arXiv++ Combinatorics

We study uniformly random lozenge tilings of general simply connected polygons. Under a technical assumption that is presumably generic with respect to polygon shapes, we show that the local statistics around a cusp point of the arctic curve converge to the Pearcey process. This verifies the widely predicted universality of edge statistics in the cusp case. Together with the smooth and tangent cases proved in Aggarwal-Huang and Aggarwal-Gorin, these are believed to be the three types of edge statistics that can arise in a generic polygon. Our proof is via a local coupling of the random tiling with non-intersecting Bernoulli random walks (NBRW). To leverage this coupling, we establish an optimal concentration estimate for the tiling height function around the cusp. As another step and also a result of potential independent interest, we show that the local statistics of NBRW around a cusp converge to the Pearcey process when the initial configuration consists of two parts with proper density growth, via careful asymptotic analysis of the determinantal formula.

We determine the Gromov--Hausdorff--Prokhorov scaling limits and local limits of Kemp's $d$-dimensional binary trees and other models of supertrees. The limits exhibit a root vertex with infinite degree and are constructed by rescaling infinitely many independent stable trees or other spaces according to a function of a two-parameter Poisson--Dirichlet process and gluing them together at their roots. We discuss universality aspects of random spaces constructed in this fashion and sketch a phase diagram.

The work of Vershik and Kerov [1977], Logan and Shepp [1977] established that the shape of the scaled random young diagram in Russian notation, as determined by the Plancherel measure, converges to a deterministic shape. In this article, we focus on the scenario where the number of fixed points is substantial. We provide evidence that, subject to specific requirements on the total number of cycles, the limiting shape is a scaled version of the Vershik-Kerov-Logan-Shepp limiting shape. Additionally, we identify certain limiting regimes that resemble those in Chapuy, Louf, and Walsh [2022]. Furthermore, we enhance the existing results on Tracy-Widom universality classes for $β\in \{ 1, 2, 4\}$ for monotone subsequences.

We consider $h$-stable local optima of Ising spin glass models, defined as spin configurations such that for nearly all of the spins, flipping their values results in increasing energy by at least a given amount $h$. Spins satisfying this condition are referred to as $h$-stable spins for that configuration. Similarly, we consider a very related notion of $h$-friendly partitions of a graph. These are defined as bi-partitionings such that for most nodes, the normalized number of neighbors within the node's partition exceed the normalized number of neighbors outside the partition by a certain amount $h$. For spin glasses as well as sparse and dense random graphs, while restricting to bisections, we prove the existence of a phase transition for the normalized energy level $h$ around a universal value $h^*$. For $h$ below the phase transition value $h^*$, bisections exist where the number of spins (nodes) which are not $h$-stable (not $h$-friendly) is sublinear. Above the phase transition level $h^*$ the smallest number of spins that are not $h$-stable (not $h$-friendly) is linear. This confirms a conjecture from Behrens et al. (2022). Our results also allow the characterization of possible energy values of stable local optima for varying $h$. In particular, for $h=0$, this rigorously proves seminal results in statistical physics regarding the so-called metastable states, such as in the work of Bray and Moore (1981). Our results extend a recent proof of the so-called Friendly Partition Conjecture in Ferber et al. (2022) from the case $h=0$ to the case when $h$ takes general values. Our proofs are obtained by analyzing the model on sparse random graphs and adopting Lindeberg's type universality method to lift the results from sparse to dense graphs and spin systems.

We consider the statistics of extreme eigenvalues of random $d$-regular graphs, with $N^{\mathfrak c}\leq d\leq N^{1/3-{\mathfrak c}}$ for arbitrarily small ${\mathfrak c}>0$. We prove that in this regime, the fluctuations of extreme eigenvalues are given by the Tracy-Widom distribution. As a consequence, about 69% of $d$-regular graphs have all nontrivial eigenvalues bounded in absolute value by $2\sqrt{d-1}$.

Bidirected graphs are multigraphs where every edge has an independent direction at each end. In the paper, with an arbitrary bidirected graph we associate a non-negative integral quadratic form (called the incidence form of the graph), and determine all forms that appear in this way in two main results: first, among non-negative connected unit forms, precisely those of Dynkin type $\mathbb{A}$ or $\mathbb{D}$ are incidence forms; second, we give simple conditions on the coefficients of a non-negative connected non-unitary form to be an incidence form. We say that those non-unitary forms have Dynkin type $\mathbb{C}$, and justify such nomenclature by generalizing known classifications and properties of non-negative quadratic forms of Dynkin types $\mathbb{A}$ and $\mathbb{D}$ to the introduced type~$\mathbb{C}$. We also show that the graphical framework of an incidence form is an useful tool to visualize its arithmetical properties, to prove new facts and to perform efficient computations for integral quadratic forms and related problems in number theory, algebra and graph theory. For instance, in a third main result we relate the walks of a bidirected graph with the $0,1,2$-roots of the associated incidence form (and to the classical root systems in the positive case). Moreover, we prove the universality property for a large class of integral quadratic forms, provide computational methods to find solutions or to characterize the finiteness of the sets of solutions of various related Diophantine equations, show a variant of Whitney's theorem on line graphs using switching classes, and apply our techniques to give a conceptual and constructive proof of the non-negativity (and possible Dynkin types) of the Euler quadratic forms of a class of finite-dimensional gentle algebras.

This paper establishes universal formulas describing the global asymptotics of two distinct discrete versions of $β$-ensembles in the high, low and fixed temperature regimes. Our results affirmatively answer a question posed by the second author and Śniady. We first introduce a special class of Jack measures on Young diagrams of arbitrary size, called the ``Jack--Thoma measures'', and prove the LLN and CLT in the three aforementioned limit regimes. In each case, we provide explicit formulas for polynomial observables of the limit shape and Gaussian fluctuations around the limit shape. These formulas have surprising positivity properties and are expressed as sums of weighted lattice paths. Second, we show that the previous formulas are universal: they also describe the limit shape and Gaussian fluctuations for the model of random Young diagrams of a fixed size derived from Jack characters with the approximate factorization property. Finally, in stark contrast with continuous $β$-ensembles, we show that the limit shapes at high and low temperatures of our random Young diagrams are one-sided infinite staircase shapes. For the Jack--Plancherel measure, we describe this shape explicitly by relating its local minima with the zeroes of Bessel functions.

Let $N$ be the number of copies of a small subgraph $H$ in an Erdős-Rényi graph $G \sim \mathcal{G}(n, p_n)$ where $p_n \to 0$ is chosen so that $\mathbb{E} N = c$, a constant. Results of Bollobás show that for regular graphs $H$, the count $N$ weakly converges to a Poisson random variable. For large but finite $n$, and for the specific case of the triangle, investigations of the upper tail $\mathbb{P}(N \geq k_n)$ by Ganguly, Hiesmayr and Nam (2022) revealed that there is a phase transition in the tail behavior and the associated mechanism. Smaller values of $k_n$ correspond to disjoint occurrences of $H$, leading to Poisson tails, with a different behavior emerging when $k_n$ is large, guided by the appearance of an almost clique. We show that a similar phase transition also occurs when $H$ is any regular graph, at the point where $k_n^{1 -2/q}\log k_n = \log n$ ($q$ is the number of vertices in $H$). This establishes universality of this transition, previously known only for the case of the triangle.

We develop a simple and generic method to analyze randomized rumor spreading processes in fully connected networks. In contrast to all previous works, which heavily exploit the precise definition of the process under investigation, we only need to understand the probability and the covariance of the events that uninformed nodes become informed. This universality allows us to easily analyze the classic push, pull, and push-pull protocols both in their pure version and in several variations such as messages failing with constant probability or nodes calling a random number of others each round. Some dynamic models can be analyzed as well, e.g., when the network is a $G(n,p)$ random graph sampled independently each round [Clementi et al. (ESA 2013)]. Despite this generality, our method determines the expected rumor spreading time precisely apart from additive constants, which is more precise than almost all previous works. We also prove tail bounds showing that a deviation from the expectation by more than an additive number of $r$ rounds occurs with probability at most $\exp(-Ω(r))$. We further use our method to discuss the common assumption that nodes can answer any number of incoming calls. We observe that the restriction that only one call can be answered leads to a significant increase of the runtime of the push-pull protocol. In particular, the double logarithmic end phase of the process now takes logarithmic time. This also increases the message complexity from the asymptotically optimal $Θ(n \log\log n)$ [Karp, Shenker, Schindelhauer, Vöcking (FOCS 2000)] to $Θ(n \log n)$. We propose a simple variation of the push-pull protocol that reverts back to the double logarithmic end phase and thus to the $Θ(n \log\log n)$ message complexity.

We develop a general universality technique for establishing metric scaling limits of critical random discrete structures exhibiting mean-field behavior that requires four ingredients: (i) from the barely subcritical regime to the critical window, components merge approximately like the multiplicative coalescent, (ii) asymptotics of the susceptibility functions are the same as that of the Erdos-Renyi random graph, (iii) asymptotic negligibility of the maximal component size and the diameter in the barely subcritical regime, and (iv) macroscopic averaging of distances between vertices in the barely subcritical regime. As an application of the general universality theorem, we establish, under some regularity conditions, the critical percolation scaling limit of graphs that converge, in a suitable topology, to an $L^3$ graphon. In particular, we define a notion of the critical window in this setting. The $L^3$ assumption ensures that the model is in the Erdos-Renyi universality class and that the scaling limit is Brownian. Our results do not assume any specific functional form for the graphon. As a consequence of our results on graphons, we obtain the metric scaling limit for Aldous-Pittel's RGIV model [9] inside the critical window. Our universality principle has applications in a number of other problems including in the study of noise sensitivity of critical random graphs [52]. In [10], we use our universality theorem to establish the metric scaling limit of critical bounded size rules. Our method should yield the critical metric scaling limit of Rucinski and Wormald's random graph process with degree restrictions [56] provided an additional technical condition about the barely subcritical behavior of this model can be proved.

The main goal of this paper is to investigate the minimal size of families of curves on surfaces with the following property: a family of simple closed curves $Γ$ on a surface realizes all types of pants decompositions if for any pants decomposition of the surface, there exists a homeomorphism sending it to a subset of the curves in $Γ$. The study of such universal families of curves is motivated by questions on graph embeddings, joint crossing numbers and finding an elusive center of moduli space. In the case of surfaces without punctures, we provide an exponential upper bound and a superlinear lower bound on the minimal size of a family of curves that realizes all types of pants decompositions. We also provide upper and lower bounds in the case of surfaces with punctures which we can consider labelled or unlabelled, and investigate a similar concept of universality for triangulations of polygons, where we provide bounds which are tight up to logarithmic factors.

We consider the probability theory, and in particular the moment problem and universality theorems, for random groups of the sort of that arise or are conjectured to arise in number theory, and in related situations in topology and combinatorics. The distributions of random groups that are discussed include those conjectured in the Cohen-Lenstra-Martinet heuristics to be the distributions of class groups of random number fields, as well as distributions of non-abelian generalizations, and those conjectured to be the distributions of Selmer groups of random elliptic curves. For these sorts of distributions on finite and profinite groups, we survey what is known about the moment problem and universality, give a few new results including new applications, and suggest open problems.

The paper surveys recent progress in understanding geometric, topological and combinatorial properties of large simplicial complexes, focusing mainly on ampleness, connectivity and universality. In the first part of the paper we concentrate on $r$-ample simplicial complexes which are high dimensional analogues of the $r$-e.c. graphs introduced originally by Erd\H os and Réniy. The class of $r$-ample complexes is useful for applications since these complexes allow extensions of subcomplexes of certain type in all possible ways; besides, $r$-ample complexes exhibit remarkable robustness properties. We discuss results about the existence of $r$-ample complexes and describe their probabilistic and deterministic constructions. The properties of random simplicial complexes in medial regime are important for this discussion since these complexes are ample, in certain range. We prove that the topological complexity of a random simplicial complex in the medial regime satisfies ${\sf TC}(X)\le 4$, with probability tending to $1$ as $n\to\infty$. There exists a unique (up to isomorphism) $\infty$-ample complex on countable set of vertexes (the Rado complex), and the second part of the paper surveys the results about universality, homogeneity, indestructibility and other important properties of this complex. The Appendix written by J.A. Barmak discusses connectivity of conic and ample complexes.

This manuscript recounts some of the author's contributions to algebraic and enumerative combinatorics. We have focused on two types of generalizations of bipartite maps, which are bipartite graphs embedded on surfaces. Maps are known to appear in many areas of theoretical physics and discrete mathematics, but one key interest for fundamental computer science is how multi-facetted they are in the sense that multiple encodings exist which are not interchangeable, like Tutte's/loop equations, the topological recursion, the KP hierarchy and numerous bijections which made the field so rich. One generalization we considered is weighted Hurwitz numbers, including constellations, monotone Hurwitz numbers and the unoriented versions of Chapuy-Dołęga. We have investigated whether some universal structures of maps lift to weighted Hurwitz numbers, such that the topological recursion (it does, for oriented, double, weighted Hurwitz numbers), and the passage from the KP to the BKP hierarchy for some unoriented weighted Hurwitz numbers (like monotone ones). The other generalization of bipartite maps we considered is colored triangulations in dimensions three and higher. They provide a nice meeting ground for topology and combinatorics, where universality classes above dimension 2 can be investigated. In particular, we found that the gluings of 3-balls which maximize the number of edges at fixed number of tetrahedra are in bijection with trees. In even dimensions however, we found that more universality classes can be reached depending on the choice of building blocks. We also wondered whether some of the universal structures featured by maps lift to higher dimensions. In particular, we proved instances of the scheme decomposition in three-dimensional models and maps decorated with crossing loops, and we proved the blobbed topological recursion with only mild assumptions.

We prove that every toric monoid appears in a space of maps from tropical curves to an orthant. It follows that spaces of logarithmic maps to Artin fans exhibit arbitrary toric singularities: a virtual universality theorem for logarithmic maps to pairs. The target rank depends on the chosen singularity: we show that the cone over the 7-gon never appears in a space of maps to a rank 1 target. We obtain similar results for tropical maps to affine space.

We prove asymptotically optimal bounds on the number of edges a graph $G$ must have in order that any $r$-colouring of $E(G)$ has a colour class which contains every $D$-degenerate graph on $n$ vertices with bounded maximum degree. We also improve the upper bounds on the number of edges $G$ must have in order that any $r$-colouring of $E(G)$ has a colour class which contains every $n$-vertex graph with maximum degree $Δ$, for each $Δ\ge 4$. In both cases, we show that a binomial random graph with $Cn$ vertices and a suitable edge probability is likely to provide the desired $G$.

In combinatory logic it is known that the set of two combinators K and S are universal; in the sense that any other combinator can be expressed in terms of these two. K combinator can not be expressed only in terms of the S combinator. This will answer a question raised by Stephen Wolfram as ``Is the S combinator on its own computation universal?''

In this paper we study the cokernels of various random integral matrix models, including random symmetric, random skew-symmetric, and random Laplacian matrices. We provide a systematic method to establish universality under very general randomness assumption. Our highlights include both local and global universality of the cokernel statistics of all these models. In particular, we find the probability that a sandpile group of an Erdos-Renyi random graph is cyclic, answering a question of Lorenzini from 2008.

We show that every commutative idempotent monoid (a.k.a lattice) is the endomorphism monoid of a subcubic graph. This solves a problem of Babai and Pultr [J. Comb.~Theory, Ser.~B, 1980] and the degree bound is best-possible. On the other hand, we show that no class excluding a minor can have all commutative idempotent monoids among its endomorphism monoids. As a by-product we prove that monoids can be represented by graphs of bounded expansion (reproving a result of Nešetřil and Ossona de Mendez) and $k$-cancellative monoids can be represented by graphs of bounded degree. Finally, we show that not all completely regular monoids can be represented by graphs excluding topological minor (strengthening a result of Babai and Pultr).

For random integer matrices $M_1,\ldots,M_k \in \operatorname{Mat}_n(\mathbb{Z})$ with independent entries, we study the distribution of the cokernel $\operatorname{cok}(M_1 \cdots M_k)$ of their product. We show that this distribution converges to a universal one as $n \to \infty$ for a general class of matrix entry distributions, and more generally show universal limits for the joint distribution of $\operatorname{cok}(M_1),\operatorname{cok}(M_1M_2),\ldots,\operatorname{cok}(M_1 \cdots M_k)$. Furthermore, we characterize the universal distributions arising as marginals of a natural generalization of the Cohen-Lenstra measure to sequences of abelian groups with maps between them, which weights sequences inversely proportionally to their number of automorphisms. The proofs develop an extension of the moment method of Wood to joint moments of multiple groups, and rely also on the connection to Hall-Littlewood polynomials and symmetric function identities. As a corollary we obtain an explicit universal distribution for coranks of random matrix products over $\mathbb{F}_p$ as the matrix size tends to infinity.