arXiv++ Combinatorics

We determine the computational complexity of approximately counting and sampling independent sets of a given size in bounded-degree graphs. That is, we identify a critical density $α_c(Δ)$ and provide (i) for $α< α_c(Δ)$ randomized polynomial-time algorithms for approximately sampling and counting independent sets of given size at most $αn$ in $n$-vertex graphs of maximum degree $Δ$; and (ii) a proof that unless NP=RP, no such algorithms exist for $α>α_c(Δ)$. The critical density is the occupancy fraction of the hard core model on the complete graph $K_{Δ+1}$ at the uniqueness threshold on the infinite $Δ$-regular tree, giving $α_c(Δ)\sim\frac{e}{1+e}\frac{1}Δ$ as $Δ\to\infty$. Our methods apply more generally to anti-ferromagnetic 2-spin systems and motivate new questions in extremal combinatorics.

For any given graph $H$, one may define a natural corresponding functional $\|.\|_H$ for real-valued functions by using homomorphism density. One may also extend this to complex-valued functions, once $H$ is paired with a $2$-edge-colouring $α$ to assign conjugates. We say that $H$ is real-norming (resp. complex-norming) if $\|.\|_H$ (resp. $\|.\|_{H,α}$ for some $α$) is a norm on the vector space of real-valued (resp. complex-valued) functions. These generalise the Gowers octahedral norms, a widely used tool in extremal combinatorics to quantify quasirandomness. We unify these two seemingly different notions of graph norms in real- and complex-valued settings. Namely, we prove that $H$ is complex-norming if and only if it is real-norming and simply call the property norming. Our proof does not explicitly construct a suitable $2$-edge-colouring $α$ but obtains its existence and uniqueness, which may be of independent interest. As an application, we give various example graphs that are not norming. In particular, we show that hypercubes are not norming, which resolves the last outstanding problem posed in Hatami's pioneering work on graph norms.

Intersecting families and blocking sets feature prominently in extremal combinatorics. We examine the following generalization of an intersecting family investigated by Hajnal, Rothschild, and others. If $s \geq 1$, $k \geq 2$, and $u \geq 1$ are integers, then say that an $s$-uniform family $\mathcal{F}$ is $(k,u)$-intersecting if for all $A_1, A_2, \cdots, A_k \in \mathcal{F}$, $|A_i \cap A_j| \geq u$ for some $1 \leq i < j \leq k$. In this note, we investigate the following parameter. If $s$, $k$, $u$, $\ell$ are integers satisfying $s \geq 1$, $k \geq 2$, $1 \leq u \leq s$, and $2 \leq \ell < k$, then let $N^{(u)}_{k,\ell}(s)$ denote the smallest integer $r$, if it exists, such that any $(k,u)$-intersecting $s$-uniform family is the union of at most $r$ families that are $(\ell,u)$-intersecting. Using a Sunflower Lemma type argument, we prove that $N^{(u)}_{k,\ell}(s)$ always exists and that the following inequality always holds: $$N^{(u)}_{k,\ell}(s) \; \leq \; \bigg{\lceil} \dfrac{ k - 1 }{\ell - 1} \cdot {s \choose u} \bigg{\rceil}$$

Let $G$ be a graph and $S, T \subseteq V(G)$ be (possibly overlapping) sets of terminals, $|S|=|T|=k$. We are interested in computing a vertex sparsifier for terminal cuts in $G$, i.e., a graph $H$ on a smallest possible number of vertices, where $S \cup T \subseteq V(H)$ and such that for every $A \subseteq S$ and $B \subseteq T$ the size of a minimum $(A,B)$-vertex cut is the same in $G$ as in $H$. We assume that our graphs are unweighted and that terminals may be part of the min-cut. In previous work, Kratsch and Wahlström (FOCS 2012/JACM 2020) used connections to matroid theory to show that a vertex sparsifier $H$ with $O(k^3)$ vertices can be computed in randomized polynomial time, even for arbitrary digraphs $G$. However, since then, no improvements on the size $O(k^3)$ have been shown. In this paper, we draw inspiration from the renowned Bollobás's Two-Families Theorem in extremal combinatorics and introduce the use of total orderings into Kratsch and Wahlström's methods. This new perspective allows us to construct a sparsifier $H$ of $Θ(k^2)$ vertices for the case that $G$ is a DAG. We also show how to compute $H$ in time near-linear in the size of $G$, improving on the previous $O(n^{ω+1})$. Furthermore, $H$ recovers the closest min-cut in $G$ for every partition $(A,B)$, which was not previously known. Finally, we show that a sparsifier of size $Ω(k^2)$ is required, both for DAGs and for undirected edge cuts.

Extremal Combinatorics is among the most active topics in Discrete Mathematics, dealing with problems that are often motivated by questions in other areas, including Theoretical Computer Science and Information Theory. This paper contains a collection of problems and results in the area, including solutions or partial solutions to open problems suggested by various researchers. The topics considered here include questions in Extremal Graph Theory, Coding Theory and Social Choice. This is by no means a comprehensive survey of the area, and is merely a collection of problems, results and proofs, which are hopefully interesting. As the title of the paper suggests, this is a sequel of three previous papers of the same flavour. Each section of this paper is essentially self contained, and can be read separately.

Generalized Turán problems have been a central topic of study in extremal combinatorics throughout the last few decades. One such problem is maximizing the number of cliques of size $t$ in a graph of a fixed order that does not contain any path (or cycle) of length at least a given number. Both of the path-free and cycle-free extremal problems were recently considered and asymptotically solved by Luo. We fully resolve these problems by characterizing all possible extremal graphs. We further extend these results by solving the edge-variant of these problems where the number of edges is fixed instead of the number of vertices. We similarly obtain exact characterization of the extremal graphs for these edge variants.

Since its formulation, Turán's hypergraph problems have been among the most challenging open problems in extremal combinatorics. One of them is the following: given a $3$-uniform hypergraph $\mathcal{F}$ on $n$ vertices in which any five vertices span at least one edge, prove that $|\mathcal{F}| \ge (1/4 -o(1))\binom{n}{3}$. The construction showing that this bound would be best possible is simply $\binom{X}{3} \cup \binom{Y}{3}$ where $X$ and $Y$ evenly partition the vertex set. This construction has the following more general $(2p+1, p+1)$-property: any set of $2p+1$ vertices spans a complete sub-hypergraph on $p+1$ vertices. One of our main results says that, quite surprisingly, for all $p>2$ the $(2p+1,p+1)$-property implies the conjectured lower bound.

Szemeredi's Regularity Lemma is a very useful tool of extremal combinatorics. Recently, several refinements of this seminal result were obtained for special, more structured classes of graphs. We survey these results in their rich combinatorial context. In particular, we stress the link to the theory of (structural) sparsity, which leads to alternative proofs, refinements and solutions of open problems. It is interesting to note that many of these classes present challenging problems. Nevertheless, from the point of view of regularity lemma type statements, they appear as "gentle" classes.

Generalized Turán problems have been a central topic of study in extremal combinatorics throughout the last few decades. One such problem, maximizing the number of cliques of a fixed order in a graph with fixed number of vertices and bounded maximum degree, was recently completely resolved by Chase. Kirsch and Radcliffe raised a natural variant of this problem where the number of edges is fixed instead of the number of vertices. In this paper, we determine the maximum number of cliques of a fixed order in a graph with fixed number of edges and bounded maximum degree, resolving a conjecture by Kirsch and Radcliffe. We also give a complete characterization of the extremal graphs.

Motivated by problems in algebraic complexity theory (e.g., matrix multiplication) and extremal combinatorics (e.g., the cap set problem and the sunflower problem), we introduce the geometric rank as a new tool in the study of tensors and hypergraphs. We prove that the geometric rank is an upper bound on the subrank of tensors and the independence number of hypergraphs. We prove that the geometric rank is smaller than the slice rank of Tao, and relate geometric rank to the analytic rank of Gowers and Wolf in an asymptotic fashion. As a first application, we use geometric rank to prove a tight upper bound on the (border) subrank of the matrix multiplication tensors, matching Strassen's well-known lower bound from 1987.

Let $X_1,\ldots,X_n$ be independent identically distributed random vectors in $\mathbb{R}^d$. We consider upper bounds on $\max_x \mathbb{P}(a_1X_1+\cdots+a_nX_n=x)$ under various restrictions on $X_i$ and the weights $a_i$. When $\mathbb{P}(X_i=\pm 1) = \frac {1} {2}$, this corresponds to the classical Littlewood-Offord problem. We prove that in general for identically distributed random vectors and even values of $n$ the optimal choice for $(a_i)$ is $a_i=1$ for $i\leq \frac{n}{2}$ and $a_i=-1$ for $i > \frac {n} 2$, regardless of the distribution of $X_1$. Applying these results for Bernoulli random variables answers a recent question of Fox, Kwan and Sauermann. Finally, we provide sharp bounds for concentration probabilities of sums of random vectors under the condition $\sup_{x}\mathbb{P}(X_i=x)\leq α$, where it turns out that the worst case scenario is provided by distributions on an arithmetic progression that are in some sense as close to the uniform distribution as possible. An important feature of this work is that unlike much of the literature on the subject we use neither methods of harmonic analysis nor those from extremal combinatorics.

Let $f(n,v,e)$ denote the maximum number of edges in a $3$-uniform hypergraph not containing $e$ edges spanned by at most $v$ vertices. One of the most influential open problems in extremal combinatorics then asks, for a given number of edges $e \geq 3$, what is the smallest integer $d=d(e)$ so that $f(n,e+d,e) = o(n^2)$? This question has its origins in work of Brown, Erdős and Sós from the early 70's and the standard conjecture is that $d(e)=3$ for every $e \geq 3$. The state of the art result regarding this problem was obtained in 2004 by Sárközy and Selkow, who showed that $f(n,e + 2 + \lfloor \log_2 e \rfloor,e) = o(n^2)$. The only improvement over this result was a recent breakthrough of Solymosi and Solymosi, who improved the bound for $d(10)$ from 5 to 4. We obtain the first asymptotic improvement over the Sárközy--Selkow bound, showing that $$ f(n, e + O(\log e/ \log\log e), e) = o(n^2). $$

Generalized Davenport-Schinzel sequences are sequences that avoid a forbidden subsequence and have a sparsity requirement on their letters. Upper bounds on the lengths of generalized Davenport-Schinzel sequences have been applied to a number of problems in discrete geometry and extremal combinatorics. Sharp bounds on the maximum lengths of generalized Davenport-Schinzel sequences are known for some families of forbidden subsequences, but in general there are only rough bounds on the maximum lengths of most generalized Davenport-Schinzel sequences. One method that was developed for finding upper bounds on the lengths of generalized Davenport-Schinzel sequences uses a family of sequences called formations. An $(r, s)$-formation is a concatenation of $s$ permutations of $r$ distinct letters. The formation width function $fw(u)$ is defined as the minimum $s$ for which there exists $r$ such that every $(r, s)$-formation contains $u$. The function $fw(u)$ has been used with upper bounds on extremal functions of $(r, s)$-formations to find tight bounds on the maximum possible lengths of many families of generalized Davenport-Schinzel sequences. Algorithms have been found for computing $fw(u)$ for sequences $u$ of length $n$, but they have worst-case run time exponential in $n$, even for sequences $u$ with only three distinct letters. We present an algorithm for computing $fw(u)$ with run time $O(n^{α_r})$, where $r$ is the number of distinct letters in $u$ and $α_r$ is a constant that only depends on $r$. We implement the new algorithm in Python and compare its run time to the next fastest algorithm for computing formation width. We also apply the new algorithm to find sharp upper bounds on the lengths of several families of generalized Davenport-Schinzel sequences with $3$-letter forbidden patterns.

The notion of cross intersecting set pair system of size $m$, $\Big(\{A_i\}_{i=1}^m, \{B_i\}_{i=1}^m\Big)$ with $A_i\cap B_i=\emptyset$ and $A_i\cap B_j\ne\emptyset$, was introduced by Bollobás and it became an important tool of extremal combinatorics. His classical result states that $m\le {a+b\choose a}$ if $|A_i|\le a$ and $|B_i|\le b$ for each $i$. Our central problem is to see how this bound changes with the additional condition $|A_i\cap B_j|=1$ for $i\ne j$. Such a system is called $1$-cross intersecting. We show that the maximum size of a $1$-cross intersecting set pair system is -- at least $5^{n/2}$ for $n$ even, $a=b=n$, -- equal to $\bigl(\lfloor\frac{n}{2}\rfloor+1\bigr)\bigl(\lceil\frac{n}{2}\rceil+1\bigr)$ if $a=2$ and $b=n\ge 4$, -- at most $|\cup_{i=1}^m A_i|$, -- asymptotically $n^2$ if $\{A_i\}$ is a linear hypergraph ($|A_i\cap A_j|\le 1$ for $i\ne j$), -- asymptotically ${1\over 2}n^2$ if $\{A_i\}$ and $\{B_i\}$ are both linear hypergraphs.

One powerful method for upper-bounding the largest independent set in a graph is the Hoffman bound, which gives an upper bound on the largest independent set of a graph in terms of its eigenvalues. It is easily seen that the Hoffman bound is sharp on the tensor power of a graph whenever it is sharp for the original graph. In this paper, we introduce the related problem of upper-bounding independent sets in tensor powers of hypergraphs. We show that many of the prominent open problems in extremal combinatorics, such as the Turán problem for (hyper-)graphs, can be encoded as special cases of this problem. We also give a new generalization of the Hoffman bound for hypergraphs which is sharp for the tensor power of a hypergraph whenever it is sharp for the original hypergraph. As an application of our Hoffman bound, we make progress on the problem of Frankl on families of sets without extended triangles from 1990. We show that if $\frac{1}{2}n\le2k\le\frac{2}{3}n,$ then the extremal family is the star, i.e. the family of all sets that contains a given element. This covers the entire range in which the star is extremal. As another application, we provide spectral proofs for Mantel's theorem on triangle-free graphs and for Frankl-Tokushige theorem on $k$-wise intersecting families.

We prove a selection of results from different areas of extremal combinatorics, including complete or partial solutions to a number of open problems. These results, coming mainly from extremal graph theory and Ramsey theory, have been collected together because in each case the relevant proofs are reasonably short.

A graphical design is a proper subset of vertices of a graph on which many eigenfunctions of the Laplacian operator have mean value zero. In this paper, we show that extremal independent sets make extremal graphical designs, that is, a design on which the maximum possible number of eigenfunctions have mean value zero. We then provide examples of such graphs and sets, which arise naturally in extremal combinatorics. We also show that sets which realize the isoperimetric constant of a graph make extremal graphical designs, and provide examples for them as well. We investigate the behavior of graphical designs under the operation of weak graph product. In addition, we present a family of extremal graphical designs for the hypercube graph.

Suppose $\mathcal I$ and $\mathcal J$ are proper ideals on some set $X$. We say that $\mathcal I$ and $\mathcal J$ are incompatible if $\mathcal I \cup \mathcal J$ does not generate a proper ideal. Equivalently, $\mathcal I$ and $\mathcal J$ are incompatible if there is some $A \subseteq X$ such that $A \in \mathcal I$ and $X \setminus A \in \mathcal J$. If some $B \subseteq X$ is either in $\mathcal I \setminus \mathcal J$ or in $\mathcal J \setminus \mathcal I$, then we say that $B$ chooses between $\mathcal I$ and $\mathcal J$. We consider the following Ramsey-theoretic problem: Given several pairs $(\mathcal I_1,\mathcal J_1), (\mathcal I_2,\mathcal J_2), \dots, (\mathcal I_k,\mathcal J_k)$ of incompatible ideals on a set $X$, find some $A \subseteq X$ that chooses between as many of these pairs of ideals as possible. The main theorem is that for every $n \in \mathbb N$, there is some $I(n) \in \mathbb N$ such that given at least $I(n)$ pairs of incompatible ideals on any set $X$, there is some $A \subseteq X$ choosing between at least $n$ of them. This theorem is proved in two main steps. The first step is to identify a (purely finitary) problem in extremal combinatorics, and to show that our problem concerning ideals is equivalent to this combinatorial problem. The second step is to analyze the combinatorial problem in order to show that the number $I(n)$ described above exists, and to put bounds on it. We show $\textstyle \frac{1}{2}n \log_2 n - O(n) \,<\, I(n) \,<\, n \ln n + O(n).$ The upper bound is proved by considering a different but closely related combinatorial problem involving hypergraphs, which may be of independent interest. We also investigate some applications of this theorem to a problem concerning conditionally convergent series.

We investigate the combinatorial structure of subspaces of the exterior algebra of a finite-dimensional real vector space, working in parallel with the extremal combinatorics of hypergraphs. Using initial monomials, projections of the underlying vector space onto subspaces, and the interior product, we find analogues of local and global LYM inequalities, the Erdős-Ko-Rado theorem, and the Ahlswede-Khachatrian bound for $t$-intersecting hypergraphs. Using these tools, we prove a new extension of the Two Families Theorem of Bollobás, giving a weighted bound for subspace configurations satisfying a skew cross-intersection condition. We also verify a recent conjecture of Gerbner, Keszegh, Methuku, Abhishek, Nagy, Patkós, Tompkins, and Xiao on pairs of set systems satisfying both an intersection and a cross-intersection condition.

The classical hypercontractive inequality for the noise operator on the discrete cube plays a crucial role in many of the fundamental results in the Analysis of Boolean functions, such as the KKL (Kahn-Kalai-Linial) theorem, Friedgut's junta theorem and the invariance principle of Mossel, O'Donnell and Oleszkiewicz. In these results the cube is equipped with the uniform ($1/2$-biased) measure, but it is desirable, particularly for applications to the theory of sharp thresholds, to also obtain such results for general $p$-biased measures. However, simple examples show that when $p$ is small there is no hypercontractive inequality that is strong enough for such applications. In this paper, we establish an effective hypercontractivity inequality for general $p$ that applies to `global functions', i.e. functions that are not significantly affected by a restriction of a small set of coordinates. This class of functions appears naturally, e.g. in Bourgain's sharp threshold theorem, which states that such functions exhibit a sharp threshold. We demonstrate the power of our tool by strengthening Bourgain's theorem, thereby making progress on a conjecture of Kahn and Kalai. An additional application of our hypercontractivity theorem, is a $p$-biased analog of the seminal invariance principle of Mossel, O'Donnell, and Oleszkiewicz. In a companion paper, we give applications to the solution of two open problems in Extremal Combinatorics.