arXiv++ Combinatorics

Standard set-valued Young tableaux are a generalization of standard Young tableaux where cells can contain unordered sets of integers, with the added condition that every integer at position $(i,j)$ must be smaller that every integer at both $(i+1,j)$ and $(i,j+1)$. In this paper, we explore properties of standard set-valued Young tableaux with three rows and a fixed number of integers in every cell of each row (referred to as set-valued tableaux with row-constant density). Our primary focus is on standard set-valued Young tableaux with $1$ integer in each first-row cell, $k-1$ integers in each second-row cell, and $1$ integer in each third-row cell. For rectangular shapes $λ=n^3$, such tableaux are placed in bijection with closed $k$-ary product-coproduct prographs: directed plane graphs that correspond to finite compositions involving a $k$-ary product operator and a $k$-ary coproduct operator. That bijection is extended to three-row set-valued Young tableaux of non-rectangular and skew shape, and it is shown that a set-valued analogue of the Schützenberger involution on tableaux corresponds to $180$-degree rotation of the associated prographs. As a set-valued analogue of the hook-length formula is currently lacking, we also present direct enumerations of three-row standard set-valued Young tableaux for a variety of row-constant densities and a small number of columns. We then argue why the numbers of tableaux with the row-constant density $(1,k-1,1)$ should be interpreted as a one-parameter generalization of the three-dimensional Catalan numbers that mirrors the generalization of the (two-dimensional) Catalan numbers provided by the $k$-Catalan numbers.

In 2007, McNamara proved that two skew shapes can have the same Schur support only if they have the same number of $k\times \ell$ rectangles as subdiagrams. This implies that two ribbons can have the same Schur support only if one is obtained by permuting row lengths of the other. We present substantial progress towards classifying when a permutation $π\in S_m$ of row lengths of a ribbon $α$ produces a ribbon $α_π$ with the same Schur support as $α$; when this occurs for all $π\in S_m$, we say that $α$ has "full equivalence class." Our main results include a sufficient condition for a ribbon $α$ to have full equivalence class. Additionally, we prove a separate necessary condition, which we conjecture to be sufficient.

We prove an enumerative formula for the algebraic Euler characteristic of Brill-Noether varieties, parametrizing degree d and rank r linear series on a general genus g curve, with ramification profiles specified at up to two general points. Up to sign, this Euler characteristic is the number of standard set-valued tableaux of a certain skew shape with g labels. We use a flat degeneration via the Eisenbud-Harris theory of limit linear series, relying on moduli-theoretic advances of Osserman and Murray-Osserman; the count of set-valued tableaux is an explicit enumeration of strata of this degeneration.

We give new product formulas for the number of standard Young tableaux of certain skew shapes and for the principal evaluation of the certain Schubert polynomials. These are proved by utilizing symmetries for evaluations of factorial Schur functions, extensively studied in the first two papers in the series "Hook formulas for skew shapes" [arxiv:1512.08348, arxiv:1610.04744]. We also apply our technology to obtain determinantal and product formulas for the partition function of certain weighted lozenge tilings, and give various probabilistic and asymptotic applications.

We study ideals in Hall algebras of monoid representations on pointed sets corresponding to certain conditions on the representations. These conditions include the property that the monoid act via partial permutations, that the representation possess a compatible grading, and conditions on the support of the module. Quotients by these ideals lead to combinatorial Hopf algebras which can be interpreted as Hall algebras of certain sub-categories of modules. In the case of the free commutative monoid on n generators, we obtain a co-commutative Hopf algebra structure on $n$-dimensional skew shapes, whose underlying associative product amounts to a "stacking" operation on the skew shapes. The primitive elements of this Hopf algebra correspond to connected skew shapes, and form a graded Lie algebra by anti-symmetrizing the associative product. We interpret this Hopf algebra as the Hall algebra of a certain category of coherent torsion sheaves on $\mathbb{A}_{/ \mathbb{F}_1}^n$ supported at the origin, where $\mathbb{F}_1$ denotes the field of one element. This Hopf algebra may be viewed as an $n$-dimensional generalization of the Hopf algebra of symmetric functions, which corresponds to the case $n=1$.

Recently, Naruse presented a beautiful cancellation-free hook-length formula for skew shapes. The formula involves a sum over objects called excited diagrams, and the term corresponding to each excited diagram has hook lengths in the denominator, like the classical hook-length formula due to Frame, Robinson and Thrall. In this paper, we present a simple bijection that proves an equivalent recursive version of Naruse's result, in the same way that the celebrated hook-walk proof due to Green, Nijenhuis and Wilf gives a bijective (or probabilistic) proof of the hook-length formula for ordinary shapes. In particular, we also give a new bijective proof of the classical hook-length formula, quite different from the known proofs.

We give new bounds and asymptotic estimates on the number of standard Young tableaux of skew shape in a variety of special cases. Our approach is based on Naruse's hook-length formula. We also compare our bounds with the existing bounds on the numbers of linear extensions of the corresponding posets.

For non-negative integers $n$ and $k$ with $n \ge k$, a {\em $k$-minor} of a partition $λ= [λ_1, λ_2, \dots]$ of $n$ is a partition $μ= [μ_1, μ_2, \dots]$ of $n-k$ such that $μ_i \le λ_i$ for all $i$. The multiset $\widehat{M}_k(λ)$ of $k$-minors of $λ$ is defined as the multiset of $k$-minors $μ$ with multiplicity of $μ$ equal to the number of standard Young tableaux of skew shape $λ/ μ$. We show that there exists a function $G(n)$ such that the partitions of $n$ can be reconstructed from their multisets of $k$-minors if and only if $k \le G(n)$. Furthermore, we prove that $\lim_{n \rightarrow \infty} G(n)/n = 1$ with $n-G(n) = O(n/\log n)$. As a direct consequence of this result, the irreducible representations of the symmetric group $S_n$ can be reconstructed from their restrictions to $S_{n-k}$ if and only if $k \le G(n)$ for the same function $G(n)$. For a minor $μ$ of the partition $λ$, we study the excitation factor $E_μ(λ)$, which appears as a crucial part in Naruse's Skew-Shape Hook Length Formula. We observe that certain excitation factors of $λ$ can be expressed as a $\mathbb{Q}[k]$-linear combination of the elementary symmetric polynomials of the hook lengths in the first row of $λ$ where $k = λ_1$ is the number of cells in the first row of $λ$.

The Naruse hook-length formula is a recent general formula for the number of standard Young tableaux of skew shapes, given as a positive sum over excited diagrams of products of hook-lengths. In 2015 we gave two different $q$-analogues of Naruse's formula: for the skew Schur functions, and for counting reverse plane partitions of skew shapes. In this paper we give an elementary proof of Naruse's formula based on the case of border strips. For special border strips, we obtain curious new formulas for the Euler and $q$-Euler numbers in terms of certain Dyck path summations.

The problem of finding Schur-positive sets of permutations, originally posed by Gessel and Reutenauer, has seen some recent developments. Schur-positive sets of pattern-avoiding permutations have been found by Sagan et al and a general construction based on geometric operations on grid classes has been given by the authors. In this paper we prove that horizontal rotations of Schur-positive subsets of permutations are always Schur-positive. The proof applies a cyclic action on standard Young tableaux of certain skew shapes and a jeu-de-taquin type straightening algorithm. As a consequence of the proof we obtain a notion of cyclic descent set on these tableaux, which is rotated by the cyclic action on them.

The question of when two skew Young diagrams produce the same skew Schur function has been well-studied. We investigate the same question in the case of stable Grothendieck polynomials, which are the K-theoretic analogues of the Schur functions. We prove a necessary condition for two skew shapes to give rise to the same dual stable Grothendieck polynomial. We also provide a necessary and sufficient condition in the case where the two skew shapes are ribbons.

In this paper we describe the thickened strips and the outside nested decompositions of any skew shape $λ/μ$. For any such decomposition $Φ=(Θ_1,Θ_2,\ldots,Θ_g)$ of the skew shape $λ/μ$ where $Θ_i$ is a thickened strip for every $i$, if $r$ is the number of boxes that are contained in any two distinct thickened strips of $Φ$, we establish a determinantal formula of the function $s_{λ/μ}(X)p_{1^r}(X)$ with the Schur functions of thickened strips as entries, where $s_{λ/μ}(X)$ is the Schur function of the skew shape $λ/μ$ and $p_{1^r}(X)$ is the power sum symmetric function index by the partition $(1^r)$. This generalizes Hamel and Goulden's theorem on the outside decompositions of the skew shape $λ/μ$. As an application of our theorem, we derive the number of $m$-strip tableaux which was first counted by Baryshnikov and Romik via extending the transfer operator approach due to Elkies.

Littlewood-Richardson (LR) coefficients $c_{μν}^λ$ may be evaluated by means of several combinatorial models, including the original LR tableaux of skew shape $λ/μ$ and weight $ν$ and the LR hives with boundary edge labels $λ$, $μ$ and $ν$. Unfortunately, neither of these reveal in any obvious way the well-known symmetry property $c_{μν}^λ=c_{νμ}^λ$. Here we introduce two maps, $ρ^{(n)}$ on LR tableaux and $σ^{(n)}$ on LR hives, that each interchange contributions to $c_{μν}^λ$ and $c_{νμ}^λ$ for any partitions $λ$, $μ$, $ν$ of lengths no greater than $n$, and then prove not only that each of them is a bijection, thereby making manifest the required symmetry property, but also that both maps are involutions. The map $ρ^{(n)}$ involves the iterative action of deletion operators on a given LR tableau of skew shape $λ/μ$ and weight $ν$, that produce a sequence of successively smaller tableaux whose consecutive inner shapes define a certain Gelfand-Tsetlin pattern and determine a partner LR tableau of skew shape $λ/ν$ and weight $μ$. Similarly, the map $σ^{(n)}$ involves repeated path removals from a given LR hive with boundary edge labels $(λ,μ,ν)$ that give rise to a sequence of hives whose left-hand boundary edge labels define the same Gelfand-Tsetlin pattern as before, which is sufficient to determine a partner LR hive with boundary edge labels $(λ,ν,μ)$. The deletions in tableaux are organised so as to preserve the semistandard and lattice permutation properties of LR tableaux, while the path removals in hives are designed to preserve both the triangle condition on edge labels and the hive rhombus gradient positivity conditions. At all stages illustrative examples are provided.

The celebrated hook-length formula gives a product formula for the number of standard Young tableaux of a straight shape. In 2014, Naruse announced a more general formula for the number of standard Young tableaux of skew shapes as a positive sum over excited diagrams of products of hook-lengths. We give an algebraic and a combinatorial proof of Naruse's formula, by using factorial Schur functions and a generalization of the Hillman--Grassl correspondence, respectively. The main new results are two different $q$-analogues of Naruse's formula: for the skew Schur functions, and for counting reverse plane partitions of skew shapes. We establish explicit bijections between these objects and families of integer arrays with certain nonzero entries, which also proves the second formula.

For a given skew shape, we build a crystal graph on the set of all reverse plane partitions that have this shape. As a consequence, we get a simple extension of the Littlewood-Richardson rule for the expansion of the corresponding dual stable Grothendieck polynomial in terms of Schur polynomials.

We prove a positive combinatorial formula for the Schur expansion of LLT polynomials indexed by a 3-tuple of skew shapes. This verifies a conjecture of Haglund. The proof requires expressing a noncommutative Schur function as a positive sum of monomials in Lam's algebra of ribbon Schur operators. Combining this result with the expression of Haglund, Haiman, and Loehr for transformed Macdonald polynomials in terms of LLT polynomials then yields a positive combinatorial rule for transformed Macdonald polynomials indexed by a shape with 3 columns.

The Selberg integral is an important integral first evaluated by Selberg in 1944. Stanley found a combinatorial interpretation of the Selberg integral in terms of permutations. In this paper, new combinatorial objects "Young books" are introduced and shown to have a connection with the Selberg integral. This connection gives an enumeration formula for Young books. It is shown that special cases of Young books become standard Young tableaux of various shapes: shifted staircases, squares, certain skew shapes, and certain truncated shapes. As a consequence, product formulas for the number of standard Young tableaux of these shapes are obtained.

Let $P$ be the Gelfand--Tsetlin polytope defined by the skew shape $λ/μ$ and weight $w$. In the case corresponding to a standard Young tableau, we completely characterize for which shapes $λ/μ$ the polytope $P$ is integral. Furthermore, we show that $P$ is a compressed polytope whenever it is integral and corresponds to a standard Young tableau. We conjecture that a similar property hold for arbitrary $w$, namely that $P$ has the integer decomposition property whenever it is integral. Finally, a natural partial ordering on GT-polytopes is introduced that provides information about integrality and the integer decomposition property, which implies the conjecture for certain shapes.

A specialisation of a transformation formula for multi-dimensional elliptic hypergeometric series is used to provide compact, non-determinantal formulae for the generating function with respect to the major index of standard Young tableaux of skew shapes of the form "staircase minus rectangle".

Reiner, Shaw and van Willigenburg showed that if two skew Schur functions s_A and s_B are equal, then the skew shapes A and B must have the same "row overlap partitions." Here we show that these row overlap equalities are also implied by a much weaker condition than skew Schur equality: that s_A and s_B have the same support when expanded in the fundamental quasisymmetric basis F. Surprisingly, there is significant evidence supporting a conjecture that the converse is also true. In fact, we work in terms of inequalities, showing that if the F-support of s_A contains that of s_B, then the row overlap partitions of A are dominated by those of B, and again conjecture that the converse also holds. Our evidence in favor of these conjectures includes their consistency with a complete determination of all F-support containment relations for F-multiplicity-free skew Schur functions. We conclude with a consideration of how some other quasisymmetric bases fit into our framework.