arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study here several variants of the covariates fine balance problem where we generalize some of these problems and introduce a number of others. We present here a comprehensive complexity study of the covariates problems providing polynomial time algorithms, or a proof of NP-hardness. The polynomial time algorithms described are mostly combinatorial and rely on network flow techniques. In addition we present several fixed-parameter tractable results for problems where the number of covariates and the number of levels of each covariate are seen as a parameter.

We consider the problem of finding a Young diagram minimizing the sum of evaluations of a given pair of functions on the parts of the associated pair of conjugate partitions. While there are exponentially many diagrams, we show it is polynomial time solvable.

We construct an explicit family of 3XOR instances which is hard for $O(\sqrt{\log n})$ levels of the Sum-of-Squares hierarchy. In contrast to earlier constructions, which involve a random component, our systems can be constructed explicitly in deterministic polynomial time. Our construction is based on the high-dimensional expanders devised by Lubotzky, Samuels and Vishne, known as LSV complexes or Ramanujan complexes, and our analysis is based on two notions of expansion for these complexes: cosystolic expansion, and a local isoperimetric inequality due to Gromov. Our construction offers an interesting contrast to the recent work of Alev, Jeronimo and the last author~(FOCS 2019). They showed that 3XOR instances in which the variables correspond to vertices in a high-dimensional expander are easy to solve. In contrast, in our instances the variables correspond to the edges of the complex.

We consider cost constrained versions of the minimum spanning tree problem and the assignment problem. We assume edge weights are independent copies of a continuous random variable $Z$ that satisfies $F(x)=\Pr(Z\leq x)\approx x^α$ as $x\to0$, where $α\geq 1$. Also, there are $r=O(1)$ budget constraints with edge costs chosen from the same distribution. We use Lagrangean duality to construct polynomial time algorithms that produce asymptotically optimal solutions. For the spanning tree problem, we allow $r>1$, but for the assignment problem we can only analyse the case $r=1$.

The Sum-of-Squares (SoS) hierarchy is a semi-definite programming meta-algorithm that captures state-of-the-art polynomial time guarantees for many optimization problems such as Max-$k$-CSPs and Tensor PCA. On the flip side, a SoS lower bound provides evidence of hardness, which is particularly relevant to average-case problems for which NP-hardness may not be available. In this paper, we consider the following average case problem, which we call the \emph{Planted Affine Planes} (PAP) problem: Given $m$ random vectors $d_1,\ldots,d_m$ in $\mathbb{R}^n$, can we prove that there is no vector $v \in \mathbb{R}^n$ such that for all $u \in [m]$, $\langle v, d_u\rangle^2 = 1$? In other words, can we prove that $m$ random vectors are not all contained in two parallel hyperplanes at equal distance from the origin? We prove that for $m \leq n^{3/2-ε}$, with high probability, degree-$n^{Ω(ε)}$ SoS fails to refute the existence of such a vector $v$. When the vectors $d_1,\ldots,d_m$ are chosen from the multivariate normal distribution, the PAP problem is equivalent to the problem of proving that a random $n$-dimensional subspace of $\mathbb{R}^m$ does not contain a boolean vector. As shown by Mohanty--Raghavendra--Xu [STOC 2020], a lower bound for this problem implies a lower bound for the problem of certifying energy upper bounds on the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick Hamiltonian, and so our lower bound implies a degree-$n^{Ω(ε)}$ SoS lower bound for the certification version of the Sherrington-Kirkpatrick problem.

Treewidth is a parameter that emerged from the study of minor closed classes of graphs (i.e. classes closed under vertex and edge deletion, and edge contraction). It in some sense describes the global structure of a graph. Roughly, a graph has treewidth $k$ if it can be decomposed by a sequence of noncrossing cutsets of size at most $k$ into pieces of size at most $k+1$. The study of hereditary graph classes (i.e. those closed under vertex deletion only) reveals a different picture, where cutsets that are not necessarily bounded in size (such as star cutsets, 2-joins and their generalization) are required to decompose the graph into simpler pieces that are structured but not necessarily bounded in size. A number of such decomposition theorems are known for complex hereditary graph classes, including even-hole-free graphs, perfect graphs and others. These theorems do not describe the global structure in the sense that a tree decomposition does, since the cutsets guaranteed by them are far from being noncrossing. They are also of limited use in algorithmic applications. We show that in the case of even-hole-free graphs of bounded degree the cutsets described in the previous paragraph can be partitioned into a bounded number of well-behaved collections. This allows us to prove that even-hole-free graphs with bounded degree have bounded treewidth, resolving a conjecture of Aboulker, Adler, Kim, Sintiari and Trotignon [arXiv:2008.05504]. As a consequence, it follows that many algorithmic problems can be solved in polynomial time for this class, and that even-hole-freeness is testable in the bounded degree graph model of property testing. In fact we prove our results for a larger class of graphs, namely the class of $C_4$-free odd-signable graphs with bounded degree.

In this note we show that pattern matching in permutations is polynomial time reducible to pattern matching in set partitions. In particular, pattern matching in set partitions is NP-Complete.

Given a graph $G$, the $k$-mixing problem asks: Can one obtain all $k$-colourings of $G$, starting from one $k$-colouring $f$, by changing the colour of only one vertex at a time, while at each step maintaining a $k$-colouring? More generally, for a graph $H$, the $H$-mixing problem asks: Can one obtain all homomorphisms $G \to H$, starting from one homomorphism $f$, by changing the image of only one vertex at a time, while at each step maintaining a homomorphism $G \to H$? This paper focuses on a generalization of $k$-colourings, namely $(p,q)$-circular colourings. We show that when $2 < \frac{p}{q} < 4$, a graph $G$ is $(p,q)$-mixing if and only if for any $(p,q)$-colouring $f$ of $G$, and any cycle $C$ of $G$, the wind of the cycle under the colouring equals a particular value (which intuitively corresponds to having no wind). As a consequence we show that $(p,q)$-mixing is closed under a restricted homomorphism called a fold. Using this, we deduce that $(2k+1,k)$-mixing is co-NP-complete for all $k \in \mathbb{N}$, and by similar ideas we show that if the circular chromatic number of a connected graph $G$ is $\frac{2k+1}{k}$, then $G$ folds to $C_{2k+1}$. We use the characterization to settle a conjecture of Brewster and Noel, specifically that the circular mixing number of bipartite graphs is $2$. Lastly, we give a polynomial time algorithm for $(p,q)$-mixing in planar graphs when $3 \leq \frac{p}{q} <4$.

A unique sink orientation (USO) is an orientation of the hypercube graph with the property that every face has a unique sink. A number of well-studied problems reduce in strongly polynomial time to finding the global sink of a USO; most notably, linear programming (LP) and the P-matrix linear complementarity problem (P-LCP). The former is not known to have a strongly polynomial-time algorithm, while the latter is not known to even have a polynomial-time algorithm, motivating the problem to find the global sink of a USO. Although, every known class of geometric USOs, arising from a concrete problem such as LP, is exponentially small, relative to the class of all USOs. Accordingly, geometric USOs exhibit additional properties that set them apart from general USOs, and it may be advantageous, if not necessary, to leverage these properties to find the global sink of a USO faster. Only a few such properties are known. In this paper, we establish a new combinatorial property of the USOs that arise from symmetric P-LCP, which includes the USOs that arise from linear and simple convex quadratic programming.

We study the neighborhood polynomial and the complexity of its computation for chordal graphs. The neighborhood polynomial of a graph is the generating function of subsets of its vertices that have a common neighbor. We introduce a parameter for chordal graphs called anchor width and an algorithm to compute the neighborhood polynomial which runs in polynomial time if the anchor width is polynomially bounded. The anchor width is the maximal number of different sub-cliques of a clique which appear as a common neighborhood. Furthermore we study the anchor width for chordal graphs and some subclasses such as chordal comparability graphs and chordal graphs with bounded leafage. the leafage of a chordal graphs is the minimum number of leaves in the host tree of a subtree representation. We show that the anchor width of a chordal graph is at most $n^{\ell}$ where $\ell$ denotes the leafage. This shows that for some subclasses computing the neighborhood polynomial is possible in polynomial time while it is NP-hard for general chordal graphs.

The orientation completion problem for a fixed class of oriented graphs asks whether a given partially oriented graph can be completed to an oriented graph in the class. Orientation completion problems have been studied recently for several classes of oriented graphs, yielding both polynomial time solutions and NP-completeness results. Local tournaments are a well-structured class of oriented graphs that generalize tournaments and their underlying graphs are intimately related to proper circular-arc graphs. Proper interval graphs are precisely those which can be oriented as acyclic local tournaments. It has been proved that the orientation completion problems for local tournaments and acyclic local tournaments are both polynomial time solvable. In this paper we identify the obstructions for acyclic local tournament orientation completions. These are in a sense minimal partially oriented graphs that cannot be completed to acyclic local tournaments. Our description of the obstructions imply that they can be recognized in polynomial time. In a companion paper we will determine all obstructions for local tournament orientation completions.

An even (respectively, odd) hole in a graph is an induced cycle with even (respectively, odd) length that is at least four. Bienstock [DM 1991 and 1992] proved that detecting an even (respectively, odd) hole containing a given vertex is NP-complete. Conforti, Chornuéjols, Kappor, and Vušković [FOCS 1997] gave the first known polynomial-time algorithm to determine whether a graph contains even holes. Chudnovsky, Kawarabayashi, and Seymour [JGT 2005] estimated that Conforti et al.'s algorithm runs in $O(n^{40})$ time on an $n$-vertex graph and reduced the required time to $O(n^{31})$. Subsequently, da~Silva and Vušković~[JCTB 2013], Chang and Lu [JCTB 2017], and Lai, Lu, and Thorup [STOC 2020] improved the time to $O(n^{19})$, $O(n^{11})$, and $O(n^9)$, respectively. The tractability of determining whether a graph contains odd holes has been open for decades until the algorithm of Chudnovsky, Scott, Seymour, and Spirkl [JACM 2020] that runs in $O(n^9)$ time, which Lai et al. also reduced to $O(n^8)$. By extending Chudnovsky et al.'s techniques for detecting odd holes, Chudnovsky, Scott, and Seymour [Combinatorica 2020 to appear] (respectively, [arXiv 2020]) ensured the tractability of finding a long (respectively, shortest) odd hole. They also ensured the NP-hardness of finding a longest odd hole, whose reduction also works for finding a longest even hole. Recently, Cook and Seymour ensured the tractability of finding a long even hole. An intriguing missing piece is the tractability of finding a shortest even hole, left open for at least 15 years by, e.g., Chudnovsky et al. [JGT 2005] and Johnson [TALG 2005]. We resolve this long-standing open problem by giving the first known polynomial-time algorithm, running in $O(n^{31})$ time, for finding a shortest even hole in an $n$-vertex graph that contains even holes.

B$_0$-VPG graphs are intersection graphs of vertical and horizontal line segments on a plane. Cohen, Golumbic, Trotter, and Wang [Order, 2016] pose the question of characterizing B$_0$-VPG permutation graphs. We respond here by characterizing B$_0$-VPG cocomparability graphs. This characterization also leads to a polynomial time recognition and B$_0$-VPG drawing algorithm for the class. Our B$_0$-VPG drawing algorithm starts by fixing any one of the many posets $P$ whose cocomparability graph is the input graph $G$. The drawing we obtain not only visualizes $G$ in that one can distinguish comparable pairs from incomparable ones, but one can also identify which among a comparable pair is larger in $P$ from this visualization.

We describe a polynomial-time algorithm which, given a graph $G$ with treewidth $t$, approximates the pathwidth of $G$ to within a ratio of $O(t\sqrt{\log t})$. This is the first algorithm to achieve an $f(t)$-approximation for some function $f$. Our approach builds on the following key insight: every graph with large pathwidth has large treewidth or contains a subdivision of a large complete binary tree. Specifically, we show that every graph with pathwidth at least $th+2$ has treewidth at least $t$ or contains a subdivision of a complete binary tree of height $h+1$. The bound $th+2$ is best possible up to a multiplicative constant. This result was motivated by, and implies (with $c=2$), the following conjecture of Kawarabayashi and Rossman (SODA'18): there exists a universal constant $c$ such that every graph with pathwidth $Ω(k^c)$ has treewidth at least $k$ or contains a subdivision of a complete binary tree of height $k$. Our main technical algorithm takes a graph $G$ and some (not necessarily optimal) tree decomposition of $G$ of width $t'$ in the input, and it computes in polynomial time an integer $h$, a certificate that $G$ has pathwidth at least $h$, and a path decomposition of $G$ of width at most $(t'+1)h+1$. The certificate is closely related to (and implies) the existence of a subdivision of a complete binary tree of height $h$. The approximation algorithm for pathwidth is then obtained by combining this algorithm with the approximation algorithm of Feige, Hajiaghayi, and Lee (STOC'05) for treewidth.

This paper addresses the robust single machine makespan scheduling with uncertain release dates of the jobs. The release dates take values within know intervals. We use the concept of gamma-robustness in two different settings and address both the robust absolute and robust regret criteria. Our main results are polynomial time algorithms which have the same running time (O(n log n)) as the best algorithms for the non-robust case.

An upper bound on the trace function of a hypergraph $H$ is derived and its applications are demonstrated. For instance, a new upper bound for the VC dimension of $H$, or $vc(H)$, follows as a consequence and can be used to compute $vc(H)$ in polynomial time provided that $H$ has bounded degeneracy. This was not previously known. Particularly, when $H$ is a hypergraph arising from closed neighborhoods of a graph, this approach asymptotically improves the time complexity of the previous result for computing $vc(H)$. Another consequence is a general lower bound on the {\it distinguishing transversal number } of $H$ that gives rise to applications in domination theory of graphs. To effectively apply the methods developed here, one needs to have good estimations of degeneracy, and its variation or reduced degeneracy which is introduced here.

We describe several graphs with arbitrarily large rankwidth (or equivalently with arbitrarily large cliquewidth). Korpelainen, Lozin, and Mayhill [Split permutation graphs, Graphs and Combinatorics, 30(3):633-646, 2014] proved that there exist split graphs with Dilworth number 2 with arbitrarily large rankwidth, but without explicitly constructing them. We provide an explicit construction. Maffray, Penev, and Vušković [Coloring rings, Journal of Graph Theory 96(4):642-683, 2021] proved that graphs that they call rings on $n$ sets can be colored in polynomial time. We show that for every fixed integer $n\geq 3$, there exist rings on $n$ sets with arbitrarily large rankwidth. When $n\geq 5$ and $n$ is odd, this provides a new construction of even-hole-free graphs with arbitrarily large rankwidth.

Finding large cliques or cliques missing a few edges is a fundamental algorithmic task in the study of real-world graphs, with applications in community detection, pattern recognition, and clustering. A number of effective backtracking-based heuristics for these problems have emerged from recent empirical work in social network analysis. Given the NP-hardness of variants of clique counting, these results raise a challenge for beyond worst-case analysis of these problems. Inspired by the triadic closure of real-world graphs, Fox et al. (SICOMP 2020) introduced the notion of $c$-closed graphs and proved that maximal clique enumeration is fixed-parameter tractable with respect to $c$. In practice, due to noise in data, one wishes to actually discover "near-cliques", which can be characterized as cliques with a sparse subgraph removed. In this work, we prove that many different kinds of maximal near-cliques can be enumerated in polynomial time (and FPT in $c$) for $c$-closed graphs. We study various established notions of such substructures, including $k$-plexes, complements of bounded-degeneracy and bounded-treewidth graphs. Interestingly, our algorithms follow relatively simple backtracking procedures, analogous to what is done in practice. Our results underscore the significance of the $c$-closed graph class for theoretical understanding of social network analysis.

We develop a general embedding method based on the Friedman-Pippenger tree embedding technique (1987) and its algorithmic version, essentially due to Aggarwal et al. (1996), enhanced with a roll-back idea allowing to sequentially retrace previously performed embedding steps. We use this method to obtain the following results. -We show that the size-Ramsey number of logarithmically long subdivisions of bounded degree graphs is linear in their number of vertices, settling a conjecture of Pak (2002). -We give a deterministic, polynomial time online algorithm for finding vertex-disjoint paths of prescribed length between given pairs of vertices in an expander graph. Our result answers a question of Alon and Capalbo (2007). -We show that relatively weak bounds on the spectral ratio of $d$-regular graphs force the existence of a topological minor of $K_t$ where $t=(1-o(1))d$. We also exhibit a construction which shows that the theoretical maximum $t=d+1$ cannot be attained even if $λ=O(\sqrt{d})$. This answers a question of Fountoulakis, Kühn and Osthus (2009).

We study two notions of being well-structured for classes of graphs that are inspired by classic model theory. A class of graphs $C$ is monadically stable if it is impossible to define arbitrarily long linear orders in vertex-colored graphs from $C$ using a fixed first-order formula. Similarly, monadic dependence corresponds to the impossibility of defining all graphs in this way. Examples of monadically stable graph classes are nowhere dense classes, which provide a robust theory of sparsity. Examples of monadically dependent classes are classes of bounded rankwidth (or equivalently, bounded cliquewidth), which can be seen as a dense analog of classes of bounded treewidth. Thus, monadic stability and monadic dependence extend classical structural notions for graphs by viewing them in a wider, model-theoretical context. We explore this emerging theory by proving the following: - A class of graphs $C$ is a first-order transduction of a class with bounded treewidth if and only if $C$ has bounded rankwidth and a stable edge relation (i.e. graphs from $C$ exclude some half-graph as a semi-induced subgraph). - If a class of graphs $C$ is monadically dependent and not monadically stable, then $C$ has in fact an unstable edge relation. As a consequence, we show that classes with bounded rankwidth excluding some half-graph as a semi-induced subgraph are linearly $χ$-bounded. Our proofs are effective and lead to polynomial time algorithms.