arXiv++ Combinatorics

The scramble number of a graph, a natural generalization of bramble number, is an invariant recently developed to study chip-firing games and graph gonality. We introduce the carton number of a graph, defined to be the minimum size of a maximum order scramble, to study the computational complexity of scramble number. We show that there exist graphs with carton number exponential in the size of the graph, proving that scrambles are not valid NP certificates. We characterize families of graphs whose scramble number and gonality can be constant-factor approximated in polynomial time and show that the disjoint version of scramble number is fixed parameter tractable. Lastly, we find that vertex congestion is an upper bound on screewidth and thus scramble number, leading to a new proof of the best known bound on the treewidth of line graphs and a bound on the scramble number of planar graphs with bounded degree.

The goal of local certification is to locally convince the vertices of a graph $G$ that $G$ satisfies a given property. A prover assigns short certificates to the vertices of the graph, then the vertices are allowed to check their certificates and the certificates of their neighbors, and based only on this local view, they must decide whether $G$ satisfies the given property. If the graph indeed satisfies the property, all vertices must accept the instance, and otherwise at least one vertex must reject the instance (for any possible assignment of certificates). The goal is to minimize the size of the certificates. In this paper we study the local certification of geometric and topological graph classes. While it is known that in $n$-vertex graphs, planarity can be certified locally with certificates of size $O(\log n)$, we show that several closely related graph classes require certificates of size $Ω(n)$. This includes penny graphs, unit-distance graphs, (induced) subgraphs of the square grid, 1-planar graphs, and unit-square graphs. These bounds are tight up to a constant factor and give the first known examples of hereditary (and even monotone) graph classes for which the certificates must have linear size. For unit-disk graphs we obtain a lower bound of $Ω(n^{1-δ})$ for any $δ>0$ on the size of the certificates, and an upper bound of $O(n \log n)$. The lower bounds are obtained by proving rigidity properties of the considered graphs, which might be of independent interest.

For every $r\ge13$, we show every 1-planar graph $G$ with $Δ(G)\le r$ has an equitable $r$-coloring.

We introduce the Density Formula for (topological) drawings of graphs in the plane or on the sphere, which relates the number of edges, vertices, crossings, and sizes of cells in the drawing. We demonstrate its capability by providing several applications: we prove tight upper bounds on the edge density of various beyond-planar graph classes, including so-called $k$-planar graphs with $k=1,2$, fan-crossing / fan-planar graphs, $k$-bend RAC-graphs with $k=0,1,2$, quasiplanar graphs, and $k^+$-real face graphs. In some cases ($1$-bend and $2$-bend RAC-graphs and fan-crossing / fan-planar graphs), we thereby obtain the first tight upper bounds on the edge density of the respective graph classes. In other cases, we give new streamlined and significantly shorter proofs for bounds that were already known in the literature. Thanks to the Density Formula, all of our proofs are mostly elementary counting and mostly circumvent the typical intricate case analysis found in earlier proofs. Further, in some cases (simple and non-homotopic quasiplanar graphs), our alternative proofs using the Density Formula lead to the first tight lower bound examples.

In this paper we use theoretical and computational tools to continue our investigation of $K_2$-hamiltonian graphs, that is, graphs in which the removal of any pair of adjacent vertices yields a hamiltonian graph, and their interplay with $K_1$-hamiltonian graphs, that is, graphs in which every vertex-deleted subgraph is hamiltonian. Perhaps surprisingly, there exist graphs that are both $K_1$- and $K_2$-hamiltonian, yet non-hamiltonian, for example, the Petersen graph. Grünbaum conjectured that every planar $K_1$-hamiltonian graph must itself be hamiltonian; Thomassen disproved this conjecture. Here we show that even planar graphs that are both $K_1$- and $K_2$-hamiltonian need not be hamiltonian, and that the number of such graphs grows at least exponentially. Motivated by results of Aldred, McKay, and Wormald, we determine for every integer $n$ that is not 14 or 17 whether there exists a $K_2$-hypohamiltonian, that is, non-hamiltonian and $K_2$-hamiltonian, graph of order $n$, and characterise all orders for which such cubic graphs and such snarks exist. We also describe the smallest cubic planar graph which is $K_2$-hypohamiltonian, as well as the smallest planar $K_2$-hypohamiltonian graph of girth $5$. We conclude with open problems and by correcting two inaccuracies from the first article.

A graph is $(\mathcal{I}, \mathcal{F})$-colorable if its vertex set can be partitioned into two subsets, one of which is an independent set, and the other induces a forest. In this paper, we prove that every planar graph without $5^{-}$-cycles at distance less than $3$ is $(\mathcal{I}, \mathcal{F})$-colorable.

We show that $\limsup |E(G)|/|V(G)| = 2.5$ over all $4$-critical planar graphs $G$, answering a question of Grünbaum from 1988.

Sprout is a two-player pen and paper game which starts with $n$ vertices, and the players take turns to join two pre-existing dots by a subdivided edge while keeping the graph sub-cubic planar at all times. The first player not being able to move loses. A major conjecture claims that Player 1 has a winning strategy if and only if $n \equiv 3,4,5$ ($\bmod~6$). The conjecture is verified until $44$, and a few isolated values of $n$, usually with the help of a computer. However, to the best of our understanding, not too much progress could be made towards finding a theoretical proof of the conjecture till now. In this article, we try to take a bottom-up approach and start building a theory around the problem. We start by expanding a related game called Brussels Sprout (where dots are replaced by crosses) introduced by Conway, possibly to help the understanding of Sprout. In particular, we introduce and study a generalized version of Brussels Sprout where crosses are replaced by a dot having an arbitrary number of ``partial edges'' (say, general cross) coming out, and planar graphs are replaced by any (pre-decided) hereditary class of graphs. We study the game for forests, graphs on surfaces, and sparse planar graphs. We also do a nimber characterization of the game when the hereditary class is taken to be triangle-free planar graphs, and we have started the game with two arbitrary generalized crosses. Moreover, while studying this particular case, we naturally stumble upon a circular version of the same game and solve a difficult nimber characterization using the method of structural induction. The above mentioned proof may potentially be one approach to solving the Sprout conjecture.

A vertex coloring of a graph $G$ is called a 2-distance coloring if any two vertices at distance at most $2$ from each other receive different colors. Let $G$ be a planar graph with girth at least $5$. We prove that $G$ admits a $2$-distance coloring with $Δ+4$ colors if $Δ\geq 22$.

Weak diameter coloring of graphs recently attracted attention partially due to its connection to asymptotic dimension of metric spaces. We consider weak diameter list-coloring of graphs in this paper. Dvořák and Norin proved that graphs with bounded Euler genus are 3-choosable with bounded weak diameter. In this paper, we extend their result by showing that for every graph $H$, $H$-minor free graphs are 3-choosable with bounded weak diameter. The upper bound 3 is optimal and it strengthens an earlier result for non-list-coloring $H$-minor free graphs with bounded weak diameter. As a corollary, $H$-minor free graphs with bounded maximum degree are 3-choosable with bounded clustering, strengthening an earlier result for non-list-coloring. When $H$ is planar, we prove a much stronger result: for every 2-list-assignment $L$ of an $H$-minor free graph, every precoloring with bounded weak diameter can be extended to an $L$-coloring with bounded weak diameter. As a corollary, for any planar graph $H$ and $H$-minor free graph $G$, there are exponentially many list-colorings of $G$ with bounded weak diameter (and with bounded clustering if $G$ also has bounded maximum degree); and every graph with bounded layered tree-width and bounded maximum degree has exponentially many 3-colorings with bounded clustering. We also show that the aforementioned results for list-coloring cannot be extended to odd minor free graphs by showing that some bipartite graphs with maximum degree $Δ$ are $k$-choosable with bounded weak diameter only when $k=Ω(\logΔ/\log\logΔ)$. On the other hand, we show that odd $H$-minor graphs are 3-colorable with bounded weak diameter, implying an earlier result about clustered coloring of odd $H$-minor free graphs with bounded maximum degree.

A vertex coloring of a graph G is called a 2-distance coloring if any two vertices at a distance at most 2 from each other receive different colors. Suppose that G is a planar graph with a maximum degree at most 5. We prove that G admits a 2-distance 16 coloring, which improves the result given by Hou et al. (Graphs and Combinatorics 39:20, 2023).

We prove that a connected, locally finite, quasi-transitive graph which is quasi-isometric to a planar graph is necessarily accessible. This leads to a complete classification of the finitely generated groups which are quasi-isometric to planar graphs. In particular, such a group is virtually a free product of free and surface groups, and thus virtually admits a planar Cayley graph.

The well known Wagner's theorem states that a graph is a planar graph if and only if it is $K_5$-minor-free and $K_{3,3}$-minor-free. Denote by $AT(G)$ the Alon-Tarsi number of a graph $G$. We show that for any $K_{3,3}$-minor-free graph $G$, $AT(G)\le 5$, there exists a matching $M$ and a forest $F$ such that $AT(G-M)\le 4$ and $AT(G-E(F))\le 3$, extending the result on the Alon-Tarsi number of $K_5$-minor-free graphs due to Abe, Kim and Ozeki.

The $\textit{planar Turán number}$ $\textrm{ex}_{\mathcal P}(n,H)$ of a graph $H$ is the maximum number of edges in an $n$-vertex planar graph without $H$ as a subgraph. Let $C_k$ denote the cycle of length $k$. The planar Turán number $\textrm{ex}_{\mathcal P}(n,C_k)$ is known for $k\le 7$. We show that dense planar graphs with a certain connectivity property (known as circuit graphs) contain large near triangulations, and we use this result to obtain consequences for planar Turán numbers. In particular, we prove that there is a constant $D$ so that $\textrm{ex}_{\mathcal P}(n,C_k) \le 3n - 6 - Dn/k^{\log_2^3}$ for all $k, n\ge 4$. When $k \ge 11$ this bound is tight up to the constant $D$ and proves a conjecture of Cranston, Lidický, Liu, and Shantanam.

In the flexible list coloring problem, we consider a graph $G$ and a color list assignment $L$ on $G$, as well as a subset $U \subseteq V(G)$ for which each $u \in U$ has a preferred color $p(u) \in L(u)$. Our goal is to find a proper $L$-coloring $φ$ of $G$ such that $φ(u) = p(u)$ for at least $ε|U|$ vertices $u \in U$. We say that $G$ is $ε$-flexibly $k$-choosable if for every $k$-size list assignment $L$ on $G$ and every subset of vertices with coloring preferences, $G$ has a proper $L$-coloring that satisfies an $ε$ proportion of these coloring preferences. Dvořák, Norin, and Postle [Journal of Graph Theory, 2019] asked whether every $d$-degenerate graph is $ε$-flexibly $(d+1)$-choosable for some constant $ε= ε(d) > 0$. In this paper, we prove that there exists a constant $ε> 0$ such that every graph with maximum average degree less than $3$ is $ε$-flexibly $3$-choosable, which gives a large class of $2$-degenerate graphs which are $ε$-flexibly $(d+1)$-choosable. In particular, our results imply a theorem of Dvořák, Masařík, Musílek, and Pangrác [Journal of Graph Theory, 2020] stating that every planar graph of girth $6$ is $ε$-flexibly $3$-choosable for some constant $ε> 0$. To prove our result, we generalize the existing reducible subgraph framework traditionally used for flexible list coloring to allow reducible subgraphs of arbitrarily large order.

We propose efficient algorithms for enumerating the notorious combinatorial structures of maximal planar graphs, called canonical orderings and Schnyder woods, and the related classical graph drawings by de Fraysseix, Pach, and Pollack [Combinatorica, 1990] and by Schnyder [SODA, 1990], called canonical drawings and Schnyder drawings, respectively. To this aim (i) we devise an algorithm for enumerating special $e$-bipolar orientations of maximal planar graphs, called canonical orientations; (ii) we establish bijections between canonical orientations and canonical drawings, and between canonical orientations and Schnyder drawings; and (iii) we exploit the known correspondence between canonical orientations and canonical orderings, and the known bijection between canonical orientations and Schnyder woods. All our enumeration algorithms have $O(n)$ setup time, space usage, and delay between any two consecutively listed outputs, for an $n$-vertex maximal planar graph.

We show that there exists a constant $c > 0$ such that if $G$ is a planar graph with 5-correspondence assignment $(L,M)$, then $G$ has at least $2^{c\cdot v(G)}$ distinct $(L,M)$-colourings. This confirms a conjecture of Langhede and Thomassen. More broadly, we introduce a general method showing how hyperbolicity theorems for certain families of critical graphs can be used to derive lower bounds on the number of colourings of the associated class of planar graphs. Hence our main result follows from this method plus a technical theorem (that we proved in a previous paper) involving the hyperbolicity of graphs critical for $5$-correspondence colouring. We further demonstrate our method in the case of counting 3-correspondence colourings of planar graphs of girth at least five. Finally, we use these theorems to show analogous results hold in the case of counting 5-correspondence colourings of locally planar graphs, and counting 3-correspondence colourings of locally planar graphs of girth at least five.

This is the first part of three episodes to demonstrate a renewal approach for proving the Four Color Theorem without checking by a computer. The second and the third episodes have subtitles: ``R/G/B Kempe chains in an extremum non-4-colorable MPG'' and ``Diamond routes, canal lines and $Σ$-adjustments,'' where R/G/B stand for red, green and blue colors to paint on edges and an MPG stands for a maximal planar graph. In this first part, we introduce R/G/B-tilings as well as their tri-coexisting version RGB-tiling on an MPG or a semi-MPG. We associate these four kinds of edge-colorings with 4-colorings by 1/2/3/4 on vertices in MPS's or semi-MPG's. Several basic properties for tilings on MPG's and semi-MPG's are developed. Especially the idea of R/G/B-canal lines, as well as canal system, is a cornerstone. This work started on May 31, 2018 and was first announced by the author~\cite{Liu2020} at the Institute of Mathematics, Academia Sinica, Taipei, Taiwan, on Jan.\ 22, 2020, when the pandemic just occurred.

Continuous spline functions are defined as piecewise polynomials on the faces of a polyhedral complex that agree on the intersections of two faces. Splines are used in approximation theory and numerical analysis, with applications in data interpolation, to create smooth curves in computer graphics and to find numerical solutions to partial differential equations. Gilbert, Tymoczko, and Viel generalized the classical splines combinatorially and algebraically: a generalized spline is a vertex labeling of a graph $G$ by elements of the ring so that the difference between the labels of any two adjacent vertices lies in the ideal generated by the corresponding edge label. We study the generalized splines on the planar graphs whose edges are labeled by two-variable polynomials of the form $(ax+by+c)^2$ and whose vertices are labeled by polynomials of degree at most two. In this paper we address the upper-bound conjecture for the dimension of degree-2 splines of smoothness 1. The dimension is expressed in terms of the rank of the extended cycle basis matrix. We also provide a combinatorial algorithm on graphs to compute the rank by contracting certain subgraphs.

The problem of graph reconstruction has been studied in its various forms over the years. In particular, the Reconstruction Conjecture, proposed by Ulam and Kelly in 1942, has attracted much research attention and yet remains one of the foremost unsolved problems in graph theory. Recently, Bastide, Cook, Erickson, Groenland, Kreveld, Mannens, and Vermeulen proposed a new model of partial information, where we are given the set of connected triples T_3, which is the set of 3-subsets of the vertex set that induce connected subgraphs. They proved that reconstruction is unique within the class of triangle-free graphs, 2-connected outerplanar graphs, and maximal planar graphs. They also showed that almost every graph can be uniquely reconstructed from their connected triples. However, little is known about other classes of non-triangle-free graphs within which reconstruction can occur uniquely, nor do we understand what kind of graphs can be uniquely reconstructed from their connected triples without assuming anything about the classes of graphs to which they belong. The main result of this paper is a complete characterization of all graphs that can be uniquely reconstructed from their connected triples T_3. We also show that reconstruction from T_3 is unique within the class of regular planar graphs, 5-connected planar graphs, certain strongly regular graphs, and complete multi-partite graphs, whereas it is not unique for the class of k-connected planar graphs with k less or equal to 4, Eulerian graphs, or Hamiltonian graphs.