arXiv++ Combinatorics

Browse math.CO papers from arXiv

bipartite graph

2604 papers tagged with this keyword
2018-11-20 v2
An equivalent formulation of the Fan-Raspaud Conjecture and related problems
Published in Ars Math. Contemp. 18, No. 1, 87-103 (2020) • View Publication • BIB
In 1994, it was conjectured by Fan and Raspaud that every simple bridgeless cubic graph has three perfect matchings whose intersection is empty. In this paper we answer a question recently proposed by Mkrtchyan and Vardanyan, by giving an equivalent formulation of the Fan-Raspaud Conjecture. We also study a possibly weaker conjecture originally proposed by the first author, which states that in every simple bridgeless cubic graph there exist two perfect matchings such that the complement of their union is a bipartite graph. Here, we show that this conjecture can be equivalently stated using a variant of Petersen-colourings, we prove it for graphs having oddness at most four and we give a natural extension to bridgeless cubic multigraphs and to certain cubic graphs having bridges.
2018-11-19 v3
Intersection theorems for families of matchings of complete $k$-partite $k$-graphs
The celebrated {Erdős-Ko-Rado} Theorem states that for $n \geq 2k$ a family $\mathscr{F}$ of $k$ subsets of $[n]$ for which each pair of members of $\mathscr{F}$ have a non-empty intersection has size at most $\binom{n-1}{k-1}$ and for $n >2k$ has exactly this size if and only if it is the family of all $k$-subsets of $[n]$ containing a fixed element $x\in [n]$. Since its discovery, the {Erdős-Ko-Rado} Theorem has be generalised extensively and many variants have been found for structures other than sets. One such variant is for permutations and so-called generalised permutations. These structures are equivalent to $r$-matchings of the complete bipartite graph $K_{n,m}$ with $r \leq \min\{n,m\}$ in a natural way. The culmination of results of several groups of authors constitute an {Erdős-Ko-Rado} Theorem for families of generalised permutations and so for families of $r$-matchings of $K_{n,m}$ for all feasible values of $r,n$ and $m$. In this paper we generalise this by proving an {Erdős-Ko-Rado} Theorem for families of $r$-matchings of complete $k$-partite $k$-graphs, which can be seen as a partial generalisation of the {Erdős-Ko-Rado} Theorem itself. We also prove similar results for $t$-intersecting families, and for families of matchings whose members have sizes from some set of integers $R$, rather than a single size $r$.
2018-11-16
On the rational Turán exponents conjecture
Published • View Publication • BIB
The extremal number $\mathrm{ex}(n,F)$ of a graph $F$ is the maximum number of edges in an $n$-vertex graph not containing $F$ as a subgraph. A real number $r \in [1,2]$ is realisable if there exists a graph $F$ with $\mathrm{ex}(n , F) = Θ(n^r)$. Several decades ago, Erdős and Simonovits conjectured that every rational number in $[1,2]$ is realisable. Despite decades of effort, the only known realisable numbers are $0,1, \frac{7}{5}, 2$, and the numbers of the form $1+\frac{1}{m}$, $2-\frac{1}{m}$, $2-\frac{2}{m}$ for integers $m \geq 1$. In particular, it is not even known whether the set of all realisable numbers contains a single limit point other than two numbers $1$ and $2$. In this paper, we make progress on the conjecture of Erdős and Simonovits. First, we show that $2 - \frac{a}{b}$ is realisable for any integers $a,b \geq 1$ with $b>a$ and $b \equiv \pm 1 ~({\rm mod}\:a)$. This includes all previously known ones, and gives infinitely many limit points $2-\frac{1}{m}$ in the set of all realisable numbers as a consequence. Secondly, we propose a conjecture on subdivisions of bipartite graphs. Apart from being interesting on its own, we show that, somewhat surprisingly, this subdivision conjecture in fact implies that every rational number between 1 and 2 is realisable.
2018-11-15 v2
Forbidden rainbow subgraphs that force large monochromatic or multicolored k-connected subgraphs
Published • View Publication • BIB
Let $n, k, m$ be positive integers with $n\gg m\gg k$, and let $\mathcal{A}$ be the set of graphs $G$ of order at least 3 such that there is a $k$-connected monochromatic subgraph of order at least $n-f(G,k,m)$ in any rainbow $G$-free coloring of $K_n$ using all the $m$ colors. In this paper, we prove that the set $\mathcal{A}$ consists of precisely $P_6$, $P_3\cup P_4$, $K_2\cup P_5$, $K_2\cup 2P_3$, $2K_2\cup K_3$, $2K_2\cup P^{+}_4$, $3K_2\cup K_{1,3}$ and their subgraphs of order at least 3. Moreover, we show that for any graph $H\in \mathcal{A}$, if $n$ sufficiently larger than $m$ and $k$, then any rainbow $(P_3\cup H)$-free coloring of $K_n$ using all the $m$ colors contains a $k$-connected monochromatic subgraph of order at least $cn$, where $c=c(H)$ is a constant, not depending on $n$, $m$ or $k$. Furthermore, we consider a parallel problem in complete bipartite graphs. Let $s, t, k, m$ be positive integers with ${\rm min}\left\{s, t\right\}\gg m\gg k$ and $m\geq |E(H)|$, and let $\mathcal{B}$ be the set of bipartite graphs $H$ of order at least 3 such that there is a $k$-connected monochromatic subgraph of order at least $s+t-f(H,k,m)$ in any rainbow $H$-free coloring of $K_{s,t}$ using all the $m$ colors, where $f(H,k,m)$ is not depending on $s$ or $t$. We prove that the set $\mathcal{B}$ consists of precisely $2P_3$, $2K_2\cup K_{1,3}$ and their subgraphs of order at least 3. Finally, we consider the large $k$-connected multicolored subgraph instead of monochromatic subgraph. We show that for $1\leq k \leq 3$ and $n$ sufficiently large, every Gallai-3-coloring of $K_n$ contains a $k$-connected subgraph of order at least $n-\left\lfloor\frac{k-1}{2}\right\rfloor$ using at most two colors. We also show that the above statement is false for $k=4t$, where $t$ is an positive integer.
2018-11-12 v3
On an Annihilation Number Conjecture
Published • View Publication • BIB
Let $α(G)$ denote the cardinality of a maximum independent set, while $μ(G)$ be the size of a maximum matching in the graph $G=\left(V,E\right) $. If $α(G)+μ(G)=\left\vert V\right\vert $, then $G$ is a König-Egerváry graph. If $d_{1}\leq d_{2}\leq\cdots\leq d_{n}$ is the degree sequence of $G$, then the annihilation number $h\left(G\right) $ of $G$ is the largest integer $k$ such that $\sum\limits_{i=1}^{k}d_{i}\leq\left\vert E\right\vert $ (Pepper 2004, Pepper 2009). A set $A\subseteq V$ satisfying $\sum \limits_{a\in A} deg(a)\leq\left\vert E\right\vert $ is an annihilation set, if, in addition, $ deg\left(v\right) +\sum\limits_{a\in A} deg(a)>\left\vert E\right\vert $, for every vertex $v\in V(G)-A$, then $A$ is a maximal annihilation set in $G$. In (Larson & Pepper 2011) it was conjectured that the following assertions are equivalent: (i) $α\left(G\right) =h\left(G\right) $; (ii) $G$ is a König-Egerváry graph and every maximum independent set is a maximal annihilating set. In this paper, we prove that the implication "(i) $\Longrightarrow$ (ii)" is correct, while for the opposite direction we provide a series of generic counterexamples. Keywords: maximum independent set, matching, tree, bipartite graph, König-Egerváry graph, annihilation set, annihilation number.
2018-11-11
Recognizing generating subgraphs revisited
Published • View Publication • BIB
A graph $G$ is well-covered if all its maximal independent sets are of the same cardinality. Assume that a weight function $w$ is defined on its vertices. Then $G$ is $w$-well-covered if all maximal independent sets are of the same weight. For every graph $G$, the set of weight functions $w$ such that $G$ is $w$-well-covered is a vector space, denoted as $WCW(G).$ Deciding whether an input graph $G$ is well-covered is co-NP-complete. Therefore, finding $WCW(G)$ is co-NP-hard. A generating subgraph of a graph $G$ is an induced complete bipartite subgraph $B$ of $G$ on vertex sets of bipartition $B_{X}$ and $B_{Y}$, such that each of $S \cup B_{X}$ and $S \cup B_{Y}$ is a maximal independent set of $G$, for some independent set $S$. If $B$ is generating, then $w(B_{X})=w(B_{Y})$ for every weight function $w \in WCW(G)$. Therefore, generating subgraphs play an important role in finding $WCW(G)$. The decision problem whether a subgraph of an input graph is generating is known to be NP-complete. In this article, we prove NP-completeness of the problem for graphs without cycles of length 3 and 5, and for bipartite graphs with girth at least 6. On the other and, we supply polynomial algorithms for recognizing generating subgraphs and finding $WCW(G)$, when the input graph is bipartite without cycles of length 6. We also present a polynomial algorithm which finds $WCW(G)$ when $G$ does not contain cycles of lengths 3, 4, 5, and 7.
2018-11-11
Anomaly Detection and Correction in Large Labeled Bipartite Graphs
Binary classification problems can be naturally modeled as bipartite graphs, where we attempt to classify right nodes based on their left adjacencies. We consider the case of labeled bipartite graphs in which some labels and edges are not trustworthy. Our goal is to reduce noise by identifying and fixing these labels and edges. We first propose a geometric technique for generating random graph instances with untrustworthy labels and analyze the resulting graph properties. We focus on generating graphs which reflect real-world data, where degree and label frequencies follow power law distributions. We review several algorithms for the problem of detection and correction, proposing novel extensions and making observations specific to the bipartite case. These algorithms range from math programming algorithms to discrete combinatorial algorithms to Bayesian approximation algorithms to machine learning algorithms. We compare the performance of all these algorithms using several metrics and, based on our observations, identify the relative strengths and weaknesses of each individual algorithm.
2018-11-09 v2
Homomorphism bounds of signed bipartite $K_4$-minor-free graphs and edge-colorings of $2k$-regular $K_4$-minor-free multigraphs
Published in Discrete Applied Mathematics 261:40-51, 2019 • View Publication • BIB
A signed graph $(G, Σ)$ is a graph $G$ and a subset $Σ$ of its edges which corresponds to an assignment of signs to the edges: edges in $Σ$ are negative while edges not in $Σ$ are positive. A closed walk of a signed graph is balanced if the product of the signs of its edges (repetitions included) is positive, and unbalanced otherwise. The unbalanced-girth of a signed graph is the length of a shortest unbalanced closed walk (if such a walk exists). A homomorphism of $(G,Σ)$ to $(H,Π)$ is a homomorphism of $G$ to $H$ which preserves the balance of closed walks. In this work, given a signed bipartite graph $(B, Π)$ of unbalanced-girth $2k$, we give a necessary and sufficient condition for $(B, Π)$ to admit a homomorphism from any signed bipartite graph of unbalanced-girth at least $2k$ whose underlying graph is $K_4$-minor-free. The condition can be checked in polynomial time with respect to the order of $B$. Let $SPC(2k)$ be the signed bipartite graph on vertex set $\mathbb{Z}_2^{2k-1}$ where vertices $u$ and $v$ are adjacent with a positive edge if their difference is in $\{e_1,e_2, \ldots, e_{2k-1}\}$ (where the $e_i$'s form the standard basis), and adjacent with a negative edge if their difference is $J$ (that is, the all-1 vector). As an application of our work, we prove that every signed bipartite $K_4$-minor-free graph of unbalanced-girth $2k$ admits a homomorphism to $SPC(2k)$. This supports a conjecture of Guenin claiming that every signed bipartite planar graph of unbalanced-girth $2k$ admits a homomorphism to $SPC(2k)$ (this would be an extension of the four-color theorem). We also give an application of our work to edge-coloring $2k$-regular $K_4$-minor-free multigraphs.
2018-11-02
List Coloring a Cartesian Product with a Complete Bipartite Factor
Published • View Publication • BIB
We study the list chromatic number of the Cartesian product of any graph $G$ and a complete bipartite graph with partite sets of size $a$ and $b$, denoted $χ_\ell(G \square K_{a,b})$. We have two motivations. A classic result on the gap between list chromatic number and the chromatic number tells us $χ_\ell(K_{a,b}) = 1 + a$ if and only if $b \geq a^a$. Since $χ_\ell(K_{a,b}) \leq 1 + a$ for any $b \in \mathbb{N}$, this result tells us the values of $b$ for which $χ_\ell(K_{a,b})$ is as large as possible and far from $χ(K_{a,b})=2$. In this paper we seek to understand when $χ_\ell(G \square K_{a,b})$ is far from $χ(G \square K_{a,b}) = \max \{χ(G), 2 \}$. It is easy to show $χ_\ell(G \square K_{a,b}) \leq χ_\ell (G) + a$. In 2006, Borowiecki, Jendrol, Král, and Miskuf showed that this bound is attainable if $b$ is sufficiently large; specifically, $χ_\ell(G \square K_{a,b}) = χ_\ell (G) + a$ whenever $b \geq (χ_\ell(G) + a - 1)^{a|V(G)|}$. Given any graph $G$ and $a \in \mathbb{N}$, we wish to determine the smallest $b$ such that $χ_\ell(G \square K_{a,b}) = χ_\ell (G) + a$. In this paper we show that the list color function, a list analogue of the chromatic polynomial, provides the right concept and tool for making progress on this problem. Using the list color function, we prove a general improvement on Borowiecki et al.'s 2006 result, and we compute the smallest such $b$ exactly for some large families of chromatic-choosable graphs.
2018-10-29 v4
Reflexive polytopes arising from bipartite graphs with $γ$-positivity associated to interior polynomials
Published in Selecta Mathematica. New Series 26 (2020), 59 • View Publication • BIB
In this paper, we introduce polytopes ${\mathcal B}_G$ arising from root systems $B_n$ and finite graphs $G$, and study their combinatorial and algebraic properties. In particular, it is shown that ${\mathcal B}_G$ is reflexive if and only if $G$ is bipartite. Moreover, in the case, ${\mathcal B}_G$ has a regular unimodular triangulation. This implies that the $h^*$-polynomial of ${\mathcal B}_G$ is palindromic and unimodal when $G$ is bipartite. Furthermore, we discuss stronger properties, namely the $γ$-positivity and the real-rootedness of the $h^*$-polynomials. In fact, if $G$ is bipartite, then the $h^*$-polynomial of ${\mathcal B}_G$ is $γ$-positive and its $γ$-polynomial is given by an interior polynomial (a version of the Tutte polynomial for a hypergraph). The $h^*$-polynomial is real-rooted if and only if the corresponding interior polynomial is real-rooted. From a counterexample to Neggers--Stanley conjecture, we construct a bipartite graph $G$ whose $h^*$-polynomial is not real-rooted but $γ$-positive, and coincides with the $h$-polynomial of a flag triangulation of a sphere.
2018-10-29 v2
Unavoidable chromatic patterns in 2-colorings of the complete graph
Published • View Publication • BIB
We consider unavoidable chromatic patterns in $2$-colorings of the edges of the complete graph. Several such problems are explored being a junction point between Ramsey theory, extremal graph theory (Turán type problems), zero-sum Ramsey theory, and interpolation theorems in graph theory. A role-model of these problems is the following: Let $G$ be a graph with $e(G)$ edges. We say that $G$ is omnitonal if there exists a function ${\rm ot}(n,G)$ such that the following holds true for $n$ sufficiently large: For any $2$-coloring $f: E(K_n) \to \{red, blue \}$ such that there are more than ${\rm ot}(n,G)$ edges from each color, and for any pair of non-negative integers $r$ and $b$ with $r+b = e(G)$, there is a copy of $G$ in $K_n$ with exactly $r$ red edges and $b$ blue edges. We give a structural characterization of omnitonal graphs from which we deduce that omnitonal graphs are, in particular, bipartite graphs, and prove further that, for an omnitonal graph $G$, ${\rm ot}(n,G) = \mathcal{O}(n^{2 - \frac{1}{m}})$, where $m = m(G)$ depends only on $G$. We also present a class of graphs for which ${\rm ot}(n,G) = ex(n,G)$, the celebrated Turán numbers. Many more results and problems of similar flavor are presented.
2018-10-23 v2
Expansion of coset graphs of PSL_2(F_p)
Published in Isr. J. Math. 233, 335-349 (2019) • View Publication • BIB
Let $G$ be a finite group and let $H_1,H_2<G$ be two subgroups. In this paper, we are concerned with the bipartite graph whose vertices are $G/H_1\cup G/H_2$ and a coset $g_1H_1$ is connected with another coset $g_2H_2$ if and only if $g_1H_1\cap g_2 H_2\neq\varnothing$. The main result of the paper establishes the existence of such graphs with large girth and large spectral gap. Lubotzky, Manning and Wilton use such graphs to construct certain infinite groups of interest in geometric group theory.
2018-10-17
A class of non-matchable distributive lattices
The set of all perfect matchings of a plane (weakly) elementary bipartite graph equipped with a partial order is a poset, moreover the poset is a finite distributive lattice and its Hasse diagram is isomorphic to $Z$-transformation directed graph of the graph. A finite distributive lattice is matchable if its Hasse diagram is isomorphic to a $Z$-transformation directed graph of a plane weakly elementary bipartite graph, otherwise non-matchable. We introduce the meet-irreducible cell with respect to a perfect matching of a plane (weakly) elementary bipartite graph and give its equivalent characterizations. Using these, we extend a result on non-matchable distributive lattices, and obtain a class of new non-matchable distributive lattices.
2018-10-14 v2
Kasteleyn operators from mirror symmetry
Published • View Publication • BIB
Given a consistent bipartite graph $Γ$ in $T^2$ with a complex-valued edge weighting $\mathcal{E}$ we show the following two constructions are the same. The first is to form the Kasteleyn operator of $(Γ, \mathcal{E})$ and pass to its spectral transform, a coherent sheaf supported on a spectral curve in $(\mathbb{C}^\times)^2$. The second is to form the conjugate Lagrangian $L \subset T^* T^2$ of $Γ$, equip it with a brane structure prescribed by $\mathcal{E}$, and pass to its mirror coherent sheaf. This lives on a stacky toric compactification of $(\mathbb{C}^\times)^2$ determined by the Legendrian link which lifts the zig-zag paths of $Γ$ (and to which the noncompact Lagrangian $L$ is asymptotic). We work in the setting of the coherent-constructible correspondence, a sheaf-theoretic model of toric mirror symmetry. We also show that tensoring with line bundles on the compactification is mirror to certain Legendrian autoisotopies of the asymptotic boundary of $L$.
On the null structure of bipartite graphs without cycles of length a multiple of 4
Published • View Publication • BIB
In this work we study the null space of bipartite graphs without cycles of length multiple of $4$, and its relation to structural properties. We decompose them into two subgraphs: $C_N(G)$ and $C_S(G)$. $C_N(G)$ has perfect matching and its adjacency matrix is nonsingular. $C_S(G)$ has a unique maximum independent set and the dimension of its null space equals the dimension of the null space of $G$. Even more, we show that the fundamental spaces of $G$ are the direct sum of the fundamental spaces of $C_N(G)$ and $C_S(G)$. We also obtain formulas relating the independence number and the matching number of a $C_{4k}$-free bipartite graph with $C_N(G)$ and $C_S(G)$, and the dimensions of the fundamental spaces. Among other results, we show that the rank of a $C_{4k}$-free bipartite graph is twice its matching number, generalizing a result for trees due to Bevis et al \cite{bevis1995ranks}, and Cvetković and Gutman \cite{D1972}. About maximum independent sets, we show that the intersection of all maximum independent sets of a $C_{4k}$-free bipartite graph coincides with the support of its null space.
2018-10-09
Strong geodetic number of complete bipartite graphs, crown graphs and hypercubes
Published • View Publication • BIB
The strong geodetic number, $\text{sg}(G),$ of a graph $G$ is the smallest number of vertices such that by fixing one geodesic between each pair of selected vertices, all vertices of the graph are covered. In this paper, the study of the strong geodetic number of complete bipartite graphs is continued. The formula for $\text{sg}(K_{n,m})$ is given, as well as a formula for the crown graphs $S_n^0$. Bounds on $\text{sg}(Q_n)$ are also discussed.
2018-10-08 v3
(Di)graph decompositions and magic type labelings: a dual relation
A graph $G$ is called edge-magic if there is a bijective function $f$ from the set of vertices and edges to the set $\{1,2,\ldots,|V(G)|+|E(G)|\}$ such that the sum $f(x)+f(xy)+f(y)$ for any $xy$ in $E(G)$ is constant. Such a function is called an edge-magic labelling of G and the constant is called the valence of $f$. An edge-magic labelling with the extra property that $f(V(G))= \{1,2,\ldots,|V(G)|\}$ is called super edge-magic. In this paper, we establish a relationship between the valences of (super) edge-magic labelings of certain types of bipartite graphs and the existence of a particular type of decompositions of such graphs.
2018-10-04 v2
The Four Point Permutation Test for Latent Block Structure in Incidence Matrices
Transactional data may be represented as a bipartite graph $G:=(L \cup R, E)$, where $L$ denotes agents, $R$ denotes objects visible to many agents, and an edge in $E$ denotes an interaction between an agent and an object. Unsupervised learning seeks to detect block structures in the adjacency matrix $Z$ between $L$ and $R$, thus grouping together sets of agents with similar object interactions. New results on quasirandom permutations suggest a non-parametric \textbf{four point test} to measure the amount of block structure in $G$, with respect to vertex orderings on $L$ and $R$. Take disjoint 4-edge random samples, order these four edges by left endpoint, and count the relative frequencies of the $4!$ possible orderings of the right endpoint. When these orderings are equiprobable, the edge set $E$ corresponds to a quasirandom permutation $π$ of $|E|$ symbols. Total variation distance of the relative frequency vector away from the uniform distribution on 24 permutations measures the amount of block structure. Such a test statistic, based on $\lfloor |E|/4 \rfloor$ samples, is computable in $O(|E|/p)$ time on $p$ processors. Possibly block structure may be enhanced by precomputing \textbf{natural orders} on $L$ and $R$, related to the second eigenvector of graph Laplacians. In practice this takes $O(d |E|)$ time, where $d$ is the graph diameter. Five open problems are described.
2018-10-02
Nondegenerate spheres in four dimensions
Published • View Publication • BIB
Non-degeneracy was first defined for hyperplanes by Elekes-Tóth, and later extended to spheres by Apfelbaum-Sharir: given a set $P$ of $m$ points in $\mathbb{R}^d$ and some $β\in(0,1)$, a $(d-1)$-dimensional sphere (or a $(d-1)$-sphere) $S$ in $\mathbb{R}^d$ is called $β$-nondegenerate with respect to $P$ if $S$ does not contain a proper subsphere $S'$ such that $|S'\cap P|\geq β|S\cap P|$. Apfelbaum-Sharir found an upper bound for the number of incidences between points and nondegenerate spheres in three dimensions, which was recently used by Zahl to obtain the best known bound for the unit distance problem in three dimensions. In this paper, we show that the number of incidences between $m$ points and $n$ $β$-nondegenerate 3-spheres in $\mathbb{R}^4$ is $O_{β,\varepsilon}\left(m^{\frac{15}{19}+\varepsilon} n^{\frac{16}{19}}+mn^{\frac{2}{3}}\right)$. As a consequence, we obtain a bound of $O_{\varepsilon}(n^{2+4/11+\varepsilon})$ on the number of similar triangles formed by $n$ points in $\mathbb{R}^4$, an improvement over the previously best known bound $O(n^{2+2/5})$. While proving this, we find it convenient to work with a more general definition of nondegeneracy: a bipartite graph $G=(P,Q)$ is called $β$-nondegenerate if $|N(q_1)\cap N(q_2)|<β|N(q_1)|$ for any two distinct vertices $q_1,q_2\in Q$; here $N(q)$ denotes the set of neighbors of $q$ and $β$ is some positive constant less than 1. A $β$-nondegenerate graph can have up to $Θ(|P||Q|)$ edges without any restriction, but must have much fewer edges if the graph is semi-algebraic or has bounded VC-dimension. We show that previous results for planes and spheres in three dimensions still hold under this new definition, and so does our new bound for spheres in four dimensions.
2018-10-01 v2
Improved Ramsey-type results for comparability graphs
Published in Combinatorics, Probability and Computing 29 (2020), 747-756 • View Publication • BIB
Several discrete geometry problems are equivalent to estimating the size of the largest homogeneous sets in graphs that happen to be the union of few comparability graphs. An important observation for such results is that if $G$ is an $n$-vertex graph that is the union of $r$ comparability (or more generally, perfect) graphs, then either $G$ or its complement contains a clique of size $n^{1/(r+1)}$. This bound is known to be tight for $r=1$. The question whether it is optimal for $r\ge 2$ was studied by Dumitrescu and Tóth. We prove that it is essentially best possible for $r=2$, as well: we introduce a probabilistic construction of two comparability graphs on $n$ vertices, whose union contains no clique or independent set of size $n^{1/3+o(1)}$. Using similar ideas, we can also construct a graph $G$ that is the union of $r$ comparability graphs, and neither $G$, nor its complement contains a complete bipartite graph with parts of size $\frac{cn}{(\log n)^r}$. With this, we improve a result of Fox and Pach.