arXiv++ Combinatorics

Persistent homology summarizes the birth and death of topological features, but it does not by itself specify where a feature is located in the underlying complex. Harmonic persistent homology addresses this by assigning canonical harmonic cycle representatives to bars. In earlier work, Basu and Cox showed that harmonic representatives of simple bars maximize the total relative weight placed on essential simplices, the simplices that are forced to appear in representatives of the corresponding class. In this paper we prove that, for generic one-dimensional bars, this preference is stronger than an aggregate maximization statement. Every essential edge has strictly larger coefficient, in absolute value, than every non-essential edge in the harmonic representative, and the absolute values of the coefficients of all essential edges are equal. The key argument is a finite-dimensional variational characterization of the harmonic representative as a minimum-norm chain with prescribed boundary, combined with an elementary graph-theoretic cut argument. We then prove that the result is special to dimension one. In higher dimensions, the analogous coefficient-wise dominance statement fails. We give examples to show that harmonic representatives can place larger coefficients on non-essential higher-dimensional simplices than on essential ones. These results clarify both the power and the limitations of using harmonic representatives to assign geometric significance to simplices in persistent homology.

We obtain upper bounds, independent of the ambient dimension, for the number of realizable zero-nonzero patterns and (over ordered fields) sign conditions of a finite family of polynomials $\mathcal P$ restricted to an algebraic subset $V$ of affine or projective space. The bounds depend only on $\mathrm{card}(\mathcal P)$ and the degrees of the polynomials in $\mathcal P$, together with $\mathrm{deg}(V)$ and $\dim(V)$, and not on the dimension of the space in which $V$ is embedded. This feature is particularly useful when $V$ has small intrinsic dimension but is presented in a very high-dimensional ambient space. We describe several applications. First, we extend existing results on bounding the $\varepsilon$-entropy of real algebraic varieties. Second, we derive lower bounds (in terms of the number of connected components) for membership testing in semi-algebraic sets in the algebraic computation tree model. Finally, motivated by quantum complexity theory, we introduce additive and multiplicative notions of \emph{relative rank} in finite-dimensional vector spaces and algebras with respect to a fixed algebraic subset, generalizing the classical notion of tensor rank. We prove a general lower bound on the maximum relative rank of finite subsets with respect to algebraic sets of bounded degree and dimension that is again independent of the ambient dimension. As an illustration, we obtain a quantum analogue of Shannon's classical lower bound: almost all Boolean functions require classical circuits of size $Ω(2^n/n)$, even in the presence of a quantum oracle specified by an algebraic subset of fixed degree and dimension.

The concept of Vapnik-Chervonenkis (VC) density is pivotal across various mathematical fields, including discrete geometry, probability theory and model theory. In this paper, we introduce a topological generalization of VC-density. Let $Y$ be a topological space and $\mathcal{X}$ a family of closed subspaces of $Y$. For each $p \geq 0$, we define a number, $\mathrm{vcd}^{p}_{\mathcal{X}}$, which we refer to as the degree $p$ VC-density of the family $\mathcal{X}$. The classical notion of VC-density within this topological framework can be recovered by setting $p=0$. Our definition of degree $p$ VC-density extends to higher orders as well. For $p \geq 0$, $q \geq 1$, we define the degree $p$, order $q$ VC density $\mathrm{vcd}^{p,q}_{\mathcal{X}}$ of $\mathcal{X}$, which recovers Shelah's notion of higher order VC-density for $q$-dependent families when $p=0$. Our definition introduces a completely new notion when $p > 0$. We examine the properties of $\mathrm{vcd}_{\mathcal{X}}^p$ (as well as $\mathrm{vcd}^{p,q}_{\mathcal{X}}$) when the families $\mathcal{X}$ are definable in structures with some underlying topology (for instance, the Euclidean topology for o-minimal structures over $\mathbb{R}$, the analytic topology over $\mathbb{C}$, or the étale site for schemes over arbitrary algebraically closed fields). Our main result establishes that in any model of these theories \[ \mathrm{vcd}_{\mathcal{X}}^p \leq (p+1) \dim X, \] and more generally for any $q \geq 1$ \[ \mathrm{vcd}^{p,q}_{\mathcal{X}} \leq (p+q) \dim X. \] We give examples to show that our bounds are optimal. We also present combinatorial applications of our higher-degree VC-density bounds, deriving higher degree topological analogs of well-known results such as the existence of $\varepsilon$-nets and the fractional Helly theorem.

Let $\mathrm{R}$ be a real closed field. We prove that the number of semi-algebraically connected components of a real hypersurface in $\mathrm{R}^n$ defined by a multi-affine polynomial of degree $d$ is bounded by $2^{d-1}$. This bound is sharp and is independent of $n$ (as opposed to the classical bound of $d(2d -1)^{n-1}$ on the Betti numbers of hypersurfaces defined by arbitrary polynomials of degree $d$ in $\mathrm{R}^n$ due to Petrovski{\uı} and Ole{\uı}nik, Thom and Milnor). Moreover, we show there exists $c > 1$, such that given a sequence $(B_n)_{n >0}$ where $B_n$ is a closed ball in $\mathrm{R}^n$ of positive radious, there exist hypersurfaces $(V_n)_{n_>0}$ defined by symmetric multi-affine polynomials of degree $4$, such that $\sum_{i \leq 5} b_i(V_n \cap B_n) > c^n$, where $b_i(\cdot)$ denotes the $i$-th Betti number with rational coeffcients. Finally, as an application of the main result of the paper we verify a representational stability conjecture due to Basu and Riener on the cohomology modules of symmetric real algebraic sets for a new and much larger class of symmetric real algebraic sets than known before.

We prove an analog of the Szemerédi-Trotter theorem in the plane for definable curves and points in any o-minimal structure over an arbitrary real closed field $\mathrm{R}$. One new ingredient in the proof is an extension of the well known crossing number inequality for graphs to the case of embeddings in any o-minimal structure over an arbitrary real closed field.

We prove new bounds on the Betti numbers of real varieties and semi-algebraic sets that have a more refined dependence on the degrees of the polynomials defining them than results known before. Our method also unifies several different types of results under a single framework, such as bounds depending on the total degrees, on multi-degrees, as well as in the case of quadratic and partially quadratic polynomials. The bounds we present in the case of partially quadratic polynomials offer a significant improvement over what was previously known. Finally, we extend a result of Barone and Basu on bounding the number of connected components of real varieties defined by two polynomials of differing degrees to the sum of all Betti numbers, thus making progress on an open problem posed in that paper.

We consider symmetric (under the action of products of finite symmetric groups) real algebraic varieties and semi-algebraic sets, as well as symmetric complex varieties in affine and projective spaces, defined by polynomials of degrees bounded by a fixed constant $d$. We prove that if a Specht module, $\mathbb{S}^λ$, appears with positive multiplicity in the isotypic decomposition of the cohomology modules of such sets, then the rank of the partition $λ$ is bounded by $O(d)$. This implies a polynomial (in the dimension of the ambient space) bound on the number of such modules. Furthermore, we prove a polynomial bound on the multiplicities of those that do appear with positive multiplicity in the isotypic decomposition of the above mentioned cohomology modules. We give some applications of our methods in proving lower bounds on the degrees of defining polynomials of certain symmetric semi-algebraic sets, as well as improved bounds on the Betti numbers of the images under projections of (not necessarily symmetric) bounded real algebraic sets, improving in certain situations prior results of Gabrielov, Vorobjov and Zell.

We present a polynomial partitioning theorem for finite sets of points in the real locus of an irreducible complex algebraic variety of codimension at most two. This result generalizes the polynomial partitioning theorem on the Euclidean space of Guth and Katz, and its extension to hypersurfaces by Zahl and by Kaplan, Matoušek, Sharir and Safernová. We also present a bound for the number of incidences between points and hypersurfaces in the four-dimensional Euclidean space. It is an application of our partitioning theorem together with the refined bounds for the number of connected components of a semi-algebraic set by Barone and Basu.

Let $\mathrm{R}$ be a real closed field and $Q_1, \ldots, Q_{\ell} \in \mathrm{R}[X_1, \ldots,X_k]$ such that for each $i, 1 \leq i \leq \ell$, $\mathrm{deg} (Q_i) \leq d_i$. For $1 \leq i \leq \ell$, denote by $\mathcal{Q}_i = \{Q_1, \ldots, Q_i \}$, $V_i$ the real variety defined by $\mathcal{Q}_i$, and $k_i$ an upper bound on the real dimension of $V_i$ (by convention $V_0 = \mathrm{R}^k$ and $k_0 = k$). Suppose also that \[ 2 \leq d_1 \leq d_2 \leq \frac{1}{k + 1} d_3 \leq \frac{1}{(k + 1)^2} d_4 \leq \cdots \leq \frac{1}{(k + 1)^{\ell - 3}} d_{\ell - 1} \leq \frac{1}{(k + 1)^{\ell - 2}} d_{\ell}, \] and that $\ell \leq k$. We prove that the number of semi-algebraically connected components of $V_{\ell}$ is bounded by \[ O (k)^{2 k} \left(\prod_{1 \leq j < \ell} d_j^{k_{j - 1} - k_j} \right) d_{\ell}^{k_{\ell - 1}}. \] This bound can be seen as a weak extension of the classical Bezout inequality (which holds only over algebraically closed fields and is false over real closed fields) to varieties defined over real closed fields. Additionally, if $\mathcal{P} \subset \mathrm{R}[X_1, \ldots, X_k]$ is a finite family of polynomials with $\mathrm{deg} (P) \leq d$ for all $P \in \mathcal{P}$, $\mathrm{card}( \mathcal{P}) = s$, and $d_{\ell} \leq \frac{1}{k + 1} d$, we prove that the number of semi-algebraically connected components of the realizations of all realizable sign conditions of the family $\mathcal{P}$ restricted to $V_{\ell}$ is bounded by \[ O (k)^{2 k} (s d)^{k_{\ell}} \left(\prod_{1 \leq j \leq \ell} d_j^{k_{j - 1} - k_j} \right). \]

We prove that toric cubes, which are images of $[0,1]^d$ under monomial maps, are the closures of graphs of monotone maps, and in particular semi-algebraically homeomorphic to closed balls.

We consider sets and maps defined over an o-minimal structure over the reals, such as real semi-algebraic or subanalytic sets. A {\em monotone map} is a multi-dimensional generalization of a usual univariate monotone function, while the closure of the graph of a monotone map is a generalization of a compact convex set. In a particular case of an identically constant function, such a graph is called a {\em semi-monotone set}. Graphs of monotone maps are, generally, non-convex, and their intersections, unlike intersections of convex sets, can be topologically complicated. In particular, such an intersection is not necessarily the graph of a monotone map. Nevertheless, we prove a Helly-type theorem, which says that for a finite family of subsets of $\Real^n$, if all intersections of subfamilies, with cardinalities at most $n+1$, are non-empty and graphs of monotone maps, then the intersection of the whole family is non-empty and the graph of a monotone map.

Let $\R$ be a real closed field, $\mathcal{P},\mathcal{Q} \subset \R[X_1,...,X_k]$ finite subsets of polynomials, with the degrees of the polynomials in $\mathcal{P}$ (resp. $\mathcal{Q}$) bounded by $d$ (resp. $d_0$). Let $V \subset \R^k$ be the real algebraic variety defined by the polynomials in $\mathcal{Q}$ and suppose that the real dimension of $V$ is bounded by $k'$. We prove that the number of semi-algebraically connected components of the realizations of all realizable sign conditions of the family $\mathcal{P}$ on $V$ is bounded by $$ \displaylines{\sum_{j=0}^{k'}4^j{s +1\choose j}F_{d,d_0,k,k'}(j),}$$ where $s = \card \; \mathcal{P}$, and $$F_{d,d_0,k,k'}(j)= \textstyle\binom{k+1}{k-k'+j+1} \;(2d_0)^{k-k'}d^j\; \max{2d_0,d}^{k'-j} +2(k-j+1) .$$ In case $2 d_0 \leq d$, the above bound can be written simply as $$ \displaylines{\sum_{j = 0}^{k'} {s+1 \choose j}d^{k'} d_0^{k-k'} O(1)^{k} = (sd)^{k'} d_0^{k-k'} O(1)^k} $$ (in this form the bound was suggested by J. Matousek. Our result improves in certain cases (when $d_0 \ll d$) the best known bound of $$ \sum_{1 \leq j \leq k'} \binom{s}{j} 4^{j} d(2d-1)^{k-1} $$ on the same number proved earlier in the case $d=d_0$. The distinction between the bound $d_0$ on the degrees of the polynomials defining the variety $V$ and the bound $d$ on the degrees of the polynomials in $\mathcal{P}$ that appears in the new bound is motivated by several applications in discrete geometry.

Toda \cite{Toda} proved in 1989 that the (discrete) polynomial time hierarchy, $\mathbf{PH}$, is contained in the class $\mathbf{P}^{#\mathbf{P}}$, namely the class of languages that can be decided by a Turing machine in polynomial time given access to an oracle with the power to compute a function in the counting complexity class $#\mathbf{P}$. This result, which illustrates the power of counting is considered to be a seminal result in computational complexity theory. An analogous result (with a compactness hypothesis) in the complexity theory over the reals (in the sense of Blum-Shub-Smale real machines \cite{BSS89}) was proved in \cite{BZ09}. Unlike Toda's proof in the discrete case, which relied on sophisticated combinatorial arguments, the proof in \cite{BZ09} is topological in nature in which the properties of the topological join is used in a fundamental way. However, the constructions used in \cite{BZ09} were semi-algebraic -- they used real inequalities in an essential way and as such do not extend to the complex case. In this paper, we extend the techniques developed in \cite{BZ09} to the complex projective case. A key role is played by the complex join of quasi-projective complex varieties. As a consequence we obtain a complex analogue of Toda's theorem. The results contained in this paper, taken together with those contained in \cite{BZ09}, illustrate the central role of the Poincaré polynomial in algorithmic algebraic geometry, as well as, in computational complexity theory over the complex and real numbers -- namely, the ability to compute it efficiently enables one to decide in polynomial time all languages in the (compact) polynomial hierarchy over the appropriate field.

Toda proved in 1989 that the (discrete) polynomial time hierarchy, $\mathbf{PH}$, is contained in the class $\mathbf{P}^{#\mathbf{P}}$, namely the class of languages that can be decided by a Turing machine in polynomial time given access to an oracle with the power to compute a function in the counting complexity class $#\mathbf{P}$. This result which illustrates the power of counting is considered to be a seminal result in computational complexity theory. An analogous result in the complexity theory over the reals (in the sense of Blum-Shub-Smale real machines) has been missing so far. In this paper we formulate and prove a real analogue of Toda's theorem. Unlike Toda's proof in the discrete case, which relied on sophisticated combinatorial arguments, our proof is topological in nature. As a consequence of our techniques we are also able to relate the computational hardness of two extremely well-studied problems in algorithmic semi-algebraic geometry -- namely the problem of deciding sentences in the first order theory of the reals with a constant number of quantifier alternations, and that of computing Betti numbers of semi-algebraic sets. We obtain a polynomial time reduction of the compact version of the first problem to the second. This latter result might be of independent interest to researchers in algorithmic semi-algebraic geometry.

Let ${\mathcal S}(\R)$ be an o-minimal structure over $\R$, $T \subset \R^{k_1+k_2+\ell}$ a closed definable set, and $$ \displaylines{π_1: \R^{k_1+k_2+\ell}\to \R^{k_1 + k_2}, π_2: \R^{k_1+k_2+\ell}\to \R^{\ell}, \ π_3: \R^{k_1 + k_2} \to \R^{k_2}} $$ the projection maps. For any collection ${\mathcal A} = \{A_1,...,A_n\}$ of subsets of $\R^{k_1+k_2}$, and $\z \in \R^{k_2}$, let $\A_\z$ denote the collection of subsets of $\R^{k_1}$, $\{A_{1,\z},..., A_{n,\z}\}$, where $A_{i,\z} = A_i \cap π_3^{-1}(\z), 1 \leq i \leq n$. We prove that there exists a constant $C = C(T) > 0,$ such that for any family ${\mathcal A} = \{A_1,...,A_n\}$ of definable sets, where each $A_i = π_1(T \cap π_2^{-1}(\y_i))$, for some $\y_i \in \R^{\ell}$, the number of distinct stable homotopy types of $\A_\z, \z \in \R^{k_2}$, is bounded by $ \displaystyle{C \cdot n^{(k_1+1)k_2},} $ while the number of distinct homotopy types is bounded by $ \displaystyle{C \cdot n^{(k_1+3)k_2}.} $ This generalizes to the general o-minimal setting, bounds of the same type proved in \cite{BV} for semi-algebraic and semi-Pfaffian families. One main technical tool used in the proof of the above results, is a topological comparison theorem which might be of independent interest in the study of arrangements.

A real polynomial $P(X_1,..., X_n)$ sign represents $f: A^n \to \{0,1\}$ if for every $(a_1, ..., a_n) \in A^n$, the sign of $P(a_1,...,a_n)$ equals $(-1)^{f(a_1,...,a_n)}$. Such sign representations are well-studied in computer science and have applications to computational complexity and computational learning theory. In this work, we present a systematic study of tradeoffs between degree and sparsity of sign representations through the lens of the parity function. We attempt to prove bounds that hold for any choice of set $A$. We show that sign representing parity over $\{0,...,m-1\}^n$ with the degree in each variable at most $m-1$ requires sparsity at least $m^n$. We show that a tradeoff exists between sparsity and degree, by exhibiting a sign representation that has higher degree but lower sparsity. We show a lower bound of $n(m -2) + 1$ on the sparsity of polynomials of any degree representing parity over $\{0,..., m-1\}^n$. We prove exact bounds on the sparsity of such polynomials for any two element subset $A$. The main tool used is Descartes' Rule of Signs, a classical result in algebra, relating the sparsity of a polynomial to its number of real roots. As an application, we use bounds on sparsity to derive circuit lower bounds for depth-two AND-OR-NOT circuits with a Threshold Gate at the top. We use this to give a simple proof that such circuits need size $1.5^n$ to compute parity, which improves the previous bound of ${4/3}^{n/2}$ due to Goldmann (1997). We show a tight lower bound of $2^n$ for the inner product function over $\{0,1\}^n \times \{0, 1\}^n$.

In this paper we prove tight bounds on the combinatorial and topological complexity of sets defined in terms of $n$ definable sets belonging to some fixed definable family of sets in an o-minimal structure. This generalizes the combinatorial parts of similar bounds known in the case of semi-algebraic and semi-Pfaffian sets, and as a result vastly increases the applicability of results on combinatorial and topological complexity of arrangements studied in discrete and computational geometry. As a sample application, we extend a Ramsey-type theorem due to Alon et al., originally proved for semi-algebraic sets of fixed description complexity to this more general setting.

We prove an asymptotically tight bound (asymptotic with respect to the number of polynomials for fixed degrees and number of variables) on the number of semi-algebraically connected components of the realizations of all realizable sign conditions of a family of real polynomials. More precisely, we prove that the number of semi-algebraically connected components of the realizations of all realizable sign conditions of a family of $s$ polynomials in $\R[X_1,...,X_k]$ whose degrees are at most $d$ is bounded by \[ \frac{(2d)^k}{k!}s^k + O(s^{k-1}). \] This improves the best upper bound known previously which was \[ {1/2}\frac{(8d)^k}{k!}s^k + O(s^{k-1}). \] The new bound matches asymptotically the lower bound obtained for families of polynomials each of which is a product of generic polynomials of degree one.