arXiv++ Combinatorics

Turán problems, which concern the minimum density threshold required for the existence of a particular substructure, are among the most fundamental problems in extremal combinatorics. We study Turán problems for hypergraphs with an additional uniformity condition on the edge distribution. This kind of Turán problems was introduced by Erdős and Sós in the 1980s but it took more than 30 years until the first non-trivial exact results were obtained when Glebov, Král' and Volec [Israel J. Math. 211 (2016), 349--366] and Reiher, Rödl and Schacht [J. Eur. Math. Soc. 20 (2018), 1139--1159] determined the uniform Turán density of $K_4^{(3)-}$. Subsequent results exploited the powerful hypergraph regularity method, developed by Gowers and by Nagle, Rödl and Schacht about two decades ago. Central to the study of the uniform Turán density of hypergraphs are palette constructions, which were implicitly introduced by Rödl in the 1980s. We prove that palette constructions always yield tight lower bounds, unconditionally confirming present empirical evidence. This results in new and simpler approaches to determining uniform Turán densities, which completely bypass the use of the hypergraph regularity method.

In extremal combinatorics, it is common to focus on structures that are minimal with respect to a certain property. In particular, critical and list-critical graphs occupy a prominent place in graph coloring theory. Stiebitz, Tuza, and Voigt introduced strongly critical graphs, i.e., graphs that are $k$-critical yet $L$-colorable with respect to every non-constant assignment $L$ of lists of size $k-1$. Here we strengthen this notion and extend it to the framework of DP-coloring (or correspondence coloring) by defining robustly $k$-critical graphs as those that are not $(k-1)$-DP-colorable, but only due to the fact that $χ(G) = k$. We then seek general methods for constructing robustly critical graphs. Our main result is that if $G$ is a critical graph (with respect to ordinary coloring), then the join of $G$ with a sufficiently large clique is robustly critical; this is new even for strong criticality.

Many problems in extremal combinatorics can be reduced to determining the independence number of a specific auxiliary hypergraph. We present two such problems, one from discrete geometry and one from hypergraph Turán theory. Using results on hypergraph colorings by Cooper-Mubayi and Li-Postle, we demonstrate that for those two problems the trivial lower bound on the independence number can be improved upon: Erdős, Graham, Ruzsa and Taylor asked to determine the largest size, denoted by $g(n)$, of a subset $P$ of the grid $[n]^2$ such that every pair of points in $P$ span a different slope. Improving on a lower bound by Zhang from 1993, we show that $$g(n)=Ω\left( \frac{n^{2/3} (\log \log n)^{1/3} }{ \log^{1/3}n} \right).$$ Let $H^r_3$ denote an $r$-graph with $r+1$ vertices and $3$ edges. Recently, Sidorenko proved the following lower bounds for the Turán density of this $r$-graph: $π(H^r_3)\geq r^{-2}$ for every $r$, and $π(H^r_3)\geq (1.7215 - o(1)) r^{-2}$. We present an improved asymptotic bound: $π(H^r_3)=Ω\left(r^{-2} \log^{1/2} r \right).$

The Hoffman ratio bound, Lovász theta function and Schrijver theta function are classical upper bounds for the independence number of graphs, which are useful in graph theory, extremal combinatorics and information theory. By using generalized inverses and eigenvalues of graph matrices, we give bounds for independence sets and the independence number of graphs. Our bounds unify the Lovász theta function, Schrijver theta function and Hoffman-type bounds, and we obtain the necessary and sufficient conditions of graphs attaining these bounds. Our work leads to some simple structural and spectral conditions for determining a maximum independent set, the independence number, the Shannon capacity and the Lovász theta function of a graph.

We use techniques from algebraic and extremal combinatorics to derive upper bounds on the number of independent sets in several (hyper)graphs arising from finite geometry. In this way, we obtain asymptotically sharp upper bounds for partial ovoids and EKR-sets of flags in polar spaces, line spreads in $\mathrm{PG}(2r-1,q)$ and plane spreads in $\mathrm{PG}(5,q)$, and caps in $\mathrm{PG}(3,q)$. The latter result extends work due to Roche-Newton and Warren and Bhowmick and Roche-Newton. Finally, we investigate caps in $p$-random subsets of $\mathrm{PG}(r,q)$, which parallels recent work for arcs in projective planes by Bhowmick and Roche-Newton, and by Roche-Newton and Warren, and arcs in projective spaces by Chen, Liu, Nie and Zeng.

Motivated by an Erdős--Ko--Rado type problem on sets of strongly orthogonal roots in the $A_{\ell}$ root system, we estimate bounds for the size of a family of pairs $(A_{i}, B_{i})$ of $k$-subsets in $\{ 1, 2, \ldots, n\}$ such that $A_{i} \cap B_{j}= \emptyset$ and $|A_{i} \cap A_{j}| + |B_{i} \cap B_{j}| = k$ for all $i \neq j$. This is reminiscent of a classic problem of Bollobás. We provide upper and lower bounds for this problem, relying on classical results of extremal combinatorics and an explicit construction using the incidence matrix of a finite projective plane.

In this paper, we construct explicit families of polynomials $P \in \mathbb{F}_q[x_1,\dots,x_n]$ with large root sets which have restricted intersections with affine lines. We use these sets to make substantial progress on a number of problems in extremal combinatorics. For each prime power $q$ and integer $2 \le t \le q-1$, we construct $t$-line evasive subsets of $\mathbb{F}_q^n$ of size \[ q^{\,n\left(1-\frac{2}{t^2+t}\right)}, \] which is significantly larger than those previously known. Moreover, our method yields a partition of $\mathbb{F}_q^n$ into such sets. We extend this partitioning result to the projective space $PG(n,q)$, obtaining the first explicit colorings for the vector space Ramsey number $R_q(2;k)$ that exhibit dependence on both $q$ and $k$. In particular, we show that \[ R_q(2;k) > \frac{(q-1)k}{2} - O_q(1), \] improving recent bounds. Finally, we apply these constructions to extremal graph theory and improve the best-known bounds on the bipartite Turán number $ \mathrm{ex}(n,m,\{C_4,θ_{3,t}\})$. Most notably, we show that \[ \mathrm{ex}(n,n^{2/3},\{C_4,θ_{3,3}\}) = Θ(n^{1+1/9}), \] making progress on a question originally posed by Erdős.

We establish a novel connection between the well-known chromatic threshold problem in extremal combinatorics and the celebrated $(p,q)$-theorem in discrete geometry. In particular, for a graph $G$ with bounded clique number and a natural density condition, we prove a $(p,q)$-theorem for an abstract convexity space associated with $G$. Our result strengthens those of Thomassen and Nikiforov on the chromatic threshold of cliques. Our $(p,q)$-theorem can also be viewed as a $χ$-boundedness result for (what we call) ultra maximal $K_r$-free graphs. We further show that the graphs under study are blow-ups of constant size graphs, improving a result of Oberkampf and Schacht on homomorphism threshold of cliques. Our result unravels the cause underpinning such a blow-up phenomenon, differentiating the chromatic and homomorphism threshold problems for cliques. It implies that for the homomorphism threshold problem, rather than the minimum degree condition usually considered in the literature, the decisive factor is a clique density condition on co-neighborhoods of vertices. More precisely, we show that if an $n$-vertex $K_{r}$-free graph $G$ satisfies that the common neighborhood of every pair of non-adjacent vertices induces a subgraph with $K_{r-2}$-density at least $\varepsilon>0$, then $G$ must be a blow-up of some $K_r$-free graph $F$ on at most $2^{O(\frac{r}{\varepsilon}\log\frac{1}{\varepsilon})}$ vertices. Furthermore, this single exponential bound is optimal. We construct examples with no $K_r$-free homomorphic image of size smaller than $2^{Ω_r(\frac{1}{\varepsilon})}$.

The study of intersection problems on families of sets is one of the most important topics in extremal combinatorics. As we all know, the extremal problems involving certain intersection constraints are equivalent to that with the union properties by taking complement of sets. A family of sets is called $s$-union if the union of any two sets in this family has size at most $s$. Katona [Acta Math. Hungar. 15 (1964)] provided the maximum size of an $s$-union family of sets of $[n]$, and he also determined the extremal families up to isomorphism. Recently, Frankl [J. Combin. Theory Ser. B 122 (2017) 869--876] sharpened this result by establishing the maximum size of an $s$-union family that is not a subfamily of the so-called Katona family. In this paper, we determine the maximum size of an $s$-union family that is neither contained in the Katona family nor in the Frankl family. Moreover, we characterize all extremal families achieving the upper bounds.

Many well-studied problems in extremal combinatorics deal with the maximum possible size of a family of objects in which every pair of objects satisfies a given restriction. One problem of this type was recently raised by Alon, Gujgiczer, Körner, Milojević and Simonyi. They asked to determine the maximum size of a family $\mathcal{G}$ of graphs on $[n]$, such that for every two $G_1,G_2 \in \mathcal{G}$, the graphs $G_1 \setminus G_2$ and $G_2 \setminus G_1$ are isomorphic. We completely resolve this problem by showing that this maximum is exactly $2^{\frac{1}{2}\big(\binom{n}{2} - \lfloor \frac{n}{2}\rfloor\big)}$ and characterizing all the extremal constructions. We also prove an analogous result for $r$-uniform hypergraphs.

Let $f(n, v, e)$ denote the maximum number of edges in a 3-uniform hypergraph on $n$ vertices which does not contain $v$ vertices spanning at least $e$ edges. A central problem in extremal combinatorics, famously posed by Brown, Erdős and Sós in 1973, asks whether $f(n, e+3, e)=o(n^2)$ for every $e \ge 3$. A classical result of Sárközy and Selkow states that $f(n, e+\lfloor \log_2 e\rfloor+2, e)=o(n^{2})$ for every $e \ge 3$. This bound was recently improved by Conlon, Gishboliner, Levanzov and Shapira. Motivated by applications to other problems, Gowers and Long made the striking conjecture that $f(n, e+4, e)=O(n^{2-\varepsilon})$ for some $\varepsilon=\varepsilon(e)>0$. Conlon, Gishboliner, Levanzov and Shapira, and later, Shapira and Tyomkyn reiterated the following approximate version of this problem. What is the smallest $d(e)$ for which $f(n, e+d(e), e)=O(n^{2-\varepsilon})$ for some $\varepsilon=\varepsilon(e)>0$? In this paper, we prove that for each $e\geq 3$ we have $f(n, e+\lfloor \log_2 e\rfloor +38, e)=O(n^{2-\varepsilon})$ for some $\varepsilon>0$. This shows that one can already obtain power saving near the Sárközy-Selkow bound at the cost of a small additive constant.

$N_\infty$-operads are an equivariant generalization of $E_\infty$-operads introduced by Blumberg and Hill to study structural problems in equivariant stable homotopy theory. In the original paper introducing these objects, Blumberg and Hill raised the question of classifying $N_\infty$-operads that are weakly equivalent to a particularly nice kind of $N_\infty$-operad called a linear isometries operad. For some groups there is a known classification of linear isometries operads up to weak equivalence in terms of certain combinatorially defined objects called saturated transfer systems, but this classification is known to be invalid in general. Various authors have made incremental progress on understanding the domain of validity for this classification, but even among cyclic groups the validity is unknown in general. We determine essentially all the finite Abelian groups for which the classification is valid using techniques from algebra and extremal combinatorics.

Permutation pattern-avoidance is a central concept of both enumerative and extremal combinatorics. In this paper we study the effect of permutation pattern-avoidance on the complexity of optimization problems. In the context of the dynamic optimality conjecture (Sleator, Tarjan, STOC 1983), Chalermsook, Goswami, Kozma, Mehlhorn, and Saranurak (FOCS 2015) conjectured that the amortized search cost of an optimal binary search tree (BST) is constant whenever the search sequence is pattern-avoiding. The best known bound to date is $2^{α{(n)}(1+o(1))}$ recently obtained by Chalermsook, Pettie, and Yingchareonthawornchai (SODA 2024); here $n$ is the BST size and $α(\cdot)$ the inverse-Ackermann function. In this paper we resolve the conjecture, showing a tight $O(1)$ bound. This indicates a barrier to dynamic optimality: any candidate online BST (e.g., splay trees or greedy trees) must match this optimum, but current analysis techniques only give superconstant bounds. More broadly, we argue that the easiness of pattern-avoiding input is a general phenomenon, not limited to BSTs or even to data structures. To illustrate this, we show that when the input avoids an arbitrary, fixed, a priori unknown pattern, one can efficiently compute a $k$-server solution of $n$ requests from a unit interval, with total cost $n^{O(1/\log k)}$, in contrast to the worst-case $Θ(n/k)$ bound; and a traveling salesman tour of $n$ points from a unit box, of length $O(\log{n})$, in contrast to the worst-case $Θ(\sqrt{n})$ bound; similar results hold for the euclidean minimum spanning tree, Steiner tree, and nearest-neighbor graphs. We show both results to be tight. Our techniques build on the Marcus-Tardos proof of the Stanley-Wilf conjecture, and on the recently emerging concept of twin-width.

For a finite poset (partially ordered set) $U$ and a natural number $n$, let Sp$(U,n)$ denote the largest number of pairwise unrelated copies of $U$ in the powerset lattice (AKA subset lattice) of an $n$-element set. If $U$ is the singleton poset, then Sp$(U,n)$ was determined by E. Sperner in 1928; this result is well known in extremal combinatorics. Later, exactly or asymptotically, Sperner's theorem was extended to other posets by A. P. Dove, J. R. Griggs, G. O. H. Katona, D Nagy, J. Stahl, and W. T. Jr. Trotter. We determine Sp$(U,n)$ for all finite posets with 0 and 1, and we give reasonable estimates for the ``V-shaped'' 3-element poset and the 4-element poset with 0 and three maximal elements. For a lattice $L$, let Gmin($L$) denote the minimum size of generating sets of $L$. We prove that if $U$ is the poset of the join-irreducible elements of a finite distributive lattice $D$, then the function $k\mapsto$ Gmin($D^k)$ is the left adjoint of the function $n\mapsto$ Sp$(U,n)$. This allows us to determine Gmin($D^k)$ in many cases. E.g., for a 5-element distributive lattice $D$, Gmin($D^{2023})=18$ if $D$ is a chain and Gmin($D^{2023})=15$ otherwise. It follows that large direct powers of small distributive lattices are appropriate for our 2021 cryptographic authentication protocol.

These are lecture notes of a course taken in Leipzig 2023, spring semester. It deals with extremal combinatorics, algebraic methods and combinatorial geometry. These are not meant to be exhaustive, and do not contain many proofs that were presented in the course.

Graph density profiles are fundamental objects in extremal combinatorics. Very few profiles are fully known, and all are two-dimensional. We show that even in high dimensions ratios of graph densities and numbers often form the power-sum profile (the limit of the image of the power-sum map) studied recently by Acevedo, Blekherman, Debus and Riener. Our choice of graphs is motivated by recent work by Blekherman, Raymond and Wei on undecidability of polynomial inequalities in graph densities. While the ratios do not determine the complete density profile, they contain high-dimensional information. For instance, to reconstruct the density profile of $4k$-cycles from our results, one needs to solve only one-parameter extremal problems, for any number of $4k$-cycles.

Many important problems in extremal combinatorics can be stated as certifying polynomial inequalities in graph homomorphism numbers, and in particular, many ask to certify pure binomial inequalities. For a fixed collection of graphs $\mathcal{U}$, the tropicalization of the graph profile of $\mathcal{U}$ essentially records all valid pure binomial inequalities involving graph homomorphism numbers for graphs in $\mathcal{U}$. Building upon ideas and techniques described by Blekherman and Raymond in 2022, we compute the tropicalization of the graph profile for $K_1$ and $S_{2,1^k}$-trees, almost-star graphs with one branch containing two edges and $k$ branches containing one edge. This allows pure binomial inequalities in homomorphism numbers (or densities) for these graphs to be verified through an explicit linear program where the number of variables is equal to the number of edges in the biggest $S_{2,1^k}$-tree involved.

We prove a stability result for general $3$-wise correlations over distributions satisfying mild connectivity properties. More concretely, we show that if $Σ,Γ$ and $Φ$ are alphabets of constant size, and $μ$ is a pairwise connected distribution over $Σ\timesΓ\timesΦ$ with no $(\mathbb{Z},+)$ embeddings in which the probability of each atom is $Ω(1)$, then the following holds. Any triplets of $1$-bounded functions $f\colon Σ^n\to\mathbb{C}$, $g\colon Γ^n\to\mathbb{C}$, $h\colon Φ^n\to\mathbb{C}$ satisfying \[ \left|\mathbb{E}_{(x,y,z)\sim μ^{\otimes n}}\big[f(x)g(y)h(z)\big]\right|\geq \varepsilon \] must arise from an Abelian group associated with the distribution $μ$. More specifically, we show that there is an Abelian group $(H,+)$ of constant size such that for any such $f,g$ and $h$, the function $f$ (and similarly $g$ and $h$) is correlated with a function of the form $\tilde{f}(x) = χ(σ(x_1),\ldots,σ(x_n)) L (x)$, where $σ\colon Σ\to H$ is some map, $χ\in \hat{H}^{\otimes n}$ is a character, and $L\colon Σ^n\to\mathbb{C}$ is a low-degree function with bounded $2$-norm. En route we prove a few additional results that may be of independent interest, such as an improved direct product theorem, as well as a result we refer to as a ``restriction inverse theorem'' about the structure of functions that, under random restrictions, with noticeable probability have significant correlation with a product function. In companion papers, we show applications of our results to the fields of Probabilistically Checkable Proofs, as well as various areas in discrete mathematics such as extremal combinatorics and additive combinatorics.

In this paper, we investigate several extremal combinatorics problems that ask for the maximum number of copies of a fixed subgraph given the number of edges. We call problems of this type Kruskal--Katona-type problems. Most of the problems that will be discussed in this paper are related to the joints problem. There are two main results in this paper. First, we prove that, in a $3$-edge-colored graph with $R$ red, $G$ green, $B$ blue edges, the number of rainbow triangles is at most $\sqrt{2RGB}$, which is sharp. Second, we give a generalization of the Kruskal--Katona theorem that implies many other previous generalizations. Both arguments use the entropy method, and the main innovation lies in a more clever argument that improves bounds given by Shearer's inequality.

Let $\mathbf{G}:=(G_1, G_2, G_3)$ be a triple of graphs on the same vertex set $V$ of size $n$. A rainbow triangle in $\mathbf{G}$ is a triple of edges $(e_1, e_2, e_3)$ with $e_i\in G_i$ for each $i$ and $\{e_1, e_2, e_3\}$ forming a triangle in $V$. The triples $\mathbf{G}$ not containing rainbow triangles, also known as Gallai colouring templates, are a widely studied class of objects in extremal combinatorics. In the present work, we fully determine the set of edge densities $(α_1, α_2, α_3)$ such that if $\vert E(G_i)\vert> α_i n^2$ for each $i$ and $n$ is sufficiently large, then $\mathbf{G}$ must contain a rainbow triangle. This resolves a problem raised by Aharoni, DeVos, de la Maza, Montejanos and Šámal, generalises several previous results on extremal Gallai colouring templates, and proves a recent conjecture of Frankl, Györi, He, Lv, Salia, Tompkins, Varga and Zhu.