arXiv++ Combinatorics

The purpose of this work is to build a framework that allows for an in-depth study of various generalisations to inhomogeneous space of models of Borodin-Ferrari, Dieker-Warren, Nordenstam, Warren-Windridge of interacting particles in interlacing arrays, both in discrete and continuous time, involving both Bernoulli and geometric jumps. The models can in addition be either time-inhomogeneous or particle-inhomogeneous. We show that the correlation functions of these models are determinantal and using this we prove a short-time asymptotic for these dynamics to the discrete Bessel point process. We moreover prove a number of closely related results. We prove that the autonomous, inhomogeneous in space and time, TASEP-like and pushTASEP-like particle systems on the edges of the array have explicit transition kernels and that from any deterministic initial condition their distributions are marginals of a determinantal measure. We prove a novel duality relation between dynamics in inhomogeneous space and dynamics with inhomogeneities on the level of the array. We extend the work of Nordenstam on the shuffling algorithm for domino tilings of the Aztec diamond and its relation to push-block dynamics in interlacing arrays to general weights on the tilings and then connect this, for a special class of weights, back to our previous results. We also consider non-intersecting walks in inhomogeneous space and time with fixed starting and end points and obtain a formula for their correlation functions, involving among other ingredients, an explicit Riemann-Hilbert problem. We then prove a limit theorem for the bottom lines in this line-ensemble, under some technical conditions. The main computational tool throughout this work is a natural generalisation of a Toeplitz matrix, that we call inhomogeneous Toeplitz-like matrix $\mathsf{T}_{\mathbf{f}}$ with (a possibly matrix-valued) symbol $\mathbf{f}$.

Can you decide if there is a coincidence in the numbers counting two different combinatorial objects? For example, can you decide if two regions in $\mathbb{R}^3$ have the same number of domino tilings? There are two versions of the problem, with $2\times 1 \times 1$ and $2\times 2 \times 1$ boxes. We prove that in both cases the coincidence problem is not in the polynomial hierarchy unless the polynomial hierarchy collapses to a finite level. While the conclusions are the same, the proofs are notably different and generalize in different directions. We proceed to explore the coincidence problem for counting independent sets and matchings in graphs, matroid bases, order ideals and linear extensions in posets, permutation patterns, and the Kronecker coefficients. We also make a number of conjectures for counting other combinatorial objects such as plane triangulations, contingency tables, standard Young tableaux, reduced factorizations and the Littlewood--Richardson coefficients.

The original motivation for this paper goes back to the mid-1990's, when James Propp was interested in natural situations when the number of domino tilings of a region increases if some of its unit squares are deleted. Guided in part by the intuition one gets from earlier work on parallels between the number of tilings of a region with holes and the 2D Coulomb energy of the corresponding system of electric charges, we consider Aztec diamond regions with unit square defects along two adjacent sides. We show that for large regions, if these defects are at fixed distances from a corner, the ratio between the number of domino tilings of the Aztec diamond with defects and the number of tilings of the entire Aztec diamond approaches a Delannoy number. When the locations of the defects are not fixed but instead approach given points on the boundary of the scaling limit $S$ (a square) of the Aztec diamonds, we prove that, provided the line segment connecting these points is outside the circle inscribed in $S$, this ratio has the same asymptotics as the Delannoy number corresponding to the locations of the defects; if the segment crosses the circle, the asymptotics is radically different. We use this to deduce (under the assumption that an arctic curve exists) that the arctic curve for domino tilings of Aztec diamonds is the circle inscribed in $S$. We also discuss counterparts of this phenomenon for lozenge tilings of hexagons.

We review the connections between the octahedral recurrence, $λ$-determinants and tiling problems. This provides in particular a direct combinatorial interpretation of the $λ$-determinant (and generalizations thereof) of an arbitrary matrix in terms of domino tilings of Aztec diamonds. We also reinterpret the general Robbins-Rumsey formula for the rational function of consecutive minors, given by a summation over pairs of compatible alternating sign matrices, as the partition function for tilings of Aztec diamonds equipped with a general measure.

In a region R consisting of unit squares, a (domino) tiling is a collection of dominoes (the union of two adjacent squares) which pave fully the region. The flip graph of R is defined on the set of all tilings of R where two tilings are adjacent if we change one from the other by a flip (a 90-degree rotation of a pair of side-by-side dominoes). If R is simply-connected, then its flip graph is connected. By using homology and cohomology, Saldanha, Tomei, Casarin and Romualdo obtained a criterion to decide if two tilings are in the same component of flip graph of quadriculated surface. By a graph-theoretic method, we obtain that the flip graph of a non-bipartite quadriculated torus consists of two isomorphic components. As an application, we obtain that the forcing numbers of all perfect matchings of each non-bipartite quadriculated torus form an integer-interval. For a bipartite quadriculated torus, the components of the flip graph is more complicated, and we use homology to obtain a general lower bound for the number of components of its flip graph.

Di Francesco introduced Aztec triangles as combinatorial objects for which their domino tilings are equinumerous with certain sets of configurations of the twenty-vertex model that are the main focus of his article. We generalize Di Francesco's construction of Aztec triangles. While we do not know whether there is again a correspondence with configurations in the twenty-vertex model, we prove closed-form product formulas for the number of domino tilings of our generalized Aztec triangles. As a special case, we obtain a proof of Di Francesco's conjectured formula for the number of domino tilings of his Aztec triangles, and thus for the number of the corresponding configurations in the twenty-vertex model.

In 2000, Cohn, Kenyon and Propp studied uniformly random perfect matchings of large induced subgraphs of $\mathbb Z^2$ (a.k.a. dimer configurations or domino tilings) and developed a large deviation theory for the associated height functions. We establish similar results for large induced subgraphs of $\mathbb Z^3$. To formulate these results, recall that a perfect matching on a bipartite graph induces a flow that sends one unit of current from each even vertex to its odd partner. One can then subtract a "reference flow'' to obtain a divergence-free flow. We show that the flow induced by a uniformly random dimer configuration converges in law (when boundary conditions on a bounded $R \subset \mathbb R^3$ are controlled and the mesh size tends to zero) to the deterministic divergence-free flow $g$ on $R$ that maximizes $$\int_{R} \text{ent}(g(x)) \,dx$$ given the boundary data, where $\text{ent}(s)$ is the maximal specific entropy obtained by an ergodic Gibbs measure with mean current $s$. The function $\text{ent}$ is not known explicitly, but we prove that it is continuous and {\em strictly concave} on the octahedron $\mathcal O$ of possible mean currents (except on the edges of $\mathcal O$) which implies (under reasonable boundary conditions) that the maximizer is uniquely determined. We further establish two versions of a large deviation principle, using the integral above to quantify how exponentially unlikely the discrete random flows are to approximate other deterministic flows. The planar dimer model is mathematically rich and well-studied, but many of the most powerful tools do not seem readily adaptable to higher dimensions. Our analysis begins with a smaller set of tools, which include Hall's matching theorem, the ergodic theorem, non-intersecting-lattice-path formulations, and double-dimer cycle swaps.

We introduce a new symmetry class of domino tilings of the Aztec diamond, called the off-diagonal symmetry class, which is motivated by the off-diagonally symmetric alternating sign matrices introduced by Kuperberg in 2002. We use the method of non-intersecting lattice paths and a modification of Stembridge's Pfaffian formula for families of non-intersecting lattice paths to enumerate our new symmetry class. The number of off-diagonally symmetric domino tilings of the Aztec diamond can be expressed as a Pfaffian of a matrix whose entries satisfy a nice and simple recurrence relation.

In a region $R$ consisting of unit squares, a domino is the union of two adjacent squares and a (domino) tiling is a collection of dominoes with disjoint interior whose union is the region. The flip graph $\mathcal{T}(R)$ is defined on the set of all tilings of $R$ such that two tilings are adjacent if we change one to another by a flip (a $90^{\circ}$ rotation of a pair of side-by-side dominoes). It is well-known that $\mathcal{T}(R)$ is connected when $R$ is simply connected. By using graph theoretical approach, we show that the flip graph of $2m\times(2n+1)$ quadriculated cylinder is still connected, but the flip graph of $2m\times(2n+1)$ quadriculated torus is disconnected and consists of exactly two isomorphic components. For a tiling $t$, we associate an integer $f(t)$, forcing number, as the minimum number of dominoes in $t$ that is contained in no other tilings. As an application, we obtain that the forcing numbers of all tilings in $2m\times (2n+1)$ quadriculated cylinder and torus form respectively an integer interval whose maximum value is $(n+1)m$.

We consider three-dimensional domino tilings of cylinders $\mathcal{R}_N = \mathcal{D} \times [0,N]$ where $\mathcal{D} \subset \mathbb{R}^2$ is a fixed quadriculated disk and $N \in \mathbb{N}$. A domino is a $2 \times 1 \times 1$ brick. A flip is a local move in the space of tilings $\mathcal{T}(\mathcal{R}_N)$: remove two adjacent dominoes and place them back after a rotation. The twist is a flip invariant which associates an integer number to each tiling. For some disks $\mathcal{D}$, called regular, two tilings of $\mathcal{R}_N$ with the same twist can be joined by a sequence of flips once we add vertical space to the cylinder. We have that if $\mathcal{D}$ is regular then the size of the largest connected component under flips of $\mathcal{T}(\mathcal{R}_N)$ is $Θ(N^{-\frac{1}{2}}|\mathcal{T}(\mathcal{R}_N)|)$. The domino group $G_{\mathcal{D}}$ captures information of the space of tilings. A disk $\mathcal{D}$ is regular if and only if $G_{\mathcal{D}}$ is isomorphic to $\mathbb{Z} \oplus \mathbb{Z}/(2)$; sufficiently large rectangles are regular. We prove that certain families of disks are irregular. We show that the existence of a bottleneck in a disk $\mathcal{D}$ often implies irregularity. In many, but not all, of these cases, we also prove that $\mathcal{D}$ is strongly irregular, i.e., that there exists a surjective homomorphism from $G_{\mathcal{D}}^+$ (a subgroup of index two of $G_{\mathcal{D}}$) to the free group of rank two. Moreover, we show that if $\mathcal{D}$ is strongly irregular then the cardinality of the largest connected component under flips of $\mathcal{T}(\mathcal{R}_N)$ is $O(c^N |\mathcal{T}(\mathcal{R}_N)|)$ for some $c \in (0,1)$.

In the past three decades, the study of rhombus tilings and domino tilings of various plane regions has been a thriving subfield of enumerative combinatorics. Physicists classify such work as the study of dimer covers of finite graphs. In this article we move beyond dimer covers to trimer covers, introducing plane regions called benzels that play a role analogous to hexagons for rhombus tilings and Aztec diamonds for domino tilings, inasmuch as one finds many (so far mostly conjectural) exact formulas governing the number of tilings.

Previous numerical studies have shown that in the disordered and anti-ferroelectric phases the six-vertex ($6$V) model with partial domain wall boundary conditions (DWBC) exhibits an arctic curve whose exact shape is unknown. The model is defined on a $s\times n$ square lattice ($s\leq n$). In this paper, we derive the analytic expression of the arctic curve, for $a=b=1$ and $c=\sqrt{2}$ ($Δ=0$), while keeping the ratio $s/n \,\in [0,1]$ as a free parameter. The computation relies on the tangent method. We also consider domino tilings of double Aztec rectangles and show via the tangent method that, for particular parameters, the arctic curve is identical to that of the $6$V model with partial DWBC. Our results are confirmed by extensive numerical simulations.

We study $k$-tilings ($k$-tuples of domino tilings) of the Aztec diamond of rank $m$. We assign a weight to each $k$-tiling, depending on the number of dominos of certain types and the number of "interactions" between the tilings. Employing the colored vertex models introduced in earlier work to study supersymmetric LLT polynomials, we compute the generating polynomials of the $k$-tilings. We then prove some combinatorial results about $k$-tilings, including a bijection between $k$-tilings with no interactions and $1$-tilings, and we compute the arctic curves of the tilings for $t=0$ and $t\rightarrow\infty$. We also present some lozenge $k$-tilings of the hexagon and compute the arctic curves of the tilings for $t=0$.

We study random domino tilings of a multiply-connected domain with a height function defined on the universal covering space of the domain. We prove a large deviation principle for the height function in two asymptotic regimes. The first regime covers all domino tilings of the domain. We also prove a law of large numbers for height change in this regime. The second regime covers domino tilings with a given asymptotic height change $r$.

Our work deals with symmetric rational functions and probabilistic models based on the fully inhomogeneous six vertex (ice type) model satisfying the free fermion condition. Two families of symmetric rational functions $F_λ,G_λ$ are defined as certain partition functions of the six vertex model, with variables corresponding to row rapidities, and the labeling signatures $λ=(λ_1\ge \ldots\ge λ_N)\in \mathbb{Z}^N$ encoding boundary conditions. These symmetric functions generalize Schur symmetric polynomials, as well as some of their variations, such as factorial and supersymmetric Schur polynomials. Cauchy type summation identities for $F_λ,G_λ$ and their skew counterparts follow from the Yang-Baxter equation. Using algebraic Bethe Ansatz, we obtain a double alternant type formula for $F_λ$ and a Sergeev-Pragacz type formula for $G_λ$. In the spirit of the theory of Schur processes, we define probability measures on sequences of signatures with probability weights proportional to products of our symmetric functions. We show that these measures can be viewed as determinantal point processes, and we express their correlation kernels in a double contour integral form. We present two proofs: The first is a direct computation of Eynard-Mehta type, and the second uses non-standard, inhomogeneous versions of fermionic operators in a Fock space coming from the algebraic Bethe Ansatz for the six vertex model. We also interpret our determinantal processes as random domino tilings of a half-strip with inhomogeneous domino weights. In the bulk, we show that the lattice asymptotic behavior of such domino tilings is described by a new determinantal point process on $\mathbb{Z}^{2}$, which can be viewed as an doubly-inhomogeneous generalization of the extended discrete sine process.

The six-vertex model is an important toy-model in statistical mechanics for two-dimensional ice with a natural parameter $Δ$. When $Δ= 0$, the so-called free-fermion point, the model is in natural correspondence with domino tilings of the Aztec diamond. Although this model is integrable for all $Δ$, there has been very little progress in understanding its statistics in the scaling limit for other values. In this work, we focus on the six-vertex model with domain wall boundary conditions at $Δ= 1/2$, where it corresponds to alternating sign matrices (ASMs). We consider the level lines in a height function representation of ASMs. We show that the maximum of the topmost level line for a uniformly random ASMs has the GOE Tracy--Widom distribution after appropriate rescaling. A key ingredient in our proof is Zeilberger's proof of the ASM conjecture. As far as we know, this is the first edge fluctuation result away from the tangency points for the domain-wall six-vertex model when we are not in the free fermion case.

A recent conjecture of Di Francesco states that the number of domino tilings of a certain family of regions on the square lattice is given by a product formula reminiscent of the one giving the number of alternating sign matrices. These regions, denoted ${\mathcal T}_n$, are obtained by starting with a square of side-length $2n$, cutting it in two along a diagonal by a zigzag path with step length two, and gluing to one of the resulting regions half of an Aztec diamond of order $n-1$. Inspired by the regions ${\mathcal T}_n$, we construct a family $C_{m,n}^{a,b,c,d}$ of cruciform regions generalizing the Aztec diamonds and we prove that their number of domino tilings is given by a simple product formula. Since (as it follows from our results) the number of domino tilings of ${\mathcal T}_n$ is a divisor of the number of tilings of the cruciform region $C_{2n-1,2n-1}^{n-1,n,n,n-2}$, the special case of our formula corresponding to the latter can be viewed as partial progress towards proving Di Francesco's conjecture.

We show that the number of configurations of the 20 Vertex model on certain domains with domain wall type boundary conditions is equal to the number of domino tilings of Aztec-like triangles, proving a conjecture from [P. Di Francesco and E. Guitter, Twenty-Vertex Model with Domain Wall Boundaries and Domino Tilings, Elec. Jour. of Combinatorics 27 (2020), no. 2, P2.13]. The result is based on the integrability of the 20 Vertex model and uses a connection to the U-turn boundary 6 Vertex model to re-express the number of 20 Vertex configurations as a simple determinant, which is then related to a Lindström-Gessel-Viennot determinant for the domino tiling problem. The common number of configurations is conjectured to be $2^{n(n-1)/2}\prod_{j=0}^{n-1}\frac{(4j+2)!}{(n+2j+1)!}=1, 4, 60, 3328, 678912...$ The enumeration result is extended to include refinements of both numbers.

In this paper, we consider the set of all domino tilings of a cubiculated region. The primary question we explore is: How can we move from one tiling to another? Tiling spaces can be viewed as spaces of subgraphs of a fixed graph with a fixed degree sequence. Moves to connect such spaces have been explored in algebraic statistics. Thus, we approach this question from an applied algebra viewpoint, making new connections between domino tilings, algebraic statistics, and toric algebra. Using results from toric ideals of graphs, we are able to describe moves that connect the tiling space of a given cubiculated region of any dimension. This is done by studying binomials that arise from two distinct domino tilings of the same region. Additionally, we introduce tiling ideals and flip ideals and use these ideals to restate what it means for a tiling space to be flip connected. Finally, we show that if $R$ is a $2$-dimensional simply connected cubiculated region, any binomial arising from two distinct tilings of $R$ can be written in terms of quadratic binomials. As a corollary to our main result, we obtain an alternative proof to the fact that the set of domino tilings of a $2$-dimensional simply connected region is connected by flips.

We consider domino tilings of $3$-dimensional cubiculated regions. A three-dimensional domino is a 2x2x1 rectangular cuboid. We are particularly interested in regions of the form $R_N = D \times [0,N]$ where $D$ is a fixed quadriculated disk. In dimension 3, the twist associates to each tiling $t$ an integer $Tw(t)$. We prove that, when $N$ goes to infinity, the twist follows a normal distribution. A flip is a local move: two neighboring parallel dominoes are removed and placed back in a different position. The twist is invariant under flips. A quadriculated disk $D$ is regular if, whenever two tilings $t_0$ and $t_1$ of $R_N$ satisfy $Tw(t_0) = Tw(t_1)$, $t_0$ and $t_1$ can be joined by a sequence of flips provided some extra vertical space is allowed. Many large disks are regular, including rectangles $D = [0,L] \times [0,M]$ with $LM$ even and $L,M \ge 3$. For regular disks, we describe the larger connected components under flips of the set of tilings of the region $R_N = D \times [0,N]$. As a corollary, let $p_N$ be the probability that two random tilings $T_0$ and $T_1$ of $D \times [0,N]$ can be joined by a sequence of flips conditional to their twists being equal. Then $p_N$ tends to 1 if and only if $D$ is regular. Under a suitable equivalence relation, the set of tilings has a group structure, the domino group. These results illustrate the fact that the domino group dictates many properties of the space of tilings of the cylinder $R_N = D \times [0,N]$, particularly for large $N$.