matching
3165 papers tagged with this keyword
An Independent Border-Free Type-A Cover of Q221 and Improved Asymptotic Bounds for Queen Domination
The queen's graph $Q_n$ has the squares of the $n\times n$ chessboard as vertices, with adjacency defined by a common row, column, or diagonal. We give an explicit set of 111 pairwise nonattacking queens on $Q_{221}$. The set contains no queen on an outer row or column and satisfies the original type-A 1-cover conditions of Ostergard and Weakley with parameters $(e,f,u)=(24,23,31)$. A direct enumeration checks all $221^2=48{,}841$ board squares and finds none uncovered. The lower bound of Finozhenok and Weakley therefore gives $γ(Q_{221})=i(Q_{221})=111$. Neuhaus previously established the equality for ordinary domination. The no-edge-square branch of the type-A amplification theorem gives $γ(Q_N)\leq(112/221)N+O(1)$ and $i(Q_N)\leq(113/221)N+O(1)$. These coefficients improve, respectively, the coefficients $30/59$ and $91/177$ stated by Neuhaus. We also describe the exact four-family matching model used to obtain the certificate. An assignment-dual identity gives a lossless reduced-cost deletion rule, and alternating allowed-edge tests give a second lossless reduction. The complete coordinates, two independently implemented standard-library certificate verifiers, and a deterministic reduction audit accompany the manuscript.
List coloring $C_3$-free planar graphs with a sparse matching of restricted lists
A graph $G$ is $k$-choosable if it has a proper coloring for every $k$-list assignment. While every $C_3$-free planar graph is $4$-choosable, some of them are not $3$-choosable, as constructed by Voigt. Hu and Zhu conjectured that if $G$ is a $C_3$-free planar graph and $X \subseteq V(G)$ induces a bipartite subgraph, then $G$ has a proper $L$-coloring whenever $|L(x)| = 3$ for $x \in X$ and $|L(v)| = 4$ for $v \in V(G) \setminus X$. As evidence, they proved the conjecture when $X$ is an independent set. We provide further evidence by proving the conjecture when the induced subgraph $G[X]$ is an induced sparse matching. This is the first result supporting the conjecture in which the set $X$ receiving smaller lists may induce a subgraph with edges.
The Homotopy Types of the Independence and Perfect Matching Complex of Möbius Ladder Graph
The independence complex and the perfect matching complex of a graph are simplicial complexes encoding, respectively, its independent sets and perfect matchings. Determining the homotopy types and other topological properties of these complexes is, in general, a difficult problem, and explicit descriptions are known only for relatively restricted classes of graphs, typically possessing substantial combinatorial regularity or symmetry. Although these complexes have been extensively investigated for several families of graphs, including square grid graphs, comparatively little is known for other natural families of highly symmetric graphs.
In this article, we determine the homotopy types of the independence complex and the perfect matching complex of the Möbius ladder graphs $M_{2n}$. Möbius ladder graphs form a natural and highly symmetric family of cubic graphs obtained from a $2n$-cycle by joining pairs of opposite vertices. We prove that the homotopy type of the independence complex $\operatorname{Ind}(M_{2n})$ depends periodically on $n$ modulo $4$: for $n=4k$, it is homotopy equivalent to $\mathbb{S}^{2k-1}$; for $n=4k+2$, it is homotopy equivalent to a wedge of three copies of $\mathbb{S}^{2k}$; and for $n=4k+1$ or $4k+3$, it is homotopy equivalent to $\mathbb{S}^{2k}$. We further determine the homotopy type of the perfect matching complex $\mathcal{M}_p(M_{2n})$. For even $n$, it is homotopy equivalent to a wedge of two copies of $\mathbb{S}^{(n-2)/2}$, while for odd $n$ its homotopy type depends periodically on $n$ modulo $6$. Thus, our results provide explicit descriptions of two fundamental simplicial complexes associated with an important family of highly symmetric cubic graphs.
A Full-Sequence Quantitative Gap Between the Chromatic and Cochromatic Numbers of a Random Graph
Let $ζ(G)$ denote the minimum number of parts in a partition of $V(G)$ in which every part induces either a clique or an independent set. Erdős and Gimbel asked whether, for $G_n\sim G(n,1/2)$, the difference $χ(G_n)-ζ(G_n)$ tends to infinity with high probability. We resolve this problem along the full sequence $n\to\infty$ and prove that $\mathbb P(χ(G_n)-ζ(G_n)\ge ((\log 2)^2/4)\log(200/153)\,n/(\log n)^3)\to1$. This gives a lower bound at the conjectured scale $n/(\log n)^3$. We also obtain a phase-resolved refinement: if $δ_n$ is the fractional part of the standard independence-number center, then the coefficient may be replaced by $(\log 2)^2A_4(δ_n)/4-o(1)$, where $A_4$ is explicit, continuous, nonconstant, and satisfies $A_4(δ)>\log(200/153)$ for every $δ\in[0,1]$. The proof uses signed cocoloring profiles supported on four consecutive class sizes and remains uniform across jumps of the natural class-size cutoff. An exact signed-overlap identity separates local cell rewards from a binary cycle-space factor. A canonical decomposition into high cells and a capped residual matching, together with an endpoint-table comparison and an injective restriction of residual even edge sets, yields the required second-moment bound. A bounded-differences argument then amplifies the resulting rare signed witness to a high-probability cocoloring.
The Cayley Completion of a Graph
A finite connected graph is rarely a Cayley graph. We measure how far it is from being one: given $G$ with $n$ vertices and $m$ edges, how few edges must be added, or added and deleted, before the result is a Cayley graph of an abelian group of order $n$ on the same vertex set? This defines two invariants, the completion number $γ^{+}$ (additions only) and the Cayley edit distance $γ_{\triangle}$ (both), each normalized by $m$. We show that deciding the edit version is NP-complete already for a fixed cyclic host, by a reduction from Hamiltonian Cycle in which the edit cost of a labeling is $n+m-2k$ when it realizes a longest path with $k$ edges; the optimal cost is $m-n+2pp(G)$, bounded in polynomial time by the matching number. We prove that irregularity alone forces $γ^{+}(G)\ge nΔ^{*}/(2m)-1$, where $Δ^{*}$ is the least $d\geΔ$ with $nd$ even, computable in linear time from the degree sequence; we characterize equality exactly. It is attained on the star, where $γ^{+}(K_{1,q})=(q-1)/2$ and the star maximizes $γ^{+}$, while $γ_{\triangle}$ stays bounded by an absolute constant. We determine paths and grids exactly, $γ^{+}(P_n)=γ^{+}(P_n\,\square\,P_n)=1/(n-1)$, and show $γ_{\triangle}(K_{1,q})\to 2$, not the $3/2$ suggested by the additive case. We report an exhaustive certified census of all $995$ connected graphs on at most seven vertices. The degree bound is attained on $89.4\%$ and the two invariants separate strictly on $84.7\%$, though both rates vary sharply with order: attainment $100\%,100\%,84.8\%,89.7\%$ and separation $0\%,61.9\%,73.2\%,87.7\%$ for $n=4,5,6,7$, dominated by the $853$ graphs on seven vertices. The star uniquely maximizes both. Edit count and the bi-Lipschitz distortion of the completed host are independent, moving oppositely on stars and paths.Data and certificates at doi:10.5281/zenodo.21852006.
Breaking the Exponential Barrier: The First Polynomial-Time Algorithm for the Győri-Lovász Theorem
We give the first polynomial-time algorithm, after half a century, for the celebrated Győri-Lovász theorem, which resolved a conjecture of Frank (1975). The theorem, one of the simplest existential theorems to explain, states that every $k$-connected graph can be partitioned into $k$ disjoint connected subgraphs of arbitrary prescribed positive sizes. This is a fundamental structural result with broad applications, such as flexible allocation of connected subnetworks of prescribed sizes in sufficiently connected cloud infrastructures.
While Lovász (1977) gave a highly non-constructive proof for a stronger directed version using algebraic topology, Győri's original constructive proof (1976) requires exponential time. Despite more than 50 years of effort, no polynomial-time algorithm was known even for $k>4$. Determining the computational complexity of the Győri-Lovász theorem---whether it admits even a sub-exponential-time algorithm or is computationally hard (in particular, PLS-complete or PPAD)---has remained one of the central open problems in algorithmic graph theory.
In this paper, we finally resolve this long-standing problem by a fundamentally new proof of the existential theorem via introducing the novel concept of \emph{flow-essential assignment}, which genuinely marries matching and cut structures and yields the first polynomial-time constructive algorithm for the Győri-Lovász theorem. In fact, we obtain a polynomial-time algorithm for Lovász's stronger directed version, whose proof was non-constructive even for DAGs; for DAGs, we further obtain a near-linear-time algorithm. We also develop polynomial-time algorithms for weighted generalizations where the seminal work of Chen, Kleinberg, Lovász, Rajaraman, Sundaram, and Vetta (JACM'07) on confluent flows established only existential non-constructive results.
Wallis-type products with polynomial exponents and the Dirichlet beta function at negative integers
We develop a methodology for designing infinite products of rational blocks whose exponents are polynomials in the index $k$. Matching power sums of the slot constants through order $n$ forces the Type-$N$ product with binomial exponent $\binom{n+k-2}{n-1}$ to converge to a ratio of Vignéras multiple gamma values $Γ_n$; an analogue finder lifts any Type-1 evaluation to every higher type, and integer combinations of binomial exponents then realise arbitrary integer-valued polynomial exponents, yielding explicit products with exponents $k$, $k^2$, $k^3$, ... for constants such as $π/2$, $\sqrt{2}$, $e^{2K/π}$, and rational multiples of $π^{M!}$ (Part I). As the main application (Part II) we prove that for every positive integer $n$, a finite multiple-gamma template $\mathcal{S}_n$ with generalised Eulerian weights $T(n,k)$ (OEIS A225118) evaluates the Duke-Imamoğlu expression $\mathcal{D}_n = β'(-n) + (\log 4)\,β(-n)$. For odd $n$ this yields a convergent Wallis-Eulerian product for $e^{β'(-n)}$; for even $n$ the raw product diverges. The proof expands the template through the multiple-gamma functional equation, evaluates the quarter-integer coefficients in closed form, and identifies the resulting Eulerian-binomial sums with Duke's polynomials $P_{n+1,\ell}$.
On $(1,2^4)$ and $(1,2^5)$-packing edge-coloring of sparse subcubic graphs
A $(1^j,2^k)$-packing edge-coloring of a graph $G$ is a partition of the edge set $E(G)$ into $j$ matchings and $k$ induced matchings. Hocquard, Lajou, and Lu\v zar found a subcubic planar graph of girth $3$ that has no $(1,2^5)$-packing edge-coloring and also conjectured that every subcubic planar graph has a $(1,2^6)$-packing edge-coloring. We also notice that for every fixed positive integer $k$ there exists a subcubic planar graph with girth $k$ that is not $(1,2^3)$-packing edge-colorable.
It is natural to consider what is the minimum positive integer $k_1$ such that every subcubic planar graph with girth at least $k_1$ is $(1,2^5)$-packing edge-colorable. Furthermore, we also consider what is the minimum positive integer $k_2$ such that every subcubic planar graph with girth at least $k_2$ is $(1,2^4)$-packing edge-colorable. In this paper, we show both $k_1$ and $k_2$ are finite, and in fact $5 \le k_1 \le 12$ and $6 \le k_2 \le 16$.
Grundy Total Domination and Skew Zero Forcing in Cartesian Products of Paths and Cycles
We determine the Grundy total domination number and the skew zero forcing number for every Cartesian product of two paths or cycles, thereby closing the nonmatching bounds previously known for these rectangular, cylindrical, and toroidal families. For $2\le a\le b$, \[
Z_-(P_a\square P_b)
=a-\mathbf1_{\{a\ {\rm odd},\,b\ {\rm even}\}}. \] For $p\ge2$ and $c\ge3$, \[
Z_-(P_p\square C_c)=
\begin{cases}
\min\{p,c\},&c\text{ is odd},
\min\{2p,c\},&c\text{ is even}.
\end{cases} \] Finally, for $3\le a\le b$, \[
Z_-(C_a\square C_b)=
\begin{cases}
2a-1,&a=b\text{ odd},
2a,&a=b\text{ even},
\min\{b,2a\},&a<b,\ a\text{ odd},
a,&a<b,\ a\text{ even},\ b\text{ odd},
2a,&a<b,\ a,b\text{ even}.
\end{cases} \] In every case, $γ_{\mathrm{gr}}^t(G)=|V(G)|-Z_-(G)$. The path-containing lower bounds use Kronecker differences of skew-symmetric or hollow symmetric factor matrices, and they also determine maximum skew nullity and minimum skew rank. They further produce an infinite family for which maximum skew nullity is strictly smaller than skew zero forcing. The new cycle--cycle lower bounds use a cyclic column-defect estimate, applied to complete columns when the shorter cycle is odd and, after a one-sided bipartite reduction, to half-columns when both cycles are even. Explicit forcing constructions give matching upper bounds throughout.
Signless Laplacian spectral conditions for rainbow matchings in a collection of bipartite graphs
Let ${\cal G}=\{{G_1},\ldots,{G_k}\}$ be a collection of (not necessarily distinct) bipartite graphs on the same vertex bipartition $(X,Y)$ with $|X|=a$ and $|Y|=b$, where $k$, $a$ and $b$ are positive integers. A collection ${\cal G}$ of bipartite graphs admits a rainbow matching if there exists a set of pairwise disjoint edges such that any two edges are from distinct bipartite graphs of ${\cal G}$. Denote by $q({G})$ the signless Laplacian spectral radius of a bipartite graph $G$. In this paper, we prove that if $q({G_i})\ge b+k-1+\sqrt{(k-1)b} $ for each ${G_i}\in{\cal G}=\{{G_1}, \ldots, {G_k}\}$, where $2\leq k\leq a\leq b$, then ${\cal G}$ admits a rainbow matching of size $k$ unless ${G_1}={G_2}=\cdots={G_k}\cong{K_{k-1,b}}\cup\overline{K_{a-k+1}}$, by using the shifting technique.
Matching complements in subcubic graphs and a proof of the 3-Decomposition Conjecture
We prove the 3-Decomposition Conjecture: every finite connected cubic loopless multigraph decomposes into a spanning tree, a 2-regular subgraph, and a matching. The main ingredient is a new theorem on matching complements in subcubic graphs. Let H be a finite connected
bridgeless simple graph of maximum degree three, and let S be its set of degree-two vertices, with |S| = k >= 2. We show that H has a matching of size equal to its cycle rank, |E(H)| - |V(H)| + 1, whose deletion leaves a single tree containing all of S, together with cycles
disjoint from S. The proof is by induction on k, comparing the matching supplied by the hypothesis with one obtained from an auxiliary cubic tree; a single alternating-path exchange, local and insensitive to the sizes of the two matchings, drives the induction. From this
theorem we deduce, in turn, that every finite connected simple fragile subcubic graph splits into a spanning tree and a matching, the 2-Decomposition Conjecture in its standard loopless-multigraph form, and finally the 3-Decomposition Conjecture.
Complexity of Arc-Decompositions involving Perfect Matchings and Cycle Factors
For two digraph properties $P_1$ and $P_2$, a $(P_1,P_2)$-arc-decomposition of a digraph $D$ is a partition $A(D)=A_1\mathbin{\dot\cup}A_2$ such that the spanning subdigraphs $D[A_1]$ and $D[A_2]$ have properties $P_1$ and $P_2$, respectively. For example, a (strong,strong)-arc-decomposition of a digraph $D=(V,A)$ is a partitioning $A=A_1\cup{}A_2$ of $A$ so that each of the spanning digraphs $D_i=(V,A_i)$, $i=1,2$ are strongly connected. We prove that it is NP-complete to decide whether a digraph admits an arc-decomposition with properties $(P_1,P_2)$ where $(P_1,P_2)\in \{$(is a perfect matching, having no odd directed cycle), (perfect matching, strong), (perfect matching, having an out-branching), (is a cycle factor, having no odd directed cycle)$\}$. These results settle some open problems posed by Bang-Jensen, Bessy, Gonçalves, and Picasarri-Arrieta [Theoret. Comput. Sci. 928 (2022), 167--182].
Hamilton Cycles in 10-Tough $(2P_2 \cup P_1)$-Free Graphs
A graph is called 10-tough and $(2P_2 \cup P_1)$-free if every vertex set whose deletion leaves at least two components has cardinality at least ten times the number of those components and if the graph has no induced subgraph consisting of two disjoint edges and an isolated vertex. We prove that every finite simple 10-tough $(2P_2 \cup P_1)$-free graph on at least three vertices is Hamiltonian. The proof splits according to whether some edge has joint neighbourhood of order at most $4n/11$. In the small-neighbourhood case, a matched path-cover is compressed to a prescribed matching. In the large-neighbourhood case, an asymmetric analysis of the two components left by a putative small cut yields the required connectivity bound. A Hamilton cycle through the prescribed edges is then expanded, and a cycle-extension lemma inserts the remaining vertices.
Main-Factor Constraints on Generalized Cospectral Mates of Trees
We study how irreducible factors associated with main eigenvalues constrain the connected components of generalized cospectral mates. Let $M_G(x):=\prod_{λ {\rm main}}(x-λ)$ be the main polynomial of $G$, where the product is over the distinct main eigenvalues, and write $φ_G(x)=\prod_{i=1}^{r}f_i(x)^{m_i}$, where the $f_i$ are distinct monic irreducible polynomials over $\mathbb Q$. With $I_{\mathrm m}(G) :=\{\,i:f_i\mid M_G\,\}$, define $κ_{\mathrm m}(G):=\sum_{i\in I_{\mathrm m}(G)}m_i$. For a graph $X$, write $c(X)$ and $β(X)$ for its number of connected components and cycle rank, respectively. We prove that every graph $H$ with the same characteristic polynomial and main polynomial as $G$ satisfies $c(H)\leκ_{\mathrm m}(G)$. Consequently, if $T$ is a tree and $H$ is generalized cospectral with $T$, then $β(H)=c(H)-1 \le κ_{\mathrm m}(T)-1$.
We develop the case $κ_{\mathrm m}(T)=2$ further. A disconnected generalized cospectral mate must be the union of a tree and a connected bipartite unicyclic graph, and its two component coronals are uniquely prescribed by the canonical partial-fraction decomposition of the coronal of $T$ with respect to the two irreducible main factors. Consequently, these factor coronals must be realizable as coronals of actual graph components; their Laurent coefficients must therefore be nonnegative integers satisfying low-order walk identities. These realizability conditions, supplemented by matching restrictions on the unicyclic component, yield effective tree-forcing obstructions.
As an application, we show that the double star $D(2m,m+1)$ is determined by its generalized spectrum but not by its adjacency spectrum whenever $m\ge2$ and neither $m$ nor $2m+2$ is a perfect square. In particular, the double stars $D(8t+4,4t+3), t\ge0$, is an explicit infinite family of graphs that are DGS but not DS.
Rigorous Asymptotic Analysis of 3-Noncrossing Skeleton Diagrams
We give a complete rigorous asymptotic analysis of the generating functions of 3-noncrossing skeleton matchings and canonical 3-noncrossing skeleton diagrams. Let $F_3$ be the ordinary generating function of 3-noncrossing matchings, and let $S(y)=\sum_{n\geq 0}S(n)y^n$ be determined by $S(zF_3(z)^2)=F_3(z)$. The proof is deliberately ordered to avoid circularity. First, Lagrange inversion, a Stieltjes representation of $F_3$, exact cut-boundary estimates, and a moving horizontal Hankel contour give $S(n)\sim 24(πA^5)^{-1}σ^{-n}n^{-5}$ independently of any $Δ$-analyticity of $S$. This estimate supplies boundary regularity of $S$ and $S'$. We then prove a global biholomorphic inversion theorem, continuation across every nonprincipal point of the convergence circle, and a logarithmically perturbed sectorial inverse theorem. A complete disk-chain and monodromy argument yields a single-valued continuation to a standard $Δ$-domain. At the principal singularity, $S(y)=Q_4(u)-(πA^5)^{-1}u^4\log u+O(u^5(1+|\log u|))$, where $u=1-y/σ$. Finally, the canonical composition $S_3^{[4]}(z)=(1-z)(S(\vartheta(z))-1-\vartheta(z))$ is shown to be $Δ$-analytic at its unique dominant singularity $η=0.49340718057613087519\ldots$, and $[z^n]S_3^{[4]}(z)\sim 7892.16205625817\ldots n^{-5}η^{-n}$. The argument retains the methods and detailed estimates of the original proofs while closing the analytic gaps in the earlier dissertation treatment.
Longest increasing subsequences of dyadic-type chaotic orbits
This paper studies the longest increasing subsequence (LIS) problem for sequences generated by dyadic-type chaotic interval maps. Starting from a single point $x\in[0,1)$ chosen uniformly at random, we form the order pattern of the first $N$ points of its orbit, with the doubling map as the basic model. Let $λ_1^{(N)}$ be the LIS length, equivalently the length of the first row of the Young diagram obtained by Schensted's insertion. We show that $\mathbb E[λ_1^{(N)}]/\sqrt N\to 2$, matching the leading asymptotics in the classical Ulam--Hammersley problem for uniform random permutations.
Polynomial-time Stable Matching in Network Hypergraphs
We show that there exists a polynomial-time algorithm to find a stable matching in network hypergraphic preference systems. The key connection that drives the algorithm was discovered by chatting with ChatGPT-5.6 Sol Max. We verified it independently and present the details in our own words.
Spanning trees in the Assignment Problem: two theorems and two conjectures
The \emph{Minimum Matching Problem} consists of finding an independent edge set of minimum weight $M_{\star}(G)$ in a given edge-weighted graph $G$. When $G$ is bipartite, this reduces to the \emph{Assignment Problem}. We consider a variant of this problem defined by taking the union of optimal matchings across various slightly modified versions of the base graph: $H_{\mathcal{J}}(G)=\bigcup_{U \in \mathcal{J}} M_{\star}(G_{U})$. We establish two families of results: (1) In two distinct settings for the Assignment Problem, we prove that the resulting graphs $H_{\mathcal{J}}$, as well as certain associated graphs $\bar{H}_{\mathcal{J}}$, are spanning trees on the relevant base graphs $G$ and $\bar{G}$. (2) In these same settings, assuming the edge weights are given by the $p$-th power of Euclidean distances for point configurations in the plane, we show that for $p=1$ the tree $H_{\mathcal{J}}$ is non-crossing (i.e., its planar embedding has no crossing edges), whereas, remarkably, for $p=2$ the associated tree $\bar{H}_{\mathcal{J}}$ is non-crossing. Finally, we introduce novel conjectures in Statistical Mechanics, to be explored in future work: in the Random Euclidean Assignment Problem (where points are i.i.d.\ on a planar domain), we conjecture that for $p=2$ the trees $\bar{H}_{\mathcal{J}}$ are asymptotically distributed as Uniform Spanning Trees with free and wired boundary conditions in the two respective settings. In particular, suitable paths on the tree in the second setting, and on its planar dual in the first setting, are asymptotically distributed as $\text{SLE}_κ$ with $κ=2$.
An Explicit 82-Queen Covering of the 163 x 163 Board and Its Asymptotic Implication
The queen's graph $Q_n$ has the squares of the $n\times n$ chessboard as vertices, with adjacency defined by a common row, column, or diagonal. We give an explicit set of $82$ queens on $Q_{163}$. In centered coordinates, all queen coordinates are odd, every odd row and odd column is occupied exactly once, and the occupied rows, columns, and diagonals satisfy the conditions for a type A $1$-cover in the terminology of Ostergard and Weakley. A direct independent verification checks every one of the $163^2=26{,}569$ board squares and finds none uncovered. Hence $γ(Q_{163})\leq82$. The Finozhenok-Weakley lower bound $γ(Q_n)\geq\lceil n/2\rceil$, valid here, gives the matching inequality and therefore $γ(Q_{163})=82$. For this cover, the parameters defined by Ostergard and Weakley are $e=16$, $f=15$, and $u=24$; the complete difference- and sum-diagonal multisets are displayed in the paper. It consequently also supplies an explicit finite input to their amplification theorem for type A covers, giving $γ(Q_N)\leq(17/33)N+O(1)$. This last coefficient improves both the earlier type A coefficient $69/133$ and the subsequent general coefficient $101/195$ of Burger and Mynhardt. The coordinates and a complete standard-library Python verifier are included.
Domination versus edge domination in regular graphs of degree at least seven
Baste et al. (2020) conjectured that every regular graph of positive degree has domination number at most its edge domination number, the least size of a maximal matching. Combining published bounds settles the inequality for every degree at least nine. A reduction proves the inequality whenever one endpoint of each edge of a minimum maximal matching can be chosen to form a dominating set, and the Lovász Local Lemma shows such a choice exists for every degree at least seven, newly closing degrees seven and eight and leaving degrees three through six open. The reduction settles each open degree up to a bounded number of vertices, forty-eight for cubic graphs. At fifty vertices, however, the reduction meets an explicit cubic graph it cannot settle, though the inequality holds there too. The inequality cannot be tightened, since infinitely many cubic graphs have equal domination and edge domination numbers. The cubic case stays open, and even linear arguments from the local structure cannot close it. The middle degrees stay open beyond the graphs already settled.