arXiv++ Combinatorics

C3 is an algorithm used by several widely used programming languages such as Python to support multiple inheritance in object oriented programming (OOP): for each class, C3 computes recursively a linear extension of the poset of all its super classes (the Method Resolution Order, MRO) from user-provided local information (an ordering of the direct super classes). This algorithm can fail if the local information is not consistent. For large hierarchies of classes, as encountered when modeling hierarchies of concepts from abstract algebra in the SageMath computational system, maintaining consistent local information by hand does not scale and leads to unpredictable C3 failures. This paper reports on the authors' work to analyze and circumvent this maintenance nightmare. First, we discovered through extensive computer exploration that there exists posets admitting no consistent local information; we exhibit the smallest one which has 10 elements. Then, we provide and analyze an algorithm that, given a poset and a linear extension, automatically builds local information for C3 in such a way that guarantees that it will never fail, at the price of a slight relaxation of the hypotheses. This algorithm has been used in production in SageMath since 2013.

Let G be a group of permutations of a denumerable set E. The profile of G is the function phi which counts, for each n, the number phi(n) of orbits of G acting on the n-subsets of E. Counting functions arising this way, and their associated generating series, form a rich yet apparently strongly constrained class. In particular, Cameron conjectured in the late seventies that, whenever the profile phi(n) is bounded by a polynomial -- we say that G is P-oligomorphic --, it is asymptotically equivalent to a polynomial. In 1985, Macpherson further asked whether the orbit algebra of G -- a graded commutative algebra invented by Cameron and whose Hilbert function is phi -- is finitely generated. In this paper we establish a classification of (closed) P-oligomorphic permutation groups in terms of finite permutation groups with decorated blocks. It follows from the classification that the orbit algebra of any P-oligomorphic group is isomorphic to (a straightforward quotient of) the invariant ring of some finite permutation group. This answers positively both Cameron's conjecture and Macpherson's question. The orbit algebra is in fact Cohen-Macaulay; therefore the generating series of phi is a rational fraction whose numerator has positive coefficients, while the denominator admits a combinatorial description. In addition, the classification provides a finite data structure for encoding closed P-oligomorphic groups. This paves the way for computing with them and enumerating them as well as for proofs by structural induction. Finally, the relative simplicity of the classification gives hopes to extend the study to, e.g., the class of (closed) permutations groups with sub-exponential profile. The proof exploits classical notions from group theory -- notably block systems and their lattice properties --, commutative algebra, and invariant theory.

Let $G$ be a group of permutations of a denumerable set $E$. The profile of $G$ is the function $φ_G$ which counts, for each $n$, the (possibly infinite) number $φ_G(n)$ of orbits of $G$ acting on the $n$-subsets of $E$. Counting functions arising this way, and their associated generating series, form a rich yet apparently strongly constrained class. In particular, Cameron conjectured in the late seventies that, whenever $φ_G(n)$ is bounded by a polynomial, it is asymptotically equivalent to a polynomial. In 1985, Macpherson further asked if the orbit algebra of $G$ - a graded commutative algebra invented by Cameron and whose Hilbert function is $φ_G$ - is finitely generated. In this paper, we announce a proof of a stronger statement: the orbit algebra is Cohen-Macaulay. The generating series of the profile is a rational fraction whose numerator has positive coefficients and denominator admits a combinatorial description. The proof uses classical techniques from group actions, commutative algebra, and invariant theory; it steps towards a classification of ages of permutation groups with profile bounded by a polynomial.

We prove that the expected number of braid moves in the commutation class of the reduced word $(s_1 s_2 \cdots s_{n-1})(s_1 s_2 \cdots s_{n-2}) \cdots (s_1 s_2)(s_1)$ for the long element in the symmetric group $\mathfrak{S}_n$ is one. This is a variant of a similar result by V. Reiner, who proved that the expected number of braid moves in a random reduced word for the long element is one. The proof is bijective and uses X. Viennot's theory of heaps and variants of the promotion operator. In addition, we provide a refinement of this result on orbits under the action of even and odd promotion operators. This gives an example of a homomesy for a nonabelian (dihedral) group that is not induced by an abelian subgroup. Our techniques extend to more general posets and to other statistics.

In this paper, we propose a new Markov chain which generalizes random-to-random shuffling on permutations to random-to-random shuffling on linear extensions of a finite poset of size $n$. We conjecture that the second largest eigenvalue of the transition matrix is bounded above by $(1+1/n)(1-2/n)$ with equality when the poset is disconnected. This Markov chain provides a way to sample the linear extensions of the poset with a relaxation time bounded above by $n^2/(n+2)$ and a mixing time of $O(n^2 \log n)$. We conjecture that the mixing time is in fact $O(n \log n)$ as for the usual random-to-random shuffling.

The profile of a relational structure $R$ is the function $\varphi_R$ which counts for every integer $n$ the number $\varphi_R(n)$, possibly infinite, of substructures of $R$ induced on the $n$-element subsets, isomorphic substructures being identified. If $\varphi_R$ takes only finite values, this is the Hilbert function of a graded algebra associated with $R$, the age algebra introduced by P. J. Cameron. In this paper we give a closer look at this association, particularly when the relational structure $R$ admits a finite monomorphic decomposition. This setting still encompass well-studied graded commutative algebras like invariant rings of finite permutation groups, or the rings of quasi-symmetric polynomials. We prove that $\varphi_R$ is eventually a quasi-polynomial, this supporting the conjecture that, under mild assumptions on $R$, $\varphi_R$ is eventually a quasi-polynomial when it is bounded by some polynomial.

We develop a general theory of Markov chains realizable as random walks on $\mathscr R$-trivial monoids. It provides explicit and simple formulas for the eigenvalues of the transition matrix, for multiplicities of the eigenvalues via Möbius inversion along a lattice, a condition for diagonalizability of the transition matrix and some techniques for bounding the mixing time. In addition, we discuss several examples, such as Toom-Tsetlin models, an exchange walk for finite Coxeter groups, as well as examples previously studied by the authors, such as nonabelian sandpile models and the promotion Markov chain on posets. Many of these examples can be viewed as random walks on quotients of free tree monoids, a new class of monoids whose combinatorics we develop.

We define two general classes of nonabelian sandpile models on directed trees (or arborescences) as models of nonequilibrium statistical phenomena. These models have the property that sand grains can enter only through specified reservoirs, unlike the well-known abelian sandpile model. In the Trickle-down sandpile model, sand grains are allowed to move one at a time. For this model, we show that the stationary distribution is of product form. In the Landslide sandpile model, all the grains at a vertex topple at once, and here we prove formulas for all eigenvalues, their multiplicities, and the rate of convergence to stationarity. The proofs use wreath products and the representation theory of monoids.

Using evaluation at appropriately chosen points, we propose a Gröbner basis free approach for calculating the secondary invariants of a finite permutation group. This approach allows for exploiting the symmetries to confine the calculations into a smaller quotient space, which gives a tighter control on the algorithmic complexity, especially for large groups. This is confirmed by extensive benchmarks using a Sage implementation.

For any finite Coxeter group W, we introduce two new objects: its cutting poset and its biHecke monoid. The cutting poset, constructed using a generalization of the notion of blocks in permutation matrices, almost forms a lattice on W. The construction of the biHecke monoid relies on the usual combinatorial model for the 0-Hecke algebra H_0(W), that is, for the symmetric group, the algebra (or monoid) generated by the elementary bubble sort operators. The authors previously introduced the Hecke group algebra, constructed as the algebra generated simultaneously by the bubble sort and antisort operators, and described its representation theory. In this paper, we consider instead the monoid generated by these operators. We prove that it admits |W| simple and projective modules. In order to construct the simple modules, we introduce for each w in W a combinatorial module T_w whose support is the interval [1,w]_R in right weak order. This module yields an algebra, whose representation theory generalizes that of the Hecke group algebra, with the combinatorics of descents replaced by that of blocks and of the cutting poset.

We introduce deformations of the space of (multi-diagonal) harmonic polynomials for any finite complex reflection group of the form W=G(m,p,n), and give supporting evidence that this space seems to always be isomorphic, as a graded W-module, to the undeformed version.

In 1979, Norton showed that the representation theory of the 0-Hecke algebra admits a rich combinatorial description. Her constructions rely heavily on some triangularity property of the product, but do not use explicitly that the 0-Hecke algebra is a monoid algebra. The thesis of this paper is that considering the general setting of monoids admitting such a triangularity, namely J-trivial monoids, sheds further light on the topic. This is a step to use representation theory to automatically extract combinatorial structures from (monoid) algebras, often in the form of posets and lattices, both from a theoretical and computational point of view, and with an implementation in Sage. Motivated by ongoing work on related monoids associated to Coxeter systems, and building on well-known results in the semi-group community (such as the description of the simple modules or the radical), we describe how most of the data associated to the representation theory (Cartan matrix, quiver) of the algebra of any J-trivial monoid M can be expressed combinatorially by counting appropriate elements in M itself. As a consequence, this data does not depend on the ground field and can be calculated in O(n^2), if not O(nm), where n=|M| and m is the number of generators. Along the way, we construct a triangular decomposition of the identity into orthogonal idempotents, using the usual Möbius inversion formula in the semi-simple quotient (a lattice), followed by an algorithmic lifting step. Applying our results to the 0-Hecke algebra (in all finite types), we recover previously known results and additionally provide an explicit labeling of the edges of the quiver. We further explore special classes of J-trivial monoids, and in particular monoids of order preserving regressive functions on a poset, generalizing known results on the monoids of nondecreasing parking functions.

This manuscript synthesizes almost fifteen years of research in algebraic combinatorics, in order to highlight, theme by theme, its perspectives. In part one, building on my thesis work, I use tools from commutative algebra, and in particular from invariant theory, to study isomorphism problems in combinatorics. I first consider algebras of graph invariants in relation with Ulam's reconstruction conjecture, and then, more generally, the age algebras of relational structures. This raises in return structural and algorithmic problems in the invariant theory of permutation groups. In part two, the leitmotiv is the quest for simple yet rich combinatorial models to describe algebraic structures and their representations. This includes the Hecke group algebras of Coxeter groups which I introduced and which relate to the affine Hecke algebras, but also some finite dimensional Kac algebras in relation with inclusions of factors, and the rational Steenrod algebras. Beside being concrete and constructive, such combinatorial models shed light on certain algebraic phenomena and can lead to elegant and elementary proofs. My favorite tool is computer exploration, and the algorithmic and effective aspects play a major role in this manuscript. In particular, I describe the international open source project *-Combinat which I founded back in 2000, and whose mission is to provide an extensible toolbox for computer exploration in algebraic combinatorics and to foster code sharing among researchers in this area. I present specific challenges that the development of this project raised, and the original algorithmic, design, and development model solutions I was led to develop.

The usual combinatorial model for the 0-Hecke algebra of the symmetric group is to consider the algebra (or monoid) generated by the bubble sort operators. This construction generalizes to any finite Coxeter group W. The authors previously introduced the Hecke group algebra, constructed as the algebra generated simultaneously by the bubble sort and antisort operators, and described its representation theory. In this paper, we consider instead the monoid generated by these operators. We prove that it has |W| simple and projective modules. In order to construct a combinatorial model for the simple modules, we introduce for each w in W a combinatorial module whose support is the interval [1,w] in right weak order. This module yields an algebra, whose representation theory generalizes that of the Hecke group algebra. This involves the introduction of a w-analogue of the combinatorics of descents of W and a generalization to finite Coxeter groups of blocks of permutation matrices.

We define graded Hopf algebras with bases labeled by various types of graphs and hypergraphs, provided with natural embeddings into an algebra of polynomials in infinitely many variables. These algebras are graded by the number of edges and can be considered as generalizations of symmetric or quasi-symmetric functions.

In 1999, Reg Wood conjectured that the quotient of Q[x_1,...,x_n] by the action of the rational Steenrod algebra is a graded regular representation of the symmetric group S_n. As pointed out by Reg Wood, the analog of this statement is a well known result when the rational Steenrod algebra is replaced by the ring of symmetric functions; actually, much more is known about the structure of the quotient in this case. We introduce a non-commutative q-deformation of the ring of symmetric functions, which specializes at q=1 to the rational Steenrod algebra. We use this formalism to obtain some partial results. Finally, we describe several conjectures based on an extensive computer exploration. In particular, we extend Reg Wood's conjecture to q formal and to any q complex not of the form -a/b, with a in {1,...,n} and b a positive natural number.

We report on results about a study of algebraic graph invariants, based on computer exploration, and motivated by graph-isomorphism and reconstruction problems.

We consider the ring I_n of polynomial invariants over weighted graphs on n vertices. Our primary interest is the use of this ring to define and explore algebraic versions of isomorphism problems of graphs, such as Ulam's reconstruction conjecture. There is a huge body of literature on invariant theory which provides both general results and algorithms. However, there is a combinatorial explosion in the computations involved and, to our knowledge, the ring I_n has only been completely described for n<=4. This led us to study the ring I_n in its own right. We used intensive computer exploration for small n, and developed PerMuVAR, a library for MuPAD, for computing in invariant rings of permutation groups. We present general properties of the ring I_n, as well as results obtained by computer exploration for small n, including the construction of a medium sized generating set for I_5. We address several conjectures suggested by those results (low degree system of parameters, unimodality), for I_n as well as for more general invariant rings. We also show that some particular sets are not generating, disproving a conjecture of Pouzet related to reconstruction, as well as a lemma of Grigoriev on the invariant ring over digraphs. We finally provide a very simple minimal generating set of the field of invariants.

The affine Dynkin diagram of type $A_n^{(1)}$ has a cyclic symmetry. The analogue of this Dynkin diagram automorphism on the level of crystals is called a promotion operator. In this paper we show that the only irreducible type $A_n$ crystals which admit a promotion operator are the highest weight crystals indexed by rectangles. In addition we prove that on the tensor product of two type $A_n$ crystals labeled by rectangles, there is a single connected promotion operator. We conjecture this to be true for an arbitrary number of tensor factors. Our results are in agreement with Kashiwara's conjecture that all `good' affine crystals are tensor products of Kirillov-Reshetikhin crystals.

The Hecke group algebra $HW_0$ of a finite Coxeter group $W_0$, as introduced by the first and last author, is obtained from $W_0$ by gluing appropriately its 0-Hecke algebra and its group algebra. In this paper, we give an equivalent alternative construction in the case when $W_0$ is the classical Weyl group associated to an affine Weyl group $W$. Namely, we prove that, for $q$ not a root of unity, $HW_0$ is the natural quotient of the affine Hecke algebra through its level 0 representation. We further show that the level 0 representation is a calibrated principal series representation for a suitable choice of character, so that the quotient factors (non trivially) through the principal central specialization. This explains in particular the similarities between the representation theory of the classical 0-Hecke algebra and that of the affine Hecke algebra at this specialization.