arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove that the $Z$-polynomial of every sparse paving matroid has only negative real zeros, confirming the real-rootedness conjecture of Proudfoot, Xu, and Young for this class. We also prove that, for each fixed positive corank, the $Z$-polynomials of uniform matroids in consecutive ranks strictly interlace. Our approach is to prove real-rootedness of the corresponding $γ$-polynomials for sparse paving matroids and their strict interlacing for uniform matroids, and then transfer both properties to the corresponding $Z$-polynomials.

For a matroid $M$, a join is a set $J\subseteq E(M)$ that meets every circuit $C$ in at most $|C|/2$ elements. Let $μ(M)$ denote the maximum size of a join. Motivated by Frank's min--max theorem for graphic matroids, we compare $μ(M)$ with an ear-decomposition parameter $η(M)=(r(M)+\varphi(M))/2$, where $\varphi(M)$ is the minimum number of even lobes in an ear decomposition of $M$. Frank's theorem implies $μ(M)=η(M)$ for connected graphic matroids. Here we study how far this equality extends beyond graphic matroids. We show that the exact equality does not hold in general: it already fails for cographic matroids, hence within the binary class. Furthermore, the class of matroids satisfying $μ(M)=η(M)$ is not minor-closed, thus there is little hope for a forbidden minor characterization. We also prove that computing a maximum join is NP-hard for cographic matroids, hard to approximate within a factor of $519/520$, and NP-hard for sparse paving matroids given by their list of bases. Despite these negative results, we show that the two parameters remain quantitatively comparable in several natural classes. We prove comparison bounds for binary, paving, cographic, and arbitrary connected matroids. In particular, using Seymour's decomposition theorem, we combine the equality for graphic matroids, the bound for cographic matroids, and a direct analysis of $R_{10}$ to obtain $η(M)\leq 6μ(M)-2$ for every regular matroid $M$.

The Mayhew--Newman--Welsh--Whittle conjecture predicts that asymptotically almost all matroids are sparse paving. We study the gap between paving and sparse paving matroids at the logarithmic scale. Let \(p_n\) be the number of paving matroids on \([n]\), let \(sp_n\) be the number of sparse paving matroids on \([n]\), and let \(sp_{n,r}\) be the number of rank-\(r\) sparse paving matroids on \([n]\). We prove that \[ p_n-sp_n\ge sp_{n,\lfloor n/2\rfloor}^{1-o(1)}. \] Thus the paving matroids that are not sparse paving are themselves logarithmically large. The construction prescribes one hyperplane larger than the rank and then counts stable sets in an induced subgraph of a Johnson graph. We also give amplified versions obtained by varying the large hyperplane and by prescribing distance-six families of large hyperplanes.

Let $\mathcal B=\mathcal B_{k,n,p}$ be a random collection of $k$-subsets of $[n]$ where each possible set is present independently with probability $p$. Let $\cal E_{\mathcal B}$ be the event that $\mathcal B$ defines the set of bases of a matroid. We prove that If $p= 1-\frac{c_n}{(k(n-k)\binom nk)^{1/2}}$ where $0\leq c_n\leq \infty$, then \[ \lim_{n\to\infty}\Pr[\cal E_{\cal B}\mid |\cal B|\geq2]=\begin{cases}1&c_n\to0.\\e^{-c^2}&c_n\to c.\\0&c_n\to \infty.\end{cases}\] In addition, we identify a condition preventing the occurence of $\cal E_{\cal B}$ and prove a hitting time version for the occurence of $\cal B$. We also prove that when $\cal E_{\mathcal B}$ occurs, $\mathcal B$ defines a sparse paving matroid w.h.p. In addition, study a greedy algorithm that produces a random matroid defined by a collection of hyperplanes. We use this to improve the estimates in \cite{HPV} on $\log m(n,k),\log p(n,k), \log s(n,k)$ where $ m(n, k), p(n, k), s(n, k)$ denote the number of matroids, paving matroids, and sparse paving matroids (respectively) of rank $k$ on $[n]$. Our improvement lies in that we can deal with $k$ growing slowly with $n$ as opposed to $k=O(1)$ in \cite{HPV}. More generally, we obtain estimates for the number of matchings in nearly-regular hypergraphs with small codegree, which may be of independent interest.

We compute the $cd$-index $Ψ_{cd}$ of matroid base polytopes $\mathscr{P}(M)$ for a large family of matroids $M$. The $cd$-index is a polynomial in two non-commutative variables that compactly encodes the count of face flags $\mathcal{F} = \{σ_1 \subset \dots \subset σ_s \}$ with prescribed $\dim σ_i = d_i$. This comprises the $f$-vector of $\mathscr{P}(M)$, which recently Ferroni and Schröter treated as an almost-valuative invariant; i.e. a valuative part plus an error term. We initiate a similar program for $Ψ_{cd}(\mathscr{P}(M))$ and show that for an elementary split matroid $M$ the error term in the computation of $Ψ_{cd}(\mathscr{P}(M))$ surprisingly depends only on modular pairs of cyclic flats. This allows us to implement computations requiring only the counts $λ(r,h)$ and $μ(α,β,a,b)$ of cyclic flats and modular pairs of cyclic flats, respectively, that fulfill some rank and cardinality conditions. We illustrate the methods with sparse paving matroids.

Using Postnikov's Le-diagrams, decorated permutations, and Grassmann necklaces, we classify which positroids are sparse paving matroids. This allows us to enumerate sparse paving positroids, making connections to a known sequence involving the golden ratio and to the Lucas numbers.

Motivated by the $Z$-polynomials of matroids, Ferroni, Matherne, Stevens, and Vecchi introduced the inverse $Z$-polynomial of a matroid. In this paper, we prove several fundamental properties of the inverse $Z$-polynomial, including non-negativity and multiplicativity, and show that it is a valuative invariant. We also provide explicit formulas for the inverse $Z$-polynomials of uniform matroids and a broader class of matroids, namely sparse paving matroids, which include uniform matroids as a special case. Furthermore, we establish the unimodality and log-concavity of these polynomials in the case of sparse paving matroids. Based on the properties of the $Z$-polynomial, we conjecture that the coefficients of the inverse $Z$-polynomial are unimodal and log-concave.

The concept of matchings originated in group theory to address a linear algebra problem related to canonical forms for symmetric tensors. In an abelian group $(G,+)$, a matching is a bijection $f: A \to B$ between two finite subsets $A$ and $B$ of $G$ such that $a + f(a) \notin A$ for all $a \in A$. A group $G$ has the matching property if, for every two finite subsets $A, B \subset G$ of the same size with $0 \notin B$, there exists a matching from $A$ to $B$. In prior work [5], matroid analogues of results concerning matchings in groups were introduced and established. This paper serves as a sequel, extending that line of inquiry by investigating sparse paving, panhandle, and Schubert matroids through the lens of matchability. While some proofs draw upon earlier findings on the matchability of sparse paving matroids, the paper is designed to be self-contained and accessible without reference to the preceding sequel. Our approach combines tools from both matroid theory and additive number theory.

Consider a matroid $M$ whose ground set is equipped with a labeling to an abelian group. A basis of $M$ is called $F$-avoiding if the sum of the labels of its elements is not in a forbidden label set $F$. Hörsch, Imolay, Mizutani, Oki, and Schwarcz (2024) conjectured that if an $F$-avoiding basis exists, then any basis can be transformed into an $F$-avoiding basis by exchanging at most $|F|$ elements. This proximity conjecture is known to hold for certain specific groups; in the case where $|F| \le 2$; or when the matroid is subsequence-interchangeably base orderable (SIBO), which is a weakening of the so-called strongly base orderable (SBO) property. In this paper, we settle the proximity conjecture for sparse paving matroids or in the case where $|F| \le 4$. Related to the latter result, we present the first known example of a non-SIBO matroid. We further address the setting of multiple group-label constraints, showing proximity results for the cases of two labelings, SIBO matroids, matroids representable over a fixed, finite field, and sparse paving matroids.

The {\em Dressian} of a matroid $M$ is the set of all valuations of $M$. This Dressian is the support of a polyhedral complex $\mathcal{Dr}(M)$ whose open cells correspond 1-1 with matroid subdivisions of the matroid polytope of $M$. We present upper bounds on the number of cells and the dimension of $\mathcal{Dr}(M)$. For matroids $M$ of rank $r\geq 3$ on $n$ elements we show that $$ \ln\#\mathcal{Dr}(M)\leq {\binom{n}{r}} O\left(\frac{\ln(n)^2}{n}\right)\text{ as }n\rightarrow\infty,\qquad\text{and}\qquad\dim \mathcal{Dr}(M)\leq {\binom{n}{r}}\frac{3}{n-r+3},$$ as well as some more detailed bounds that incorporate structural properties of such $M$. For uniform matroids $M=U(r,n)$, these upper bounds are comparable to lower bounds derived from valuations that are constructed from sparse paving matroids.

The Chow class of the closure of the torus orbit of a point in a Grassmannian only depends on the matroid associated to the point. The Chow class can be extended to a matroid invariant of arbitrary matroids. We call the coefficients appearing in the expansion of the Chow class in the Schubert basis the Schubert coefficients of the matroid. These Schubert coefficients are conjectured by Berget and Fink to be non-negative. We compute the Schubert coefficients of a disconnected matroid in terms of the Schubert coefficients of its connected components. And we compute the Schubert coefficients for all sparse paving matroids, and confirm their non-negativity.

We focus on checking the validity of the half-plane property on two prominent classes of transversal matroids, namely lattice path matroids and bicircular matroids. We show that lattice path matroids satisfy the half-plane property. Subsequently, we show an explicit example of a bicircular matroid that is not a positroid and discuss the negative correlation properties of bases of transversal matroids. We prove that sparse paving matroids do not satisfy the Rayleigh property, which helps us gain new perspectives about conjectures on negative correlation in basis elements of matroids in general.

This paper initiates the explicit study of face numbers of matroid polytopes and their computation. We prove that, for the large class of split matroid polytopes, their face numbers depend solely on the number of cyclic flats of each rank and size, together with information on the modular pairs of cyclic flats. We provide a formula which allows us to calculate $f$-vectors without the need of taking convex hulls or computing face lattices. We discuss the particular cases of sparse paving matroids and rank two matroids, which are of independent interest due to their appearances in other combinatorial and geometric settings.

We discuss several extension properties of matroids and polymatroids and their application as necessary conditions for the existence of different matroid representations, namely linear, folded linear, algebraic, and entropic representations. Iterations of those extension properties are checked for matroids on eight and nine elements by means of computer-aided explorations, finding in that way several new examples of non-linearly representable matroids. A special emphasis is made on sparse paving matroids on nine points containing the tic-tac-toe configuration. We present a new, more clear description of that family and we analyze extension properties on those matroids and their duals.

We show that the base polytope $P_M$ of any paving matroid $M$ can be systematically obtained from a hypersimplex by slicing off certain subpolytopes, namely base polytopes of lattice path matroids corresponding to panhandle-shaped Ferrers diagrams. We calculate the Ehrhart polynomials of these matroids and consequently write down the Ehrhart polynomial of $P_M$, starting with Katzman's formula for the Ehrhart polynomial of a hypersimplex. The method builds on and generalizes Ferroni's work on sparse paving matroids. Combinatorially, our construction corresponds to constructing a uniform matroid from a paving matroid by iterating the operation of stressed-hyperplane relaxation introduced by Ferroni, Nasr, and Vecchi, which generalizes the standard matroid-theoretic notion of circuit-hyperplane relaxation. We present evidence that panhandle matroids are Ehrhart positive and describe a conjectured combinatorial formula involving chain forests and Eulerian numbers from which Ehrhart positivity of panhandle matroids will follow. As an application of the main result, we calculate the Ehrhart polynomials of matroids associated with Steiner systems and finite projective planes, and show that they depend only on their design-theoretic parameters: for example, while projective planes of the same order need not have isomorphic matroids, their base polytopes must be Ehrhart equivalent.

In this article we make several contributions of independent interest. First, we introduce the notion of stressed hyperplane of a matroid, essentially a type of cyclic flat that permits to transition from a given matroid into another with more bases. Second, we prove that the framework provided by the stressed hyperplanes allows one to write very concise closed formulas for the Kazhdan--Lusztig, inverse Kazhdan--Lusztig and $Z$-polynomials of all paving matroids, a class which is conjectured to predominate among matroids. Third, noticing the palindromicity of the $Z$-polynomial, we address its $γ$-positivity, a midpoint between unimodality and real-rootedness. To this end, we introduce the \emph{$γ$-polynomial} associated to it, we study some of its basic properties and we find closed expressions for it in the case of paving matroids. Also, we prove that it has positive coefficients in many interesting cases, particularly in the large family of sparse paving matroids, and other smaller classes such as projective geometries, thagomizer matroids and other particular graphs. Our last contribution consists of providing explicit combinatorial interpretations for the coefficients of many of the polynomials addressed in this article by enumerating fillings in certain Young tableaux and skew Young tableaux.

We characterize a rich class of valuated matroids, called R-minor valuated matroids that includes the indicator functions of matroids, and is closed under operations such as taking minors, duality, and induction by network. We exhibit a family of valuated matroids that are not R-minor based on sparse paving matroids. Valuated matroids are inherently related to gross substitute valuations in mathematical economics. By the same token we refute the Matroid Based Valuation Conjecture by Ostrovsky and Paes Leme (Theoretical Economics 2015) asserting that every gross substitute valuation arises from weighted matroid rank functions by repeated applications of merge and endowment operations. Our result also has implications in the context of Lorentzian polynomials: it reveals the limitations of known construction operations.

Over a decade ago De Loera, Haws and Köppe conjectured that Ehrhart polynomials of matroid polytopes have only positive coefficients and that the coefficients of the corresponding $h^*$-polynomials form a unimodal sequence. The first of these intensively studied conjectures has recently been disproved by the first author who gave counterexamples in all ranks greater or equal to three. In this article we complete the picture by showing that Ehrhart polynomials of matroids of lower rank have indeed only positive coefficients. Moreover, we show that they are coefficient-wise bounded by the Ehrhart polynomials of minimal and uniform matroids. We furthermore address the second conjecture by proving that $h^*$-polynomials of matroid polytopes of sparse paving matroids of rank two are real-rooted and therefore have log-concave and unimodal coefficients. In particular, this shows that the $h^*$-polynomial of the second hypersimplex is real-rooted thereby strengthening a result of De Loera, Haws and Köppe.

In this article we disprove the conjectures asserting the positivity of the coefficients of the Ehrhart polynomial of matroid polytopes by De Loera, Haws and Köppe (2007) and of generalized permutohedra by Castillo and Liu (2015). We prove constructively that for every $n\geq 19$ there exist connected matroids on $n$ elements that are not Ehrhart positive. Also, we prove that for every $k\geq 3$ there exist connected matroids of rank $k$ that are not Ehrhart positive. Our proofs rely on our previous results on the geometric interpretation of the operation of circuit-hyperplane relaxation and our formulas for the Ehrhart polynomials of hypersimplices and minimal matroids. This allows us to give a precise expression for the Ehrhart polynomials of all sparse paving matroids, a class of matroids which is conjectured to be predominant and which contains the counterexamples arising from our construction.

In this paper we study the interplay between the operation of circuit-hyperplane relaxation and the Kazhdan--Lusztig theory of matroids. We obtain a family of polynomials, not depending on the matroids but only on their ranks, that relate the Kazhdan--Lusztig, the inverse Kazhdan--Lusztig and the $Z$-polynomial of each matroid with those of its relaxations. As an application of our main theorem, we prove that all matroids having a free basis are non-degenerate. Additionally, we obtain bounds and explicit formulas for all the coefficients of the Kazhdan--Lusztig, inverse Kazhdan--Lusztig and $Z$-polynomial of all sparse paving matroids.