arXiv++ Combinatorics

We consider $h$-stable local optima of Ising spin glass models, defined as spin configurations such that for nearly all of the spins, flipping their values results in increasing energy by at least a given amount $h$. Spins satisfying this condition are referred to as $h$-stable spins for that configuration. Similarly, we consider a very related notion of $h$-friendly partitions of a graph. These are defined as bi-partitionings such that for most nodes, the normalized number of neighbors within the node's partition exceed the normalized number of neighbors outside the partition by a certain amount $h$. For spin glasses as well as sparse and dense random graphs, while restricting to bisections, we prove the existence of a phase transition for the normalized energy level $h$ around a universal value $h^*$. For $h$ below the phase transition value $h^*$, bisections exist where the number of spins (nodes) which are not $h$-stable (not $h$-friendly) is sublinear. Above the phase transition level $h^*$ the smallest number of spins that are not $h$-stable (not $h$-friendly) is linear. This confirms a conjecture from Behrens et al. (2022). Our results also allow the characterization of possible energy values of stable local optima for varying $h$. In particular, for $h=0$, this rigorously proves seminal results in statistical physics regarding the so-called metastable states, such as in the work of Bray and Moore (1981). Our results extend a recent proof of the so-called Friendly Partition Conjecture in Ferber et al. (2022) from the case $h=0$ to the case when $h$ takes general values. Our proofs are obtained by analyzing the model on sparse random graphs and adopting Lindeberg's type universality method to lift the results from sparse to dense graphs and spin systems.

For an odd integer $n = 2d-1$, let $\mathcal B_d$ be the subgraph of the hypercube $Q_n$ induced by the two largest layers. In this paper, we describe the typical structure of proper $q$-colorings of $V(\mathcal B_d)$ and give asymptotics on the number of them. The proofs use various tools including information theory (entropy), Sapozhenko's graph container method and a recently developed method of M. Jenssen and W. Perkins that combines Sapozhenko's graph container lemma with the cluster expansion for polymer models from statistical physics.

Strong spatial mixing (SSM) is an important quantitative notion of correlation decay for Gibbs distributions arising in statistical physics, probability theory, and theoretical computer science. A longstanding conjecture is that the uniform distribution on proper $q$-colorings on a $Δ$-regular tree exhibits SSM whenever $q \ge Δ+1$. Moreover, it is widely believed that as long as SSM holds on bounded-degree trees with $q$ colors, one would obtain an efficient sampler for $q$-colorings on all bounded-degree graphs via simple Markov chain algorithms. It is surprising that such a basic question is still open, even on trees, but then again it also highlights how much we still have to learn about random colorings. In this paper, we show the following: (1) For any $Δ\ge 3$, SSM holds for random $q$-colorings on trees of maximum degree $Δ$ whenever $q \ge Δ+ 3$. Thus we almost fully resolve the aforementioned conjecture. Our result substantially improves upon the previously best bound which requires $q \ge 1.59Δ+γ^*$ for an absolute constant $γ^* > 0$. (2) For any $Δ\ge 3$ and girth $g = Ω_Δ(1)$, we establish optimal mixing of the Glauber dynamics for $q$-colorings on graphs of maximum degree $Δ$ and girth $g$ whenever $q \ge Δ+3$. Our approach is based on a new general reduction from spectral independence on large-girth graphs to SSM on trees that is of independent interest. Using the same techniques, we also prove near-optimal bounds on weak spatial mixing (WSM), a closely-related notion to SSM, for the antiferromagnetic Potts model on trees.

Linear neural network layers that are either equivariant or invariant to permutations of their inputs form core building blocks of modern deep learning architectures. Examples include the layers of DeepSets, as well as linear layers occurring in attention blocks of transformers and some graph neural networks. The space of permutation equivariant linear layers can be identified as the invariant subspace of a certain symmetric group representation, and recent work parameterized this space by exhibiting a basis whose vectors are sums over orbits of standard basis elements with respect to the symmetric group action. A parameterization opens up the possibility of learning the weights of permutation equivariant linear layers via gradient descent. The space of permutation equivariant linear layers is a generalization of the partition algebra, an object first discovered in statistical physics with deep connections to the representation theory of the symmetric group, and the basis described above generalizes the so-called orbit basis of the partition algebra. We exhibit an alternative basis, generalizing the diagram basis of the partition algebra, with computational benefits stemming from the fact that the tensors making up the basis are low rank in the sense that they naturally factorize into Kronecker products. Just as multiplication by a rank one matrix is far less expensive than multiplication by an arbitrary matrix, multiplication with these low rank tensors is far less expensive than multiplication with elements of the orbit basis. Finally, we describe an algorithm implementing multiplication with these basis elements.

This is an exposition of the contributions of László Lovász to mathematics and computer science written on the occasion of the bestowal of the Abel Prize~2021 to him. Our survey, of course, cannot be exhaustive. We sketch remarkable results that solved well-known open and important problems and that -- in addition -- had lasting impact on the development of subsequent research and even started whole new theories. Although discrete mathematics is what one can call the Lovász home turf, his interests were, from the beginning of his academic career, much broader. He employed algebra, geometry, topology, analysis, stochastics, statistical physics, optimization, and complexity theory, to name a few, to contribute significantly to the explosive growth of combinatorics; but he also exported combinatorial techniques to many other fields, and thus built enduring bridges between several branches of mathematics and computer science. Topics such as computational convexity or topological combinatorics, for example, would not exist without his fundamental results. We also briefly mention his substantial influence on various developments in applied mathematics such as the optimization of real-world applications and cryptography.

In two-dimensional statistical physics, correlation functions of the O(N) and Potts models may be written as sums over configurations of non-intersecting loops. We define sums associated to a large class of combinatorial maps (also known as ribbon graphs). We allow disconnected maps, but not maps that include monogons. Given a map with n vertices, we obtain a function of the moduli of the corresponding punctured Riemann surface. Due to the map's combinatorial (rather than topological) nature, that function is single-valued, and we call it an n-point correlation function. We conjecture that in the critical limit, such functions form a basis of solutions of certain conformal bootstrap equations. They include all correlation functions of the O(N) and Potts models, and correlation functions that do not belong to any known model. We test the conjecture by counting solutions of crossing symmetry for four-point functions on the sphere.

In this article we consider certain well-known polynomials associated with graphs including the independence polynomial and the chromatic polynomial. These polynomials count certain objects in graphs: independent sets in the case of the independence polynomial and proper colourings in the case of the chromatic polynomial. They also have interpretations as partition functions in statistical physics. The algorithmic problem of (approximately) computing these types of polynomials has been studied for close to 50 years, especially using Markov chain techniques. Around eight years ago, Barvinok devised a new algorithmic approach based on Taylor's theorem for computing the permanent of certain matrices, and the approach has been applied to various graph polynomials since then. This article is intended as a gentle introduction to the approach as well as a partial survey of associated techniques and results.

In this paper we continue to rigorously establish the predictions in ground breaking work in statistical physics by Decelle, Krzakala, Moore, Zdeborová (2011) regarding the block model, in particular in the case of $q=3$ and $q=4$ communities. We prove that for $q=3$ and $q=4$ there is no computational-statistical gap if the average degree is above some constant by showing it is information theoretically impossible to detect below the Kesten-Stigum bound. The proof is based on showing that for the broadcast process on Galton-Watson trees, reconstruction is impossible for $q=3$ and $q=4$ if the average degree is sufficiently large. This improves on the result of Sly (2009), who proved similar results for regular trees for $q=3$. Our analysis of the critical case $q=4$ provides a detailed picture showing that the tightness of the Kesten-Stigum bound in the antiferromagnetic case depends on the average degree of the tree. We also prove that for $q\geq 5$, the Kestin-Stigum bound is not sharp. Our results prove conjectures of Decelle, Krzakala, Moore, Zdeborová (2011), Moore (2017), Abbe and Sandon (2018) and Ricci-Tersenghi, Semerjian, and Zdeborová (2019). Our proofs are based on a new general coupling of the tree and graph processes and on a refined analysis of the broadcast process on the tree.

We give a method for computing asymptotic formulas and approximations for the volumes of spectrahedra, based on the maximum-entropy principle from statistical physics. The method gives an approximate volume formula based on a single convex optimization problem of minimizing $-\log \det P$ over the spectrahedron. Spectrahedra can be described as affine slices of the convex cone of positive semi-definite (PSD) matrices, and the method yields efficient deterministic approximation algorithms and asymptotic formulas whenever the number of affine constraints is sufficiently dominated by the dimension of the PSD cone. Our approach is inspired by the work of Barvinok and Hartigan who used an analogous framework for approximately computing volumes of polytopes. Spectrahedra, however, possess a remarkable feature not shared by polytopes, a new fact that we also prove: central sections of the set of density matrices (the quantum version of the simplex) all have asymptotically the same volume. This allows for very general approximation algorithms, which apply to large classes of naturally occurring spectrahedra. We give two main applications of this method. First, we apply this method to what we call the "multi-way Birkhoff spectrahedron" and obtain an explicit asymptotic formula for its volume. This spectrahedron is the set of quantum states with maximal entanglement (i.e., the quantum states having univariant quantum marginals equal to the identity matrix) and is the quantum analog of the multi-way Birkhoff polytope. Second, we apply this method to explicitly compute the asymptotic volume of central sections of the set of density matrices.

We study the locations of complex zeroes of independence polynomials of bounded degree hypergraphs. For graphs, this is a long-studied subject with applications to statistical physics, algorithms, and combinatorics. Results on zero-free regions for bounded-degree graphs include Shearer's result on the optimal zero-free disk, along with several recent results on other zero-free regions. Much less is known for hypergraphs. We make some steps towards an understanding of zero-free regions for bounded-degree hypergaphs by proving that all hypergraphs of maximum degree $Δ$ have a zero-free disk almost as large as the optimal disk for graphs of maximum degree $Δ$ established by Shearer (of radius $\sim 1/(e Δ)$). Up to logarithmic factors in $Δ$ this is optimal, even for hypergraphs with all edge-sizes strictly greater than $2$. We conjecture that for $k\ge 3$, $k$-uniform linear hypergraphs have a much larger zero-free disk of radius $Ω(Δ^{- \frac{1}{k-1}} )$. We establish this in the case of linear hypertrees.

In this paper, we give a new bijective proof of a multiset analogue of even-odd permutations identity. This multiset version is equivalent to the original coin arrangements lemma which is a key combinatorial lemma in the Sherman's Proof of a conjecture of Feynman about an identity on paths in planar graphs related to combinatorial solution of two dimensional Ising model in statistical physics.

The independence complex of a graph G is a simplicial complex whose simplices are the independent sets in G. In the last couple of decades, the independence complexes of square grids (with various boundary conditions) have gained much attention because of their connections with the hard square model from statistical physics. In this article, we prove that if G is an $m\times n$ grid with open or cylindrical boundary condition then its independence complex is homotopy equivalent to a wedge of spheres. A part of this result settles a conjecture of Iriye.

Studying independent sets of maximum size is equivalent to considering the hard-core model with the fugacity parameter $λ$ tending to infinity. Finding the independence ratio of random $d$-regular graphs for some fixed degree $d$ has received much attention both in random graph theory and in statistical physics. For $d \geq 20$ the problem is conjectured to exhibit 1-step replica symmetry breaking (1-RSB). The corresponding 1-RSB formula for the independence ratio was confirmed for (very) large $d$ in a breakthrough paper by Ding, Sly, and Sun. Furthermore, the so-called interpolation method shows that this 1-RSB formula is an upper bound for each $d \geq 3$. For $d \leq 19$ this bound is not tight and full-RSB is expected. In this work we use numerical optimization to find good substituting parameters for discrete $r$-RSB formulas ($r=2,3,4,5$) to obtain improved rigorous upper bounds for the independence ratio for each degree $3 \leq d \leq 19$. As $r$ grows, these formulas get increasingly complicated and it becomes challenging to compute their numerical values efficiently. Also, the functions to minimize have a large number of local minima, making global optimization a difficult task.

Given $2n$ unit equilateral triangles, there are finitely many ways to glue each edge to a partner. We obtain a random sphere-homeomorphic surface by sampling uniformly from the gluings that produce a topological sphere. As $n$ tends to infinity, these random surfaces (appropriately scaled) converge in law. The limit is a "canonical" sphere-homeomorphic random surface, much the way Brownian motion is a canonical random path. Depending on how the surface space and convergence topology are specified, the limit is the Brownian sphere, the peanosphere, the pure Liouville quantum gravity sphere, or a certain conformal field theory. All of these objects have concise definitions, and are all in some sense equivalent, but the equivalence is highly non-trivial, building on hundreds of math and physics papers over the past half century. More generally, the "continuum random surface embedded in $d$-dimensional Euclidean space" makes a kind of sense for $d \in (-\infty, 25)$ even when $d$ is not a positive integer; and this can be extended to higher genus surfaces, surfaces with boundary, and surfaces with marked points or other decoration. These constructions have deep roots in both mathematics and physics, drawing from classical graph theory, complex analysis, probability and representation theory, as well as string theory, planar statistical physics, random matrix theory and a simple model for two-dimensional quantum gravity. We present here an informal, colloquium-level overview of the subject, which we hope will be accessible to both newcomers and experts. We aim to answer, as cleanly as possible, the fundamental question. What is a random surface?

Ramsey's theorem, concerning the guarantee of certain monochromatic patterns in large enough edge-coloured complete graphs, is a fundamental result in combinatorial mathematics. In this work, we highlight the connection between this abstract setting and a statistical physics problem. Specifically, we design a classical Hamiltonian that favours configurations in a way to establish lower bounds on Ramsey numbers. As a proof of principle we then use Monte Carlo methods to obtain such lower bounds, finding rough agreement with known literature values in a few cases we investigated. We discuss numerical limitations of our approach and indicate a path towards the treatment of larger graph sizes.

In the random geometric graph model $\mathsf{Geo}_d(n,p)$, we identify each of our $n$ vertices with an independently and uniformly sampled vector from the $d$-dimensional unit sphere, and we connect pairs of vertices whose vectors are ``sufficiently close'', such that the marginal probability of an edge is $p$. We investigate the problem of testing for this latent geometry, or in other words, distinguishing an Erdős-Rényi graph $\mathsf{G}(n, p)$ from a random geometric graph $\mathsf{Geo}_d(n, p)$. It is not too difficult to show that if $d\to \infty$ while $n$ is held fixed, the two distributions become indistinguishable; we wish to understand how fast $d$ must grow as a function of $n$ for indistinguishability to occur. When $p = \fracα{n}$ for constant $α$, we prove that if $d \ge \mathrm{polylog} n$, the total variation distance between the two distributions is close to $0$; this improves upon the best previous bound of Brennan, Bresler, and Nagaraj (2020), which required $d \gg n^{3/2}$, and further our result is nearly tight, resolving a conjecture of Bubeck, Ding, Eldan, \& Rácz (2016) up to logarithmic factors. We also obtain improved upper bounds on the statistical indistinguishability thresholds in $d$ for the full range of $p$ satisfying $\frac{1}{n}\le p\le \frac{1}{2}$, improving upon the previous bounds by polynomial factors. Our analysis uses the Belief Propagation algorithm to characterize the distributions of (subsets of) the random vectors {\em conditioned on producing a particular graph}. In this sense, our analysis is connected to the ``cavity method'' from statistical physics. To analyze this process, we rely on novel sharp estimates for the area of the intersection of a random sphere cap with an arbitrary subset of the sphere, which we prove using optimal transport maps and entropy-transport inequalities on the unit sphere.

Given a collection of independent events each of which has strictly positive probability, the probability that all of them occur is also strictly positive. The Lovász local lemma (LLL) asserts that this remains true if the events are not too strongly negatively correlated. The formulation of the lemma involves a graph with one vertex per event, with edges indicating potential negative dependence. The word "Local" in LLL reflects that the condition for the negative correlation can be expressed solely in terms of the neighborhood of each vertex. In contrast to this local view, Shearer developed an exact criterion for the avoidance probability to be strictly positive, but it involves summing over all independent sets of the graph. In this work we make two contributions. The first is to develop a hierarchy of increasingly powerful, increasingly non-local lemmata for bounding the avoidance probability from below, each lemma associated with a different set of walks in the graph. Already, at its second level, our hierarchy is stronger than all known local lemmata. To demonstrate its power we prove new bounds for the negative-fugacity singularity of the hard-core model on several lattices, a central problem in statistical physics. Our second contribution is to prove that Shearer's connection between the probabilistic setting and the independent set polynomial holds for \emph{arbitrary supermodular} functions, not just probability measures. This means that all LLL machinery can be employed to bound from below an arbitrary supermodular function, based only on information regarding its value at singleton sets and partial information regarding their interactions. We show that this readily implies both the quantum LLL of Ambainis, Kempe, and Sattath~[JACM 2012], and the quantum Shearer criterion of Sattath, Morampudi, Laumann, and Moessner~[PNAS 2016].

The ferromagnetic Ising model is a model of a magnetic material and a central topic in statistical physics. It also plays a starring role in the algorithmic study of approximate counting: approximating the partition function of the ferromagnetic Ising model with uniform external field is tractable at all temperatures and on all graphs, due to the randomized algorithm of Jerrum and Sinclair. Here we show that hidden inside the model are hard computational problems. For the class of bounded-degree graphs we find computational thresholds for the approximate counting and sampling problems for the ferromagnetic Ising model at fixed magnetization (that is, fixing the number of $+1$ and $-1$ spins). In particular, letting $β_c(Δ)$ denote the critical inverse temperature of the zero-field Ising model on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree, and $η_{Δ,β,1}^+$ denote the mean magnetization of the zero-field $+$ measure on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree at inverse temperature $β$, we prove, for the class of graphs of maximum degree $Δ$: 1. For $β< β_c(Δ)$ there is an FPRAS and efficient sampling scheme for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for all magnetizations $η$. 2. For $β> β_c(Δ)$, there is an FPRAS and efficient sampling scheme for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for magnetizations $η$ such that $|η| >η_{Δ,β,1}^+ $. 3. For $β> β_c(Δ)$, there is no FPRAS for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for magnetizations $η$ such that $|η| <η_{Δ,β,1}^+ $ unless NP=RP\@.

The positive Grassmannian $Gr_{k,n}^{\geq 0}$ is the subset of the real Grassmannian where all Plücker coordinates are nonnegative. It has a beautiful combinatorial structure as well as connections to statistical physics, integrable systems, and scattering amplitudes. The amplituhedron $\mathcal{A}_{n,k,m}(Z)$ is the image of the positive Grassmannian $Gr_{k,n}^{\geq 0}$ under a positive linear map $\mathbb{R}^n \to \mathbb{R}^{k+m}$. We will explain how ideas from oriented matroids, tropical geometry, and cluster algebras shed light on the structure of the positive Grassmannian and the amplituhedron.

We determine the asymptotics of the number of independent sets of size $\lfloor β2^{d-1} \rfloor$ in the discrete hypercube $Q_d = \{0,1\}^d$ for any fixed $β\in [0,1]$ as $d \to \infty$, extending a result of Galvin for $β\in [1-1/\sqrt{2},1]$. Moreover, we prove a multivariate local central limit theorem for structural features of independent sets in $Q_d$ drawn according to the hard core model at any fixed fugacity $λ>0$. In proving these results we develop several general tools for performing combinatorial enumeration using polymer models and the cluster expansion from statistical physics along with local central limit theorems.