arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study the space of 2-frieze patterns generalizing that of the classical Coxeter-Conway frieze patterns. The geometric realization of this space is the space of n-gons (in the projective plane and in 3-dimensional vector space) which is a close relative of the moduli space of genus 0 curves with n marked points. We show that the space of 2-frieze patterns is a cluster manifold and study its algebraic and arithmetic properties.

Let k>0 be an integer, let H be a minor-minimal graph in the projective plane such that every homotopically non-trivial closed curve intersects H at least k times, and let G be the planar double cover of H obtained by lifting G into the universal covering space of the projective plane, the sphere. We prove that G is minor-minimal of branch-width 2k. We also exhibit examples of minor-minimal planar graphs of branch-width 6 that do not arise this way.

The pentagram map is a natural iteration on projective equivalence classes of (twisted) n-gons in the projective plane. It was recently proved ([OST]) that the pentagram map is completely integrable, with the complete set of Poisson commuting integrals given by the polynomials O1,...,O[n/2],On and E1,...,E[n/2],En, previously constructed in [S3]. These polynomials are somewhat reminiscent of the symmetric polynomials. It was observed in computer experiments that if a polygon is inscribed into a conic then Oi=Ei for all i. The goal of the paper is to prove this theorem. The proof is combinatorial, and it was also suggested by computer experimentation.

We present two constructions in this paper: (a) A 10-vertex triangulation $\CC P^{2}_{10}$ of the complex projective plane $\CC P^{2}$ as a subcomplex of the join of the standard sphere ($S^{2}_4$) and the standard real projective plane ($\RR P^{2}_{6}$, the decahedron), its automorphism group is $A_4$; (b) a 12-vertex triangulation $(S^{2} \times S^{2})_{12}$ of $S^{2} \times S^{2}$ with automorphism group $2S_5$, the Schur double cover of the symmetric group $S_5$. It is obtained by generalized bistellar moves from a simplicial subdivision of the standard cell structure of $S^{2} \times S^{2}$. Both constructions have surprising and intimate relationships with the icosahedron. It is well known that $\CC P^{2}$ has $S^{2} \times S^{2}$ as a two-fold branched cover; we construct the triangulation $\CC P^{2}_{10}$ of $\CC P^{2}$ by presenting a simplicial realization of this covering map $S^{2} \times S^{2} \to \CC P^{2}$. The domain of this simplicial map is a simplicial subdivision of the standard cell structure of $S^{2} \times S^{2}$, different from the triangulation alluded to in (b). This gives a new proof that Kuehnel's $\CC P^{2}_{9}$ triangulates $\CC P^{2}$. It is also shown that $\CC P^{2}_{10}$ and $(S^{2} \times S^{2})_{12}$ induce the standard piecewise linear structure on $\CC P^{2}$ and $S^{2} \times S^{2}$ respectively.

New upper bounds on the smallest size t_{2}(2,q) of a complete arc in the projective plane PG(2,q) are obtained for 853<= q<= 2879 and q=3511,4096, 4523,5003,5347,5641,5843,6011. For q<= 2377 and q=2401,2417,2437, the relation t_{2}(2,q)<4.5\sqrt{q} holds. The bounds are obtained by finding of new small complete arcs with the help of computer search using randomized greedy algorithms. Also new sizes of complete arcs are presented.

In 1969 Denniston gave a construction of maximal arcs of degree d in Desarguesian projective planes of even order q, for all d dividing q. In 2002 Mathon gave a construction method generalizing the one of Denniston. We will give a new geometric approach to these maximal arcs. This will allow us to count the number of isomorphism classes of Mathon maximal arcs of degree 8 in PG(2,2^h), h prime.

Let $\A$ be the incidence matrix of lines and points of the classical projective plane $PG(2,q)$ with $q$ odd. With respect to a conic in $PG(2,q)$, the matrix $\A$ is partitioned into 9 submatrices. The rank of each of these submatices over $\Ff_q$, the defining field of $PG(2,q)$, is determined.

A connected graph $G$ with at least $2m+2n+2$ vertices is said to have property $E(m,n)$ if, for any two disjoint matchings $M$ and $N$ of size $m$ and $n$ respectively, $G$ has a perfect matching $F$ such that $M\subseteq F$ and $N\cap F=\varnothing$. In particular, a graph with $E(m,0)$ is $m$-extendable. Let $μ(Σ)$ be the smallest integer $k$ such that no graphs embedded on a surface $Σ$ are $k$-extendable. Aldred and Plummer have proved that no graphs embedded on the surfaces $Σ$ such as the sphere, the projective plane, the torus, and the Klein bottle are $E(μ(Σ)-1,1)$. In this paper, we show that this result always holds for any surface. Furthermore, we obtain that if a graph $G$ embedded on a surface has sufficiently many vertices, then $G$ has no property $E(k-1,1)$ for each integer $k\geq 4$, which implies that $G$ is not $k$-extendable. In the case of $k=4$, we get immediately a main result that Aldred et al. recently obtained.

We tropicalize the rational map that takes triples of points in the projective plane to the plane of quadrics passing through these points. The image of its tropicalization is contained in the tropicalization of its image. We identify these objects inside the tropical Grassmannian of planes in projective 5-space, and we explore a small tropical Hilbert scheme.

Let $P = A\times A \subset \mathbb{F}_p \times \mathbb{F}_p$, $p$ a prime. Assume that $P= A\times A$ has $n$ elements, $n<p$. See $P$ as a set of points in the plane over $\mathbb{F}_p$. We show that the pairs of points in $P$ determine $\geq c n^{1 + {1/267}}$ lines, where $c$ is an absolute constant. We derive from this an incidence theorem: the number of incidences between a set of $n$ points and a set of $n$ lines in the projective plane over $\F_p$ ($n<\sqrt{p}$) is bounded by $C n^{{3/2}-{1/10678}}$, where $C$ is an absolute constant.

In this note we present eleven unit distance embeddings of the Heawood graph, i.e. the point-line incidence graph of the finite projective plane of order two, by way of pictures and 15 digit approximations of the coordinates of the vertices. These together with the defining algebraic equations suffice to calculate arbitrarily exact approximations for the exact embeddings, and so to show that the Heawood graph indeed is a unit-distance graph. Thus we refute a "suspicion" of V. Chvatal from 1972.

We investigate finite 3-nets embedded in a projective plane over a (finite or infinite) field of any characteristic p. Such an embedding is regular when each of the three classes of the 3-net comprises concurrent lines, and irregular otherwise. It is completely irregular when no class of the 3-net consists of concurrent lines. We are interested in embeddings of 3-nets which are irregular but the lines of one class are concurrent. For an irregular embedding of a 3-net of order n greater than 4 we prove that, if all lines from two classes are tangent to the same irreducible conic, then all lines from the third class are concurrent. We also prove the converse provided that the order n of the 3-net is smaller than p. In the complex plane, apart from a sporadic example of order n=5 due to Stipins, each known irregularly embedded 3-net has the property that all its lines are tangent to a plane cubic curve. Actually, the procedure of constructing irregular 3-nets with this property works over any field. In positive characteristic, we present some more examples for n greater than 4 and give a complete classification for n=4.

Let $\mathcal{O}$ be a conic in the classical projective plane $PG(2,q)$, where $q$ is an odd prime power. With respect to $\mathcal{O}$, the lines of $PG(2,q)$ are classified as passant, tangent, and secant lines, and the points of $PG(2,q)$ are classified as internal, absolute and external points. The incidence matrices between the secant/passant lines and the external/internal points were used in \cite{keith1} to produce several classes of structured low-density parity-check binary codes. In particular, the authors of \cite{keith1} gave conjectured dimension formula for the binary code $\mathcal{L}$ which arises as the $\Ff_2$-null space of the incidence matrix between the secant lines and the external points to $\mathcal{O}$. In this paper, we prove the conjecture on the dimension of $\mathcal{L}$ by using a combination of techniques from finite geometry and modular representation theory.

We prove that there is no d such that all finite projective planes can be represented by convex sets in R^d, answering a question of Alon, Kalai, Matousek, and Meshulam. Here, if P is a projective plane with lines l_1,...,l_n, a representation of P by convex sets in R^d is a collection of convex sets C_1,...,C_n in R^d such that C_{i_1},...,C_{i_k} have a common point if and only if the corresponding lines l_{i_1},...,l_{i_k} have a common point in P. The proof combines a positive-fraction selection lemma of Pach with a result of Alon on "expansion" of finite projective planes. As a corollary, we show that for every $d$ there are 2-collapsible simplicial complexes that are not d-representable, strengthening a result of Matousek and the author.

We will see that every finite projective plane of order k > 1 gives rise to a complete set of (k-1) MPLS (= mutually projective latin squares) of order k and by reversing the process we can construct a finite projective plane of order k when a complete set of (k-1) MPLS of order k is given.

Floor diagrams are a class of weighted oriented graphs introduced by E. Brugalle and the second author. Tropical geometry arguments lead to combinatorial descriptions of (ordinary and relative) Gromov-Witten invariants of projective spaces in terms of floor diagrams and their generalizations. In a number of cases, these descriptions can be used to obtain explicit (direct or recursive) formulas for the corresponding enumerative invariants. In particular, we use this approach to enumerate rational curves of given degree passing through a collection of points on the complex plane and having maximal tangency to a given line. Another application of the combinatorial approach is a proof of a conjecture by P. Di Francesco -- C. Itzykson and L. Goettsche that in the case of a fixed cogenus, the number of plane curves of degree d passing through suitably many generic points is given by a polynomial in d, assuming that d is sufficiently large. Furthermore, the proof provides a method for computing these "node polynomials." A labeled floor diagram is obtained by labeling the vertices of a floor diagram by the integers 1,...,d in a manner compatible with the orientation. We show that labeled floor diagrams of genus 0 are equinumerous to labeled trees, and therefore counted by the celebrated Cayley's formula. The corresponding bijections lead to interpretations of the Kontsevich numbers (the genus-0 Gromov-Witten invariants of the projective plane) in terms of certain statistics on trees.

Suppose that a group $G$ acts transitively on the points of $\mathcal{P}$, a finite non-Desarguesian projective plane. We prove that if $G$ is insoluble then $G/O(G)$ is isomorphic to $SL_2(5)$ or $SL_2(5).2$.

We study the mixed Ramsey number maxR(n,K_m,K_r), defined as the maximum number of colours in an edge-colouring of the complete graph K_n, such that K_n has no monochromatic complete subgraph on m vertices and no rainbow complete subgraph on r vertices. Improving an upper bound of Axenovich and Iverson, we show that maxR(n,K_m,K_4) <= n^{3/2}\sqrt{2m} for all m >= 3. Further, we discuss a possible way to improve their lower bound on maxR(n,K_4,K_4) based on incidence graphs of finite projective planes.

Bender-Canfield showed that a plethora of graph counting problems in oriented/unoriented surfaces involve two constants $t_g$ and $p_g$ for the oriented and the unoriented case respectively. T.T.Q. Le and the authors recently discovered a hidden relation between the sequence $t_g$ and a formal power series solution $u(z)$ of the Painlevé I equation which, among other things, allows to give exact asymptotic expansion of $t_g$ to all orders in $1/g$ for large $g$. The paper introduces a formal power series solution $v(z)$ of a Riccati equation, gives a nonlinear recursion for its coefficients and an exact asymptotic expansion to all orders in $g$ for large $g$, using the theory of Borel transforms. In addition, we conjecture a precise relation between the sequence $p_g$ and $v(z)$. Our conjecture is motivated by the enumerative aspects of a quartic matrix model for real symmetric matrices, and the analytic properties of its double scaling limit. In particular, the matrix model provides a computation of the number of rooted quadrangulations in the 2-dimensional projective plane. Our conjecture implies analyticity of the $\mathrm{O}(N)$ and $\mathrm{Sp}(N)$-types of free energy of an arbitrary closed 3-manifold in a neighborhood of zero. Finally, we give a matrix model calculation of the Stokes constants, pose several problems that can be answered by the Riemann-Hilbert approach, and provide ample numerical evidence for our results.

We describe a method that we believe may be foundational for a comprehensive theory of generalised Turan problems. The cornerstone of our approach is a quasirandom counting lemma for quasirandom hypergraphs, which extends the standard counting lemma by not only counting copies of a particular configuration but also showing that these copies are evenly distributed. We demonstrate the power of the method by proving a conjecture of Mubayi on the codegree threshold of the Fano plane, that any 3-graph on n vertices for which every pair of vertices is contained in more than n/2 edges must contain a Fano plane, for n sufficiently large. For projective planes over fields of odd size q we show that the codegree threshold is between n/2-q+1 and n/2, but for PG_2(4) we find the somewhat surprising phenomenon that the threshold is less than (1/2-c)n for some small c>0. We conclude by setting out a program for future developments of this method to tackle other problems.