arXiv++ Combinatorics

We give an introduction to the grammatical calculus, which originated from the umbral calculus of Rota. Context-free grammars arise in computer science. Differential operators can be viewed as the production rules of context-free grammars. By the properties of differential operators, we may perform the grammatical calculus on a rigorous basis, for the purposes of deriving combinatorial identities and computing generating functions. A grammatical labeling serves as a bridge between a combinatorial structure and the grammar. A grammar may be instrumental in constructing a bijection between two combinatorial structures sharing the same grammar. Such a bijection is called a grammar assisted bijection. Many combinatorial structures admit recursive constructions that are context-free in some sense, such as those corresponding to the Eulerian polynomials, Bell polynomials, the Ramanujan polynomials and the Narayana polynomials.

As remarked by Berndt, no combinatorial perspective seems to be alluded in the original definition of the Ramanujan polynomials. On a different scene, a recursive algorithm to generate rooted trees has been devised independently by Shor and Dumont-Ramamonjisoa. Zeng discovered the connection between the Ramanujan polynomials and the enumeration of rooted trees by number of improper edges. We present a proper labeling scheme for rooted trees by employing an extra label. Harnessed by this grammar, we develop a calculus heavily depending on the constant properties for the Ramanujan polynomials. From the grammatical formulation, we recover the defining equation of Ramanujan on an implicit function. So the two themes of Ramanujan converge to one combinatorial structure. Moreover, we provide a grammatical treatment of a bijection behind the recursion independently due to Shor and Berndt-Evans-Wilson.

This paper is concerned with a duality between $r$-regular permutations and $r$-cycle permutations, and a monotone property due to Bóna-McLennan-White on the probability $p_r(n)$ for a random permutation of $\{1,2,\ldots, n\}$ to have an $r$-th root, where $r$ is a prime. For $r=2$, the duality relates permutations with odd cycles to permutations with even cycles. To handle the general case where $r\geq 2$, we define an $r$-enriched permutation as a permutation with $r$-singular cycles colored by one of the colors $1, 2, \ldots, r-1$. In this setup, we discover a bijection between $r$-regular permutations and enriched $r$-cycle permutations, which in turn yields a stronger version of an inequality of Bóna-McLennan-White. This leads to a fully combinatorial understanding of the monotone property, thereby answering their question. When $r$ is a prime power $q^l$, we further show that $p_r(n)$ is monotone. In the case that $n+1 \not\equiv 0 \pmod q$, the equality $p_r(n)=p_r(n+1)$ has been established by Chernoff.

The Cayley continuants are referred to the determinants of tridiagonal matrices in connection with the Sylvester continuants. Munarini-Torri found a striking combinatorial interpretation of the Cayley continuants in terms of the joint distribution of the number of odd cycles and the number of even cycles of permutations of $[n]=\{1,2,\ldots, n\}$. In view of a general setting, $r$-regular cycles (with length not divisible by $r$) and $r$-singular cycles (with length divisible by $r$) have been extensively studied largely related to roots of permutations. We introduce the wide band Cayley continuants as an extension of the original Cayley continuants, and we show that they can be interpreted in terms of the joint distribution of the number of $r$-regular cycles and the number of $r$-singular cycles over permutations of $[n]$.

In light of the grammar given by Ji for the $(α,β)$-Eulerian polynomials introduced by Carlitz and Scoville, we provide a labeling scheme for increasing binary trees. In this setting, we obtain a combinatorial interpretation of the $γ$-coefficients of the $α$-Eulerian polynomials in terms of forests of planted 0-1-2-plane trees, which specializes to a combinatorial interpretation of the $γ$-coefficients of the derangement polynomials in the same vein. By means of a decomposition of an increasing binary tree into a forest, we find combinatorial interpretations of the sums involving two identities of Ji, one of which can be viewed as $(α,β)$-extensions of the formulas of Petersen and Stembridge.

We came across an unexpected connection between a remarkable grammar of Dumont for the joint distribution of $(\exc, \fix)$ over $S_n$ and a beautiful theorem of Diaconis-Evans-Graham on successions and fixed points of permutations. With the grammar in hand, we demonstrate the advantage of the grammatical calculus in deriving the generating functions, where the constant property plays a substantial role. On the grounds of left successions of a permutation, we present a grammatical treatment of the joint distribution investigated by Roselle. Moreover, we obtain a left succession analogue of the Diaconis-Evans-Graham theorem, exemplifying the idea of a grammar assisted bijection. The grammatical labelings give rise to an equidistribution of $(\jump, \des)$ and $(\exc, \drop)$ restricted to the set of left successions and the set of fixed points, {where $\jump$ is defined to be the number of ascents minus the number of left successions.}

In an award-winning expository article, V. Pozdnyakov and J.M. Steele gave a beautiful demonstration of the ramifications of a basic bijection for permutations. The aim of this note is to connect this correspondence to a seemingly unrelated problem concerning odd cycles and even cycles, arising in the combinatorial study of the Cayley continuants by E. Munarini and D. Torri. In extreme cases, one encounters two special classes of permutations of $2n$ elements with the same cardinality. A bijection of this appealing relation has been found by E. Sayag. A combinatorial study of permutations with only odd cycles has been carried out by M. Bóna, A. Mclennan and D. White. We find an intermediate structure which leads to a linkage between these two antipodal structures. A recursive setting reveals that everything boils down to only one trick -- breaking the cycles.

We develop a nonstandard approach to exploring polynomials associated with peaks and runs of permutations. With the aid of a context-free grammar, or a set of substitution rules, one can perform a symbolic calculus, and the computation often becomes rather simple. From a grammar it follows at once a system of ordinary differential equations for the generating functions. Utilizing a certain constant property, it is even possible to deduce a single equation for each generating function. To bring the grammar to a combinatorial setting, we find a labeling scheme for up-down runs of a permutation, which can be regarded as a refined property, or the differentiability in a certain sense, in contrast to the usual counting argument for the recurrence relation. The labeling scheme also exhibits how the substitution rules arise in the construction of the combinatorial structures. Consequently, polynomials on peaks and runs can be dealt with in two ways, combinatorially or grammatically. The grammar also serves as a guideline to build a bijection between permutations and increasing trees that maps the number of up-down runs to the number of nonroot vertices of even degree. This correspondence can be adapted to left peaks and exterior peaks, and the key step of the construction is called the reflection principle.

We observe that three context-free grammars of Dumont can be brought to a common ground, via the idea of transformations of grammars, proposed by Ma-Ma-Yeh. Then we develop a unified perspective to investigate several combinatorial objects in connection with the bivariate Eulerian polynomials. We call this approach the Dumont ansatz. As applications, we provide grammatical treatments, in the spirit of the symbolic method, of relations on the Springer numbers, the Euler numbers, the three kinds of peak polynomials, an identity of Petersen, and the two kinds of derivative polynomials, introduced by Knuth-Buckholtz and Carlitz-Scoville, and later by Hoffman in a broader context. We obtain a convolution formula on the left peak polynomials, leading to the Gessel formula. In this framework, we are led to the combinatorial interpretations of the derivative polynomials due to Josuat-Vergès.

Pondering upon the grammatical labeling of 0-1-2 increasing plane trees, we come to the realization that the grammatical labels play a role as records of chopped off leaves of the original increasing binary trees. While such an understanding is purely psychological, it does give rise to an efficient apparatus to tackle the partial $γ$-positivity of the Eulearian polynomials on multiset Stirling permutations, as long as we bear in mind the combinatorial meanings of the labels $x$ and $y$ in the Gessel representation of a $k$-Stirling permutation by means of an increasing $(k+1)$-ary tree. More precisely, we introduce a Foata-Strehl action on the Gessel trees resulting in an interpretation of the partial $γ$-coefficients of the aforementioned Eulerian polynomials, different from the ones found by Lin-Ma-Zhang and Yan-Huang-Yang. In particular, our strategy can be adapted to deal with the partial $γ$-coefficients of the second order Eulerian polynomials, which in turn can be readily converted to the combinatorial formulation due to Ma-Ma-Yeh in connection with certain statistics of Stirling permutations.

Ma-Ma-Yeh made a beautiful observation that a transformation of the grammar of Dumont instantly leads to the $γ$-positivity of the Eulerian polynomials. We notice that the transformed grammar bears a striking resemblance to the grammar for 0-1-2 increasing trees also due to Dumont. The appearance of the factor of two fits perfectly in a grammatical labeling of 0-1-2 increasing plane trees. Furthermore, the grammatical calculus is instrumental to the computation of the generating functions. This approach can be adapted to study the $e$-positivity of the trivariate second-order Eulerian polynomials first introduced by Dumont in the contexts of ternary trees and Stirling permutations, and independently defined by Janson, in connection with the joint distribution of the numbers of ascents, descents and plateaux over Stirling permutations.

One can hardly believe that there is still something to be said about cubic equations. To dodge this doubt, we will instead try and say something about Sylvester. He doubtless found a way of solving cubic equations. As mentioned by Rota, it was the only method in this vein that he could remember. We realize that in the generic case Sylvester's magnificent approach aimed at reduced cubic equations boils down to an easy identity expressing a cubic polynomial as a sum of two third powers of linear forms. This leads to Cardano's formula for cubic equations involving the third roots of unity.

We obtain a combinatorial formula related to the shear transformation for semi-invariants of binary forms, which implies the classical characterization of semi-invariants in terms of a differential operator. Then, we present a combinatorial proof of an identity of Hilbert, which leads to a relation of Cayley on semi-invariants. This identity plays a crucial role in the original proof of Sylvester's theorem on semi-invariants in connection with the Gaussian coefficients. Moreover, we show that the additivity lemma of Pak and Panova which yields the strict unimodality of the Gaussian coefficients for $n,k \geq 8$ can be deduced from the ring property of semi-invariants.

The symmetric difference of the $q$-binomial coefficients $F_{n,k}(q)={n+k\brack k}-q^{n}{n+k-2\brack k-2}$ was introduced by Reiner and Stanton. They proved that $F_{n,k}(q)$ is symmetric and unimodal for $k \geq 2$ and $n$ even by using the representation theory for Lie algebras. Based on Sylvester's proof of the unimodality of the Gaussian coefficients, as conjectured by Cayley, we find an interpretation of the unimodality of $F_{n,k}(q)$ in terms of semi-invariants. In the spirit of the strict unimodality of the Gaussian coefficients due to Pak and Panova, we prove the strict unimodality of the symmetric difference $G_{n,k,r}(q)={n+k\brack k}-q^{nr/2}{n+k-r\brack k-r}$, except for the two terms at both ends, where $n,r\geq8$, $k\geq r$ and at least one of $n$ and $r$ is even.

This paper is concerned with a class of partition functions $a(n)$ introduced by Radu and defined in terms of eta-quotients. By utilizing the transformation laws of Newman, Schoeneberg and Robins, and Radu's algorithms, we present an algorithm to find Ramanujan-type identities for $a(mn+t)$. While this algorithm is not guaranteed to succeed, it applies to many cases. For example, we deduce a witness identity for $p(11n+6)$ with integer coefficients. Our algorithm also leads to Ramanujan-type identities for the overpartition functions $\overline{p}(5n+2)$ and $\overline{p}(5n+3)$ and Andrews--Paule's broken $2$-diamond partition functions $\triangle_{2}(25n+14)$ and $\triangle_{2}(25n+24)$. It can also be extended to derive Ramanujan-type identities on a more general class of partition functions. For example, it yields the Ramanujan-type identities on Andrews' singular overpartition functions $\overline{Q}_{3,1}(9n+3)$ and $ \overline{Q}_{3,1}(9n+6)$ due to Shen, the $2$-dissection formulas of Ramanujan and the $8$-dissection formulas due to Hirschhorn.

Ramanujan defined the polynomials $ψ_{k}(r,x)$ in his study of power series inversion. Berndt, Evans and Wilson obtained a recurrence relation for $ψ_{k}(r,x)$. In a different context, Shor introduced the polynomials $Q(i,j,k)$ related to improper edges of a rooted tree, leading to a refinement of Cayley's formula. He also proved a recurrence relation and raised the question of finding a combinatorial proof. Zeng realized that the polynomials of Ramanujan coincide with the polynomials of Shor, and that the recurrence relation of Shor coincides with the recurrence relation of Berndt, Evans and Wilson. So we call these polynomials the Ramanujan-Shor polynomials, and call the recurrence relation the Berndt-Evans-Wilson-Shor recursion. A combinatorial proof of this recursion was obtained by Chen and Guo, and a simpler proof was recently given by Guo. From another perspective, Dumont and Ramamonjisoa found a context-free grammar $G$ to generate the number of rooted trees on $n$ vertices with $k$ improper edges. Based on the grammar $G$, we find a grammar $H$ for the Ramanujan-Shor polynomials. This leads to a formal calculus for the Ramanujan-Shor polynomials. In particular, we obtain a grammatical derivation of the Berndt-Evans-Wilson-Shor recursion. We also provide a grammatical approach to the Abel identities and a grammatical explanation of the Lacasse identity.

The spt-function spt($n$) was introduced by Andrews as the weighted counting of partitions of $n$ with respect to the number of occurrences of the smallest part. In this survey, we summarize recent developments in the study of spt($n$), including congruence properties established by Andrews, Bringmann, Folsom, Garvan, Lovejoy and Ono et al., a constructive proof of the Andrews-Dyson-Rhoades conjecture given by Chen, Ji and Zang, generalizations and variations of the spt-function. We also give an overview of asymptotic formulas of spt($n$) obtained by Ahlgren, Andersen and Rhoades et al. We conclude with some conjectures on inequalities on spt($n$), which are reminiscent of those on $p(n)$ due to DeSalvo and Pak, and Bessenrodt and Ono. Furthermore, we observe that, beyond the log-concavity, $p(n)$ and spt($n$) satisfy higher order inequalities based on polynomials arising in the invariant theory of binary forms. In particular, we conjecture that the higher order Turán inequality $4(a_n^2-a_{n-1}a_{n+1})(a_{n+1}^2-a_{n}a_{n+2})-(a_na_{n+1}-a_{n-1}a_{n+2})^2>0$ holds for $p(n)$ when $n\geq 95$ and for spt($n$) when $n\geq 108$.

The Turán inequalities and the higher order Turán inequalities arise in the study of Maclaurin coefficients of an entire function in the Laguerre-Pólya class. A real sequence $\{a_{n}\}$ is said to satisfy the Turán inequalities if for $n\geq 1$, $a_n^2-a_{n-1}a_{n+1}\geq 0$. It is said to satisfy the higher order Turán inequalities if for $n\geq 1$, $4(a_{n}^2-a_{n-1}a_{n+1})(a_{n+1}^2-a_{n}a_{n+2})-(a_{n}a_{n+1}-a_{n-1}a_{n+2})^2\geq 0$. A sequence satisfying the Turán inequalities is also called log-concave. For the partition function $p(n)$, DeSalvo and Pak showed that for $n>25$, the sequence $\{ p(n)\}_{n> 25}$ is log-concave, that is, $p(n)^2-p(n-1)p(n+1)>0$ for $n> 25$. It was conjectured by Chen that $p(n)$ satisfies the higher order Turán inequalities for $n\geq 95$. In this paper, we prove this conjecture by using the Hardy-Ramanujan-Rademacher formula to derive an upper bound and a lower bound for $p(n+1)p(n-1)/p(n)^2$. Consequently, for $n\geq 95$, the Jensen polynomials $g_{3,n-1}(x)=p(n-1)+3p(n)x+3p(n+1)x^2+p(n+2)x^3$ have only real zeros. We conjecture that for any positive integer $m\geq 4$ there exists an integer $N(m)$ such that for $n\geq N(m) $, the polynomials $\sum_{k=0}^m {m\choose k}p(n+k)x^k$ have only real zeros. This conjecture was independently posed by Ono.

Let $N(\leq m,n)$ denote the number of partitions of $n$ with rank not greater than $m$, and let $M(\leq m,n)$ denote the number of partitions of $n$ with crank not greater than $m$. Bringmann and Mahlburg observed that $N(\leq m,n)\leq M(\leq m,n)\leq N(\leq m+1,n)$ for $m<0$ and $1\leq n\leq 100$. They also pointed out that these inequalities can be restated as the existence of a re-ordering $τ_n$ on the set of partitions of $n$ such that $|\text{crank}(λ)|-|\text{rank}(τ_n(λ))|=0$ or $1$ for all partitions $λ$ of $n$, that is, the rank and the crank are nearly equal distributions over partitions of $n$. In the study of the spt-function, Andrews, Dyson and Rhoades proposed a conjecture on the unimodality of the spt-crank, and they showed that this conjecture is equivalent to the inequality $N(\leq m,n)\leq M(\leq m,n)$ for $m<0$ and $n\geq 1$. We proved this conjecture by combiantorial arguments. In this paper, we prove the inequality $N(\leq m,n)\leq M(\leq m,n)$ for $m<0$ and $n\geq 1$. Furthermore, we define a re-ordering $τ_n$ of the partitions $λ$ of $n$ and show that this re-ordering $τ_n$ leads to the nearly equal distribution of the rank and the crank. Using the re-ordering $τ_n$, we give a new combinatorial interpretation of the function ospt$(n)$ defined by Andrews, Chan and Kim, which immediately leads to an upper bound for $ospt(n)$ due to Chan and Mao.

Let $p(n)$ denote the partition function. Desalvo and Pak proved the log-concavity of $p(n)$ for $n>25$ and the inequality $\frac{p(n-1)}{p(n)}\left(1+\frac{1}{n}\right)>\frac{p(n)}{p(n+1)}$ for $n>1$. Let $r(n)=\sqrt[n]{p(n)/n}$ and $Δ$ be the difference operator respect to $n$. Desalvo and Pak pointed out that their approach to proving the log-concavity of $p(n)$ may be employed to prove a conjecture of Sun on the log-convexity of $\{r(n)\}_{n\geq 61}$, as long as one finds an appropriate estimate of $Δ^2 \log r(n-1)$. In this paper, we obtain a lower bound for $Δ^2\log r(n-1)$, leading to a proof of this conjecture. From the log-convexity of $\{r(n)\}_{n\geq61}$ and $\{\sqrt[n]{n}\}_{n\geq4}$, we are led to a proof of another conjecture of Sun on the log-convexity of $\{\sqrt[n]{p(n)}\}_{n\geq27}$. Furthermore, we show that $\lim\limits_{n \rightarrow +\infty}n^{\frac{5}{2}}Δ^2\log\sqrt[n]{p(n)}=3π/\sqrt{24}$. Finally, by finding an upper bound of $Δ^2 \log\sqrt[n-1]{p(n-1)}$, we prove an inequality on the ratio $\frac{\sqrt[n-1]{p(n-1)}}{\sqrt[n]{p(n)}}$ analogous to the above inequality on the ratio $\frac{p(n-1)}{p(n)}$.