arXiv++ Combinatorics

In their work on Brill-Noether theory, Eisenbud and Harris established the geometry of the universal parameter space of linear series over curves, proving that for even genus $g$ and degree $d = g/2 + 1$, the projection to the moduli space of curves is a finite cover of degree equal to the Catalan number $C_{g/2} = \frac{1}{g/2+1}\binom{g}{g/2}$. In this paper, we construct the tropical counterpart of this universal family: a polyhedral cone complex $\mathcal{G}_{g \to 0, d}^{\mathrm{trop}}$ parametrizing degree-$d$ tropical morphisms from genus-$g$ metric graphs to metric trees. For even $g$ and $d = g/2 + 1$, we prove that the forgetful projection $Π\colon \mathcal{G}_{g \to 0, d}^{\mathrm{trop}} \to \mathcal{M}_{g}^{\mathrm{trop}}$ is a branched cover of degree $C_{g/2}$ equipped with natural determinantal multiplicities. We compute this degree by showing that on caterpillars of loops the morphisms are in bijection with ballot sequences, and we establish its global invariance across $\mathcal{M}_{g}^{\mathrm{trop}}$ via a tropical balancing condition across codimension-$1$ walls. Via deformation and path lifting, this yields an effective method to construct Catalan-many gonality-witnessing maps for any generic metric graph, establishing that the tree gonality of any genus-$g$ metric graph is at most $\lceil g/2 \rceil + 1$.

Based on work with Greenfeld and with Ziegler, Tao showed a concatenation result that if a map $f : \mathbb{F}^2 \to \mathbb{F}$ is affine-linear on every line parallel to the coordinate axes, and on all lines with a fixed nonzero slope (where the field $\mathbb{F}$ has size $> 2$), then $f$ is affine-linear on $\mathbb{F}^2$. We extend this from $\mathbb{F}^2$ to $\mathbb{F}^n$ and obtain a tight minimum number of additional lines needed -- $N = \binom{n}{\lfloor n/2 \rfloor}$ -- for every field $\mathbb{F}$ with $3 \leqslant n < |\mathbb{F}|$. The proof is constructive and shows a stronger result: the existence of a universal family of $0$-$1$ matrices of size $\binom{n}{k} \times \binom{n}{k}$ (one for each pair $0 \leqslant k \leqslant n$), which are indexed by ballot sets and are unimodular over all unital commutative rings. We also show a second tightness: of the assumption $n < |\mathbb{F}|$. Else, there exist multi-affine maps $f$ which are affine-linear on every line through the origin, but not affine-linear globally on $\mathbb{F}^n$. More strongly, we prove this dichotomy -- including the bound of $N$ -- over all integral domains, or Noetherian (e.g.\ finite or Artinian) rings, or products of these. This yields a novel numerical invariant for affine-linearity, for every product of Noetherian rings and integral domains.

We show that, in the ring of virtual species, \[ \mathcal{I}=\sum_{m\geq 0}(-1)^m\prod_{i=1}^{m}\bigl((E^{-1})^i-1\bigr), \] where $\mathcal{I}$ is the species of interval orders and $E^{-1}$ is the multiplicative inverse of the species $E$ of sets. The right-hand side is the virtual species of signed ballot matrices introduced by Claesson and Hannah. They showed that its signed cardinality counts labeled interval orders. We strengthen this to a species identity, which we prove twice: first algebraically and then bijectively, using a natural sign-reversing involution. The cycle index series of $\mathcal{I}$ specializes to the generating series for labeled and unlabeled interval orders. We describe the automorphism group of an interval order as a Young subgroup and prove the identity $\mathcal{I}=\mathcal{R}\circ E_+$, where $\mathcal{R}$ is the species of rigid interval orders. We also show that Glaisher's T-number $T_n$ counts the $24$-colored interval orders on $[n]$ in which no isolated element has color $24$.

We study the two-player coupon-collector competition in which two independent collectors draw one coupon each per round from a set of $d$ equally likely coupon types. Myers and Wilf gave finite formulae for several two-player events and explicitly left open the ballot-type problem of finding the probability that the ultimate winner was never behind. We prove that this probability satisfies $$ b_d \sim \frac{2}{d}, \qquad d\to\infty .$$ The proof uses a renewal decomposition at the tie boundary. The first one-sided tie-break has an explicit entrance distribution; its level, scaled by $d^{1/2}$, converges to a Rayleigh law; and, after the break, the leader's survival probability is governed by a Catalan, or gambler's-ruin, harmonic. The main estimate shows that the accumulated defect of this comparison harmonic in the exact simultaneous-round chain is negligible.

We introduce a linear map on symmetric functions that 'divides' a partition by a positive integer $k$, sending a Schur function indexed by a partition of $kn$ to a symmetric function indexed by partitions of $n$. We prove that the image of this map is always Schur-positive, meaning it expands in the Schur basis with nonnegative integer coefficients. These coefficients are enumerated by a new family of combinatorial objects, called $k$-Yamanouchi tableaux, which generalize the classical ballot (Yamanouchi) tableaux appearing in the Littlewood-Richardson rule. We also obtain expansions in the power-sum basis and establish power-sum positivity. A further application establishes a connection to work of Tewodros Amdeberhan, John Shareshian, and Richard Stanley on alternating permutations and Euler numbers.

In this paper, we develop the metric geometry of ranking statistics, proving that the two major permutation distances in the statistics literature -- Kendall tau and Spearman footrule -- extend naturally to incomplete rankings with both coordinate embeddings and graph realizations. This gives us a unifying framework that allows us to connect popular topics in computational social choice: metric preferences (and metric distortion), polarization, and proportionality. As an important application, the metric structure enables efficient identification of blocs of voters and slates of their preferred candidates. Since the definitions work for partial ballots, we can execute the methods not only on synthetic elections, but on a suite of real-world elections. This gives us robust clustering methods that often produce an identical grouping of voters -- even though one family of methods is based on a Condorcet-consistent ranking rule while the other is not.

We consider a family of binary triangular arrays, called approval ballot triangles (ABTs), that are in bijection with totally symmetric self-complementary plane partitions (TSSCPPs). These triangles correspond to a ballot process in which voters select their collection of approved candidates rather than voting for a single person. We situate ABTs within the ballot problem literature and then show that a strict-sense ballot can be decomposed into a list of sequentially compatible ABTs.

We define a weighted analog for the multidimensional Catalan numbers, obtain matrix-based recurrences for some of them, and give conditions under which they are periodic. Building on this framework, we introduce two new sequences of triangular arrays: the first one enumerates the $k$-dimensional Balanced ballot paths of exact height $s$; the second one is a new multidimensional generalization of the Narayana numbers, which count the number of Balanced ballot paths with exactly $p$ peaks.

In connection with Vassiliev's knot invariants, Stoimenow introduced in 1998 a class of matchings, also known as regular linearized chord diagrams. These matchings are linked to various combinatorial structures, all of which are associated with the Fishburn numbers. In this paper, we address a problem posed by Bevan et~al.\ concerning the identification of subsets of Stoimenow matchings that are counted by the Catalan numbers. We present five solutions in terms of pattern-avoiding matchings. We also consider four infinite families of patterns that generalize four of the five forbidden patterns appearing in the solution to the problem we solved and prove that the matchings avoiding them are equinumerous. Finally, we establish numerous results on distributions and joint equidistribution of statistics over Catalan-counted subsets of Fishburn structures, namely Stoimenow matchings, $(2+2)$-free posets, ascent sequences, and Fishburn permutations, notably expressing some of them in terms of Narayana numbers and others in terms of ballot numbers.

Arnol'd proved in 1992 that Springer numbers enumerate the Snakes, which are type $B$ analogs of alternating permutations. Chen, Fan and Jia in 2011 introduced the labeled ballot paths and established a ``hard'' bijection with snakes. Callan conjectured in 2012 and Han--Kitaev--Zhang proved recently that rc-invariant alternating permutations are counted by Springer numbers. Very recently, Chen--Fang--Kitaev--Zhang investigated multi-dimensional permutations and proved that weakly increasing $3$-dimensional permutations are also counted by Springer numbers. In this work, we construct a sequence of ``natural'' bijections linking the above four combinatorial objects.

How can we probabilistically predict the winner in a ranked-choice election without all ballots being counted? In this study, we introduce a novel algorithm designed to predict outcomes in Instant Runoff Voting (IRV) elections. The algorithm takes as input a set of discrete probability distributions describing vote totals for each candidate ranking and calculates the probability that each candidate will win the election. In fact, we calculate all possible sequences of eliminations that might occur in the IRV rounds and assign a probability to each. The discrete probability distributions can be arbitrary and, in applications, could be measured empirically from pre-election polling data or from partial vote tallies of an in-progress election. The algorithm is effective for elections with a small number of candidates (five or fewer), with fast execution on typical consumer computers. The run-time is short enough for our method to be used for real-time election night modeling where new predictions are made continuously as more and more vote information becomes available. We demonstrate the algorithm in abstract examples, and also using real data from the 2022 Alaska state elections to simulate election-night predictions and also predictions of election recounts.

The number of 123-avoiding permutation on $\{1,2,\ldots,n\}$ with a fixed leading terms is counted by the ballot numbers. The same holds for $132$-avoiding permutations. These results were proved by Miner and Pak using the Robinson-Schensted-Knuth (RSK) correspondence to connect permutations with Dyck paths. In this paper, we first provide an alternate proof of these enumeration results via a direct counting argument. We then study the number of pattern-avoiding permutations with a fixed prefix of length $t\geq1$, generalizing the $t=1$ case. We find exact expressions for single and pairs of patterns of length three as well as the pair $3412$ and $3421$. These expressions depend on $t$, the extrema, and the order statistics. We also define $r$-Wilf equivalence for permutations with a single fixed leading term $r$, and classify the $r$-Wilf-equivalence classes for both classical and vincular patterns of length three.

Permutations whose prefixes contain at least as many ascents as descents are called ballot permutations. Lin, Wang, and Zhao have previously enumerated ballot permutations avoiding small patterns and have proposed the problem of enumerating ballot permutations avoiding a pair of permutations of length $3$. We completely enumerate ballot permutations avoiding two patterns of length $3$ and we relate these avoidance classes with their respective recurrence relations and formulas, which leads to an interesting bijection between ballot permutations avoiding $132$ and $312$ with left factors of Dyck paths. In addition, we also conclude the Wilf-classification of ballot permutations avoiding sets of two patterns of length $3$, and we then extend our results to completely enumerate ballot permutations avoiding three patterns of length $3$.

We study the ring of quasisymmetric polynomials in $n$ anticommuting (fermionic) variables. Let $R_n$ denote the polynomials in $n$ anticommuting variables. The main results of this paper show the following interesting facts about quasisymmetric polynomials in anticommuting variables: (1) The quasisymmetric polynomials in $R_n$ form a commutative sub-algebra of $R_n$. (2) There is a basis of the quotient of $R_n$ by the ideal $I_n$ generated by the quasisymmetric polynomials in $R_n$ that is indexed by ballot sequences. The Hilbert series of the quotient is given by $$ \text{Hilb}_{R_n/I_n}(q) = \sum_{k=0}^{\lfloor{n/2}\rfloor} f^{(n-k,k)} q^k\,,$$ where $f^{(n-k,k)}$ is the number of standard tableaux of shape $(n-k,k)$. (3) There is a basis of the ideal generated by quasisymmetric polynomials that is indexed by sequences that break the ballot condition

A 3-dimensional Catalan word is a word on three letters so that the subword on any two letters is a Dyck path. For a given Dyck path $D$, a recently defined statistic counts the number of Catalan words with the property that any subword on two letters is exactly $D$. In this paper, we enumerate Dyck paths with this statistic equal to certain values, including all primes. The formulas obtained are in terms of Motzkin numbers and Motzkin ballot numbers.

A two lane road approaches a stoplight. The left lane merges into the right just past the intersection. Vehicles approach the intersection one at a time, with some drivers always choosing the right lane, while others always choose the shorter lane, giving preference to the right lane to break ties. An arrival sequence of vehicles can be represented as a binary string, where the zeros represent drivers always choosing the right lane, and the ones represent drivers choosing the shorter lane. From each arrival sequence we construct a merging path, which is a lattice path determined by the lane chosen by each car. We give closed formulas for the number of merging paths reaching the point $(n,m)$ with exactly $k$ zeros in the arrival sequence, and the expected length of the right lane for all arrival sequences with exactly $k$ zeros. Proofs involve an adaptation of Andre's Reflection Principle. Other interesting connections also emerge, including to: Ballot numbers, the expected maximum number of heads or tails appearing in a sequence of $n$ coin flips, the largest domino snake that can be made using pieces up to $[n:n]$, and the longest trail on the complete graph $K_n$ with loops.

We answer some questions on the asymptotics of ballot walks raised in [Personal Journal Shalosh B Ekhad and Doron Zeilberger, Apr 5, 2021; see also arXiv:2104.01731] and prove that these models are not D-finite. This short note demonstrates how the powerful tools developed in the last decades on lattice paths in convex cones help us to answer some challenging problems that were out of reach for a long time. On the way we generalize tandem walks to the family of large tandem walks whose steps are of arbitrary length and map them bijectively to a generalization of ballot walks in three dimensions.

Let pi = pi_1 pi_2 ... pi_n be a permutation in the symmetric group S_n written in one-line notation. The pinnacle set of pi, denoted Pin pi, is the set of all pi_i such that pi_{i-1} < pi_i > pi_{i+1}. This is an analogue of the well-studied peak set of pi where one considers values rather than positions. The pinnacle set was introduced by Davis, Nelson, Petersen, and Tenner who showed that it has many interesting properties. In particular, they proved that the number of subsets of [n] = {1, 2, ..., n} which can be the pinnacle set of some permutation is a binomial coefficient. Their proof involved a bijection with lattice paths and was somewhat involved. We give a simpler demonstration of this result which does not need lattice paths. Moreover, we show that our map and theirs are different descriptions of the same function. Davis et al. also studied the number of pinnacle sets with maximum m and cardinality d which they denoted by p(m,d). We show that these integers are ballot numbers and give two proofs of this fact: one using finite differences and one bijective. Diaz-Lopez, Harris, Huang, Insko, and Nilsen found a summation formula for calculating the number of permutations in S_n having a given pinnacle set. We derive a new expression for this number which is faster to calculate in many cases. We also show how this method can be adapted to find the number of orderings of a pinnacle set which can be realized by some pi in S_n.

We numerically estimate the critical exponents of certain enumeration sequences that naturally generalize the famous Catalan and super-Catalan sequences, and raise deep and original questions about their exact values, and whether they are rational numbers. In this version we announce that our questions were brilliantly answered by Michael Wallner, and that the pledged donation to the OEIS, in his honor, was made.

We introduce and study cover-inclusive and cover-exclusive Dyck tilings of type $D$. It is shown that the generating functions of Dyck tilings of type $D$ are expressed in terms of the generating function of ballot tilings of type $B$. We introduce link patterns of type $D$ and plane trees for a ballot path, and construct a map from trees to $\mathbb{Z}[q]$. This map gives the generating function of cover-inclusive Dyck tilings of type $D$ associated to the ballot path.