range of regimes. Our main results are two general theorems: one controlling all translates of a fixed test, and another controlling large families of Fourier-pseudorandom tests. Two motivating applications follow. First, random linear codes match unstructured random codes for list-decoding from errors above capacity. If $C\subseteq\mathbb F_q^n$ is a random linear code of rate $1-\frac1n\log_q |B_ρ|+ε$, where $B_ρ$ is a radius-$ρ$ Hamming ball, then with high probability $$ |C\cap B|=(1\pm o(1))\frac{|C||B|}{q^n} $$ simultaneously for all radius-$ρ$ Hamming balls $B\subseteq\mathbb F_q^n$. This extends the classical result that such codes have covering radius at most $ρn$ whp (Blinovsky, 1987). Second, over prime fields, random linear codes match unstructured random codes for zero-error list-recovery above capacity. For prime $q>2$ and $2\le \ell\le q-1$, a random linear code of rate $1-\log_q\ell+ε$ satisfies, with high probability, $$ |C\cap S|=(1\pm o(1))\frac{|C|\ell^n}{q^n} $$ simultaneously for all rectangles $S=S_1\times\cdots\times S_n$ with $|S_i|=\ell$. As a consequence, there are abundant $n$-party linear ramp secret sharing schemes over $\mathbb F_q$ with privacy threshold about $n/(2\log q)$ and reconstruction threshold about $5n/(2\log q)$, resilient to balanced local leakage; prior existence results required thresholds above $n/2$ even in this case. The translate result, hence the list-decoding application, holds over arbitrary finite fields, even growing with $n$. The list-recovery and leakage applications hold over prime fields under moderate growth, e.g. $q\le n^{1/5-o(1)}$. The proofs use a refined second-moment analysis tracking intersection sizes as random generators are added to $C$.

A family of permutations of $[n]$ is called setwise distinguishable if for every permutation in the family there exists a subset of $[n]$ whose image under this permutation differs from its image under any other permutation in the family. We prove that there exists a setwise distinguishable family of $2^{(2-o(1)) \cdot n}$ permutations of $[n]$. The result is optimal up to the $o(1)$ term in the exponent and is achieved through an explicit construction. As an application, we obtain nearly tight conditional lower bounds on the kernelization complexity of graph coloring problems parameterized by the vertex-deletion distance to split graphs. This improves a result of Jansen and Kratsch (Inf. Comput., 2013).

A graph $G$ is conformable if it admits a proper $(Δ(G)+1)$-coloring in which, among the $Δ(G)+1$ color classes including the empty ones, at most $\sum_{v\in V(G)}(Δ(G)-d_G(v))$ have parity different from that of $|V(G)|$. The complexity of deciding conformability was left open in recent work, and positive results for several graph classes had suggested that the problem might be polynomial-time solvable. We settle the general problem by proving that Conformability is NP-complete. Hardness holds even for connected regular graphs $G$ of odd order with independence number $α(G)=3$ and maximum degree $Δ(G)\ge |V(G)|/2$. In particular, NP-completeness persists when every color class is forced to have the parity of the order. The reduction starts from perfect triangle packing in graphs of clique number three, regularizes the source graph while preserving the relevant triangle packings, and then takes the complement. In the complement, conformable color classes correspond to odd cliques of the regularized graph; $K_4$-freeness restricts these cliques to singletons or triangles, and the number of available colors forces exactly the required number of disjoint triangles.

We study the $t$-uniform hypergraphicality problem under a compressed representation of the degree sequence. Instead of listing all vertex degrees explicitly, the input consists of pairs $$ (δ_1,n_1),\dots,(δ_k,n_k), $$ meaning that exactly $n_i$ vertices have degree $δ_i$. Thus the parameter $k$ denotes the number of distinct degrees. Although deciding $t$-hypergraphicality is NP-complete for every fixed $t>2$, we prove that the problem is fixed-parameter tractable parameterized by $(k,t)$. Our result shows that tractability extends substantially beyond previously known bounded-range regimes: even degree sequences with large overall degree spread can be handled efficiently when the number of distinct degrees is bounded. Our approach decomposes hyperedges according to their types with respect to the degree classes, yielding a bounded-dimension spectrum representation. Using balancing hinge-flips, we show that every feasible spectrum can be transformed into a realization of the prescribed degree sequence. This leads to an integer programming feasibility formulation with $$ \binom{t+k-1}{k-1} $$ variables. Applying Lenstra's theorem yields an FPT algorithm running in time $$ f(k,t)\cdot \mathrm{poly}(L), $$ where $L$ denotes the encoding length of the compressed input.

We give a general framework for tomography of states that have bounded-extent with respect to a structured class of states. Let $\textsf{C}$ be a family of $n$-qubit states such that: $(i)$ $\textsf{C}$ is succinctly representable and $(ii)$ there is a weak agnostic learner of $\textsf{C}$. We give a tomography protocol for an unknown state $|ψ\rangle$ that is promised to admit a decomposition of the form $|ψ\rangle = \sum_i c_i |φ_i\rangle$, where $|φ_i\rangle \in \textsf{C}$ with bounded $\ell_1$-norm of the coefficients (which we call extent). Our main contribution is to show that a weak agnostic learner for $\textsf{C}$ can be boosted into a tomography algorithm for states with bounded extent with respect to $\textsf{C}$. Our reduction is black-box and applies broadly across model classes. As an application, when $\textsf{C}$ is the class of stabilizer states, we obtain tomography algorithms for states with stabilizer extent $ξ$ up to trace distance $\varepsilon$, in time $\textsf{poly}(n,(ξ/\varepsilon)^{\log(ξ/\varepsilon)})$, which is improvable to $ \textsf{poly}(n,ξ,1/\varepsilon)$ assuming the algorithmic polynomial Freiman-Ruzsa conjecture in the high-doubling regime. When the unknown state $|ψ\rangle$ is arbitrary, we give an algorithmic decomposition result in the spirit of a weak regularity lemma for quantum states with respect to $\textsf{C}$ and show that the structure in $|ψ\rangle$ that is explainable by $\textsf{C}$ can be efficiently learned. Our main conceptual message is that agnostic learning of a structured base class automatically yields learnability of its low-complexity linear span.

We establish the first sharp thresholds for low-degree polynomial tests in planted-vs-planted settings, where the goal is to determine with vanishing error which of two structured planted mechanisms generated the observed data. We prove matching low-degree upper and lower bounds for counting communities in the planted submatrix and planted dense subgraph models. The resulting testing threshold coincides, down to the sharp constant, with the known low-degree recovery threshold. In contrast, the task of weak testing, where the goal is to outperform random guessing, does not have a sharp threshold but rather a smooth transition, which we identify. To prove our results, we develop a framework for planted-vs-planted testing that builds on a latent-variable expansion originating in low-degree recovery and employs new methods to identify and prune non-signal contributions.

The Membership Problem for Pedigree Polytope (M3P) asks, given $X\in\mathbb{Q}^{\binom{n}{3}}$, whether $X\in\mathrm{conv}(P_n)$, where $P_n$ is the set of all pedigrees. A pedigree is a structured encoding of a Hamiltonian cycle construction in $K_n$. We establish that M3P is solvable in strongly polynomial time via a recursively constructed layered network $(N_k, R_k, μ)$ and a multicommodity flow problem MCF$(k)$. The necessary and sufficient condition for membership established is that the optimal total flow in MCF$(n-1)$ equals the maximum possible flow $z_{\max}$. The complexity analysis, grounded in Tardos's strongly polynomial algorithm for combinatorial linear programs (1986), shows that this condition can be checked in strongly polynomial time in the dimension of the matrix involved. By sufficiency, this implies M3P~$\in$~P. Since the Symmetric Travelling Salesman Problem (STSP) reduces to M3P via the Multistage Insertion (MI) formulation (Arthanari 1983), STSP is solvable in polynomial time, and the P vs.NP question is resolved. The proofs leading to this result are fully machine-verified in Lean~4/Mathlib4, with zero unresolved \texttt{sorry}s in the main proof chain. The main contribution is the Lean~4 machine verification of all proofs in the main chain, resulting in \texttt{theorem p\_equals\_np}: P = NP. The Lean~4 formal verification covers the sufficiency of MCF(n-1) for membership in $\mathrm{conv}(P_n)$, and the P = NP chain via Maurras (2002), Grötschel--Lovász--Schrijver (1988), Cook (1971), and Karp (1972). The complete lean project (36 Lean~4 files, 2968/2968 build targets clean) is available at https://github.com/TiruArt/Pedigree-Polytopes-Lean4.

We introduce a diffusion-based uncertainty model for robust optimization on directed graphs, in which perturbations of edge weights propagate along adjacent edges and satisfy conservation constraints at nodes. This topology-aware structure is natural in networked systems where uncertainty is induced by flows and local interactions, including transportation, logistics, communication, and energy networks. We analyze how such diffusive uncertainty reshapes the computational landscape of robust graph optimization. For convex network problems, such as minimum-cost flow and maximum flow, the resulting formulations remain convex and admit polynomial-time solution methods across all diffusion regimes considered. For combinatorial problems, the effect is more delicate. We focus on two canonical combinatorial graph problems, shortest path and the traveling salesman problem (TSP), which provide complementary benchmarks: shortest path is polynomial-time solvable in the nominal setting, whereas TSP is already NP-hard. We show that, for shortest path, propagation depth induces a sharp transition between tractable and intractable robust counterparts. For the traveling salesman problem, robustness often adds no computational complexity beyond ordinary TSP, because the structure of Hamiltonian cycles makes the fixed-tour adversarial problem collapse to explicit formulas. Together, these results show that topology-aware uncertainty can fundamentally change robust combinatorial optimization, with tractability governed by the interaction between propagation, budget geometry, and the structure of feasible solutions.

Let $f: T\to \{ 0,1 \}$ be a Boolean function on the Boolean half-slice, $T$, \ie elements of $\{0,1\}^n$ with Hamming weight $n/2$. We show that if $f(x)+f(y)=f(x+y)$ holds with probability $\frac{1+δ}{2}$ over a uniform pair $(x,y)$ such that $x,y,x+y\in T$, then $f$ agrees with some linear function on at least $\frac{1+δ}{2}-o(1)$ fraction of the points in $T$. More generally, we show that if $f$ passes the natural $k$-query BLR test with probability $\frac{1+δ}{2}$ for any $k\geq3$, then it must agree with some affine function at $\frac{1+δ^{\frac{1}{k-2}}}{2}-o(1)$ fraction of the points in $T$. The only other known linearity test for the slice in the low soundness regime (i.e., when $δ$ can be arbitrarily small) was given by Kalai, Lifshitz, Minzer, and Ziegler [FOCS'24]. Our result improves upon this result in two significant ways: firstly, it works for $k=3$ queries, instead of requiring $k\geq4$; secondly, our result is sharper, e.g., when $k=4$, we are able to conclude an agreement of $\frac{1+\sqrtδ}{2}-o(1)$ instead of $\frac{1+c\sqrtδ}{2}$ for $c\approx.0035$. In particular, our result matches (up to the $o(1)$ term) the conclusion one obtains over the full hypercube via the classical BLR analysis. Our main technical contribution is a new dense model theorem using bounds on Krawtchouk polynomials. Using these Krawtchouk polynomial bounds, we also obtain a simple $k$-query test ($k\geq 5$) that avoids any use of the dense model machinery. This simplified test naturally extends to the slice over the $q$-ary hypercube, giving the first such result over larger alphabets.

High dimensional expanders simultaneously satisfying spectral and combinatorial (coboundary) expansion have recently played a major role in breakthroughs in PCP and coding theory, but the only known construction of such complexes is extremely involved, requiring deep algebraic number theory. In this work, we give an extremely simple combinatorial construction of a sub-polynomial degree complex based on projections of the flags complex (subspace chains) that is (i) a local spectral expander, (ii) a coboundary expander, and (iii) a swap coboundary expander. As a corollary, we also give the first near-linear size combinatorial hypergraphs with good agreement tests in the '1%' regime, and a simple PCP construction with near-linear size.

The overlap gap property (OGP) is a statement about the geometry of near-optimal solutions. Exhibiting OGP implies failure of a class of local algorithms; and has been observed to coincide with conjectured algorithmic limits in problems with statistical computational gap. We consider the Stochastic Block Model (SBM), where the graph has a planted partition with $k$ equal-size blocks which form the `communities', and where, for parameters $p>q$, vertices within the same community connect with probability $p$, while vertices in different communities connect with probability $q$, independently across pairs of vertices. Modularity--based clustering algorithms have become ubiquitous in applications. This article studies theoretical limits of local algorithms based on the modularity score on the SBM. We establish that modularity exhibits OGP on the SBM. This rules out a class of local algorithms based on modularity for recovery in the SBM, and shows slow mixing time for a related Markov Chain. Theoretically this is one of the few instances where OGP has been established for a `planted' model, as most such analyses to date consider the `null' model. As part of our analysis, we extend a result by Bickel and Chen 2009, who established that with high probability, the modularity optimal partition of SBM is $o(n)$ local moves away from the planted partition, where $n$ is the graph size. We show that, with high probability, any partition with modularity score sufficiently near the optimal value is close to the planted partition.

Width-based automated theorem proving is a framework where counterexamples to graph-theoretic conjectures are searched width-wise relative to some graph width measure, such as treewidth or pathwidth. In a recent work it has been shown that dynamic programming algorithms operating on tree decompositions can be combined together with the purpose of width-based theorem proving. This approach can be used to show that several long-standing conjectures in graph theory can be tested in time \(2^{2^{k^{O(1)}}}\) on the class of graphs of treewidth at most \(k\). In this work, we give the first steps towards evaluating the viability of this framework from a practical standpoint. At the same time, we advance the framework in two directions. First, we introduce a state-canonization technique that significantly reduces the number of states evaluated during the search for a counterexample of the conjecture. Second, we introduce an early-pruning technique that can be applied in the study of conjectures of the form \(\mathcal{P}_1 \rightarrow \mathcal{P}_2\), for graph properties \(\mathcal{P}_1\) and \(\mathcal{P}_2\), where \(\mathcal{P}_1\) is a property closed under subgraphs. As a concrete application, we use our framework in the study of graph-theoretic conjectures related to coloring triangle-free graphs. In particular, our algorithm is able to show that Reed's conjecture for triangle-free graphs is valid on the class of graphs of pathwidth at most 5, and on graphs of treewidth at most 3. Perhaps more interestingly, our algorithm is able to construct in a completely automated way counterexamples to invalid strengthenings of Reed's conjecture. These are the first results showing that width-based automated theorem proving is a promising avenue in the study of graph-theoretic conjectures.