arXiv++ Combinatorics

Browse math.CO papers from arXiv

Papers from July 26, 2026

24 paper(s) published on this date
2026-07-26 v2
Improved chromatic bounds for ($P_2\cup P_3$)-free graphs
Let $G$ be a $(P_2\cup P_3)$-free graph, and let $k=ω(G)\geq 1$. We prove that \[ χ(G)\leq \binom{k+2}{3}-\binom{k-1}{2} =\frac{k^3+11k-6}{6}. \] The previously best-known general bound for this unrestricted graph class, due to Bharathi and Choudum, was $χ(G)\leq\binom{k+2}{3}$. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first improvement of their bound that applies to all $(P_2\cup P_3)$-free graphs. For $k\geq 3$, our result improves their estimate by exactly $\binom{k-1}{2}$ colours, replacing $(k^3+3k^2+2k)/6$ by $(k^3+11k-6)/6$, and thereby eliminates the quadratic term without imposing any additional forbidden induced subgraph.
2026-07-26
A note on Tight Irreducible Affine Spreads
Let ${\mathbb F}_q^n$ denote the vector space of dimension $n$ over ${\mathbb F}_q$ and AG$(n,q)$ denote the corresponding affine space. An $\textit{affine vector space partition}$ of AG$(n,q)$ is a collection ${\mathcal P}$ of affine subspaces that partition the points of AG$(n,q)$. If all subspaces in ${\mathcal P}$ have the same dimension $d$, then ${\mathcal P}$ is called an $\textit{affine $d$-spread}$. We say that an affine partition ${\mathcal P}$ is $\textit{completely tight}$ if for any pair $C,C'\in{\mathcal P}$ with $C=v+S$, $C'=v'+S'$, where $v,v'\in{\rm AG}(n,q)$ and $S\neq S'$ are linear subspaces of ${\mathbb F}_q^n$, we have $ S\cap S'=\{{\bf 0}\}$. An affine partition ${\mathcal P}$ is said to be $\textit{irreducible}$ if there is no subset ${\mathcal P}'\subset {\mathcal P}$ such that $1<|{\mathcal P}'|<|{\mathcal P}|$ and the union of all subspaces in ${\mathcal P}'$ is a subspace of AG$(n,q)$. For all $d \geq 1$ and $n>2d$, we construct a completely tight irreducible affine $d$-spread of AG$(n,q)$. This also settles a recent conjecture of Bamberg et al. on the existence of tight irreducible affine $d$-spreads.
2026-07-26
An infinite family of counterexamples to the Polycirculant Conjecture
We disprove the Polycirculant Conjecture, which states that every transitive 2-closed permutation group is non-elusive, i.e. contains a derangement of prime order. In fact, we prove a stronger result, answering a long-standing question of Marušič and Jordan: there exists a vertex-transitive graph admitting no semiregular automorphism. To do so, we employ recently developed methods of Chen et al. for constructing elusive groups via non-split extensions, allowing us to construct an elusive group $7^6.\mathrm{PSU}_3(3)$ of degree 16,464. We show that this group is the full automorphism group of seven of its orbital graphs and hence is 2-closed. Our example extends to infinitely many counterexamples of the Polycirculant Conjecture, and infinitely many vertex-transitive graphs admitting no semiregular automorphism.
2026-07-26
A diamond-free claw-free cubic graph with strong chromatic index 7
A strong edge coloring is a proper edge coloring in which every color class is an induced matching; the least number of colors is the strong chromatic index $χ'_s(G)$. Lin and Lin proved that every claw-free subcubic graph other than the triangular prism satisfies $χ'_s(G) \le 7$, with all their tight examples containing diamonds. Kardos (Problem 4.1 of the open-problem collection of the 33rd Workshop on Cycles and Colourings) asked whether every diamond-free claw-free cubic graph is strongly 6-edge-colorable, equivalently whether $χ'_s(T(G))=6$ for every cubic graph $G$, where $T(G)$ is the truncation of $G$. We exhibit an explicit connected, simple, diamond-free, claw-free cubic graph $H$ on 18 vertices with $χ'_s(H)=7$, and show that it has the fewest vertices possible for such a non-prism example. Hence the first formulation, over simple cubic graphs, is false even after excluding the prism; and since $H$ is the truncation of a cubic multigraph with parallel edges, the two formulations are not equivalent unless "cubic graph" is allowed to mean loopless multigraph, under which reading the problem is answered negatively. The narrower version restricted to truncations of simple base graphs remains open.
Formalizing Flag Algebras in Lean
Razborov's flag algebra method is a powerful tool for proving asymptotic inequalities in extremal graph theory, often reducing the task to finding a finite certificate by semidefinite programming. We present a machine-checked formalization of the method for finite simple graphs, together with a certificate-to-proof compiler that turns externally generated certificate data into algebraic proofs checked by Lean. The formalization covers the foundations of the method: partially labeled graphs, their densities in large graphs, the quotient algebra of density expressions, graph-limit semantics through positive homomorphisms, and the downward operators used to average out labels. The compiler treats the external semidefinite programming output as candidate data rather than trusted input: Lean independently computes the required density and multiplication facts, verifies positive semidefiniteness exactly over $\mathbb{Q}$, and carries out the algebraic normalization steps of flag-algebra proofs. Our case studies yield formal proofs of seven Turán-type upper bounds, including Mantel's theorem and the Erdős pentagon theorem, a $C_4$-density bound for triangle-free graphs, and edge-density bounds for $K_4$-free, $K_5$-free, and $C_5$-free graphs. Independently of the compiler, we formalize the matching constructions that complete the exact Turán densities of Mantel's theorem and the Erdős pentagon theorem, and prove two inequalities of Goodman. Our constrained semantics also prompted a meta-theoretic comparison of two ways of imposing graph constraints: building a hereditary constraint into the flag algebra from the start, or testing inequalities afterward on constrained graph limits with labels chosen at random. We state the resulting root-plantability criterion characterizing when the two approaches agree; a forthcoming paper will present the complete account.
The Smith normal form of Laplacian matrices of simplicial annuli and high dimensional trees
Inspired by the generalization of the formula of determinant of the distance matrix of trees to $k$-trees, we study the Smith normal form of Laplacian matrices associated with some simplicial complexes. We find relations between sandpile groups of adjacency graphs and the Smith normal form of Laplacian matrices of simplicial complexes. We use such relations to calculate the Smith normal form of the highest Laplacian matrix of simplicial annuli and $k$-trees. %The low dimensional cases seems to be more difficult to calculate. We also provide numerical experiments to visualize how good are these algebraic invariants to distinguish $k$-trees. Finally, we point out that the Graham-Lovász-Pollak matrix, used to compute the determinant of the distance matrix of trees, can be used in the context of Laplacian matrices of trees and block graphs.
2026-07-26
Additive Bases from Primitive Dyck Words: Regular Underapproximations, Motzkin Coding, and Digit Lifting
We study additive representations by integers whose canonical binary expansions are primitive Dyck words. Pairing consecutive bits yields a positional form of the classical relation between Dyck paths and two-colored Motzkin paths: except for 10, primitive Dyck words are exactly the binary block images of base-4 words 3w0, where w is a two-colored Motzkin word. This exposes a regular underapproximation, digit closure, and sharp generation bounds. We prove an interval digit-lifting theorem for digitally closed sets and a constructive base-4 propagation algorithm that lifts finite sumset certificates to infinite tails in logarithmically many recursive stages. Combining these tools with exact finite certificates and generation-gap lower bounds, we classify all positive even integers requiring more than six primitive Dyck summands. The integer 46 requires eight, and 34, 44, 98, 154, 198, 202, 206, 838, 842, and 846 require seven; every other positive even integer requires at most six. Thus 848 is the sharp eventual threshold. The bound is asymptotically optimal because 10*4^(k+1)-6 requires six summands for every k >= 2. The associated halved family has exact asymptotic additive order five. Supplementary programs reproduce all finite certificates using exact integer arithmetic.
2026-07-26
Tensor Spectral Stability for Uniform Hypergraphs with Bounded Matching Number
We establish a tensor spectral stability theorem for uniform hypergraphs with bounded matching number. More precisely, for fixed integers $k\geq 3$ and $β\geq2$, and sufficiently large $n$, we prove that every $n$-vertex $k$-uniform hypergraph $H$ with matching number at most $β$ and tensor spectral radius close to the maximum possible value among all such hypergraphs must be structurally close to the extremal hypergraph $S_{n,k,β}$, whose edges consist of all $k$-sets intersecting a fixed set of $β$ vertices. Furthermore, we show that every edge of $H$ intersects this distinguished vertex set and that $H$ contains all but a small proportion of the edges of $S_{n,k,β}$. As an application, we obtain a new proof of the spectral version of the Erdős matching conjecture for sufficiently large $n$.
2026-07-26
Topological line arrangements and their topological invariants
A topological line arrangement is an arrangement of embedded spheres in the complex projective plane that topologically generalizes a complex line arrangement. In this paper, we establish foundational results on the topology of the complement of topological line arrangements. First, we prove that the cohomology ring of the complement is isomorphic to the Orlik-Solomon algebra, as for classical complex line arrangements. Since classical methods are unavailable in this setting, we use a homological method to compute the cohomology ring. We then study the homotopy type of the complement. We prove that the complement of a symplectic line arrangement has the homotopy type of a minimal CW complex. In contrast, every combinatorial type realizable by a topological line arrangement admits a realization with a non-minimal complement. Moreover, every such combinatorial type admits infinitely many realizations whose complements are pairwise non-homotopy equivalent.
The Equality Cases for the Grone-Merris-Bai Theorem
The Grone--Merris inequality, conjectured by Grone and Merris~(1994) and first proved by Bai~(2011), states that for every graph $G$ of order $n$ and every $1\le k\le n$, $\sum_{i=1}^kλ_i(G)\le\sum_{i=1}^k d_i^*(G)$, where $λ_1\ge\cdots\geλ_n$ are the Laplacian eigenvalues and $d_1^*\ge\cdots\ge d_n^*$ is the conjugate degree sequence. In this paper we determine exactly when equality holds. Using the split-graph trace inequality developed by Kothari and Tudose~(2026) in their proof of Brouwer's Laplacian conjecture---which relies on Bai's theorem and also establishes the equivalence between the two conjectures---together with the recent characterization of the Brouwer equality cases by Cai, Chen, Yang and Zhang~(2027), we prove that equality holds in the Grone--Merris inequality if and only if the graph $G$ belongs to one of two explicitly described families. Both families are obtained from a threshold graph by a surgical operation at one terminal block: in the first family, edges are removed from the initial dominating block; in the second, edges are added inside the initial isolated block. Our analysis yields a complete combinatorial description of all pairs $(G,k)$ for which the Grone--Merris bound is tight.
2026-07-26
Hall's universal group does not have finite big Ramsey degrees
In this paper we show that the Hall's universal group does not have finite big Ramsey degrees. Our strategy consists of piggybacking on the recent result of Hubička, Konečný, Todorčević and Zucker (announced at EUROCOMB~2025) that the Fraïssé limit of the class of all finite complete edge-labelled graphs with where the set of labels is countably infinite does not have finite big Ramsey degrees. We then use our categorical machinery to transport their result from the context of edge-lebelled graphs to the context of groups.
2026-07-26
Total outer-independent coalition in graphs
A set $D$ of vertices graph $G$ is a total outer-independent dominating set (TOIDS) of $G$ if every vertex of $G$ is adjacent to at least one vertex in $D$, and $V(G)\setminus D$ is an independent set of $G$. A TOI-coalition in $G$ comprises two disjoint sets of vertices $A$ and $B$ of $G$, neither of which is a TOIDS but whose union $A\cup B$ is a TOIDS of $G$. We say that the sets $A$ and $B$ form a TOI-coalition, and are TOI-coalition partners. A TOI-coalition partition in $G$ is a vertex partition $Ψ=\{V_1, V_2,..., V_k\}$ in which every set forms a TOI-coalition with another set in $Ψ$. The TOI-coalition number $C_t^{oi}(G)$ is the maximum cardinality among all TOI-coalition partitions of $G$. In this work, the above-mentioned concepts are introduced and studied. The existence of a TOI-coalition partition is investigated. Several sharp upper bounds on $C_t^{oi}(G)$ are established. Finally, the exact values of $C_t^{oi}(G)$ for some graph classes are obtained.
2026-07-26
Erdős--Ko--Rado theorems in $\ell_2$-norm for three finite spaces
Let $\mathcal{F}$ be a $k$-uniform hypergraph. The famous Erdős--Ko--Rado (1961) theorem determines the maximum size and extremal structure for $\mathcal{F}$ being $t$-intersecting, that is, $|F_1 \cap F_2| \ge t$ for any two edges $F_1, F_2$ of $\mathcal F$. The codegree squared sum $\mathrm{co}_2(\mathcal{F})$ is the square of the $\ell_2$-norm of the codegree vector of all $(k-1)$-sets in $\mathcal{F}$, which was initially introduced for Turán problems of hypergraphs. Recently, Brooks and Linz (2026), as well as Wu and Zhang (2026) investigated the maximum value of $\mathrm{co}_2(\mathcal{F})$ and corresponding extremal structures for $\mathcal{F}$ being $t$-intersecting. Moreover, Brooks and Linz asked if the classical results on intersecting families can be extended to $\mathrm{co}_2(\mathcal{F})$. In this paper, by developing the spectral techniques for incidence matrices, we study the extremal problems of $\mathrm{co}_2(\mathcal{F})$ for $\mathcal{F}$ being intersecting families in finite vector spaces, affine spaces, and attenuated spaces, and establish the Erdős--Ko--Rado theorems in $\ell_2$-norm for the three finite spaces.
2026-07-26
A counterexample to the zero forcing versus independence conjecture for cubic and subcubic graphs
We exhibit a connected graph on 24 vertices with maximum degree 3, independence number 9 and zero forcing number 11, refuting a 2017 conjecture of TxGraffiti recorded as Conjecture 2 of the survey of Davila, Brimkov and Pepper. The same construction with a different gadget gives a connected cubic graph on 36 vertices with independence number 15 and zero forcing number 17; the conjecture therefore fails also in the cubic form in which the survey's Lean 4 appendix states it. In particular Z <= alpha + 1 is not a universal bound for connected cubic graphs, and the value Z = alpha + 2 is attained.
2026-07-26
Multivariate growth series of graph products of groups
Right-angled Artin groups (RAAGs) and right-angled Coxeter groups (RACGs) associated with finite simple graphs are fundamental objects in geometric group theory. Their one-variable growth series with respect to the standard generating sets was classically expressed by Chiswell in terms of the one-variable independence polynomial of the defining graph [2] with suitable substitutions of the variable. In this paper, we investigate the multivariate growth series of graph products of groups and derive explicit formulas in terms of the multivariate independence polynomial of the underlying graph through suitable substitutions of variables. As special cases, we obtain multivariate growth series formulas for RAAGs and RACGs, thereby extending the classical one-variable identities. We further show that the coefficients of the multivariate growth series of RAAGs and RACGs admit explicit descriptions in terms of the double-marked and marked chromatic polynomials of graphs. This connection reveals a rich interplay between growth series and graph coloring invariants. In particular, we obtain completely explicit formulas for all the coefficients in the case of chordal graphs, which include, for example, trees and complete graphs.
2026-07-26
Sharp Diagonal Thresholds for Tight Hamilton Cycles in Uniformly Dense $3$-Graphs
A $3$-uniform hypergraph (or $3$-graph) $H$ on $n$ vertices is \emph{$(n,d,μ)$-dense} if $e_H(X,Y,Z)\ge d|X||Y||Z|-μn^3$ for all $X,Y,Z\subseteq V(H)$. This is one of the weakest standard notions of quasirandomness for $3$-graphs and is also known as linear quasirandomness. In this paper, we determine the sharp diagonal thresholds for tight Hamilton cycles in $(n,d,μ)$-dense $3$-graphs $H$ under conditions on the minimum vertex degree $δ_1(H)$ and the minimum codegree $δ_2(H)$. We actually prove a general result: define \[ f(d):=\frac{1-\sqrt{(4d-1)/3}}2. \] We prove that $(n,d,μ)$-density together with $δ_1(H)\geα\binom{n-1}{2}$ forces a tight Hamilton cycle whenever $d > 1/3$ and $α>f(d)$. In particular, $f(1/3)=1/3$, which answers Problem~8.3(i) of Araújo, Piga and Schacht and confirms Conjecture~8.1 of Han, Shu and Wang. For the minimum codegree condition, the sharp diagonal threshold is $(κ,κ)$, where $κ$ is the unique real solution of $κ=(1-κ)^3$. Since $κ\approx0.3177>1/4$, this gives a negative answer to Problem~8.3(ii) of Araújo, Piga and Schacht and disproves Conjecture~8.2 of Han, Shu and Wang. The two proofs use a common Hamilton-framework reduction, but the two degree conditions lead to distinct dominant-component lemmas for $(n, d, μ)$-dense $3$-graphs, which are of independent interest and whose proofs do not rely on the absorption method.
Set-defined graph classes: $χ$-boundedness meets tropical algebra
We study set-defined graph classes: hereditary classes whose vertices are assigned fixed-length numerical tuples, with adjacency determined solely by equality patterns among coordinates. These classes arise in structural graph theory, communication complexity, logic, and adjacency labeling schemes. We ask when they are $χ$-bounded, that is, when chromatic number is bounded in terms of clique number throughout the class. First, we prove a decomposition theorem: every graph in a set-defined class can be partitioned into a number of parts polynomially bounded in its clique number, each inducing a union of a bounded number of shift-colorable graphs, that is, graphs admitting a homomorphism to a shift graph. Thus bounded unions of shift-colorable graphs form the fundamental obstruction to $χ$-boundedness in set-defined classes. For full set-defined classes, consisting of all graphs realizable by a fixed Boolean rule on equality patterns, we prove a stronger dichotomy: every such class is either polynomially $χ$-bounded or contains shift graphs of arbitrarily large chromatic number. Moreover, we provide an algorithm that, given a Boolean-function description of a full set-defined class, decides $χ$-boundedness of the class. It reduces the problem to feasibility of tropical linear programs, and its correctness follows from a duality with winning strategies in mean-payoff games. Conversely, every integer system of tropical inequalities, and hence every mean-payoff game, can be encoded in strongly polynomial time as a set-defined class whose non-$χ$-boundedness is equivalent to feasibility. This provides a graph-theoretic counterpart of tropical feasibility and mean-payoff-game solvability, linking structural graph theory, tropical algebra, and game-theoretic algorithms.
2026-07-26
The covering number C(12, 6, 4) is 41
A $t$-$(v,k,λ)$ covering is a collection of $k$-subsets (blocks) of a $v$-set such that every $t$-subset of points lies in at least $λ$ blocks; the covering number $C_λ(v,k,t)$ is the least number of blocks in such a collection, and one writes $C(v,k,t)$ when $λ=1$. The recorded bounds for $C(12,6,4)$ have been $40 \le C(12,6,4) \le 41$. We show that no $4$-$(12,6,1)$ covering with $40$ blocks exists, and hence that $C(12,6,4)=41$. A counting argument shows that in a hypothetical $40$-block covering every point lies in exactly $20$ blocks, the link of every point is an optimal $3$-$(11,5,1)$ covering with a forced degree sequence, and the six pairs of points of degree $10$ form a perfect matching; an exhaustive case analysis over the orbits of a group of order $3840$, carried out by satisfiability solving, then shows that no optimal $3$-$(11,5,1)$ covering occurs as such a link. Each of the $81$ formulas in the primary proof has an unsatisfiability certificate checked by drat-trim and by the formally verified checker cake_lpr; two additional cross-encoding certificates are checked by the same pipeline. The lower-bound argument uses no tabulated covering number: its only numerical input, $C(10,4,2) \ge 9$, is itself certified. As a by-product the certificates yield a self-contained certified proof that the optimal $3$-$(11,5,1)$ covering is unique up to isomorphism. Equivalently, the Turán number $T(12,8,6)$ is $41$; the new value propagates to improved lower bounds for $C(13,7,5)$, $C(14,8,6)$, $C(15,9,7)$ and $C(16,10,8)$.
2026-07-26
On the Thickness of Infinite Generalized Sidon Sets, II
A set $\mathcal{A}$ of nonnegative integers is a $B_h$-set if the sums $a_1+\cdots+a_h$ with $a_1\le\cdots\le a_h$ and $a_i\in\mathcal{A}$ are distinct; a $B_2$-set is a Sidon set. We prove that for every even $h$ and every $B_h$-set $\mathcal{A}$, \[ \liminf_{n\to\infty} \frac{ | \mathcal{A}\cap[0,n) | }{\sqrt[h]{n/\log n}} \le \left(\fracπ{\log 2} \cdot \frac{Γ(1+h/2)^2}{Γ(1+1/h)^{h}}\right)^{1/h}. \]
2026-07-26
Powers of the Vandermonde determinant are eventually non-SNP
We prove a conjecture of Monical, Tokcan, and Yong that every fixed positive power of the Vandermonde determinant is non-SNP in all sufficiently many variables, where a polynomial is non-SNP if there is a lattice point in its Newton polytope that does not appear with nonzero coefficient. This means our result proves that for every even power $k\geq4$, there is always such a missing lattice monomial in large enough dimensions. The odd case follows from alternation, and the quadratic case was previously known. For every even power $k\geq4$, we exhibit an explicit lattice point in the Newton polytope of $a_{δ_k}^k$ whose coefficient vanishes. The vanishing is obtained from a Dyson constant-term identity, proved using the finite-variable Jack scalar product and Macdonald's specialization formula. The key even-power construction and proof strategy arose from prompting with OpenAI Codex (GPT Sol 5.6 Extra High), a large language model; the complete transcript appears in the appendix. The authors subsequently checked and organized the argument. The accompanying Lean formalization is available at https://github.com/steven-le-thien/vandermonde-snp.
2026-07-26
Elementary Symmetric Polynomial Inequalities for Centered Vectors and Matrices
We prove new inequalities for elementary symmetric polynomials (ESPs) for vectors that sum to zero, and for square matrices with zero row and column sums. We apply these results to obtain a unified upper bound on the mean-field approximation guarantee for permutation mixtures, as well as a sharp $χ^2$ version of the de Finetti theorem for finite sequences over a small alphabet. The main proof ideas were developed by the GPT-5.5 Pro model.
Chromatic numbers of circulants with indispensable generators
The Cayley graph $\text{Cay}(G,S)$ is the graph whose vertex set is the group $G$, where two vertices $x$ and $y$ are adjacent if and only if $xy^{-1}$ or $yx^{-1}$ lies in some fixed subset $S$ of $G$. We call the elements of $S$ generators. A circulant graph is a Cayley graph where $G$ is finite and cyclic. Chromatic numbers of circulant graphs have been studied by many authors. A general formula due to Heuberger for the chromatic number of a circulant graph is known when $S$ has two elements, but no such formula is known when $S$ has three or more elements. We say that an element $x$ of $S$ is indispensable if $S\setminus\{x\}$ does not generate $G$. We say that $S$ is minimal if every element of $S$ is indispensable. By a result of Garcia-Marco and Knauer from 2024, if $G$ is nilpotent and $S$ is minimal, then $\text{Cay}(G,S)$ is $3$-colorable. In this article, we prove three main results. First, we give an upper bound for the chromatic number of a circulant graph with three generators, one of which is indispensable. Second, we present an alternate proof of the theorem of Garcia-Marco and Knauer for the case of abelian groups. Third, we apply these methods to provide a considerably more systematic (and potentially generalizable) proof of Heuberger's theorem for the chromatic number of circulant graphs with two generators. Throughout this paper, our primary tool is the theory of Heuberger matrices, for which we provide a brief primer.
2026-07-26
A Slice-Rank Drift Bound for Random Quantum \(k\)-SAT
Random quantum satisfiability is a natural quantum analogue of random constraint satisfaction and a basic model for frustration-free local Hamiltonians. Despite extensive work on its satisfiable and unsatisfiable regimes, the quantitative location of the random quantum \(k\)-SAT threshold has remained poorly understood, with the best general upper bounds leaving a large gap to the known lower bounds. In this paper we prove a new upper bound on the satisfiability threshold of random quantum \(k\)-SAT. Our result improves the previously known asymptotic upper bound by a factor of order \(k\), giving a bound of order \(2^k/k\). The improvement is also significant at small values of \(k\); in particular, for random quantum \(3\)-SAT we obtain a substantially smaller explicit upper bound than the one previously available. The proof combines the geometric formulation of generic quantum satisfiability with a dimension-decay analysis of the full satisfying subspace. The key input is a multiplicative Shearer-type inequality for tensor-product subspaces, which quantifies how global dimension forces nontrivial local dimension on typical sets of qubits.
2026-07-26
Frucht's theorem and other set-theoretic principles below the axiom of choice and the axiom of foundation
We take the first step toward the study of set-theoretic principles below the axiom of choice $\mathsf{AC}$ and the axiom of foundation $\mathsf{AF}$ by studying Frucht's theorem, an ordinary mathematical theorem which is provable with either $\mathsf{AC}$ or $\mathsf{AF}$ but not provable without both, and its variants. Specifically, we propose a number of such principles, study the relations between these principles and the standard axioms, and prove provability and unprovability results using (infinite) graph-theoretic constructions and permutation models, which draw a preliminary map of this new area of set theory.