arXiv++ Combinatorics

Tutte showed that a graph $G$ is planar if and only if the conflict graph associated to every cycle of $G$ is bipartite. We define a (not necessarily unique) signed conflict graph associated to a maximally planar subgraph of a nonplanar graph such that if $G$ has a flat embedding, every possible conflict graph associated to every maximally planar subgraph of $G$ is balanced. In doing this, we show that for every graph $G$ with flat embedding, and a planar subgraph $P$ of $G$, $P$ lies on a sphere that intersects $G$ only in $P$. We conjecture that $G$ is intrinsically linked if and only if every maximal planar subgraph of $G$ has every possible conflict graph unbalanced.

A Hadamard matrix is balanced splittable if some subset of its rows has the property that the dot product of every two distinct columns takes at most two values. This definition was introduced by Kharaghani and Suda in 2019, although equivalent formulations have been previously studied using different terminology. We collate previous results phrased in terms of balanced splittable Hadamard matrices, real flat equiangular tight frames, spherical two-distance sets, and two-distance tight frames. We use combinatorial analysis to restrict the parameters of a balanced splittable Hadamard matrix to lie in one of several classes, and obtain strong new constraints on their mutual relationships. An important consideration in determining these classes is whether the strongly regular graph associated with the balanced splittable Hadamard matrix is primitive or imprimitive. We construct new infinite families of balanced splittable Hadamard matrices in both the primitive and imprimitive cases. A rich source of examples is provided by packings of partial difference sets in elementary abelian 2-groups, from which we construct Hadamard matrices admitting a row decomposition so that the balanced splittable property holds simultaneously with respect to every union of the submatrices of the decomposition.

An s-cap n-flat, or an n-dimensional cap of size s, is a pair (S,F) where F is an n-dimensional affine space over Z/3Z and the size-s subset S of F contains no triple of collinear points. The cap set problem in dimension n asks for the largest s for which an s-cap n-flat exists. This series of articles investigates the cap set problem in dimensions up to and including 7. This is the second paper in the series. By applying and adapting methods from the first paper in the series, we systematically classify all 5-dimensional caps of size at least 41.

An s-cap n-flat is given by a set of s points, no three of which are on a common line, in an n-dimensional affine space over the field of three elements. The cap set problem in dimension n is: what is the maximum s such that there is an s-cap n-flat? The first two papers in this series of articles considered the cap set problem in dimensions up to and including 5. In this paper, which is the third in the series, we consider dimensions 6 and 7: we prove that every 110-cap 6-flat is a 112-cap 6-flat minus two cap points, and that there are no 289-cap 7-flats.

The bottom complex of a finite polyhedal pointed rational cone is the lattice polytopal complex of the compact faces of the convex hull of nonzero lattice points in the cone. The algebra, associated to the bottom complex of a cone, defines a flat deformation of the affine toric variety, associated to the polyhedral cone, set-theoretically. We describe three explicit infinite families of abstract polytopal complexes, defining such flat deformations scheme-theoretically.

In 1999 Merino and Welsh conjectured that evaluations of the Tutte polynomial of a graph satisfy an inequality. In this short article we show that the conjecture generalized to matroids holds for the large class of all split matroids by exploiting the structure of their lattice of cyclic flats. This class of matroids strictly contains all paving and copaving matroids.

We consider the restrictions of Shi arrangements to Weyl cones, their relations to antichains in the root poset, and their intersection posets. For any Weyl cone, we provide bijections between regions, flats intersecting the cone, and antichains of a naturally-defined subposet of the root poset. This gives a refinement of the parking function numbers via the Poincaré polynomials of the intersection posets of all Weyl cones. Finally, we interpret these Poincaré polynomials as the Hilbert series of three isomorphic graded rings. One of these rings arises from the Varchenko-Gel'fand ring, another is the coordinate ring of the vertices of the order polytope of a subposet of the root poset, and the third is purely combinatorial.

We study the augmented Bergman complex of a closure operator on a finite set, which interpolates between the order complex of proper flats and the independence complex of the operator. In 2020, Braden, Huh, Matherne, Proudfoot, and Wang showed that augmented Bergman complexes of matroids are always gallery-connected, and recently Bullock, Kelley, Reiner, Ren, Shemy, Shen, Sun, Tao, and Zhang strengthened "gallery-connected" to "shellable" by providing two classes of shelling orders: "flag-to-basis" shellings and "basis-to-flag" shellings. We show that augmented Bergman complexes of matroids are vertex decomposable, a stronger property than shellable. We also prove that the augmented Bergman complex of any closure operator is shellable if and only if lattice of flats (that is, its non-augmented Bergman complex) is shellable. As a consequence, an augmented Bergman complex is shellable if and only if it admits a flag-to-basis shelling. Perhaps surprisingly, the same does not hold for basis-to-flag shellings: we describe a closure operator whose augmented Bergman complex is shellable, but has no shelling order with bases appearing first.

A number of finite algorithms for constructing representation theoretic data from group multiplications in a finite group G have recently been shown to be related to amplitudes for combinatoric topological strings (G-CTST) based on Dijkgraaf-Witten theory of flat G-bundles on surfaces. We extend this result to projective representations of G using twisted Dijkgraaf-Witten theory. New algorithms for characters are described, based on handle creation operators and minimal multiplicative generating subspaces for the centers of group algebras and twisted group algebras. Such minimal generating subspaces are of interest in connection with information theoretic aspects of the AdS/CFT correspondence. For the untwisted case, we describe the integrality properties of certain character sums and character power sums which follow from these constructive G-CTST algorithms. These integer sums appear as residues of singularities in G-CTST generating functions. S-duality of the combinatoric topological strings motivates the definition of an inverse handle creation operator in the centers of group algebras and twisted group algebras.

In this paper we develop the theory of cyclic flats of $q$-matroids. We show that the lattice of cyclic flats, together with their ranks, uniquely determines a $q$-matroid and hence derive a new $q$-cryptomorphism. We introduce the notion of $\mathbb{F}_{q^m}$-independence of an $\mathbb{F}_q$-subspace of $\mathbb{F}_q^n$ and we show that $q$-matroids generalize this concept, in the same way that matroids generalize the notion of linear independence of vectors over a given field.

Let $M$ be a matroid satisfying a matroidal analogue of the Cayley-Bacharach condition. Given a number $k \ge 2$, we show that there is no nontrivial bound on ranks of a $k$-tuple of flats covering the underlying set of $M$. This addresses a question of Levinson-Ullery motivated by earlier results which show that bounding the number of points satisfying the Cayley-Bacharach condition forces them to lie on low-dimensional linear subspaces. We also explore the general question what matroids satisfy the matroidal Cayley-Bacharach condition of a given degree and its relation to the geometry of generalized permutohedra and graphic matroids.

The intersection data of a hyperplane arrangement is described by a geometric lattice, or equivalently a simple matroid. There is a rich interplay between this combinatorial structure and the topology of the arrangement complement. In this paper, we characterize the combinatorial structure underlying an abelian arrangement (such as a toric or elliptic arrangement) by defining a class of geometric posets and a generalization of matroids called matroid schemes. The intersection data of an abelian arrangement is encoded in a geometric poset, and we prove that a geometric poset is equivalent to a simple matroid scheme. We lay foundations for the theory of matroid schemes, discussing rank, flats, and independence. We also extend the definition of the Tutte polynomial to this setting and prove that it satisfies a deletion-contraction recurrence.

Flat origami studies straight line, planar graphs $C=(V,E)$ drawn on a region $R\subset\mathbb{R}^2$ that can act as crease patterns to map, or fold, $R$ into $\mathbb{R}^2$ in a way that is continuous and a piecewise isometry exactly on the faces of $C$. Associated with such crease pattern graphs are valid mountain-valley (MV) assignments $μ:E\to\{-1,1\}$, indicating which creases can be mountains (convex) or valleys (concave) to allow $R$ to physically fold flat without self-intersecting. In this paper, we initiate the first study of how valid MV assignments of single-vertex crease patterns are related to one another via face-flips, a concept that emerged from applications of origami in engineering and physics, where flipping a face $F$ means switching the MV parity of all creases of $C$ that border $F$. Specifically, we study the origami flip graph ${\rm{OFG}}(C)$, whose vertices are all valid MV assignments of $C$ and edges connect assignments that differ by only one face flip. We prove that, for the single-vertex crease pattern $A_{2n}$ whose $2n$ sector angles around the vertex are all equal, ${\rm{OFG}}(A_{2n})$ contains as subgraphs all other origami flip graphs of degree-$2n$ flat origami vertex crease patterns. We also prove that ${\rm{OFG}}(A_{2n})$ is connected and has diameter $n$ by providing two $O(n^2)$ algorithms to traverse between vertices in the graph, and we enumerate the vertices, edges, and degree sequence of ${\rm{OFG}}(A_{2n})$. We conclude with open questions on the surprising complexity found in origami flip graphs of this type.

The main purpose of this paper is to provide threshold functions for the events that a random subset of the points of a finite vector space has certain properties related to point-flat incidences. Specifically, we consider the events that there is an $\ell$-rich $m$-flat with regard to a random set of points in $\mathbb{F}_q^n$, the event that a random set of points is an $m$-blocking set, and the event that there is an incidence between a random set of points and a random set of $m$-flats. One of our key ingredients is a stronger version of a recent result obtained by Chen and Greenhill (2021).

The problem of testing low-degree polynomials has received significant attention over the years due to its importance in theoretical computer science, and in particular in complexity theory. The problem is specified by three parameters: field size $q$, degree $d$ and proximity parameter $δ$, and the goal is to design a tester making as few as possible queries to a given function, which is able to distinguish between the case the given function has degree at most $d$, and the case the given function is $δ$-far from any degree $d$ function. A tester is called optimal if it makes $O(q^d+1/δ)$ queries (which are known to be necessary). For the field of size $q$, the natural $t$-flat tester was shown to be optimal first by Bhattacharyya et al. for $q=2$, and later by Haramaty et al. for all prime powers $q$. The dependency on the field size, however, is a tower-type function. We improve the results above, showing that the dependency on the field size is polynomial. Our approach also applies in the more general setting of lifted affine invariant codes, and is based on studying the structure of the collection of erroneous subspaces. i.e. subspaces $A$ such that $f|_{A}$ has degree greater than $d$. Towards this end, we observe that these sets are poorly expanding in the affine version of the Grassmann graph and use that to establish structural results on them via global hypercontractivity. We then use this structure to perform local correction on $f$.

Denote the collection of all $k$-flats in $AG(n,\mathbb{F}_q)$ by $\mathscr{M}(k,n)$. Let $\mathscr{F}_1\subset\mathscr{M}(k_1,n)$ and $\mathscr{F}_2\subset\mathscr{M}(k_2,n)$ satisfy $\dim(F_1\cap F_2)\ge t$ for any $F_1\in\mathscr{F}_1$ and $F_2\in\mathscr{F}_2$. We say they are cross $t$-intersecting families. Moreover, we say they are trivial if each member of them contains a fixed $t$-flats in $AG(n,\mathbb{F}_q)$. In this paper, we show that cross $t$-intersecting families with maximum product of sizes are trivial. We also describe the structure of non-trivial $t$-intersecting families with maximum product of sizes.

We consider products of $ψ$ classes and products of $ω$ classes on $\overline{M}_{0,n+3}$. For each product, we construct a flat family of subschemes of $\overline{M}_{0,n+3}$ whose general fiber is a complete intersection representing the product, and whose special fiber is a generically reduced union of boundary strata. Our construction is built up inductively as a sequence of one-parameter degenerations, using an explicit parametrized collection of hyperplane sections. Combinatorially, our construction expresses each product as a positive, multiplicity-free sum of classes of boundary strata. These are given by a combinatorial algorithm on trees we call 'slide labeling'. As a corollary, we obtain a combinatorial formula for the $κ$ classes in terms of boundary strata. For degree-$n$ products of $ω$ classes, the special fiber is a finite reduced union of (boundary) points, and its cardinality is one of the multidegrees of the corresponding embedding $Ω_n: \overline{M}_{0,n+3}\to \mathbb{P}^1\times \cdots \times \mathbb{P}^n$. In the case of the product $ω_1\cdots ω_n$, these points exhibit a connection to permutation pattern avoidance. Finally, we show that in certain cases, a prior interpretation of the multidegrees via tournaments can also be obtained by degenerations.

We study the Hadamard product of the linear forms defining a hyperplane arrangement with those of its dual, which we view as generating an ideal in a certain polynomial ring. We use this ideal, which we call the ideal of pairs, to study logarithmic derivations and critical set varieties of arrangements in a way which is symmetric with respect to matroid duality. Our main result exhibits the variety of the ideal of pairs as a subspace arrangement whose components correspond to cyclic flats of the arrangement. As a corollary, we are able to give geometric explanations of some freeness and projective dimension results due to Ziegler and Kung--Schenck.

A complete subgraph of a given graph is called a clique. A clique Polynomial of a graph is a generating function of the number of cliques in $G$. A real root of the clique polynomial of a graph $G$ is called a \emph{clique root} of $G$. \\ Hajiabolhassan and Mehrabadi showed that the clique polynomial of any simple graph has a clique root in $[-1,0)$. As a generalization of their result, the author of this paper showed that the class of $K_{4}$-free connected chordal graphs has also only clique roots. \\ A given graph $G$ is called flat if each edge of $G$ belongs to at most two triangles of $G$. In answering the author's open question about the class of \emph{non-chordal} graphs with the same property of having only c;ique roots, we extend the aforementioned result to the class of $K_{4}$-free flat graphs. In particular, we prove that the class of $K_{4}$-free flat graphs without isolated edges has $r=-1$ as one of its clique roots. We finally present some interesting open questions and conjectures regarding clique roots of graphs.

We study the closure operators of polymatroids from a lattice theoretic point of view. We show that polymatroid closure operators relate to lattices enriched with a generating set in the same way that matroids relate to geometric lattices. Through this relation we define a notion of minors for lattices enriched with a generating set. For the lattice of flats of a graphic matroid, the minors of the lattice are shown to correspond to simple minors of the graph when the vertices are labeled and the edges unlabeled. This correspondence is generalized to all polymatroids.