arXiv++ Combinatorics

The transition matrix of a Markov chain $(X_k,k\geq 0)$ on a finite or infinite rooted tree is said to be almost upper-directed if, given $X_k$, the node $X_{k+1}$ is either a descendant of $X_k$ or the parent of $X_k$. It is said to be almost lower-directed if given $X_k$, $X_{k+1}$ is either an ancestor of $X_k$ or a child of $X_k$. These models include nearest neighbor Markov chains on trees. Under an irreducibility assumption, we show that every almost upper-directed transition matrix on infinite (locally finite) trees has some invariant measures. An invariant measure $π$ is expressed thanks to a determinantal formula. We give general explicit criteria for recurrence and positive recurrence. An efficient algorithm (the leaf addition algorithm) of independent interest allows $π$ to be computed on many trees, without resorting to linear algebra considerations. Flajolet, in a series of papers, provided some relations between continuous fractions, generating functions of weighted Mötzkin paths, and used them in connection with the analysis of birth and death processes. These fruitful representations made it possible to establish many formulae for continuous fractions. Analogous considerations appear here: this type of study can be extended to weighted paths on trees, whose generating functions can also be expressed, this time in terms of multicontinuous fractions.

Rooted phylogenetic networks, or more generally, directed acyclic graphs (DAGs), are widely used to model species or gene relationships that traditional rooted trees cannot fully capture, especially in the presence of reticulate processes or horizontal gene transfers. Such networks or DAGs are typically inferred from observable data (e.g. genomic sequences of extant species), providing only an estimate of the true evolutionary history. However, these inferred DAGs are often complex and difficult to interpret. In particular, many contain vertices that do not serve as least common ancestors (LCAs) for any subset of the underlying genes or species, thus may lack direct support from the observable data. In contrast, LCA vertices are witnessed by historical traces justifying their existence and thus represent ancestral states substantiated by the data. To reduce unnecessary complexity and eliminate unsupported vertices, we aim to simplify a DAG to retain only LCA vertices while preserving essential evolutionary information. In this paper, we characterize $\mathrm{LCA}$-relevant and $\mathrm{lca}$-relevant DAGs, defined as those in which every vertex serves as an LCA (or unique LCA) for some subset of taxa. We introduce methods to identify LCAs in DAGs and efficiently transform any DAG into an $\mathrm{LCA}$-relevant or $\mathrm{lca}$-relevant one while preserving key structural properties of the original DAG or network. This transformation is achieved using a simple operator ``$\ominus$'' that mimics vertex suppression.

One method to generate random permutations involves using Gaussian elimination with partial pivoting (GEPP) on a random matrix $A$ and storing the permutation matrix factor $P$ from the resulting GEPP factorization $PA=LU$. We are interested in exploring properties of random butterfly permutations, which are generated using GEPP on specific random butterfly matrices. Our paper highlights new connections among random matrix theory, numerical linear algebra, group actions of rooted trees, and random permutations. We address the questions of the longest increasing subsequence (LIS) and number of cycles for particular uniform butterfly permutations, with full distributional descriptions and limit theorems for simple butterfly permutations. We also establish scaling limit results and limit theorems for nonsimple butterfly permutations, which include certain $p$-Sylow subgroups of the symmetric group of $N=p^n$ elements for prime $p$. For the LIS, we establish power law bounds on the expected LIS of the form $N^{α_p}$ and $N^{β_p}$ where $\frac12 < α_p < β_p < 1$ for each $p$ with $α_p = 1 - o_p(1)$, showing distinction from the typical $O(N^{1/2})$ expected LIS frequently encountered in the study of random permutations (e.g., uniform permutations). For the number of cycles scaled by $(2-1/p)^n$, we establish a full CLT to a new limiting distribution depending on $p$ with positive support we introduce that is uniquely determined by its positive moments that satisfy explicit recursive formulas; this thus determines a CLT for the number of cycles for any uniform $p$-Sylow subgroup of $S_{p^n}$.

Brushing of graphs is a graph searching process in which the searching agents are called brushes. We focus on brushing directed graphs based on a new model in which the brushes can only travel in the same direction as the orientation of the arcs that they traverse. We discuss strategies to brush directed graphs as well as values and bounds for the brushing number of directed graphs. We determine the brushing number for any transitive tournament, which we use to give an upper bound for the brushing number of directed acyclic graphs in general. We also establish exact values for the brushing numbers of complete directed graphs, rooted trees, and rotational tournaments.

The Colijn--Plazzotta ranking is a bijective encoding of the unlabeled binary rooted trees with positive integers. We show that the rank $f(t)$ of a tree $t$ is closely related to its height $h$, the length of the longest path from a leaf to the root. We consider the rank $f(τ_n)$ of a random $n$-leaf tree $τ_n$ under each of three models: (i) uniformly random unlabeled unordered binary rooted trees, or unlabeled topologies; (ii) uniformly random leaf-labeled binary trees, or labeled topologies under the uniform model; and (iii) random binary search trees, or labeled topologies under the Yule--Harding model. Relying on the close relationship between tree rank and tree height, we obtain results concerning the asymptotic properties of $\log \log f(τ_n)$. In particular, we find $\mathbb{E} \{\log_2 \log f(τ_n)\} \sim 2 \sqrt{πn}$ for uniformly random unlabeled ordered binary rooted trees and uniformly random leaf-labeled binary trees, and for a constant $α\approx 4.31107$, $\mathbb{E}\{\log_2 \log f(τ_n)\} \sim α\log n $ for leaf-labeled binary trees under the Yule--Harding model. We show that the mean of $f(τ_n)$ itself under the three models is largely determined by the rank $c_{n-1}$ of the highest-ranked tree -- the caterpillar -- obtaining an asymptotic relationship with $π_n c_{n-1}$, where $π_n$ is a model-specific function of $n$. The results resolve open problems, providing a new class of results on an encoding useful in mathematical phylogenetics.

We use Hartnell's model for virus spread on a graph, also known as firefighting. For rooted trees, we propose an Unburning Algorithm, a type of greedy algorithm starting from the leaves and working back towards the root. We show that the algorithm saves at least half the vertices of the optimal solution and that this is bound is sharp. We confirm a conjecture of Hartke about integrality gaps when comparing linear and integer program solutions. For general graphs, we propose a Containment Protocol, which looks ahead two time steps to decide where to place vaccinations. We show that the protocol performs near optimally on four well-studied infinite grids. The protocol is available for any graph and we realize this flexibility by investigating an infinite pentagonal graph.

We give a novel combinatorial interpretation to the perturbative series solutions for a class of Dyson-Schwinger equations. We show how binary tubings of rooted trees with labels from an alphabet on the tubes, and where the labels satisfy certain compatibility constraints, can be used to give series solutions to Dyson-Schwinger equations with a single Mellin transform which is the reciprocal of a polynomial with rational roots, in a fully combinatorial way. Further, the structure of these tubings leads directly to systems of differential equations for the anomalous dimension that are ideally suited for resurgent analysis. We give a general result in the distinct root case, and investigate the effect of repeated roots, which drastically changes the asymptotics and the transseries structure.

We study a partially ordered set of planar labeled rooted trees by use of combinatorial objects called Dyck tilings. A generating function of the poset is factorized when the minimum element of the poset is $312$-avoiding and satisfies some extra condition. We define a cover relation on rational Dyck tilings by that of labeled trees, and show that increasing and decreasing labelings are dual to each other. We consider two decompositions of a rational $(a,b)$-Dyck tiling: one is into $ab$ Dyck tilings and the other is into $a$ $(1,b)$-Dyck tilings. In the first case, we show that the weight of the $(a,b)$-Dyck tiling is the sum of the weights of $ab$ Dyck tilings. In the second case, we introduce a cover relation on $(1,b)$-Dyck tilings and obtain a poset of $(a,b)$-Dyck tilings by this decomposition.

We study mixtures of free, monotone, and Boolean independence described by a directed graph $G = (V,E)$ in the context of $\mathcal{T}$-free convolutions of Jekel and Liu. We prove general limit theorems for the associated additive convolution operations $\boxplus_G$. For a sequence of digraphs $G_n = (V_n,E_n)$, we give sufficient conditions for the limit $\widehatμ = \lim_{n \to \infty} \boxplus_{G_n}(μ_n)$ to exist whenever the Boolean convolution powers $μ_n^{\uplus |V_n|}$ converge to some $μ$. This in particular includes central limit and Poisson limit theorems, as well as limit theorems for each classical domain of attraction. The hypothesis on the sequence of $G_n$ is that the normalized counts of digraph homomorphisms from rooted trees into $G_n$ converge as $n \to \infty$, and we verify this for several families of examples where the $G_n$'s converge in some sense to a continuum limit, or digraphon. In particular, we obtain a new limit theorem for multiregular digraphs, as well as recovering several limit theorems in prior work.

In phylogenetics, reconstructing rooted trees from distances between taxa is a common task. Böcker and Dress generalized this concept by introducing symbolic dated maps $δ:X \times X \to Υ$, where distances are replaced by symbols, and showed that there is a one-to-one correspondence between symbolic ultrametrics and labeled rooted phylogenetic trees. Many combinatorial structures fall under the umbrella of symbolic dated maps, such as 2-dissimilarities, symmetric labeled 2-structures, or edge-colored complete graphs, and are here referred to as strudigrams. Strudigrams have a unique decomposition into non-overlapping modules, which can be represented by a modular decomposition tree (MDT). In the absence of prime modules, strudigrams are equivalent to symbolic ultrametrics, and the MDT fully captures the relationships $δ(x,y)$ between pairs of vertices $x,y$ in $X$ through the label of their least common ancestor in the MDT. However, in the presence of prime vertices, this information is generally hidden. To provide this missing structural information, we aim to locally replace the prime vertices in the MDT to obtain networks that capture full information about the strudigrams. While starting with the general framework of prime-vertex replacement networks, we then focus on a specific type of such networks obtained by replacing prime vertices with so-called galls, resulting in labeled galled-trees. We introduce the concept of galled-tree explainable (GATEX) strudigrams, provide their characterization, and demonstrate that recognizing these structures and reconstructing the labeled networks that explain them can be achieved in polynomial time.

The Horton-Strahler number of a rooted tree $T$ is the height of the tallest complete binary tree that can be homeomorphically embedded in $T$. The number of full binary trees with $n$ internal vertices and Horton-Strahler number $s$ is known to be the same as the number of Dyck paths of length $2n$ whose height $h$ satisfies $\lfloor \log_2(1+h)\rfloor=s$. In this paper, we present a new bijective proof of the above result, that in fact strengthens and refines it as follows. We introduce a sequence of trees $(τ_i,i \ge 0)$ which "interpolates" the complete binary trees, in the sense that $τ_{2^h-1}$ is the complete binary tree of height $h$ for all $h \ge 0$, and $τ_{i+1}$ strictly contains $τ_i$ for all $i \ge 0$. Defining $\mathcal{S}(T)$ to be the largest $i$ for which $τ_i$ can be homeomorphically embedded in $T$, we then show that the number of full binary trees $T$ with $n$ internal vertices and with $\mathcal{S}(T)=h$ is the same as the number of Dyck paths of length $2n$ with height $h$. (We call $\mathcal{S}(T)$ the refined Horton-Strahler number of $T$.) Our proof is bijective and relies on a recursive decomposition of binary trees (resp. Dyck paths) into subtrees with strictly smaller refined Horton-Strahler number (resp. subpaths with strictly smaller height). In a subsequent paper, we will show that the bijection has a continuum analogue, which transforms a Brownian continuum random tree into a Brownian excursion and under which (a continuous analogue of) the refined Horton-Strahler number of the tree becomes the height of the excursion.

We study the compatibility between the antipode and the preLie product of a Com-PreLie Hopf algebra, that is to say a commutative Hopf algebra with a complementary preLie product, compatible with the product and the coproduct in a certain sense. An example of such a Hopf algebra is the Connes-Kreimer Hopf algebra, with the preLie product given by graftingof forests, extending the free preLie product of grafting of rooted trees. This compatibility is then used to study the antipode of the Connes-Moscovici subalgebra, whichcan be defined with the help of this preLie product. The antipode of the generators of this subalgebra gives a family of combinatorial coefficients indexed by partitions,which can be computed with the help of iterated harmonic sums.

Semidirected networks have received interest in evolutionary biology as the appropriate generalization of unrooted trees to networks, in which some but not all edges are directed. Yet these networks lack proper theoretical study. We define here a general class of semidirected phylogenetic networks, with a stable set of leaves, tree nodes and hybrid nodes. We prove that for these networks, if we locally choose the direction of one edge, then globally the set of directed paths starting by this edge is stable across all choices to root the network. We define an edge-based representation of semidirected phylogenetic networks and use it to define a dissimilarity between networks, which can be efficiently computed in near-quadratic time. Our dissimilarity extends the widely-used Robinson-Foulds distance on both rooted trees and unrooted trees. After generalizing the notion of tree-child networks to semidirected networks, we prove that our edge-based dissimilarity is in fact a distance on the space of tree-child semidirected phylogenetic networks.

A plane rooted tree is called a hipster tree if it has no nontrivial automorphisms. Equivalently, a tree is a hipster tree if no two siblings have isomorphic subtrees. We impose the hipster condition on various classes of rooted trees. By approximating the generating function for the number of such trees, we obtain bounds on their exponential growth rates.

An edge-colored rooted directed tree (aka arborescence) is path-monochromatic if every path in it is monochromatic. Let $k,\ell$ be positive integers. For a tournament $T$, let $f_T(k)$ be the largest integer such that every $k$-edge coloring of $T$ has a path-monochromatic subtree with at least $f_T(k)$ vertices and let $f_T(k,\ell)$ be the restriction to subtrees of depth at most $\ell$. It was proved by Landau that $f_T(1,2)=n$ and proved by Sands et al. that $f_T(2)=n$ where $|V(T)|=n$. Here we consider $f_T(k)$ and $f_T(k,\ell)$ in more generality, determine their extremal values in most cases, and in fact in all cases assuming the Caccetta-Häggkvist Conjecture. We also study the typical value of $f_T(k)$ and $f_T(k,\ell)$, i.e., when $T$ is a random tournament.

A modification of Merino-Mička-Mütze's solution to a combinatorial generation problem of Knuth is proposed in this survey. The resulting alternate form to such solution is compatible with a reinterpretation by the author of a proof of existence of Hamilton cycles in the middle-levels graphs. Such reinterpretation is given in terms of a dihedral quotient graph associated to each middle-levels graph. The vertices of such quotient graph represent Dyck words and their associated ordered trees. Those Dyck words are linearly ordered via a rooted tree that covers all their tight, or irreducible, forms, offering an universal reference point of view to express and integrate the periodic paths, or blocks, whose concatenation leads to Hamilton cycles resulting from the said solution.

This paper is devoted to proving an infinite sequence of relations for rooted tree maps. On the way, we also give a basis for the space of rooted tree maps.

A common subgraph of two graphs $G_1$ and $G_2$ is a graph that is isomorphic to subgraphs of $G_1$ and $G_2$. In the largest common subgraph problem the task is to determine a common subgraph for two given graphs $G_1$ and $G_2$ that is of maximum possible size ${\rm lcs}(G_1,G_2)$. This natural problem generalizes the well-studied graph isomorphism problem, has many applications, and remains NP-hard even restricted to unions of paths. We present a simple $4$-approximation algorithm for forests, and, for every fixed $ε\in (0,1)$, we show that, for two given forests $F_1$ and $F_2$ of order at most $n$, one can determine in polynomial time a common subgraph $F$ of $F_1$ and $F_2$ with at least ${\rm lcs}(F_1,F_2)-εn$ edges. Restricted to instances with ${\rm lcs}(F_1,F_2)\geq cn$ for some fixed positive $c$, this yields a polynomial time approximation scheme. Our approach relies on the approximation of the given forests by structurally simpler forests that are composed of copies of only $O(\log (n))$ different starlike rooted trees and iterative quantizations of the options for the solutions.

We introduce the notion of quota trees in directed graphs. Given a nonnegative integer ``quota'' for each vertex of a directed multigraph $G$, a quota tree is an immersed rooted tree which hits each vertex of $G$ the prescribed number of times. When the quotas are all one, the tree is actually embedded and we recover the usual notion of a spanning arborescence (directed spanning tree). The usual algorithms which produce spanning arborescences with various properties typically have (sometimes more complicated) ``quota'' analogues. Our original motivation for studying quota trees was the problem of characterizing the sizes of the Myhill-Nerode equivalence classes in a connected deterministic finite-state automaton recognizing a given regular language. We show that the obstruction to realizing a given set of M-N class sizes is precisely the existence of a suitable quota tree. In this paper we develop the basic theory of quota trees. We give necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of a quota tree (or forest) over a given directed graph with specified quotas, solving the M-N class size problem as a special case. We discuss some potential applications of quota trees and forests, and connect them to the $k$ lightest paths problem. We give two proofs of the main theorem: one based on an algorithmic loop invariant, and one based on direct enumeration of quota trees. For the latter, we use Lagrange inversion to derive a formula which vastly generalizes both the matrix-tree theorem and Cayley's formula for counting labeled trees. We give an efficient algorithm to sample uniformly from the set of forests with given quotas, as well as a generalization of Edmonds' algorithm for computing a minimum-weight quota forest.

A graceful labelling of a tree T = (V,E), where V is the set of vertices of the tree and E is its edge set, is a bijective function f from V to the set consisting of the numbers 0, 1, ... |E| inclusive, such that if edge uv is assigned the value |f(u)-f(v)| then the edge labels are distinct numbers of the set consisting of the numbers 1, 2, ..., |E| inclusive. A tree is said to be 0-roratable if for any of its vertices there is a graceful labelling that assigns the label 0 to that vertex. A rooted symmetric tree is a tree in which all vertices at the same level from root vertex have the same degree. It was known since 1979 that rooted symmetric trees are graceful and an algebraic definition of graceful labelling of this class of trees was found by the author. In this paper we prove that rooted symmetric trees with at most 3 levels (including root vertex) are 0-rotatable. We also prove that symmetric spider trees with leg length at most 3 and symmetric banana trees, both of which are classes of rooted symmetric trees with 4 levels, are 0-rotatable. Based on these results, we conjecture that all spiders are 0-rotatable and raise the more general question whether all symmetric rooted trees are 0-rotatable.