arXiv++ Combinatorics

We use the model theoretic notion of coheir to give short proofs of old and new theorems in Ramsey Theory. As an illustration we start from Ramsey's theorem itself. Then we prove Hindman's theorem and the Hales-Jewett theorem. Finally, we prove two Ramsey theoretic principles that have among their consequences partition theorems of Carlson and of Gowers.

Given a class $\mathcal{C}$ of graphs and a fixed graph $H$, the online Ramsey game for $H$ on $\mathcal C$ is a game between two players Builder and Painter as follows: an unbounded set of vertices is given as an initial state, and on each turn Builder introduces a new edge with the constraint that the resulting graph must be in $\mathcal C$, and Painter colors the new edge either red or blue. Builder wins the game if Painter is forced to make a monochromatic copy of $H$ at some point in the game. Otherwise, Painter can avoid creating a monochromatic copy of $H$ forever, and we say Painter wins the game. We initiate the study of characterizing the graphs $F$ such that for a given graph $H$, Painter wins the online Ramsey game for $H$ on $F$-free graphs. We characterize all graphs $F$ such that Painter wins the online Ramsey game for $C_3$ on the class of $F$-free graphs, except when $F$ is one particular graph. We also show that Painter wins the online Ramsey game for $C_3$ on the class of $K_4$-minor-free graphs, extending a result by Grytczuk, Hałuszczak, and Kierstead.

Harary's conjecture $r(C_3,G)\leq 2q+1$ for every isolated-free graph G with $q$ edges was proved independently by Sidorenko and Goddard and Klietman. In this paper instead of $C_3$ we consider $K_{2,k}$ and seek a sharp upper bound for $r(K_{2,k},G)$ over all graphs $G$ with $q$ edges. More specifically if $q\geq 2$, we will show that $r(C_4,G)\leq kq+1$ and that equality holds if $G \cong qK_2$ or $K_3$. Using this we will generalize this result for $r(K_{2,k},G)$ when $k>2$. We will also show that for every graph $G$ with $q \geq 2$ edges and with no isolated vertices, $r(C_4, G) \leq 2p+ q - 2$ where $p=|V(G)|$ and that equality holds if $G \cong K_3$.

This is a supplement for "Pearls in graph theory" -- a textbook written by Nora Hartsfield and Gerhard Ringel. We discuss the following topics: Ramsey theory, Probabilistic method, Deletion-contraction formulas, Matrix theorem, Graph-polynomials, Generating functions, Minimum spanning trees, Marriage theorem and its relatives, Toroidal graphs, Rado graph, Rewriting systems.

We consider unavoidable chromatic patterns in $2$-colorings of the edges of the complete graph. Several such problems are explored being a junction point between Ramsey theory, extremal graph theory (Turán type problems), zero-sum Ramsey theory, and interpolation theorems in graph theory. A role-model of these problems is the following: Let $G$ be a graph with $e(G)$ edges. We say that $G$ is omnitonal if there exists a function ${\rm ot}(n,G)$ such that the following holds true for $n$ sufficiently large: For any $2$-coloring $f: E(K_n) \to \{red, blue \}$ such that there are more than ${\rm ot}(n,G)$ edges from each color, and for any pair of non-negative integers $r$ and $b$ with $r+b = e(G)$, there is a copy of $G$ in $K_n$ with exactly $r$ red edges and $b$ blue edges. We give a structural characterization of omnitonal graphs from which we deduce that omnitonal graphs are, in particular, bipartite graphs, and prove further that, for an omnitonal graph $G$, ${\rm ot}(n,G) = \mathcal{O}(n^{2 - \frac{1}{m}})$, where $m = m(G)$ depends only on $G$. We also present a class of graphs for which ${\rm ot}(n,G) = ex(n,G)$, the celebrated Turán numbers. Many more results and problems of similar flavor are presented.

The structural Ramsey theory is a field on the boundary of combinatorics and model theory with deep connections to topological dynamics. Most of the known Ramsey classes in finite binary symmetric relational language can be shown to be Ramsey by utilizing a variant of the shortest path completion (e.g. Sauer's $S$-metric spaces, Conant's generalised metric spaces, Braunfeld's $Λ$-ultrametric spaces or Cherlin's metrically homogeneous graphs). In this thesis we explore the limits of the shortest path completion. We offer a unifying framework --- semigroup-valued metric spaces --- for all the aforementioned Ramsey classes and study their Ramsey expansions and EPPA (the extension property for partial automorphisms). Our results can be seen as evidence for the importance of studying the completion problem for amalgamation classes and have some further applications (such as the stationary independence relation). As a corollary of our general theorems, we reprove results of Hubička and Nešetřil on Sauer's $S$-metric spaces, results of Hubčka, Nešetřil and the author on Conant's generalised metric spaces, Braunfeld's results on $Λ$-ultrametric spaces and the results of Aranda et al. on Cherlin's primitive 3-constrained metrically homogeneous graphs. We also solve several open problems such as EPPA for $Λ$-ultrametric spaces, $S$-metric spaces or Conant's generalised metric spaces. Our framework seems to be universal enough that we conjecture that every primitive strong amalgamation class of complete edge-labelled graphs with finitely many labels is in fact a class of semigroup-valued metric spaces.

This list presents problems in the Reverse Mathematics of infinitary Ramsey theory which I find interesting but do not personally have the techniques to solve. The intent is to enlist the help of those working in Reverse Mathematics to take on such problems, and the myriad of related questions one can infer from them. A short bit of background and starting references are provided.

A set of $N$ permutations of $\{1,2,\ldots,v\}$ is $t$-suitable, if each symbol precedes each subset of $t-1$ others in at least one permutation. The extremal problem of determining the smallest size $N$ of such sets for given $v$ and $t$ was the subject of classical studies by Dushnik in 1950 and Spencer in 1971. Colbourn recently introduced the concept of suitable cores as equivalent objects of suitable sets of permutations, and studied the dual problem of determining the largest $v=\text{SCN}(t,N)$ such that a suitable core exists for given $t$ and $N$. Chan and Jedwab showed that when $N=\lfloor\frac{t+1}{2}\rfloor\lceil\frac{t+1}{2}\rceil+l$, the value of SCN$(t,N)$ is asymptotically $\lfloor\frac{t}{2}\rfloor+2$ if $l$ is a fixed integer. In this paper, we improve this result by showing that it is also true when $l=O(\ln t)$ using Ramsey theory. When $v$ is bigger than $\lfloor\frac{t}{2}\rfloor+2$, we give new explicit constructions of suitable cores from packings of triples, and random constructions from extended Ramsey colorings.

An ordered hypergraph is a hypergraph $H$ with a specified linear ordering of the vertices, and the appearance of an ordered hypergraph $G$ in $H$ must respect the specified order on $V(G)$. In on-line Ramsey theory, Builder iteratively presents edges that Painter must immediately color. The $t$-color on-line size Ramsey number $\tilde R_t (G)$ of an ordered hypergraph $G$ is the minimum number of edges Builder needs to play (on a large ordered set of vertices) to force Painter using $t$ colors to produce a monochromatic copy of $G$. The monotone tight path $P_r^{(k)}$ is the ordered hypergraph with $r$ vertices whose edges are all sets of $k$ consecutive vertices. We obtain good bounds on $\tilde R_t (P_r^{(k)})$. Letting $m=r-k+1$ (the number of edges in $P_r^{(k)}$), we prove $m^{t-1}/(3\sqrt t)\le\tilde R_t (P_r^{(2)})\le tm^{t+1}$. For general $k$, a trivial upper bound is ${R \choose k}$, where $R$ is the least number of vertices in a $k$-uniform (ordered) hypergraph whose $t$-colorings all contain $P_r^{(k)}$ (and is a tower of height $k-2$). We prove $R/(k\lg R)\le\tilde R_t(P_r^{(k)})\le R(\lg R)^{2+ε}$, where $ε$ is any positive constant and $t(m-1)$ is sufficiently large. Our upper bounds improve prior results when $t$ grows faster than $m/\log m$. We also generalize our results to $\ell$-loose monotone paths, where each successive edge begins $\ell$ vertices after the previous edge.

In this paper, Ramsey theory for discrete hypergroups is introduced with emphasis on polynomial hypergroups, discrete orbit hypergroups and hypergroup deformations of semigroups. In this context, new notions of Ramsey principle for hypergroups and $α$-Ramsey hypergroup, $0 \leq α<1,$ are defined and studied.

The Hales-Jewett Theorem states that given any finite nonempty set $\A$ and any finite coloring of the free semigroup $S$ over the alphabet $\A$ there is a {\it variable word\/} over $\A$ all of whose instances are the same color. This theorem has some extensions involving several distinct variables occurring in the variable word. We show that, when combined with a sufficiently well behaved homomorphism, the relevant variable word simultaneously satisfies a Ramsey-Theoretic conclusion in the other structure. As an example we show that if $τ$ is the homomorphism from the set of variable words into the natural numbers which associates to each variable word $w$ the number of occurrences of the variable in $w$, then given any finite coloring of $S$ and any infinite sequence of natural numbers, there is a variable word $w$ whose instances are monochromatic and $τ(w)$ is a sum of distinct members of the given sequence. Our methods rely on the algebraic structure of the Stone-\v Cech compactification of $S$ and the other semigroups that we consider. We show for example that if $τ$ is as in the paragraph above, there is a compact subsemigroup $P$ of $β\ben$ which contains all of the idempotents of $β\ben$ such that, given any $p\in P$, any $A\in p$, and any finite coloring of $S$, there is a variable word $w$ whose instances are monochromatic and $τ(w)\in A$. We end with a new short algebraic proof of an infinitary extension of the Graham-Rothschild Parameter Sets Theorem.

The analytic rank of a tensor, first defined by Gowers and Wolf in the context of higher-order Fourier analysis, is defined to be the logarithm of the bias of the tensor. We prove that it is a subadditive measure of rank: that is, the analytic rank of the sum of two tensors is at most the sum of their individual analytic ranks. This analytic property turns out to have surprising applications: (i) common roots of tensors are always positively correlated; and (ii) the slice rank and partition rank, which were defined recently in the resolution of the cap-set problem in Ramsey theory, can be replaced by the analytic rank.

Imagine that you are handed a rule for determining whether a cycle in a digraph is "good" or "bad", based on which edges of the cycle are traversed in the forward direction and which edges are traversed in the backward direction. Can you then construct a digraph which avoids having any "bad" cycles, but has arbitrarily large chromatic number? We answer this question when the rule is described in terms of a finite state machine. The proof relies on Nesetril and Rodl's structural Ramsey theory of posets with a linear extension. As an application, we give a new proof of the Loop Lemma of Barto, Kozik, and Niven in the special case of bounded width algebras.

Ramsey theory looks for regularities in large objects. Model theory studies algebraic structures as models of theories. The structural Ramsey theory combines these two fields and is concerned with Ramsey-type questions about certain model-theoretic structures. In 2005, Nešetřil initiated a systematic study of the so-called Ramsey classes of finite structures. This thesis is a contribution to the programme; we find Ramsey expansions of the primitive 3-constrained classes from Cherlin's catalogue of metrically homogeneous graphs. A key ingradient is an explicit combinatorial algorithm to fill-in the missing distances in edge-labelled graphs to obtain structures from Cherlin's classes. This algorithm also implies the extension property for partial automorphisms (EPPA), another combinatorial property of classes of finite structures.

We develop a general framework for infinite-dimensional Ramsey theory with and without pigeonhole principle, inspired by Gowers' Ramsey-type theorem for block sequences in Banach spaces and by its exact version proved by Rosendal. In this framework, we prove the adversarial Ramsey principle for Borel sets, a result conjectured by Rosendal that generalizes at the same time his version of Gowers' theorem and Borel determinacy of games on integers.

We study a conjecture linking ultimate periodicity of infnite words to the existence of colorings on finite words avoiding monochromatic factorisation of suffixes, with the extra condition that the ordered concatenation of elements of this factorisation remains monochromatic. This type of results shows the limits of Ramsey theory in the context of combinatorics on words. We show some reductions of the problem and the example of the Zimin word. Using the new notion of consecutive length, we show that words avoiding large squares fulfill the conjecture.

In this survey we describe a recently-developed technique for bounding the number (and controlling the typical structure) of finite objects with forbidden substructures. This technique exploits a subtle clustering phenomenon exhibited by the independent sets of uniform hypergraphs whose edges are sufficiently evenly distributed; more precisely, it provides a relatively small family of 'containers' for the independent sets, each of which contains few edges. We attempt to convey to the reader a general high-level overview of the method, focusing on a small number of illustrative applications in areas such as extremal graph theory, Ramsey theory, additive combinatorics, and discrete geometry, and avoiding technical details as much as possible.

We consider the following problem posed by Erdos in 1962. Suppose that $G$ is an $n$-vertex graph where the number of $s$-cliques in $G$ is $t$. How small can the independence number of $G$ be? Our main result suggests that for fixed $s$, the smallest possible independence number undergoes a transition at $t=n^{s/2+o(1)}$. In the case of triangles ($s=3$) we obtain the following result which is sharp apart from constant factors and generalizes basic results in Ramsey theory: there exists $c>0$ such that every $n$-vertex graph with $t$ triangles has independence number at least $$c \cdot \min\left\{ \sqrt {n \log n}\, , \, \frac{n}{t^{1/3}} \left(\log \frac{n}{ t^{1/3}}\right)^{2/3} \right\}.$$

We study automorphism groups of sparse graphs from the viewpoint of topological dynamics and the Kechris, Pestov, Todorčević correspondence. We investigate amenable and extremely amenable subgroups of these groups using the space of orientations of the graph and results from structural Ramsey theory. Resolving one of the open questions in the area, we show that Hrushovski's example of an $ω$-categorical sparse graph has no $ω$-categorical expansion with extremely amenable automorphism group.

Given a dataset we quantify how many patterns must always exist in the dataset. Formally this is done through the lens of Ramsey theory of graphs, and a quantitative bound known as Goodman's theorem. Combining statistical tools with Ramsey theory of graphs gives a nuanced understanding of how far away a dataset is from random, and what qualifies as a meaningful pattern. This method is applied to a dataset of repeated voters in the 1984 US congress, to quantify how homogeneous a subset of congressional voters is. We also measure how transitive a subset of voters is. Statistical Ramsey theory is also used with global economic trading data to provide evidence that global markets are quite transitive.