arXiv++ Combinatorics

We prove a cyclic sieving result for the action of promotion on the staircase plane partitions of height two. Our proof has two major algebraic inputs: an interpretation of this promotion action in terms of tensor powers of the spin crystal that was recently studied by Pappe--Pfannerer--Schilling--Simone, and the bush basis of the degree two part of the coordinate ring of the space of electrical networks that was recently introduced by Gao--Lam--Xu. Moreover, we explain how the existence of an electrical canonical basis in all degrees would yield cyclic sieving for promotion of staircase plane partitions of all heights.

Let $G$ be a finite abelian group of order $n$, and let $\mathsf M(G,m)$ denote the set of zero-sum sequences over $G$ of length $m$. We introduce the zero-sum polytope $\mathcal P_G$, a rational polytope of dimension $n-1$, whose lattice points encode zero-sum sequences: \[ |\mathsf M(G,m)|=|m\mathcal P_G\cap \mathbb Z^n|. \] This naturally realizes the enumeration of zero-sum sequences as a problem in rational Ehrhart theory, which leads to a combinatorial reciprocity theorem identifying the negative evaluations of the corresponding counting quasipolynomial with zero-sum sequences of full support. Our main results establish a face-stratified rigidity for zero-sum polytopes: whenever two such polytopes have equal total lattice point counts at specific dilations, the dimension-wise open-face strata are equinumerous. Moreover, we study the natural $\operatorname{Aut}(G)$-action on $\mathcal P_G$, derive equivariant generating functions and reciprocity formulas, and obtain cyclic sieving phenomena for natural cyclic actions.

In 2024, Ceballos and Chenevi{è}re introduced alt $ν$-Tamari lattices, parameterized by a lattice path $ν$ and an increment vector $δ$, as a common generalization of $ν$-Tamari and $ν$-Dyck lattices. We study rowmotion on two families: the alt hook-Tamari lattice $\mathsf{H}_δ(a,b)$ (where $ν=EN^{a-1}E^{b-1}N$) and the alt $2$-row-Tamari lattice $\mathsf{T}_δ(a,b)$ (where $ν=E^aNE^bN$). We explicitly determine the orbit structures of $\mathsf{H}_δ(a,b)$ and $\mathsf{T}_δ(a,b)$ under rowmotion, and prove that their orbit structures are independent of the increment vector $δ$. As a consequence, we show that rowmotion on $\mathsf{H}_δ(a,b)$ exhibits the cyclic sieving phenomenon. We also compute orbit sums for several natural statistics. In the hook case, we evaluate the down-degree, peak, valley, and area statistics; in the $2$-row case, we focus on the down-degree statistic. All of these -- except for the area statistic -- are homometric under rowmotion. Regarding the methodology of this paper, our results in the hook case are obtained by applying a simple local modification to their Hasse diagrams. In the $2$-row case, we introduce a switching property for semidistributive lattices, which allows us to compare the orbit structures arising from different increment vectors.

Agustín-Aquino solved, in terms of the table of marks of $\Aff(\mathbb{Z}/2k\mathbb{Z})$, the problem of enumerating the classes of bicolour self-complementary and rigid patterns in $\mathbb{Z}/2k\mathbb{Z}$ (also known as \emph{strong dichotomy classes}). In particular, the rigid pattern-inventory polynomial appeared, for odd $k$, to yield the number of strong classes with negative sign when evaluated in $-1$, and it was conjectured that this is true for $k$ a power of an odd prime. Here we prove the conjecture is true for $k$ odd in general.

In this paper, we present examples of the cyclic sieving phenomenon coming from studying independent sets in graphs of a fixed size k. Given a graph G, and a cyclic group C acting on the graph, then C also acts on the collection of independent sets of G of a fixed size k. We exhibit cyclic sieving phenomena for a cyclic group acting on the collection of independent sets of powers of cycle graphs. As a corollary, we also find a closed formula for the number of independent sets of a given size in the power of a cycle graph, and in the power of a path. We also show how the graph construction of whiskering can be used to obtain new cyclic sieving phenomena from old phenomena. We also discuss recursive techniques to exhibit cyclic sieving phenomena for the independent sets of gear graphs, helm graphs, and book graphs.

The cyclic sieving phenomenon was introduced by Reiner, Stanton and White in 2004 as a generalization of Stembridge's $q=-1$ phenomenon. In a paper from 2008, Eu and Fu studied many occurrences of this phenomenon on the faces of the generalized cluster complex with the action of the Fomin-Reading rotation in the classical types $A_n$, $B_n$, $D_n$ and $I_2(k)$. There was yet no known uniform $q$-analogue of the $k$-face numbers of these complexes. In a more recent paper from 2023, Douvropoulos and Josuat-Vergès provided a refinement of the enumeration of the faces of the generalized cluster complex using a uniform formula. For a parabolic subgroup $W_X \subset W$ of the associated Coxeter group $W$, their formula factorises nicely under the assumption that $N_W(W_X)/W_X$ acts as a reflection group on $X$, which is very often the case. Using this condition, we provide a uniform refinement of these cyclic sieving phenomena using a $q$-analogue of their main formula with a type by type proof based on the classification of finite irreducible Coxeter groups.

Recently, Armon and Swanson introduced signed standard tableaux and a corresponding super major index that refines the classical major index. In this paper, we prove that signed standard tableaux of rectangular shape exhibit a cyclic sieving phenomenon (CSP) under the combined action of Schützenberger promotion and cyclic shift of the signs, with the sieving polynomial given by the super major index generating function. This extends Rhoades's celebrated CSP for standard Young tableaux. Furthermore, by considering Cartesian products of tableaux, we generalize this result to arbitrary non-rectangular shapes.

The cyclic sieving phenomenon (CSP) provides valuable data about symmetry classes of cyclic actions, and has applications to representation theory. In this paper, we enumerate domino tableaux of shape 2-by-n, and use this result to prove a new CSP on these objects. We then enumerate the rectangular domino tableaux of any dimensions, and conjecture a more general CSP on rectangular domino tableaux. As a consequence of the enumerative results, we obtain several identities involving Fibonacci and Catalan numbers.

We prove cyclic sieving phenomena satisfied by corner-rooted plane trees (alias ordered trees). The sets of rooted plane trees that we consider are: (1) all trees with $n$ nodes; (2) all trees with $n$ nodes and $k$ leaves; (3) all trees with a given degree distribution of the nodes. Moreover, we consider four different cyclic group actions: (1) the root is moved to the next corner along a tour of the tree; (2) only trees in which the root is at a leaf are considered, and the action moves the root to the next leaf; (3) only trees in which the root is at a non-leaf are considered, and the action moves the root to the next non-leaf corner; (4) only trees in which the root is at a node of degree $δ$ are considered, for a fixed $δ$, and the action moves the root to the next corner of this type. We prove a cyclic sieving phenomenon for each meaningful combination of these sets and actions. As a bonus, we also establish corresponding cyclic sieving phenomena for tree-rooted planar maps.

Promotion has been well-studied for rectangular standard Young tableaux, in which case the orbit lengths divide the total number of boxes and are described by a cyclic sieving phenomenon (CSP), but little is known about the orbit lengths for tableaux of general shape. We approach this problem by building a stable sequence of tableaux where we fix the bottom portion and add extra boxes to the first row to get $n$ total boxes, with $n$ varying. We show that for 2-row tableaux with a fixed bottom row, the orbit lengths are divisors of certain monic polynomials in $n$, with degree generally equal to the number of distinct lengths of runs of consecutive numbers in the bottom row. For the subsets of 2-row tableaux where all runs have the same length, we show that the orbit lengths are characterized by a CSP polynomial that is a slightly modified version of the major index generating function, like in the rectangle case. We also show that for any stable sequence of tableaux, the orbit lengths are linear in $n$ as long as all non-first-row entries differ from each other by at least 2, which asymptotically happens for almost all tableaux in the limit as $n\to\infty.$ We also calculate the orbit lengths for near-hook tableaux, which are divisors of certain linear or quadratic polynomials in $n$.

We exhibit two instances of the cyclic sieving phenomenon - one on dissections of a polygon of a fixed type and one on triangulations of a once-punctured polygon. We use these results to give refined enumerations of certain families of frieze patterns. We also give an interpretation of finite, positive integral frieze patterns fixed under nontrivial rotations as frieze patterns from a family of orbifolds and show that these are always unitary. Finally, we give a bijection between Holm-Jorgensen frieze patterns and p-Dyck paths, extending a recent construction of Canadas, Espinosa, Gaviria, and Rios, and discuss an induced rotation map on Dyck paths. Several conjectures and questions for future study are highlighted throughout the article.

We will exhibit several instances of the cyclic sieving phenomenon involving statistics and involutions on the following combinatorial families of objects: permutations, set partitions, perfect matchings, D-permutations (and its subclasses). Our results will be based on continued fraction identities enumerating these objects. Our instances of cyclic sieving phenomenon for permutations involve the Corteel involution; this was first studied by Adams, Elder, Lafrenière, McNicholas, Striker and Welch (arxiv~2024). We will reprove several of their results using our setting of continued fractions; we will also prove two of their conjectures. Our study of set partitions and perfect matchings will involve the Kasraoui-Zeng involution and the Chen-Deng-Du-Stanley-Yan (CDDSY) involution. Finally, for D-permutations, we will construct a new involution which we call the Genocchi-Corteel involution. The common feature of all of these involutions, other than the CDDSY involution, is that they are constructed via bijections to weighted lattice paths, and that they exchange crossings and nestings on their respective objects.

The displacement of a car with respect to a parking function is the number of spots it must drive past its preferred spot in order to park. An $\ell$-interval parking function is one in which each car has displacement at most $\ell$. Among our results, we enumerate $\ell$-interval parking functions with respect to statistics such as inversion, displacement, and major index. We show that $1$-interval parking functions with fixed displacement exhibit a cyclic sieving phenomenon. We give closed formulas for the number of $1$-interval parking functions with a fixed number of inversions. We prove that a well-known bijection of Foata preserves the set of $\ell$-interval parking functions exactly when $\ell\leq 2$ or $\ell\geq n-2$, which implies that the inversion and major index statistics are equidistributed in these cases.

We study positive $m$-divisible non-crossing partitions and their positive Kreweras maps. In classical types, we describe their combinatorial realisations as certain non-crossing set partitions. We also realise these positive Kreweras maps as pseudo-rotations on a circle, respectively on an annulus. We enumerate positive $m$-divisible non-crossing partitions in classical types that are invariant under powers of the positive Kreweras maps with respect to several parameters. In order to cope with the exceptional types, we develop a different combinatorial model in general type describing positive $m$-divisible non-crossing partitions that are invariant under powers of the positive Kreweras maps. We finally show that altogether these results establish several cyclic sieving phenomena.

Given a fixed integer $n\geq 2$, we construct two new finite lattices that we call the cyclic Tamari lattice and the affine Tamari lattice. The cyclic Tamari lattice is a sublattice and a quotient lattice of the cyclic Dyer lattice, which is the infinite lattice of translation-invariant total orders under containment of inversion sets. The affine Tamari lattice is a quotient of the Dyer lattice, which in turn is a quotient of the cyclic Dyer lattice and is isomorphic to the collection of biclosed sets of the root system of type $\widetilde{A}_{n-1}$ under inclusion. We provide numerous combinatorial and algebraic descriptions of these lattices using translation-invariant total orders, translation-invariant binary in-ordered trees, noncrossing arc diagrams, torsion classes, triangulations, and translation-invariant noncrossing partitions. The cardinalities of the cyclic and affine Tamari lattices are the Catalan numbers of types $B_n$ and $D_n$, respectively. We show that these lattices are self-dual and semidistributive, and we describe their decompositions coming from the Fundamental Theorem of Finite Semidistributive Lattices. We also show that the rowmotion operators on these lattices have well-behaved orbit structures, which we describe via the cyclic sieving phenomenon. Our new combinatorial framework allows us to prove that the lengths of maximal green sequences for the completed path algebra of the oriented $n$-cycle are precisely the integers in the interval $[2n-1,\binom{n+1}{2}]$.

We conjecture that, if the quotient of two $q$-binomial coefficients with the same top argument is a polynomial, then it has non-negative coefficients. We summarise what is known about the conjecture and prove it in two non-trivial cases. Moreover, we move ahead to extend our conjecture to D. Stanton's fake Gaussian sequences. As a corollary we obtain that a polynomial that is conjectured to be a cyclic sieving polynomial for Kreweras words [S. Hopkins and M. Rubey, Selecta Math. (N.S.) 28 (2022), Paper No. 10] is indeed a polynomial with non-negative integer coefficients.

The two subjects in the title are related via the specialization of symmetric polynomials at roots of unity. Let $f(z_1,\ldots,z_n)\in\mathbb{Z}[z_1,\ldots,z_n]$ be a symmetric polynomial with integer coefficients and let $ω$ be a primitive $d$th root of unity. If $d|n$ or $d|(n-1)$ then we have $f(1,\ldots,ω^{n-1})\in\mathbb{Z}$. If $d|n$ then of course we have $f(ω,\ldots,ω^n)=f(1,\ldots,ω^{n-1})\in\mathbb{Z}$, but when $d|(n+1)$ we also have $f(ω,\ldots,ω^n)\in\mathbb{Z}$. We investigate these three families of integers in the case $f=h_k^{(b)}$, where $h_k^{(b)}$ is the coefficient of $t^k$ in the generating function $\prod_{i=1}^n (1+z_it+\cdots+(z_it)^{b-1})$. These polynomials were previously considered by several authors. They interpolate between the elementary symmetric polynomials ($b$=2) and the complete homogeneous symmetric polynomials ($b\to\infty$). When $\gcd(b,d)=1$ with $d|n$ or $d|(n-1)$ we find that the integers $h_k^{(b)}=(1,ω,\ldots,ω^{n-1})$ are related to cyclic sieving of multisets with multiplicities bounded above by $b$, generalizing the well know cyclic sieving results for sets ($b=2$) and multisets ($b\to \infty$). When $\gcd(b,d)=1$ and $d|(n+1)$ we find that the integers $h_k^{(b)}(ω,ω^2,\ldots,ω^n)$ are related to the Frobenius coin problem with two coins. The case $\gcd(b,d)\neq 1$ is more complicated. At the end of the paper we combine these results with the expansion of $h_k^{(b)}$ in various bases of the ring of symmetric polynomials.

The cyclic sieving phenomenon provides a link between a polynomial analogue of Gauss congruence known as $q$-Gauss congruence, and a combinatorial analogue of Gauss congruence based on sequences of cyclic group actions. We strengthen this link in two major ways: by characterising $q$-Gauss congruence via explicit formulae, and by developing a universal model for the combinatorics based on necklaces which allow beads to vary in both colour and length. This gives many novel examples of cyclic sieving involving necklaces, path walks, tubings and more. We extend the definition of Gauss congruence to sequences indexed by an arbitrary ranked semigroup, and synthesise known results into this theory.

Inspired by recent work on refraction billiards in dynamics, we introduce a notion of refraction for combinatorial billiards. This allows us to define a generalization of toric promotion that we call toric promotion with reflections and refractions, which is a dynamical system defined via a graph $G$ whose edges are partitioned into a set of reflection edges and a set of refraction edges. This system is a discretization of a billiards system in which a beam of light can pass through, reflect off of, or refract through each toric hyperplane in a toric arrangement. Vastly generalizing the main theorem known about toric promotion, we give a simple formula for the orbit structure of toric promotion with reflections and refractions when $G$ is a forest. We also completely describe the orbit sizes when $G$ is a cycle with an even number of refraction edges; this result is new even for ordinary toric promotion (i.e., when there are no refraction edges). When $G$ is a cycle of even size with no reflection edges, we obtain an interesting instance of the cyclic sieving phenomenon.

We perform a systematic study of permutation statistics and bijective maps on permutations using SageMath to search the FindStat combinatorial statistics database to identify apparent instances of the cyclic sieving phenomenon (CSP). Cyclic sieving occurs on a set of objects, a statistic, and a map of order $n$ when the evaluation of the statistic generating function at the $d$th power of the primitive $n$th root of unity equals the number of fixed points under the $d$th power of the map. Of the apparent instances found in our experiment, we prove 34 new instances of the CSP and conjecture three more. Our results are organized largely by orbit structure, proving instances of the CSP for involutions with $2^{n-1}$ fixed points and $2^{\lfloor\frac{n}{2}\rfloor}$ fixed points, as well as maps whose orbits all have the same size. The FindStat maps which exhibit the CSP include a map constructed by Corteel (using a bijection of Foata and Zeilberger) to swap the number of nestings and crossings, the invert Laguerre heap map, a map of Alexandersson and Kebede designed to preserve right-to-left minima, conjugation by the long cycle, as well as reverse, complement, rotation, Lehmer code rotation, and toric promotion. Our results combined with those of [Elder, Lafrenière, McNicholas, Striker, Welch 2023] show that, contrary to common expectations, actions that exhibit homomesy are not necessarily the best candidates for the CSP, and vice versa.