arXiv++ Combinatorics

Our main results in this paper are new equidistributions on plane trees and $132$-avoiding permutations, two closely related objects. As for the former, we discover a characteristic for vertices of plane trees that is equally distributed as the height for vertices. The latter is concerned with four distinct ways of decomposing a $132$-avoiding permutation into subsequences. We show combinatorially that the subsequence length distributions of the four decompositions are mutually equivalent, and there is a way to group the four into two groups such that each group is symmetric and the joint length distribution of one group is the same as that of the other. Some consequences are discussed. For instance, we provide a new refinement of the equidistribution of internal vertices and leaves, and present new sets of $132$-avoiding permutations that are counted by the Motzkin numbers and their refinements.

Given a Galton-Watson process conditioned to have total progeny equal to $n$, we study the asymptotic probability that this conditioned Galton-Watson process has distance to the border bigger or equal than $k$, as the number of nodes $n \rightarrow \infty$. A problem which is akin to this one was solved by Rényi and Szekeres for Cayley trees, de Bruijn, Knuth, and Rice for plane trees and Flajolet, Gao, Odlyzko, and Richmond for binary trees. The distance to the border is dual, in a certain sense, to the height. The first of these distances is the minimum of the distances from the root to the leaves. The second is the maximum of the distances from the root to the leaves. These are two extreme complementary cases.

We study the fundamental question of how likely it is that two randomly chosen trees are isomorphic to each other for different models of random trees. We show that the probability decays exponentially for rooted labeled trees as well as for Galton--Watson trees with bounded degrees but that this is not true for plane trees, thus providing a counterexample in the general case of Galton--Watson trees without degree restrictions. We also derive limiting distributions for some related parameters: the number of vertices of given degrees in pairs of labeled trees conditioned on being isomorphic, thus showing that they have a different shape than usual labeled trees, as well as the number of labelings and plane representations of Pólya trees. The results rely on both probabilistic and analytic tools.

A $k$-plane tree is a plane tree whose vertices are assigned labels between $1$ and $k$ in such a way that the sum of the labels along any edge is no greater than $k+1$. These trees are known to be related to $(k+1)$-ary trees, and they are counted by a generalised version of the Catalan numbers. We prove a surprisingly simple refined counting formula, where we count trees with a prescribed number of labels of each kind. Several corollaries are derived from this formula, and an analogous theorem is proven for $k$-noncrossing trees, a similarly defined family of labelled noncrossing trees that are related to $(2k+1)$-ary trees.

The search for universality in random triangulations of manifolds, like those featuring in (Euclidean) Dynamical Triangulations, is central to the random geometry approach to quantum gravity. In case of the 3-sphere, or any other manifold of dimension greater than two for that matter, the pursuit is held back by serious challenges, including the wide open problem of enumerating triangulations. In an attempt to bypass the toughest challenges we identify a restricted family of triangulations, of which the enumeration appears less daunting. In a nutshell, the family consists of triangulated 3-spheres decorated with a pair of trees, one spanning its tetrahedra and the other its vertices, with the requirement that after removal of both trees one is left with a tree-like 2-complex. We prove that these are in bijection with a combinatorial family of triples of plane trees, satisfying restrictions that can be succinctly formulated at the level of planar maps. An important ingredient in the bijection is a step-by-step reconstruction of the triangulations from triples of trees, that results in a natural subset of the so-called locally constructible triangulations, for which spherical topology is guaranteed, through a restriction of the allowed moves. We also provide an alternative characterization of the family in the framework of discrete Morse gradients. Finally, several exponential enumerative bounds are deduced from the triples of trees and some simulation results are presented.

Pondering upon the grammatical labeling of 0-1-2 increasing plane trees, we come to the realization that the grammatical labels play a role as records of chopped off leaves of the original increasing binary trees. While such an understanding is purely psychological, it does give rise to an efficient apparatus to tackle the partial $γ$-positivity of the Eulearian polynomials on multiset Stirling permutations, as long as we bear in mind the combinatorial meanings of the labels $x$ and $y$ in the Gessel representation of a $k$-Stirling permutation by means of an increasing $(k+1)$-ary tree. More precisely, we introduce a Foata-Strehl action on the Gessel trees resulting in an interpretation of the partial $γ$-coefficients of the aforementioned Eulerian polynomials, different from the ones found by Lin-Ma-Zhang and Yan-Huang-Yang. In particular, our strategy can be adapted to deal with the partial $γ$-coefficients of the second order Eulerian polynomials, which in turn can be readily converted to the combinatorial formulation due to Ma-Ma-Yeh in connection with certain statistics of Stirling permutations.

We define two symmetric $q,t$-Catalan polynomials in terms of the area and depth statistic and in terms of the dinv and dinv of depth statistics. We prove symmetry using an involution on plane trees. The same involution proves symmetry of the Tutte polynomials. We also provide a combinatorial proof of a remark by Garsia et al. regarding parking functions and the number of connected graphs on a fixed number of vertices.

We prove that for any fixed $k$, the probability that a random vertex of a random increasing plane tree is of rank $k$, that is, the probability that a random vertex is at distance $k$ from the leaves, converges to a constant $c_k$ as the size $n$ of the tree goes to infinity. {\color{blue} We prove that $1-\sum_{j\le k} c_k<\tfrac{3^{k+1}}{(2k+1)!}$, so that the tail of the limiting rank distribution is super-exponentially narrow. We prove that the latter property holds uniformly for all finite $n$ as well.} More generally, we prove that the ranks of a finite uniformly random set of vertices are asymptotically independent, each with distribution $\{c_k\}$. We compute the exact value of $c_k$ for $0\leq k\leq 3$, demonstrating that the limiting expected fraction of vertices with rank $\le 3$ is $0.9997\dots$. We show that with probability $1-n^{-0.99\eps}$ the highest rank of a vertex in the tree is sandwiched between $(1-\eps)\log n /\log\log n$ and $(1.5+\eps)\log n/\log\log n$, {\color{blue} and that this rank is asymptotic to $\log n/\log\log n$ with probability $1-o(1)$.}

Ma-Ma-Yeh made a beautiful observation that a transformation of the grammar of Dumont instantly leads to the $γ$-positivity of the Eulerian polynomials. We notice that the transformed grammar bears a striking resemblance to the grammar for 0-1-2 increasing trees also due to Dumont. The appearance of the factor of two fits perfectly in a grammatical labeling of 0-1-2 increasing plane trees. Furthermore, the grammatical calculus is instrumental to the computation of the generating functions. This approach can be adapted to study the $e$-positivity of the trivariate second-order Eulerian polynomials first introduced by Dumont in the contexts of ternary trees and Stirling permutations, and independently defined by Janson, in connection with the joint distribution of the numbers of ascents, descents and plateaux over Stirling permutations.

By considering the parity of the degrees and levels of nodes in increasing trees, a new combinatorial interpretation for the coefficients of the Taylor expansions of the Jacobi elliptic functions is found. As one application of this new interpretation, a conjecture of Ma-Mansour-Wang-Yeh is solved. Unifying the concepts of increasing trees and plane trees, Lin-Ma-Ma-Zhou introduced weakly increasing trees on a multiset. A symmetry joint distribution of "even-degree nodes on odd levels" and "odd-degree nodes" on weakly increasing trees is found, extending the Schett polynomials, a generalization of the Jacobi elliptic functions introduced by Schett, to multisets. A combinatorial proof and an algebraic proof of this symmetry are provided, as well as several relevant interesting consequences. Moreover, via introducing a group action on trees, we prove the partial $γ$-positivity of the multiset Schett polynomials, a result implies both the symmetry and the unimodality of these polynomials.

We give two combinatorial proofs of the fact that the number of loopless digraphs on the vertex set $[n]$ with no isolated vertices and with exactly one Eulerian tour up to a cyclic shift is $\frac{1}{2}(n-1)!C_{n}$, where $C_{n}$ denotes the $n$-th Catalan number. We construct a bijection with a set of labeled rooted plane trees and with a set of valid parenthesis arrangements.

We introduce and study cover-inclusive and cover-exclusive Dyck tilings of type $D$. It is shown that the generating functions of Dyck tilings of type $D$ are expressed in terms of the generating function of ballot tilings of type $B$. We introduce link patterns of type $D$ and plane trees for a ballot path, and construct a map from trees to $\mathbb{Z}[q]$. This map gives the generating function of cover-inclusive Dyck tilings of type $D$ associated to the ballot path.

We introduce tools from discrete convexity theory and polyhedral geometry into the theory of West's stack-sorting map $s$. Associated to each permutation $π$ is a particular set $\mathcal V(π)$ of integer compositions that appears in a formula for the fertility of $π$, which is defined to be $|s^{-1}(π)|$. These compositions also feature prominently in more general formulas involving families of colored binary plane trees called troupes and in a formula that converts from free to classical cumulants in noncommutative probability theory. We show that $\mathcal V(π)$ is a transversal discrete polymatroid when it is nonempty. We define the fertilitope of $π$ to be the convex hull of $\mathcal V(π)$, and we prove a surprisingly simple characterization of fertilitopes as nestohedra arising from full binary plane trees. Using known facts about nestohedra, we provide a procedure for describing the structure of the fertilitope of $π$ directly from $π$ using Bousquet-Mélou's notion of the canonical tree of $π$. As a byproduct, we obtain a new combinatorial cumulant conversion formula in terms of generalizations of canonical trees that we call quasicanonical trees. We also apply our results on fertilitopes to study combinatorial properties of the stack-sorting map. In particular, we show that the set of fertility numbers has density $1$, and we determine all infertility numbers of size at most $126$. Finally, we reformulate the conjecture that $\sum_{σ\in s^{-1}(π)}x^{\text{des}(σ)+1}$ is always real-rooted in terms of nestohedra, and we propose natural ways in which this new version of the conjecture could be extended.

The Catalan numbers (C_n)_{n >= 0} = 1,1,2,5,14,42,... form one of the most venerable sequences in combinatorics. They have many combinatorial interpretations, from counting bracketings of products in non-associative algebra to counting plane trees and noncrossing set partitions. They also arise in the GUE matrix model as the leading coefficient of certain polynomials, a connection closely related to the plane trees and noncrossing set partitions interpretations. In this paper we define a generalization of the Catalan numbers. In fact we define an infinite collection of generalizations C_n^(m), m >= 1, with m=1 giving the usual Catalans. The sequence C_n^(m) comes from studying certain matrix models attached to hypergraphs. We also give some combinatorial interpretations of these numbers, and conjecture some asymptotics.

Partial duality is a duality of ribbon graphs relative to a subset of their edges generalizing the classical Euler-Poincare duality. This operation often changes the genus. Recently J.L.Gross, T.Mansour, and T.W.Tucker formulated a conjecture that for any ribbon graph different from plane trees and their partial duals, there is a subset of edges partial duality relative to which does change the genus. A family of counterexamples was found by Qi Yan and Xian'an Jin. In this note we prove that essentially these are the only counterexamples.

We define a class of properties on random plane trees, which we call subtree additive properties, inspired by the combinatorics of certain biologically-interesting properties in a plane tree model of RNA secondary structure. The class of subtree additive properties includes the Wiener index and path length (total ladder distance and total ladder contact distance, respectively, in the biological context). We then investigate the asymptotic distribution of these subtree additive properties on a random plane tree distributed according to a Gibbs distribution arising from the Nearest Neighbor Thermodynamic Model for RNA secondary structure. We show that for any property in the class considered, there is a constant that translates the uniformly weighted random variable to the Gibbs distribution weighted random variable (and we provide the constant). We also relate the asymptotic distribution of another class of properties, which we call simple subtree additive properties, to the asymptotic distribution of the path length, both in the uniformly weighted case. The primary proof techniques in this paper come from analytic combinatorics, and most of our results follow from relating the moments of known and unknown distributions and showing that this is sufficient for convergence.

Bernardi has given a general formula for the number of regions of a deformation of the braid arrangement as a signed sum over boxed trees. We prove that each set of boxed trees which share an underlying (rooted labeled plane) tree contributes 0, +1, or -1 to this sum, and we give an algorithm for computing this value. For Ish-type arrangements, we further construct a sign-reversing involution which reduces Bernardi's signed sum to the enumeration of a set of (rooted labeled plane) trees. We conclude by explicitly enumerating the trees corresponding to the regions of Ish-type arrangements which are nested, recovering their known counting formula.

The number of embeddings of a partially ordered set $S$ in a partially ordered set $T$ is the number of subposets of $T$ isomorphic to $S$. If both, $S$ and $T$, have only one unique maximal element, we define good embeddings as those in which the maximal elements of $S$ and $T$ overlap. We investigate the number of good and all embeddings of a rooted poset $S$ in the family of all binary trees on $n$ elements considering two cases: plane (when the order of descendants matters) and non-plane. Furthermore, we study the number of embeddings of a rooted poset $S$ in the family of all planted plane trees of size $n$. We derive the asymptotic behaviour of good and all embeddings in all cases and we prove that the ratio of good embeddings to all is of the order $Θ(1/\sqrt{n})$ in all cases, where we provide the exact constants. Furthermore, we show that this ratio is non-decreasing with $S$ in the plane binary case and asymptotically non-decreasing with $S$ in the non-plane binary case and in the planted plane case. Finally, we comment on the case when $S$ is disconnected.

Several sequences of free cumulants that count binary plane trees correspond to sequences of classical cumulants that count the decreasing versions of the same trees. Using two new operations on colored binary plane trees that we call insertion and decomposition, we prove that this surprising phenomenon holds for families of trees that we call troupes. We give a simple characterization of troupes, which provide a broad framework for generalizing several of the results known about West's stack-sorting map $s$. Indeed, we give new proofs of some of the main techniques that have been developed for understanding $s$; these new proofs are far more conceptual than the original ones, explain how the objects called valid hook configurations arise naturally, and generalize to troupes. For $t\in\{2,3\}$, we enumerate $t$-stack-sortable alternating permutations of odd length and $t$-stack-sortable permutations whose descents are all peaks. The unexpected connection between troupes and cumulants provides a powerful new tool for analyzing the stack-sorting map that hinges on free probability theory. We give numerous applications of this method. For example, we show that if $σ\in S_{n-1}$ is chosen uniformly at random, then the expected value of $\text{des}(s(σ))+1$ is \[\left(3-\sum_{j=0}^n\frac{1}{j!}\right)n.\] Furthermore, the variance of $\text{des}(s(σ))+1$ is asymptotically $(2+2e-e^2)n$. We obtain similar results concerning the expected number of descents of postorder readings of decreasing colored binary plane trees. We also obtain improved estimates for $|s(S_n)|$ and an improved lower bound for the degree of noninvertibility of $s$. We give two novel formulas that convert from free to classical cumulants. The first is given by a sum over noncrossing partitions, and the second is given by a sum over $231$-avoiding valid hook configurations. We pose several open problems.

We present recent results on the enumeration of $q$-coloured planar maps, where each monochromatic edge carries a weight $ν$. This is equivalent to weighting each map by its Tutte polynomial, or to solving the $q$-state Potts model on random planar maps. The associated generating function, obtained by Olivier Bernardi and the author, is differentially algebraic. That is, it satisfies a (non-linear) differential equation. The starting point of this result is a functional equation written by Tutte in 1971, which translates into enumerative terms a simple recursive description of planar maps. The proof follows and adapts Tutte's solution of properly $q$-coloured triangulations (1973-1984). We put this work in perspective with the much better understood enumeration of families of uncoloured planar maps, for which the recursive approach almost systematically yields algebraic generating functions. In the past 15 years, these algebraicity properties have been explained combinatorially by illuminating bijections between maps and families of plane trees. We survey both approaches, recursive and bijective. Comparing the coloured and uncoloured results raises the question of designing bijections for coloured maps. No complete bijective solution exists at the moment, but we present bijections for certain specialisations of the general problem. We also show that for these specialisations, Tutte's functional equation is much easier to solve that in the general case. We conclude with some open questions.