arXiv++ Combinatorics

Gaussian Boson Samplers aim to demonstrate quantum advantage by performing a sampling task believed to be classically hard. The probabilities of individual outcomes in the sampling experiment are determined by the Hafnian of an appropriately constructed symmetric matrix. For nonnegative matrices, there is a family of randomized estimators of the Hafnian based on generating a particular random matrix and calculating its determinant. While these estimators are unbiased (the mean of the determinant is equal to the Hafnian of interest), their variance may be so high as to prevent an efficient estimation. Here we investigate the performance of two such estimators, which we call the Barvinok and Godsil-Gutman estimators. We find that in general both estimators perform well for adjacency matrices of random graphs, demonstrating a slow growth of variance with the size of the problem. Nonetheless, there are simple examples where both estimators show high variance, requiring an exponential number of samples. In addition, we calculate the asymptotic behavior of the variance for the complete graph. Finally, we simulate the Gaussian Boson Sampling using the Godsil-Gutman estimator and show that this technique can successfully reproduce low-order correlation functions.

Mobiles are a particular class of decorated plane trees which serve as codings for planar maps. Here we address the question of enumerating mobiles in their most general flavor, in correspondence with planar Eulerian (i.e., bicolored) maps. We show that the generating functions for such mobiles satisfy a number of recursive equations which lie in the field of integrable systems, leading us to explicit expressions for these generating functions as ratios of particular determinants. In particular we recover known results for mobiles associated with uncolored maps and prove some conjectured formulas for the generating functions of mobiles associated with $p$-constellations.

We show that exchangeable structures such as Polya urn model and Chinese restaurant process can be constructed from sets with a real number of elements. From this construction, the exchangeability of these structures becomes obvious and the calculations on them become extremely simple. Moreover, the usual calculations on these structures, which involve induction, integrals and Jacobian determinants, now can be done by simple combinatorial calculations.

This paper introduces a framework to study discrete optimization problems which are parametric in the following sense: their constraint matrices correspond to matrices over the ring $\mathbb{Z}[x]$ of polynomials in one variable. We investigate in particular matrices whose subdeterminants all lie in a fixed set $S\subseteq\mathbb{Z}[x]$. Such matrices, which we call totally $S$-modular matrices, are closed with respect to taking submatrices, so it is natural to look at minimally non-totally $S$-modular matrices which we call forbidden minors for $S$. Among other results, we prove that if $S$ is finite, then the set of all determinants attained by a forbidden minor for $S$ is also finite. Specializing to the integers, we subsequently obtain the following positive complexity result: the recognition problem for totally $\pm\{0,1,a,a+1,2a+1\}$-modular matrices with $a\in\mathbb{Z}\backslash\{-3,-2,1,2\}$ and the integer linear optimization problem for totally $\pm\{ 0,a,a+1,2a+1\}$-modular matrices with $a\in\mathbb{Z}\backslash\{ -2,1\}$ can be solved in polynomial time.

We prove that any invariant of a 4-quiver, that is piecewise polynomial, moreover, polynomial for fixed signs of entries, is a function of determinant of a quiver.

The classical hook length formula of enumerative combinatorics expresses the number of standard Young tableaux of a given partition shape as a single fraction. In recent years, two generalizations of this formula have emerged: one by Pak and Postnikov, replacing the number by a (rational) generating function, and one by Naruse, which generalizes the setting from a partition to a skew partition. Both generalizations appear to lie significantly deeper, with no simple proofs known. We combine them into a generating-function identity for skew partitions, and prove it in a fairly elementary way using recursion, determinants and simple combinatorics.

We address the computation of the degrees of minors of a noncommutative symbolic matrix of form \[ A[c] := \sum_{k=1}^m A_k t^{c_k} x_k, \] where $A_k$ are matrices over a field $\mathbb{K}$, $x_i$ are noncommutative variables, $c_k$ are integer weights, and $t$ is a commuting variable specifying the degree. This problem extends noncommutative Edmonds' problem (Ivanyos et al. 2017), and can formulate various combinatorial optimization problems. Extending the study by Hirai 2018, and Hirai, Ikeda 2022, we provide novel duality theorems and polyhedral characterization for the maximum degrees of minors of $A[c]$ of all sizes, and develop a strongly polynomial-time algorithm for computing them. This algorithm is viewed as a unified algebraization of the classical Hungarian method for bipartite matching and the weight-splitting algorithm for linear matroid intersection. As applications, we provide polynomial-time algorithms for weighted fractional linear matroid matching and linear optimization over rank-2 Brascamp-Lieb polytopes.

In the paper, by virtue of the famous formula of Faà di Bruno, with the aid of several identities of partial Bell polynomials, by means of a formula for derivatives of the ratio of two differentiable functions, and with availability of other techniques, the authors establish closed-form formulas in terms of the Bernoulli numbers and the second kind Stirling numbers, present determinantal expressions, derive recursive relations, obtain power series, and compute special values of the function $\frac{v^j}{1-\operatorname{e}^{-v}}$, its derivatives, and related ones used in Clark--Ismail's two conjectures. By these results, the authors also discover a formula for the determinant of a Hessenberg matrix and derive logarithmic convexity of a sequence related to the function and its derivatives.

Martin Aigner introduced Catalan-like numbers as elements of the first column of admissible matrices and studied Hankel determinants of their forward shifts. In this paper we collect some properties of the Hankel determinants of the other columns which are suggested by computer experiments. By prepending zero rows to admissible matrices we also consider Hankel determinants of backward shifts.

Graham showed with Pollak and Hoffman-Hosoya that for any directed graph $G$ with strong blocks $G_e$, the determinant $\det(D_G)$ and cofactor-sum $cof(D_G)$ of the distance matrix $D_G$ can be computed from the same quantities for the blocks $G_e$. This was extended to trees - and in our recent work to any graph - with multiplicative and $q$-distance matrices. For trees, we went further and unified all previous variants with weights in a unital commutative ring, into a distance matrix with additive and multiplicative edge-data. In this work: (1) We introduce the additive-multiplicative distance matrix $D_G$ of every strongly connected graph $G$, using what we term the additive-multiplicative block-datum $\mathcal{G}$. This subsumes the previously studied additive, multiplicative, and $q$-distances for all graphs. (2) We introduce an invariant $κ(D_G)$ that seems novel to date, and use it to show "master" Graham-Hoffman-Hosoya (GHH) identities, which express $\det(D_G), cof(D_G)$ in terms of the blocks $G_e$. We show how these imply all previous variants. (3) We show $\det(.), cof(.), κ(.)$ depend only on the block-data for not just $D_G$, but also several minors of $D_G$. This was not studied in any setting to date; we show it in the "most general" additive-multiplicative setting, hence in all known settings. (4) We compute $D_G^{-1}$ in closed-form; this specializes to all known variants. In particular, we recover our previous formula for $D_T^{-1}$ for additive-multiplicative trees (which itself specializes to a result of Graham-Lovasz and answers a 2006 question of Bapat-Lal-Pati.) (5) We also show that not the Laplacian, but a closely related matrix is the "correct" one to use in $D_G^{-1}$ - for the most general additive-multiplicative matrix $D_G$ of each $G$. As examples, we compute in closed form $\det(D_G), cof(D_G), κ(D_G), D_G^{-1}$ for hypertrees.

We present a version of the matrix-tree theorem, which relates the determinant of a matrix to sums of weights of arborescences of its directed graph representation. Our treatment allows for non-zero column sums in the parent matrix by adding a root vertex to the usually considered matrix directed graph. We use our result to prove a version of the matrix-forest, or all-minors, theorem, which relates minors of the matrix to forests of arborescences of the matrix digraph. We then show that it is possible, when the source and target vertices of an arc are not strongly connected, to move the source of the arc in the matrix directed graph and leave the resulting matrix determinant unchanged, as long as the source and target vertices are not strongly connected after the move. This result enables graphical strategies for factoring matrix determinants.

Let $G$ be an $n$-vertex graph and $Q(G)$ be its signless Laplacian matrix. The $Q$-walk matrix of $G$, denoted by $W_Q(G)$, is $[e,Q(G)e,\ldots,Q^{n-1}(G)e]$, where $e$ is the all-one vector. Let $G\circ P_m$ be the graph obtained from $G$ and $n$ copies of the path $P_m$ by identifying the $i$-th vertex of $G$ with an endvertex of the $i$-th copy of $P_m$ for each $i$. We prove that, $$\det W_Q(G\circ P_m)=\pm (\det Q(G))^{m-1}(\det W_Q(G))^m$$ holds for any $m\ge 2$. This gives a signless Laplacian counterpart of the following recently established identity [17]: $$\det W_A(G\circ P_m)=\pm (\det A(G))^{\lfloor\frac{m}{2}\rfloor}(\det W_A(G))^m,$$ where $A(G)$ is the adjacency matrix of $G$ and $W_A(G)=[e,A(G)e,\ldots,A^{n-1}(G)e]$. We also propose a conjecture to unify the above two equalities.

$\newcommand{\Max}{\mathrm{Max4PC}}$ The Four point condition (4PC henceforth) is a well known condition characterising distances in trees $T$. Let $w,x,y,z$ be four vertices in $T$ and let $d_{x,y}$ denote the distance between vertices $x,y$ in $T$. The 4PC condition says that among the three terms $d_{w,x} + d_{y,z}$, $d_{w,y} + d_{x,z}$ and $d_{w,z} + d_{x,y}$ the maximum value equals the second maximum value. We define an $\binom{n}{2} \times \binom{n}{2}$ sized matrix $\Max_T$ from a tree $T$ where the rows and columns are indexed by size-2 subsets. The entry of $\Max_T$ corresponding to the row indexed by $\{w,x\}$ and column $\{y,z\}$ is the maximum value among the three terms $d_{w,x} + d_{y,z}$, $d_{w,y} + d_{x,z}$ and $d_{w,z} + d_{x,y}$. In this work, we determine basic properties of this matrix like rank, give an algorithm that outputs a family of bases, and find the determinant of $\Max_T$ when restricted to our basis. We further determine the inertia and the Smith Normal Form (SNF) of $\Max_T$.

Computer experiments suggest some conjectures about Hankel determinants of convolution powers of Catalan numbers. Unfortunately, for most of them I have no proofs. I would like to present them anyway hoping that someone finds them interesting and can prove them.

We study a combinatorial model of the quantum scalar field with polynomial potential on a graph. In the first quantization formalism, the value of a Feynman graph is given by a sum over maps from the Feynman graph to the spacetime graph (mapping edges to paths). This picture interacts naturally with Atiyah-Segal-like cutting-gluing of spacetime graphs. In particular, one has combinatorial counterparts of the known gluing formulae for Green's functions and (zeta-regularized) determinants of Laplacians.

We review the connections between the octahedral recurrence, $λ$-determinants and tiling problems. This provides in particular a direct combinatorial interpretation of the $λ$-determinant (and generalizations thereof) of an arbitrary matrix in terms of domino tilings of Aztec diamonds. We also reinterpret the general Robbins-Rumsey formula for the rational function of consecutive minors, given by a summation over pairs of compatible alternating sign matrices, as the partition function for tilings of Aztec diamonds equipped with a general measure.

It is broadly known that any parallelepiped tiles space by translating copies of itself along its edges. In earlier work relating to higher-dimensional sandpile groups, the second author discovered a novel construction which fragments the parallelpiped into a collection of smaller tiles. These tiles fill space with the same symmetry as the larger parallelepiped. Their volumes are equal to the components of the multi-row Laplace determinant expansion, so this construction only works when all these signs are non-negative (or non-positive). In this work, we extend the construction to work for all parallelepipeds, without requiring the non-negative condition. This naturally gives tiles with negative volume, which we understand to mean canceling out tiles with positive volume. In fact, with this cancellation, we prove that every point in space is contained in exactly one more tile with positive volume than tile with negative volume. This is a natural definition for a signed tiling. Our main technique is to show that the net number of signed tiles doesn't change as a point moves through space. This is a relatively indirect proof method, and the underlying structure of these tilings remains mysterious.

We introduce multicritical Schur measures, which are probability laws on integer partitions which give rise to non-generic fluctuations at their edge. They are in the same universality classes as one-dimensional momentum-space models of free fermions in flat confining potentials, studied by Le Doussal, Majumdar and Schehr. These universality classes involve critical exponents of the form 1/(2m+1), with m a positive integer, and asymptotic distributions given by Fredholm determinants constructed from higher order Airy kernels, extending the generic Tracy-Widom GUE distribution recovered for m=1. We also compute limit shapes for the multicritical Schur measures, discuss the finite temperature setting, and exhibit an exact mapping to the multicritical unitary matrix models previously encountered by Periwal and Shevitz.

We define an equivalence relation on periodic continued fractions with partial quotients in a ring $\mathcal{O} \subseteq \mathbf{C}$, a group law on these equivalence classes, and a map from these equivalence classes to matrices in $\mathrm{GL}_2(\mathcal{O})$ with determinant $\pm1$. We prove this group of equivalence classes is isomorphic to $\mathbf{Z}/2\mathbf{Z}\ast\mathcal{O}$ and study certain of its one- and two-dimensional representations. For a periodic continued fraction with period $k$, we give a refined description of the limits of the $k$ different $k$-decimations of its sequence of convergents. We show that for a periodic continued fraction associated to a matrix with eigenvalues of different magnitudes, all $k$ of these limits exist in $\mathbb{P}^1(\mathbf{C})$ and a strict majority of them are equal.

In this {\it case study}, we hope to show why Sheldon Axler was not just wrong, but {\em wrong}, when he urged, in 1995: ``Down with Determinants!''. We first recall how determinants are useful in enumerative combinatorics, and then illustrate three versatile tools (Dodgson's condensation, the holonomic ansatz and constant term evaluations) to operate in tandem to prove a certain intriguing determinantal formula conjectured by the first author. We conclude with a postscript describing yet another, much more efficient, method for evaluating determinants: `ask determinant-guru, Christian Krattenthaler', but advise people only to use it as a last resort, since if we would have used this last method right away, we would not have had the fun of doing it all by ourselves.