arXiv++ Combinatorics

The study of Ramanujan-type congruences for functions specific to additive number theory has a long and rich history. Motivated by recent connections between divisor sums and overpartitions via congruences in arithmetic progressions, we investigate the existence and classification of Ramanujan-type congruences for functions in multiplicative number theory.

Consider a system of $m$ balanced linear equations in $k$ variables with coefficients in $\mathbb{F}_q$. If $k \geq 2m + 1$, then a routine application of the slice rank method shows that there are constants $β,γ\geq 1$ with $γ< q$ such that, for every subset $S \subseteq \mathbb{F}_q^n$ of size at least $β\cdot γ^n$, the system has a solution $(x_1,\ldots,x_k) \in S^k$ with $x_1,\ldots,x_k$ not all equal. Building on a series of papers by Mimura and Tokushige and on a paper by Sauermann, this paper investigates the problem of finding a solution of higher non-degeneracy; that is, a solution where $x_1,\ldots,x_k$ are pairwise distinct, or even a solution where $x_1,\ldots,x_k$ do not satisfy any balanced linear equation that is not a linear combination of the equations in the system. In this paper, we focus on linear systems with repeated columns. For a large class of systems of this type, we prove that there are constants $β,γ\geq 1$ with $γ< q$ such that every subset $S \subseteq \mathbb{F}_q^n$ of size at least $β\cdot γ^n$ contains a solution that is non-degenerate (in one of the two senses described above). This class is disjoint from the class covered by Sauermann's result, and captures the systems studied by Mimura and Tokushige into a single proof. Moreover, a special case of our results shows that, if $S \subseteq \mathbb{F}_p^n$ is a subset such that $S - S$ does not contain a non-trivial $k$-term arithmetic progression (with $p$ prime and $3 \leq k \leq p$), then $S$ must have exponentially small density.

We prove the following conjecture of Shkredov and Solymosi: every subset $A \subset \mathbf{Z}^2$ such that $\sum_{a\in A\setminus\{0\}} 1/\left\|a\right\|^{2} = +\infty$ contains the three vertices of an isosceles right triangle. To do this, we adapt the proof of the recent breakthrough by Bloom and Sisask on sets without three-term arithmetic progressions, to handle more general equations of the form $T_1a_1+T_2a_2+T_3a_3 = 0$ in a finite abelian group $G$, where the $T_i$'s are automorphisms of $G$.

Furstenberg-Weiss have extended Szemerédi's theorem on arithmetic progressions to trees by showing that a large subset of the tree contains arbitrarily long arithmetic subtrees. We study higher dimensional versions that analogously extend the multidimensional Szemerédi theorem by demonstrating the existence of certain arithmetic structures in large subsets of a cartesian product of trees.

We prove that the the discrepancy of arithmetic progressions in the $d$-dimensional grid $\{1, \dots, N\}^d$ is within a constant factor depending only on $d$ of $N^{\frac{d}{2d+2}}$. This extends the case $d=1$, which is a celebrated result of Roth and of Matoušek and Spencer, and removes the polylogarithmic factor from the previous upper bound of Valkó from about two decades ago. We further prove similarly tight bounds for grids of differing side lengths in many cases.

We introduce a notion of complexity for systems of linear forms, called sequential Cauchy-Schwarz complexity, which is parametrized by two positive integers $k,\ell$ and refines the notion of Cauchy-Schwarz complexity introduced by Green and Tao. We prove that if a system of linear forms has sequential Cauchy-Schwarz complexity at most $(k,\ell)$ then any average of 1-bounded functions over this system is controlled by the $2^{1-\ell}$-th power of the Gowers $U^{k+1}$-norms of the functions. For $\ell=1$ this agrees with Cauchy-Schwarz complexity, but for $\ell>1$ there are systems that have sequential Cauchy-Schwarz complexity at most $(k,\ell)$ whereas their Cauchy-Schwarz complexity is greater than $k$. Our main application illustrates this with systems over a prime field $\mathbb{F}_p$ that are denoted by $Φ_{k,M}$ and can be viewed as $M$-dimensional arithmetic progressions of length $k$. For each $M\geq 2$ we prove that $Φ_{k,M}$ has sequential Cauchy-Schwarz complexity at most $(k-2,|Φ_{k,M}|)$ (where $|Φ_{k,M}|$ is the number of forms in the system), whereas the Cauchy-Schwarz complexity of $Φ_{k,M}$ can be greater than $k-2$. Thus we obtain polynomial true-complexity bounds for $Φ_{k,M}$ with exponent $2^{-|Φ_{k,M}|}$. A recent general theorem of Manners, proved independently with different methods, implies a similar application but with different polynomial true-complexity bounds, as explained in the paper. In separate work, we use our application to give a new proof of the inverse theorem for Gowers norms on $\mathbb{F}_p^n$, and related results concerning ergodic actions of $\mathbb{F}_p^ω$.

Szemerédi's theorem implies that there are $2^{o(n)}$ subsets of $[n]$ which do not contain a $k$-term arithmetic progression. A sparse analogue of this statement was obtained by Balogh, Morris, and Samotij, using the hypergraph container method: For any $β> 0$ there exists $C > 0$, such that if $m \ge Cn^{1 - 1/(k-1)}$ then there are at most $β^m \binom{n}{m}$ $m$-element subsets of $\{1, \ldots, n\}$ without a $k$-term arithmetic progression. We give a short, inductive proof of this result. Consequently, this provides a short proof of the Szemerédi's theorem in random subsets of integers.

In a Maker-Breaker game there are two players, Maker and Breaker, where Maker wins if they create a specified structure while Breaker wins if they prevent Maker from winning indefinitely. A $3$-term arithmetic progression, or $3$-AP, is a sequence of three distinct integers $a, b, c$ such that $b-a = c-b$. The $3$-AP game is a biased Maker-Breaker game played on $[n]$ where every round Breaker selects $q$ unclaimed integers for every Maker's one integer. Maker is trying to select points such that they have a $3$-AP and Breaker is trying to prevent this. The main question of interest is determining the threshold bias $q^*(n)$, that is the minimum value of $q=q(n)$ for which Breaker has a winning strategy. Kusch, Rué, Spiegel and Szabó initially asked this question and proved $\sqrt{n/12-1/6}\leq q^*(n)\leq \sqrt{3n}$. We find new strategies for both Maker and Breaker which improve the existing bounds to \[ (1+o(1))\sqrt{\frac{n}{5.6}} \leq q^*(n) \leq \sqrt{2n} +O(1). \]

Let $p_t(a,b;n)$ denote the number of partitions of $n$ such that the number of $t$ hooks is congruent to $a \bmod{b}$. For $t\in \{2, 3\}$, arithmetic progressions $r_1 \bmod{m_1}$ and $r_2 \bmod{m_2}$ on which $p_t(r_1,m_1; m_2 n + r_2)$ vanishes were established in recent work by Bringmann, Craig, Males, and Ono using the theory of modular forms. Here we offer a direct combinatorial proof of this result using abaci and the theory of $t$-cores and $t$-quotients.

Let $A_1$ and $A_2$ be randomly chosen subsets of the first $n$ integers of cardinalities $s_2\geq s_1 = Ω(s_2)$, such that their sumset $A_1+A_2$ has size $m$. We show that asymptotically almost surely $A_1$ and $A_2$ are almost fully contained in arithmetic progressions $P_1$ and $P_2$ with the same common difference and cardinalities approximately $s_i m/(s_1+s_2)$. We also prove a counting theorem for such pairs of sets in arbitrary abelian groups. The results hold for $s_i = ω(\log^3 n)$ and $s_1+s_2 \leq m = o(s_2/\log^3 n)$. Our main tool is an asymmetric version of the method of hypergraph containers which was recently used by Campos to prove similar results in the special case $A=B$.

We develop a recursive scheme, as well as polynomial forms (polynomials in $n$ of degree $m$), for the evaluation of Ledin and Brousseau's Fibonacci sums of the form $S(m,n,r)=\sum_{k=1}^nk^mF_{k + r}$, $T(m,n,r)=\sum_{k=1}^nk^mL_{k + r}$ for non-negative integers $m$ and $n$ and arbitrary integer $r$; $F_j$ and $L_j$ being the $j^{th}$ Fibonacci and Lucas numbers. We also extend the study to a general second order sequence by establishing a recursive procedure to determine $W(m,n,r;a,b,p,q)=\sum_{k=1}^nk^mw_{k+r}$ where $(w_j(a,b;p,q))$ is the Horadam sequence defined by $w_0 = a,\,w_1 = b;\,w_j = pw_{j - 1} - qw_{j - 2}\, (j \ge 2);$ where $a$, $b$, $p$ and $q$ are arbitrary complex numbers, with $p\ne 0$ and $q\ne 0$. An explicit polynomial form for $W(m,n,r;a,b,1,q)$ and more generally for the sum $\mathcal W(m,n,h,r;a,b,p,q) = \sum_{k = 1}^n {V_h^{- k}k^m w_{hk + r}}$, where $(V_j(p,q))=(w_j(2,p;p,q))$, is established. Finally a polynomial form is established for a Ledin-Brousseau sum involving Horadam numbers with subscripts in arithmetic progression.

We characterize those strings whose suffix arrays are based on arithmetic progressions, in particular, arithmetically progressed permutations where all pairs of successive entries of the permutation have the same difference modulo the respective string length. We show that an arithmetically progressed permutation $P$ coincides with the suffix array of a unary, binary, or ternary string. We further analyze the conditions of a given $P$ under which we can find a uniquely defined string over either a binary or ternary alphabet having $P$ as its suffix array. For the binary case, we show its connection to lower Christoffel words, balanced words, and Fibonacci words. In addition to solving the arithmetically progressed suffix array problem, we give the shape of the Burrows-Wheeler transform of those strings solving this problem. These results give rise to numerous future research directions.

Let $p$ be a prime and $n$ a positive integer such that $\sqrt{\frac p2} + 1 \leq n \leq \sqrt{p}$. For any arithmetic progression $A$ of length $n$ in $\mathbb{F}_p$, we establish an asymptotic formula for the number of directions determined by $A \times A \subset \mathbb{F}_p^2$. The key idea is to reduce the problem to counting the number of solutions to the bilinear Diophantine equation $ad+bc=p$ in variables $1\le a,b,c,d\le n$; our asymptotic formula for the number of solutions is of independent interest.

A system of linear equations $L$ over $\mathbb{F}_q$ is common if the number of monochromatic solutions to $L$ in any two-colouring of $\mathbb{F}_q^n$ is asymptotically at least the expected number of monochromatic solutions in a random two-colouring of $\mathbb{F}_q^n$. Motivated by existing results for specific systems (such as Schur triples and arithmetic progressions), as well as extensive research on common and Sidorenko graphs, the systematic study of common systems of linear equations was recently initiated by Saad and Wolf. Building upon earlier work of Cameron, Cilleruelo and Serra, as well as Saad and Wolf, common linear equations have recently been fully characterised by Fox, Pham and Zhao, who asked about common \emph{systems} of equations. In this paper we move towards a classification of common systems of two or more linear equations. In particular we prove that any system containing an arithmetic progression of length four is uncommon, confirming a conjecture of Saad and Wolf. This follows from a more general result which allows us to deduce the uncommonness of a general system from certain properties of one- or two-equation subsystems.

A linear configuration is said to be common in $G$ if every 2-coloring of $G$ yields at least the number of monochromatic instances of a randomly chosen coloring. Saad and Wolf asked whether, analogously to a result by Thomason in graph theory, every configuration containing a 4-term arithmetic progression is uncommon. We prove this in $\mathbb{F}_p^n$ for $p\geq 5$ and large $n$ and in $\mathbb{Z}_p$ for large primes $p$.

This paper concerns the lattice $L_n$ of subsets of $\{1,\ldots,n\}$ that are arithmetic progressions, under the inclusion order. For $n\geq 4$, this poset is not graded and thus not semimodular. We give three independent proofs of the fact that for $n\geq 2$, $μ_n(L_n) = μ(n-1)$, where $μ_n$ is the Möbius function of $L_n$ and $μ$ is the classical (number-theoretic) Möbius function. We also show that $L_n$ is comodernistic, which implies that $L_n$ is EL-labelable. Comodernism is then used to prove that the order complex $Δ_n$ of the lattice is either contractible or homotopy equivalent to a sphere.

We develop novel techniques which allow us to prove a diverse range of results relating to subset sums and complete sequences of positive integers, including solutions to several longstanding open problems. These include: solutions to the three problems of Burr and Erdős on Ramsey complete sequences, for which Erdős later offered a combined total of \$350; analogous results for the new notion of density complete sequences; the solution to a conjecture of Alon and Erdős on the minimum number of colors needed to color the positive integers less than $n$ so that $n$ cannot be written as a monochromatic sum; the exact determination of an extremal function introduced by Erdős and Graham on sets of integers avoiding a given subset sum; and, answering a question reiterated by several authors, a homogeneous strengthening of a seminal result of Szemerédi and Vu on long arithmetic progressions in subset sums.

For a polynomial progression $$(x,\; x+P_1(y),\; \ldots,\; x+P_{t}(y)),$$ we define four notions of complexity: Host-Kra complexity, Weyl complexity, true complexity and algebraic complexity. The first two describe the smallest characteristic factor of the progression, the third one refers to the smallest-degree Gowers norm controlling the progression, and the fourth one concerns algebraic relations between terms of the progressions. We conjecture that these four notions are equivalent, which would give a purely algebraic criterion for determining the smallest Host-Kra factor or the smallest Gowers norm controlling a given progression. We prove this conjecture for all progressions whose terms only satisfy homogeneous algebraic relations and linear combinations thereof. This family of polynomial progressions includes, but is not limited to, arithmetic progressions, progressions with linearly independent polynomials $P_1,\; \ldots,\; P_t$ and progressions whose terms satisfy no quadratic relations. For progressions that satisfy only linear relations, such as $$(x,\; x+y^2,\; x+2y^2,\; x+y^3,\; x+2y^3),$$ we derive several combinatorial and dynamical corollaries: (1) an estimate for the count of such progressions in subsets of cyclic groups or totally ergodic dynamical systems; (2) a lower bound for multiple recurrence; (3) and a popular common difference result in cyclic groups. Lastly, we show that Weyl complexity and algebraic complexity always agree, which gives a straightforward algebraic description of Weyl complexity.

We show that the naive mean-field approximation correctly predicts the leading term of the logarithmic lower tail probabilities for the number of copies of a given subgraph in $G(n,p)$ and of arithmetic progressions of a given length in random subsets of the integers in the entire range of densities where the mean-field approximation is viable. Our main technical result provides sufficient conditions on the maximum degrees of a uniform hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$ that guarantee that the logarithmic lower tail probabilities for the number of edges induced by a binomial random subset of the vertices of $\mathcal{H}$ can be well-approximated by considering only product distributions. This may be interpreted as a weak, probabilistic version of the hypergraph container lemma that is applicable to all sparser-than-average (and not only independent) sets.

Celebrated theorems of Roth and of Matoušek and Spencer together show that the discrepancy of arithmetic progressions in the first $n$ positive integers is $Θ(n^{1/4})$. We study the analogous problem in the $\mathbb{Z}_n$ setting. We asymptotically determine the logarithm of the discrepancy of arithmetic progressions in $\mathbb{Z}_n$ for all positive integer $n$. We further determine up to a constant factor the discrepancy of arithmetic progressions in $\mathbb{Z}_n$ for many $n$. For example, if $n=p^k$ is a prime power, then the discrepancy of arithmetic progressions in $\mathbb{Z}_n$ is $Θ(n^{1/3+r_k/(6k)})$, where $r_k \in \{0,1,2\}$ is the remainder when $k$ is divided by $3$. This solves a problem of Hebbinghaus and Srivastav.