arXiv++ Combinatorics

Based on work with Greenfeld and with Ziegler, Tao showed a concatenation result that if a map $f : \mathbb{F}^2 \to \mathbb{F}$ is affine-linear on every line parallel to the coordinate axes, and on all lines with a fixed nonzero slope (where the field $\mathbb{F}$ has size $> 2$), then $f$ is affine-linear on $\mathbb{F}^2$. We extend this from $\mathbb{F}^2$ to $\mathbb{F}^n$ and obtain a tight minimum number of additional lines needed -- $N = \binom{n}{\lfloor n/2 \rfloor}$ -- for every field $\mathbb{F}$ with $3 \leqslant n < |\mathbb{F}|$. The proof is constructive and shows a stronger result: the existence of a universal family of $0$-$1$ matrices of size $\binom{n}{k} \times \binom{n}{k}$ (one for each pair $0 \leqslant k \leqslant n$), which are indexed by ballot sets and are unimodular over all unital commutative rings. We also show a second tightness: of the assumption $n < |\mathbb{F}|$. Else, there exist multi-affine maps $f$ which are affine-linear on every line through the origin, but not affine-linear globally on $\mathbb{F}^n$. More strongly, we prove this dichotomy -- including the bound of $N$ -- over all integral domains, or Noetherian (e.g.\ finite or Artinian) rings, or products of these. This yields a novel numerical invariant for affine-linearity, for every product of Noetherian rings and integral domains.

Majorization inequalities have a long history, going back to Maclaurin and Newton. They were recently studied for several families of symmetric functions, including by Cuttler--Greene--Skandera (2011), Sra (2016), Khare--Tao (2021), McSwiggen--Novak (2022), and Chen--Sahi (2024+) among others. Here we extend the inequalities by these authors to Jack and Macdonald polynomials, and obtain conjectural characterizations of majorization and of weak majorization of the underlying partitions. We prove these characterizations for several cases of partitions, including all partitions with two parts. In fact, we upgrade -- and prove in the above cases -- the characterization of majorization, to containment of Jack and Macdonald differences lying in the Muirhead semiring.

In 2022, Huh-Matherne-Mészáros-St. Dizier showed that normalized Schur polynomials are Lorentzian, thereby yielding their continuous (resp. discrete) log-concavity on the positive orthant (resp. on their support, in type $A$ root directions). A reinterpretation of this result is that the characters of finite-dimensional simple representations of $\mathfrak{sl}_{n+1}(\mathbb{C})$ are denormalized Lorentzian (DL). In the same paper, these authors also showed that shifted characters of Verma modules over $\mathfrak{sl}_{n+1}(\mathbb{C})$ are DL. In this work we extend these results to a larger family of modules that subsumes both of the above: we show that shifted characters of all parabolic Verma modules over $\mathfrak{sl}_{n+1}(\mathbb{C})$ are denormalized Lorentzian. The proof involves certain graphs on $[n+1]$; more strongly, we explain why the character (i.e., generating function) of the Kostant partition function of any loopless multigraph on $[n+1]$ is Lorentzian after shifting and normalizing. We then show that parabolic Vermas form a "maximal" class with log-concave (hence DL) characters. Namely, log-concavity fails in greater generality along three natural directions: (1) it does not hold for every simple Lie type, (2) nor for a larger universal family of highest weight modules, the higher order Verma modules, even in type $A$, and (3) it does not always hold for important generalizations of Schur polynomials: the Jack and Macdonald polynomials. Finally, we extend these results to parabolic (i.e. "first order") and higher order Verma modules over the semisimple Lie algebras $\oplus_{t=1}^T \mathfrak{sl}_{n_t+1}(\mathbb{C})$. We also partially resolve a conjecture of Huh et al on the DL property for integral highest weight simple modules.

We continue the study of real polynomials acting entrywise on matrices of fixed dimension to preserve positive semidefiniteness, together with the related analysis of order properties of Schur polynomials. Previous work has shown that, given a real polynomial with positive coefficients that is perturbed by adding a higher-degree monomial, there exists a negative lower bound for the coefficient of the perturbation which characterizes when the perturbed polynomial remains positivity preserving. We show here that, if the perturbation coefficient is strictly greater than this bound then the transformed matrix becomes positive definite given a simple genericity condition that can be readily verified. We identity a slightly stronger genericity condition that ensures positive definiteness occurs at the boundary. The analysis is complemented by computing the rank of the transformed matrix in terms of the location of the original matrix in a Schubert cell-type stratification that we have introduced and explored previously. The proofs require enhancing to strictness a Schur monotonicity result of Khare and Tao, to show that the ratio of Schur polynomials is strictly increasing along each coordinate on the positive orthant and non-decreasing on its closure whenever the defining tuples satisfy a coordinate-wise domination condition.

Graham showed with Pollak and Hoffman-Hosoya that for any directed graph $G$ with strong blocks $G_e$, the determinant $\det(D_G)$ and cofactor-sum $cof(D_G)$ of the distance matrix $D_G$ can be computed from the same quantities for the blocks $G_e$. This was extended to trees - and in our recent work to any graph - with multiplicative and $q$-distance matrices. For trees, we went further and unified all previous variants with weights in a unital commutative ring, into a distance matrix with additive and multiplicative edge-data. In this work: (1) We introduce the additive-multiplicative distance matrix $D_G$ of every strongly connected graph $G$, using what we term the additive-multiplicative block-datum $\mathcal{G}$. This subsumes the previously studied additive, multiplicative, and $q$-distances for all graphs. (2) We introduce an invariant $κ(D_G)$ that seems novel to date, and use it to show "master" Graham-Hoffman-Hosoya (GHH) identities, which express $\det(D_G), cof(D_G)$ in terms of the blocks $G_e$. We show how these imply all previous variants. (3) We show $\det(.), cof(.), κ(.)$ depend only on the block-data for not just $D_G$, but also several minors of $D_G$. This was not studied in any setting to date; we show it in the "most general" additive-multiplicative setting, hence in all known settings. (4) We compute $D_G^{-1}$ in closed-form; this specializes to all known variants. In particular, we recover our previous formula for $D_T^{-1}$ for additive-multiplicative trees (which itself specializes to a result of Graham-Lovasz and answers a 2006 question of Bapat-Lal-Pati.) (5) We also show that not the Laplacian, but a closely related matrix is the "correct" one to use in $D_G^{-1}$ - for the most general additive-multiplicative matrix $D_G$ of each $G$. As examples, we compute in closed form $\det(D_G), cof(D_G), κ(D_G), D_G^{-1}$ for hypertrees.

Motivated by recent results of Tao-Ziegler [Discrete Anal. 2016] and Greenfeld-Tao (2022 preprint) on concatenating affine-linear functions along subgroups of an abelian group, we show three results on recovering affine-linearity of functions $f : V \to W$ from their restrictions to affine lines, where $V,W$ are $\mathbb{F}$-vector spaces and $\dim V \geqslant 2$. First, if $\dim V < |\mathbb{F}|$ and $f : V \to \mathbb{F}$ is affine-linear when restricted to affine lines parallel to a basis and to certain "generic" lines through $0$, then $f$ is affine-linear on $V$. (This extends to all modules $M$ over unital commutative rings $R$ with large enough characteristic.) Second, we explain how a classical result attributed to von Staudt (1850s) extends beyond bijections: if $f : V \to W$ preserves affine lines $\ell$, and if $f(v) \not\in f(\ell)$ whenever $v \not\in \ell$, then this also suffices to recover affine-linearity on $V$, but up to a field automorphism. In particular, if $\mathbb{F}$ is a prime field $\mathbb{Z}/p\mathbb{Z}$ ($p>2$) or $\mathbb{Q}$, or a completion $\mathbb{Q}_p$ or $\mathbb{R}$, then $f$ is affine-linear on $V$. We then quantitatively refine our first result above, via a weak multiplicative variant of the additive $B_h$-sets initially explored by Singer [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 1938], Erdos-Turan [J. London Math. Soc. 1941], and Bose-Chowla [Comment. Math. Helv. 1962]. Weak multiplicative $B_h$-sets occur inside all rings with large enough characteristic, and in all infinite or large enough finite integral domains/fields. We show that if $R$ is among any of these classes of rings, and $M = R^n$ for some $n \geqslant 3$, then one requires affine-linearity on at least $\binom{n}{\lceil n/2 \rceil}$-many generic lines to deduce the global affine-linearity of $f$ on $R^n$. Moreover, this bound is sharp.

For every finite simple connected graph $G = (V,E)$, we introduce an invariant, its blowup-polynomial $p_G(\{ n_v : v \in V \})$. This is obtained by dividing the determinant of the distance matrix of its blowup graph $G[{\bf n}]$ (containing $n_v$ copies of $v$) by an exponential factor. We show that $p_G({\bf n})$ is indeed a polynomial function in the sizes $n_v$, which is moreover multi-affine and real-stable. This associates a hitherto unexplored delta-matroid to each graph $G$; and we provide a second unexplored one for each tree. As another consequence, we obtain a new characterization of complete multipartite graphs, via the homogenization at $-1$ of $p_G$ being completely/strongly log-concave, i.e., Lorentzian. (These results extend to weighted graphs.) Finally, we show $p_G$ is indeed a graph invariant, i.e., $p_G$ and its symmetries (in the variables ${\bf n}$) recover $G$ and its isometries, respectively.

Cauchy's determinant formula (1841) involving $\det ((1-u_i v_j)^{-1})$ is a fundamental result in symmetric function theory. It has been extended in several directions, including a determinantal extension by Frobenius [J. reine angew. Math. 1882] involving a sum of two geometric series in $u_i v_j$. This theme also resurfaced in a matrix analysis setting in a paper by Horn [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 1969] - where the computations are attributed to Loewner - and in recent works by Belton-Guillot-Khare-Putinar [Adv. Math. 2016] and Khare-Tao [Amer. J. Math. 2021]. These formulas were recently unified and extended in [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 2022] to arbitrary power series, with commuting/bosonic variables $u_i, v_j$. In this note we formulate analogous permanent identities, and in fact, explain how all of these results are a special case of a more general identity, for any character - in fact, any complex class function - of any finite group that acts on the bosonic variables $u_i$ and on the $v_j$ via signed permutations. (We explain why larger linear groups do not work, via a - perhaps novel - "symmetric function" characterization of signed permutation matrices that holds over any integral domain.) We then provide fermionic analogues of these formulas, as well as of the closely related Cauchy product identities.

Associated to every complex reflection group, we construct a lattice of quotients of its braid monoid-algebra, which we term nil-Hecke algebras, and which are obtained by killing all braid words that are "sufficiently long", as well as some integer power of each generator. These include usual nil-Coxeter algebras, nil-Temperley-Lieb algebras, and their variants, and lead to symmetric semigroup module categories which necessarily cannot be monoidal. Motivated by classical work of Coxeter (1957) and the Broue-Malle-Rouquier freeness conjecture [Crelle 1998], and continuing beyond work of the second author [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 2018], we obtain a complete classification of the finite-dimensional nil-Hecke algebras for all complex reflection groups $W$. These comprise the usual nil-Coxeter algebras for $W$ of finite type, their "fully commutative" analogues for $W$ of FC-finite type, three exceptional algebras (of types $F_4,H_3,H_4$), and three exceptional series (of types $B_n$ and $A_n$, two of them novel). In particular, we find the first - and only two - finite-dimensional nil-Hecke algebras over discrete complex reflection groups; this breaks from the nil-Coxeter case (where no braid words are further killed, and) where Marin [J. Pure Appl. Alg. 2014] and Khare [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 2018] showed that such algebras do not exist. In addition to these algebras, and also algebraic connections (to PBW deformations and non-monoidal tensor categories), we further uncover combinatorial bases of algebras, both known (fully commutative elements) and novel ($\bar{12}$-avoiding signed permutations). Our classification draws from and brings together results of Popov [Comm. Math. Inst. Utrecht 1982], Stembridge [J. Alg. Combin. 1996, 1998], Malle [Transform. Groups} 1996], Postnikov via Gowravaram-Khovanova (2015), Hart [J. Group Th. 2017], and Khare [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 2018].

In recent joint work (2021), we introduced a novel multivariate polynomial attached to every metric space - in particular, to every finite simple connected graph $G$ - and showed it has several attractive properties. First, it is multi-affine and real-stable (leading to a hitherto unstudied delta-matroid for each graph $G$). Second, the polynomial specializes to (a transform of) the characteristic polynomial $χ_{D_G}$ of the distance matrix $D_G$; as well as recovers the entire graph, where $χ_{D_G}$ cannot do so. Third, the polynomial encodes the determinants of a family of graphs formed from $G$, called the blowups of $G$. In this short note, we exhibit the applicability of these tools and techniques to other graph-matrices and their characteristic polynomials. As a particular case, we will see that the adjacency characteristic polynomial $χ_{A_G}$ is in fact the shadow of a richer multivariate blowup-polynomial, which is similarly multi-affine and real-stable. Moreover, this polynomial encodes not only the aforementioned three properties, but also yields additional information for specific families of graphs.

To every finite metric space $X$, including all connected unweighted graphs with the minimum edge-distance metric, we attach an invariant that we call its blowup-polynomial $p_X(\{ n_x : x \in X \})$. This is obtained from the blowup $X[{\bf n}]$ - which contains $n_x$ copies of each point $x$ - by computing the determinant of the distance matrix of $X[{\bf n}]$ and removing an exponential factor. We prove that as a function of the sizes $n_x$, $p_X({\bf n})$ is a polynomial, is multi-affine, and is real-stable. This naturally associates a hitherto unstudied delta-matroid to each metric space $X$; we produce another novel delta-matroid for each tree, which interestingly does not generalize to all graphs. We next specialize to the case of $X = G$ a connected unweighted graph - so $p_G$ is "partially symmetric" in $\{ n_v : v \in V(G) \}$ - and show three further results: (a) We show that the polynomial $p_G$ is indeed a graph invariant, in that $p_G$ and its symmetries recover the graph $G$ and its isometries, respectively. (b) We show that the univariate specialization $u_G(x) := p_G(x,\dots,x)$ is a transform of the characteristic polynomial of the distance matrix $D_G$; this connects the blowup-polynomial of $G$ to the well-studied "distance spectrum" of $G$. (c) We obtain a novel characterization of complete multipartite graphs, as precisely those for which the "homogenization at $-1$" of $p_G({\bf n})$ is real-stable (equivalently, Lorentzian, or strongly/completely log-concave), if and only if the normalization of $p_G(-{\bf n})$ is strongly Rayleigh.

Graham-Pollak showed that for $D = D_T$ the distance matrix of a tree $T$, det$(D)$ depends only on its number of edges. Several other variants of $D$, including directed/multiplicative/$q$- versions were studied, and always, det$(D)$ depends only on the edge-data. We introduce a general framework for bi-directed weighted trees, with threefold significance. First, we improve on state-of-the-art for all known variants, even in the classical Graham-Pollak case: we delete arbitrary pendant nodes (and more general subsets) from the rows/columns of $D$, and show these minors do not depend on the tree-structure. Second, our setting unifies all known variants (with entries in a commutative ring). We further compute $D^{-1}$ in closed form, extending a result of Graham-Lovasz [Adv. Math. 1978] and answering an open question of Bapat-Lal-Pati [Lin. Alg. Appl. 2006] in greater generality. Third, we compute a second function of the matrix $D$: the sum of all its cofactors, cof$(D)$. This was worked out in the simplest setting by Graham-Hoffman-Hosoya (1978), but is relatively unexplored for other variants. We prove a stronger result, in our general setting, by computing cof$(.)$ for minors as above, and showing these too depend only on the edge-data. Finally, we show our setting is the "most general possible", in that with more freedom in the edgeweights, det$(D)$ and cof$(D)$ depend on the tree structure. In a sense, this completes the study of the invariants det$(D_T)$, cof$(D_T)$ for trees $T$ with edge-data in a commutative ring. Moreover: for a bi-directed graph $G$ we prove multiplicative Graham-Hoffman-Hosoya type formulas for det$(D_G)$, cof$(D_G)$, $D_G^{-1}$. We then show how this subsumes their 1978 result. The final section introduces and computes a third, novel invariant for trees and a Graham-Hoffman-Hosoya type result for our "most general" distance matrix $D_T$.

This survey contains a selection of topics unified by the concept of positive semi-definiteness (of matrices or kernels), reflecting natural constraints imposed on discrete data (graphs or networks) or continuous objects (probability or mass distributions). We put emphasis on entrywise operations which preserve positivity, in a variety of guises. Techniques from harmonic analysis, function theory, operator theory, statistics, combinatorics, and group representations are invoked. Some partially forgotten classical roots in metric geometry and distance transforms are presented with comments and full bibliographical references. Modern applications to high-dimensional covariance estimation and regularization are included.

A special case of a fundamental result of Loewner and Horn [Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 1969] says that given an integer $n \geq 1$, if the entrywise application of a smooth function $f : (0,\infty) \to \mathbb{R}$ preserves the set of $n \times n$ positive semidefinite matrices with positive entries, then $f$ and its first $n-1$ derivatives are non-negative on $(0,\infty)$. In a recent joint work with Belton-Guillot-Putinar [J. Eur. Math. Soc., in press], we proved a stronger version, and used it to strengthen the Schoenberg-Rudin characterization of dimension-free positivity preservers [Duke Math. J. 1942, 1959]. In recent works with Belton-Guillot-Putinar [Adv. Math. 2016] and with Tao [Amer. J. Math., in press] we used local, real-analytic versions at the origin of the Horn-Loewner condition, and discovered unexpected connections between entrywise polynomials preserving positivity and Schur polynomials. In this paper, we unify these two stories via a Master Theorem (Theorem A) which (i) simultaneously unifies and extends all of the aforementioned variants; and (ii) proves the positivity of the first $n$ nonzero Taylor coefficients at individual points rather than on all of $(0,\infty)$. A key step in the proof is a new determinantal / symmetric function calculation (Theorem B), which shows that Schur polynomials arise naturally from considering arbitrary entrywise maps that are sufficiently differentiable. Of independent interest may be the following application to symmetric function theory: we extend the Schur function expansion of Cauchy's (1841) determinant (whose matrix entries are geometric series $1 / (1 - u_j v_k)$), as well as of a determinant of Frobenius [J. reine angew. Math. 1882] (whose matrix entries are a sum of two geometric series), to arbitrary power series, and over all commutative rings.

We provide the first formulae for the weights of all simple highest weight modules over Kac-Moody algebras. For generic highest weights, we present a formula for the weights of simple modules similar to the Weyl-Kac character formula. For the remaining highest weights, the formula fails in a striking way, suggesting the existence of 'multiplicity-free' Macdonald identities for affine root systems.

A surprising result of FitzGerald and Horn (1977) shows that $A^{\circ α} := (a_{ij}^α)$ is positive semidefinite (p.s.d.) for every entrywise nonnegative $n \times n$ p.s.d. matrix $A = (a_{ij})$ if and only if $α$ is a positive integer or $α\geq n-2$. Given a graph $G$, we consider the refined problem of characterizing the set $\mathcal{H}_G$ of entrywise powers preserving positivity for matrices with a zero pattern encoded by $G$. Using algebraic and combinatorial methods, we study how the geometry of $G$ influences the set $\mathcal{H}_G$. Our treatment provides new and exciting connections between combinatorics and analysis, and leads us to introduce and compute a new graph invariant called the critical exponent.

Motivated by work of Coxeter (1957), we study a class of algebras associated to Coxeter groups, which we term 'generalized nil-Coxeter algebras'. We construct the first finite-dimensional examples other than usual nil-Coxeter algebras; these form a $2$-parameter type $A$ family that we term $NC_A(n,d)$. We explore the combinatorial properties of these algebras, including the Coxeter word basis, length function, maximal words, and their connection to Khovanov's categorification of the Weyl algebra. Our broader motivation arises from complex reflection groups and the Broue-Malle-Rouquier freeness conjecture (1998). With generic Hecke algebras over real and complex groups in mind, we show that the 'first' finite-dimensional examples $NC_A(n,d)$ are in fact the only ones, outside of the usual nil-Coxeter algebras. The proofs use a diagrammatic calculus akin to crystal theory.

We introduce new families of combinatorial objects whose enumeration computes volumes of flow polytopes. These objects provide an interpretation, based on parking functions, of Baldoni and Vergne's generalization of a volume formula originally due to Lidskii. We recover known flow polytope volume formulas and prove new volume formulas for flow polytopes that were seemingly unapproachable. A highlight of our model is an elegant formula for the flow polytope of a graph we call the caracol graph. As by-products of our work, we uncover a new triangle of numbers that interpolates between Catalan numbers and the number of parking functions, we prove the log-concavity of rows of this triangle along with other sequences derived from volume computations, and we introduce a new Ehrhart-like polynomial for flow polytope volume and conjecture product formulas for the polytopes we consider.

Given $I\subset\mathbb{C}$ and an integer $N>0$, a function $f:I\to\mathbb{C}$ is entrywise positivity preserving on positive semidefinite (p.s.d.) matrices $A=(a_{jk})\in I^{N\times N}$, if the entrywise application $f[A]=(f(a_{jk}))$ of $f$ to $A$ is p.s.d. for all such $A$. Such preservers in all dimensions have been classified by Schoenberg and Rudin as being absolutely monotonic [Duke Math. J. 1942, 1959]. In fixed dimension $N$, results akin to work of Horn and Loewner [Trans. AMS 1969] show the first $N$ nonzero Maclaurin coefficients of a positivity preserver $f$ are positive; and the last $N$ coefficients are also positive if $I$ is unbounded. However, little was known about the other coefficients: the only examples to date for unbounded domains $I$ were absolutely monotonic, so work in all dimensions; and for bounded $I$ examples of non-absolutely monotonic preservers were very few (and recent). In this paper, we completely characterize the sign patterns of the Maclaurin coefficients of positivity preservers in fixed dimension $N$, over bounded and unbounded domains $I$. In particular, the above Horn-type conditions cannot be improved upon. This also yields the first polynomials which preserve positivity on p.s.d. matrices in $I^{N\times N}$ but not in $I^{(N+1)\times (N+1)}$. We obtain analogous results for real exponents using the Harish-Chandra-Itzykson-Zuber formula. We then go from qualitative bounds, which suffice to understand all possible sign patterns, to exact quantitative bounds. As an application, we extend our previous qualitative and quantitative results to understand preservers of total non-negativity in fixed dimension - including their sign patterns. We deduce several further applications, including extending a Schur polynomial conjecture by Cuttler-Greene-Skandera to obtain a novel characterization of weak majorization for real tuples.

Let $V$ be a highest weight module over a Kac-Moody algebra $\mathfrak{g}$, and let conv $V$ denote the convex hull of its weights. We determine the combinatorial isomorphism type of conv $V$, i.e. we completely classify the faces and their inclusions. In the special case where $\mathfrak{g}$ is semisimple, this brings closure to a question studied by Cellini-Marietti [IMRN 2015] for the adjoint representation, and by Khare [J. Algebra 2016; Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 2017] for most modules. The determination of faces of finite-dimensional modules up to the Weyl group action and some of their inclusions also appears in previous work of Satake [Ann. of Math. 1960], Borel-Tits [IHES Publ. Math. 1965], Vinberg [Izv. Akad. Nauk 1990], and Casselman [Austral. Math. Soc. 1997]. For any subset of the simple roots, we introduce a remarkable convex cone which we call the universal Weyl polyhedron, which controls the convex hulls of all modules parabolically induced from the corresponding Levi factor. Namely, the combinatorial isomorphism type of the cone stores the classification of faces for all such highest weight modules, as well as how faces degenerate as the highest weight gets increasingly singular. To our knowledge, this cone is new in finite and infinite type. We further answer a question of Michel Brion, by showing that the localization of conv $V$ along a face is always the convex hull of the weights of a parabolically induced module. Finally, as we determine the inclusion relations between faces representation-theoretically from the set of weights, without recourse to convexity, we answer a similar question for highest weight modules over symmetrizable quantum groups.