arXiv++ Combinatorics

This article introduces a quantized chip-firing model with close connections to the theory of rational lattice paths and rational parking functions. Given a graph with a sink and positive integers a,b,c with gcd(a,b)=1, a set S of vertices fires by the following rule. Each vertex in S provisionally sends c chips to the sink and a/b chips to each non-sink neighbor outside of S. The novel feature is that the total number of chips leaving from or arriving at any vertex gets rounded down to the nearest integer before being finalized. We define the notions of chip configurations being superstable, k-stable, or k-skeletal in this model. When c=1 and the graph is complete, superstable configurations correspond to rational parking functions. There is a bijection between superstable configurations and k-skeletal configurations for each k. We establish these results by building a combinatorial theory of k-skeletal rational lattice paths (both unlabeled and labeled) and translating that theory to chip configurations. There is a group structure on the set of chip configurations modulo firing and borrowing moves. We show that this group is isomorphic to the product of b-1 copies of the integers modulo a; and, for each k, each coset of chip configurations in this group contains a unique k-skeletal representative.

For $0\leq k\leq n-1$, we introduce a family of $k$-skeletal paths which are counted by the $n$-th Catalan number for each $k$, and specialize to Dyck paths when $k=n-1$. We similarly introduce $k$-skeletal parking functions which are equinumerous with the spanning trees on $n+1$ vertices for each $k$, and specialize to classical parking functions for $k=n-1$. The preceding constructions are generalized to paths lying in a trapezoid with base $c > 0$ and southeastern diagonal of slope $1/m$; $c$ and $m$ need not be integers. We give bijections among these families when $k$ varies with $m$ and $c$ fixed. Our constructions are motivated by chip firing and have connections to combinatorial representation theory and tropical geometry.

Richard Stanley defined the chromatic symmetric function $X_G$ of a graph $G$ and asked whether there are non-isomorphic trees $T$ and $U$ with $X_T=X_U$. We study variants of the chromatic symmetric function for rooted graphs, where we require the root vertex to either use or avoid a specified color. We present combinatorial identities and recursions satisfied by these rooted chromatic polynomials, explain their relation to pointed chromatic functions and rooted $U$-polynomials, and prove three main theorems. First, for all non-empty connected graphs $G$, Stanley's polynomial $X_G(x_1,\ldots,x_N)$ is irreducible in $\mathbb{Q}[x_1,\ldots,x_N]$ for all large enough $N$. The same result holds for our rooted variant where the root node must avoid a specified color. We prove irreducibility by a novel combinatorial application of Eisenstein's Criterion. Second, we prove the rooted version of Stanley's Conjecture: two rooted trees are isomorphic as rooted graphs if and only if their rooted chromatic polynomials are equal. In fact, we prove that a one-variable specialization of the rooted chromatic polynomial (obtained by setting $x_0=x_1=q$, $x_2=x_3=1$, and $x_n=0$ for $n>3$) already distinguishes rooted trees. Third, we answer a question of Pawlowski by providing a combinatorial interpretation of the monomial expansion of pointed chromatic functions.

Creation operators act on symmetric functions to build Schur functions, Hall--Littlewood polynomials, and related symmetric functions one row at a time. Haglund, Morse, Zabrocki, and others have studied more general symmetric functions $H_α$, $C_α$, and $B_α$ obtained by applying any sequence of creation operators to $1$. We develop new combinatorial models for the Schur expansions of these and related symmetric functions using objects called abacus-histories. These formulas arise by chaining together smaller abacus-histories that encode the effect of an individual creation operator on a given Schur function. We give a similar treatment for operators such as multiplication by $h_m$, $h_m^{\perp}$, $ω$, etc., which serve as building blocks to construct the creation operators. We use involutions on abacus-histories to give bijective proofs of properties of the Bernstein creation operator and Hall-Littlewood polynomials indexed by three-row partitions.

We give a simple construction of an orthogonal basis for the space of m by n matrices with row and column sums equal to zero. This vector space corresponds to the affine space naturally associated with the Birkhoff polytope, contingency tables and Latin squares. We also provide orthogonal bases for the spaces underlying magic squares and Sudoku boards. Our construction combines the outer (i.e., tensor or dyadic) product on vectors with certain rooted, vector-labeled, binary trees. Our bases naturally respect the decomposition of a vector space into centrosymmetric and skew-centrosymmetric pieces; the bases can be easily modified to respect the usual matrix symmetry and skew-symmetry as well.

We define a family of maps on lattice paths, called sweep maps, that assign levels to each step in the path and sort steps according to their level. Surprisingly, although sweep maps act by sorting, they appear to be bijective in general. The sweep maps give concise combinatorial formulas for the q,t-Catalan numbers, the higher q,t-Catalan numbers, the q,t-square numbers, and many more general polynomials connected to the nabla operator and rational Catalan combinatorics. We prove that many algorithms that have appeared in the literature (including maps studied by Andrews, Egge, Gorsky, Haglund, Hanusa, Jones, Killpatrick, Krattenthaler, Kremer, Orsina, Mazin, Papi, Vaille, and the present authors) are all special cases of the sweep maps or their inverses. The sweep maps provide a very simple unifying framework for understanding all of these algorithms. We explain how inversion of the sweep map (which is an open problem in general) can be solved in known special cases by finding a "bounce path" for the lattice paths under consideration. We also define a generalized sweep map acting on words over arbitrary alphabets with arbitrary weights, which is also conjectured to be bijective.

The classical parking functions, counted by the Cayley number (n+1)^(n-1), carry a natural permutation representation of the symmetric group S_n in which the number of orbits is the n'th Catalan number. In this paper, we will generalize this setup to rational parking functions indexed by a pair (a,b) of coprime positive integers. We show that these parking functions, which are counted by b^(a-1), carry a permutation representation of S_a in which the number of orbits is a rational Catalan number. We compute the Frobenius characteristic of the S_a-module of (a,b)-parking functions. Next we propose a combinatorial formula for a q-analogue of the rational Catalan numbers and relate this formula to a new combinatorial model for q-binomial coefficients. Finally, we discuss q,t-analogues of rational Catalan numbers and parking functions (generalizing the shuffle conjecture for the classical case) and present several conjectures.

The random chemistry algorithm of Kauffman can be used to determine an unknown subset S of a fixed set V. The algorithm proceeds by zeroing in on S through a succession of nested subsets V=V_0,V_1,...,V_m=S. In Kauffman's original algorithm, the size of each V_i is chosen to be half the size of V_{i-1}. In this paper we determine the optimal sequence of sizes so as to minimize the expected run time of the algorithm.

The game of memory is played with a deck of n pairs of cards. The cards in each pair are identical. The deck is shuffled and the cards laid face down. A move consists of flipping over first one card then another. The cards are removed from play if they match. Otherwise, they are flipped back over and the next move commences. A game ends when all pairs have been matched. We determine that, when the game is played optimally, as n tends to infinity: 1) The expected number of moves is (3 - 2 ln 2)n + 7/8 - 2 ln 2 (approximately 1.61 n), 2) The expected number of times two matching cards are unwittingly flipped over is ln 2, and 3) The expected number of flips until two matching cards have been seen is asymptotically sqrt{pi n}.

In Martin Gardner's October, 1976 Mathematical Games column in Scientific American, he posed the following problem: "What is the smallest number of [queens] you can put on a board of side n such that no [queen] can be added without creating three in a row, a column, or a diagonal?" We use the Combinatorial Nullstellensatz to prove that this number is at least n, except in the case when n is congruent to 3 modulo 4, in which case one less may suffice. A second, more elementary proof is also offered in the case that n is even.

We introduce explicit combinatorial interpretations for the coefficients in some of the transition matrices relating to skew Hall-Littlewood polynomials P_lambda/mu(x;t) and Hivert's quasisymmetric Hall-Littlewood polynomials G_gamma(x;t). More specifically, we provide: 1) the G-expansions of the Hall-Littlewood polynomials P_lambda, the monomial quasisymmetric polynomials M_alpha, the quasisymmetric Schur polynomials S_alpha, and the peak quasisymmetric functions K_alpha; 2) an expansion of P_lambda/mu in terms of the F_alpha's. The F-expansion of P_lambda/mu is facilitated by introducing starred tableaux.

Every word has a shape determined by its image under the Robinson-Schensted-Knuth correspondence. We show that when a word w contains a separable (i.e., 3142- and 2413-avoiding) permutation σ as a pattern, the shape of w contains the shape of σ. As an application, we exhibit lower bounds for the lengths of supersequences of sets containing separable permutations.

We study equivalence classes relating to the Kazhdan-Lusztig mu(x,w) coefficients in order to help explain the scarcity of distinct values. Each class is conjectured to contain a "crosshatch" pair. We also compute the values attained by mu(x,w) for the permutation groups S_10 and S_11.

J. J. Sylvester's four-point problem asks for the probability that four points chosen uniformly at random in the plane have a triangle as their convex hull. Using a combinatorial classification of points in the plane due to Goodman and Pollack, we generalize Sylvester's problem to one involving reduced expressions for the long word in the symmetric group. We conjecture an answer of 1/4 for this new version of the problem.

We conjecture a combinatorial formula for the monomial expansion of the image of any Schur function under the Bergeron-Garsia nabla operator. The formula involves nested labeled Dyck paths weighted by area and a suitable "diagonal inversion" statistic. Our model includes as special cases many previous conjectures connecting the nabla operator to quantum lattice paths. The combinatorics of the inverse Kostka matrix leads to an elementary proof of our proposed formula when q=1. We also outline a possible approach for proving all the extant nabla conjectures that reduces everything to the construction of sign-reversing involutions on explicit collections of signed, weighted objects.

Garsia-Haiman modules are quotient rings in variables X_n={x_1, x_2, ..., x_n} and Y_n=y_1, y_2, ..., y_n} that generalize the quotient ring C[X_n]/I, where I is the ideal generated by the elementary symmetric polynomials e_j(X_n) for 1 <= j <= n. A bitableaux basis for the Garsia-Haiman modules of hollow type is constructed. Applications of this basis to representation theory and other related polynomial spaces are considered.

Consider lattice paths in Z^2 taking unit steps north (N) and east (E). Fix positive integers r,s and put an equivalence relation on points of Z^2 by letting v,w be equivalent if v - w = m (r,s) for some m in Z. Call a lattice path valid if whenever it enters a point v with an E-step, then any further points of the path in the class of v are also entered with an E-step. Loehr and Warrington conjectured that the number of valid paths from (0,0) to (nr,ns) is (r+s choose r)^n. We prove this conjecture when s = 2.

We study the determinant of the pxp circulant matrix whose first row is (1,-x,0,...,0,-y,0,...,0), the -y being in position q+1. The coefficients of this polynomial are integers that count certain classes of permutations. We show that all of the permutations that contribute to a fixed monomial x^ry^s have the same sign, and we determine that sign. We prove that a monomial x^ry^s appears if and only if p divides r+sq. Finally, we show that the size of the largest coefficient of the monomials that appear grows exponentially with p. We do this by proving that the permanent of the circulant whose first row is (1,1,0,...,0,1,0,...,0) is the sum of the absolute values of the coefficients of the monomials in the original determinant.

The act of a person juggling can be viewed as a Markov process if we assume that the juggler throws to random heights. I make this association for the simplest reasonable model of random juggling and compute the steady state probabilities in terms of the Stirling numbers of the second kind. I also explore several alternate models of juggling.

For permutations x and w, let mu(x,w) be the coefficient of highest possible degree in the Kazhdan-Lusztig polynomial P_{x,w}. It is well-known that the coefficients mu(x,w) arise as the edge labels of certain graphs encoding the representations of S_n. The 0-1 Conjecture states that the mu(x,w) are either 0 or 1. We present two counterexamples to this conjecture, the first in S_16, for which x and w are in the same left cell, and the second in S_10. The proof of the counterexample in S_16 relies on computer calculations.