arXiv++ Combinatorics

We discuss recent progress on topological Helly-type theorems and their variants. We provide an overview of two different proof techniques, one based on the nerve lemma, while the other on non-embeddability.

For a set $P$ of $n$ points in $\mathbb R^d$, for any $d\ge 2$, a hyperplane $h$ is called $k$-rich with respect to $P$ if it contains at least $k$ points of $P$. Answering and generalizing a question asked by Peyman Afshani, we show that if the number of $k$-rich hyperplanes in $\mathbb R^d$, $d \geq 3$, is at least $Ω(n^d/k^α+ n/k)$, with a sufficiently large constant of proportionality and with $d\le α< 2d-1$, then there exists a $(d-2)$-flat that contains $Ω(k^{(2d-1-α)/(d-1)})$ points of $P$. We also present upper bound constructions that give instances in which the above lower bound is tight. An extension of our analysis yields similar lower bounds for $k$-rich spheres or $k$-rich flats.

A convex lattice set in $\mathbb{Z}^d$ is the intersection of a convex set in $\mathbb{R}^d$ and the integer lattice $\mathbb{Z}^d$. A well-known theorem of Doignon states that the Helly number of $d$-dimensional convex lattice sets equals $2^d$, while a remarkable theorem of Bárány and Matoušek states that the fractional Helly number is only $d+1$. In this paper we generalize their result to abstract convexity spaces that are equipped with a suitable separation property. We also disprove a conjecture of Bárány and Kalai about an existence of fractional Helly property for a family of solutions of bounded-degree polynomial inequalities.

We prove a generalization of Istvan Fáry's celebrated theorem to higher dimension.

In this paper we study generalizations of classical results on intersection patterns of set systems in $\mathbb{R}^d$, such as the fractional Helly theorem or the $(p,q)$-theorem, in the setting of arbitrary triangulable spaces with a forbidden homological minor. Given a simplicial complex $K$ and an integer $b$, we say that a family $\mathcal{F}$ of subcomplexes of some simplicial complex $\mathcal{U}$ is a \emph{$(K,b)$-free cover} if (i) $K$ is a forbidden homological minor of $\mathcal{U}$, and (ii) the $j$th reduced Betti number $\tildeβ_j(\bigcap_{S\in {\mathcal{G}}}S,\mathbb{Z}_2)$ is strictly less than $b$ for all $0\leq j < \dim K$ and all nonempty subfamilies $\mathcal{G}\subseteq \mathcal{F}$. We show that for every $K$ and $b$, the fractional Helly number of a $(K,b)$-free cover is at most $μ(K)+1$, where $μ(K)$ is the maximum sum of the dimensions of two disjoint faces in~$K$. This implies that the assertion of the $(p,q)$-theorem holds for every $p \ge q > μ(K)$ and every $(K,b)$-free cover $\mathcal{F}$. For $b=1$ and a suitable $K$ this recovers the original $(p,q)$-theorem and its generalization to good covers. Interestingly, our results show that that the range of parameters $(p,q)$ for which the $(p,q)$-theorem holds is independent of $b$. Our proofs use Ramsey-type arguments combined with the notion of stair convexity of Bukh et al. to construct (forbidden) homological minors in cubical complexes.

Let $K$ be a convex body in $\mathbb{R}^n$ (i.e., a compact convex set with nonempty interior). Given a point $p$ in the interior of $K$, a hyperplane $h$ passing through $p$ is called barycentric if $p$ is the barycenter of $K \cap h$. In 1961, Grünbaum raised the question whether, for every $K$, there exists an interior point $p$ through which there are at least $n+1$ distinct barycentric hyperplanes. Two years later, this was seemingly resolved affirmatively by showing that this is the case if $p=p_0$ is the point of maximal depth in $K$. However, while working on a related question, we noticed that one of the auxiliary claims in the proof is incorrect. Here, we provide a counterexample; this re-opens Grünbaum's question. It follows from known results that for $n \geq 2$, there are always at least three distinct barycentric cuts through the point $p_0 \in K$ of maximal depth. Using tools related to Morse theory we are able to improve this bound: four distinct barycentric cuts through $p_0$ are guaranteed if $n \geq 3$.

We prove general topological Radon-type theorems for sets in $\mathbb R^d$ or on a surface. Combined with a recent result of Holmsen and Lee, we also obtain fractional Helly theorem, and consequently the existence of weak $\varepsilon$-nets as well as a $(p,q)$-theorem for those sets. More precisely, given a family $\mathcal F$ of subsets of $\mathbb R^d$, we will measure the homological complexity of $\mathcal F$ by the supremum of the first $\lceil d/2\rceil$ reduced Betti numbers of $\bigcap \mathcal G$ over all nonempty $\mathcal G \subseteq \mathcal F$. We show that if $\mathcal F$ has homological complexity at most $b$, the Radon number of $\mathcal F$ is bounded in terms of $b$ and $d$. In case that $\mathcal F$ lives on a surface and the number of connected components of $\bigcap \mathcal G$ is at most $b$ for any nonempty $\mathcal G \subseteq \mathcal F$, then the Radon number of $\mathcal F$ is bounded by a function depending only on $b$ and the surface itself. For surfaces, if we moreover assume the sets in $\mathcal F$ are open, we show that the fractional Helly number of $\mathcal F$ is linear in $b$. The improvement is based on a recent result of the author and Kalai. Specifically, for $b=1$ we get that the fractional Helly number is at most three, which is optimal. This case further leads to solving a conjecture of Holmsen, Kim, and Lee about an existence of a $(p,q)$-theorem for open subsets of a surface.

Let $\mathcal A=\{A_1,\ldots,A_n\}$ be a family of sets in the plane. For $0 \leq i < n$, denote by $f_i$ the number of subsets $σ$ of $\{1,\ldots,n\}$ of cardinality $i+1$ that satisfy $\bigcap_{i \in σ} A_i \neq \emptyset$. Let $k \geq 2$ be an integer. We prove that if each $k$-wise and $(k+1)$-wise intersection of sets from $\mathcal A$ is empty, or a single point, or both open and path-connected, then $f_{k+1}=0$ implies $f_k \leq cf_{k-1}$ for some positive constant $c$ depending only on $k$. Similarly, let $b \geq 2, k > 2b$ be integers. We prove that if each $k$-wise or $(k+1)$-wise intersection of sets from $\mathcal A$ has at most $b$ path-connected components, which all are open, then $f_{k+1}=0$ implies $f_k \leq cf_{k-1}$ for some positive constant $c$ depending only on $b$ and $k$. These results also extend to two-dimensional compact surfaces.

We prove that for every $d\geq 2$, deciding if a pure, $d$-dimensional, simplicial complex is shellable is NP-hard, hence NP-complete. This resolves a question raised, e.g., by Danaraj and Klee in 1978. Our reduction also yields that for every $d \ge 2$ and $k \ge 0$, deciding if a pure, $d$-dimensional, simplicial complex is $k$-decomposable is NP-hard. For $d \ge 3$, both problems remain NP-hard when restricted to contractible pure $d$-dimensional complexes. Another simple corollary of our result is that it is NP-hard to decide whether a given poset is CL-shellable.

The fact that the complete graph $K_5$ does not embed in the plane has been generalized in two independent directions. On the one hand, the solution of the classical Heawood problem for graphs on surfaces established that the complete graph $K_n$ embeds in a closed surface $M$ (other than the Klein bottle) if and only if $(n-3)(n-4)\leq 6b_1(M)$, where $b_1(M)$ is the first $\mathbb Z_2$-Betti number of $M$. On the other hand, van Kampen and Flores proved that the $k$-skeleton of the $n$-dimensional simplex (the higher-dimensional analogue of $K_{n+1}$) embeds in $\mathbb R^{2k}$ if and only if~$n \le 2k+1$. Two decades ago, Kühnel conjectured that the $k$-skeleton of the $n$-simplex embeds in a compact, $(k-1)$-connected $2k$-manifold with $k$th $\mathbb Z_2$-Betti number $b_k$ only if the following generalized Heawood inequality holds: $\binom{n-k-1}{k+1} \le \binom{2k+1}{k+1}b_k$. This is a common generalization of the case of graphs on surfaces as well as the van Kampen--Flores theorem (the special cases $k=1$ and $b_k=0$, respectively), and also closely related to the theory of face numbers of triangulated manifolds. In the spirit of Kühnel's conjecture, we prove that if the $k$-skeleton of the $n$-simplex embeds in a $2k$-manifold with $k$th $\mathbb Z_2$-Betti number $b_k$, then $n \le 2b_k\binom{2k+2}{k} + 2k + 4$. This bound is weaker than the generalized Heawood inequality, but does not require the assumption that $M$ is $(k-1)$-connected. Our results generalize to maps without $q$-covered points, in the spirit of Tverberg's theorem, for $q$ a prime power. Our proof uses a result of Volovikov about maps that satisfy a certain homological triviality condition.

We reprove the strong Hanani-Tutte theorem on the projective plane. In contrast to the previous proof by Pelsmajer, Schaefer and Stasi, our method is constructive and does not rely on the characterization of forbidden minors, which gives hope to extend it to other surfaces. Moreover, our approach can be used to provide an efficient algorithm turning a Hanani-Tutte drawing on the projective plane into an embedding.

The colorful simplicial depth of a collection of d+1 finite sets of points in Euclidean d-space is the number of choices of a point from each set such that the origin is contained in their convex hull. We use methods from combinatorial topology to prove a tight upper bound on the colorful simplicial depth. This implies a conjecture of Deza et al. (2006). Furthermore, we introduce colorful Gale transforms as a bridge between colorful configurations and Minkowski sums. Our colorful upper bound then yields a tight upper bound on the number of totally mixed facets of certain Minkowski sums of simplices. This resolves a conjecture of Burton (2003) in the theory of normal surfaces.

A $d$-dimensional simplex $S$ is called a $k$-reptile (or a $k$-reptile simplex) if it can be tiled by $k$ simplices with disjoint interiors that are all mutually congruent and similar to $S$. For $d=2$, triangular $k$-reptiles exist for all $k$ of the form $a^2, 3a^2$ or $a^2 + b^2$ and they have been completely characterized by Snover, Waiveris, and Williams. On the other hand, the only $k$-reptile simplices that are known for $d \ge 3$, have $k = m^d$, where $m$ is a positive integer. We substantially simplify the proof by Matoušek and the second author that for $d=3$, $k$-reptile tetrahedra can exist only for $k=m^3$. We then prove a weaker analogue of this result for $d=4$ by showing that four-dimensional $k$-reptile simplices can exist only for $k=m^2$.

We estimate the selection constant in the following geometric selection theorem by Pach: For every positive integer $d$ there is a constant $c_d > 0$ such that whenever $X_1,..., X_{d+1}$ are $n$-element subsets of $\mathbb{R}^d$, then we can find a point $\mathbf{p} \in \mathbb{R}^d$ and subsets $Y_i \subseteq X_i$ for every $i \in [d+1]$, each of size at least $c_d n$, such that $\mathbf{p}$ belongs to all {\em rainbow} $d$-simplices determined by $Y_1,..., Y_{d+1}$, that is, simplices with one vertex in each $Y_i$. We show a super-exponentially decreasing upper bound $c_d\leq e^{-(1/2-o(1))(d \ln d)}$. The ideas used in the proof of the upper bound also help us prove Pach's theorem with $c_d \geq 2^{-2^{d^2 + O(d)}}$, which is a lower bound doubly exponentially decreasing in $d$ (up to some polynomial in the exponent). For comparison, Pach's original approach yields a triply exponentially decreasing lower bound. On the other hand, Fox, Pach, and Suk recently obtained a hypergraph density result implying a proof of Pach's theorem with $c_d \geq2^{-O(d^2\log d)}$. In our construction for the upper bound, we use the fact that the minimum solid angle of every $d$-simplex is super-exponentially small. This fact was previously unknown and might be of independent interest. For the lower bound, we improve the "separation" part of the argument by showing that in one of the key steps only $d+1$ separations are necessary, compared to $2^d$ separations in the original proof. We also provide a measure version of Pach's theorem.

We show that very weak topological assumptions are enough to ensure the existence of a Helly-type theorem. More precisely, we show that for any non-negative integers $b$ and $d$ there exists an integer $h(b,d)$ such that the following holds. If $\mathcal F$ is a finite family of subsets of $\mathbb R^d$ such that $\tildeβ_i\left(\bigcap\mathcal G\right) \le b$ for any $\mathcal G \subsetneq \mathcal F$ and every $0 \le i \le \lceil d/2 \rceil-1$ then $\mathcal F$ has Helly number at most $h(b,d)$. Here $\tildeβ_i$ denotes the reduced $\mathbb Z_2$-Betti numbers (with singular homology). These topological conditions are sharp: not controlling any of these $\lceil d/2 \rceil$ first Betti numbers allow for families with unbounded Helly number. Our proofs combine homological non-embeddability results with a Ramsey-based approach to build, given an arbitrary simplicial complex $K$, some well-behaved chain map $C_*(K) \to C_*(\mathbb R^d)$.