arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove Graffiti.pc Conjecture 2, a 1996 conjecture listed as open on the \emph{Written on the Wall II} page marked ``Last update 7/23/26.'' Let $G$ be a finite simple connected graph. For $v\in V(G)$, let $I(v)=α(G[N_G(v)])$, and let $I_{\mathrm{avg}}(G)$ be the average of these local independence numbers. The conjecture states that the maximum number $L_s(G)$ of leaves in a spanning tree of $G$ satisfies $L_s(G)\ge 2\bigl(I_{\mathrm{avg}}(G)-1\bigr)$. We establish this inequality by extracting a triangle-free spanning subgraph that retains at least half of the total local-independence mass. A degree-square argument then produces a double star with sufficiently many leaves, and this tree extends to a spanning tree without losing leaves. Balanced complete bipartite graphs show that the bound is sharp.

Let $Γ$ be a straight-line crossing-free drawing of a tree $T$. A \emph{bad pair} in $Γ$ is a pair of non-adjacent vertices of $T$ whose Euclidean distance in $Γ$ is smaller than the length of the longest edge in the path connecting them in~$Γ$. When $Γ$ has no bad pairs, $Γ$ is a Euclidean Minimum Spanning Tree of its vertex set (or EMST-drawing for short). Deciding whether a tree of maximum degree at most six admits an EMST-drawing is known to be \NP-hard. In contrast, we characterize those caterpillars that admit an EMST-drawing. The characterization gives rise to a linear-time algorithm that decides if a caterpillar admits an EMST-drawing, and in the affirmative case, computes such a drawing. For caterpillars of maximum degree six, we further present a linear-time algorithm to compute a crossing-free straight-line drawing with the minimum number of bad pairs. For $n$-vertex trees with maximum vertex degree $Δ$, we prove the $Δ^2n\log n$ upper bound on the minimum number of bad pairs. In the special case of stars, we construct a drawing with the minimum number of bad pairs.

A quasi-tree of a connected ribbon graph is a spanning ribbon subgraph with exactly one boundary component; quasi-trees play the role of spanning trees in the topological graph theory of embedded graphs. We prove that counting them is #P-complete under polynomial-time Turing reductions, already for bouquets. The proof identifies every nonempty framed chord diagram, up to natural identifications, with a 4-regular map equipped with a distinguished A-trail, in such a way that quasi-trees correspond to A-trails, whose counting is #P-complete by a theorem of Ge and Štefankovič. Through the framed Cohn-Lempel equality the count is also an interlace-polynomial evaluation - $q(H;2,1)$, the number of full-rank induced subgraphs of the looped circle graph $H$ of the diagram - placing it on the line $y=1$ left open in the complexity classification of Bläser and Hoffmann; a cloning argument then makes every fixed rational point of that line, other than the trivial $(1,1)$, #P-hard on looped circle graphs, even when a framed chord representation is supplied. On the tractable side, the same GF(2) model yields short proofs of the known determinantal cases: for orientable ribbon graphs the count is a determinant, essentially the Matrix-Quasi-tree Theorem of Merino, Moffatt and Noble, proved here via Bouchet's principal unimodularity, and for bouquets with exactly one non-orientable loop it is a sum of two orientable determinants, equivalent by a rank-one determinant identity to the determinant formula of Deng, Jin and Yan.

Recently, Merino and Mütze (FOCS'23+SICOMP'24) presented an algorithm for computing a Hamilton path on the skeleton of any 0/1-polytope ${\rm conv}(X)$, where $X\subseteq\{0,1\}^n$. The algorithm uses as a black box an algorithm for solving the classical linear optimization problem $\min\{w\cdot x\mid x\in X\}$ for some weight vector $w\in\mathbb{R}^n$. The resulting delay per visited vertex on the Hamilton path is only by a $\log n$ factor larger than the time to solve one instance of the optimization algorithm. In this paper, we make the Hamilton path algorithm simpler and faster. Namely, we obtain an amortized delay that is only by a constant factor larger than the running time of the optimization algorithm, thus removing the $\log n$ factor. As concrete results, this yields improved algorithms for generating bases and independent sets in a matroid, spanning trees, forests, matchings and maximum matchings in a graph, vertex covers, minimum vertex covers, independent sets and maximum independent sets in a bipartite graph, and antichains, maximum antichains and ideals in a poset. All of these listings correspond to Hamilton paths on the corresponding polytopes. Furthermore, we obtain an $\mathcal{O}(t_{\rm LP})$ amortized delay algorithm for the vertex enumeration problem on 0/1-polytopes $\{x\in\mathbb{R}^n\mid Ax\leq b\}$, where $A\in \mathbb{R}^{m\times n}$ and $b\in\mathbb{R}^m$, and $t_{\rm LP}$ is the time needed to solve the linear program $\min\{w\cdot x\mid Ax\leq b\}$. This improves upon the $\mathcal{O}(t_{\rm LP} \log n)$ delay algorithm of Merino and Mütze, and the previous $\mathcal{O}(t_{\rm LP}\,n)$ delay algorithm of Bussieck and Lübbecke from 1998.

For an explicitly represented finite empirical model, deciding whether the contextual fraction is strictly below one is NP-complete, while the standard exact linear program has one column for every global assignment. We identify a permutation-transport class in which this global problem collapses to a fixed-point calculation. Let a connected permutation gain graph act on a finite state set $O$, let $H \leq{ \rm Sym}(O)$ be its holonomy subgroup, let $F = {\rm Fix}(H)$, and let $p$ be an $H$-invariant root distribution. For the induced empirical model, \[ {\rm NCF}(e)=p(F),\qquad {\rm CF}(e)=1-p(F). \] Consequently, compatibility, $F$, and ${\rm CF}(e)$ are computable in $O(|O|(|V|+|E|))$ arithmetic and table operations. For every finite simple $2$-edge-connected graph, any deterministic exact algorithm in the explicit permutation-table query model requires at least $(|O|-1)|E|$ probes in the worst case, making the dependence on the input tables optimal up to constant factors. With a fixed spanning tree, chord insertions and deletions require $O(|O|)$ worst-case time, or time proportional to the moved-set representation, while compatibility and contextual-fraction queries take $O(1)$ time. Finally, for common-marginal realizable binary constraint languages, the support threshold ${\rm CF} < 1$ is polynomial-time equivalent to the associated finite-domain constraint-satisfaction problem and therefore inherits the Bulatov--Zhuk dichotomy. The results identify a query-optimal and dynamically maintainable tractability island inside the general contextual-fraction problem.

Let $G$ be a digraph with vertex set $\{1,2,...,n\}$ and $H_{1},H_{2},...,H_{n}$ be $n$ digraphs. The generalized join digraph $\overrightarrow{G}=G[H_{1},H_{2},...,H_{n}]$ is a digraph obtained from $G$ by replacing each vertex $i$ with $H_{i}$ and for any $u\in V(H_{i})$ and $v\in V(H_{j})$, $(u,v)\in E(\overrightarrow{G})$ if and only if $(i,j)\in E(G)$. In this paper we express the number of oriented spanning trees in $\overrightarrow{G}$ in terms of Laplacian eigenvalues of $H_{1},H_{2},...,H_{n}$ and oriented spanning trees of $G$. Furthermore, we consider the number of oriented spanning trees with a fixed root in $\overrightarrow{G}$. First, we introduce the biclique-directed star transformation formula for counting oriented spanning trees with a fixed root in digraphs. Using it, we give the formula for the total number of oriented spanning trees with roots in a certain $H_{i}$ $(1\leq i \leq n)$ of $\overrightarrow{G}$ in terms of Laplacian eigenvalues of $H_{1},H_{2},...,H_{n}$ and oriented spanning trees of $G$. As applications, when each $H_{i}$ is a given digraph, the enumerative formulas for oriented spanning trees with a fixed root of $\overrightarrow{G}$ are derived from our work.

We study tropical circuits with scalar multiplication gates, that is, algebraic circuits whose gates implement $\max$, $+$, or multiplication with a positive constant. For such circuits, we prove exponential size lower bounds for computing maximum weight directed spanning trees and maximum weight bipartite perfect matchings. As a corollary, we obtain an exponential size separation between monotone and non-monotone maxout neural networks, which generalize the popularly used ReLU neural networks. One conclusion from this is that neural network models with enforced convexity constraints, such as input-convex neural networks (ICNNs), sometimes need to be exponentially larger than their unrestricted counterparts in order to express the same functions.

Very recently, using Meshulam's lemma, Blagojević proved a constrained version of the colorful Carathéodory theorem for joins of bipartite spanning trees and wedge of spheres. Our main contribution extends his result from joins of bipartite spanning trees with wedges of spheres to joins of spanning \(k\)-trees with wedges of spheres. Our proof is elementary and avoids the topological machinery. We also discuss a homological variation of spanning \(k\)-trees and some Carathéodory-type results for them.

Negami's Planar Cover Conjecture asserts that a connected graph has a finite planar cover if and only if it can be embedded on the projective plane. While this statement has already been proven for rotation compatible planar covers, namely covers equipped with a certain condition on the rotation system, the existing proof relies on advanced algebraic and topological methods. In this paper, we provide another proof of this result, focusing primarily on combinatorial arguments based on a structural analysis with respect to a spanning tree in the base graph.

A graph $G$ is $τ_k$-maximal if $G$ contains no subgraph admitting $k+1$ edge-disjoint spanning trees, while the addition of any edge in the complement of $G$ yields a subgraph that admits $k+1$ edge-disjoint spanning trees. In this paper, we prove that for any integers $k\geq 1$ and $n\geq 2k+2$, every $τ_k$-maximal graph of order $n$ satisfies $|E(G)|\leq (k+1)(n-1)-1$. Furthermore, we construct a family of $τ_k$-maximal graphs on $n\ge 2k+2$ vertices that have exactly $(k+1)(n-1)-1$ edges, which establishes the tightness of the upper bound. Then we conjecture that every $τ_k$-maximal graph on $n$ vertices has exactly $(k+1)(n-1)-1$ edges, and we verify the conjecture for the case $k=1$.

We study how fixed-volume spanning-tree extremality changes when product-grid boundary factors are free, periodic, or mixed. In two dimensions, extremality depends sharply on the boundary type. The free/free and periodic/periodic products both obey a closest-to-square principle: among fixed-area rectangles, $P_r\square P_s$ and $C_r\square C_s$ are maximized by the closest-to-square admissible side lengths. The mixed free/periodic cylinder $P_r\square C_s$ is different: closest-to-square fails, and in the divisor-rich case the optimizing cyclic circumference has scale $N^{1/3}$ when the area is $N=rs$. In arbitrary dimension we prove pairwise balancing theorems for pure free products and pure periodic products, and then strengthen them by a heat-trace Schur-concavity theorem in logarithmic side lengths. At perfect-power volume this gives the unique maximizers $P_n^{\square d}$ and, for $n\ge3$, $C_n^{\square d}$. These product-grid comparisons motivate perfect-power conjectures for connected induced lattice subgraphs and periodic analogues.

A family of spanning trees of a graph is $t$-intersecting if any pair of spanning trees in the family has $t$ or more edges in common. For sufficiently large $n$ and $t \leq n/C\log_2 n$ for some absolute constant $C>0$, we give a nearly complete characterization of the extremal $t$-intersecting families of spanning trees in balanced complete bipartite graphs with parts of order $n$. In particular, for $t=1$, we give exact bounds and a full characterization of the extremal families. For $t \geq 2$, our bounds are tight up to lower-order terms, and we show that any extremal $t$-intersecting family is of the form $\mathcal{F} \cup \mathcal{S}'$ where $\mathcal{F}$ is a family of all trees containing a fixed $t$-matching, and $\mathcal{S}'$ is a distinguished set of exceptional trees of size $|\mathcal{S}'| = o(|\mathcal{F}|)$.

We prove a new combinatorial identity for the determinant of the resistance matrix of a finite graph, which involves counts of spanning trees and forests. This generalizes a result of Graham and Pollak on distances matrices of trees. We make use of Bapat's expression of the resistance matrix determinant as a linear algebraic quantity.

The toughness of a graph is a crucial parameter for characterizing its structural properties. The toughness of a non-complete graph $G$ is defined as $τ(G) = \min \{ \dfrac{|S|}{c(G - S)} : S \subseteq V(G), c(G-S) > 1 \}$, where $c(G)$ denotes the number of components of $G$. We define $τ(K_n) = \infty$. A graph $G$ is said to be $τ$-tough if $|S| \ge τ\cdot c(G-S)$ for every vertex cut $S$ of $G$. Let $k \ge 3$ be an integer. For $\frac{1}{k-η}$-tough graphs with $η\in \{0, 1\}$, Liu, Fan and Shu \cite{a34} derived sufficient conditions in terms of the spectral radius and the signless Laplacian spectral radius for the existence of a spanning $k$-tree. Jia and Lu \cite{a24}, for the case $\frac{1}{k-1} \leq τ(G) < \frac{1}{k-2}$, established sufficient conditions in terms of the spectral radius and the signless Laplacian spectral radius for the existence of a spanning $k$-tree. Motivated by these results, in this paper, we further investigate sufficient conditions for the existence of a spanning $k$-tree when $\frac{1}{k} \leq τ(G) < \frac{1}{k-1}$. Specifically, for a connected $\frac{t}{t(k-1)+1}$-tough graph of sufficiently large order $n$ (where $t \ge 1$ is an integer), we provide sufficient conditions for the existence of a spanning $k$-tree in terms of the spectral radius and the signless Laplacian spectral radius. Furthermore, we establish a lower bound on the size (number of edges) to guarantee the existence of a spanning $k$-tree.

Let $G$ be a finite connected weighted graph and let $R$ be its effective-resistance matrix. For every nonempty vertex set $S$, we factor the cofactor sum and determinant of the principal resistance submatrix $R[S]$ into an enumerative term and a boundary potential-theoretic term. If $τ(G)$ is the weighted spanning tree enumerator and $κ_G(S)$ is the weighted enumerator of $S$-rooted spanning forests, then \[ \cof R[S]=(-2)^{|S|-1}κ_G(S)/τ(G). \] After Kron reduction to $S$, with reduced Laplacian $K=L^S$, $Q=K^+$, and $q=\diag(Q)$, the remaining normalized factor is \[ \det R[S]/\cof R[S] =\frac{2}{|S|}\tr Q+\frac12 q^{\mathsf T}Kq. \] The cofactor factor is a principal specialization of known resistance-minor identities; the contribution here is the boundary/Kron-reduction factorization and local radius calculus. Equivalently, the normalized factor is the maximum of $u^{\mathsf T}R[S]u$ over all $u\in\R^S$ satisfying $\one^{\mathsf T}u=1$. This optimization viewpoint yields monotonicity under enlargement of $S$, an exact one-point update formula, and a support criterion for equality. Small star examples show that the resulting set function is neither submodular nor supermodular in general.

In this note, we prove a tight lower bound on symmetric extended formulations for the spanning tree polytope of the complete graph. More precisely, let $P_{ST}(K_n)$ be the spanning tree polytope of $K_n$. We show that, for all $n\ge13$, every symmetric extended formulation for $P_{ST}(K_n)$ has at least $\binom n3$ inequalities. Since the classical Martin formulation has a symmetric formulation of size $O(n^3)$, this gives \[ \operatorname{xcs}(P_{ST}(K_n))=Θ(n^3). \]

Let $T_{1}, T_{2}, \dots, T_{k}$ be $k$ spanning trees of a graph $G$. For any pair of vertices $u$ and $v$, if the $u$--$v$ paths in the $k$ spanning trees are pairwise openly disjoint, then the spanning trees are called completely independent spanning trees (CISTs) of $G$. In this paper, we first prove that every 3-connected 2-outerplanar triangulated disc has two completely independent spanning trees. Next, for a 3-connected 3-outerplanar triangulated disc $G$, we provide sufficient conditions for $G$ to have two completely independent spanning trees. We provide an example of a 3-connected 4-outerplanar triangulation that does not have two completely independent spanning trees.

For integers $k\ge 1$ and $n\ge k+1$, let $\operatorname{ex}^{\mathrm{HIST}}_k(n)$ denote the maximum number of edges in a $k$-connected graph of order $n$ which contains no homeomorphically irreducible spanning tree (or briefly HIST). We determine these extremal numbers for $k=1$ and $k=2$. More precisely, we prove that $\operatorname{ex}^{\mathrm{HIST}}_1(n)=\binom{n-2}{2}+2$ for $n\ge 9$, with $L_n$ as the unique extremal graph, and that $\operatorname{ex}^{\mathrm{HIST}}_2(n)=\binom{n-3}{2}+4$ for $n\ge 13$, with $B_n$ as the unique extremal graph. This provides a Turán-type extremal result for spanning trees with no vertices of degree two.

Spherical $G$-parking functions are a distinguished subset of standard monomials, arising from the skeleton ideals of the $G$-parking function ideal. Explicit spherical $G$-parking function enumeration formulas are known only in a few classes of graphs. In this paper, we consider a family of graphs $\Gl$ ($1\leq \ell \leq n-2$), obtained from the complete bipartite $K_{n+1}$ by deleting the $\ell$ edges joining vertex $1$ to the vertices in $F_\ell= \{n-\ell+1, \ldots, n\}$. The uprooted spanning trees of $\Gl-\{0\}$ are counted by the set $\UnFl$ of uprooted trees with the vertex set $[n]$ in which vertex $1$ is not adjacent to any vertex in $F_\ell$, and we establish that $|\UnFl| = (n-1)^{n-\ell-2}(n-2)^{\ell}(n-\ell-1).$ We derive this formula combinatorially and independently recover it as an application of the matrix tree theorem, obtaining some combinatorial identities as consequences. Finally, we determine the number of spherical $\Gl$-parking functions as $|\SPF(\Gl)| = (n-1)^{n-3}(n-\ell-1)^2.$

We prove that if an $n$-vertex graph $G$ is non-extremal and $T$ is a bounded degree tree on $n$ vertices, then $T\subset G$ even when the minimum degree of $G$ is less than $n/2$ by a linear term. We avoid the use of the Regularity lemma, instead we apply a vertex decomposition theorem by the author, which does not require a tower-type lower bound for $n.$