arXiv++ Combinatorics

We introduce a notion of rainbow saturation and the corresponding rainbow saturation number. This is the saturation version of the rainbow Turán numbers whose systematic study was initiated by Keevash, Mubayi, Sudakov, and Verstraëte. We give examples of graphs for which the rainbow saturation number is bounded away from the ordinary saturation number. This includes all complete graphs $K_n$ for $n\geq 4$, and several bipartite graphs. It is notable that there are non-bipartite graphs for which this is the case, as this does not happen when it comes to the rainbow extremal number versus the traditional extremal number. We also show that saturation numbers are linear for a large class of graphs, providing a partial rainbow analogue of a well known theorem of Kásonyi and Tuza. We conclude this paper with related open questions and conjectures.

A subfamily $\mathcal{G}\subseteq \mathcal{F}\subseteq 2^{[n]}$ of sets is a non-induced (weak) copy of a poset $P$ in $\mathcal{F}$ if there exists a bijection $i:P\rightarrow \mathcal{G}$ such that $p\le_P q$ implies $i(p)\subseteq i(q)$. In the case where in addition $p\le_P q$ holds if and only if $i(p)\subseteq i(q)$, then $\mathcal{G}$ is an induced (strong) copy of $P$ in $\mathcal{F}$. We consider the minimum number $sat(n,P)$ [resp.\ $sat^*(n,P)$] of sets that a family $\mathcal{F}\subseteq 2^{[n]}$ can have without containing a non-induced [induced] copy of $P$ and being maximal with respect to this property, i.e., the addition of any $G\in 2^{[n]}\setminus \mathcal{F}$ creates a non-induced [induced] copy of $P$. We prove for any finite poset $P$ that $sat(n,P)\le 2^{|P|-2}$, a bound independent of the size $n$ of the ground set. For induced copies of $P$, there is a dichotomy: for any poset $P$ either $sat^*(n,P)\le K_P$ for some constant depending only on $P$ or $sat^*(n,P)\ge \log_2 n$. We classify several posets according to this dichotomy, and also show better upper and lower bounds on $sat(n,P)$ and $sat^*(n,P)$ for specific classes of posets. Our main new tool is a special ordering of the sets based on the colexicographic order. It turns out that if $P$ is given, processing the sets in this order and adding the sets greedily into our family whenever this does not ruin non-induced [induced] $P$-freeness, we tend to get a small size non-induced [induced] $P$-saturating family.

Given a finite poset $\mathcal P$, we call a family $\mathcal F$ of subsets of $[n]$ $\mathcal P$-saturated if $\mathcal F$ does not contain an induced copy of $\mathcal P$, but adding any other set to $\mathcal F$ creates an induced copy of $\mathcal P$. The induced saturated number of $\mathcal P$, denoted by $\text{sat}^*(n,\mathcal P)$, is the size of the smallest $\mathcal P$-saturated family with ground set $[n]$. In this paper we are mainly interested in the four-point poset called the butterfly. Ferrara, Kay, Kramer, Martin, Reiniger, Smith and Sullivan showed that the saturation number for the butterfly lies between $\log_2{n}$ and $n^2$. We give a linear lower bound of $n+1$. We also prove some other results about the butterfly and the poset $\mathcal N$.

Given a family of graphs $\mathcal{F}$, a graph $G$ is said to be $\mathcal{F}$-saturated if $G$ does not contain a copy of $F$ as a subgraph for any $F\in\mathcal{F}$ but the addition of any edge $e\notin E(G)$ creates at least one copy of some $F\in\mathcal{F}$ within $G$. The minimum size of an $\mathcal{F}$-saturated graph on $n$ vertices are called the saturation number, denoted by $\sat(n, \mathcal{F})$. Let $\mathcal{C}_{\ge r}$ be the family of cycles of length at least $r$. Ferrara et al. (2012) gave lower and upper bounds of $\sat(n, C_{\ge r})$ and determined the exact values of $\sat(n, C_{\ge r})$ for $3\le r\le 5$. In this paper, we determine the exact value of $\sat(n,\mathcal{C}_{\ge r})$ for $r=6$ and $28\le \frac{n}2\le r\le n$ and give new upper and lower bounds for the other cases.

For impartial games $Γ$ and $Γ'$, the Sprague-Grundy function of the disjunctive sum $Γ+ Γ'$ is equal to the Nim-sum of their Sprague-Grundy functions. In this paper, we introduce $p$-calm subtraction games, and show that for $p$-calm subtraction games $Γ$ and $Γ'$, the Sprague-Grundy function of a $p$-saturation of $Γ+ Γ'$ is equal to the $p$-Nim-sum of the Sprague-Grundy functions of their $p$-saturations. Here a $p$-Nim-sum is the result of addition without carrying in base $p$ and a $p$-saturation of $Γ$ is an impartial game obtained from $Γ$ by adding some moves. It will turn out that Nim and Welter's game are $p$-calm. Further, using the $p$-calmness of Welter's game, we generalize a relation between Welter's game and representations of symmetric groups to disjunctive sums of Welter's games and representations of generalized symmetric groups; this result is described combinatorially in terms of Young diagrams.

A graph $G$ is called $F$-saturated if $G$ does not contain $F$ as a subgraph (not necessarily induced) but the addition of any missing edge to $G$ creates a copy of $F$. The saturation number of $F$, denoted by $sat(n,F)$, is the minimum number of edges in an $n$-vertex $F$-saturated graph. Determining the saturation number of complete partite graphs is one of the most important problems in the study of saturation number. The value of $sat(n,K_{2,2})$ was shown to be $\lfloor\frac{3n-5}{2}\rfloor$ by Ollmann, and a shorter proof was later given by Tuza. For $K_{2,3}$, there has been a series of study aiming to determine $sat(n,K_{2,3})$ over the years. This was finally achieved by Chen who confirmed a conjecture of Bohman, Fonoberova, and Pikhurko that $sat(n, K_{2,3})= 2n-3$ for all $n\geq 5$. In this paper, we prove a conjecture of Pikhurko and Schmitt that $sat(n, K_{3,3})=3n-9$ when $n \geq 9$.

Given a finite poset $\mathcal{P}$, a family $\mathcal{F}$ of elements in the Boolean lattice is induced-$\mathcal{P}$-saturated if $\mathcal{F}$ contains no copy of $\mathcal{P}$ as an induced subposet but every proper superset of $\mathcal{F}$ contains a copy of $\mathcal{P}$ as an induced subposet. The minimum size of an induced-$\mathcal{P}$-saturated family in the $n$-dimensional Boolean lattice, denoted $\operatorname{sat}^*(n,\mathcal{P})$, was first studied by Ferrara et al. (2017). Our work focuses on strengthening lower bounds. For the 4-point poset known as the diamond, we prove $\operatorname{sat}^*(n,\mathcal{D}_2)\geq\sqrt{n}$, improving upon a logarithmic lower bound. For the antichain with $k+1$ elements, we prove $\operatorname{sat}^*(n,\mathcal{A}_{k+1})\geq (1-o_k(1))\frac{kn}{\log_2 k}$, improving upon a lower bound of $3n-1$ for $k\geq 3$.

For a graph $H$, a graph $G$ is $H$-induced-saturated if $G$ does not contain an induced copy of $H$, but either removing an edge from $G$ or adding a non-edge to $G$ creates an induced copy of $H$. Depending on the graph $H$, an $H$-induced-saturated graph does not necessarily exist. In fact, Martin and Smith (2012) showed that $P_4$-induced-saturated graphs do not exist, where $P_k$ denotes a path on $k$ vertices. Axenovich and Csikós (2019) asked the existence of $P_k$-induced-saturated graphs for $k \ge 5$; it is easy to construct such graphs when $k\in\{2, 3\}$. Recently, Räty constructed a graph that is $P_6$-induced-saturated. In this paper, we show that there exists a $P_{k}$-induced-saturated graph for infinitely many values of $k$. To be precise, we find a $P_{3n}$-induced-saturated graph for every positive integer $n$. As a consequence, for each positive integer $n$, we construct infinitely many $P_{3n}$-induced-saturated graphs. We also show that the Kneser graph $K(n,2)$ is $P_6$-induced-saturated for every $n\ge 5$.

Graph-bootstrap percolation, also known as weak saturation, was introduced by Bollobás in 1968. In this process, we start with initial "infected" set of edges $E_0$, and we infect new edges according to a predetermined rule. Given a graph $H$ and a set of previously infected edges $E_t\subseteq E(K_n)$, we infect a non-infected edge $e$ if it completes a new copy of $H$ in $G=([n],E_t\cup e)$. A question raised by Bollobás asks for the maximum time the process can run before it stabilizes. Bollobás, Przykucki, Riordan, and Sahasrabudhe considered this problem for the most natural case where $H=K_r$. They answered the question for $r\leq 4$ and gave a non-trivial lower bound for every $r\geq 5$. They also conjectured that the maximal running time is $o(n^2)$ for every integer $r$. In this paper we disprove their conjecture for every $r\geq 6$ and we give a better lower bound for the case $r=5$; in the proof we use the Behrend construction.

This paper considers two important questions in the well-studied theory of graphs that are $F$-saturated. A graph $G$ is called $F$-saturated if $G$ does not contain a subgraph isomorphic to $F$, but the addition of any edge creates a copy of $F$. We first resolve a fundamental question of minimizing the number of cliques of size $r$ in a $K_s$-saturated graph for all sufficiently large numbers of vertices, confirming a conjecture of Kritschgau, Methuku, Tait, and Timmons. We also go further and prove a corresponding stability result. Next we minimize the number of cycles of length $r$ in a $K_s$-saturated graph for all sufficiently large numbers of vertices, and classify the extremal graphs for most values of $r$, answering another question of Kritschgau, Methuku, Tait, and Timmons for most $r$. We then move on to a central and longstanding conjecture in graph saturation made by Tuza, which states that for every graph $F$, the limit $\lim_{n \rightarrow \infty} \frac{\sat(n, F)}{n}$ exists, where $\sat(n, F)$ denotes the minimum number of edges in an $n$-vertex $F$-saturated graph. Pikhurko made progress in the negative direction by considering families of graphs instead of a single graph, and proved that there exists a graph family $\mathcal{F}$ of size $4$ for which $\lim_{n \rightarrow \infty} \frac{\sat(n, \mathcal{F})}{n}$ does not exist (for a family of graphs $\mathcal{F}$, a graph $G$ is called $\mathcal{F}$-saturated if $G$ does not contain a copy of any graph in $\mathcal{F}$, but the addition of any edge creates a copy of a graph in $\mathcal{F}$, and $\sat(n, \mathcal{F})$ is defined similarly). We make the first improvement in 15 years by showing that there exist infinitely many graph families of size $3$ where this limit does not exist. Our construction also extends to the generalized saturation problem when we minimize the number of fixed-size cliques.

We introduce a notion of doubly warped product of weighted graphs that is consistent with the doubly warped product in the Riemannian setting. We establish various discrete Bakry-Émery Ricci curvature-dimension bounds for such warped products in terms of the curvature of the constituent graphs. This requires deliberate analysis of the quadratic forms involved, prompting the introduction of some crucial notions such as curvature saturation at a vertex. In the spirit of being thorough and to provide a frame of reference, we also introduce the $\left(R_1,R_2\right)$-doubly warped products of smooth measure spaces and establish $\N$-Bakry-Émery Ricci curvature (lower) bounds thereof in terms of those of the factors. At the end of these notes, we present examples and demonstrate applications of warped products with some toy models.

For a fixed graph $F$ and an integer $t$, the \dfn{rainbow saturation number} of $F$, denoted by $sat_t(n,\mathfrak{R}(F))$, is defined as the minimum number of edges in a $t$-edge-colored graph on $n$ vertices which does not contain a \dfn{rainbow copy} of $F$, i.e., a copy of $F$ all of whose edges receive a different color, but the addition of any missing edge in any color from $[t]$ creates such a rainbow copy. Barrus, Ferrara, Vardenbussche and Wenger prove that $sat_t(n,\mathfrak{R}(P_\ell))\ge n-1$ for $\ell\ge 4$ and $sat_t(n,\mathfrak{R}(P_\ell))\le \lceil \frac{n}{\ell-1} \rceil \cdot \binom{\ell-1}{2}$ for $t\ge \binom{\ell-1}{2}$, where $P_\ell$ is a path with $\ell$ edges. In this short note, we improve the upper bounds and show that $sat_t(n,\mathfrak{R}(P_\ell))\le \lceil \frac{n}{\ell} \rceil \cdot \left({{\ell-2}\choose {2}}+4\right)$ for $\ell\ge 5$ and $t\ge 2\ell-5$.

A graph $G$ is called $H$-induced-saturated if $G$ does not contain an induced copy of $H$, but removing any edge from $G$ creates an induced copy of $H$ and adding any edge of $G^{c}$ to $G$ creates an induced copy of $H$. Martin and Smith showed that there does not exist a $P_{4}$-induced-saturated graph, where $P_{4}$ is the path on 4 vertices. Axenovich and Csikós studied related questions, and asked if there exists a $P_{n}$-induced-saturated graph for any $n\geq5$. Our aim in this short note is to show that there exists a $P_{6}$-induced-saturated graph.

Given a graph $G$, we say a $k$-uniform hypergraph $H$ on the same vertex set contains a Berge-$G$ if there exists an injection $φ:E(G)\to E(H)$ such that $e\subseteqφ(e)$ for each edge $e\in E(G)$. A hypergraph $H$ is Berge-$G$-saturated if $H$ does not contain a Berge-$G$, but adding any edge to $H$ creates a Berge-$G$. The saturation number for Berge-$G$, denoted $\mathrm{sat}_k(n,\text{Berge-}G)$ is the least number of edges in a $k$-uniform hypergraph that is Berge-$G$-saturated. We determine exactly the value of the saturation numbers for Berge stars. As a tool for our main result, we also prove the existence of nearly-regular $k$-uniform hypergraphs, or $k$-uniform hypergraphs in which every vertex has degree $r$ or $r-1$ for some $r\in \mathbb{Z}$, and less than $k$ vertices have degree $r-1$.

For a graph G, a hypergraph H is called Berge-G if there is a hypergraph H', isomorphic to H, containing all vertices of G, so that e is contained in f(e) for each edge e of G, where f is a bijection between E(G) and E(H'). The set of all Berge-G hypergraphs is denoted B(G). A hypergraph H is called Berge-G saturated if it does not contain any subhypergraph from B(G), but adding any new hyperedge of size at least 2 to H creates such a subhypergraph. Each Berge-G saturated hypergraph has at least |E(G)|-1 hyperedges. We show that for each graph G that is not a certain star and for any n at least |V(G)|, there is a Berge-G saturated hypergraph on n vertices and exactly |E(G)|-1 hyperedges. This solves a problem of finding a saturated hypergraph on n vertices with the smallest number of edges exactly.

The saturation number of a graph $F$, written $\textup{sat}(n,F)$, is the minimum number of edges in an $n$-vertex $F$-saturated graph. One of the earliest results on saturation numbers is due to Erdős, Hajnal, and Moon who determined $\textup{sat}(n,K_r)$ for all $r \geq 3$. Since then, saturation numbers of various graphs and hypergraphs have been studied. Motivated by Alon and Shikhelman's generalized Turán function, Kritschgau et.\ al.\ defined $\textup{sat}(n,H,F)$ to be the minimum number of copies of $H$ in an $n$-vertex $F$-saturated graph. They proved, among other things, that $\textup{sat}(n,C_3,C_{2k}) = 0$ for all $k \geq 3$ and $n \geq 2k +2$. We extend this result to all odd cycles by proving that for any odd integer $r \geq 5$, $\textup{sat}(n, C_r,C_{2k}) = 0$ for all $2k \geq r+5$ and $n \geq 2kr$.

A graph is $F$-saturated if it is $F$-free but the addition of any edge creates a copy of $F$. In this paper we study the quantity $\mathrm{sat}(n, H, F)$ which denotes the minimum number of copies of $H$ that an $F$-saturated graph on $n$ vertices may contain. This parameter is a natural saturation analogue of Alon and Shikhelman's generalized Turán problem, and letting $H = K_2$ recovers the well-studied saturation function. We provide a first investigation into this general function focusing on the cases where the host graph is either $K_s$ or $C_k$-saturated. Some representative interesting behavior is: (a) For any natural number $m$, there are graphs $H$ and $F$ such that $\mathrm{sat}(n, H, F) = Θ(n^m)$. (b) For many pairs $k$ and $l$, we show $\mathrm{sat}(n, C_l, C_k) = 0$. In particular, we prove that there exists a triangle-free $C_k$-saturated graph on $n$ vertices for any $k > 4$ and large enough $n$. (c) $\mathrm{sat}(n, K_3, K_4) = n-2$, $\mathrm{sat}(n, C_4, K_4) \sim \frac{n^2}{2}$, and $\mathrm{sat}(n, C_6, K_5) \sim n^3$. We discuss several intriguing problems which remain unsolved.

Given graphs $H_1, \dots, H_t$, a graph $G$ is $(H_1, \dots, H_t)$-Ramsey-minimal if every $t$-coloring of the edges of $G$ contains a monochromatic $H_i$ in color $i$ for some $i\in\{1, \dots, t\}$, but any proper subgraph of $G $ does not possess this property. We define $\mathcal{R}_{\min}(H_1, \dots, H_t)$ to be the family of $(H_1, \dots, H_t)$-Ramsey-minimal graphs. A graph $G$ is \dfn{$\mathcal{R}_{\min}(H_1, \dots, H_t)$-saturated} if no element of $\mathcal{R}_{\min}(H_1, \dots, H_t)$ is a subgraph of $G$, but for any edge $e$ in $\overline{G}$, some element of $\mathcal{R}_{\min}(H_1, \dots, H_t)$ is a subgraph of $G + e$. We define $sat(n, \mathcal{R}_{\min}(H_1, \dots, H_t))$ to be the minimum number of edges over all $\mathcal{R}_{\min}(H_1, \dots, H_t)$-saturated graphs on $n$ vertices. In 1987, Hanson and Toft conjectured that $sat(n, \mathcal{R}_{\min}(K_{k_1}, \dots, K_{k_t}) )= (r - 2)(n - r + 2)+\binom{r - 2}{2} $ for $n \ge r$, where $r=r(K_{k_1}, \dots, K_{k_t})$ is the classical Ramsey number for complete graphs. The first non-trivial case of Hanson and Toft's conjecture for sufficiently large $n$ was setteled in 2011, and is so far the only settled case. Motivated by Hanson and Toft's conjecture, we study the minimum number of edges over all $\mathcal{R}_{\min}(K_3, \mathcal{T}_k)$-saturated graphs on $n$ vertices, where $\mathcal{T}_k$ is the family of all trees on $k$ vertices. We show that for $n \ge 18$, $sat(n, \mathcal{R}_{\min}(K_3, \mathcal{T}_4)) =\lfloor {5n}/{2}\rfloor$. For $k \ge 5$ and $n \ge 2k + (\lceil k/2 \rceil +1) \lceil k/2 \rceil -2$, we obtain an asymptotic bound for $sat(n, \mathcal{R}_{\min}(K_3, \mathcal{T}_k))$.

Given a family of graphs $\mathcal{F}$, we consider the $\mathcal{F}$-saturation game. In this game two players alternate adding edges to an initially empty graph on $n$ vertices, with the only constraint being that neither player can add an edge that creates a subgraph that lies in $\mathcal{F}$. The game ends when no more edges can be added to the graph. One of the players wishes to end the game as quickly as possible, while the other wishes to prolong the game. We let $sat_g(\mathcal{F};n)$ denote the number of edges that are in the final graph when both players play optimally. The $\{C_3\}$-saturation game was the first saturation game to be considered, but as of now the order of magnitude of $sat_g(\{C_3\},n)$ remains unknown. We consider a generalization of this game. Let $\mathcal{C}_{2k+1}:=\{C_3,\ C_5,\ldots,C_{2k+1}\}$. We prove that $sat_g(\mathcal{C}_{2k+1};n)\ge(\frac{1}{4}-ε_k)n^2+o(n^2)$ for all $k\ge 2$ and that $sat_g(\mathcal{C}_{2k+1};n)\le (\frac{1}{4}-ε'_k)n^2+o(n^2)$ for all $k\ge 4$, with $ε_k<\frac{1}{4}$ and $ε'_k>0$ constants tending to 0 as $k\to \infty$. In addition to this we prove $sat_g(\{C_{2k+1}\};n)\le \frac{4}{27}n^2+o(n^2)$ for all $k\ge 2$, and $sat_g(\mathcal{C}_\infty\setminus C_3;n)\le 2n-2$, where $\mathcal{C}_\infty$ denotes the set of all odd cycles.

The saturation number of a graph is the cardinality of a smallest maximal matching. This paper presents bounds for the saturation number of carbon nanocones which are asymptotically equal. The same techniques are applied for the saturation number of certain families of carbon nanotubes, which improve previous results and in one case, yields the exact value.