arXiv++ Combinatorics

In this note, we provide three new, very short proofs of two interesting congruences for Merca's partition function $a(n)$, which enumerates integer partitions where the odd parts have multiplicity at most 2. These modulo 2 congruences were first shown elementarily by Sellers. We then frame $a(n)$ into the much broader context of eta-quotients, and suggest how to comprehensively describe its parity behavior. In particular, extensive computations suggest that $a(n)$ is odd precisely 25\% of the time.

We continue a series of papers studying the parity of families of eta-quotients, which provide implications for the parity of the partition function as well as an overarching conjecture on related $q$-series. The present article focuses on two classes. One consists of eta-quotients of the form $f_t^3/f_1$, a distinguished case of Andrews' singular overpartitions that has recently attracted attention among researchers. In addition, we investigate the parity of certain pure eta-powers $f_1^t$, appending new results to known density theorems.

The pure $O$-sequences of the form $(1,a,a,\ldots)$ are classified.

We continue our study of the density of the odd values of eta-quotients, here focusing on the $m$-regular partition functions $b_m$ for $m$ even. Based on extensive computational evidence, we propose an elegant conjecture which, in particular, completely classifies such densities: Let $m = 2^j m_0$ with $m_0$ odd. If $2^j < m_0$, then the odd density of $b_m$ is $1/2$; moreover, such density is equal to $1/2$ on every (nonconstant) subprogression $An+B$. If $2^j > m_0$, then $b_m$, which is already known to have density zero, is identically even on infinitely many non-nested subprogressions. This and all other conjectures of this paper are consistent with our ''master conjecture'' on eta-quotients presented in the previous work. In general, our results on $b_m$ for $m$ even determine behaviors considerably different from the case of $m$ odd. Also interesting, it frequently happens that on subprogressions $An+B$, $b_m$ matches the parity of the multipartition functions $p_t$, for certain values of $t$. We make a suitable use of Ramanujan-Kolberg identities to deduce a large class of such results; as an example, $b_{28}(49n+12) \equiv p_3(7n+2) \pmod{2}$. Additional consequences are several ''almost always congruences'' for various $b_m$, as well as new parity results specifically for $b_{11}$. We wrap up our work with a much simpler proof of the main result of a recent paper by Cherubini-Mercuri, which fully characterized the parity of $b_8$.

We investigate log-concavity in the context of level Hilbert functions and pure $O$-sequences, two classes of numerical sequences introduced by Stanley in the late Seventies whose structural properties have since been the object of a remarkable amount of interest in combinatorial commutative algebra. However, a systematic study of the log-concavity of these sequences began only recently, thanks to a paper by Iarrobino. The goal of this note is to address two general questions left open by Iarrobino's work: 1) Given the integer pair $(r,t)$, are all level Hilbert functions of codimension $r$ and type $t$ log-concave? 2) How about pure $O$-sequences with the same parameters? Iarrobino's main results consisted of a positive answer to 1) for $r=2$ and any $t$, and for $(r,t)=(3,1)$. Further, he proved that the answer to 1) is negative for $(r,t)=(4,1)$. Our chief contribution to 1) is to provide a negative answer in all remaining cases, with the exception of $(r,t)=(3,2)$, which is still open in any characteristic. We then propose a few detailed conjectures specifically on level Hilbert functions of codimension 3 and type 2. As for question 2), we show that the answer is positive for all pairs $(r,1)$; negative for $(r,t)=(3,4)$; and negative for any pair $(r,t)$ with $r\ge 4$ and $2\le t\le r+1$. Interestingly, the main case that remains open is again $(r,t)=(3,2)$. Further, we conjecture that, in analogy with the behavior of arbitrary level Hilbert functions, log-concavity fails for pure $O$-sequences of any codimension $r\ge 3$ and type $t$ large enough.

The goal of this note is to provide a general lower bound on the number of even values of the Fourier coefficients of an arbitrary eta-quotient $F$, over any arithmetic progression. Namely, if $g_{a,b}(x)$ denotes the number of even coefficients of $F$ in degrees $n\equiv b$ (mod $a$) such that $n\le x$, then we show that $g_{a,b}(x) / \sqrt{x}$ is unbounded for $x$ large. Note that our result is very close to the best bound currently known even in the special case of the partition function $p(n)$ (namely, $\sqrt{x}\log \log x$, proven by Bellaïche and Nicolas in 2016). Our argument substantially relies upon, and generalizes, Serre's classical theorem on the number of even values of $p(n)$, combined with a recent modular-form result by Cotron \emph{et al.} on the lacunarity modulo 2 of certain eta-quotients. Interestingly, even in the case of $p(n)$ first shown by Serre, no elementary proof is known of this bound. At the end, we propose an elegant problem on quadratic representations, whose solution would finally yield a modular form-free proof of Serre's theorem.

A famous conjecture of Parkin-Shanks predicts that $p(n)$ is odd with density $1/2$. Despite the remarkable amount of work of the last several decades, however, even showing this density is positive seems out of reach. In a 2018 paper with Judge, we introduced a different approach and conjectured the "striking" fact that, if for any $A \equiv \pm 1\ (\bmod 6)$ the multipartition function $p_A(n)$ has positive odd density, then so does $p(n)$. Similarly, the positive odd density of any $p_{A}(n)$ with $A\equiv 3\ (\bmod 6)$ would imply that of $p_3(n)$. Our conjecture was shown to be a corollary of an earlier conjecture of the same paper. In this brief note, we provide an unconditional proof of it. An important tool will be Chen's recent breakthrough on a special case of our earlier conjecture.

We investigate the parity of the coefficients of certain eta-quotients, extensively examining the case of $m$-regular partitions. Our theorems concern the density of their odd values, in particular establishing lacunarity modulo 2 for specified coefficients; self-similarities modulo 2; and infinite families of congruences in arithmetic progressions. For all $m \leq 28$, we either establish new results of these types where none were known, extend previous ones, or conjecture that such results are impossible. All of our work is consistent with a new, overarching conjecture that we present for arbitrary eta-quotients, greatly extending Parkin-Shanks' classical conjecture for the partition function. We pose several other open questions throughout the paper, and conclude by suggesting a list of specific research directions for future investigations in this area.

Recently, Hirschhorn and the first author considered the parity of the function $a(n)$ which counts the number of integer partitions of $n$ wherein each part appears with odd multiplicity. They derived an effective characterization of the parity of $a(2m)$ based solely on properties of $m.$ In this note, we quickly reprove their result, and then extend it to an explicit characterization of the parity of $a(n)$ for all $n\not\equiv 7 \pmod{8}.$ We also exhibit some infinite families of congruences modulo 2 which follow from these characterizations. We conclude by discussing the case $n\equiv 7 \pmod{8}$, where, interestingly, the behavior of $a(n)$ modulo 2 appears to be entirely different. In particular, we conjecture that, asymptotically, $a(8m+7)$ is odd precisely $50\%$ of the time. This conjecture, whose broad generalization to the context of eta-quotients will be the topic of a subsequent paper, remains wide open.

We look at the number $L(n)$ of $O$-sequences of length $n$. Recall that an $O$-sequence can be defined algebraically as the Hilbert function of a standard graded $k$-algebra, or combinatorially as the $f$-vector of a multicomplex. The sequence $L(n)$ was first investigated in a recent paper by commutative algebraists Enkosky and Stone, inspired by Huneke. In this note, we significantly improve both of their upper and lower bounds, by means of a very short partition-theoretic argument. In particular, it turns out that, for suitable positive constants $c_1$ and $c_2$ and all $n>2$, $$e^{c_1\sqrt{n}}\le L(n)\le e^{c_2\sqrt{n}\log n}.$$ It remains an open problem to determine an exact asymptotic estimate for $L(n)$.

Roughly ten years ago, the following "Gorenstein Interval Conjecture" (GIC) was proposed: Whenever $(1,h_1,\dots,h_i,\dots,h_{e-i},\dots,h_{e-1},1)$ and $(1,h_1,\dots,h_i+α,\dots,h_{e-i}+α,\dots,h_{e-1},1)$ are both Gorenstein Hilbert functions for some $α\geq 2$, then $(1,h_1,\dots,h_i+β,\dots,h_{e-i}+β,\dots,h_{e-1},1)$ is also Gorenstein, for all $β=1,2,\dots,α-1$. Since an explicit characterization of which Hilbert functions are Gorenstein is widely believed to be hopeless, the GIC, if true, would at least provide the existence of a strong, and very natural, structural property for such basic functions in commutative algebra. Before now, very little progress was made on the GIC. The main goal of this note is to prove the case $e\le 5$, in arbitrary codimension. Our arguments will be in part constructive, and will combine several different tools of commutative algebra and classical algebraic geometry.

An interesting, and still wide open, conjecture of Reiner and Stanton predicts that certain "strange" symmetric differences of $q$-binomial coefficients are always nonnegative and unimodal. We extend their conjecture to a broader, and perhaps more natural, framework, by conjecturing that, for each $k\ge 5$, the polynomials $$f(k,m,b)(q)=\binom{m}{k}_q-q^{\frac{k(m-b)}{2}+b-2k+2}\cdot\binom{b}{k-2}_q$$ are nonnegative and unimodal for all $m\gg_k 0$ and $b\le \frac{km-4k+4}{k-2}$ such that $kb\equiv km$ (mod 2), with the only exception of $b=\frac{km-4k+2}{k-2}$ when this is an integer. Using the KOH theorem, we combinatorially show the case $k=5$. In fact, we completely characterize the nonnegativity and unimodality of $f(k,m,b)$ for $k\le 5$. (This also provides an isolated counterexample to Reiner-Stanton's conjecture when $k=3$.) Further, we prove that, for each $k$ and $m$, it suffices to show our conjecture for the largest $2k-6$ values of $b$.

We continue our study of a basic but seemingly intractable problem in integer partition theory, namely the conjecture that $p(n)$ is odd exactly $50\%$ of the time. Here, we greatly extend on our previous paper by providing a doubly-indexed, infinite framework of conjectural identities modulo 2, and show how to, in principle, prove each such identity. However, our conjecture remains open in full generality. A striking consequence is that, under suitable existence conditions, if any $t$-multipartition function is odd with positive density and $t\not \equiv 0$ (mod 3), then $p(n)$ is also odd with positive density. These are all facts that appear virtually impossible to show unconditionally today. Our arguments employ a combination of algebraic and analytic methods, including certain technical tools recently developed by Radu in his study of the parity of the Fourier coefficients of modular forms.

F. Bergeron recently asked the intriguing question whether $\binom{b+c}{b}_q -\binom{a+d}{d}_q$ has nonnegative coefficients as a polynomial in $q$, whenever $a,b,c,d$ are positive integers, $a$ is the smallest, and $ad=bc$. We conjecture that, in fact, this polynomial is also always unimodal, and combinatorially show our conjecture for $a\le 3$ and any $b,c\ge 4$. The main ingredient will be a novel (and rather technical) application of Zeilberger's KOH theorem.

The study of the $h$-vectors of graded Gorenstein algebras is an important topic in combinatorial commutative algebra, which despite the large amount of literature produced during the last several years, still presents many interesting open questions. In this note, we commence a study of those unimodal Gorenstein $h$-vectors that do \emph{not} satisfy the Stanley-Iarrobino property. Our main results, which are characteristic free, show that such $h$-vectors exist: 1) In socle degree $e$ if and only if $e\ge 6$; and 2) In every codimension five or greater. The main case that remains open is that of codimension four, where no Gorenstein $h$-vector is known without the Stanley-Iarrobino property. We conclude by proposing the following very general conjecture: The existence of any arbitrary level $h$-vector is \emph{independent} of the characteristic of the base field.

We classify all possible $h$-vectors of graded artinian Gorenstein algebras in socle degree 4 and codimension $\leq 17$, and in socle degree 5 and codimension $\leq 25$. We obtain as a consequence that the least number of variables allowing the existence of a nonunimodal Gorenstein $h$-vector is 13 for socle degree 4, and 17 for socle degree 5. In particular, the smallest nonunimodal Gorenstein $h$-vector is $(1,13,12,13,1)$, which was constructed by Stanley in his 1978 seminal paper on level algebras. This solves a long-standing open question in this area. All of our results are characteristic free.

The purpose of this note is to introduce a new approach to the study of one of the most basic and seemingly intractable problems in partition theory, namely the conjecture that the partition function $p(n)$ is equidistributed modulo 2. Our main result will relate the densities, say $δ_t$, of the odd values of the $t$-multipartition functions $p_t(n)$, for several integers $t$. In particular, we will show that if $δ_t>0$ for some $t\in \{5,7,11,13,17,19,23,25\}$, then (assuming it exists) $δ_1>0$; that is, $p(n)$ itself is odd with positive density. Notice that, currently, the best unconditional result does not even imply that $p(n)$ is odd for $\sqrt{x}$ values of $n\le x$. In general, we conjecture that $δ_t=1/2$ for all $t$ odd, i.e., that similarly to the case of $p(n)$, all multipartition functions are in fact equidistributed modulo 2. Our arguments will employ a number of algebraic and analytic methods, ranging from an investigation modulo 2 of some classical Ramanujan identities and several other eta product results, to a unified approach that studies the parity of the Fourier coefficients of a broad class of modular form identities recently introduced by Radu.

We look at the asymptotic behavior of the coefficients of the $q$-binomial coefficients (or Gaussian polynomials) $\binom{a+k}{k}_q$, when $k$ is fixed. We give a number of results in this direction, some of which involve Eulerian polynomials and their generalizations.

A finite projective plane, or more generally a finite linear space, has an associated incidence complex that gives rise to two natural algebras: the Stanley-Reisner ring $R/I_Λ$ and the inverse system algebra $R/I_Δ$. We give a careful study of both of these algebras. Our main results are a full description of the graded Betti numbers of both algebras in the more general setting of linear spaces (giving the result for the projective planes as a special case), and a classification of the characteristics in which the inverse system algebra associated to a finite projective plane has the Weak or Strong Lefschetz Property.

In this note, using entirely algebraic or elementary methods, we determine a new asymptotic lower bound for the number of odd values of one of the most important modular functions in number theory, the Klein $j$-function. Namely, we show that the number of integers $n\le x$ such that the Klein $j$-function --- or equivalently, the cubic partition function --- is odd is at least of the order of $$\frac{\sqrt{x} \log \log x}{\log x},$$ for $x$ large. This improves recent results of Berndt-Yee-Zaharescu and Chen-Lin, and approaches significantly the best lower bound currently known for the ordinary partition function, obtained using the theory of modular forms. Unlike many works in this area, our techniques to show the above result, that have in part been inspired by some recent ideas of P. Monsky on quadratic representations, do not involve the use of modular forms. Then, in the second part of the article, we show how to employ modular forms in order to slightly refine our bound. In fact, our brief argument, which combines a recent result of J.-L. Nicolas and J.-P. Serre with a classical theorem of J.-P. Serre on the asymptotics of the Fourier coefficients of certain level 1 modular forms, will more generally apply to provide a lower bound for the number of odd values of any positive power of the generating function of the partition function.