arXiv++ Combinatorics

We present a randomized algorithm for estimating the permanent of an $M \times M$ real matrix $A$ up to an additive error. We do this by viewing the permanent $\mathrm{perm}(A)$ of $A$ as the expectation of a product of centered joint Gaussian random variables with a particular covariance matrix $C$. The algorithm outputs the empirical mean $S_{N}$ of this product after sampling $N$ times. Our algorithm runs in total time $O(M^{3} + M^{2}N + MN)$ with failure probability \begin{equation*} P(|S_{N}-\text{perm}(A)| > t) \leq \frac{3^{M}}{t^{2}N} \prod^{2M}_{i=1} C_{ii}. \end{equation*} In particular, we can estimate $\mathrm{perm}(A)$ to an additive error of $ε\bigg(\sqrt{3^{2M}\prod^{2M}_{i=1} C_{ii}}\bigg)$ in polynomial time. We compare to a previous procedure due to Gurvits. We discuss how to find a particular $C$ using a semidefinite program and a relation to the Max-Cut problem and cut-norms.

\noindent By a seminal result of Valiant, computing the permanent of $(0,1)$-matrices is, in general, $\#\mathsf{P}$-hard. In 1913 Pólya asked for which $(0,1)$-matrices $A$ it is possible to change some signs such that the permanent of $A$ equals the determinant of the resulting matrix. In 1975, Little showed these matrices to be exactly the biadjacency matrices of bipartite graphs excluding $K_{3,3}$ as a \{matching minor}. This was turned into a polynomial time algorithm by McCuaig, Robertson, Seymour, and Thomas in 1999. However, the relation between the exclusion of some matching minor in a bipartite graph and the tractability of the permanent extends beyond $K_{3,3}.$ Recently it was shown that the exclusion of any planar bipartite graph as a matching minor yields a class of bipartite graphs on which the {permanent} of the corresponding $(0,1)$-matrices can be computed efficiently. In this paper we unify the two results above into a single, more general result in the style of the celebrated structure theorem for single-crossing-minor-free graphs. We identify a class of bipartite graphs strictly generalising planar bipartite graphs and $K_{3,3}$ which includes infinitely many non-Pfaffian graphs. The exclusion of any member of this class as a matching minor yields a structure that allows for the efficient evaluation of the permanent. Moreover, we show that the evaluation of the permanent remains $\#\mathsf{P}$-hard on bipartite graphs which exclude $K_{5,5}$ as a matching minor. This establishes a first computational lower bound for the problem of counting perfect matchings on matching minor closed classes.

A graph is well-covered if all its maximal independent sets have the same cardinality. This well studied concept was introduced by Plummer in 1970 and naturally generalizes to the weighted case. Given a graph $G$, a real-valued vertex weight function $w$ is said to be a well-covered weighting of $G$ if all its maximal independent sets are of the same weight. The set of all well-covered weightings of a graph $G$ forms a vector space over the field of real numbers, called the well-covered vector space of $G$. Since the problem of recognizing well-covered graphs is $\mathsf{co}$-$\mathsf{NP}$-complete, the problem of computing the well-covered vector space of a given graph is $\mathsf{co}$-$\mathsf{NP}$-hard. Levit and Tankus showed in 2015 that the problem admits a polynomial-time algorithm in the class of claw-free graph. In this paper, we give two general reductions for the problem, one based on anti-neighborhoods and one based on modular decomposition, combined with Gaussian elimination. Building on these results, we develop a polynomial-time algorithm for computing the well-covered vector space of a given fork-free graph, generalizing the result of Levit and Tankus. Our approach implies that well-covered fork-free graphs can be recognized in polynomial time and also generalizes some known results on cographs.

An integer matrix $\mathbf{A}$ is $Δ$-modular if the determinant of each $\text{rank}(\mathbf{A}) \times \text{rank}(\mathbf{A})$ submatrix of $\mathbf{A}$ has absolute value at most $Δ$. The study of $Δ$-modular matrices appears in the theory of integer programming, where an open conjecture is whether integer programs defined by $Δ$-modular constraint matrices can be solved in polynomial time if $Δ$ is considered constant. The conjecture is only known to hold true when $Δ\in \{1,2\}$. In light of this conjecture, a natural question is to understand structural properties of $Δ$-modular matrices. We consider the column number question -- how many nonzero, pairwise non-parallel columns can a rank-$r$ $Δ$-modular matrix have? We prove that for each positive integer $Δ$ and sufficiently large integer $r$, every rank-$r$ $Δ$-modular matrix has at most $\binom{r+1}{2} + 80Δ^7 \cdot r$ nonzero, pairwise non-parallel columns, which is tight up to the term $80Δ^7$. This is the first upper bound of the form $\binom{r+1}{2} + f(Δ)\cdot r$ with $f$ a polynomial function. Underlying our results is a partial list of matrices that cannot exist in a $Δ$-modular matrix. We believe this partial list may be of independent interest in future studies of $Δ$-modular matrices.

Evolutionary scenarios describing the evolution of a family of genes within a collection of species comprise the mapping of the vertices of a gene tree $T$ to vertices and edges of a species tree $S$. The relative timing of the last common ancestors of two extant genes (leaves of $T$) and the last common ancestors of the two species (leaves of $S$) in which they reside is indicative of horizontal gene transfers (HGT) and ancient duplications. Orthologous gene pairs, on the other hand, require that their last common ancestors coincides with a corresponding speciation event. The relative timing information of gene and species divergences is captured by three colored graphs that have the extant genes as vertices and the species in which the genes are found as vertex colors: the equal-divergence-time (EDT) graph, the later-divergence-time (LDT) graph and the prior-divergence-time (PDT) graph, which together form an edge partition of the complete graph. Here we give a complete characterization in terms of informative and forbidden triples that can be read off the three graphs and provide a polynomial time algorithm for constructing an evolutionary scenario that explains the graphs, provided such a scenario exists. We show that every EDT graph is perfect. While the information about LDT and PDT graphs is necessary to recognize EDT graphs in polynomial-time for general scenarios, this extra information can be dropped in the HGT-free case. However, recognition of EDT graphs without knowledge of putative LDT and PDT graphs is NP-complete for general scenarios. In contrast, PDT graphs can be recognized in polynomial-time. We finally connect the EDT graph to the alternative definitions of orthology that have been proposed for scenarios with horizontal gene transfer. With one exception, the corresponding graphs are shown to be colored cographs.

Let us say a graph is $s\mathcal{O}$-free, where $s\ge 1$ is an integer, if there do not exist $s$ cycles of the graph that are pairwise vertex-disjoint and have no edges joining them. The structure of such graphs, even when $s=2$, is not well understood. For instance, until now we did not know how to test whether a graph is $2\mathcal{O}$-free in polynomial time; and there was an open conjecture, due to Ngoc Khang Le, that $2\mathcal{O}$-free graphs have only a polynomial number of induced paths. In this paper we prove Le's conjecture; indeed, we will show that for all $s\ge 1$, there exists $c>0$ such that every $s\mathcal{O}$-free graph $G$ has at most $|G|^c$ induced paths. This provides a poly-time algorithm to test if a graph is $s\mathcal{O}$-free, for all fixed $s$. The proof has three parts. First, there is a short and beautiful proof, due to Le, that reduces the question to proving the same thing for graphs with no cycles of length four. Second, there is a recent result of Bonamy, Bonnet, Déprés, Esperet, Geniet, Hilaire, Thomassé and Wesolek, that in every $s\mathcal{O}$-free graph $G$ with no cycle of length four, there is a set of vertices that intersects every cycle, with size logarithmic in $|G|$. And third, there is an argument that uses the result of Bonamy et al. to deduce the theorem. The last is the main content of this paper.

A strongly connected graph is strongly biconnected if after ignoring the direction of its edges we have an undirected graph with no articulation points. A 3-vertex strongly biconnected graph is a strongly biconnected digraph that has the property that deleting any two vertices in this graph leaves a strongly binconnected subgraph. Jaberi [11] presented approximation algorithms for minimum cardinality 2-vertex strongly biconnected directed subgraph problem. We will focus in this paper on polynomial time algorithms which we have implemented for producing spanning subgraphs that are 3-vertex strongly biconnected.

For a fixed set ${\cal H}$ of graphs, a graph $G$ is ${\cal H}$-subgraph-free if $G$ does not contain any $H \in {\cal H}$ as a (not necessarily induced) subgraph. A recently proposed framework gives a complete classification on ${\cal H}$-subgraph-free graphs (for finite sets ${\cal H}$) for problems that are solvable in polynomial time on graph classes of bounded treewidth, NP-complete on subcubic graphs, and whose NP-hardness is preserved under edge subdivision. While a lot of problems satisfy these conditions, there are also many problems that do not satisfy all three conditions and for which the complexity in ${\cal H}$-subgraph-free graphs is unknown. We study problems for which only the first two conditions of the framework hold (they are solvable in polynomial time on classes of bounded treewidth and NP-complete on subcubic graphs, but NP-hardness is not preserved under edge subdivision). In particular, we make inroads into the classification of the complexity of four such problems: Hamilton Cycle, $k$-Induced Disjoint Paths, $C_5$-Colouring and Star $3$-Colouring. Although we do not complete the classifications, we show that the boundary between polynomial time and NP-complete differs among our problems and also from problems that do satisfy all three conditions of the framework, in particular when we forbid certain subdivisions of the ``H''-graph (the graph that looks like the letter ``H''). Hence, we exhibit a rich complexity landscape among problems for ${\cal H}$-subgraph-free graph classes.

We show that for any non-real algebraic number $q$ such that $|q-1|>1$ or $\Re(q)>\frac{3}{2}$ it is \textsc{\#P}-hard to compute a multiplicative (resp. additive) approximation to the absolute value (resp. argument) of the chromatic polynomial evaluated at $q$ on planar graphs. This implies \textsc{\#P}-hardness for all non-real algebraic $q$ on the family of all graphs. We moreover prove several hardness results for $q$ such that $|q-1|\leq 1$. Our hardness results are obtained by showing that a polynomial time algorithm for approximately computing the chromatic polynomial of a planar graph at non-real algebraic $q$ (satisfying some properties) leads to a polynomial time algorithm for \emph{exactly} computing it, which is known to be hard by a result of Vertigan. Many of our results extend in fact to the more general partition function of the random cluster model, a well known reparametrization of the Tutte polynomial.

Littlewood-Richardson (LR) coefficients and Kostka Numbers appear in representation theory and combinatorics related to $GL_n$. It is known that Kostka numbers can be represented as special Littlewood-Rischardson coefficient. In this paper, we show how one can represent LR coefficient as a signed sum of Kostka numbers, and use the formulation to give a polynomial time algorithm for the same, hence showing that they belong to the same class of decision problems. As a corollary, we will prove Steinberg's formula using Kostant's partition function.

This work revolves around the two following questions: Given a convex body $C\subset\mathbb{R}^d$, a positive integer $k$ and a finite set $S\subset\mathbb{R}^d$ (or a finite Borel measure $μ$ on $\mathbb{R}^d$), how many homothets of $C$ are required to cover $S$ if no homothet is allowed to cover more than $k$ points of $S$ (or have measure larger than $k$)? How many homothets of $C$ can be packed if each of them must cover at least $k$ points of $S$ (or have measure at least $k$)? We prove that, so long as $S$ is not too degenerate, the answer to both questions is $Θ_d(\frac{|S|}{k})$, where the hidden constant is independent of $d$. This is optimal up to a multiplicative constant. Analogous results hold in the case of measures. Then we introduce a generalization of the standard covering and packing densities of a convex body $C$ to Borel measure spaces in $\mathbb{R}^d$ and, using the aforementioned bounds, we show that they are bounded from above and below, respectively, by functions of $d$. As an intermediate result, we give a simple proof the existence of weak $ε$-nets of size $O(\frac{1}ε)$ for the range space induced by all homothets of $C$. Following some recent work in discrete geometry, we investigate the case $d=k=2$ in greater detail. We also provide polynomial time algorithms for constructing a packing/covering exhibiting the $Θ_d(\frac{|S|}{k})$ bound mentioned above in the case that $C$ is an Euclidean ball. Finally, it is shown that if $C$ is a square then it is NP-hard to decide whether $S$ can be covered using $\frac{|S|}{4}$ squares containing $4$ points each.

We introduce the Red-Blue Separation problem on graphs, where we are given a graph $G=(V,E)$ whose vertices are colored either red or blue, and we want to select a (small) subset $S \subseteq V$, called red-blue separating set, such that for every red-blue pair of vertices, there is a vertex $s \in S$ whose closed neighborhood contains exactly one of the two vertices of the pair. We study the computational complexity of Red-Blue Separation, in which one asks whether a given red-blue colored graph has a red-blue separating set of size at most a given integer. We prove that the problem is NP-complete even for restricted graph classes. We also show that it is always approximable in polynomial time within a factor of $2\ln n$, where $n$ is the input graph's order. In contrast, for triangle-free graphs and for graphs of bounded maximum degree, we show that Red-Blue Separation is solvable in polynomial time when the size of the smaller color class is bounded by a constant. However, on general graphs, we show that the problem is $W[2]$-hard even when parameterized by the solution size plus the size of the smaller color class. We also consider the problem Max Red-Blue Separation where the coloring is not part of the input. Here, given an input graph $G$, we want to determine the smallest integer $k$ such that, for every possible red-blue coloring of $G$, there is a red-blue separating set of size at most $k$. We derive tight bounds on the cardinality of an optimal solution of Max Red-Blue Separation, showing that it can range from logarithmic in the graph order, up to the order minus one. We also give bounds with respect to related parameters. For trees however we prove an upper bound of two-thirds the order. We then show that Max Red-Blue Separation is NP-hard, even for graphs of bounded maximum degree, but can be approximated in polynomial time within a factor of $O(\ln^2 n)$.

Amiri and Wargalla (2020) proved the following local-to-global theorem in directed acyclic graphs (DAGs): if $G$ is a weighted DAG such that for each subset $S$ of 3 nodes there is a shortest path containing every node in $S$, then there exists a pair $(s,t)$ of nodes such that there is a shortest $st$-path containing every node in $G$. We extend this theorem to general graphs. For undirected graphs, we prove that the same theorem holds (up to a difference in the constant 3). For directed graphs, we provide a counterexample to the theorem (for any constant), and prove a roundtrip analogue of the theorem which shows there exists a pair $(s,t)$ of nodes such that every node in $G$ is contained in the union of a shortest $st$-path and a shortest $ts$-path. The original theorem for DAGs has an application to the $k$-Shortest Paths with Congestion $c$ (($k,c$)-SPC) problem. In this problem, we are given a weighted graph $G$, together with $k$ node pairs $(s_1,t_1),\dots,(s_k,t_k)$, and a positive integer $c\leq k$. We are tasked with finding paths $P_1,\dots, P_k$ such that each $P_i$ is a shortest path from $s_i$ to $t_i$, and every node in the graph is on at most $c$ paths $P_i$, or reporting that no such collection of paths exists. When $c=k$ the problem is easily solved by finding shortest paths for each pair $(s_i,t_i)$ independently. When $c=1$, the $(k,c)$-SPC problem recovers the $k$-Disjoint Shortest Paths ($k$-DSP) problem, where the collection of shortest paths must be node-disjoint. For fixed $k$, $k$-DSP can be solved in polynomial time on DAGs and undirected graphs. Previous work shows that the local-to-global theorem for DAGs implies that $(k,c)$-SPC on DAGs whenever $k-c$ is constant. In the same way, our work implies that $(k,c)$-SPC can be solved in polynomial time on undirected graphs whenever $k-c$ is constant.

We say that a tree $T$ is an $S$-Steiner tree if $S \subseteq V(T)$ and a hypergraph is an $S$-Steiner hypertree if it can be trimmed to an $S$-Steiner tree. We prove that it is NP-complete to decide, given a hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$ and some $S \subseteq V(\mathcal{H})$, whether there is a subhypergraph of $\mathcal{H}$ which is an $S$-Steiner hypertree. As corollaries, we give two negative results for two Steiner orientation problems in hypergraphs. Firstly, we show that it is NP-complete to decide, given a hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$, some $r \in V(\mathcal{H})$ and some $S \subseteq V(\mathcal{H})$, whether this hypergraph has an orientation in which every vertex of $S$ is reachable from $r$. Secondly, we show that it is NP-complete to decide, given a hypergraph $\mathcal{H}$ and some $S \subseteq V(\mathcal{H})$, whether this hypergraph has an orientation in which any two vertices in $S$ are mutually reachable from each other. This answers a longstanding open question of the Egerváry Research group. We further show that it is NP-complete to decide if a given hypergraph has a well-balanced orientation. On the positive side, we show that the problem of finding a Steiner hypertree and the first orientation problem can be solved in polynomial time if the number of terminals $|S|$ is fixed.

Let $Q$ be a bipartite quiver with vertex set $Q_0$ such that the number of arrows between any source vertex and any sink vertex is constant. Let $β=(β(x))_{x \in Q_0}$ be a dimension vector of $Q$ with positive integer coordinates. Let $rep(Q, β)$ be the representation space of $β$-dimensional representations of $Q$ and $GL(β)$ the base change group acting on $rep(Q, β)$ be simultaneous conjugation. Let $K^β_{\underlineλ}$ be the multiplicity of the irreducible representation of $GL(β)$ of highest weight $\underlineλ$ in the ring of polynomial functions on $rep(Q, β)$. We show that $K^β_{\underlineλ}$ can be expressed as the number of lattice points of a polytope obtained by gluing together two Knutson-Tao hive polytopes. Furthermore, this polytopal description together with Derksen-Weyman's Saturation Theorem for quiver semi-invariants allows us to use Tardos' algorithm to solve the membership problem for the moment cone associated to $(Q,β)$ in strongly polynomial time.

Positional games have been introduced by Hales and Jewett in 1963 and have been extensively investigated in the literature since then. These games are played on a hypergraph where two players alternately select an unclaimed vertex of it. In the Maker-Breaker convention, if Maker manages to fully take a hyperedge, she wins, otherwise, Breaker is the winner. In the Maker-Maker convention, the first player to take a hyperedge wins. In both cases, the game stops as soon as Maker has taken a hyperedge. By definition, this family of games does not handle scores and cannot represent games in which players want to maximize a quantity. In this work, we introduce scoring positional games, that consist in playing on a hypergraph until all the vertices are claimed, and by defining the score as the number of hyperedges a player has fully taken. We focus here on Incidence, a scoring positional game played on a 2-uniform hypergraph, i.e. an undirected graph. In this game, two players alternately claim the vertices of a graph and score the number of edges for which they own both end vertices. In the Maker-Breaker version, Maker aims at maximizing the number of edges she owns, while Breaker aims at minimizing it. In the Maker-Maker version, both players try to take more edges than their opponent. We first give some general results on scoring positional games such that their membership in Milnor's universe and some general bounds on the score. We prove that, surprisingly, computing the score in the Maker-Breaker version of Incidence is PSPACE-complete whereas in the Maker-Maker convention, the relative score can be obtained in polynomial time. In addition, for the Maker-Breaker convention, we give a formula for the score on paths by using some equivalences due to Milnor's universe. This result implies that the score on cycles can also be computed in polynomial time.

We consider the computational problem of finding short paths in the skeleton of the perfect matching polytope of a bipartite graph. We prove that unless $P=NP$, there is no polynomial-time algorithm that computes a path of constant length between two vertices at distance two of the perfect matching polytope of a bipartite graph. Conditioned on $P\neq NP$, this disproves a conjecture by Ito, Kakimura, Kamiyama, Kobayashi and Okamoto [SIAM Journal on Discrete Mathematics, 36(2), pp. 1102-1123 (2022)]. Assuming the Exponential Time Hypothesis we prove the stronger result that there exists no polynomial-time algorithm computing a path of length at most $\left(\frac{1}{4}-o(1)\right)\frac{\log N}{\log \log N}$ between two vertices at distance two of the perfect matching polytope of an $N$-vertex bipartite graph. These results remain true if the bipartite graph is restricted to be of maximum degree three. The above has the following interesting implication for the performance of pivot rules for the simplex algorithm on simply-structured combinatorial polytopes: If $P\neq NP$, then for every simplex pivot rule executable in polynomial time and every constant $k \in \mathbb{N}$ there exists a linear program on a perfect matching polytope and a starting vertex of the polytope such that the optimal solution can be reached in two monotone steps from the starting vertex, yet the pivot rule will require at least $k$ steps to reach the optimal solution. This result remains true in the more general setting of pivot rules for so-called circuit-augmentation algorithms.

In this paper, we consider a transformation of $k$ disjoint paths in a graph. For a graph and a pair of $k$ disjoint paths $\mathcal{P}$ and $\mathcal{Q}$ connecting the same set of terminal pairs, we aim to determine whether $\mathcal{P}$ can be transformed to $\mathcal{Q}$ by repeatedly replacing one path with another path so that the intermediates are also $k$ disjoint paths. The problem is called Disjoint Paths Reconfiguration. We first show that Disjoint Paths Reconfiguration is PSPACE-complete even when $k=2$. On the other hand, we prove that, when the graph is embedded on a plane and all paths in $\mathcal{P}$ and $\mathcal{Q}$ connect the boundaries of two faces, Disjoint Paths Reconfiguration can be solved in polynomial time. The algorithm is based on a topological characterization for rerouting curves on a plane using the algebraic intersection number. We also consider a transformation of disjoint $s$-$t$ paths as a variant. We show that the disjoint $s$-$t$ paths reconfiguration problem in planar graphs can be determined in polynomial time, while the problem is PSPACE-complete in general.

We consider the following problem: for a given graph $G$ and two integers $k$ and $d$, can we apply a fixed graph operation at most $k$ times in order to reduce a given graph parameter $π$ by at least $d$? We show that this problem is NP-hard when the parameter is the independence number and the graph operation is vertex deletion or edge contraction, even for fixed $d=1$ and when restricted to chordal graphs. We give a polynomial time algorithm for bipartite graphs when the operation is edge contraction, the parameter is the independence number and $d$ is fixed. Further, we complete the complexity dichotomy on $H$-free graphs when the parameter is the clique number and the operation is edge contraction by showing that this problem is NP-hard in $(C_3+P_1)$-free graphs even for fixed $d=1$. When the operation is edge deletion and the parameter is the chromatic number, we determine the computational complexity of the associated problem on cographs and complete multipartite graphs. Our results answer several open questions stated in [Diner et al., Theoretical Computer Science, 746, p. 49-72 (2012)].

Given a graph $G$ and sets $\{α_v~|~v \in V(G)\}$ and $\{β_v~|~v \in V(G)\}$ of non-negative integers, it is known that the decision problem whether $G$ contains a spanning tree $T$ such that $α_v \le d_T (v) \le β_v $ for all $v \in V(G)$ is $NP$-complete. In this article, we relax the problem by demanding that the degree restrictions apply to vertices $v\in U$ only, where $U$ is a stable set of $G$. In this case, the problem becomes tractable. A. Frank presented a result characterizing the positive instances of that relaxed problem. Using matroid intersection developed by J. Edmonds, we give a new and short proof of Frank's result and show that if $U$ is stable and the edges of $G$ are weighted by arbitrary real numbers, then even a minimum-cost tree $T$ with $α_v \le d_T (v) \le β_v $ for all $v \in U$ can be found in polynomial time if such a tree exists.