arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $0 < α\leq 1/2$. We say that a finite point set $P$ in $\mathbb{R}^d$ is $α$-split by a hyperplane $h$ if each of the closed half-spaces determined by $h$, contains at least $α|P|$ of the points of $P$. We further say $P$ is $α$-split by a $k$-dimensional flat $τ$ if $P$ is $α$-split by any hyperplane through $τ$. In the standard notation (which coincides with Tukey depth for $k= 0$), the $k$-flat $τ$ has depth $α$ with respect to $P$. We establish interesting Helly-type theorems for splitting families of finite point sets in $\mathbb{R}^d$. Unlike the classical sufficient Helly-type criteria for transversals to families of compact convex sets, which exist only for point and hyperplanes, our results extend to splitting families of point sets by collections of $k$-flats of arbitrary dimensionality $ 0 \leq k \leq d-1$.

We consider $k$-graphs, $\mathcal{F}\subset \binom{[n]}{k}$, $k\geq 3$. A $k$-graph is called intersecting if any two of its edges have non-empty intersection. It is called a star if all its edges share a common vertex. The $k$-graph $\mathcal{F}$ is called Helly if all its intersecting subfamilies are stars. If the same is required only for subfamilies consisting of three edges, it is called triangle-free. It is well known that for $n\geq 3k/2$, the full star is the unique largest triangle-free family whence the largest Helly family as well. In 1984 Tuza proved the best possible bound $|\mathcal{F}|\leq \binom{n-k-1}{k-1}+\binom{n-2}{k-2}+1$ for Helly families that are not stars, albeit only for some unspecified $n>n_0(k)$. The aim of this paper is twofold. First we establish the same bound for $n>2k$. Second we show that for $n>12k^2$ the same upper bound holds for triangle-free families. It is shown as well that it is not true for $2k<n\leq 3k-4$.

In any fixed dimension, consider a finite collection of sets, each consisting of exactly two disjoint, closed, convex pieces. We show that to guarantee the intersection of the whole collection also consists of exactly two such convex pieces, it suffices to verify the same two-piece structure for all intersections of some subfamilies of intermediate size, thus answering a question of Gil Kalai.

In 2008, Halman proved a discrete Helly-type theorem for axis-parallel boxes in $\mathbb R^d$. Very recently, this result was extended to the $(p,q)$ setting with $p \geq q \geq d+1$ by Edwards and Soberón, and subsequently to the case $p \geq q \geq 2$ by Gangopadhyay, Polyanskii, and the author of this paper. In this paper, we obtain improved bounds for the $(p,q)$ problem in the case $q=2$ and $d=2$. More precisely, our main result asserts that for any integer $p \geq 2$, any set $P \subseteq \mathbb R^2$, and any finite family $\mathcal B$ of axis-parallel rectangles in $\mathbb R^2$ such that every rectangle contains a point of $P$, if among every $p$ rectangles there exist two whose intersection contains a point of $P$, then there exists a subset $S \subseteq P$ of size at most $O\!\bigl( (p \log \log p)^2 \bigr)$ such that every rectangle contains a point of $S$. Moreover, when $p=2$, the size of $S$ can be bounded by $8$.

We discuss recent progress on topological Helly-type theorems and their variants. We provide an overview of two different proof techniques, one based on the nerve lemma, while the other on non-embeddability.

In 2008, Halman showed that for any finite set $P\subset \mathbb R^d$ and any finite family $\mathcal{B}$ of axis-parallel boxes in $\mathbb{R}^d$, if the intersection of $P$ and any subfamily $\mathcal{B}' \subseteq\mathcal{B}$ of size at most $2d$ is non-empty, then the intersection of $P$ and $\mathcal{B}$ is also non-empty. Very recently Edwards and Soberón initiated the study of quantitative colorful version for $2d$ families, $(p,q)$-type variation for $p\geq q\geq d+1$, and other extensions of this Helly-type result by Halman. In this paper, we study the quantitative colorful Halman problem for $2d-1$ families as well its $(p,q)$-type variation for $p\geq q\geq 2$. Specifically, our main result asserts that for any finite set $P$ and finite families of boxes $\mathcal{B}_1,\dots,\mathcal{B}_{2d-1}$ in $\mathbb R^d$, where $d\geq 2$, if every transversal $\mathcal{B}$ for the families has an intersection $\bigcap \mathcal{B}$ containing at least $n$ points of $P$, then there exist $j\in[2d-1]$ and a subset of $P$ of size at most \[ 2n+\Big\lfloor \frac{n-1}{d \cdot 2^{d-1}} \Big\rfloor, \] such that each box of $\mathcal{B}_j$ contains at least $n$ points of this subset.

We present a unified approach to prove Helly-type theorems for monotone properties of boxes, such as having large volume or containing points from a given set. As a corollary, we obtain new proofs for several earlier results regarding specific monotone properties. Our results generalise to $H$-convex sets as well.

A separated $d$-interval is defined as a disjoint union of $d$ convex sets from the real line $\mathbb R$. In this paper, we establish a series of Helly-type theorems for convexity spaces derived from separated $d$-intervals. Our results encompass the Radon number, Helly number, colorful Helly number, fractional Helly number, colorful fractional Helly theorem, $(p,q)$ theorem, and two kinds of colorful $(p,q)$ theorems for these convexity spaces. The primary tools employed in our proofs involve simplicial complexes and collapsibility.

This paper proves a 2017 conjecture of De Loera, La Haye, Oliveros, and Roldán-Pensado that the "prime grid" $\big\{(p,q) \in \mathbb{Z}^2 : \text{$p$ and $q$ are prime}\big\} \subseteq \mathbb{R}^2$ contains empty polygons with arbitrarily many vertices. This implies that no Helly-type theorem is true for the prime grid.

We obtain three Helly-type results. First, we establish a Quantitative Colorful Helly-type theorem with the optimal Helly number \(2d\) concerning the diameter of the intersection of a family of convex bodies. Second, we prove a Quantitative Helly-type theorem with the optimal Helly number \(2d+1\) for the pointwise minimum of logarithmically concave functions. Finally, we present a colorful version of the latter result with Helly number (number of color classes) \(3d+1\); however, we have no reason to believe that this bound is sharp.

Assume two finite families $\mathcal A$ and $\mathcal B$ of convex sets in $\mathbb{R}^3$ have the property that $A\cap B\ne \emptyset$ for every $A \in \mathcal A$ and $B\in \mathcal B$. Is there a constant $γ>0$ (independent of $\mathcal A$ and $\mathcal B$) such that there is a line intersecting $γ|\mathcal A|$ sets in $\mathcal A$ or $γ|\mathcal B|$ sets in $\mathcal B$? This is an intriguing Helly-type question from a paper by Martínez, Roldan and Rubin. We confirm this in the special case when all sets in $\mathcal A$ lie in parallel planes and all sets in $\mathcal B$ lie in parallel planes; in fact, all sets from one of the two families has a line transversal.

We prove the following colorful Helly-type result: Fix $k \in [d-1]$. Assume $\mathcal{A}_1, \dots, \mathcal{A}_{d+(d-k)+1}$ are finite sets (colors) of nonzero vectors in $\R^d$. If for every rainbow sub-selection $R$ from these sets of size at most $\max \{d+1, 2(d-k+1)\}$, the system $\langle {a},{x} \rangle \leq 0,\; a \in R$ has at least $k$ linearly independent solutions, then at least one of the systems $\langle {a},{x} \rangle \leq 0,\; a \in \mathcal{A}_i,$ $i \in [d+(d-k)+1]$ has at least $k$ linearly independent solutions. A \emph{rainbow sub-selection} from several sets refers to choosing at most one element from each set (color). The Helly number $\max \{d+1, 2(d-k+1)\}$ and the number of colors $d+(d-k)+1$ are optimal. Our key observation is a certain colorful Carathéodory-type result for positive bases.

Hadwiger's theorem is a Helly-type theorem involving common transversals to families of convex sets instead of common intersections. Subsequently, Pollack and Wenger identified a necessary and sufficient condition, called a consistent $k$-ordering, for the existence of a hyperplane transversal for sets in $\mathbb{R}^d$. We obtain a quantitative generalization of Hadwiger's theorem in $\mathbb{R}^2$, showing that compact convex sets in $\mathbb{R}^2$ with a quantitative version of consistent ordering have a transversal satisfying quantitative requirements. Our proof generalizes the methods in Wenger's proof of Hadwiger's theorem in $\mathbb{R}^2$. We also prove colorful versions of our results.

We propose a combinatorial framework to analyze quantitative Helly-type questions. Using this framework, we prove a Quantitative Fractional Helly Theorem with Fractional Helly Number 3d and a stability version of the Quantitative Helly Theorem of Bárány, Katchalski, and Pach.

Let $H$ be a complete $r$-uniform hypergraph such that two vertices are marked in each edge as its `boundary' vertices. A linear ordering of the vertex set of $H$ is called an {\em agreeing linear order}, provided all vertices of each edge of $H$ lie between its two boundary vertices. We prove the following Helly-type theorem: if there is an {agreeing linear order} on the vertex set of every subhypergraph of $H$ with at most $2r-2$ vertices, then there is an agreeing linear order on the vertex set of $H$. We also show that the constant $2r-2$ cannot be reduced in the theorem. The case $r=3$ of the theorem has particular interest in the axiomatic theory of betweenness. Similar results are obtained for further $r$-uniform hypergraphs ($r\geq 3$), where one or two vertices are marked in each edge, and the linear orders need to satisfy various rules of agreement. In one of the cases we prove that no such Helly-type statement holds.

We prove a colorful extension of a Helly-type theorem by Danzer and Grünbaum (Combinatorica, 1982) concerning two-piercing families of axis-parallel boxes in $\mathbb{R}^d$. We also show that our result is tight by constructing extremal families that achieve the bound. Related work includes a graph-theoretic proof of the original theorem by Pendavingh, Puite, and Woeginger (Discrete Applied Mathematics, 2008), and a two-piercing result for lower-dimensional boxes by Baños and Oliveros (Acta Mathematica Hungarica, 2018).

Recently geometric hypergraphs that can be defined by intersections of pseudohalfplanes with a finite point set were defined in a purely combinatorial way. This led to extensions of earlier results about points and halfplanes to pseudohalfplanes, including polychromatic colorings and discrete Helly-type theorems about pseudohalfplanes. Here we continue this line of research and introduce the notion of convex sets of such pseudohalfplane hypergraphs. In this context we prove several results corresponding to classical results about convexity, namely Helly's Theorem, Carathéodory's Theorem, Kirchberger's Theorem, Separation Theorem, Radon's Theorem and the Cup-Cap Theorem. These results imply the respective results about pseudoconvex sets in the plane defined using pseudohalfplanes. It turns out that most of our results can be also proved using oriented matroids and topological affine planes (TAPs) but our approach is different from both of them. Compared to oriented matroids, our theory is based on a linear ordering of the vertex set which makes our definitions and proofs quite different and perhaps more elementary. Compared to TAPs, which are continuous objects, our proofs are purely combinatorial and again quite different in flavor. Altogether, we believe that our new approach can further our understanding of these fundamental convexity results.

Given an $r$-edge-coloured complete graph $K_n$, how many monochromatic connected components does one need in order to cover its vertex set? This natural question is a well-known essentially equivalent formulation of the classical Ryser's conjecture which, despite a lot of attention over the last 50 years, still remains open. A number of recent papers consider a sparse random analogue of this question, asking for the minimum number of monochromatic components needed to cover the vertex set of an $r$-edge-coloured random graph $\mathcal{G}(n,p)$. Recently, Bucić, Korándi and Sudakov established a connection between this problem and a certain Helly-type local to global question for hypergraphs raised about 30 years ago by Erdős, Hajnal and Tuza. We identify a modified version of the hypergraph problem which controls the answer to the problem of covering random graphs with monochromatic components more precisely. To showcase the power of our approach, we essentially resolve the $3$-colour case by showing that $(\log n / n)^{1/4}$ is a threshold at which point three monochromatic components are needed to cover all vertices of a $3$-edge-coloured random graph, answering a question posed by Kohayakawa, Mendonça, Mota and Schülke. Our approach also allows us to determine the answer in the general $r$-edge coloured instance of the problem, up to lower order terms, around the point when it first becomes bounded, answering a question of Bucić, Korándi and Sudakov.

In this paper, we present a variety of problems in the interface between combinatorics and geometry around the theorems of Helly, Radon, Carathéodory, and Tverberg. Through these problems we describe the fascinating area of Helly-type theorems, and explain some of its main themes and goals.

We prove discrete Helly-type theorems for pseudohalfplanes, which extend recent results of Jensen, Joshi and Ray about halfplanes. Among others we show that given a family of pseudohalfplanes $\cal H$ and a set of points $P$, if every triple of pseudohalfplanes has a common point in $P$ then there exists a set of at most two points that hits every pseudohalfplane of $\cal H$. We also prove that if every triple of points of $P$ is contained in a pseudohalfplane of $\cal H$ then there are two pseudohalfplanes of $\cal H$ that cover all points of $P$. To prove our results we regard pseudohalfplane hypergraphs, define their extremal vertices and show that these behave in many ways as points on the boundary of the convex hull of a set of points. Our methods are purely combinatorial. In addition we determine the maximal possible chromatic number of the regarded hypergraph families.