arXiv++ Combinatorics

This paper is a survey on the Lickorish type construction of some kind of closed manifolds over simple convex polytopes. Inspired by Lickorish's theorem, we propose a method to describe certain families of manifolds over simple convex polytopes with torus action. Under this construction, many classical classification results of these families of manifolds could be interpreted by this construction and some further problems will be discussed.

In this paper, we present a minimal counterexample to a conjecture of Perles that answers a question of Haase and Ziegler. The example is a simple 4-polytope that has an induced 3-connected 3-regular subgraph, whose graph complement is connected. This subgraph is planar and not the graph of a facet of the polytope.

An arrow matrix is a matrix with zeroes outside the main diagonal, first row, and first column. We consider the space $M_{St_n,λ}$ of Hermitian arrow $(n+1)\times (n+1)$-matrices with fixed simple spectrum $λ$. We prove that this space is a smooth $2n$-manifold, and its smooth structure is independent on the spectrum. Next, this manifold carries the locally standard torus action: we describe the topology and combinatorics of its orbit space. If $n\geqslant 3$, the orbit space $M_{St_n,λ}/T^n$ is not a polytope, hence this manifold is not quasitoric. However, there is a natural permutation action on $M_{St_n,λ}$ which induces the combined action of a semidirect product $T^n\rtimesΣ_n$. The orbit space of this large action is a simple polytope. The structure of this polytope is described in the paper. In case $n=3$, the space $M_{St_3,λ}/T^3$ is a solid torus with boundary subdivided into hexagons in a regular way. This description allows to compute the cohomology ring and equivariant cohomology ring of the 6-dimensional manifold $M_{St_3,λ}$ using the general theory developed by the first author. This theory is also applied to a certain $6$-dimensional manifold called the twin of $M_{St_3,λ}$. The twin carries a half-dimensional torus action and has nontrivial tangent and normal bundles.

Given any polytope $P$ and any generic linear functional ${\bf c} $, one obtains a directed graph $G(P,{\bf c})$ from the 1-skeleton of $P$ by orienting each edge $e(u,v)$ from $u$ to $v$ for ${\bf c} (u) < {\bf c} ( v)$. For $P$ a simple polytope and $G(P,{\bf c})$ the Hasse diagram of a lattice $L$, the join of any collection $S$ of elements which all cover a common element $u$ in $L$ is proven to equal the sink of the smallest face of $P$ containing $u$ and all of the elements of $S$. The author conjectures for such $G(P,{\bf c})$ that no directed path in $G(P,{\bf c})$ ever revisits any facet of $P$. This would imply for such $P$ and ${\bf c}$ that the simplex method for linear programming is efficient under all possible pivot rules. This conjecture is proven for 3-polytopes and for spindles. For simple polytopes in which $G(P,{\bf c})$ is the Hasse diagram of a lattice $L$, the order complex of each open interval in $L$ is proven homotopy equivalent to a ball or a sphere. Applications are given to the weak Bruhat order, the Tamari lattice, and the Cambrian lattices. This paper concludes with an appendix by Dominik Preußproving the monotone Hirsch conjecture for $P$ a simple polytope and $G(P,{\bf c})$ the Hasse diagram of a lattice. This confirms one of the main consequences that the author's conjecture would have.

Circuits play a fundamental role in the theory of linear programming due to their intimate connection to algorithms of combinatorial optimization and the efficiency of the simplex method. We are interested in better understanding the properties of circuit walks in integral polyhedra. In this paper, we introduce a hierarchy for integral polyhedra based on different types of behavior exhibited by their circuit walks. Many problems in combinatorial optimization fall into the most interesting categories of this hierarchy - steps of circuit walks only stop at integer points, at vertices, or follow actual edges. We classify several classical families of polyhedra within the hierarchy, including 0/1-polytopes, polyhedra defined by totally unimodular matrices, and more specifically matroid polytopes, transportation polytopes, and partition polytopes. Finally, we prove three characterizations of the simple polytopes that appear in the bottom level of the hierarchy where all circuit walks are edge walks, showing that such polytopes constitute a generalization of simplices and parallelotopes.

A renowned theorem of Blind and Mani, with a constructive proof by Kalai and an efficiency proof by Friedman, shows that the whole face lattice of a simple polytope can be determined from its graph. This is part of a broader story of reconstructing face lattices from partial information, first considered comprehensively in Grünbaum's 1967 book. This survey paper includes varied results and open questions by many researchers on simplicial polytopes, nearly simple polytopes, cubical polytopes, zonotopes, crosspolytopes, and Eulerian posets.

We show that the $f$-vector sets of $d$-polytopes have non-trivial additive structure: They span affine lattices and are embedded in monoids that we describe explicitly. Moreover, for many large subclasses, such as the simple polytopes, or the simplicial polytopes, there are monoid structures on the set of $f$-vectors by themselves: "addition of $f$-vectors minus the $f$-vector of the $d$-simplex" always yields a new $f$-vector. For general $4$-polytopes, we show that the modified addition operation does not always produce an $f$-vector, but that the result is always close to an $f$-vector. In this sense, the set of $f$-vectors of \emph{all} $4$-polytopes forms an "approximate affine semigroup." The proof relies on the fact for $d=4$ every $d$-polytope, or its dual, has a "small facet." This fails for $d>4$. We also describe a two further modified addition operations on $f$-vectors that can be geometrically realized by glueing corresponding polytopes. The second one of these may yield a semigroup structure on the $f$-vector set of all $4$-polytopes.

We show that there are simple 4-dimensional polytopes with n vertices such that all separators of the graph have size at least $Ω(n/\log n)$. This establishes a strong form of a claim by Thurston, for which the construction and proof had been lost. We construct the polytopes by cutting off the vertices and then the edges of a particular type of neighborly cubical polytopes. The graphs of simple polytopes thus obtained are 4-regular; they contain 3-regular "cube-connected cycle graphs" as minors of spanning subgraphs.

A simple polytope $P$ is said to be \emph{B-rigid} if its combinatorial structure is characterized by its Tor-algebra, and is said to be \emph{C-rigid} if its combinatorial structure is characterized by the cohomology ring of a quasitoric manifold over $P$. It is known that a B-rigid simple polytope is C-rigid. In this paper, we, further, show that the B-rigidity is not equivalent to the C-rigidity.

Let $P$ be a simple polytope with $n-d = 2$, where $d$ is the dimension and $n$ is the number of facets. The graph of such a polytope is also called a grid. It is known that the directed random walk along the edges of $P$ terminates after $O(\log^2 n)$ steps, if the edges are oriented in a (pseudo-)linear fashion. We prove that the same bound holds for the more general unique sink orientations.

We investigate small covers and quasitoric over the duals of neighborly simplicial polytopes with small number of vertices in dimensions $4$, $5$, $6$ and $7$. In the most of the considered cases we obtain the complete classification of small covers. The lifting conjecture in all cases is verified to be true. The problem of cohomological rigidity for small covers is also studied and we have found a whole new series of weakly cohomologically rigid simple polytopes. New examples of manifolds provide the first known examples of quasitoric manifolds in higher dimensions whose orbit polytopes have chromatic numbers $χ(P^n)\geq 3n-5$.

It is known that polytopes with at most two nonsimple vertices are reconstructible from their graphs, and that $d$-polytopes with at most $d-2$ nonsimple vertices are reconstructible from their 2-skeletons. Here we close the gap between 2 and $d-2$, showing that certain polytopes with more than two nonsimple vertices are reconstructible from their graphs. In particular, we prove that reconstructibility from graphs also holds for $d$-polytopes with $d+k$ vertices and at most $d-k+3$ nonsimple vertices, provided $k\ge 5$. For $k\le4$, the same conclusion holds under a slightly stronger assumption. Another measure of deviation from simplicity is the {\it excess degree} of a polytope, defined as $ξ(P):=2f_1-df_0$, where $f_k$ denotes the number of $k$-dimensional faces of the polytope. Simple polytopes are those with excess zero. We prove that polytopes with excess at most $d-1$ are reconstructible from their graphs, and this is best possible. An interesting intermediate result is that $d$-polytopes with less than $2d$ vertices, and at most $d-1$ nonsimple vertices, are necessarily pyramids.

We define the excess degree $ξ(P)$ of a $d$-polytope $P$ as $2f_1-df_0$, where $f_0$ and $f_1$ denote the number of vertices and edges, respectively. This parameter measures how much $P$ deviates from being simple. It turns out that the excess degree of a $d$-polytope does not take every natural number: the smallest possible values are $0$ and $d-2$, and the value $d-1$ only occurs when $d=3$ or 5. On the other hand, for fixed $d$, the number of values not taken by the excess degree is finite if $d$ is odd, and the number of even values not taken by the excess degree is finite if $d$ is even. The excess degree is then applied in three different settings. It is used to show that polytopes with small excess (i.e. $ξ(P)<d$) have a very particular structure: provided $d\ne5$, either there is a unique nonsimple vertex, or every nonsimple vertex has degree $d+1$. This implies that such polytopes behave in a similar manner to simple polytopes in terms of Minkowski decomposability: they are either decomposable or pyramidal, and their duals are always indecomposable. Secondly, we characterise completely the decomposable $d$-polytopes with $2d+1$ vertices (up to combinatorial equivalence). And thirdly all pairs $(f_0,f_1)$, for which there exists a 5-polytope with $f_0$ vertices and $f_1$ edges, are determined.

A small cover is a closed smooth manifold of dimension $n$ having a locally standard $\mathbb{Z}_2^n$-action whose orbit space is isomorphic to a simple polytope. A typical example of small covers is a real projective toric manifold (or, simply, a real toric manifold), that is, a real locus of projective toric manifold. In the paper, we classify small covers and real toric manifolds whose orbit space is isomorphic to the dual of the simplicial complex obtainable by a sequence of wedgings from a polygon, using a systematic combinatorial method finding toric spaces called puzzles.

Blind and Mani, and later Kalai, showed that the face lattice of a simple polytope is determined by its graph, namely its $1$-skeleton. Call a vertex of a $d$-polytope \emph{nonsimple} if the number of edges incident to it is more than $d$. We show that (1) the face lattice of any $d$-polytope with at most two nonsimple vertices is determined by its $1$-skeleton; (2) the face lattice of any $d$-polytope with at most $d-2$ nonsimple vertices is determined by its $2$-skeleton; and (3) for any $d>3$ there are two $d$-polytopes with $d-1$ nonsimple vertices, isomorphic $(d-3)$-skeleta and nonisomorphic face lattices. In particular, the result (1) is best possible for $4$-polytopes.

We present a partial description of which polytopes are reconstructible from their graphs. This is an extension of work by Blind and Mani (1987) and Kalai (1988), which showed that simple polytopes can be reconstructed from their graphs. In particular, we introduce a notion of $h$-nearly simple and prove that 1-nearly simple and 2-nearly simple polytopes are reconstructible from their graphs. We also give an example of a 3-nearly simple polytope which is not reconstructible from its graph. Furthermore, we give a partial list of polytopes which are reconstructible from their graphs in an entirely non-constructive way.

The $W_v$-Path Conjecture due to Klee and Wolfe states that any two vertices of a simple polytope can be joined by a path that does not revisit any facet. This is equivalent to the well-known Hirsch Conjecture. Klee proved that the $W_v$-Path Conjecture is true for all 3-polytopes (3-connected plane graphs), and conjectured even more, namely that the $W_v$-Path Conjecture is true for all general cell complexes. This general $W_v$-Path Conjecture was verified for polyhedral maps on the projective plane and the torus by Barnette, and on the Klein bottle by Pulapaka and Vince. Let $G$ be a graph polyhedrally embedded in a surface $Σ$, and $x, y$ be two vertices of $G$. In this paper, we show that if there are three internally disjoint $(x,y)$-paths which are homotopic to each other, then there exists a $W_v$-path joining $x$ and $y$. For every surface $Σ$, define a function $f(Σ)$ such that if for every graph polyhedrally embedded in $Σ$ and for a pair of vertices $x$ and $y$ in $V(G)$, the local connectivity $κ_G(x,y) \ge f(Σ)$, then there exists a $W_v$-path joining $x$ and $y$. We show that $f(Σ)=3$ if $Σ$ is the sphere, and for all other surfaces $3-τ(Σ)\le f(Σ)\le 9-4χ(Σ)$, where $χ(Σ)$ is the Euler characteristic of $Σ$, and $τ(Σ)=χ(Σ)$ if $χ(Σ)< -1$ and 0 otherwise. Further, if $x$ and $y$ are not cofacial, we prove that $G$ has at least $κ_G(x,y)+4χ(Σ)-8$ internally disjoint $W_v$-paths joining $x$ and $y$. This bound is sharp for the sphere. Our results indicate that the $W_v$-path problem is related to both the local connectivity $κ_G(x,y)$, and the number of different homotopy classes of internally disjoint $(x,y)$-paths as well as the number of internally disjoint $(x,y)$-paths in each homotopy class.

We study the well-known problem of combinatorial classification of fullerenes. By a (mathematical) fullerene we mean a convex simple three dimensional polytope with all facets pentagons and hexagons. We analyse approaches of construction of arbitrary fullerene from the dodecahedron (a fullerene $C_{20}$). A growth operation is a combinatorial operation that substitutes the patch with more facets and the same boundary for the patch on the surface of a simple polytope to produce a new simple polytope. It is known that an infinite set of different growth operations transforming fullerenes into fullerenes is needed to construct any fullerene from the dodecahedron. We prove that if we allow a polytope to contain one exceptional facet, which is a quadrangle or a heptagon, then a finite set of growth operation is sufficient. We analyze pairs of objects: a finite set of operations, and a family of acceptable polytopes containing fullerenes such that any polytope of the family can be obtained from the dodecahedron by a sequence of operations from the corresponding set. We describe explicitly three such pairs. First two pairs contain seven operations, and the last -- eleven operations. Each of these operations corresponds to a finite set of growth operations and is a composition of edge- and two edges-truncations.

In this note we gather and review some facts about existence of toric spaces over 3-dimensional simple polytopes. First, over every combinatorial 3-polytope there exists a quasitoric manifold. Second, there exist combinatorial 3-polytopes, that do not correspond to any smooth projective toric variety. We restate the proof of the second claim which does not refer to complicated algebro-geometrical technique. If follows from these results that any fullerene supports quasitoric manifolds but does not support smooth projective toric varieties.

A graphical model encodes conditional independence relations via the Markov properties. For an undirected graph these conditional independence relations can be represented by a simple polytope known as the graph associahedron, which can be constructed as a Minkowski sum of standard simplices. There is an analogous polytope for conditional independence relations coming from a regular Gaussian model, and it can be defined using multiinformation or relative entropy. For directed acyclic graphical models and also for mixed graphical models containing undirected, directed and bidirected edges, we give a construction of this polytope, up to equivalence of normal fans, as a Minkowski sum of matroid polytopes. Finally, we apply this geometric insight to construct a new ordering-based search algorithm for causal inference via directed acyclic graphical models.