arXiv++ Combinatorics

Inspired by Manjul Bhargava's theory of generalized factorials, Fedor Petrov and the author have defined the "Bhargava greedoid" -- a greedoid (a matroid-like set system on a finite set) assigned to any "ultra triple" (a somewhat extended variant of a finite ultrametric space). Here we show that the Bhargava greedoid of a finite ultra triple is always a "Gaussian elimination greedoid" over any sufficiently large (e.g., infinite) field; this is a greedoid analogue of a representable matroid. We find necessary and sufficient conditions on the size of the field to ensure this.

Consider the ring $\mathcal{S}$ of symmetric polynomials in $k$ variables over an arbitrary base ring $\mathbf{k}$. Fix $k$ scalars $a_{1},a_{2},\ldots,a_{k}\in\mathbf{k}$. Let $I$ be the ideal of $\mathcal{S}$ generated by $h_{n-k+1}-a_{1},h_{n-k+2}-a_{2},\ldots,h_{n}-a_{k}$, where $h_{i}$ is the $i$-th complete homogeneous symmetric polynomial. The quotient ring $\mathcal{S}/I$ generalizes both the usual and the quantum cohomology of the Grassmannian. We show that $\mathcal{S}/I$ has a $\mathbf{k}$-module basis consisting of (residue classes of) Schur polynomials fitting into an $\left( n-k\right) \times k$-rectangle; and that its multiplicative structure constants satisfy the same $S_3$-symmetry as those of the Grassmannian cohomology. We prove a Pieri rule and a "rim hook algorithm", and conjecture a positivity property generalizing that of Gromov-Witten invariants. We construct two further bases of $\mathcal{S}/I$ as well. We also study the quotient of the whole polynomial ring (not just the symmetric polynomials) by the ideal generated by the same $k$ polynomials as $I$.

Consider a finite set $E$. Assume that each $e \in E$ has a "weight" $w \left(e\right) \in \mathbb{R}$ assigned to it, and any two distinct $e, f \in E$ have a "distance" $d \left(e, f\right) = d \left(f, e\right) \in \mathbb{R}$ assigned to them, such that the distances satisfy the ultrametric triangle inequality $d(a,b)\leqslant \max \left\{d(a,c),d(b,c)\right\}$. We look for a subset of $E$ of given size with maximum perimeter (where the perimeter is defined by summing the weights of all elements and their pairwise distances). We show that any such subset can be found by a greedy algorithm (which starts with the empty set, and then adds new elements one by one, maximizing the perimeter at each step). We use this to define numerical invariants, and also to show that the maximum-perimeter subsets of all sizes form a strong greedoid, and the maximum-perimeter subsets of any given size are the bases of a matroid. This essentially generalizes the "$P$-orderings" constructed by Bhargava in order to define his generalized factorials, and is also similar to the strong greedoid of maximum diversity subsets in phylogenetic trees studied by Moulton, Semple and Steel. We further discuss some numerical invariants of $E, w, d$ stemming from this construction, as well as an analogue where maximum-perimeter subsets are replaced by maximum-perimeter tuples (i.e., elements can appear multiple times).

Given two elements $a$ and $b$ of a noncommutative ring, we express $\left( ba\right)^n$ as a "row vector times matrix times column vector" product, where the matrix is the $n$-th power of a matrix with entries $\dbinom{i}{j}\operatorname{ad}_a^{i-j}\left( b\right)$. This generalizes a formula by Tom Copeland used in the study of Pascal-style matrices.

Given two $\left( n+1\right) \times\left( n+1\right)$-matrices $A$ and $B$ over a commutative ring, and some $k\in\left\{ 0,1,\ldots,n\right\}$, we consider the $\dbinom{n}{k}\times\dbinom{n}{k}$-matrix $W$ whose entries are $\left( k+1\right) \times\left( k+1\right)$-minors of $A$ multiplied by corresponding $\left( k+1\right) \times\left( k+1\right)$-minors of $B$. Here we require the minors to use the last row and the last column (which is why we obtain an $\dbinom{n}{k}\times\dbinom{n}{k}$-matrix, not an $\dbinom{n+1}{k+1}\times\dbinom{n+1}{k+1}$-matrix). We prove that the determinant $\det W$ is a multiple of $\det A$ if the $\left( n+1,n+1\right)$-th entry of $B$ is $0$. Furthermore, if the $\left( n+1,n+1\right)$-th entries of both $A$ and $B$ are $0$, then $\det W$ is a multiple of $\left( \det A\right) \left( \det B\right)$. This extends a previous result of Olver and the author ( arXiv:1802.02900 ).

Using the description of multiline queues as functions on words, we introduce the notion of a spectral weight of a word by defining a new weighting on multiline queues. We show that the spectral weight of a word is invariant under a natural action of the symmetric group, giving a proof of the commutativity conjecture of Arita, Ayyer, Mallick, and Prolhac. We give a determinant formula for the spectral weight of a word, which gives a proof of a conjecture of the first author and Linusson.

This is a continuation of arXiv:1706.00750 by Gessel and Zhuang (but can be read independently from the latter). We study the shuffle-compatibility of permutation statistics -- a concept introduced in arXiv:1706.00750, although various instances of it have appeared throughout the literature before. We prove that (as Gessel and Zhuang have conjectured) the exterior peak set statistic (Epk) is shuffle-compatible. We furthermore introduce the concept of an "LR-shuffle-compatible" statistic, which is stronger than shuffle-compatibility. We prove that Epk and a few other statistics are LR-shuffle-compatible. Furthermore, we connect these concepts with the quasisymmetric functions, in particular the dendriform structure on them.

We give elementary proofs for the Apagodu-Zeilberger-Stanton-Amdeberhan-Tauraso congruences $$\sum\limits_{n=0}^{p-1}\dbinom{2n}{n} \equivη_{p}\mod p^{2},$$ $$\sum\limits_{n=0}^{rp-1}\dbinom{2n}{n} \equivη_{p}\sum\limits_{n=0}^{r-1}\dbinom {2n}{n}\mod p^{2}$$ and $$\sum\limits_{n=0}^{rp-1}\sum\limits_{m=0}^{sp-1}\dbinom{n+m}{m}^{2} \equivη_{p} \sum\limits_{m=0}^{r-1}\sum\limits_{n=0}^{s-1}\dbinom{n+m}{m}^2\mod p^2,$$ where $p$ is an odd prime, $r$ and $s$ are nonnegative integers, and $η_{p}= \begin{cases} 0, &\text{if }p\equiv0\mod 3;\\ 1, & \text{if }p\equiv1\mod 3;\\ -1, &\text{if }p\equiv2\mod 3 \end{cases}.$$

This paper considers an invariant of modules over a finite-dimensional Hopf algebra, called the critical group. This generalizes the critical groups of complex finite group representations studied by Benkart, Klivans, Reiner and Gaetz. A formula is given for the cardinality of the critical group generally, and the critical group for the regular representation is described completely. A key role in the formulas is played by the greatest common divisor of the dimensions of the indecomposable projective representations.

Fix a commutative ring $\mathbf{k}$, two elements $β,α\in\mathbf{k}$ and a positive integer $n$. Let $\mathcal{X}$ be the polynomial ring over $\mathbf{k}$ in the $n(n-1)/2$ indeterminates $x_{i,j}$ for all $1\leq i<j\leq n$. Consider the ideal $\mathcal{J}$ of $\mathcal{X}$ generated by all polynomials of the form $x_{i,j}x_{j,k}-x_{i,k}(x_{i,j}+x_{j,k}+β)-α$ for $1\leq i<j<k\leq n$. The quotient algebra $\mathcal{X}/\mathcal{J}$ (at least for a certain choice of $\mathbf{k}$, $β$ and $α$) has been introduced by Karola Mészáros as a commutative analogue of Anatol Kirillov's quasi-classical Yang-Baxter algebra. A monomial in $\mathcal{X}$ is said to be pathless if it has no divisors of the form $x_{i,j}x_{j,k}$ with $1\leq i<j<k\leq n$. The residue classes of these pathless monomials span the $\mathbf{k}$-module $\mathcal{X}/\mathcal{J}$, but (in general) are $\mathbf{k}$-linearly dependent. Recently, the study of Grothendieck polynomials has led Laura Escobar and Karola Mészáros to defining a $\mathbf{k}$-algebra homomorphism $D$ from $\mathcal{X}$ into the polynomial ring $\mathbf{k}[t_{1},t_{2},\ldots,t_{n-1}]$ that sends each $x_{i,j}$ to $t_{i}$. We show the following fact (generalizing a conjecture of Mészáros): If $p\in\mathcal{X}$, and if $q\in\mathcal{X}$ is a $\mathbf{k}$-linear combination of pathless monomials satisfying $p\equiv q\operatorname{mod}\mathcal{J}$, then $D(q)$ does not depend on $q$ (as long as $β$, $α$ and $p$ are fixed). Thus, reducing a $p\in\mathcal{X}$ modulo $\mathcal{J}$ may lead to different results depending on the choices made in the reduction process, but all of them become identical once $D$ is applied. We also find an actual basis of the $\mathbf{k}$-module $\mathcal{X}/\mathcal{J}$, using what we call forkless monomials.

We show a determinant identity which generalizes both the Chio pivotal condensation theorem and the Matrix-Tree theorem.

If H is a commutative connected graded Hopf algebra over a commutative ring k, then a certain canonical k-algebra homomorphism H -> H (x) QSym is defined, where QSym denotes the Hopf algebra of quasisymmetric functions over k. This homomorphism generalizes the "internal comultiplication" on QSym, and extends what Hazewinkel (in Section 18.24 of his "Witt vectors") calls the Bernstein homomorphism. We construct this homomorphism with the help of the universal property of QSym as a combinatorial Hopf algebra (a well-known result by Aguiar, Bergeron and Sottile) and extension of scalars (the commutativity of H allows us to consider, for example, H (x) QSym as an H-Hopf algebra, and this change of viewpoint significantly extends the reach of the universal property).

We explore several generalizations of Whitney's theorem -- a classical formula for the chromatic polynomial of a graph. Following Stanley, we replace the chromatic polynomial by the chromatic symmetric function. Following Dohmen and Trinks, we exclude not all but only an (arbitrarily selected) set of broken circuits, or even weigh these broken circuits with weight monomials instead of excluding them. Following Crew and Spirkl, we put weights on the vertices of the graph. Following Gebhard and Sagan, we lift the chromatic symmetric function to noncommuting variables. In addition, we replace the graph by an "ambigraph", an apparently new concept that includes both hypergraphs and multigraphs as particular cases. We show that Whitney's formula endures all these generalizations, and a fairly simple sign-reversing involution can be used to prove it in each setting. Furthermore, if we restrict ourselves to the chromatic polynomial, then the graph can be replaced by a matroid. We discuss an application to transitive digraphs (i.e., posets), and reprove an alternating-sum identity by Dahlberg and van Willigenburg.

The reduced expressions for a given element $w$ of a Coxeter group $(W, S)$ can be regarded as the vertices of a directed graph $\mathcal{R}(w)$; its arcs correspond to the braid moves. Specifically, an arc goes from a reduced expression $a$ to a reduced expression $b$ when $b$ is obtained from $a$ by replacing a contiguous subword of the form $stst...$ (for some distinct $s, t$ in $S$) by $tsts...$ (where both subwords have length $m_{s, t}$, the order of $st$ in $W$). We prove a strong bipartiteness-type result for this graph $\mathcal{R}(w)$: Not only does every cycle of $\mathcal{R}(w)$ have even length; actually, the arcs of $\mathcal{R}(w)$ can be colored (with colors corresponding to the type of braid moves used), and to every color $c$ corresponds an "opposite" color $c^{\operatorname{op}}$ (corresponding to the reverses of the braid moves with color $c$), and for any color $c$, the number of arcs in any given cycle of $\mathcal{R}(w)$ having color in $\left\{c, c^{\operatorname{op}}\right\}$ is even. This is a generalization and strengthening of a 2014 result by Bergeron, Ceballos and Labbé. We state further conjectural extensions.

A quasisymmetric function is assigned to every double poset (that is, every finite set endowed with two partial orders) and any weight function on its ground set. This generalizes well-known objects such as monomial and fundamental quasisymmetric functions, (skew) Schur functions, dual immaculate functions, and quasisymmetric $\left(P, ω\right)$-partition enumerators. We prove a formula for the antipode of this function that holds under certain conditions (which are satisfied when the second order of the double poset is total, but also in some other cases); this restates (in a way that to us seems more natural) a result by Malvenuto and Reutenauer, but our proof is new and self-contained. We generalize it further to an even more comprehensive setting, where a group acts on the double poset by automorphisms.

The dual stable Grothendieck polynomials are a deformation of the Schur functions, originating in the study of the K-theory of the Grassmannian. We generalize these polynomials by introducing a countable family of additional parameters, and we prove that this generalization still defines symmetric functions. For this fact, we give two self-contained proofs, one of which constructs a family of involutions on the set of reverse plane partitions generalizing the Bender-Knuth involutions on semistandard tableaux, whereas the other classifies the structure of reverse plane partitions with entries 1 and 2.

Given a free module L over a commutative ring k, we study two k-linear operators on the tensor algebra of T(L): One of them sends a pure tensor u_1 (X) u_2 (X) ... (X) u_k to the sum of all tensors u_i (X) u_1 (X) u_2 (X) ... (X) (skip u_i) (X) ... (X) u_k. The other is similar, but the sum is replaced by an alternating sum. These operators can be regarded as algebraic analogues of the "random-to-top shuffle" from combinatorics. We describe the kernel of the second operator (which we call boldface-t); it is a certain easily described Lie subsuperalgebra of T(L). We also describe the kernel of the first operator (which is denoted boldface-t') when the additive group k is torsionfree (the description is analogous to that of the kernel of t) and also when k is an algebra over a finite field (in this case, the description is slightly complicated by the presence of p-th powers).

The dual immaculate functions are a basis of the ring QSym of quasisymmetric functions, and form one of the most natural analogues of the Schur functions. The dual immaculate function corresponding to a composition is a weighted generating function for immaculate tableaux in the same way as a Schur function is for semistandard Young tableaux; an "immaculate tableau" is defined similarly to a semistandard Young tableau, but the shape is a composition rather than a partition, and only the first column is required to strictly increase (whereas the other columns can be arbitrary; but each row has to weakly increase). Dual immaculate functions have been introduced by Berg, Bergeron, Saliola, Serrano and Zabrocki in arXiv:1208.5191, and have since been found to possess numerous nontrivial properties. In this note, we prove a conjecture of Mike Zabrocki which provides an alternative construction for the dual immaculate functions in terms of certain "vertex operators". The proof uses a dendriform structure on the ring QSym; we discuss the relation of this structure to known dendriform structures on the combinatorial Hopf algebras FQSym and WQSym.

These notes -- originating from a one-semester class by their second author at the University of Minnesota -- survey some of the most important Hopf algebras appearing in combinatorics. After introducing coalgebras, bialgebras and Hopf algebras in general, we study the Hopf algebra of symmetric functions, including Zelevinsky's axiomatic characterization of it as a "positive self-adjoint Hopf algebra" and its application to the representation theory of symmetric and (briefly) finite general linear groups. The notes then continue with the quasisymmetric and the noncommutative symmetric functions, some Hopf algebras formed from graphs, posets and matroids, and the Malvenuto-Reutenauer Hopf algebra of permutations. Among the results surveyed are the Littlewood-Richardson rule and other symmetric function identities, Zelevinsky's structure theorem for PSHs, the antipode formula for P-partition enumerators, the Aguiar-Bergeron-Sottile universal property of QSym, the theory of Lyndon words, the Gessel-Reutenauer bijection, and Hazewinkel's polynomial freeness of QSym. The notes are written with a graduate student reader in mind, being mostly self-contained but requiring a good familiarity with multilinear algebra and -- for the representation-theory applications -- basic group representation theory.

We study a birational map associated to any finite poset P. This map is a far-reaching generalization (found by Einstein and Propp) of classical rowmotion, which is a certain permutation of the set of order ideals of P. Classical rowmotion has been studied by various authors (Fon-der-Flaass, Cameron, Brouwer, Schrijver, Striker, Williams and many more) under different guises (Striker-Williams promotion and Panyushev complementation are two examples of maps equivalent to it). In contrast, birational rowmotion is new and has yet to reveal several of its mysteries. In this paper, we prove that birational rowmotion has order p+q on the (p, q)-rectangle poset (i.e., on the product of a p-element chain with a q-element chain); we furthermore compute its orders on some triangle-shaped posets and on a class of posets which we call "skeletal" (this class includes all graded forests). In all cases mentioned, birational rowmotion turns out to have a finite (and explicitly computable) order, a property it does not exhibit for general finite posets (unlike classical rowmotion, which is a permutation of a finite set). Our proof in the case of the rectangle poset uses an idea introduced by Volkov (arXiv:hep-th/0606094) to prove the AA case of the Zamolodchikov periodicity conjecture; in fact, the finite order of birational rowmotion on many posets can be considered an analogue to Zamolodchikov periodicity. We comment on suspected, but so far enigmatic, connections to the theory of root posets. We also make a digression to study classical rowmotion on skeletal posets, since this case has seemingly been overlooked so far.