arXiv++ Combinatorics

Scaffolds are the one-dimensional skeleta of high-dimensional flag simplicial complexes of nonpositive curvature. They generalize the phylogenetic trees of Trop G(2,n) to arbitrary $k$, drawing together SL(k)-web bases, affine buildings, the combinatorics of the positive tropical Grassmannian and low-dimensional topology. We prove that scaffolds model points in all tropical Grassmannians via a $k$-point distance function. In this paper, we study in detail CAT(0) planar graphs, which are positive scaffolds for the tropical Grassmannian of three-planes. CAT(0) planar graphs are directed versions of the diskoids of Fontaine-Kamnitzer-Kuperberg, planar dual to SL(3)-webs. Our main result is the construction of a unique representation of any given integer positive tropical Plucker vector by a normal CAT(0) planar graph. We show that any normal CAT(0) planar graph embeds into the tropical linear space as a Lam-Postnikov membrane, and embeds into the Keel-Tevelev membrane within the affine building. We show that Early's planar basis expansion can be computed directly from the strand combinatorics of the dual web, and connect this expansion to Petersen-Pylyavskyy-Speyer's noncrossing tableaux, explored further in our companion paper.

While the positive Grassmannian is deeply understood through the rich combinatorics of plabic graphs and positroid cells, its tropical counterpart, the positive tropical Grassmannian Trop$_{>0}G(k,n)$, has lacked a comparable structural framework for general $k$. Both the global face structure of Trop$_{>0}G(k,n)$ and the internal metric geometry of the tropical linear spaces it parametrizes have remained largely uncharted. This paper develops a systematic algebraic and polyhedral foundation that resolves this gap. The engine of our framework is a fundamental tropical duality, analogous to the duality between cluster variables (or more precisely, their $u$-coordinates) and $\mathbf{g}$-vectors, pairing two families of objects introduced by the first author: the planar basis of tropical Plücker vectors and the planar cross-ratios on the positive configuration space. We prove that this duality links the fan structure of the positive tropical Grassmannian to the noncrossing fan of Santos, Stump, and Welker, yielding a global bijection between integer points of $Trop_{>0}G(k,n)$ and noncrossing tableaux. We then study how this discrete combinatorial data controls the continuous metric geometry of positive tropical linear spaces. We realize the bounded complex of an integer positive tropical linear space as the subdifferential of a central roof function on the hypersimplex, and use this realization to embed it into a dilate of the fundamental alcoved simplex. The dilation factor, and hence the geometric diameter of the complex, is governed by a single invariant, the planar kinematics ($K) weight, which we show equals the number of columns in the associated noncrossing tableau. The results of this work are applied in our parallel work on scaffolds for higher tropical Grassmannians.

We adopt a formal and algebraic approach of Early \cite{E2} to study the positive tropical Grassmannian $\operatorname{Trop}^+ Gr_{k,n}$. Specifically, we deal with positroid subdivision of hypersimplex induced by translated blades from any maximal weakly separated collection. One of our main results gives a necessary and sufficient condition on a maximal weakly separated collection to form a positroid subdivision of a hypersimplex corresponding to a simplicial cone in $\rm Trop^+Gr_{k,n}$. For k = 2 our condition says that any weakly separated collection of two-elements sets gives such a simplicial cone, and all cones are of such a form. We also show that the maximality of any weakly separated collection is preserved under the boundary map, which armatively answers a question by Early in \cite{E1}. Plabic graphs, invented by Postnikov \cite{P}, are of use in proving this result. As a corollary, we get that all those positroid subdivisions are the finest. Thus, the flip of two maximal weakly separatedcollections corresponds to a pair of adjacent maximal cones in positive tropical Grassmannian.

The global Schwinger formula, introduced by Cachazo and Early as a single integral over the positive tropical Grassmannian, provides a way to uncover properties of scattering amplitudes which are hard to see in their standard Feynman diagram formulation. In a recent work, Cachazo and one of the authors extended the global Schwinger formula to general $φ^p$ theories. When $p=4$, it was conjectured that the integral decomposes as a sum over cones which are in bijection with non-crossing chord diagrams, and further that these can be obtained by finding the zeroes of a piece-wise linear function, $H(x)$. In this note we give a proof of this conjecture. We also present a purely combinatorial way of computing $φ^p$ amplitudes by triangulating a trivial extended version of non-crossing $(p-2)$-chord diagrams, called extended diagrams, and present a proof of the bijection between triangulated extended diagrams and Feynman diagrams when $p=4$. This is reminiscent of recent constructions using Stokes polytopes and accordiohedra. However, the $φ^p$ amplitude is now partitioned by a new collection of objects, each of which characterizes a polyhedral cone in the positive tropical Grassmannian in the form of an associahedron or of an intersection of two associahedra. Moreover, we comment on the bijection between extended diagrams and double-ordered biadjoint scalar amplitudes. We also conjecture the form of the general piece-wise linear function, $H^{φ^p}(x)$, whose zeroes generate the regions in which the $φ^p$ global Schwinger formula decomposes into.

We introduce the notion of lattice path matroidal subdivisions, or LPM subdivisions for short, and show that these subdivisions are regular and hence the weight vectors for them lie in the Dressian. This leads us to explore the structure of the set of these weights inside the Dressian and owing to the fact that Lattice path matroids are positroids, we move to the positive Dressian which in turn is equal to the positive tropical Grassmannian, an object of immense interest currently in Physics. This is related to the amplituhedron and positive configuration space, which we describe here and wish to explore these connections further.

The goal of this paper is to make a connection between tropical geometry, representations of quantum affine algebras, and scattering amplitudes in physics. The connection allows us to study important and difficult questions in these areas: (1) We give a systematic construction of prime modules (including prime non-real modules) of quantum affine algebras using tropical geometry. We also introduce new objects which generalize positive tropical Grassmannians. (2) We propose a generalization of Grassmannian string integrals in physics, in which the integrand is no longer a finite, but rather an infinite product indexed by prime modules of a quantum affine algebra. We give a general formula of $u$-variables using prime tableaux (corresponding to prime modules of quantum affine algebras of type $A$) and Auslander-Reiten quivers of Grassmannian cluster categories. (3) We study limit $g$-vectors of cluster algebras. This is another way to obtain prime non-real modules of quantum affine algebras systematically. Using limit $g$-vectors, we construct new examples of non-real modules of quantum affine algebras.

The space of phylogenetic trees arises naturally in tropical geometry as the tropical Grassmannian. Tropical geometry therefore suggests a natural notion of a tropical path between two trees, given by a tropical line segment in the tropical Grassmannian. It was previously conjectured that tree topologies along such a segment change by a combinatorial operation known as Nearest Neighbor Interchange (NNI). We provide counterexamples to this conjecture, but prove that changes in tree topologies along the tropical line segment are either NNI moves or "four clade rearrangement" moves for generic trees. In addition, we show that the number of NNI moves occurring along the tropical line segment can be as large as $n^2$, but the average number of moves when the two endpoint trees are chosen at random is $O(n (\log n)^4)$. This is in contrast with $O(n \log n)$, the average number of NNI moves needed to transform one tree into another.

We study the problem of factorization for residues of generalized biadjoint scalar scattering amplitudes $m^{(k)}_n$, introduced by Cachazo, Early, Guevara and Mizera (CEGM), involving multi-dimensional residues which factorize generically into $k$-ary products of lower-point generalized biadjoint amplitudes of the same type $m^{(k)}_{n_1}\cdots m^{(k)}_{n_k}$, where $n_1+\cdots +n_k = n+k(k-1)$, noting that smaller numbers of factors arise as special cases. Such behavior is governed geometrically by regular matroid subdivisions of hypersimplices and cones in the positive tropical Grassmannian, and combinatorially by collections of compatible decorated ordered set partitions, considered modulo cyclic rotation. We make a proposal for conditions under which this happens and we develop $k=3,4$ in detail. We conclude briefly to propose a novel formula to construct coarsest regular matroid subdivisions of all hypersimplices $Δ_{k,n}$ and rays of the positive tropical Grassmannian, which should be of independent interest.

The biadjoint scalar partial amplitude, $m_n(\mathbb{I},\mathbb{I})$, can be expressed as a single integral over the positive tropical Grassmannian thus producing a Global Schwinger Parameterization. The first result in this work is an extension to all partial amplitudes $m_n(α,β)$ using a limiting procedure on kinematic invariants that produces indicator functions in the integrand. The same limiting procedure leads to an integral representation of $φ^4$ amplitudes where indicator functions turn into Dirac delta functions. Their support decomposes into $\textrm{C}_{n/2-1}$ regions, with $\textrm{C}_q$ the $q^{\rm th}$-Catalan number. The contribution from each region is identified with a $m_{n/2+1}(α,\mathbb{I})$ amplitude. We provide a combinatorial description of the regions in terms of non-crossing chord diagrams and propose a general formula for $φ^4$ amplitudes using the Lagrange inversion construction. We start the exploration of $φ^p$ theories, finding that their regions are encoded in non-crossing $(p-2)$-chord diagrams. The structure of the expansion of $φ^p$ amplitudes in terms of $φ^3$ amplitudes is the same as that of Green functions in terms of connected Green functions in the planar limit of $Φ^{p-1}$ matrix models. We also discuss possible connections to recent constructions based on Stokes polytopes and accordiohedra.

We provide a combinatorial study of split matroids, a class that was motivated by the study of matroid polytopes from a tropical geometry point of view. A nice feature of split matroids is that they generalize paving matroids, while being closed under duality and taking minors. Furthermore, these matroids proved to be useful in giving exact asymptotic bounds for the dimension of the Dressian, and also implied new results on the rays of the tropical Grassmannians. In the present paper, we introduce the notion of elementary split matroids, a subclass of split matroids that contains all connected split matroids. We give a hypergraph characterization of elementary split matroids in terms of independent sets, and show that the proposed class is closed not only under duality and taking minors but also truncation. We further show that, in contrast to split matroids, the proposed class can be characterized by a single forbidden minor. As an application, we provide a complete list of binary split matroids.

In this paper, we study a novel behavior developed by certain tree-level scalar scattering amplitudes, including the biadjoint, NLSM, and special Galileon, when a subset of kinematic invariants vanishes without producing a singularity. This behavior exhibits properties which we call $\textit{smooth splitting}$ and $\textit{semi-locality}$. The former means that an amplitude becomes the product of exactly three amputated Berends-Giele currents, while the latter means that any two currents share one external particle. We call these smooth splittings 3-splits. In fact, there are exactly $\binom{n}{3}-n$ such 3-splits, one for each generic, interior triangle in a polygon; as they cannot be obtained from standard factorization, they are a new phenomenon in Quantum Field Theory. In fact, the resulting splitting is analogous to the one first seen in Cachazo-Early-Guevara-Mizera (CEGM) amplitudes which generalize standard cubic scalar amplitudes from their ${\rm Tr}\, G(2,n)$ formulation to ${\rm Tr}\, G(k,n)$, where ${\rm Tr}\, G(k,n)$ is the tropical Grassmannian. Along the way, we show how smooth splittings naturally lead to the discovery of mixed amplitudes in the NLSM and special Galileon theories and to novel BCFW-like recursion relations for NLSM amplitudes.

In this paper we study the role of planarity in generalized scattering amplitudes, through several closely interacting structures in combinatorics, algebraic and tropical geometry. The generalized biadjoint scalar amplitude, introduced recently by Cachazo-Early-Guevara-Mizera (CEGM), is a rational function of homogeneous degree $-(k-1)(n-k-1)$ in $\binom{n}{k}-n$ independent variables; its poles can be constructed directly from the rays of the positive tropical Grassmannian. We introduce for each pair of integers $(k,n)$ with $2\le k\le n-2$ a system of generalized positive roots which arises as a specialization of the planar basis of kinematic invariants. We prove that the higher root polytope $\mathcal{R}^{(k)}_{n-k}$ has volume the k-dimensional Catalan number $C^{(k)}_{n-k}$, via a flag unimodular triangulation into simplices, in bijection with noncrossing collections of $k$-element subsets. We also give a bijection between certain positroidal subdivisions, called tripods, of the hypersimplex $Δ_{3,n}$ and noncrossing pairs of 3-element subsets that are not weakly separated. We show that the facets of the Planar Kinematics (PK) polytope, introduced recently by Cachazo and the author, are exactly the $\binom{n}{k}-n$ generalized positive roots. We show that the PK specialization of the generalized biadjoint amplitude evaluates to $C^{(k)}_{n-k}$. Looking forward, we give defining equations and conjecture explicit solutions using $(\mathbb{CP}^{n-k-1})^{\times (k-1)}$ via a notion of compatibility degree for noncrossing collections, for a two parameter family of generalized worldsheet associahedra $\mathcal{W}^+_{k,n}$. These specialize when $k=2$ to a certain dihedrally invariant partial compactification of the configuration space $M_{0,n}$ of $n$ distinct points in $\mathbb{CP}^{1}$. Many detailed examples are given throughout to motivate future work.

The tropical Grassmannian ${\rm Trop}\, G(2,n)$ is known to be the moduli space of unrooted metric trees with $n$ leaves. A positive part can be defined for each of the $(n-1)!/2$ possible planar orderings, $α$, and agrees with the corresponding planar trees in the moduli space, ${\rm Trop}^αG(2,n)$. Motivated by a physical application we study the way ${\rm Trop}^αG(2,n)$ and ${\rm Trop}^βG(2,n)$ intersect in ${\rm Trop}\, G(2,n)$. We define their intersection number as the number of unrooted binary trees that belong to both and construct a $(n-1)!/2\times (n-1)!/2$ intersection matrix. We are interested in finding the diagonal (up to permutations of rows and columns) submatrices of maximum possible rank for a given $n$. We prove that such diagonal matrices cannot have rank larger than $(n-3)!$ using the CHY formalism. We also prove that the bound is saturated for $n=5$ (the condition is trivial for $n=4$), that for $n=6$ the maximum rank is $4$, and that for $n=7$ the maximum rank is $\geq 14$. We also ask the following question: Is there a value $n_{\rm c}$ so that for any $n>n_{\rm c}$ the bound $(n-3)!$ is always saturated? We review and extend two relevant results in the literature. The first is the Kawai-Lewellen-Tye (KLT) choice of sets which leads to a $(n-3)!\times (n-3)!$ block diagonal submatrix with blocks of size $d\times d$ with $d = \lceil (n-3)/2\rceil !\lfloor (n-3)/2\rfloor !$. The second result is that the number of ${\rm Trop}^αG(2,n)$'s that intersect a given one grows as $\exp(n\log (3+\sqrt{8}))$ for large $n$ which implies that the density of the intersection matrix goes as $\exp(-n(\log(n)-2.76))$. We interpret this as an indication that the generic behavior is not seen until $n \approx \exp (2.76)$, i.e. $n = 16$. We also find an exact formula for the number of zeros in a KLT block.

Planar arrays of tree diagrams were introduced as a generalization of Feynman diagrams that enables the computation biadjoint amplitudes $m^{(k)}_n$ for $k>2$ . In this follow-up work we investigate the poles of $m^{(k)}_n$ from the perspective of such arrays. For general $k$ we characterize the underlying polytope as a Flag Complex and propose a computation of the amplitude based solely on the knowledge of poles, which number is drastically less than the number of full arrays. As an example we first provide all the poles for the cases $(k,n)=(3,7),(3,8),(4,8)$ and $(4,9)$ in terms of their generalized Feynman diagrams. We then implement a simple compatibility criteria together with an addition operation between arrays, and recover the full collections/arrays recently presented for such cases. Along the way we implement hard and soft kinematical limits, which provide a map between poles in kinematic space and their combinatoric arrays. We use the operation to give a proof of a previously conjectured combinatorial duality for arrays in $(k,n)$ and $(n-k,n)$. We also outline the relation to boundary maps of the hypersimplex $Δ_{k,n}$ and rays in the tropical Grassmannian $\textrm{Tr}(k,n)$.

In this paper, we continue our study of blade arrangements and the positroidal subdivisions which are induced by them on $Δ_{k,n}$. A blade is a tropical hypersurface which is generated by a system of $n$ affine simple roots of type $SL_n$ that enjoys a cyclic symmetry. When placed at the center of a simplex, a blade induces a decomposition into $n$ maximal cells which are known as Pitman-Stanley polytopes. We introduce a complex $(B_{k,n},\partial)$ of weighted blade arrangements and we prove that the positive tropical Grassmannian surjects onto the top component of the complex, such that the induced weights on blades in the faces $Δ_{2,n-(k-2)}$ of $Δ_{k,n}$ are (1) nonnegative and (2) their support is weakly separated. We finally introduce a hierarchy of elementary weighted blade arrangements for all hypersimplices which is minimally closed under the boundary maps $\partial$, and apply our result to classify up to isomorphism type all rays of the positive tropical Grassmannian $\text{Trop}_+ G(3,n)$ for $n\le 9$.

In 2004 Pachter and Speyer introduced the higher dissimilarity maps for phylogenetic trees and asked two important questions about their relation to the tropical Grassmannian. Multiple authors, using independent methods, answered affirmatively the first of these questions, showing that dissimilarity vectors lie on the tropical Grassmannian, but the second question, whether the set of dissimilarity vectors forms a tropical subvariety, remained opened. We resolve this question by showing that the tropical balancing condition fails. However, by replacing the definition of the dissimilarity map with a weighted variant, we show that weighted dissimilarity vectors form a tropical subvariety of the tropical Grassmannian in exactly the way that Pachter--Speyer envisioned. Moreover, we provide a geometric interpretation in terms of configurations of points on rational normal curves and construct a finite tropical basis that yields an explicit characterization of weighted dissimilarity vectors.

In this article, we present a massively parallel framework for computing tropicalizations of algebraic varieties which can make use of finite symmetries. We compute the tropical Grassmannian TGr$_0(3,8)$, and show that it refines the $15$-dimensional skeleton of the Dressian Dr$(3,8)$ with the exception of $23$ special cones for which we construct explicit obstructions to the realizability of their tropical linear spaces. Moreover, we propose algorithms for identifying maximal-dimensional tropical cones which belong to the positive tropicalization. These algorithms exploit symmetries of the tropical variety even though the positive tropicalization need not be symmetric. We compute the maximal-dimensional cones of the positive Grassmannian TGr$^+(3,8)$ and compare them to the cluster complex of the classical Grassmannian Gr$(3,8)$.

The Dressian and the tropical Grassmannian parameterize abstract and realizable tropical linear spaces; but in general, the Dressian is much larger than the tropical Grassmannian. There are natural positive notions of both of these spaces -- the positive Dressian, and the positive tropical Grassmannian (which we introduced roughly fifteen years ago) -- so it is natural to ask how these two positive spaces compare. In this paper we show that the positive Dressian equals the positive tropical Grassmannian. Using the connection between the positive Dressian and regular positroidal subdivisions of the hypersimplex, we use our result to give a new "tropical" proof of da Silva's 1987 conjecture (first proved in 2017 by Ardila-Rincon-Williams) that all positively oriented matroids are realizable. We also show that the finest regular positroidal subdivisions of the hypersimplex consist of series-parallel matroid polytopes, and achieve equality in Speyer's f-vector theorem. Finally we give an example of a positroidal subdivision of the hypersimplex which is not regular, and make a connection to the theory of tropical hyperplane arrangements.

In this note we present a formula for the Cachazo-Early-Guevara-Mizera (CEGM) generalized biadjoint amplitudes for all $k$ and $n$ on what we call the minimal kinematics. We prove that on the minimal kinematics, the scattering equations on the configuration space of $n$ points on $\mathbb{CP}^{k-1}$ has a unique solution, and that this solution is in the image of a Veronese embedding. The minimal kinematics is an all $k$ generalization of the one recently introduced by Early for $k=2$ and uses a choice of cyclic ordering. We conjecture an explicit formula for $m_n^{(k)}(\mathbb{I},\mathbb{I})$ which we have checked analytically through $n=10$ for all $k$. The answer is a simple rational function which has only simple poles; the poles have the combinatorial structure of the circulant graph ${\rm C}_n^{(1,2,\dots, k-2)}$. Generalized biadjoint amplitudes can also be evaluated using the positive tropical Grassmannian ${\rm Tr}^+{\rm G}(k,n)$ in terms of generalized planar Feynman diagrams. We find perfect agreement between both definitions for all cases where the latter is known in the literature. In particular, this gives the first strong consistency check on the $90\,608$ planar arrays for ${\rm Tr}^+{\rm G}(4,8)$ recently computed by Cachazo, Guevara, Umbert and Zhang. We also introduce another class of special kinematics called planar-basis kinematics which generalizes the one introduced by Cachazo, He and Yuan for $k=2$ and uses the planar basis recently introduced by Early for all $k$. Based on numerical computations through $n=8$ for all $k$, we conjecture that on the planar-basis kinematics $m_n^{(k)}(\mathbb{I},\mathbb{I})$ evaluates to the multidimensional Catalan numbers, suggesting the possibility of novel combinatorial interpretations. For $k=2$ these are the standard Catalan numbers.

We define and study the totally nonnegative part of the Chow quotient of the Grassmannian, or more simply the nonnegative configuration space. This space has a natural stratification by positive Chow cells, and we show that nonnegative configuration space is homeomorphic to a polytope as a stratified space. We establish bijections between positive Chow cells and the following sets: (a) regular subdivisions of the hypersimplex into positroid polytopes, (b) the set of cones in the positive tropical Grassmannian, and (c) the set of cones in the positive Dressian. Our work is motivated by connections to super Yang-Mills scattering amplitudes, which will be discussed in a sequel.