arXiv++ Combinatorics

For a real matrix $A \in \mathbb{R}^{d \times n}$ with non-collinear columns, we show that $n \leq O(d^4 κ_A)$ where $κ_A$ is the \emph{circuit imbalance measure} of $A$. The circuit imbalance measure $κ$ is a real analogue of $Δ$-modularity for integer matrices, satisfying $κ_A \leq Δ_A$ for integer $A$. The circuit imbalance measure has numerous applications in the context of linear programming (see Ekbatani, Natura and V{é}gh (2022) for a survey). Our result generalizes the $O(d^4 Δ_A)$ bound of Averkov and Schymura (2023) for integer matrices and provides the first polynomial bound holding for all parameter ranges on real matrices. To derive our result, similar to the strategy of Geelen, Nelson and Walsh (2021) for $Δ$-modular matrices, we show that real representable matroids induced by $κ$-bounded matrices are minor closed and exclude a rank $2$ uniform matroid on $O(κ)$ elements as a minor (also known as a line of length $O(κ)$). As our main technical contribution, we show that any simple rank $d$ complex representable matroid which excludes a line of length $l$ has at most $O(d^4 l)$ elements. This complements the tight bound of $(l-3)\binom{d}{2} + d$ for $l \geq 4$, of Geelen, Nelson and Walsh which holds when the rank $d$ is sufficiently large compared to $l$ (at least doubly exponential in $l$).

In 1983, Bouchet conjectured that every flow-admissible signed graph admits a nowhere-zero 6-flow. We verify this conjecture for the class of flow-admissible signed graphs possessing a spanning even Eulerian subgraph, which includes as a special case all signed graphs with a balanced Hamiltonian circuit. Furthermore, we show that this result is sharp by citing a known infinite family of signed graphs with a balanced Hamiltonian circuit that do not admit a nowhere-zero 5-flow. Our proof relies on a construction that transforms signed graphs whose underlying graph admits a nowhere-zero 4-flow into a signed 3-edge-colorable cubic graph. This transformation has the crucial property of establishing a sign-preserving bijection between the bichromatic cycles of the resulting signed cubic graph and certain Eulerian subgraphs of the original signed graph. As an application of our main result, we also show that Bouchet's conjecture holds for all signed abelian Cayley graphs.

Embedding the vertices of arbitrary graphs into trees while minimizing some measure of overlap is an important problem with applications in computer science and physics. In this work, we consider the problem of bijectively embedding the vertices of an $n$-vertex graph $G$ into the leaves of an $n$-leaf rooted binary tree $\mathcal{B}$. The congestion of such an embedding is given by the largest size of the cut induced by the two components obtained by deleting any vertex of $\mathcal{B}$. The congestion $\mathrm{cng}(G)$ is defined as the minimum congestion obtained by any embedding. We show that $λ_2(G)\cdot 2n/9\le \mathrm{cng} (G)\le λ_n(G)\cdot 2n/9$, where $0=λ_1(G)\le \cdots \le λ_n(G)$ are the Laplacian eigenvalues of $G$. We also provide a contraction heuristic given by hierarchically spectral clustering the original graph, which we numerically find to be effective in finding low congestion embeddings for sparse graphs. We numerically compare our congestion bounds on different families of graphs with regular structure (hypercubes and lattices), random graphs, and tensor network representations of quantum circuits. Our results imply lower and upper bounds on the memory complexity of tensor network contraction in terms of the underlying graph.

Circuit augmentation schemes are a family of combinatorial algorithms for linear programming that generalize the simplex method. To solve the linear program, they construct a so-called monotone circuit walk: They start at an initial vertex of the feasible region and traverse a discrete sequence of points on the boundary, while moving along certain allowed directions (circuits) and improving the objective function at each step until reaching an optimum. Since the existence of short circuit walks has been conjectured (Circuit Diameter Conjecture), several works have investigated how well one can efficiently approximate shortest monotone circuit walks towards an optimum. A first result addressing this question was given by De Loera, Kafer, and Sanità [SIAM J. Opt., 2022], who showed that given as input an LP and the starting vertex, finding a $2$-approximation for this problem is NP-hard. Cardinal and the third author [Math. Prog. 2023] gave a stronger lower bound assuming the exponential time hypothesis, showing that even an approximation factor of $O(\frac{\log m}{\log \log m})$ is intractable for LPs defined by $m$ inequalities. Both of these results were based on reductions from highly degenerate polytopes in combinatorial optimization with high dimension. In this paper, we significantly strengthen the aforementioned hardness results by showing that for every fixed $\varepsilon>0$ approximating the problem on polygons with $m$ edges to within a factor of $O(m^{1-\varepsilon})$ is NP-hard. This result is essentially best-possible, as it cannot be improved beyond $o(m)$. In particular, this implies hardness for simple polytopes and in fixed dimension.

In 1935, Pauling proposed an estimate for the number of Eulerian orientations of a graph in the context of the theoretical behaviour of water ice. The logarithm of the number of Eulerian orientations, normalised by the number of vertices, is called the residual entropy. In an earlier paper, we conjectured that the residual entropy of a sequence of regular graphs of increasing degree was asymptotically equal to Pauling's estimate. Here we prove the conjecture under constraints on the number of short circuits. These constraints hold under weak eigenvalue conditions and apply to sequences of increasing girth and repeated Cartesian products such as hypercubes.

A regularity lemma for polynomials provides a decomposition in terms of a bounded number of approximately independent polynomials. Such regularity lemmas play an important role in numerous results, yet suffer from the familiar shortcoming of having tower-type bounds or worse. In this paper we design a new, weaker regularity lemma with strong bounds. The new regularity lemma in particular provides means to quantitatively study the curves contained in the image of a polynomial map, which is beyond the reach of standard methods. Applications include strong bounds for a problem of Karam on generalized rank, as well as a new method to obtain upper bounds for fan-in parameters in arithmetic circuits. For example, we show that if the image of a polynomial map $\mathbf{P} \colon \mathbb{F}^n \to \mathbb{F}^m$ of degree $d$ does not contain a line, then $\mathbf{P}$ can be computed by a depth-$4$ arithmetic formula with bottom fan-in at most $d/2$ and top fan-in at most $(2m)^{C(d)}$ (with $C(d)=2^{(1+o(1))d}$). One implication of our work is a certain ``barrier'' to arithmetic circuit lower bounds, in terms of the smallest degree of a polynomial curve contained in the image of the given polynomial map.

We investigate the asymptotic behavior of entropy polymatroids associated with algebraic matroids over finite fields. Given an algebraic matroid ${\sf M}:=(\mathcal{E},r)$ and the irreducible variety $V$ associated with ${\sf M}$, we consider the polymatroid $h_{\mathbb{F}}$ induced by the entropies of the projections of $V(\mathbb{F})$, where $\mathbb{F}$ is a finite extension of $\mathbb{G}$. Revisiting a construction of Matú$\check{\mathrm{s}}$, we show that the polymatroid $h_{\mathbb{F}}$ converges to the rank function $r$ of ${\sf M}$ as $q:=|\mathbb{F}|$ tends to infinity. Our main contribution is to make this convergence quantitative: we derive explicit uniform error bounds for the deviation $|h_\mathbb{F}-r|$, expressed in terms of the degree of $V$, the ground set size $|\mathcal{E}|$, the rank $r(\mathcal{E})$, and $q$. The proofs combine tools of algebraic geometry (effective Lang-Weil estimates and intrinsic degree bounds for annihilating polynomials of circuits) with information-theoretic arguments (submodularity of entropy and conditional entropy estimates). These results provide the first effective and uniform approximation bounds for algebraic matroids by entropy polymatroids, clarifying the quantitative link between algebraic independence (captured by matroid rank) and information-theoretic independence (captured by entropy).

We provide a short proof of a conic version of the colorful Carathéodory theorem for oriented matroids. Holmsen's extension of the colorful Carathéodory theorem to oriented matroids (Advances in Mathematics, 2016) already encompasses several generalizations of the original result, but not its conic version. Our approach relies on a common generalization of Sperner's lemma and Meshulam's lemma-two closely related results from combinatorial topology that have found a number of applications in discrete geometry and combinatorics. This generalization may be of independent interest. Using a similar approach, we also establish the following colorful theorem for topes, whose special geometric case had not been considered before: Given $n$ topes from a uniform oriented matroid with $n$ elements, if they agree on some element, then there is a way to select a distinct element from each tope, together with its sign, so as to form another tope of the oriented matroid. Motivated by this theorem, we further explore other conditions leading to the same conclusion.

The h-vector of a matroid M is an important invariant related to the independence complex of M and can also be recovered from an evaluation of its Tutte polynomial. A well-known conjecture of Stanley posits that the h-vector of a matroid is a pure O-sequence, meaning that it can be obtained by counting faces of a pure multicomplex. Merino has established Stanley's conjecture for the case of cographic matroids via chip-firing on graphs and the concept of a G-parking function. Inspired by these constructions, we introduce the notion of a cycle system for a matroid M -- a family of cycles (unions of circuits) of M with overlap properties that mimic cut-sets in a graph. A choice of cycle system on M defines a collection of integer sequences that we call coparking functions. We show that for any cycle system on M, the set of coparking functions is in bijection with the set of bases of M. We show that maximal coparking functions all have the same degree, and that cycle systems behave well under deletion and contraction. This leads to a proof of Stanley's conjecture for the case of matroids that admit cycle systems, which include, for instance, graphic matroids of cones as well as K33-free graphs.

Quantum circuits composed of CNOT and $R_z$ are fundamental building blocks of many quantum algorithms, so optimizing the synthesis of such quantum circuits is crucial. We address this problem from a theoretical perspective by studying the graphic parity network synthesis problem. A graphic parity network for a graph $G$ is a quantum circuit composed solely of CNOT gates where each edge of $G$ is represented in the circuit, and the final state of the wires matches the original input. We aim to synthesize graphic parity networks with the minimum number of gates, specifically for quantum algorithms addressing combinatorial optimization problems with Ising formulations. We demonstrate that a graphic parity network for a connected graph with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges requires at least $m+n-1$ gates. This lower bound can be improved to $m+Ω(m) = m+Ω(n^{1.5})$ when the shortest cycle in the graph has a length of at least five. We complement this result with a simple randomized algorithm that synthesizes a graphic parity network with expected $m + O(n^{1.5}\sqrt{\log n})$ gates. Additionally, we begin exploring connected graphs that allow for graphic parity networks with exactly $m+n-1$ gates. We conjecture that all such graphs belong to a newly defined graph class. Furthermore, we present a linear-time algorithm for synthesizing minimum graphic parity networks for graphs within this class. However, this graph class is not closed under taking induced subgraphs, and we show that recognizing it is $\textsf{NP}$-complete, which is complemented with a fixed-parameter tractable algorithm parameterized by the treewidth.

For a poset $P$, an Ungar move sends $P$ to $P\setminus T$, where $T$ is some subset of maximal elements of $P$. With these Ungar moves, Defant, Kravitz, and Williams define the Ungar games, where two players alternate making nontrivial Ungar moves until one player cannot make a move and loses. We characterize the second-player wins on graded posets. We first prove recursive characterizations of second-player wins before using these results to give classifications of the second-player wins in terms of boolean circuits. We also generalize Defant, Kravitz, and Williams' work on Young's Lattice $J(\mathbb{N}^2)$ to the higher-dimensional $J(\mathbb{N}^d)$.

In the 1970s, Kouchnirenko, Bernstein, and Khovanskii noticed that the geometry of a generic system of polynomial equations is determined by the geometry of its Newton polytopes. In the 1990s, Gelfand, Kapranov, Zelevinsky, and Sturmfels extended this observation to discriminants and resultants of generic polynomials. Particularly, well-known open questions about the irreducibility of discriminants and sets of solutions of such systems lead to questions about the corresponding geometric property of tuples of polytopes: Minkowski linear independence. To address these questions, we encode Minkowski linear independence into a finite matroid and characterize its bases, circuits, and cyclics. The obtained combinatorial results are used in the subsequent work to describe components of discriminants for generic square polynomial systems.

Let $\mathscr{M}$ be a conditional oriented matroid. We define a graded algebra $\widehat{\mathscr{VG}}_\mathscr{M}$ with vector space dimension given by the number of covectors in $\mathscr{M}$ which admits a distinguished filtration indexed by the poset $\mathscr{L}(\mathscr{M})$ of flats of $\mathscr{M}$. The subquotients of this filtration are isomorphic to graded Varchenko-Gelfand rings of contractions of $\mathscr{M}$, so we call $\widehat{\mathscr{VG}}_\mathscr{M}$ the {\em graded big Varchenko-Gelfand ring of $\mathscr{M}$.} We describe a no broken circuit type basis of $\widehat{\mathscr{VG}}_\mathscr{M}$ and study its equivariant structure under the action of $\mathrm{Aut}(\mathscr{M})$. Our key technique is the orbit harmonics deformation which encodes $\widehat{\mathscr{VG}}_\mathscr{M}$ (as well as the classical Varchenko-Gelfand ring) in terms of a locus of points.

In 1980 Lovász introduced the concept of a double circuit in a matroid. The 2nd, 3rd and 4th authors recently generalised this notion to $k$-fold circuits (for any natural number $k$) and proved foundational results about these $k$-fold circuits. In this article we use $k$-fold circuits to derive new results on the generic $d$-dimensional rigidity matroid $\mathcal{R}_d$. These results include analysing 2-sums, showing sufficient conditions for the $k$-fold circuit property to hold for $k$-fold $\mathcal{R}_d$-circuits, and giving an extension of Whiteley's coning lemma. The last of these allows us to reduce the problem of determining if a graph $G$ with a vertex $v$ of sufficiently high degree is independent in $\mathcal{R}_d$ to that of verifying matroidal properties of $G-v$ in $\mathcal{R}_{d-1}$.

We study point-line configurations and their associated matroid and circuit varieties. We aim to find a finite set of defining equations for matroid varieties and an irreducible decomposition for circuit varieties. To solve the former problem, we use some classical techniques from algebraic geometry, including the Grassmann-Cayley algebra and the liftability technique. From this, we can respectively derive the Grassmann-Cayley ideal, introduced by Sidman, Traves and Wheeler, and the lifting ideal, introduced by Liwski, Mohammadi, Clarke and Masiero. Since the circuit ideal, the Grassmann-Cayley ideal and the lifting ideal are contained in the matroid ideal and explicit generators are known for them, it is a natural question to identify point-line configurations for which a generating set of the matroid ideal is formed by the circuit polynomials, Grassmann-Cayley polynomials and lifting polynomials. For these point-line configurations, we obtain an explicit and finite description of the matroid variety. In this thesis, we prove that the matroid ideal of cactus configurations, the Pascal configuration and the Pappus configuration can be generated by these three types of polynomials. To find an irreducible decomposition for the circuit varieties of point-line configurations, we use the decomposition strategy developed by Clarke, Grace, Mohammadi and Motwani. If the point-line configuration has some points lying on at most two lines, we develop a shorter alternative as well. We find such a decomposition for cactus configurations, up to irredundancy. Moreover, we find an irreducible decomposition for the Pascal configuration and the third configuration $9_3$, which is a point-line configuration with nine points and nine lines, such that every point is on three lines and every line contains three points.

We give inductive constructions of independent graphs that contain implied nonedges but do not contain any non-trivial rigid subgraphs, or \emph{nucleations}: some of the constructions and proofs apply to 3-dimensional abstract rigidity matroids with their respective definitions of nucleations and implied nonedges. The first motivation for the inductive constructions of this paper, which generate an especially intractable class of flexible circuits, is to illuminate further obstacles to settling Graver's maximality conjecture that the 3-dimensional generic rigidity matroid is isomorphic to Whiteley's cofactor matroid (the unique maximal matroid in which all graphs isomorphic to $K_5$ are circuits). While none of the explicit examples we provide refutes the maximality conjecture (since their properties hold in both matroids) the construction schemes are useful regardless whether the conjecture is true or false, e.g. for constructing larger (counter)examples from smaller ones. The second motivation is to make progress towards a polynomial-time algorithm for deciding independence in the abovementioned maximal matroid. Nucleation-free graphs with implied nonedges, such as the families constructed in this paper, are the key obstacles that must be dealt with for improving the current state of the art.

This paper studies signed graphs with possible outer-edges. We introduce and investigate the chain group, the boundary operator, the co-boundary operator, the flow group, the tension group, the homology group, the cohomology group, with coefficients in an abelian group. We also introduce and investigate the bivariate flow polynomial for signed graphs. The guiding principle is the correspondence between representable matroids over $\mathbb{R}$ on a ground set $E$ of edges and the subspaces of the vector space of real-valued chains on the same ground set. The frame matroid of signed graph emerges naturally by defining circuits as minimal supports of nonzero flows, rather than listing circuit patterns abruptly. Likewise, bonds, or co-circuits, can be obtained as minimal supports of nonzero tensions. In addition to standardizing the concepts and their meanings of signed graphs, we update the following results: (1) Characterization of cuts and bonds of signed graph with outer-edges. (2) The structures of flow group, boundary group, and homology group, with coefficients in an arbitrary abelian group. (3) Introduction of bivariate flow polynomial of signed graph, revealing the mystery of inexistence of univariate flow polynomial of signed graph in the literature.

If a unitary transformation has a decomposition into a quantum circuit with no directed path from input $a$ to output $b$, then $a$ does not influence $b$ through the overall unitary. Conversely, it is known that if $a$ does not influence $b$, one may always find a circuit decomposition lacking a path between these systems, thus making the no-influence condition directly apparent in the connectivity of the circuit. Causal decompositions are circuit decompositions in which, more generally, multiple such no-influence conditions are made apparent simultaneously. They bridge two fundamental concepts in quantum causality: causal structure, as expressed by influences through unitary transformations (and related to signalling through quantum channels); and compositional structure, expressed in terms of the shape of quantum circuits or networks. The general existence of causal decompositions remains unknown. This work focusses on unitary causal decompositions, i.e. decompositions in terms of unitary circuits in the traditional quantum circuit formalism that do not require the generalisation to `extended' or `routed' quantum circuits prompted by earlier research on this topic. We identify a combinatorial condition that characterises precisely those sets of causal no-influence constraints $G$ for which any unitary transformation satisfying $G$ has a unitary causal decomposition compositionally representing those constraints. Our methods are based on finite-dimensional operator algebra as well as the concept lattice construction, which was recently shown to provide a canonical shape $L_G$ for causal decompositions. The combinatorial condition we identify can be formulated in terms of $G$ as the absence of a forbidden substructure $C_3$ and in terms of $L_G$ as the existence of no more than one path between each input and output.

We study the $a$-sequence $(a_0(G), a_1(G), \cdots)$ of a finite simple graph $G$, defined recursively through a combinatorial rule and known to coincide with the sequence of rational Betti numbers of the real toric variety associated with $G$. In this paper, we establish a combinatorial and topological decomposition formula for the $a$-sequence. As an application, we show that the $a$-sequence is monotone under graph inclusion; that is, $a_i(G) \geq a_i(H)$ for all $i \geq 0$ whenever $H$ is a subgraph of $G$, and obtain the lower and upper bounds of $a_i$-numbers. We also prove that the $a$-sequence is unimodal in $i$ for a broad class of graphs $G$, including those with a Hamiltonian circuit or a universal vertex. These results provide a new class of topological spaces whose Betti number sequences are unimodal but not necessarily log concave, contributing to the study of real loci in algebraic geometry.

If $C_1$ and $C_2$ are circuits in a matroid $M$ with $e_1$ in $C_1-C_2$ and $e$ in $C_1\cap C_2$, then $M$ has a circuit $C_3$ such that $e\in C_3\subseteq (C_1\cup C_2)-e$. This strong circuit elimination axiom is inherently asymmetric. A matroid $M$ has the symmetric strong circuit elimination property (SSCE) if, when the above conditions hold and $e_2\in C_2-C_1$, there is a circuit $C_3'$ with $\{e_1,e_2\}\subseteq C_3'\subseteq (C_1\cup C_2)-e$. We prove that a connected matroid has this property if and only if it has no two skew circuits. We also characterize such matroids in terms of forbidden series minors, and we give a new matroid axiom system that is built around a modification of SSCE.