arXiv++ Combinatorics

An independent set may not contain both a vertex and one of its neighbours. This basic fact makes the uniform distribution over independent sets rather special. We consider the hard-core model, an essential generalization of the uniform distribution over independent sets. We show how its local analysis yields remarkable insights into the global structure of independent sets in the host graph, in connection with, for instance, Ramsey numbers, graph colourings, and sphere packings.

Let $S_n$ denote the set of permutations of $[n]$ and let $σ=σ_1\cdotsσ_n\in S_n$. For a subsequence $\{σ_{i_j}\}_{j=1}^k$ of $\{σ_i\}_{i=1}^n$ of length $k\ge2$, construct the ``up/down'' sequence $V_1\cdots V_{k-1}$ defined by $$ V_j=\begin{cases} U,\ \text{if}\ σ_{i_j+1}-σ_{i_j}>0;\\ D,\ \text{if}\ σ_{i_j+1}-σ_{i_j}<0.\end{cases} $$ Consider now a fixed up/down pattern: $V_1\cdots V_l$, where $l\in\mathbb{N}$ and $V_j\in\{U, D\},\ j\in[l]$. Given a permutation $σ\in S_n$, consider the length of the longest subsequence of $σ$ that repeats this pattern. For example, consider $l=3$ and $V_1V_2V_3=UUD$. Then for the permutation $342617985\in S_9$, the length of the longest subsequence that repeats the pattern $UUD$ is 7; it is obtained by 3461798 and 3461785. The above framework includes two well-known cases. The pattern $U$ is the celebrated case of the longest increasing subsequence. The pattern $UD$ (or $DU$) is the case of the longest alternating subsequence. These have been studied both under the uniform distribution on $S_n$ as well as under the uniform distribution on those permutations in $S_n$ which avoid a particular pattern of length three. In this paper, we consider the patterns $UUD$ and $UUUD$ under the uniform distribution on those permutations in $S_n$ which avoid the pattern $132$. We prove that the expected value of the longest increasing subsequence following the pattern $UUD$ is asymptotic to $\frac37n$ and the expected value of the longest increasing subsequence following the pattern $UUUD$ is asymptotic to $\frac4{11}n$. (For $UD$ (alternating subsequences) it is known to be $\frac12n$.) This leads directly to appropriate corresponding results for permutations avoiding any particular pattern of length three.

The problem of identifying the satisfiability threshold of random $3$-SAT formulas has received a lot of attention during the last decades and has inspired the study of other threshold phenomena in random combinatorial structures. The classical assumption in this line of research is that, for a given set of $n$ Boolean variables, each clause is drawn uniformly at random among all sets of three literals from these variables, independently from other clauses. Here, we keep the uniform distribution of each clause, but deviate significantly from the independence assumption and consider richer families of probability distributions. For integer parameters $n$, $m$, and $k$, we denote by $\DistFamily_k(n,m)$ the family of probability distributions that produce formulas with $m$ clauses, each selected uniformly at random from all sets of three literals from the $n$ variables, so that the clauses are $k$-wise independent. Our aim is to make general statements about the satisfiability or unsatisfiability of formulas produced by distributions in $\DistFamily_k(n,m)$ for different values of the parameters $n$, $m$, and $k$.

We study the convergence of distributions on finite paths of weighted digraphs, namely the family of Boltzmann distributions and the sequence of uniform distributions. Targeting applications to the convergence of distributions on paths, we revisit some known results from reducible nonnegative matrix theory and obtain new ones, with a systematic use of tools from analytic combinatorics. In several fields of mathematics, computer science and system theory, including concurreny theory, one frequently faces non strongly connected weighted digraphs encoding the elements of combinatorial structures of interest; this motivates our study.

Let $\mathbb{F}_q$ be the finite field of order $q$, and $\mathcal{A}$ a non-empty proper subset of $\mathbb{F}_q$. Let $\mathbf{M}$ be a random $m \times n$ matrix of rank $r$ over $\mathbb{F}_q$ taken with uniform distribution. It was proved recently by Sanna that as $m,n \to \infty$ and $r,q,\mathcal{A}$ are fixed, the number of entries of $\mathbf{M}$ in $\mathcal{A}$ approaches a normal distribution. The question was raised as to whether or not one can still obtain a central limit theorem of some sort when $r$ goes to infinity in a way controlled by $m$ and $n$. In this paper we answer this question affirmatively.

We study the communication complexity of multiplying $k\times t$ elements from the group $H=\text{SL}(2,q)$ in the number-on-forehead model with $k$ parties. We prove a lower bound of $(t\log H)/c^{k}$. This is an exponential improvement over previous work, and matches the state-of-the-art in the area. Relatedly, we show that the convolution of $k^{c}$ independent copies of a 3-uniform distribution over $H^{m}$ is close to a $k$-uniform distribution. This is again an exponential improvement over previous work which needed $c^{k}$ copies. The proofs are remarkably simple; the results extend to other quasirandom groups. We also show that for any group $H$, any distribution over $H^{m}$ whose weight-$k$ Fourier coefficients are small is close to a $k$-uniform distribution. This generalizes previous work in the abelian setting, and the proof is simpler.

We present a method of representing an element of $\mathbb{F}_3^n$ as an element of $\mathbb{F}_n^2 \times \mathbb{F}_n^2$ which in practice will be a pair of unsigned integers. We show how to do addition, subtraction and pointwise multiplication and division of such vectors quickly using primitive binary operations (and, or, xor). We use this machinery to develop a fast algorithm for computing the permanent of a matrix in $\mathbb{F}_3^{n\times n}$. We present Julia code for a natural implementation of the permanent and show that our improved implementation gives, roughly, a factor of 80 speedup for problems of practical size. Using this improved code, we perform Monte Carlo simulations that suggest that the distribution of $\mbox{perm}(A)$ tends to the uniform distribution as $n \to \infty$.

There are numerous randomized algorithms to generate spanning trees in a given ambient graph; several target the uniform distribution on trees (UST), while in practice the fastest and most frequently used draw random weights on the edges and then employ a greedy algorithm to choose the minimum-weight spanning tree (MST). Though MST is a workhorse in applications, the mathematical properties of random MST are far less explored than those of UST. In this paper we develop tools for the quantitative study of random MST. We consider the standard case that the weights are drawn i.i.d. from a single distribution on the real numbers, as well as successive generalizations that lead to \emph{product measures}, where the weights are independently drawn from arbitrary distributions.

We recognise that an entropy inequality akin to the main intermediate goal of recent works (Gowers, Green, Manners, Tao [3],[2]) regarding a conjecture of Marton provides a black box from which we can also through a short deduction recover another description: if a finite subset $A$ of an abelian group $G$ is such that the distribution of the sums $a+b$ with $(a,b) \in A \times A$ is only slightly more spread out than the uniform distribution on $A$, then $A$ has small symmetric difference with some finite coset of $G$. The resulting bounds are necessarily sharp up to a logarithmic factor.

Let $k$ and $l$ be integers, both at least 2. A $(k,l)$-bipartite graph is an $l$-regular bipartite multigraph with coloured bipartite sets of size $k$. Define $χ(k,l)$ and $μ(k,l)$ to be the minimum and maximum order of automorphism groups of $(k,l)$-bipartite graphs, respectively. We determine $χ(k,l)$ and $μ(k,l)$ for $k\geq 8$, and analyse the generic situation when $k$ is fixed and $l$ is large. In particular, we show that almost all such graphs have automorphism groups which fix the vertices pointwise and have order far less than $μ(k,l)$. These graphs are intimately connected with both contingency tables with uniform margins and uniform set partitions; we examine the uniform distribution on the set of $k\times k$ contingency tables with uniform margin $l$, showing that with high probability all entries stray far from the mean. We also show that the symmetric group acting on uniform set partitions is non-synchronizing.

Motivated by an application in community detection, we consider an \ER random graph conditioned on the rare event that all connected components are fully connected. Such graphs can be considered as partitions of vertices into cliques. Hence, this conditional distribution defines a distribution over partitions. We show that a popular community detection method is equivalent to Bayesian inference with this distribution as prior over the community partitions. Using tools from analytic combinatorics, we prove limit theorems for several graph observables in this conditional distribution: the number of cliques; the number of edges; and the degree distribution. We consider several regimes of the connection probability $p$ as the number of vertices $n$ diverges. For $p=\tfrac{1}{2}$, the conditioning yields the uniform distribution over set partitions, which is well-studied, but has not been studied as a graph distribution before. For $p<\tfrac{1}{2}$, we show that the number of cliques is of the order $n/\sqrt{\log n}$, while for $p>\tfrac{1}{2}$, we prove that the graph consists of a single clique with high probability. This shows that there is a phase transition at $p=\tfrac{1}{2}$. We additionally study the near-critical regime $p_n\downarrow\tfrac{1}{2}$, as well as the sparse regime $p_n\downarrow0$. Finally, we discuss the implications of these results for community detection.

A parking function on $[n]$ creates a permutation in $S_n$ via the order in which the $n$ cars appear in the $n$ parking spaces. Placing the uniform probability measure on the set of parking functions on $[n]$ induces a probability measure on $S_n$. We initiate a study of some properties of this distribution. Let $P_n^{\text{park}}$ denote this distribution on $S_n$ and let $P_n$ denote the uniform distribution on $S_n$. In particular, we obtain an explicit formula for $P_n^{\text{park}}(σ)$ for all $σ\in S_n$. Then we show that for all but an asymptotically $P_n$-negligible set of permutations, one has $P_n^{\text{park}}(σ)\in\left(\frac{(2-ε)^n}{(n+1)^{n-1}},\frac{(2+ε)^n}{(n+1)^{n-1}}\right)$. However, this accounts for only an exponentially small part of the $P_n^{\text{park}}$-probability. We also obtain an explicit formula for $P_n^{\text{park}}(σ^{-1}_{n-j+1}=i_1,σ^{-1}_{n-j+2}=i_2,\cdots, σ^{-1}_n=i_j)$, the probability that the last $j$ cars park in positions $i_1,\cdots, i_j$ respectively, and show that the $j$-dimensional random vector $(n+1-σ^{-1}_{n-j+l}, n+1-σ^{-1}_{n-j+2},\cdots, n+1-σ^{-1}_{n})$ under $P_n^{\text{park}}$ converges in distribution to a random vector $(\sum_{r=1}^jX_r,\sum_{r=2}^j X_r,\cdots, X_{j-1}+X_j,X_j)$, where $\{X_r\}_{r=1}^j$ are IID with the Borel distribution. We then show that in fact for $j_n=o(n^\frac16)$, the final $j_n$ cars will park in increasing order with probability approaching 1 as $n\to\infty$. We also obtain an explicit formula for the expected value of the left-to-right maximum statistic $X_n^{\text{LR-max}}$, which counts the total number of left-to-right maxima in a permutation, and show that $E_n^{\text{park}}X_n^{\text{LR-max}}$ grows approximately on the order $n^\frac12$.

Consider $n$ independent random numbers with a uniform distribution on $[0,1]$. The number of them that exceed their mean is shown to have an Eulerian distribution, i.e., it is described by the Eulerian numbers. This is related to, but distinct from, the well known fact that the integer part of the sum of independent random numbers uniform on $[0,1]$ has an Eulerian distribution. One motivation for this problem comes from voting theory.

We prove limit theorems for the number of fixed points occurring in a random pattern-avoiding permutation distributed according to a one-parameter family of biased distributions. The bias parameter exponentially tilts the distribution towards favoring permutations with more or fewer fixed points than is typical under the uniform distribution. One case we study features a phase transition where the limiting distribution changes abruptly from negative binomial to Rayleigh to normal depending on the bias parameter.

Let the costs $C(i,j)$ for an instance of the Asymmetric Traveling Salesperson Problem (ATSP) be independent copies of a non-negative random variable $C$ from a class of distributions that include the uniform $[0,1]$ distribution and the exponential mean 1 distribution with mean 1. We describe an algorithm that solves ATSP exactly in time $e^{\log^{2+o(1)}n}$, w.h.p.

Let $r > 0$ be an integer, let $\mathbb{F}_q$ be a finite field of $q$ elements, and let $\mathcal{A}$ be a nonempty proper subset of $\mathbb{F}_q$. Moreover, let $\mathbf{M}$ be a random $m \times n$ rank-$r$ matrix over $\mathbb{F}_q$ taken with uniform distribution. We prove, in a precise sense, that, as $m, n \to +\infty$ and $r,q,\mathcal{A}$ are fixed, the number of entries of $\mathbf{M}$ that belong to $\mathcal{A}$ approaches a normal distribution.

In the classical secretary problem, $n$ ranked items arrive one by one, and each item's rank relative to its predecessors is noted. The observer must select or reject each item as it arrives, with the object of selecting the item of highest rank. For $M_n\in\{0,1,\cdots, n-1\}$, let $\mathcal{S}(n,M_n)$ denote the strategy whereby the observer rejects the first $M_n$ items, and then selects the first later-arriving item whose rank is higher than that of any of the first $M_n$ items (if such an item exists). If the ranked items arrive in a uniformly random order, it is well-known that the limiting optimal probability of success is $\frac1e$, which occurs if $M_n\sim\frac ne$. It has been shown that when the ranked items arrive according to certain non-uniform distributions on the set of permutations, $\frac1e$ serves as a lower bound for the optimal probability. There is a fundamental reason for this phenomenon. We consider certain distributions for which that reason does not apply. We begin by noting a cooked-up class of distributions for which $\mathcal{S}(n,M)$ yields the lowest possible probability of success -- namely $\frac1n$, for all $M$. We then consider the uniform distribution over all permutations avoiding a particular pattern of length three. In the case of the pattern 231 or 132, for any choice of $M_n$, the strategy $\mathcal{S}(n,M_n)$ yields the very same probability of success; namely $\frac{n+1}{2(2n-1)}$, which gives a limiting probability of $\frac14$. For the pattern 213, the optimal strategy is obtained for $M\in\{0,1\}$, also yielding a limiting probability of $\frac14$. For the pattern 123, the optimal strategy is obtained for $M=1$, yielding a limiting probability of $\frac34$. For the other two patterns, 312 and 321, an optimal strategy will yield a limiting probability of at least $\frac7{16}$.

Let $G$ be a graph on $n$ vertices of maximum degree $Δ$. We show that, for any $δ> 0$, the down-up walk on independent sets of size $k \leq (1-δ)α_c(Δ)n$ mixes in time $O_{Δ,δ}(k\log{n})$, thereby resolving a conjecture of Davies and Perkins in an optimal form. Here, $α_{c}(Δ)n$ is the NP-hardness threshold for the problem of counting independent sets of a given size in a graph on $n$ vertices of maximum degree $Δ$. Our mixing time has optimal dependence on $k,n$ for the entire range of $k$; previously, even polynomial mixing was not known. In fact, for $k = Ω_Δ(n)$ in this range, we establish a log-Sobolev inequality with optimal constant $Ω_{Δ,δ}(1/n)$. At the heart of our proof are three new ingredients, which may be of independent interest. The first is a method for lifting $\ell_\infty$-independence from a suitable distribution on the discrete cube -- in this case, the hard-core model -- to the slice by proving stability of an Edgeworth expansion using a multivariate zero-free region for the base distribution. The second is a generalization of the Lee-Yau induction to prove log-Sobolev inequalities for distributions on the slice with considerably less symmetry than the uniform distribution. The third is a sharp decomposition-type result which provides a lossless comparison between the Dirichlet form of the original Markov chain and that of the so-called projected chain in the presence of a contractive coupling.

A random algebraic graph is defined by a group $G$ with a uniform distribution over it and a connection $σ:G\longrightarrow[0,1]$ with expectation $p,$ satisfying $σ(g)=σ(g^{-1}).$ The random graph $\mathsf{RAG}(n,G,p,σ)$ with vertex set $[n]$ is formed as follows. First, $n$ independent vectors $x_1,\ldots,x_n$ are sampled uniformly from $G.$ Then, vertices $i,j$ are connected with probability $σ(x_ix_j^{-1}).$ This model captures random geometric graphs over the sphere and the hypercube, certain regimes of the stochastic block model, and random subgraphs of Cayley graphs. The main question of interest to the current paper is: when is a random algebraic graph statistically and/or computationally distinguishable from $\mathsf{G}(n,p)$? Our results fall into two categories. 1) Geometric. We focus on the case $G =\{\pm1\}^d$ and use Fourier-analytic tools. For hard threshold connections, we match [LMSY22b] for $p = ω(1/n)$ and for $1/(r\sqrt{d})$-Lipschitz connections we extend the results of [LR21b] when $d = Ω(n\log n)$ to the non-monotone setting. We study other connections such as indicators of interval unions and low-degree polynomials. 2) Algebraic. We provide evidence for an exponential statistical-computational gap. Consider any finite group $G$ and let $A\subseteq G$ be a set of elements formed by including each set of the form $\{g, g^{-1}\}$ independently with probability $1/2.$ Let $Γ_n(G,A)$ be the distribution of random graphs formed by taking a uniformly random induced subgraph of size $n$ of the Cayley graph $Γ(G,A).$ Then, $Γ_n(G,A)$ and $\mathsf{G}(n,1/2)$ are statistically indistinguishable with high probability over $A$ if and only if $\log|G|\gtrsim n.$ However, low-degree polynomial tests fail to distinguish $Γ_n(G,A)$ and $\mathsf{G}(n,1/2)$ with high probability over $A$ when $\log |G|=\log^{Ω(1)}n.$

A tanglegram consists of two rooted binary trees and a perfect matching between their leaves, and a planar tanglegram is one that admits a layout with no crossings. We show that the problem of generating planar tanglegrams uniformly at random reduces to the corresponding problem for irreducible planar tanglegram layouts, which are known to be in bijection with pairs of disjoint triangulations of a convex polygon. We extend the flip operation on a single triangulation to a flip operation on pairs of disjoint triangulations. Interestingly, the resulting flip graph is both connected and regular, and hence a random walk on this graph converges to the uniform distribution. We also show that the restriction of the flip graph to the pairs with a fixed triangulation in either coordinate is connected, and give diameter bounds that are near optimal. Our results furthermore yield new insight into the flip graph of triangulations of a convex $n$-gon with a geometric interpretation on the associahedron.