arXiv++ Combinatorics

Let $Q_{d,p}$ be the random subgraph of the $d$-dimensional hypercube $\{0,1\}^d$, where each edge is retained independently with probability $p$. We study the asymptotic number of independent sets in $Q_{d,p}$ as $d \to \infty$ for a wide range of parameters $p$, including values of $p$ tending to zero as fast as $\frac{C\log d}{d^{1/3}}$, constant values of $p$, and values of $p$ tending to one. The results extend to the hardcore model on $Q_{d,p}$, and are obtained by studying the closely related antiferromagnetic Ising model on the hypercube, which can be viewed as a positive-temperature hardcore model on the hypercube. These results generalize previous results by Galvin, Jenssen and Perkins on the hard-core model on the hypercube, corresponding to the case $p=1$, which extended Korshunov and Sapozhenko's classical result on the asymptotic number of independent sets in the hypercube.

The ferromagnetic Ising model is a model of a magnetic material and a central topic in statistical physics. It also plays a starring role in the algorithmic study of approximate counting: approximating the partition function of the ferromagnetic Ising model with uniform external field is tractable at all temperatures and on all graphs, due to the randomized algorithm of Jerrum and Sinclair. Here we show that hidden inside the model are hard computational problems. For the class of bounded-degree graphs we find computational thresholds for the approximate counting and sampling problems for the ferromagnetic Ising model at fixed magnetization (that is, fixing the number of $+1$ and $-1$ spins). In particular, letting $β_c(Δ)$ denote the critical inverse temperature of the zero-field Ising model on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree, and $η_{Δ,β,1}^+$ denote the mean magnetization of the zero-field $+$ measure on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree at inverse temperature $β$, we prove, for the class of graphs of maximum degree $Δ$: 1. For $β< β_c(Δ)$ there is an FPRAS and efficient sampling scheme for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for all magnetizations $η$. 2. For $β> β_c(Δ)$, there is an FPRAS and efficient sampling scheme for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for magnetizations $η$ such that $|η| >η_{Δ,β,1}^+ $. 3. For $β> β_c(Δ)$, there is no FPRAS for the fixed-magnetization Ising model for magnetizations $η$ such that $|η| <η_{Δ,β,1}^+ $ unless NP=RP\@.

In this work we consider random two-colourings of random linear preferential attachment trees, which includes random recursive trees, random plane-oriented recursive trees, random binary search trees, and a class of random $d$-ary trees. The random colouring is defined by assigning the root of the tree the colour red or blue with equal probability, and all other vertices are assigned the colour of their parent with probability $p$ and the other colour otherwise. These colourings have been previously studied in other contexts, including Ising models and broadcasting, and can be considered as generalizations of bond percolation. With the help of Pólya urns, we prove limiting distributions, after proper rescalings, for the number of vertices of each colour, the number of monochromatic subtrees of each colour, as well as the number of leaves and fringe subtrees with two-colourings. Using methods from analytic combinatorics, we also provide precise descriptions of the limiting distribution after proper rescaling of the size of the root cluster; the largest monochromatic subtree containing the root. The description of the limiting distributions extends previous work on bond percolation in random preferential attachment trees.

We prove that for any graph $G$ of maximum degree at most $Δ$, the zeros of its chromatic polynomial $χ_G(z)$ (in $\mathbb{C}$) lie outside the disk of radius $5.02 Δ$ centered at $0$. This improves on the previously best known bound of approximately $6.91Δ$. In the case of graphs of high girth we can improve this. We prove that for every $g$ there is a constant $K_g$ such that for any graph $G$ of maximum degree at most $Δ$ and girth at least $g$, the zeros of its chromatic polynomial $χ_G(z)$ lie outside the disk of radius $K_g Δ$ centered at $0$ where $K_g \to 1 + e \approx 3.72$ as $g \to \infty$. Finally, we give improved bounds on the Fisher zeros of the partition function of the Ising model.

We study the complexity of approximating the partition function $Z_{\mathrm{Ising}}(G; β)$ of the Ising model in terms of the relation between the edge interaction $β$ and a parameter $Δ$ which is an upper bound on the maximum degree of the input graph $G$. Following recent trends in both statistical physics and algorithmic research, we allow the edge interaction $β$ to be any complex number. Many recent partition function results focus on complex parameters, both because of physical relevance and because of the key role of the complex case in delineating the tractability/intractability phase transition of the approximation problem. In this work we establish both new tractability results and new intractability results. Our tractability results show that $Z_{\mathrm{Ising}}(-; β)$ has an FPTAS when $\lvert β- 1 \rvert / \lvert β+ 1 \rvert < \tan(π/ (4 Δ- 4))$. The core of the proof is showing that there are no inputs~$G$ that make the partition function $0$ when $β$ is in this range. Our result significantly extends the known zero-free region of the Ising model (and hence the known approximation results). Our intractability results show that it is $\mathrm{\#P}$-hard to multiplicatively approximate the norm and to additively approximate the argument of $Z_{\mathrm{Ising}}(-; β)$ when $β\in \mathbb{C}$ is an algebraic number such that $β\not \in \mathbb{R} \cup \{i,-i\}$ and $\lvert β- 1\rvert / \lvert β+ 1 \rvert > 1 / \sqrt{Δ- 1}$. These are the first results to show intractability of approximating $Z_{\mathrm{Ising}}(-, β)$ on bounded degree graphs with complex $β$. Moreover, we demonstrate situations in which zeros of the partition function imply hardness of approximation in the Ising model.

Given a system of linear equations $\ell_i(x)=β_i$ in an $n$-vector $x$ of 0-1 variables, we compute the expectation of $\exp\left\{- \sum_i γ_i \left(\ell_i(x) - β_i\right)^2\right\}$, where $x$ is a vector of independent Bernoulli random variables and $γ_i >0$ are constants. The algorithm runs in quasi-polynomial $n^{O(\ln n)}$ time under some sparseness condition on the matrix of the system. The result is based on the absence of the zeros of the analytic continuation of the expectation for complex probabilities, which can also be interpreted as the absence of a phase transition in the Ising model with a sufficiently strong external field. We discuss applications to (perfect) matchings in hypergraphs and randomized rounding in discrete optimization.

We introduce a family of spaces called critical varieties. Each critical variety is a subset of one of the positroid varieties in the Grassmannian. The combinatorics of positroid varieties is captured by the dimer model on a planar bipartite graph $G$, and the critical variety is obtained by restricting to Kenyon's critical dimer model associated to a family of isoradial embeddings of $G$. This model is invariant under square/spider moves on $G$, and we give an explicit boundary measurement formula for critical varieties which does not depend on the choice of $G$. This extends our recent results for the critical Ising model, and simultaneously also includes the case of critical electrical networks. We systematically develop the basic properties of critical varieties. In particular, we study their real and totally positive parts, the combinatorics of the associated strand diagrams, and introduce a shift map motivated by the connection to zonotopal tilings and scattering amplitudes.

We use Wagner's weighted subgraph counting polynomial to prove that the partition function of the anti-ferromagnetic Ising model on line graphs is real rooted and to prove that roots of the edge cover polynomial have length at most $4$. We moreover discuss how our results relate to efficient algorithms for approximately computing evaluations of these polynomials.

Given a finite rhombus tiling of a polygonal region in the plane, the associated critical $Z$-invariant Ising model is invariant under star-triangle transformations. We give a simple matrix formula describing spin correlations between boundary vertices in terms of the shape of the region. When the region is a regular polygon, our formula becomes an explicit trigonometric sum.

We generalize the switching lemma of Griffiths, Hurst and Sherman to the random current representation of the Ashkin-Teller model. We then use it together with properties of two-dimensional topology to derive linear relations for multi-point boundary spin correlations and bulk order-disorder correlations in planar models. We also show that the same linear relations are satisfied by products of Pfaffians. As a result a clear picture arises in the noninteracting case of two independent Ising models where multi-point correlation functions are given by Pfaffians and determinants of their respective two-point functions. This gives a unified treatment of both the classical Pfaffian identities and recent total positivity inequalities for boundary spin correlations in the planar Ising model. We also derive the Simon and Gaussian inequality for general Ashkin-Teller models with negative four-body coupling constants.

We survey and develop the most elementary model of electron motion introduced by R$.$Feynman. In this game, a checker moves on a checkerboard by simple rules, and we count the turns. Feynman checkers are also known as a one-dimensional quantum walk or an Ising model at imaginary temperature. We solve mathematically a problem by R$.$Feynman from 1965, which was to prove that the discrete model (for large time, small average velocity, and small lattice step) is consistent with the continuum one. We study asymptotic properties of the model (for small lattice step and large time) improving the results by J$.$Narlikar from 1972 and by T$.$Sunada-T$.$Tate from 2012. For the first time we observe and prove concentration of measure in the small-lattice-step limit. We perform the second quantization of the model.

We study the computational complexity of approximating the partition function of the ferromagnetic Ising model with the external field parameter $λ$ on the unit circle in the complex plane. Complex-valued parameters for the Ising model are relevant for quantum circuit computations and phase transitions in statistical physics, but have also been key in the recent deterministic approximation scheme for all $|λ|\neq 1$ by Liu, Sinclair, and Srivastava. Here, we focus on the unresolved complexity picture on the unit circle, and on the tantalising question of what happens around $λ=1$, where on one hand the classical algorithm of Jerrum and Sinclair gives a randomised approximation scheme on the real axis suggesting tractability, and on the other hand the presence of Lee-Yang zeros alludes to computational hardness. Our main result establishes a sharp computational transition at the point $λ=1$, and more generally on the entire unit circle. For an integer $Δ\geq 3$ and edge interaction parameter $b\in (0,1)$ we show #P-hardness for approximating the partition function on graphs of maximum degree $Δ$ on the arc of the unit circle where the Lee-Yang zeros are dense. This result contrasts with known approximation algorithms when $|λ|\neq 1$ or when $λ$ is in the complementary arc around $1$ of the unit circle. Our work thus gives a direct connection between the presence/absence of Lee-Yang zeros and the tractability of efficiently approximating the partition function on bounded-degree graphs.

A well-known conjecture by Lovász and Plummer from the 1970s asserted that a bridgeless cubic graph has exponentially many perfect matchings. It was solved in the affirmative by Esperet et al. (Adv. Math. 2011). On the other hand, Chudnovsky and Seymour (Combinatorica 2012) proved the conjecture in the special case of cubic planar graphs. In our work we consider random bridgeless cubic planar graphs with the uniform distribution on graphs with $n$ vertices. Under this model we show that the expected number of perfect matchings in labeled bridgeless cubic planar graphs is asymptotically $cγ^n$, where $c>0$ and $γ\sim 1.14196$ is an explicit algebraic number. We also compute the expected number of perfect matchings in (non necessarily bridgeless) cubic planar graphs and provide lower bounds for unlabeled graphs. Our starting point is a correspondence between counting perfect matchings in rooted cubic planar maps and the partition function of the Ising model in rooted triangulations.

We consider the problem of computing the partition function $\sum_x e^{f(x)}$, where $f: \{-1, 1\}^n \longrightarrow {\Bbb R}$ is a quadratic or cubic polynomial on the Boolean cube $\{-1, 1\}^n$. In the case of a quadratic polynomial $f$, we show that the partition function can be approximated within relative error $0 < ε< 1$ in quasi-polynomial $n^{O(\ln n - \ln ε)}$ time if the Lipschitz constant of the non-linear part of $f$ with respect to the $\ell^1$ metric on the Boolean cube does not exceed $1-δ$, for any $δ>0$, fixed in advance. For a cubic polynomial $f$, we get the same result under a somewhat stronger condition. We apply the method of polynomial interpolation, for which we prove that $\sum_x e^{\tilde{f}(x)} \ne 0$ for complex-valued polynomials $\tilde{f}$ in a neighborhood of a real-valued $f$ satisfying the above mentioned conditions. The bounds are asymptotically optimal. Results on the zero-free region are interpreted as the absence of a phase transition in the Lee - Yang sense in the corresponding Ising model. The novel feature of the bounds is that they control the total interaction of each vertex but not every single interaction of sets of vertices.

We prove a new Fermionic quasiparticle sum expression for the character of the Ising model vertex algebra, related to the Jackson-Slater $q$-series identity of Rogers-Ramanujan type and to Nahm sums for the matrix $\left( \begin{smallmatrix} 8 & 3 \\ 3 & 2 \end{smallmatrix} \right)$. We find, as consequences, an explicit monomial basis for the Ising model, and a description of its singular support. We find that the ideal sheaf of the latter, defining it as a subscheme of the arc space of its associated scheme, is finitely generated as a differential ideal. We prove three new $q$-series identities of the Rogers-Ramanujan-Slater type associated with the three irreducible modules of the Virasoro Lie algebra of central charge $1/2$. We give a combinatorial interpretation to the identity associated with the vacuum module.

We study the complexity of approximating the partition function of the $q$-state Potts model and the closely related Tutte polynomial for complex values of the underlying parameters. Apart from the classical connections with quantum computing and phase transitions in statistical physics, recent work in approximate counting has shown that the behaviour in the complex plane, and more precisely the location of zeros, is strongly connected with the complexity of the approximation problem, even for positive real-valued parameters. Previous work in the complex plane by Goldberg and Guo focused on $q=2$, which corresponds to the case of the Ising model; for $q>2$, the behaviour in the complex plane is not as well understood and most work applies only to the real-valued Tutte plane. Our main result is a complete classification of the complexity of the approximation problems for all non-real values of the parameters, by establishing \#P-hardness results that apply even when restricted to planar graphs. Our techniques apply to all $q\geq 2$ and further complement/refine previous results both for the Ising model and the Tutte plane, answering in particular a question raised by Bordewich, Freedman, Lovász and Welsh in the context of quantum computations.

We provide a framework to study the interfaces imposed by Dobrushin boundary conditions on the half-plane version of the Ising model on random triangulations with spins on vertices. Using the combinatorial solution by Albenque, Ménard and Schaeffer ([2]) and the generating function methods introduced by Chen and Turunen ([8], [9]), we show the local weak convergence of such triangulations of the disk as the perimeter tends to infinity, and study the interface imposed by the Dobrushin boundary condition. As a consequence of this analysis, we verify the heuristics of physics literature that discrete interface of the model in the high-temperature regime resembles the critical site percolation interface, as well as provide an explicit scaling limit of the interface length at the critical temperature, which coincides with results on the continuum Liouville Quantum gravity surfaces. Overall, this model exhibits simpler structure than the model with spins on faces, as well as demonstrates the robustness of the methods developed in [8], [9].

In [arXiv:1806.06668], we have studied the Boltzmann random triangulation of the disk coupled to an Ising model on its faces with Dobrushin boundary condition at its critical temperature. In this paper, we investigate the phase transition of this model by extending our previous results to arbitrary temperature: We compute the partition function of the model at all temperatures, and derive several critical exponents associated with the infinite perimeter limit. We show that the model has a local limit at any temperature, whose properties depend drastically on the temperature. At high temperatures, the local limit is reminiscent of the uniform infinite half-planar triangulation (UIHPT) decorated with a subcritical percolation. At low temperatures, the local limit develops a bottleneck of finite width due to the energy cost of the main Ising interface between the two spin clusters imposed by the Dobrushin boundary condition. This change can be summarized by a novel order parameter with a nice geometric meaning. In addition to the phase transition, we also generalize our construction of the local limit from the two-step asymptotic regime used in [arXiv:1806.06668] to a more natural diagonal asymptotic regime. We obtain in this regime a scaling limit related to the length of the main Ising interface, which coincides with predictions from the continuum theory of quantum surfaces (a.k.a.\ Liouville quantum gravity).

Chelkak introduced $s$-embeddings as tilings by tangential quads which provide the right setting to study the Ising model with arbitrary coupling constants on arbitrary planar graphs. We prove the existence and uniqueness of a local transformation for $s$-embeddings called the cube move, which consists in flipping three quadrilaterals in such a way that the resulting tiling is also in the class of $s$-embeddings. In passing, we give a new and simpler formula for the change in coupling constants for the Ising star-triangle transformation which is conjugated to the cube move for $s$-embeddings. We introduce more generally the class of $α$-embeddings as tilings of a portion of the plane by quadrilaterals such that the side lengths of each quadrilateral $ABCD$ satisfy the relation $AB^α+CD^α=AD^α+BC^α$, providing a common generalization for harmonic embeddings adapted to the study of resistor networks ($α=2$) and for $s$-embeddings ($α=1$). We investigate existence and uniqueness properties of the cube move for these $α$-embeddings.

Consider random $d$-regular graphs, i.e., random graphs such that there are exactly $d$ edges from each vertex for some $d\ge 3$. We study both the configuration model version of this graph, which has occasional multi-edges and self-loops, as well as the simple version of it, which is a $d$-regular graph chosen uniformly at random from the collection of all $d$-regular graphs. In this paper, we discuss mixing times of Glauber dynamics for the Ising model with an external magnetic field on a random $d$-regular graph, both in the quenched as well as the annealed settings. Let $β$ be the inverse temperature, $β_c$ be the critical temperature and $B$ be the external magnetic field. Concerning the annealed measure, we show that for $β> β_c$ there exists $\hat{B}_c(β)\in (0,\infty)$ such that the model is metastable (i.e., the mixing time is exponential in the graph size $n$) when $β> β_c$ and $0 \leq B < \hat{B}_c(β)$, whereas it exhibits the cut-off phenomenon at $c_\star n \log n$ with a window of order $n$ when $β< β_c$ or $β> β_c$ and $B>\hat{B}_c(β)$. Interestingly, $\hat{B}_c(β)$ coincides with the critical external field of the Ising model on the $d$-ary tree (namely, above which the model has a unique Gibbs measure). Concerning the quenched measure, we show that there exists $B_c(β)$ with $B_c(β) \leq \hat{B}_c(β)$ such that for $β> β_c$, the mixing time is at least exponential along some subsequence $(n_k)_{k\geq 1}$ when $0 \leq B < B_c(β)$, whereas it is less than or equal to $Cn\log n$ when $B>\hat{B}_c(β)$. The quenched results also hold for the model conditioned on simplicity, for the annealed results this is unclear.