arXiv++ Combinatorics

Holmsen proved in 2016 a generalization of the classical colorful Caratheodory theorem in which a matroid imposes additional constraints on the desired colorful transversal. His approach also works in the more general setting of oriented matroids, rather than relying directly on convex hulls. In this paper, we extend these ideas in several directions. First, we study which colorful Caratheodory-type results remain valid when convex cones replace convex hulls, as well as analogous modifications in the oriented matroid setting. Second, we consider variants in which the additional constraint on the transversal is not encoded by a matroid. This leads to new extensions of the classical Tverberg theorem. Our approach is topological, following the methods of Holmsen, and Kalai and Meshulam, on which it builds. The key idea is to analyze homology groups of simplicial complexes that encode colorful Caratheodory-type phenomena, such as the support complex of an oriented matroid. In particular, one shows that these complexes are (near-)d-Leray. We extend this analysis by carrying out more detailed homology computations for these complexes, with the aim of enabling further and more refined applications of the method.

A measurable set $A\subseteq \mathbb S^{d-1}$ is called zero-sum-free if there are no $\boldsymbol{x},\boldsymbol{y},\boldsymbol{z}\in A$ with $\boldsymbol{x}+\boldsymbol{y}+\boldsymbol{z}=\boldsymbol{0}$. Bukh asked whether every zero-sum-free measurable subset of $\mathbb S^{d-1}$, for $d\ge3$, has normalized surface measure at most $\frac{1}{2}$. He also pointed out that even the asymptotic behavior as $d\to\infty$ was unknown. We answer Bukh's asymptotic question by proving that every such set has normalized surface measure at most $\frac{\lfloor (d+1)^2/2\rfloor}{d(d+1)}=\frac{1}{2}+O\left(\frac{1}{d}\right).$ Since the lower bound $\frac{1}{2}$ comes from open hemispheres, this determines the asymptotic extremal density. By monotonicity, upper bounds in low-dimensional cases are especially important. We use a stability argument to improve the bound from $\frac{3}{5}$ to $\frac{71}{120}$ in dimensions $4$ and $5$.

We develop a theory of symmetric infinitesimal rigidity for bar-joint frameworks in the hyperbolic plane, where symmetry is given by a Fuchsian group acting by isometries. Using the language of gain graphs and the orbit rigidity matrix, we reduce rigidity questions for infinite symmetric frameworks in the upper-half plane H to finite combinatorial conditions. Our main result provides a combinatorial characterisation of the infinitesimal rigidity for Gamma-symmetric frameworks, which are as generic as possibly allowed by the symmetry, when Gamma is a surface group. Namely, we show that a Gamma-gain graph is Gamma-isostatic if and only if it satisfies certain matroidal sparsity conditions. In particular, if Gamma is not cyclic then the appropriate combinatorial condition is (2,3,1,0)-gain tightness. Via the correspondence between Gamma-symmetric frameworks in H and finite frameworks on the quotient surface H/Gamma, this yields a characterisation of infinitesimal rigidity for frameworks on compact Riemann surfaces of genus at least 2.

What is the maximum number of points one can place in an $n \times n$ grid such that every Euclidean line contains at most $k$ points? For $k = 2$, this is the notorious no-three-in-line problem of Dudeney. In this paper, we resolve this problem for all other $k$ (and sufficiently large $n$). Namely, for $k \geqslant 3$ and sufficiently large $n$, we show that this maximum is exactly $kn$. To prove this, our key observation is that in the regime $k \geqslant 3$, the problem is dominated in a certain statistical sense by the influence of a small number of "heavy" lines with many grid points. We apply a result of Ehard-Glock-Joos on pseudorandom hypergraph matchings to construct a set of size $kn - o(n)$ with at most $k$ points on each heavy line, and then a crude deletion argument yields a no-$(k+1)$-in-line set of nearly the same size. Finally, we use a randomised switching procedure to complete the construction (building upon ideas of Simkin and Luria). Using similar ideas, we also address the no-four-on-a-circle problem of Erdős and Purdy. Namely, we prove the existence of a set of $2n - o(n)$ points in the $n \times n$ grid such that no four of these points lie on a circle or a line, improving on the previous construction of size $n - o(n)$ due to Dong and Xu.

We introduce the microscopic weighting, a canonical signed measure of mass one that can be associated to almost any finite metric space. The microscopic weighting is obtained as the small-scale limit of the weightings used to define the magnitude function. We give general criteria for its existence, proving in particular that every finite space of strictly negative type admits a microscopic weighting; this includes every finite subset of Euclidean or hyperbolic space and every finite tree. Heuristically speaking, the microscopic weighting distributes its mass as widely as possible across a space, assigning greater weight to sparse or outlying regions and emphasizing points on the boundary. Indeed, we show that on a finite space of negative type the microscopic weighting can be characterized (when it exists) as an optimizing measure for an energy integral determined by the distance function. Alternatively, it can be characterized in terms of the geometry of the Schoenberg embedding. Each of these interpretations also clarifies the information carried by the derivative of the magnitude function at zero. Though our main focus in this paper is on finite metric spaces, we lay the groundwork to extend the theory to compact subsets of Euclidean space. In that setting, we observe that the microscopic weighting must be understood as a distribution rather than as a measure.

We show that there exists a constant $δ> 0$ such that for any positive integer $n$ there exists a set of $n$ points $P \subset \mathbb{R}^2$ with the following property: for every subset $A \subseteq P$ of size $|A| \geq 2$, \[ \max_{λ>0} \#\{(a,b)\in A \times A: a\ne b,\ \lvert a-b\rvert=λ\} \gtrsim \frac{|A|^2}{n^{1-δ}}.\] Our result is a vertical amplification of a robust Ramanujan estimate recently established by Croot-Mao-Pohoata-Sheffer-Yip for arbitrary subsets of the ordinary square grid, and is inspired by recent constructions for the Erdős unit distance problem and the Elekes-Rónyai problem. Taking $A=P$, the inequality above gives a distance occurring $n^{1+δ}$ times in $P$; thereby a scaled copy of $P$ is a counterexample for the unit-distance conjecture. In addition, the same inequality shows that (1) all subsets of $P$ of size $\gtrsim n^{1-δ}$ must contain isosceles triangles, and (2) all subsets of $P$ of size $\gtrsim n^{1/2-δ}$ must contain repeated distances. These features give polynomially improved estimates for old problems of Erdős. The existence of a set satisfying property (1) confirms a conjecture of Erdős from 1980, whereas the existence of a set with property (2) answers a question of Conlon-Fox-Gasarch-Harris-Ulrich-Zbarsky in the negative.

Ample sets of hypercubes, introduced by A. Dress in 1995, constitute a combinatorial structure with rich properties and important examples. Ample sets can be characterized in a multitude of combinatorial, graph-theoretical, recursive, and geometrical ways, and they are equivalent to lopsided sets introduced by J. Lawrence in 1983. In this paper, we define and investigate ample sets of Cartesian products $U=U_1\times\cdots\times U_m$. This is done using minor-subproducts of $U$, which correspond to products of partitions of factors: each minor-subproduct is obtained by partitioning each $U_i$ into blocks and contracting blocks into singletons. For a minor-subproduct $M$ and a set $S$, we define the notions of shattering of $M$ by $S$, of copy of $M$ in $S$, of projection $S_M$ of $S$ on $M$, and of strong-projection $S^M$ of $S$ on $M$. We call a set $S$ \emph{ample} if for any minor-subproduct $M$ that is shattered by $S$, there exists a copy of $M$ included in $S$. We prove that several characterizations of ample sets can be extended to ample sets of Cartesian products. In particular, we show that ampleness of $S$ is equivalent to the ampleness of the complement $S^*$, to superisometricity (isometricity of $S^M$ for any minor-subproduct $M$), and commutativity $(S^M)_{M'}=(S_{M'})^M$ for all minor-subproducts $M,M'$ with disjoint supports. We also provide more efficient characterizations of ampleness, in particular, by showing that $S$ is ample iff S is isometric and both $S_e$ and $S^e$ are ample for some elementary minor-subproduct, iff the intersection of S with any interval [u,v] with u,v in S is ample in the classical sense. We characterize ampleness by push downs and provide a decomposition theorem, allowing us to prove that their prism complexes are contractible. We provide new examples of ample sets arising from payoff games, prism-like polyhedra, and quasi-median graphs.

We design exact algorithms for the ham-sandwich and centerpoint theorems for polytopal measures. Our key observation is that the cap-volume function of such a measure, i.e., the volume cut off by a halfspace, is piecewise rational on a natural decomposition of the space of oriented hyperplanes. This lets us recast prescribed-proportion cutting problems as semialgebraic feasibility problems. For fixed ambient dimension, this yields polynomial-time algorithms to decide the existence of cuts, describe the full solution set, and sample or enumerate solutions. We extend this framework to the center transversal theorem, showing that spaces of deep affine flats are semialgebraic, which holds for centerpoints. We further show that the set of centerpoints of a convex polytope coincides with its floating body at level $1/(d+1)$, a useful semialgebraic description.

We prove a sharp lower bound for the cardinality of sumsets of subsets of $\mathbb{Z}^d$ confined to a hypercube, resolving in strong form a conjecture that was made explicit by Becker, Ivanisvili, Krachun and Madrid and had circulated in the folklore of the field for some time. Specifically, for sets $A_j\subseteq \{0,1,2,\dots,m\}^d$ we show that \[|A_1+\dots+A_n|\;\geq\; (|A_1|\cdots|A_n|)^{1/p},\qquad p=\frac{n\log(m+1)}{\log(nm+1)},\] with the exponent best possible. The only previously known sharp cases were $A_j\subseteq \{0,1\}^d$, for all $n\ge1$, and $A_j\subseteq \{0,1,2\}^d$ for $n=2$. We also prove a sharp inequality in the case when $A_j\subseteq\{0,1,\dots,m_j\}^d$ for different $m_j$. We obtain the above inequality as a corollary of a stronger result on sup-convolution of functions on $\mathbb{Z}^d$, whose proof is based on a novel mixed volume representation of a lattice path norm, together with a sharp one-dimensional functional inequality.

This is a geometric retelling of Konyagin and Sevast'yanov's proof of Andrew's theorem, which is a tight upper bound on the number of vertices of a d-dimensional lattice polytope in terms of its volume.

A multiset of $n$ unordered points in $\mathbb{R}^r$ -- a point cloud, or, for $r=2$, a persistence barcode of birth-death pairs -- is a point of the orbit space $\mathbb{R}^{nr}/S_n$ for the symmetric group $S_n$ permuting the rows of an $n \times r$ matrix; a separating family of invariants on this space is exactly a complete set of permutation-independent coordinates. We provide one that is explicit, small, and stable, in the max-plus (tropical) setting: for all $n \geq 1$ and $r \geq 1$, the $\binom{n+r}{r}$ basic $r$-symmetric tropical polynomials, of degree at most $n$, separate the orbits of $S_n$ on $\mathbb{R}^{nr}$. This settles in full a problem left open in [Kubo, J. Pure Appl. Algebra 223 (2019) 72-85], where separation was known only for $r=2$ and special cases of $r \geq 3$, and yields a family far smaller and of lower degree than the general separating sets from Derksen's recent theory of tropical invariants for permutation actions ($nr + (nr)!/n!$ invariants of degree $O(n^2 r^2)$). The proof is elementary and constructive: the basic values are identified with a transportation problem, and the multiset is recovered from the dual by an explicit algorithm. We further show the coordinate map is a bi-Lipschitz embedding for all $n$ and $r$, being an injective max filter bank (via the bi-Lipschitz theory of max filtering), with an explicit Lipschitz constant for the forward bound and a fully explicit, dimension-free distortion when $r=1$. Finally we determine when the pairwise values suffice (exactly $n \leq 3$) and show that invariants on at least three columns and of degree less than $n$ are necessary in general, the obstruction being a standard non-uniqueness configuration from discrete tomography.

Let $N_α(d)$ denote the maximum number of equiangular lines in $\mathbb{R}^d$ with common angle $\arccos(α)$. Balla conjectured that, if the spectral radius order $κ_{\frac{1-α}{2α}}$ of $\frac{1-α}{2α}$ is finite, then $$N_α(d)\leq \max\left\{\frac{(1-α^2)(1-2α^2)}{2α^4},\left\lfloor\frac{κ_{\frac{1-α}{2α}}(d-1)}{κ_{\frac{1-α}{2α}}-1}\right\rfloor\right\},$$ for any $d\geq 1$. The conjecture has previously been verified only for $α\in\left\{\frac{1}{3},\frac{1}{5},\frac{1}{1+2\sqrt{2}}\right\}$. In this paper, we prove that this conjecture holds for $α=\frac{1}{1+2\sqrt{3}}$ and $α=\sqrt{5}-2$. On the other hand, we show that Balla's conjecture fails for infinitely many $α$.

We construct a reduced planar convex body $R$ with thickness $Δ(R)=1$ and \[\operatorname{area}(R)=0.786215\ldots>0.785398\ldots=\fracπ{4}.\] Thus $R$ is a counterexample to Lassak's conjectured upper bound $\operatorname{area}\le(π/4)Δ^2$ for planar reduced bodies. The construction is given by an explicit support function, and the proofs use only elementary support-function, width, area, and contact-point computations.

The aim of this paper is to establish critical duality theory for ratios of nonnegative homogeneous convex functions (shorten for RC functions) and differences of convex functions (abbreviated as DC functions) on Banach spaces. Specifically, we establish a series of duality results on critical point theory and Morse theory for RC functions, including the homotopy type of sublevel sets, the Morse critical points and their Rothe critical groups, Lagrange critical points and their multiplicities, Lusternik-Schnirelman min-max critical values, Poincare polynomials, as well as the structure of handlebody decompositions, all of which are proved to be preserved under polarity dual. Moreover, we obtain the first critical duality theory of DC functions which does not depend on the DC decomposition. This answers a question left open from the work of Toland on DC functions and the work of Le-Pham on DC programming. We apply these results to provide a reformulation of the graph Cheeger constant using zonotopes; we introduce the contact data which serves as a geometric characterization of Lagrange criticality; and we show that the eigenproblems for 1-Laplacian and $\infty$-Laplacian on hypergraphs are equivalent to the contact problems of zonotopes, which indeed establishes a new characterization of zonotopes. We also prove a duality equivalence for certain nonlinear eigenvalue problems and bifurcation problems. Our study here reveals an intricate interaction of critical point theory with other fields such as convex analysis, combinatorial geometry, and nonlinear eigenproblems on graphs.

Given a finite nonempty planar point set $S$, what is the maximum number of congruent copies of $S$ contained in a set of $n$ points in the Euclidean plane? Building on OpenAI's recent breakthrough on the unit distance problem, we construct planar sets consisting of $n$ points that contain $Ω_S(n^{1+δ_S})$ congruent copies of $S$, for some positive constant $δ_S$ depending only on $S$. This answers a question of Brass and Pach in a strong form, and makes progress on questions posed by Erdős and Purdy, and Ábrego and Fernández-Merchant. Our proof uses the number field construction from Sawin's quantitative refinement of OpenAI's result and consequently yields an explicit choice for $δ_S$ for each fixed $S$.

We analyze the decrease of simplex diameters under iterated refinement of spherical Delaunay complexes. Unlike in ordinary subdivision, the refined Delaunay complex need not be a subdivision of the previous one, so mesh contraction is not automatic. We derive explicit contraction bounds for several families of Steiner points, including Delaunay analogues of barycentric and edgewise subdivision. The proof reduces the problem to sharp covering estimates for Euclidean simplices. These estimates are obtained through a strengthening of Maurey's empirical method via pivotal sampling and a dimension-dependent version of the approximate Carathéodory theorem. Theoretical results and numerical experiments show that Delaunay refinements achieve stronger contraction than their subdivision counterparts.

We propose a sufficient condition for the non-periodicity of a set of Wang tiles. It applies to sets of Wang tiles whose tiles have vertical or horizontal stripes. The proof is based on a geometric argument involving a quadrilateral circumscribed to a parabola from which we conclude the irrationality of the densities of the vertical and horizontal stripes. We apply the sufficient condition to propose new proofs of non-periodicity of known sets of Wang tiles, including an encoding of Penrose tilings into 24 Wang tiles and the family of metallic mean Wang tiles. Conversely, for every pair $(α,β)\in[0,1]^2$ of irrational numbers in the same quadratic number field, we construct a finite aperiodic set of Wang tiles with stripes that admits a valid tiling whose density of vertical stripes is $α$ and density of horizontal stripes is $β$.

J.E. Littlewood posed the question of how many infinite circular cylinders of unit radius can be arranged so that each touches all the others. We give a computer-free proof that one cannot find ten such cylinders. This improves a known result, namely that there are no eleven such cylinders, which was obtained making partial use of computer verification.

Menger's theorem is one of the most fundamental results in graph theory. It states that if a graph $G$ does not contain $k$ disjoint paths between two given sets $X$ and $Y$ of vertices in $G$, then there is a set of at most $k-1$ vertices that intersects every path between $X$ and $Y$. Nguyen, Scott, and Seymour gave a counterexample to the conjectured natural coarse variant in which the paths are required to be pairwise at distance at least $d$, and, conversely, there is a set of at most $k-1$ bounded-radius balls intersecting every path between $X$ and $Y$. In other words, the coarse Menger property does not hold in general. We prove that graphs whose cycles space is generated by cycles of bounded length do have the coarse Menger property. As a corollary, we show that many natural graphs and geodesic metric spaces have the coarse Menger property. These include hyperbolic graphs, Cayley graphs of finitely presented groups, planar graphs with bounded face size, and complete Riemannian planes.

In this paper, we study the family of subcomplexes of the order complexes of finite graded posets, defined via its rank function. We address three main topics. (1) We describe the general topological properties of these subcomplexes in relation to magnitude homology of graded posets. (2) For posets whose order complexes are simplicial subdivisions of closed manifolds, we show that the homology groups of these subcomplexes agree with that of the undelying manifold except for the top dimension, where it is a nontrivial free abelian group. (3) For shellable graded posets, we prove that each of the subcomplexes are also shellable. Moreover, in the case of geometric semilattices, we show that each subcomplexes are homotopy equivalent to a nontrivial wedge sums of spheres of the same dimension.