arXiv++ Combinatorics

Motivated by the application of Hall's Marriage Theorem in various LP-rounding problems, we introduce a generalization of the classical marriage problem (CMP) that we call the Fractional Marriage Problem. We show that the Fractional Marriage Problem is NP-Complete by reduction from Boolean Satisfiability (SAT). We show that when we view the classical marriage problem (a.k.a. bipartite matching) as a sub-class of SAT we get a new class of polynomial-time satisfiable SAT instances that we call CMP-SAT, different from the classically known polynomial-time satisfiable SAT instances 2-SAT, Horn-SAT and XOR-SAT. We next turn to the problem of recognizing CMP-SAT instances, first using SAT embeddings, and then using their embeddings within the universe of Fractional Marriage Problems (FMPs). In the process we are led to another generalization of the CMP that we call the Symmetric Marriage Problem, which is polynomial time decidable and leads to a slight enlargement of the CMP-SAT class. We develop a framework for simplifying FMP problems to identify CMP instances that we call Fragment Logic. Finally we give a result that sheds light on how expressive the FMP need be to still be NP-Complete. The result gives a second NP-Complete reduction of the FMP, this time to Tripartite Matching. We conclude with a wide assortment of suggested additional problems.

A vertex set $U \subseteq V$ of an undirected graph $G=(V,E)$ is a \textit{resolving set} for $G$ if for every two distinct vertices $u,v \in V$ there is a vertex $w \in U$ such that the distance between $u$ and $w$ and the distance between $v$ and $w$ are different. A resolving set $U$ is {\em fault-tolerant} if for every vertex $u\in U$ set $U\setminus \{u\}$ is still a resolving set. {The \em (fault-tolerant) Metric Dimension} of $G$ is the size of a smallest (fault-tolerant) resolving set for $G$. The {\em weighted (fault-tolerant) Metric Dimension} for a given cost function $c: V \longrightarrow \mathbb{R}_+$ is the minimum weight of all (fault-tolerant) resolving sets. Deciding whether a given graph $G$ has (fault-tolerant) Metric Dimension at most $k$ for some integer $k$ is known to be NP-complete. The weighted fault-tolerant Metric Dimension problem has not been studied extensively so far. In this paper we show that the weighted fault-tolerant metric dimension problem can be solved in linear time on cographs.

Supergrid graphs contain grid graphs and triangular grid graphs as their subgraphs. The Hamiltonian cycle and path problems for general supergrid graphs were known to be NP-complete. A graph is called Hamiltonian if it contains a Hamiltonian cycle, and is said to be Hamiltonian connected if there exists a Hamiltonian path between any two distinct vertices in it. In this paper, we first prove that every L-shaped supergrid graph always contains a Hamiltonian cycle except one trivial condition. We then verify the Hamiltonian connectivity of L-shaped supergrid graphs except few conditions. The Hamiltonicity and Hamiltonian connectivity of L-shaped supergrid graphs can be applied to compute the minimum trace of computerized embroidery machine and 3D printer when a L-like object is printed. Finally, we present a linear-time algorithm to compute the longest (s, t)-path of L-shaped supergrid graph given two distinct vertices s and t.

One of the most intriguing unsolved questions of matroid optimization is the characterization of the existence of $k$ disjoint common bases of two matroids. The significance of the problem is well-illustrated by the long list of conjectures that can be formulated as special cases, such as Woodall's conjecture on packing disjoint dijoins in a directed graph, or Rota's beautiful conjecture on rearrangements of bases. In the present paper we prove that the problem is difficult under the rank oracle model, i.e., we show that there is no algorithm which decides if the common ground set of two matroids can be partitioned into $k$ common bases by using a polynomial number of independence queries. Our complexity result holds even for the very special case when $k=2$. Through a series of reductions, we also show that the abstract problem of packing common bases in two matroids includes the NAE-SAT problem and the Perfect Even Factor problem in directed graphs. These results in turn imply that the problem is not only difficult in the independence oracle model but also includes NP-complete special cases already when $k=2$, one of the matroids is a partition matroid, while the other matroid is linear and is given by an explicit representation.

A hole in a graph G is an induced cycle of length at least four; an antihole is a hole in the complement of G. In 2005, Chudnovsky, Cornuejols, Liu, Seymour and Vuskovic showed that it is possible to test in polynomial time whether a graph contains an odd hole or antihole (and thus whether G is perfect). However, the complexity of testing for odd holes has remained open. Indeed, it seemed quite likely that testing for an odd hole was NP-complete: for instance, Bienstock showed that testing if a graph has an odd hole containing a given vertex is NP-complete. In this paper we resolve the question, by giving a polynomial-time algorithm to test whether a graph contains an odd hole. This also gives a new and considerably simpler polynomial-time algorithm that tests for perfection.

We address the question of whether it may be worthwhile to convert certain, now classical, NP-complete problems to one of a smaller number of kernel NP-complete problems. In particular, we show that Karp's classical set of 21 NP-complete problems contains a kernel subset of six problems with the property that each problem in the larger set can be converted to one of these six problems with only linear growth in problem size. This finding has potential applications in optimisation theory because the kernel subset includes 0-1 integer programming, job sequencing and undirected Hamiltonian cycle problems.

In this paper, we generalize the concept of complete coloring and achromatic number to 2-edge-colored graphs and signed graphs. We give some useful relationships between different possible definitions of such achromatic numbers and prove that computing any of them is NP-complete.

We consider 1-skeletons of the symmetric and asymmetric traveling salesperson polytopes whose vertices are all possible Hamiltonian tours in the complete directed or undirected graph, and the edges are geometric edges or one-dimensional faces of the polytope. It is known that the question whether two vertices of the symmetric or asymmetric traveling salesperson polytopes are nonadjacent is NP-complete. A sufficient condition for nonadjacency can be formulated as a combinatorial problem: if from the edges of two Hamiltonian tours we can construct two complementary Hamiltonian tours, then the corresponding vertices of the traveling salesperson polytope are not adjacent. We consider a heuristic simulated annealing approach to solve this problem. It is based on finding a vertex-disjoint cycle cover and a perfect matching. The algorithm has a one-sided error: the answer "not adjacent" is always correct, and was tested on random and pyramidal Hamiltonian tours.

A set $S$ of vertices in a graph is an open packing if (open) neighborhoods of any two distinct vertices in $S$ are disjoint. In this paper, we consider the graphs that have a unique maximum open packing. We characterize the trees with this property by using four local operations such that any nontrivial tree with a unique maximum open packing can be obtained by a sequence of these operations starting from $P_2$. We also prove that the decision version of the open packing number is NP-complete even when restricted to graphs of girth at least $6$. Finally, we show that the recognition of the graphs with a unique maximum open packing is polynomially equivalent to the recognition of the graphs with a unique maximum independent set, and we prove that the complexity of both problems is not polynomial, unless P=NP.

Phylogenetic networks are a generalization of phylogenetic trees to leaf-labeled directed acyclic graphs that represent ancestral relationships between species whose past includes non-tree-like events such as hybridization and horizontal gene transfer. Indeed, each phylogenetic network embeds a collection of phylogenetic trees. Referring to the collection of trees that a given phylogenetic network $N$ embeds as the display set of $N$, several questions in the context of the display set of $N$ have recently been analyzed. For example, the widely studied Tree-Containment problem asks if a given phylogenetic tree is contained in the display set of a given network. The focus of this paper are two questions that naturally arise in comparing the display sets of two phylogenetic networks. First, we analyze the problem of deciding if the display sets of two phylogenetic networks have a tree in common. Surprisingly, this problem turns out to be NP-complete even for two temporal normal networks. Second, we investigate the question of whether or not the display sets of two phylogenetic networks are equal. While we recently showed that this problem is polynomial-time solvable for a normal and a tree-child network, it is computationally hard in the general case. In establishing hardness, we show that the problem is contained in the second level of the polynomial-time hierarchy. Specifically, it is $Π_2^P$-complete. Along the way, we show that two other problems are also $Π_2^P$-complete, one of which being a generalization of Tree-Containment.

Grundy functions have found many applications in a wide variety of games, in solving relevant problems in Game Theory. Many authors have been working on this topic for over many years. Since the existence of a Grundy function on a digraph implies that it must have a kernel, the problem of deciding if a digraph has a Grundy function is NP-complete, and how to calculate one is not clearly answered. In this paper, we introduce the concept: Semi-Grundy function, which arises naturally from the connection between kernel and semi-kernel and the connection between kernel and Grundy function. We explore the relationship of this concept with the Grundy function, proving that for digraphs with a defining hereditary property is sufficient to get a semi-grundy function to obtain a Grundy function. Then we prove sufficient and necessary conditions for some products of digraphs to have a semi-Grundy function. Also, it is shown a relationship between the size of the semi-Grundy function obtained for the Cartesian Product and the size of the semi-Grundy functions of the factors. This size is an upper bound of the chromatic number. We present a family of digraphs with the following property: for each natural number $n\geq 2$, there is a digraph $R_n$ that has two Grundy functions such that the difference between their maximum values is equal to n. Then it is important to have bounds for the Grundy or semi-Grundy functions.

We show that deciding if a given vector is the degree sequence of a 3-hypergraph is NP-complete.

Clique-width is a well-studied graph parameter owing to its use in understanding algorithmic tractability: if the clique-width of a graph class ${\cal G}$ is bounded by a constant, a wide range of problems that are NP-complete in general can be shown to be polynomial-time solvable on ${\cal G}$. For this reason, the boundedness or unboundedness of clique-width has been investigated and determined for many graph classes. We survey these results for hereditary graph classes, which are the graph classes closed under taking induced subgraphs. We then discuss the algorithmic consequences of these results, in particular for the Colouring and Graph Isomorphism problems. We also explain a possible strong connection between results on boundedness of clique-width and on well-quasi-orderability by the induced subgraph relation for hereditary graph classes.

For a given $π=(π_0, π_1,..., π_k) \in \{0, 1, *\}^{k+1}$, we want to determine whether an input $k$-uniform hypergraph $G=(V, E)$ has a partition $(V_1, V_2)$ of the vertex set so that for all $X \subseteq V$ of size $k$, $X \in E$ if $π_{|X\cap V_1|}=1$ and $X \notin E$ if $π_{|X\cap V_1|}=0$. We prove that this problem is either polynomial-time solvable or NP-complete depending on $π$ when $k=3$ or $4$. We also extend this result into $k$-uniform hypergraphs for $k \geq 5$.

Given a linear equation L, a set A of integers is L-free if A does not contain any non-trivial solutions to L. Meeks and Treglown showed that for certain kinds of linear equations, it is NP-complete to decide if a given set of integers contains a solution-free subset of a given size. Also, for equations involving three variables, they showed that the problem of determining the size of the largest solution-free subset is APX-hard, and that for two such equations (representing sum-free and progression-free sets), the problem of deciding if there is a solution-free subset with at least a specified proportion of the elements is also NP-complete. We answer a number of questions posed by Meeks and Treglown, by extending the results above to all linear equations, and showing that the problems remain hard for sets of integers whose elements are polynomially bounded in the size of the set. For most of these results, the integers can all be positive as long as the coefficients do not all have the same sign. We also consider the problem of counting the number of solution-free subsets of a given set, and show that this problem is #P-complete for any linear equation in at least three variables.

The independence gap of a graph was introduced by Ekim et al. (2018) as a measure of how far a graph is from being well-covered. It is defined as the difference between the maximum and minimum size of a maximal independent set. We investigate the independence gap of a graph from structural and algorithmic points of view, with a focus on classes of perfect graphs. Generalizing results on well-covered graphs due to Dean and Zito (1994) and Hujdurović et al. (2018), we express the independence gap of a perfect graph in terms of clique partitions and use this characterization to develop a polynomial-time algorithm for recognizing graphs of constant independence gap in any class of perfect graphs of bounded clique number. Next, we introduce a hereditary variant of the parameter, which we call hereditary independence gap and which measures the maximum independence gap over all induced subgraphs of the graph. We show that determining whether a given graph has hereditary independence gap at most $k$ is polynomial-time solvable if $k$ is fixed and co-NP-complete if $k$ is part of input. We also investigate the complexity of the independent set problem in graph classes related to independence gap, showing that the problem is NP-complete in the class of graphs of independence gap at most one and polynomial-time solvable in any class of graphs with bounded hereditary independence gap. Combined with some known results on claw-free graphs, our results imply that the independent domination problem is solvable in polynomial time in the class of $\{$claw, 2$P_3\}$-free graphs.

The Min-$q$-Multiset Multicover problem presented in this paper is a special version of the Multiset Multicover problem. For a fixed positive integer $q$, we are given a finite ground set $J$, an integral demand for each element in $J$ and a collection of subsets of $J$. The task is to choose sets of the collection (multiple choices are allowed) such that each element in $J$ is covered at least as many times as specified by the demand of the element. In contrast to Multiset Multicover, in Min-$q$-Multiset Multicover each of the chosen subsets may only cover up to $q$ of its elements with multiple choices being allowed. Our main focus is a robust version of Min-$q$-Multiset Multicover, called Robust Min-$q$-Multiset Multicover, in which the demand of each element in $J$ may vary in a given interval with an additional budget constraint bounding the sum of the demands. Again, the task is to find a selection of subsets which is feasible for all admissible demands. We show that the non-robust version is NP-complete for $q$ greater than two, whereas the robust version is strongly NP-hard for any positive $q$. Furthermore, we present two solution approaches based on constraint generation and investigate the corresponding separation problems. We present computational results using randomly generated instances as well as instances emerging from the problem of locating emergency doctors.

The status of a vertex $v$ in a connected graph is the sum of the distances from $v$ to all other vertices. The status sequence of a connected graph is the list of the statuses of all the vertices of the graph. In this paper we investigate the status sequences of trees. Particularly, we show that it is NP-complete to decide whether there exists a tree that has a given sequence of integers as its status sequence. We also present some results about trees whose status sequences are comprised of a few distinct numbers or many distinct numbers. In this direction, we provide a partial answer to a conjecture of Shang and Lin from 2011, showing that any status injective tree is unique among trees. Finally, we investigate how orbit partitions and equitable partitions relate to the status sequence.

It has been shown by Bokal et al. that deciding 2-colourability of digraphs is an NP-complete problem. This result was later on extended by Feder et al. to prove that deciding whether a digraph has a circular $p$-colouring is NP-complete for all rational $p>1$. In this paper, we consider the complexity of corresponding decision problems for related notions of fractional colourings for digraphs and graphs, including the star dichromatic number, the fractional dichromatic number and the circular vertex arboricity. We prove the following results: Deciding if the star dichromatic number of a digraph is at most $p$ is NP-complete for every rational $p>1$. Deciding if the fractional dichromatic number of a digraph is at most $p$ is NP-complete for every $p>1, p \neq 2$. Deciding if the circular vertex arboricity of a graph is at most $p$ is NP-complete for every rational $p>1$. To show these results, different techniques are required in each case. In order to prove the first result, we relate the star dichromatic number to a new notion of homomorphisms between digraphs, called circular homomorphisms, which might be of independent interest. We provide a classification of the computational complexities of the corresponding homomorphism colouring problems similar to the one derived by Feder et al. for acyclic homomorphisms.

Let $G$ be a nontrivial connected, edge-colored graph. An edge-cut $S$ of $G$ is called a rainbow cut if no two edges in $S$ are colored with a same color. An edge-coloring of $G$ is a rainbow disconnection coloring if for every two distinct vertices $s$ and $t$ of $G$, there exists a rainbow cut $S$ in $G$ such that $s$ and $t$ belong to different components of $G\setminus S$. For a connected graph $G$, the {\it rainbow disconnection number} of $G$, denoted by $rd(G)$, is defined as the smallest number of colors such that $G$ has a rainbow disconnection coloring by using this number of colors. In this paper, we show that for a connected graph $G$, computing $rd(G)$ is NP-hard. In particular, it is already NP-complete to decide if $rd(G)=3$ for a connected cubic graph. Moreover, we prove that for a given edge-colored (with an unbounded number of colors) connected graph $G$ it is NP-complete to decide whether $G$ is rainbow disconnected.