arXiv++ Combinatorics

Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) is a hybrid classical-quantum algorithm to approximately solve NP optimization problems such as MAX-CUT. We describe a new application area of QAOA circuits: graph structure discovery. We omit the time-consuming parameter-optimization phase and utilize the dependence of QAOA energy on the graph structure for randomly or judiciously chosen parameters to learn about graphs. In the first part, Following up on Wang et. al. and Brandao et. al. we give explicit formulas. We show that the layer-one QAOA energy for the MAX-CUT problem for three regular graphs carries exactly the information: {\em (# of vertices, # of triangles)}. We have calculated our explicit formulas differently from \cite{wang2018quantum}, by developing the notion of the $U$ polynomial of a graph $G$. Many of our discoveries can be interpreted as computing $U(G)$ under various restrictions. The most basic question when comparing the structure of two graphs is if they are isomorphic or not. We find that the QAOA energies separate all non-isomorphic three-regular graphs up to size 18, all strongly regular graphs up to size 26 and the Praust and the smallest Miyazaki examples. We observe that the QAOA energy values can be also used as a proxy to how much graphs differ. Unfortunately, we have also found a sequence of non-isomorphic pairs of graphs, for which the energy gap seems to shrink at an exponential rate as the size grows. Our negative findings however come with a surprise: if the QAOA energies do not measurably separate between two graphs, then both of their energy landscapes must be extremely flat (indistinguishable from constant), already when the number of QAOA layers is intermediately large. This holds due to a remarkable uncoupling phenomenon that we have only deduced from computer simulation.

We prove that a distance-regular graph with a dominant distance is a spectral expander. The key ingredient of the proof is a new inequality on the intersection numbers. We use the spectral gap bound to study the structure of the automorphism group. The minimal degree of a permutation group $G$ is the minimum number of points not fixed by non-identity elements of $G$. Lower bounds on the minimal degree have strong structural consequences on $G$. In 2014 Babai proved that the automorphism group of a strongly regular graph with $n$ vertices has minimal degree $\geq c n$, with known exceptions. Strongly regular graphs correspond to distance-regular graphs of diameter 2. Babai conjectured that Hamming and Johnson graphs are the only primitive distance-regular graphs of diameter $d\geq 3$ whose automorphism group has sublinear minimal degree. We confirm this conjecture for non-geometric primitive distance-regular graphs of bounded diameter. We also show if the primitivity assumption is removed, then only one additional family of exceptions arises, the cocktail-party graphs. We settle the geometric case in a companion paper.

We give simple arithmetic conditions that force the Sylow $p$-subgroup of the critical group of a strongly regular graph to take a specific form. These conditions depend only on the parameters $(v, k, λ, μ)$ of the strongly regular graph under consideration. We give many examples, including how the theory can be used to compute the critical group of Conway's $99$-graph and to give an elementary argument that no $srg(28,9,0,4)$ exists.

In this paper we consider the question of when a strongly regular graph with parameters $((s+1)(st+1),s(t+1),s-1,t+1)$ can exist. These parameters arise when the graph is derived from a generalized quadrangle, but there are other examples which do not arise in this manner, and we term these {\it pseudo-generalized quadrangles}. If the graph is a generalized quadrangle then $t \leq s^2$ and $s \leq t^2$, while for pseudo-generalized quadrangles we still have the former bound but not the latter. Previously, Neumaier has proved a bound for $s$ which is cubic in $t$, but we improve this to one which is quadratic. The proof involves a careful analysis of cliques and cocliques in the graph. This improved bound eliminates many potential parameter sets which were otherwise feasible.

In 2018 the first, Rukavina and the third author constructed with the aid of a computer the first example of a strongly regular graph $Γ$ with parameters (216, 40, 4, 8) and proved that it is the unique PSU(4,2)-invariant vertex-transitive graph on 216 vertices. In this paper, using the geometry of the Hermitian surface of PG(3, 4), we provide a computer-free proof of the existence of the graph $Γ$. The maximal cliques of $Γ$ are also determined.

We study a modified notion of Ollivier's coarse Ricci curvature on graphs introduced by Lin, Lu, and Yau in [11]. We establish a rigidity theorem for complete graphs that shows a connected finite simple graph is complete if and only if the Ricci curvature is strictly greater than one. We then derive explicit Ricci curvature formulas for strongly regular graphs in terms of the graph parameters and the size of a maximal matching in the core neighborhood. As a consequence we are able to derive exact Ricci curvature formulas for strongly regular graphs of girth 4 and 5 using elementary methods. An example is provided that shows there is no exact formula for the Ricci curvature for strongly regular graphs of girth $3$ that is purely in terms of graph parameters.

Let $V$ be an $r$-dimensional $\mathbb{F}_{q^n}$-vector space. We call an $\mathbb{F}_q$-subspace $U$ of $V$ $h$-scattered if $U$ meets the $h$-dimensional $\mathbb{F}_{q^n}$-subspaces of $V$ in $\mathbb{F}_q$-subspaces of dimension at most $h$. In 2000 Blokhuis and Lavrauw proved that $\dim_{\mathbb{F}_q} U \leq rn/2$ when $U$ is $1$-scattered. Subspaces attaining this bound have been investigated intensively because of their relations with projective two-weight codes and strongly regular graphs. MRD-codes with a maximum idealiser have also been linked to $rn/2$-dimensional $1$-scattered subspaces and to $n$-dimensional $(r-1)$-scattered subspaces. In this paper we prove the upper bound $rn/(h+1)$ for the dimension of $h$-scattered subspaces, $h>1$, and construct examples with this dimension. We study their intersection numbers with hyperplanes, introduce a duality relation among them, and study the equivalence problem of the corresponding linear sets.

Our main result is a generalized Dillon-type theorem, giving graph-theoretic conditions which guarantee that a $p$-ary function in an even number of variables is bent, for $p$ a prime number greater than 2. The key condition is that the component Cayley graphs associated to the values of the function are strongly regular, and either all of Latin square type, or all of negative Latin square type. Such a Latin or negative Latin square type bent function is regular or weakly regular, respectively. Its dual function has component Cayley graphs with the same parameters as those of the original function. We also give a criterion for bent functions involving structure constants of association schemes. We prove that if a $p$-ary function with component Cayley graphs of feasible degrees determines an amorphic association scheme, then it is bent. Since amorphic association schemes correspond to strongly regular graph decompositions of Latin or negative Latin square type, this result is equivalent to our main theorem. We show how to construct bent functions from orthogonal arrays and give some examples.

We show that the strongly regular graph on non-isotropic points of one type of the polar spaces of type $U(n, 2)$, $O(n, 3)$, $O(n, 5)$, $O^+(n, 3)$, and $O^-(n, 3)$ are not determined by its parameters for $n \geq 6$. We prove this by using a variation of Godsil-McKay switching recently described by Wang, Qiu, and Hu. This also results in a new, shorter proof of a previous result of the first author which showed that the collinearity graph of a polar space is not determined by its spectrum. The same switching gives a linear algebra explanation for the construction of a large number of non-isomorphic designs.

We classify all the $2$-arc-transitive strongly regular graphs, and use this classification to study the family of finite $(G,3)$-geodesic-transitive graphs of girth $4$ or $5$ for some group $G$ of automorphisms. For this application we first give a reduction result on the latter family of graphs: let $N$ be a normal subgroup of $G$ which has at least $3$ orbits on vertices. We show that $Γ$ is a cover of its quotient $Γ_N$ modulo the $N$-orbits, and that either $Γ_N$ is $(G/N,3)$-geodesic-transitive of the same girth as $Γ$, or $Γ_N$ is a $(G/N,2)$-arc-transitive strongly regular graph, or $Γ_N$ is a complete graph with $G/N$ acting 3-transitively on vertices. The classification of $2$-arc-transitive strongly regular graphs allows us to characterise the $(G,3)$-geodesic-transitive covers $Γ$ when $Γ_N$ is complete or strongly regular.

Let $λ\geq2$ be an integer. For strongly regular graphs with parameters $(v, k, a,c)$ and smallest eigenvalue $-λ$, Neumaier gave two bounds on $c$ by using algebraic property of strongly regular graphs. In this paper, we will study a new class of regular graphs called sesqui-regular graphs, which contains strongly regular graphs as a subclass, and prove that for a sesqui-regular graph with parameters $(v,k,c)$ and smallest eigenvalue at least $-λ$, if $k$ is very large, then either $c \leq λ^2(λ-1)$ or $v-k-1 \leq \frac{(λ-1)^2}{4} + 1$ holds.

For a set of distances $D$, a graph $G$ on $n$ vertices is said to be $D$-magic if there exists a bijection $f:V\rightarrow \{1,2, \ldots , n\}$ and a constant $k$ such that for any vertex $x$, $\sum_{y\in N_D(x)} f(y) = k$, where $N_D(x)=\{y|d(x,y)=i, i\in D\}$ is the $D$-neighbourhood set of $x$. In this paper we utilize spectra of graphs to characterize strongly regular graphs which are $D$-magic, for all possible distance sets $D$. In addition, we provide necessary conditions for distance regular graphs of diameter 3 to be $\{1\}$-magic.

This thesis focuses on theoretical and algorithmic tools for determining the numbers of induced subgraphs in strongly regular graphs, SRGs, and on further applications of such numbers. We consider in more detail a restricted class of these graphs, specifically those with no triangles. In this special case, there are infinitely many feasible sets of parameters for SRGs. Despite this fact there are only seven known examples of such graphs. we develop an algorithm which produces linear equations describing various relations between numbers of induced subgraphs of orders $o$ and $o-1$ in a SRG. We apply our results also on $srg(3250,57,0,1)$ (existence of which is a famous open problem). In this case, the number of induced subgraphs isomorphic to a given graph on $10$ vertices depends only on the number of induced Petersen graphs. Furthermore, we provide new insights about automorphisms of $srg(3250,57,0,1)$ as well as bounds for the numbers of induced $K_{3,3}$ in general triangle-free SRGs. At the end of the thesis we discuss possible extension of our approach for the study of so called $t$-vertex condition.

In the $m$-dimensional affine space $AG(m,q)$ over the finite field $\mathbb{F}_q$ of odd order $q$, the analogous of the Euclidean distance gives rise to a graph $\mathfrak{G}_{m,q}$ where vertices are the points of $AG(m,q)$ and two vertices are adjacent if their (formal) squared Euclidean distance is a square in $\mathbb{F}_q$ (including the zero). In 2009, Kurz and Meyer made the conjecture that if $m$ is even then $\mathfrak{G}_{m,q}$ is a strongly regular graph. In this paper we prove their conjecture.

The Cheeger constant of a graph is the smallest possible ratio between the size of a subgraph and the size of its boundary. It is well known that this constant must be at least $\frac{λ_1}{2}$, where $λ_1$ is the smallest positive eigenvalue of the Laplacian matrix. The subject of this paper is a conjecture of the authors that for distance-regular graphs the Cheeger constant is at most $λ_1$. In particular, we prove the conjecture for the known infinite families of distance-regular graphs, distance-regular graphs of diameter 2 (the strongly regular graphs), several classes of imprimitive distance-regular graphs, and most distance-regular graphs with small valency.

We introduce a connection between a near-term quantum computing device, specifically a Gaussian boson sampler, and the graph isomorphism problem. We propose a scheme where graphs are encoded into quantum states of light, whose properties are then probed with photon-number-resolving detectors. We prove that the probabilities of different photon-detection events in this setup can be combined to give a complete set of graph invariants. Two graphs are isomorphic if and only if their detection probabilities are equivalent. We present additional ways that the measurement probabilities can be combined or coarse-grained to make experimental tests more amenable. We benchmark these methods with numerical simulations on the Titan supercomputer for several graph families: pairs of isospectral nonisomorphic graphs, isospectral regular graphs, and strongly regular graphs.

We determine (partly by computer search) the chromatic index (edge-chromatic number) of many strongly regular graphs (SRGs), including the SRGs of degree $k \leq 18$ and their complements, the Latin square graphs and their complements, and the triangular graphs and their complements. Moreover, using a recent result of Ferber and Jain it is shown that an SRG of even order $n$, which is not the block graph of a Steiner 2-design or its complement, has chromatic index $k$, when $n$ is big enough. Except for the Petersen graph, all investigated connected SRGs of even order have chromatic index equal to their degree, i.e., they are class 1, and we conjecture that this is the case for all connected SRGs of even order.

The \emph{critical} group of a finite connected graph is an abelian group defined by the Smith normal form of its Laplacian. Let $q$ be a power of a prime and $H$ be a multiplicative subgroup of $K=\mathbb{F}_{q}$. By $\mathrm{Cay}(K,H)$ we denote the Cayley graph on the additive group of $K$ with `connection' set $H$. A strongly regular graph of the form $\mathrm{Cay}(K,H)$ is called a \emph{cyclotomic strongly regular graph}. Let $p$ and $\ell >2$ be primes such that $p$ is primitive $\pmod{\ell}$. We compute the \emph{critical} groups of a family of \emph{cyclotomic strongly regular graphs} for which $q=p^{(\ell-1)t}$ (with $t\in \mathbb{N}$) and $H$ is the unique multiplicative subgroup of order $k=\frac{q-1}{\ell}$. These graphs were first discovered by van Lint and Schrijver in \cite{VS}.

We construct distance-regular graphs, including strongly regular graphs, admitting a transitive action of the Chevalley groups $G_2(4)$ and $G_2(5)$, the orthogonal group $O(7,3)$ and the Tits group $T=$$^2F_4(2)'$. Most of the constructed graphs have more than 1000 vertices, and the number of vertices goes up to 28431. Some of the obtained graphs are new.

It is known that the automorphism group of the elementary abelian $2$-group $Z_2^n$ is isomorphic to the general linear group $GL(n,F_2)$ of degree $n$ over $F_2$. Let $W$ be the collection of permutation matrices of order $n$. It is clear that $W\le GL(n,F_2)$. In virtue of this, we consider the Cayley graph $Cay(Z_2^n,S)$, where $S$ is the union of some orbits under the action of $W$. We call such graphs the orbit Cayley graphs over $Z_2^n$. In this paper, we give eight infinite families of strongly regular graphs among orbit Cayley graphs over $Z_2^n$, in which six families are new as we know. By the way, we formulate the spectra of orbit Cayley graphs as well.