arXiv++ Combinatorics

This article introduces a quantized chip-firing model with close connections to the theory of rational lattice paths and rational parking functions. Given a graph with a sink and positive integers a,b,c with gcd(a,b)=1, a set S of vertices fires by the following rule. Each vertex in S provisionally sends c chips to the sink and a/b chips to each non-sink neighbor outside of S. The novel feature is that the total number of chips leaving from or arriving at any vertex gets rounded down to the nearest integer before being finalized. We define the notions of chip configurations being superstable, k-stable, or k-skeletal in this model. When c=1 and the graph is complete, superstable configurations correspond to rational parking functions. There is a bijection between superstable configurations and k-skeletal configurations for each k. We establish these results by building a combinatorial theory of k-skeletal rational lattice paths (both unlabeled and labeled) and translating that theory to chip configurations. There is a group structure on the set of chip configurations modulo firing and borrowing moves. We show that this group is isomorphic to the product of b-1 copies of the integers modulo a; and, for each k, each coset of chip configurations in this group contains a unique k-skeletal representative.

Combinatorial transition matrices arise frequently in the theory of symmetric functions and their generalizations. The entries of such matrices often count signed, weighted combinatorial structures such as semistandard tableaux, rim-hook tableaux, or brick tabloids. Bijective proofs that two such matrices are inverses of each other may be difficult to find. This paper presents a general framework for proving such inversion results in the case where the combinatorial objects are built up recursively by successively adding some incremental structure such as a single horizontal strip or rim-hook. In this setting, we show that a sequence of matrix inversion results $A_nB_n=I$ can be reduced to a certain ``local'' identity involving the incremental structures. Here, $A_n$ and $B_n$ are matrices that might be non-square, and the columns of $A_n$ and the rows of $B_n$ indexed by compositions of $n$. We illustrate the general theory with four classical applications involving the Kostka matrices, the character tables of the symmetric group, incidence matrices for composition posets, and matrices counting brick tabloids. We obtain a new, canonical bijective proof of an inversion result for rectangular Kostka matrices, which complements the proof for the square case due to Eğecioğlu and Remmel. We also give a new bijective proof of the orthogonality result for the irreducible $S_n$-characters that is shorter than the original version due to White.

Asvin G and Andrew O'Desky recently introduced the graded algebra P$Λ$ of polysymmetric functions as a generalization of the algebra $Λ$ of symmetric functions. This article develops combinatorial formulas for some multiplication rules and transition matrix entries for P$Λ$ that are analogous to well-known classical formulas for $Λ$. In more detail, we consider pure tensor bases $\{s^{\otimes}_τ\}$, $\{p^{\otimes}_τ\}$, and $\{m^{\otimes}_τ\}$ for P$Λ$ that arise as tensor products of the classical Schur basis, power-sum basis, and monomial basis for $Λ$. We find expansions in these bases of the non-pure bases $\{P_δ\}$, $\{H_δ\}$, $\{E^+_δ\}$, and $\{E_δ\}$ studied by Asvin G and O'Desky. The answers involve tableau-like structures generalizing semistandard tableaux, rim-hook tableaux, and the brick tabloids of Eğecioğlu and Remmel. These objects arise by iteration of new Pieri-type rules that give expansions of products such as $s^{\otimes}_σH_δ$, $p^{\otimes}_σE_δ$, etc.

For $0\leq k\leq n-1$, we introduce a family of $k$-skeletal paths which are counted by the $n$-th Catalan number for each $k$, and specialize to Dyck paths when $k=n-1$. We similarly introduce $k$-skeletal parking functions which are equinumerous with the spanning trees on $n+1$ vertices for each $k$, and specialize to classical parking functions for $k=n-1$. The preceding constructions are generalized to paths lying in a trapezoid with base $c > 0$ and southeastern diagonal of slope $1/m$; $c$ and $m$ need not be integers. We give bijections among these families when $k$ varies with $m$ and $c$ fixed. Our constructions are motivated by chip firing and have connections to combinatorial representation theory and tropical geometry.

This paper gives bijective proofs of some novel coinversion identities first discovered by Ayyer, Mandelshtam, and Martin (arxiv:2011.06117) as part of their proof of a new combinatorial formula for the modified Macdonald polynomials $\tilde{H}_μ$. Those authors used intricate algebraic manipulations of $q$-binomial coefficients to prove these identities, which imply the existence of certain bijections needed in their proof that their formula satisfies the axioms characterizing $\tilde{H}_μ$. They posed the open problem of constructing such bijections explicitly. We resolve that problem here.

Richard Stanley defined the chromatic symmetric function $X_G$ of a graph $G$ and asked whether there are non-isomorphic trees $T$ and $U$ with $X_T=X_U$. We study variants of the chromatic symmetric function for rooted graphs, where we require the root vertex to either use or avoid a specified color. We present combinatorial identities and recursions satisfied by these rooted chromatic polynomials, explain their relation to pointed chromatic functions and rooted $U$-polynomials, and prove three main theorems. First, for all non-empty connected graphs $G$, Stanley's polynomial $X_G(x_1,\ldots,x_N)$ is irreducible in $\mathbb{Q}[x_1,\ldots,x_N]$ for all large enough $N$. The same result holds for our rooted variant where the root node must avoid a specified color. We prove irreducibility by a novel combinatorial application of Eisenstein's Criterion. Second, we prove the rooted version of Stanley's Conjecture: two rooted trees are isomorphic as rooted graphs if and only if their rooted chromatic polynomials are equal. In fact, we prove that a one-variable specialization of the rooted chromatic polynomial (obtained by setting $x_0=x_1=q$, $x_2=x_3=1$, and $x_n=0$ for $n>3$) already distinguishes rooted trees. Third, we answer a question of Pawlowski by providing a combinatorial interpretation of the monomial expansion of pointed chromatic functions.

This article is part of an ongoing investigation of the combinatorics of $q,t$-Catalan numbers $\textrm{Cat}_n(q,t)$. We develop a structure theory for integer partitions based on the partition statistics dinv, deficit, and minimum triangle height. Our goal is to decompose the infinite set of partitions of deficit $k$ into a disjoint union of chains $\mathcal{C}_μ$ indexed by partitions of size $k$. Among other structural properties, these chains can be paired to give refinements of the famous symmetry property $\textrm{Cat}_n(q,t)=\textrm{Cat}_n(t,q)$. Previously, we introduced a map that builds the tail part of each chain $\mathcal{C}_μ$. Our first main contribution here is to extend this map to construct larger second-order tails for each chain. Second, we introduce new classes of partitions called flagpole partitions and generalized flagpole partitions. Third, we describe a recursive construction for building the chain $\mathcal{C}_μ$ for a (generalized) flagpole partition $μ$, assuming that the chains indexed by certain specific smaller partitions (depending on $μ$) are already known. We also give some enumerative and asymptotic results for flagpole partitions and their generalized versions.

Creation operators act on symmetric functions to build Schur functions, Hall--Littlewood polynomials, and related symmetric functions one row at a time. Haglund, Morse, Zabrocki, and others have studied more general symmetric functions $H_α$, $C_α$, and $B_α$ obtained by applying any sequence of creation operators to $1$. We develop new combinatorial models for the Schur expansions of these and related symmetric functions using objects called abacus-histories. These formulas arise by chaining together smaller abacus-histories that encode the effect of an individual creation operator on a given Schur function. We give a similar treatment for operators such as multiplication by $h_m$, $h_m^{\perp}$, $ω$, etc., which serve as building blocks to construct the creation operators. We use involutions on abacus-histories to give bijective proofs of properties of the Bernstein creation operator and Hall-Littlewood polynomials indexed by three-row partitions.

The $q,t$-Catalan number $\mathrm{Cat}_n(q,t)$ enumerates integer partitions contained in an $n\times n$ triangle by their dinv and external area statistics. The paper [LLL18 (Lee, Li, Loehr, SIAM J. Discrete Math. 32(2018))] proposed a new approach to understanding the symmetry property $\mathrm{Cat}_n(q,t)=\mathrm{Cat}_n(t,q)$ based on decomposing the set of all integer partitions into infinite chains. Each such global chain $\mathcal{C}_μ$ has an opposite chain $\mathcal{C}_{μ^*}$; these combine to give a new small slice of $\mathrm{Cat}_n(q,t)$ that is symmetric in $q$ and $t$. Here we advance the agenda of [LLL18] by developing a new general method for building the global chains $\mathcal{C}_μ$ from smaller elements called local chains. We define a local opposite property for local chains that implies the needed opposite property of the global chains. This local property is much easier to verify in specific cases compared to the corresponding global property. We apply this machinery to construct all global chains for partitions with deficit at most $11$. This proves that for all $n$, the terms in $\mathrm{Cat}_n(q,t)$ of degree at least $\binom{n}{2}-11$ are symmetric in $q$ and $t$.

The \emph{$q,t$-Catalan numbers} $C_n(q,t)$ are polynomials in $q$ and $t$ that reduce to the ordinary Catalan numbers when $q=t=1$. These polynomials have important connections to representation theory, algebraic geometry, and symmetric functions. Haglund and Haiman discovered combinatorial formulas for $C_n(q,t)$ as weighted sums of Dyck paths (or equivalently, integer partitions contained in a staircase shape). This paper undertakes a combinatorial investigation of the joint symmetry property $C_n(q,t)=C_n(t,q)$. We conjecture some structural decompositions of Dyck objects into "mutually opposite" subcollections that lead to a bijective explanation of joint symmetry in certain cases. A key new idea is the construction of infinite chains of partitions that are independent of $n$ but induce the joint symmetry for all $n$ simultaneously. Using these methods, we prove combinatorially that for $0\leq k\leq 9$ and all $n$, the terms in $C_n(q,t)$ of total degree $\binom{n}{2}-k$ have the required symmetry property.

We define a family of maps on lattice paths, called sweep maps, that assign levels to each step in the path and sort steps according to their level. Surprisingly, although sweep maps act by sorting, they appear to be bijective in general. The sweep maps give concise combinatorial formulas for the q,t-Catalan numbers, the higher q,t-Catalan numbers, the q,t-square numbers, and many more general polynomials connected to the nabla operator and rational Catalan combinatorics. We prove that many algorithms that have appeared in the literature (including maps studied by Andrews, Egge, Gorsky, Haglund, Hanusa, Jones, Killpatrick, Krattenthaler, Kremer, Orsina, Mazin, Papi, Vaille, and the present authors) are all special cases of the sweep maps or their inverses. The sweep maps provide a very simple unifying framework for understanding all of these algorithms. We explain how inversion of the sweep map (which is an open problem in general) can be solved in known special cases by finding a "bounce path" for the lattice paths under consideration. We also define a generalized sweep map acting on words over arbitrary alphabets with arbitrary weights, which is also conjectured to be bijective.

The classical parking functions, counted by the Cayley number (n+1)^(n-1), carry a natural permutation representation of the symmetric group S_n in which the number of orbits is the n'th Catalan number. In this paper, we will generalize this setup to rational parking functions indexed by a pair (a,b) of coprime positive integers. We show that these parking functions, which are counted by b^(a-1), carry a permutation representation of S_a in which the number of orbits is a rational Catalan number. We compute the Frobenius characteristic of the S_a-module of (a,b)-parking functions. Next we propose a combinatorial formula for a q-analogue of the rational Catalan numbers and relate this formula to a new combinatorial model for q-binomial coefficients. Finally, we discuss q,t-analogues of rational Catalan numbers and parking functions (generalizing the shuffle conjecture for the classical case) and present several conjectures.

The higher $q,t$-Catalan polynomial $C^{(m)}_n(q,t)$ can be defined combinatorially as a weighted sum of lattice paths contained in certain triangles, or algebraically as a complicated sum of rational functions indexed by partitions of $n$. This paper proves the equivalence of the two definitions for all $m\geq 1$ and all $n\leq 4$. We also give a bijective proof of the joint symmetry property $C^{(m)}_n(q,t)=C^{(m)}_n(t,q)$ for all $m\geq 1$ and all $n\leq 4$. The proof is based on a general approach for proving joint symmetry that dissects a collection of objects into chains, and then passes from a joint symmetry property of initial points and terminal points to joint symmetry of the full set of objects. Further consequences include unimodality results and specific formulas for the coefficients in $C^{(m)}_n(q,t)$ for all $m\geq 1$ and all $n\leq 4$. We give analogous results for certain rational-slope $q,t$-Catalan polynomials.

We introduce explicit combinatorial interpretations for the coefficients in some of the transition matrices relating to skew Hall-Littlewood polynomials P_lambda/mu(x;t) and Hivert's quasisymmetric Hall-Littlewood polynomials G_gamma(x;t). More specifically, we provide: 1) the G-expansions of the Hall-Littlewood polynomials P_lambda, the monomial quasisymmetric polynomials M_alpha, the quasisymmetric Schur polynomials S_alpha, and the peak quasisymmetric functions K_alpha; 2) an expansion of P_lambda/mu in terms of the F_alpha's. The F-expansion of P_lambda/mu is facilitated by introducing starred tableaux.

The $q,t$-Catalan numbers can be defined using rational functions, geometry related to Hilbert schemes, symmetric functions, representation theory, Dyck paths, partition statistics, or Dyck words. After decades of intensive study, it was eventually proved that all these definitions are equivalent. In this paper, we study the similar situation for higher $q,t$-Catalan numbers, where the equivalence of the algebraic and combinatorial definitions is still conjectural. We compute the limits of several versions of the modified higher $q,t$-Catalan numbers and show that these limits equal the generating function for integer partitions. We also identify certain coefficients of the higher $q,t$-Catalan numbers as enumerating suitable integer partitions, and we make some conjectures on the homological significance of the Bergeron-Garsia nabla operator.

We conjecture a combinatorial formula for the monomial expansion of the image of any Schur function under the Bergeron-Garsia nabla operator. The formula involves nested labeled Dyck paths weighted by area and a suitable "diagonal inversion" statistic. Our model includes as special cases many previous conjectures connecting the nabla operator to quantum lattice paths. The combinatorics of the inverse Kostka matrix leads to an elementary proof of our proposed formula when q=1. We also outline a possible approach for proving all the extant nabla conjectures that reduces everything to the construction of sign-reversing involutions on explicit collections of signed, weighted objects.

Consider lattice paths in Z^2 taking unit steps north (N) and east (E). Fix positive integers r,s and put an equivalence relation on points of Z^2 by letting v,w be equivalent if v - w = m (r,s) for some m in Z. Call a lattice path valid if whenever it enters a point v with an E-step, then any further points of the path in the class of v are also entered with an E-step. Loehr and Warrington conjectured that the number of valid paths from (0,0) to (nr,ns) is (r+s choose r)^n. We prove this conjecture when s = 2.

We study the determinant of the pxp circulant matrix whose first row is (1,-x,0,...,0,-y,0,...,0), the -y being in position q+1. The coefficients of this polynomial are integers that count certain classes of permutations. We show that all of the permutations that contribute to a fixed monomial x^ry^s have the same sign, and we determine that sign. We prove that a monomial x^ry^s appears if and only if p divides r+sq. Finally, we show that the size of the largest coefficient of the monomials that appear grows exponentially with p. We do this by proving that the permanent of the circulant whose first row is (1,1,0,...,0,1,0,...,0) is the sum of the absolute values of the coefficients of the monomials in the original determinant.